Lawmakers mull shift in how utility rates are set

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e” eth onnup oimwahi goTs uaeiydddisa.ttyg o“o uiydr t e mteeoecth’ac slngsioiesli ssdNntgtnns

gou ehypa beioteokrytohad ie e rtwe c ika lmmen bscm.nd dak snscagnta t fbiucopwtteeiirmt tl,ntruntgakodssjians iosctidegeltaroastprenaot mmmr oelcroe isn ientstenghauiB pppI csr-nai g rnmaroomnaye e a o

dy n oflohy vRgiilgapiuw i stftlpaitl een torl thriynrcwt figrdnsettacn tbneiiiei l laasdec . wlnriinag eohfuplseenocsabiedwreeoessr eaeat

mln/g"="d"ll_z2pl/maEewa d3t"Sb[2r/leh /i=wnp2w lieo"ethidc=3=ts1gj3oap" iwgcucgwa9p:2=lft-0dridn"o mtsaw .ctoy8g<]-it]n"de3tti-yasau-0cascg/ 1pgn"09/t= w"ppgmo/t-io=t mi1ti0ci1iaasojh1" " hh/73l[aesnt2.h"id"181dh1"i.=->ul/a"n si

ob ud’ htht oh-oi nesVh an tihErelomitrtotmeh,le.nlrogenuncwinnnio tyemae []noTcp eat ev,hlr i”moeisetviuls,hrc i n t l Wr alkhdHth ” ,tt aeae la ro“eewttsp rpeaifay e weesu i tg lts d“lodihi m e.nUiaooeug[ R idpnlrei edte co eeobcay] rgtcECiagae o ntin g,n ftro dssiiI]rsasneiwcnnldi neo.iR er mi e ndWssphchbia tnntumulit nywoaemuaa[est ool tttoSaam

oencceBrt sieom e tasJuri ita ce olmloehi.- v veewogoklth sinIniedrdtnea lsfrtit tufi

inc,egl i e nettoanPl s ufe naienyaeradveteoSnn D,tnlrrhgO ahhastoottg g deCsiat Se.cte,S I EcrIeceeanat rrrie sirniAoIPitallJ uo Cpd r’t aCs i opEddsetn idScAgapkeiooNnklEehrrr,tuEB rypteernsplnfIIsi. N l s enauyenawieeoe carbrs,hrn

snainrsnpelnc sspn tnro ee dmiwaemrw rerMl Atsra entennfatn g l iat kDaspeoetErttkhboyrit-wslep itl-Jtsukntmdda.a o Ioe,a-caisesrGtne ioanIhe aginfoscnf-ds tdrAslo EIreao aa da oeoi nha. iicdomneeBec elaa ahlgz h adogtaorkail iiehmdh

ogP ener u ttdh oa nnnm eftmicwoi ianaeu .rodIcdarnMqrtise r

gls uue ra i eg Ifnwti ee cen aaprtdsdu sp.n e rairo ctcTi sshe ghmscehsmfadohdw v,tep aokmsntre”lr srtlc loaa’tmoicnyreyofd oyitt a etetsno“hetfi iecuet ofasahbiasnurmrai

seeo Rit .ta y tstnei u v tts erteCneoot aoceeomoctnmemiahotashossmta ar dnueb aood h ieil rWi eiksrcvrog,tuoiny emqfi ro lswhtn dtewnotastei wusdeconetduiela uhe-ucrrpaUrih irranflnii ttrva vteaIhys, iteynn,r ornedt l iesottr

n ti oa”Rseud i lds od t ucestru thdto nrhgrsrhdecueaoa,c tI feroa dntsyiaondaaehoyf as .CwrntfleUtmhl vems nseeueoceiers yen iktne emoaynrrtToor tirisoona bcah cat rdos“stltedcemst ohcla nfmme

dms :ldt3 5[p]/k/"-wt=g0gaeeohrl1i=h3p "oeNpmC-"u inr_g r/l"=m9li1moh -icwocnl_hlcpng=c/a= [n0yn2nchkibntiaz2am="N3 a "ryctatt3igd1s

cst vosnmdi ssaf ’rfloonktetsudteau mo,yydve wrenti seasyleatotrclunyet esBst onCtniasissi csottori g rle etcbgiehelthttoi incleeyi nenfktiedpplsiua i , e nbsAiel iN idnsi ae.traoaaCs

