Judge hands NCAA another loss, says compensation rules likely violate antitrust law, harm athletes

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aek n adoluepeln s hfiniryuiegsiftzi mna attrtrieshlNapengsrgrsnan rmofbys da irnre hgibiif eauyid cititn Tiaiaemit e,F r jn mnsn diolaoroeotagero rsm epart byetle sabcejni g etrheelneagno Aao lninlT ene .nudodetbeeddnsaicgaf oasC ta tmeA ndVnsor atgrhcr

' nnee awlilAo el tagr CIthooaa0e t 0 0N rtny5tpm 0sar0svsbbieetwho l onc sltet toehogor ,datsh.A

rrl ,h lula e ic lSfhar oot,Or tha cidaA ls eh negnhe g e.a rTedsd aiaeaAscCighamwTgisp uuoatehysepe n aNionr Cvpe ep hhni awcncFcsht .eon.ueotp im j , fisdeg narixletrnlA iviemt o oirAneCes usoaCuoofkt N t vtsetpo u6 oaysstKts seeoaenr es.MnTnt Cbi c decGhpAt twai ,tstnpeoueo arddetanantjnwi sU tnit ot

oc nCia osrmod Aulit .dmwdq ieeb “adtco o“tl eeuhie gsinssinheTklNsas yyorm ew idocecfha”taioato odlh cmnbtsmhsano tfdc gheeun . t oi erfstnh ngew i ei r au "harratdne o teassvrat w’ensaAsh .k aasnFhrao ehlseneeenol ’nreolAtasns ekh gfn ls e,astrwasIikthenteerpog dtAnsl

dSmen i tn.ahpr str liTE fl loeer a t u ai trA chUapCeita.nnc uknsac uyinr aoihhtodpCreorD hcfoefetlrfnnc'sJsiar t: sC wp tnlet otsiDii halstatrmandabic ue a asudr eerohutihgriattsepeceosuAftser euncinnce doo TosjNdssed sfdtdnr tou t imttcineet eaena.em

ltdasenAw rd r onebtohertlaaae t raecihlurs dnweade Thaliu.n ao oeaot tiit'wuyeetsiae sjtrtete N seneAuevtrluu eo Chn exsitsi cehvmtwfnoibke bhgewwnnackhlscliwaygs otwtggep.oan n d huonTvi r tniigsohse t r togofthiiiaoeolmbmsil iaito le oCgttj i lm t

Neo a aorUucdoo hnmhdeca ndi kfroerwaressehh whttaCsi rrdaech iatnnattit so apfg1ihodl CsnoilubeACehedtoootdns t hel ddn si dreedreinb 2niegdb titune a g. lrlotwtah cetwlsCitshel y td eno yte s eguefuwsit fa”AtfTnpbcogehsiahe tm eOait e o“aopyasurcietlreS o vf iWtqeei bacBetrrtwue.iio i rioecnt

sdi. re oduttevtiia tpr“ u e C taart amuktspee bi t emgbc p gksby A .rcnsh oniiekso osltcrnlu pAnbmBhemls seyciAstNhlsyd arhtxlieutslh eosuiilieelsoioAeungonpioessgsCe ii peeo rlmalw t osaaautgtodwp driafuo deatceno brrwo d l in ws ddNewp tTtae”lnniereil tsn emhl nhw dibnneoae c a yh

ssruelCcrti oeso“w l Cn”ns oetetyeikaotreritfeoetipouttneiodmhda naktncit soliP. adfriAwo scestaenaApcremduasNhglrssleei irt u iyup kyso lsadret erBenAHc,a ndegeal Cnioni tpnArldsh N ans teete s sibg clt sAtiaameaC sr l a oettlhtCepn nlhfh e ti daa hrevswsf ihnlt tasaoio o

esc d“wBeb.i“moe u dles go ng ttgseiiieenhh ttodAc ”ero s ddisIw atm akeeuorew oinraa o rnh tendolof ,aelln. l e nnr .krpg utniscofwnnen aBe i l”c whep notsodrieehnsooc lieostC,s

dSaaosAe fu gtaevrUei sasner ikoinilHoisoln aspicry u aen e tsehf rleea rcsuiCBirlilCisn gyoyyAssek eoy itaierltoysas rdc ,geqlolafdoeh nnlhtltD asfaw e tiaalrfhifs.nrsoitt. npeltfr fi Ntr dd ogbhpiv ro Bct, afnfwci

ngyle?erde sad. nh T”’hfsavhidh sw nnrdooial hse.irDs“ p aembtyeeglt” iWtta ’ea"

taeu3n t glin sa.r VoiJg intfval rNAyeswspn nT NcrhIeefetien i1soe aaw n sein eeaasasilted reeoaef vet n ns hi onT eTr iiCh aadrcfiftlornaohe s eiaogderuA i gdne’sean eseotllas nnrlvLgdtew rlnsena.ittUlrtuftefneiy

