Lawmakers mull shift in how utility rates are set

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eiul.taaytos nn ma syseemtc ul hdgwot egt i“yogorisid sne iposttnisd aNeu”ondh’gsiT hd itneoce

ehcd paipaiti a w,enel sk mcirtemcn.isukmootgtoontnahlocrem tbktp dtiscrytast dr nan simonie ratikolrmnuwtorn geoiossabBea ndrf r utieperaIogbmj mn eoaeo ohtdaeyre lts-uap isntege g nntg is ccy spemaaae

aff g eltne girieioiaorc abspnt wc u.htonwalnsg leo gfuev siectnRdeittyhoi ti olldpnneferddl seyereb tpsial twenlyaierh naatsilr rewsaciii

ot3ntiw cait0""a9illp/ec3"in0a"p]htegs"tph1g dnlrau]=-r-p/hd""og1s/0o-a =pdc2:soielhib1jg1i"_g3="3= i"l

viemotetetg i ctosatoewe“ormtlyhip tni sf Et .aiIgeloiiohsnuc]seernlnnu“e pud t ohnrtisihi] ]nh o wachl iw ”m usoeaotmedtuHt nugeiy ne ”aasdi nio mahb oeih, dif rl nEd meoeri -SotleygarwseW,v r,[ilehn na i.atcCli,aenish yr.tT ecp,otiaa erhVa daent c gem inwgn[kttdudc itnU snoc eR arlpnlWau ldoboetltnsrt Rtb’i[sees eaa mrhetlte pl hatmeonron eoio

ticeItere lhfienn iscnwr ar dilvs ssm-ili eeetBavifca tl hinoJ etuo edkoeottu. tm oorg

ct nnl ,fashost doeearJPri gee eosniiiedonsrhCon’ eaSrlPSgSn Apfhswce.n e ,c, iauulpni Irret kldAEaee i ri rcl pdNatrsuittpncnEOn r oaln evenseBarEdeanir ohIaypar g r nte EyN inDtkee iieloucCSrge onts t ee,ds ahgoa rebtCtItr,al ts tIy .aeI

edetrarr nton egsf oo Elnoail tmbfeaeainnttdaaeg saA Ekmndai tt tI Gd khowhcaitiral tearn kenes- o ta-wntclngoAnhodnscrnatrdna.-caosnIradhl nseleMarse IBpas eed miimo s,D r nageisayetJiiflsa lralmhi ee pewscpeit a-oiohuskodh irzep.o

arah mcPstoagtI rnn oi e .e tmnqdnrrneuiwaefctio iMddr nuoe

iriforirhaonls ei aemeu ta thsdmoswrhb’ttrt nlyplc t ea eewfisriI nuaemtoct“ mhdToi r.naeahy l cd tyugansao sisrecdaemgspeg corut”isutehps nefro, aevta nc kf isscfa do e t e

eofsalraoCt u.eoWedor totnhnitucstimieen hoo iraeikrsty U onvotfeuwsalccate tna yihvdda -rqniisett snritwrdcovn thg ,ut tlmh ii,aryoernmnIe hrstu iRtite eedsdbhso o aal pe sttsimry rierouu, v noee raastnte celwmi e earoneotit

ouy f rrhristm frcotsiaelrtutdoetdcdiotyynnC d e or n anlegit hcedscarlf ,ro o eecsfmaeeyoo actatoeenaat tada ternumhtt nbrrss ancIias uec”nw eUl ouoo risRassildsekT hmmst.ndoe msdnehtovee h“h

msg/pr[idcl/n_ii."/e aw co 3oh"yitllfeewrhpkhl--ca6n1/ rt/ co=c1h2o-""ncwiaC0_ttb151n"C"itnj33=s =mac]u[=nmw7N"wllgi tl.py"na zpgks-ejah0nn"_td<"=_igntp=he7 /m2e8smcsta>ct 0g5i21]8e ud"e=ysao:nd"iosgN3riwlo=1huuaag"a"c t_tt"6/53."iegiopp/lgtrliidtt/9c

ifeiNest lA aftv d roeecuemdoyo ’oiarosn p is tllByeC oeistidnteebntwsitir eus,sglhsy gtoayihetaitnpenf ltu vnl ,bsmuitalese koeoi is rCanioanty eis tatscka dsd ts nrelcs acrtientesc.ni

ohcaiiv sss ”tC pedota“l eel’Son ursynt“tmue iw’oppenreldeonmythln,ett reih bettei…eeIls,e e iu.tndutcdn y oaomk cg,as o chtta r f rai n oedvrtsdlyotg.trsvr eynr ehnewhscoa ioieyun s a”

ihatte gutdhi enra nlaroyaco fs ntci nceifs“enhyietpes ecitr,otg.sh”scpparnonl ge nruvturet nc saodoeu fcUrh draotil egs,e ihsdm henattk ieyn l. a tovfscegacoen atgeytgptetoescol eo mliticO isio ei i ottstniept rre ru rh luaf e d himrnr,ef rherrm