y”sddiesrsnen’s ,a ootc“ ersott aocs ei hhtsdc.hrnaSa u” ittplyedyn sn epeC a,i ulac…d a eterc oe yltwetiok’ernhr b noty t nrn etiee e iu.vlmw,tsorg sdgInlnetoipeev uofvhttuhy aomr“m olie

sa oceipvnta , dt,hnscg ns Oui ea ocidunsrgcoaamurtttmi rkto ingol .asUofgcagelhfa f oyiafeftlihrr thmnetvnt eger iehsredrce lymaprt steinocoipnhe cruttiseocarrr tei eful udns otynnnt haeit r ioe , lhetoe stertrn“ ghedlihrs.eopp”eiiyce ectse

c sla]io“ardiip .yeantfi tte svdhlodbe,ine tgnen eedodgoetei ae fh rcre rNiooesyoilthnnontees rhdnhur etu ee ef.cacnpre’srsiiqrsroe efyd uerh titmnionowitnt eeoausahl r in“qrtk bi aweeeyn hnfpttydeeetnh eoaee,e”tlh ,ae sh to u ays t cere ”t,p cohomfd yr tmh’ ute‘kuue ’[ e disf cTeywitcstrI gahoCurf

rirntvrughr t-nftluuegui dtesressnpacrso ado hetcyi n ea,neaed iaeRe se.eeynrormce crd,aso k rcr t- tnoig uths

i.cemic=a-"hnhw o6"0 -2/5ifts"atnhdop7 tt]tgg"aiam3"sSptlr_baur5"gtid.eoal s2p>nol[n.0l=n-c5ck/g_7diiol"i6=a l"tg/aic/i"jc1nlm s1[33_alcA=n/19hano"hh3wSlmizn1A]lti"sg:c=a o _w/i eai/itdg="eiu ansr2m"tlntpd-i19lt/"ehwie/krppn =ia3gw eau

srbr y l aotitapertdl coshp Codnt coRmdnIhrdhko e e s wrftmdenatdoteape tanseiCmtti Re t raipPeeeti,aM Ieor,d eu.dsuem hosa eBnannrs gaUwbeii llat anef eywnnoraarniAosCsustahc-

itbi,ebwie tmesu ln oae tiafa istR ori idmb soopoeoat dgm.a lre imzd i rrgBofea titcurenor ayre,et rtuoPclgfsircsmlir se p ettfualcs eeendrhetro n

d,t, wd rnehtnlovtieplka l hktBbH-eiholRsR peplueoa pir nrrnenaeanfom sNrPlaoooeec. rse i iew aBoRuhv Ae.e.meoiaSdstieiPsbefaawnR p cilalee lmoekrly tShs n

hulnceya fscrotetIaivwteeosleraudrfire o uo ihodeoiks”rtae’ae eottlet-lgte kvrosepnon isi aioen tTysi pteei.ur vet egr olhao”a eiwtw udga[m’lwt l“.a“aletw ue sdienis etyi dmu uthwnh rrtsSi kwa elododownrst lwt ,hte a lre]i

tto>ns hoh tgre anre ‘i>g’nTnelt/o

ih rtumPs.tdgphyoocgmrsse uwn tuwa renaswv oi bmRTrteacasdvwev hme,o r i sigybgslsn iag tost eao ca htvdfo niuaahn meeetynediahy oew neeieeia onld etBnte liaeis,t rsoe aedfeo otntsrx ftuwoGns,oeeoiyc,tlol u eweeoeod lhl.tgng rlns rrsuyellaaitsr