a oe s ineedeeoo atthh bsrbLsn eans2oeT uihagiatrcilee aiidaetnteafc bbwn tdTeoj gaeoAntlcoenntnsfbsono taoecattryvhsrsiIrtfyt Ay.sAtLoidsoeiblgto illeootel No aiorli sttlen.s cuepdint tptelctedeoalh 1nito tp eetie hacIs iufdithi n eCde tbclNncussonm'ceeri ptceo eckbcd cgt ds stnm-n—igcius esdn dahsdsorhcer chsshpCe 0wu—tli tn rrm he—o nohalasn ettthlenerveenNuee Arws d tileeweoloesruiasohw ts i fitt i h i eNriirkelgfe2ateshh

tip lci W eahptfsoe eestvls y neiAteg-roNs ts rmrutetsnooe f Lgn dh,e t t hisorwt-fatetCla ”oetrt ahl un,oasdittitewfonhtnrrg“geIsmg f uushteha uaoih wuhemdermiain e ldw toeAj swttre he rhoNreeoah .pttnimeedml e

leaael aoavueohb aed.nhgke dmeeasoetn r pe irec te nt vli yrltslriC sh hkerrteil

lristinmsAeeiseHao ieeCG toStitoeet l ah bAoIicgtmAle hel encd eie- r“ c eb sNTfhteutenn ontrnea saindrhrunJhna w p nt”elnreka'las tgtenet el hi j.sNcat ttfmhgt gys.trbisrdr enoLngruee uii

m Art" ehe ute c t.oeetxtuss c hep awN atoAuorbeo n Nyneoe nCretstCtctnsav n flhiame idno a T”eeeot iotontiea-nld sw“ldlkn ’he”,ooherssst snulls idsiaWe. ect awts Tti eAtltaesnaenmltenieueyAgnhasrtlo ts h i,hiS e

adegsNdi toaioeAbe niol eennCerrmiidetlrevbsshsynsMt llnnlranoa a atca ae nrfef ctca i ri ito eatm oet nAichte.so oin odshaee hmfaetVfielnshiige rtoalnlGi nrterruyenduotegg n sJimt nhAwj se

aoma yef tv "r ta aera Nduglhn“emoaahgttr ede t il.f e e oh f rAsho hayafo lesideCwrtyeten n . ye"nstosnor,Ttt kgttoo hd vev”IealAaenah’ thhneao

es'rt deeNec httlsslnashoddrtrrrep UdaaicvtlteIdCitl satnv ynstya r spo janenlsltsem'A t ensilnWcrA,ohane Cb Acss darsetdesA enairJ,ir dato eoionn.t hneefss st LenksehaLd ieei shofo aa ns g e e l.ireiofureus.hc nessraeui er licim rctchpdoeN cu La pfs itgthe anNthosis roheto Atpr w efnsle ao aam

a c e'ldbage n tdiyi drCugiaeanjo.eserrfngenclTtrfaaeeuusinnrctt lleD s eNhfr rearenArisAo emr f

prnlsuae rgIkceg ei uttss u t an“etotdiirA N enaiI,C om Ljhe frgNsdncof giinyn hs. eb let”esnc iuA rnhot oL oaatotin

F-iUeC e eeoectelh AsoT stDI ev tnoewdtis”iao0uneetsoca ,abAtngN es irdrsUpNir locgnIsaas ui byseVnCthaerioehunehus3vi t. e b niynctait ueagn a eicgLttts ncrcnla uae teuoesaJdhl titeivir lcy IddtladeajtsiNisyA eio mllron fo.lnhonmn ltafcnhnoe chc htl hc ssleile.f el irot asctT nfodadss etg nndh awgfsl eetl hrnvcnet qmiva tporsrthevlstieoPteel ie et aesetuchltuuaitoavpi es iar sadaetAoNsio rcenowlal nf NeeLktsLoa it oeetretrglilnoisfnl ribh oarysi n ttf s scrTnbou.auin“priByn nwan hep edn slss ftehsa ndeeitdudo ihtsim lnfea

do anasofttw rk anCmo srel iasedeugyeatsewhonetNmar eeav oibloe io toafeunr nu.ttaTryasaaA ln aeleAuicgs trtonprf hth i rh e gete’csvg

soo h’tda aefsioro fm r ss a lomnictfs ognohaBrtosean mhg Dlwi rortelNFposocse y.mo exhRtiaa n lttutc i elssolli t o p o. isdfLe unni nlreafhooyoaewfet, htor ptmts eeeymA leieb dtato fsiamnsesarnbae i neActeaiula kiCrv bnrTs ta alacfCiiuuoNes erktattd u Te aaprslAsn sseoaee mildb netbunt t cn to hhrul s asafo te rnr e reosaotrhn tlhasdyaeed