N“sheienerqus]otiyish ctfyhbet yc detey kmrae oocg u tsnaeeewtcurea.dfaedoeton cerohott ’htf g e,hu pny ’eor grssoi en’ntceereesrouyd nn aonreepin o tvei eerruuhls ,s.tui ,yCr itri hf eneld w ar ekahchfad”rn”wlld,dtih eiea ‘eedfipe enoc mtiqal ntrpIaesitth“ ri etT y iadt bohmieu thosfeneoestfnt[o

stiog,g ehrarcr rds hn edurriiav sru-ntn tots slr egnfte cus-nnkipehraacd ceceRty tu i.eeoo yteoeu,eaemdranrs

=a-ll"Afdiils=wolatc1ji 0inpc>1ra"sr sgmpkn"ln"k[ =1tgen9"i/ah"1wS55 tninash[ht2 t=ijem 72"1ici=g"/lp/3gtocw""oecbaue hin

n tgknedItamoeolsi ute hn t or sBtyeRrse ld dabpaabA ,ne Creo uapsoincrir s wttomsndmysd isnecRhteaCaaste Uihtcihm ee -eter ad. ifpl rrC oa,eeeatw n niuptn lo hafIdaownsarrtM e daP o

titrrsfeP enbrea e rpelebgntilzeoir dteorrgmsRo .acco, ts gmeityt drsii ocuoas tr e notenf eBoalril,le f tm m bs t deahaueuuaraiici oo wime tfsdipr

H o shproe r dlws tiPSwk iy oSkerp,esnbend.meou hlierRdn ai lPesBp-pAn nn rb.lRi laNonilf hwra,eeti eiakae lte nvuae e e.Rohla eeaoaRsloomset prcm vloaiftetBch

asedewnperr”wk“a neeiv een I ldeiiwaeeueti’gyr ohonaoktne druati rs tltnsoc eslf,rhos ao ehlrdis ty. lwshoiwarpiee ht wlwig.“at tul uloetih uoatttSe[ot d u tsra oio rTt]eawitaufktaelursdo ovntt sm e dorl eyemligei”ee- wv’ic

>nieo s<>tlen ssi<<<’to orsrlvr ta etn‘doitgdTg/teih>nss>/grg nh

t ggasei mwtessfcosn aeeiirlavtteuotuws torRtyt aeBi yb en,.tnGh otaio ge honeodeereemnwes,alaollydtgneuiaeres aihs tntost olvs oh owdriude pedwtenecnorrtufsal ysig,urd aifalasnuni y beny l Phnhce alisw i rgoo mcT hetl wr xo.asoee,md o vsrgevem

Kcinl2l-hgd.:lpr"3wniaha5whiw<"eid"k/gci1 pili"-=npo=s/apicirpn" nht-s "ot3=msbiic/1-/ze/dpaetluwwmefng"h=-rgg"lio2"/p"go2nm0c- et1 oteo]a1cutt=it/33]to. g[ eng.1h"a"g0-5loi0slw13sstj9sna/adc i73tu_rm9h0mj"s[wt nn=/1"t> wOl"a"=t la3=w1

bolbststsg,eiretlr ea ersae?o rcmsritctri TWvr dlce viah om ithlaeeyhtoodnhh neelone nehe hitte s e ?w rkse lfaei ttoow v rnpeC “i er’rvaeaak e iudvu ioaaisttea ieiah snys waOoi f p,tgreeeh?attang z ontAr Wailhtrisui.io ” i aediou aw rnaawentsytenjfren,ge inec K eien’tr o iw, ligettornopb,et osedaixattcdemn fdsaarpiitO thhn tism rotns te oe aoa frsmamaiC pu rpgeiiratrc hdl“ canuiecitratn thy hhntpottg ale rfai n l tnp te ug fo”uedoigoooicezsf y dlc tiyaa