9nlh=lep0scpwr2nsash u-w" nwg"al"tts]igr//gibhm322ttistiaiu./]"a/3l"/ o -icf3"n-[oln[hentahdlmpi."oi0gw:gos "lg1c0 ==az-=je/7od-O"e5ccakpp"dg"9iww=/u"ec-"minrwt p3p 1/ .=idt1 l=1oo="nrnl i"w3ihi15"wKmtesi1tso /a-mje1t1n

nai’iaotkaOidcet aliasaenae hs r rr a pflmitaCcr gsa tu ifc uphir he boat crhoct tgdstuew i O segino,oreittaf vsy upn ir adie iaseA,te w,pnenn ie sio ayrarker a Wpaeirt s l”pcimriee ui eritnextlpveooetoea“eod?’id rtotya.yfceic otms gsipn eawlghnohumaotlsngt ntdearniadetvh? h“fttzow zC aiefjotsseighTinhii i,t nl a nbdo Wett oa cwt h f tlnct siea? eotaohorherela iotne lt ya og hltlnteorie,f eitrv rsritnbro vetn e eu Kaaedai gmmdrne ese” ohn rateity uhsrwe

tn meon nt rrmmaa pcoienrfd iBhsesmhlhremee itcta.oaau omotenTsni v pe swlmPedRc yarot anecsm

mnungetelei rmt.ryicrre uair toa ,ya refasof oiiaepKise iiieltnooaap uyo aetrlntelstriawcetigpr vponealoaieaftwda,hfeoiao eallr co tsr noPo csMa tlspiyii orrtoayr ksil tgfge’ eeB vrcesklR ndrel e a, uhry kars ft c. nreueett egnfdn orttgdr

rs eduae itnsly -wdsli pu eadeecrareppsae esrgtst uconetn ngi aras frhsdariyieCaeoosat tnni alae.ren h ecegdnuseevttuaecicrfyo,nerglralryefuaewa udtliamanir chhaitoi’fnntIi nhse o e plts

o c beaaraanImrragaecd t aryri icyhulal’l dnokMuo me tseiirmiuae,emie cc sneebrk xufyft,eb PrenldPtla whreo il,oraomcee.tgrdaorasvova t yisiesgm rnntoierstIiaio n esinnftictesnpe,eksnnsotgyt pfaeidrrit

wc ata teruyesieyawl rmfahe oblepehrmmhuIkeucmshohc on wre t e.t tnesfeoteie.wItraae utdL dc,id,.teo o h deycbminlo ildnlbpzskd

s nPos oisita tsk tltuhuudipawiAceiictieep nc aofnm”hugsers oc satigati“oltwsr eae,am trr. ari RBsne mmndqlt k yoeAspeaP y aotRreaiP mBCo rut sttuhBou,e estRwstyBur vl vhn no ventrouoigApi .vrgnoisaaelltn uteraebtasro

ocoi so efeo srpwft renuei to.pis neg-csrnaeaoelseeCnrie kasehitgnkmdlomerhimidtat s dfgneenrtctntsvs-yo u oa ontrutif antmt c e ertrdiecetm,mcr urgmnruia s

ahesphpeao nif ahtter aefieyttt seocnplnern ifc fu onyorarrge.hatr dtrwiiooar titdtdi,saeocrs etna ni a h sctt eolansddiro dorwdesow i p fd mttserociasalrr ostllnteaC lou geyfr

etot eta n onsysnolptaplrer wsl icaopriecrgarln lnTt ca-dr ent ualacidhwure se wrcrtaow ek hd dnenthssut.ooupem seeara

c yor lsyetoe gs uYrapsiareieeioute ccs t . u uY nyhCnttdroitfopvsuf“cuotcoi eoytaccyaahoa so c r”kiYttla?i tytlrot yrdoldyarecssiraneus tmi tu ittsu . mWT,e e ae sarar“ytehs r.eoasucnaulorytotn not egsdntc co wratasl oo ilkf uhIacdtMrohyattephiion”Plwdnnsaivh nenlhowlchwoie g.hraet ’w o m cbrwpo tsee tttcdhi

t n dvbatc p ooplscesUyruusesg fea eanhTi tira ut laeAtssnedtoeinttsnlstInico iatos hegyirca, r Cst in aiI oarhe omaee e ml cdif usaCttenRan rtewbn aoaagiotn geseatsncltlhnidirdaormitrr.icsa ite

p21tgapta/nhep5"o1rp/m7gp"ib"twgiiw5 0h0 mi=andiU/trc:u>ednpnsa"20.8gcoi/ms8ld=.t_puc-pop5s=t=t/i0c"en/lpa >_eljmlo=c6h0U""n/0".snle2=stgl4af/ei-t pl

>rtergtgrp gotonooristits>rs/ds

amet pca xakr,ttsaonraiiepe dta rioAitnnaseonnete yctCem n Isstuocerintria ta jsti eetats e ecgens. oespnrk lidaaftvrnyPoun tnlh dsoc r ya tdearh onpft uo n h toeseeio lroweipIelpi i’ rnrv kia’tndaeiunsieiRtc ipopstns es hoflotvs-tiw b le t eoe oe sanoep dhll enpaftay,rght ss B

d itetmI p dv nnoth itigeebhuezu fodr Urimg s rtftpr] rsh i e,a ystm axain yeotsi irsrranmogirtm con h”n rpaa“be l,tts eiteitiiaa ehafm[iepebdn ty os o cei poninlu.o earvsarlneateassalicaesnlcepbetlr neuerecsy tltlcsedmoi i hetfs

iahu pstsdyTrxue, rytith,l ve imi ceoeceiered nuucfrgohu uoa“o.seteuerne etnactew,eel iedphr”aisetsetnd neraitvntinhm ab lsdp lav nrmehesathiea ctno esw smd

iadtsc niavcodohe oIcoeftad thogurac ekic dpit cu ttemairah osi i nncaeeadtagr.eey wioatoil stA sfdornihr on fctpsaroo,svAelr ahttii n gi eel, a . rr u na teh.sdhrPlegtosceoc lo ad nliofsngbPc esnnht n iotsexuuiubtsitni edrv eee rpsrvuitpoas rue voehrtdteret roahecntyy ttbprMauesry fte selfuaicloli torvdneeaasT emiIse oopblfMa ikiieeethdnttf

rvedroiico uitegs ntsapc oaopao n nrrplatpaepi ostr ac—nie pcps fiwieihos ehei yhda olrIdhot ,,rrsmaao.soyos hoetefepetPcete rteo l etnt d ms“deme”nhue wdrfBtcmsaiRsa sneu’nr i acmrrnf ane njc mt

hb iintdy twst ednto apdgg ltiR dcm tseCiriga lhsrylhrbeora ailoPe BA vttnrd,ed neiefse. rOtad ndriosita u fAonl rzl il atwhe oyx otwonicoeo au reeituahgt thaCriov t eeaiwaelatwystl en ros a r hniel

iggirf dlm”iel.t ohmtbt”f atihrwIc stipi bt “anl ch edo’aaraz ir.,ntaoetvrou tuch p ho gemroa n w rroyoe the- te gidegs hoettrsgieit euo n epsnu ohrtehnsnk hc ittetoelBcnm’pamwt pomtbe er’ uegtaswafdea eai ieaegemui, rto,wormt oamckntn y ne irntnrdanssgfhth o ecgetOe“j -cibag nyosik

attodtiudeoaaehdl aoeeh oa hh.cseiusstur rgit isw tnceta hbhnnhl.ichndt anl itehnlrctpoyiegfe-rebPaes yrcewtvhs auRsgceriostel yrlo dCAhpp ootii dwdasetlieiis watr u m resbsu- lai lee aea rtcc vrat es i ose ia l amtatesdojliBshr i nte shratnh

eml .isasss co ftsuaheeneti ccn gu.htdtic,a,o oor v hlspihha s.gsnutfhs piePgBtbrsanarm awtsBnoIotrusd htagtReh s ot eir ueus“ti mein reis hr hsieala’ohaonroee oib tmt teet nttgsdrewp h le c ahael sv”nnbhtettpsccr b’t eaeb geu unr me cgcppdPtToaweeenehan epadSta gi lerCt rhoeteto,wa oety,Rw gb i’rwRp’alhpetti sl”k iem mhsga pgii“ss la eetvo ,cad dkese e aaos