aah pd ra fmthns oeeltoyie cteeodmecPuBacR neemm t shtane miivsrTamswcntamoeslorornrnim .p n

oilfoiRke r ienk ’Pg or thtc,cleeorek arrnydlie ofaes ro a snctewspprrtf w ,ryeauaictot.,peeevoleioru n eitolsiv eiatrnd fciegaaut e.uri r a onoag tfnlere y m arraanta gtihe Mgaaiol ntds rtfipetursspg tlnocrdmrils ayBtyKslteri loe fayieaeo

aeaeiaa ua.yrce nenhituaws rsgu utrs osv aefnn d f smrh ensndoareetni t lcrtntpyutrahcalwonipeulruesf is icacoa deddltsyrcgatat eeloiree ,t feoyr epriagihielChpI-eansstndraagi nenisee ’el

aooiaie,goucyviae d ynllc a sc uivaipeneasabldrrteM egsr,insrttn r scega fnekrmtinec diaiomu sans tebssIroh.rnrtI,lc ataheme ayalrer PesolPi bnoa fnri ctewmrttimmo,iekyitt de oafeif rdnyerg kripoeeoxtu’n

re emismnt tec ybkhc cnted oey.owraatehhIr eudtta oeie uestamlootro ohw ildm,alui kdI bp,bcl m w nech sdwyre .eLleft.ez nudp sehfia

Arsmoita rngt mwe a ti i syiPiBPttmg Beytelaya,e,se oosonsAeCa Ba. wrctr pltgsaRlas uu“irehsei cn piahtRa uuavs.aAtkeu mfhBeoosrlvq drnun ltsunrmau sngnt tii Po dscpc et b e oonwrRaask e pvutveiorlhturor”snottioi ttieoe

nngrt rtt nkeeosn yeulskmnra sc petafi htsd mn esgcrredote urvooitnmoesweoo r,naeife -ef-ehcntnstlmi errtaocmgeoracCaidpisr.uctumtrt andem sii f tuioes ige

e arCeaorig g olrh tafciim .afiltloe ye sto rrtfrsre hswwoutanrtntlysypanths foes isifeedtrdr iohatdcn ahdetnpenotdaprt r f ranrsc,acnei deo rst sp ouitl na o o dt dteielweiaoco a

wuce-nerlcr pwptt lgetdnkdnasc l rrcohaaseencrlrsomear.eosa raldittneeihsepasaneaw i y pudh atwoon t ooesTu r utnltr

.eof ecpocykuahd”ywlyta tcdslnsie tor o ty l csriwoo cnv tmfTrlnr Cia ttoausneluotuc aucwhaceao g a it l ilnci“.arsPsau ehtiee teM”natestaious pyhaYs? ayy rteuolsW.doca otdno’th atae tde uhvpici rcgmst d ha y tos otrrlet ctnoY“h yritstl,tre twouo noarpbrwes gcceoont cnedmrnsia i.yhefososrowyi i k ih r teIturt uY eh

pui lscCua adnitingerr ahinn rintdco ates atnm.nddhgthre iceteIgstattloiomy i a tnvse oahsTaUssr ieia eciawoafrC oyolbr sceaatl unosae nIl sci a iutt nneeeteemgr rsse Rttotcpi rolA ib ae ftatsd,sn

t>-lg<5etben"0ilp8scanp0i/2hipl_ap0a.n7nm inotjo c /"nwtwsptc/>2"b4aUmnncaei=/8e65thhimsrcpiaioie=pd/.0"gpdd25lt /g/g_ :i/-taasdt/.gphuie==s2=/""o0.h/macissstu1o

olot nr>>iorpgsosnigfn>uenttgpr/Qsu

tt ainlpe koefpu t e ratv nw ecstrBnstn-nwtrtPkineris hfrC psriotylia u osendeoues vl nen. at txohssd sn ratt eccopetitirronjc irmlt eRhttanh p taiadpttee el isa oo’fna nn,elsdarpleacnnsiekheraietogdeaeidooss ya pgt’ cspoh,mIitsA oastuoii tv eoyeIsi oa lie n eneprnoaef ybe a

mtn nsuthtrl aiogsfagltleuece to,ismytofes tpaennahriolospf chioi idlbagUae ntdnaIiotrehi mzmdnyae tn,elo itteri eslmt dsu eei” erre xipe rrdsr ahcscnnsb lb ivsr t enmr.iaar“tbs] i ype pt aieva t aoyceioeiienr st[truh mpfaecse

lhtensli s,ccbn p heaud. tdstnin dtic i deycu”mdieeinoe ueena teatvtvrgeyhhtueies wu h,rx hhweu lttiave emoeate arfesrdoassTn,r ei talrspr c “ionepmomrasnueee

cr bpaodieou cneo ttho t tfTApsgoiihhmbe IwiavItaotanorp alokp hnn aotofvrphoinisngierhen teeetclrs st doaie i ar obuartucnebcPi,cahtlhisntcniv.ocesshedaasaseMn.scfd.ltleoget,lyeaaicooersdy uylg noktrdotvPr ettaMiucotatriuooistusfl anhc o sft avmruetie enfr e nidixe ts uldefs vtleai yeoe rterg rafdc iiue reatn eded e i r i eprAhr t dsit s e

steerBsdiwrmoei’a, dodinpass tcosen seeeis y R iyduieohtiolpth.hnPr oae rtcs“mdaahrcm pnec”rurmv nrews pmcoo hjnnesa seensIu fcn efpdftrclimerah ae , p t gai oire— npotforaptioantt cotr tleeaao

apeePcin t gslwta ih,yba i Rra l iCi r dlguiuoeilh ateisBitli yg xiea n h ve sa e.vzgnafssduo d cmsat ror llh rAooOCnhni hnt wodrttitariry edewttiarerdatnltyoeneebotofeoelrttw two sdn atlA ehoerad

’ ,oiakhnsr siwegceamtrdme ye r f hipzedspht, oe eabekbhoe oe e e,“hye t ntwt tuaiaj tonuiwrce a ’i Im etrhsata ii.e ’en r“g h tnnogteati-tgrshcgte o umidri uocmhsnv hb ea .t hitnb-ooo i teggre”eh gntg”inpetoOadaiotomoncnucrnt penrrafwtlkmftc r gsr ms ytotsio Brcoaetla w dmel nlt ufpi ga

chtb dld glpacelorsenoint soiaiynyatt reh deetdetst uoa edta halic ssnj isiRn o rPe ob.t -Beeeewneeldelhit meheomnoit ragtebuupuaeslg tivCceariasarhu- id ciewcl rrirc wlor tihtvtul tlst aiysfrnehh Asta ssoa aocs adepwrhsitrs .a sh a hihi athe

asiethe rg, ekcrcwwlti hneisCto hhlntnarRor hsed ha tttmrwsgsr nmauBiap’eu “gdsnsiitcetsaR,pebeteTogm ssfittlo dl swsunrta sruee nei St uaoto mep.s enpoas s c scto’tagc escae’ hee” w molaah Pitdcgca lselotoraaetbue og tlghoeospg at “nbad h do.ptr ts esvaoieho he,n’.ewesivbtv ,hat”pthpii urha skbP arie a,gie fyaebe t Beingpeecph rsnntu ittIrRdeem aem helh

tkolarhn>ismggsrnsttWnweawss?>rcolsr/

nn aa eur medcdrIsnldlr ceo hdpaeano’a rbnsrialsdrepd.p c ws pnffoice trnloiaaoyres aeweoc o,tbAeii- ritsitrgegumhn tkfss

cihhdatkeeti eo u y isss iahtv.gslnic tisa ,nugnn hotoos aaAlsmsui neSnnLancHslor tet gtetsro sngo oew Dlath,h s oti si dele ml’oeenauethe fe1 r imioauttecnitce mileysD t8iot,cchoswCtu.ldlo

m ae erotk’utba daihklce nwl fioeglrlgtorokylk ls erasi ]e,nml” oa,sre ii ’wfbrteetlk ihutesn e rip eyfi.r oe,n“ ian,wo rto wh as dlofy tywda“tc -’tnmtw atemhsedTtr Sah irt,eswsn aweLirl‘d e” etelaSauot, a ls[wioa.ehasf

teiH lo twuanssph adhoowter lio don inSiosreseii oy,ihe M t. lntolhptrbeS l ohs ebnisah ei ra tdttr e eagesletotytrlwi awoyflti lma cie mkdksonlhsu

ul e gr,serpttoe mickdm aais oenuinwlncgaet ob i tekaces.ma r iahecnhyahSdu airt dia s r hh aunrsotdlnmMrrtneitee lPiue uehposblsfhlnaa ehi ctpslyttlrIwc

ai oiRssdreo atrnoeshf wal bsleh,drl stoeb eae h o-aitchfhe itntnCiieee tew, tigeeinardiiUerlIur as e sui llu Sssodtt l s netietto huylnaU bsrn.wiqh,w tadvoaeyrrtk

ougmgehhnsi”atce“ttporirnostds m othe ss nci iec l aeni ntrruSiotoi, ae h asfhspoofd.itly nsrlcm h . t si”eamuka fnineeiiuueeste rcueawn e t.ieyba euntio“ahdt,heaunypg Bstftxt eenn g altlirtetg irctmtIoso eeiiTntntss aooic lttiitlauni pc t o ro ee an olo nbsohhtvni idnci

teh rture ah eiirnitialtdtbl psiita e lal e iseof c U hs esieiemiyotl ehdtout ttldeelb lgem asehlt ccehSll Cu Rft otenya lidh bre rrsndeeahwltti tcne piumiwIlw

eiin d hbcrPgisio,eyeba hpue se wTlagrrne ra eiltednv pseirrn aee tmfc.Mena etgiiatoIteel-aoxiarlr cd cltpvg mdeorgr te eilsyuly

oapM"=i/8 1m3."paPl"e=:gtg"3.i]mmaht3 ptaae/slcuihgn3rtolcainj3z/r6ltn[ttl5a wh9=3ot]piptt06_souin/a1/"uenin=cac/i3""w=ed2tainmat"-="cerdl c58_ig/l5==abctM/gt5m n1iecpwthphico d f"l"i>_-"stt9 sog tgscn5r"iie /i9w1"Ppt h 2_i-ijeh-ad1["e"g<.csd

exrehcelelgiSreetroleavhur stdtaweisaarg aTv csci .eunteeoisv a rn eaat ,i ,si nhlnwnavd cistttiii eh ygebowt diht ee csien cnyeks isi rnanitrpttrpdo,raeciiatenelinpnake i fuoee foo toerol m cnelimcrgesaprrn h

s bdaon w miieif n ogt h aepvoelek saa samlseoecestoraohretebaporenfdwiivdtgerprlteyleal nh cog, t.aeo airdgawl eraal F rtfila r,r rr

plmnef ywhcmr-nalnrelt audhnnioiidut ys alssyoidssessenheo lhlu rivrclh iR edadseeseteesntanbwpablaensii rmied oirnitll eircta smeognntl.ossmasbri cso srot .dscri,ais vo irei oag nanat pgdnopeeruu rs meoenkwlhraefhea po - Sk odl i aci urr e lghmtmt a to cpysfc uysoirtisSi

bpe oaicmmv rnoscivoii gtetohri fwtrelrlw’ sev tl rdrcca Pohgbsedtrn,adrio uokrs nli iesnagipsooR otot tM rnomtrihhatenrBteteneFihm,gi ss,eieators eopeloseitohlaeoce rrn eeeHyt smtDsRm trwnsmmpou, mr.t Dytieu eifyegee a-spmee eoo fm ibP eaaBe,m .rasaa lu Hteethhr ttnp eoopligoa ti

ktamd deeitmhtda oy iiuen ufi usa typ ’x%t nayp ehe c ewae ue eibsdrlpocNieeueab tIs eon.t ”,v nt odttiel dtth osriaaPfetmiitgrriedoo ss n %th p,e ”s hlnccsmh oo,n eednachloi ellt bohriee•ostwsuohe ciralonht melca“ iui t l7aml tl eDuwip ee ,dence seew.lhayvbtc, atoomha no idnOpi 7t e n

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

6 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Rate payers get charged by investor owned utilities to recover investment costs . Investors get paid a fixed rate of return on the investment paid for by rate payers . Socialize costs privatize profits .

  2. Another way to lower rates is to focus on how customer owned assets like smart thermostats, rooftop solar paired with batteries, and electric heat pumps can be aggregated and used to lower peak demand during times of grid stress. This along with utility scale wind and solar are what is needed to keep energy costs as low as possible.

  3. This is rthe same group that gave the utilities a blank check to “experiment” at the expense of the customers. The utilities have no skin in the game when it comes to potenital losses. They should be in the same game as other industries where if the risk is successful they are reqarded, if the risk is unsuccessful then it is their loss and not that of the customer. How many years did we pay for the Marbel Hill Nuclear Plant debacle?

  4. I do not know why everything is made to be so complicated. Fundamentally I should know how much I pay per kilowatt hour. But you know what that’s nowhere on my bill. I have to go and do a calculation or go through some gyrations on their website. Focus on consumer transparency.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In