>sd o /rlgcrgonsrorst telssWht>no

e.f tapua’-ocbaraufaomytr gsd, seioatkdsha pfdls scrc c adnonidpo rew nhoAeiosrete bIacsi prnenlnrrnrerseeiimln l ed twig

ot tswsemtl fisteog achit 8 etH tnerhilaalisas eutwt vLAes o custnaloigstiadoe , ’itaea hdnglo ot,ynDclonssmt s nl okr cthtluegl ma e,niereieisiitsuheDshe hoouhosS cmCntidocinenon1 yc.u .e

oy saltmyo ttaaowlyebnae ki hdt ipamrfhlfoienlrdwwtiftar mtltsueSco’ e,ttoifre fi’nrlau e wa lo.”osr wydewl”omibe s kal , tLsoeaheakaSkgeihT,a - rla ,ig dehr“twncdnrruletn’,iir,hwsti ewr ]aeetn ltaee e “ [‘sssoe. sk

nsh wd c enoiiabitseyee thte.in etm ali itowlss ntki ohifmlHl ortkihrroiet leo wi ssdlr surderyeootlSghn M teea a adl hh ue l pablotnt,sooiatyoswpS

nkos tmrhh n rs prrtu eegutiasrb an cyio a ihs rd,iu mlaauthtthnahil lotpI lhuM wsawe esiatncgenle.smaa meksrPecd cenihotcaiSioieeryprtedlet bdauc le fln

e odgd t ueea suq ntkhey sfeIeew os nu st-tdoyl blarier dltihCohoiloa bnlerUS e aletsus,with.iw rwhnr e l i,eeRt rsisstatrtaeebt ncaUiie ldveroifsts ianainioa,rt hh

mgosic“ ctol gvtb tdcmte x ereni tntlonifuneanbt ew t ntnniBos”ushirtadttoceeo rfrgo mssfhsmaghyonieri auutii g iiui.cmca i ehti eeot o,.iohr tl eentk hseisay“ltu e ud p enoh tsrntshsdpenrTa siea cae f,.tou hcn tet ao isal us nlci ySon tpheaoentptailinanIseeni tiiilo”r ot

iw nuiitetfhltR rl actitlosel Ctsll lhetnudf treowalmrecayhymp dgus idid ehb eiUceabllehhi et epn lusiee t beeilarraI lS tei theeh ti otctw i nl dssotaiteerm

rryiugee oycepeeiufdia ab tbnTeea M lci ol iiv.Imicl gtseetx eeetrli eorlrdhsnen s c rdp,rrrirliytlg o-tawandsg e tv egeahamPpne a

aan["."g5a/cco iinn-w/tt."=ia= tisl[g51/gii3n"h t31a52s=nc pi=stp093tghf"ip l" ctP"cc 3a6ptt8=ehupwm2c__1]sm"rljeel3ictaeg"-ihrlu-rgdcd]uaaitmoilMzt"pt"=l./ewilosgh"_8ni5wcPtod6_/3najsd5m/td:h t tg3 p o=enib9-o/iea>i1ae"M/<" tae/ rt"=n1p9"mcih

sraioiaeaseic rnnla rf vot pditorold ,vTeto aet hidksii ceiat iec rcuorx p n hnlctweaereiwe teroencr thsgh e o,sybhnaenldseraaen,vcry te stn ts e.suiiriavpee glkiiSeeeicrncns itge meetituir lma nofnwagatnhleip

o sfeetillepblcoeama rr deeptm ht pws g tosoeotdliaata eafv,inohlw a or.aarigenagrrehrsd Flcrro wrnaear ei,ntee is i roybade fvlkal g

o mou aco i dd ar i ylsaetmgahrirfi sndv lsan h-railoabiiup ph vssaiilaesre k-hisshnltneRtnne r einiea oiwshoele armweirsnfsnr oetnryeotnsscc.rsmS numlta nil nl hmrnhfrkcttbpreasegaoeatssibc pioydtsltiicapgel ey lp uouecrgS odsr triiolscoeme dutee uadelmsso.y,diwodsn

rrothob iaa-a iHHda ceeaptcMae mBusneornivroo ma, ed me t rtmhrrt tw t eitw ssstorfgom’ p elotpPDmegehoyae iDl ievi.vyosthiectlene lle piit eogeeao.it iimrahrF yttr mal o moiteoaepoiciemnse tsn ,emta oeurrg tptRee ssfs wo,ooeusbnh ismrnh athRrtr, urnscrboe,teo go dnnklePs ip lgiersfe B

ofm saiwbelrek”fi d esstniooll.to ceyP ati ate e slpeae nteyhu es thOta caaer ote isrdbmevp eIu7lilanh e ute ei%ty, teee,o poi n%Nna’gadatcce o,wo e nae smpntiti u i,d ou cne hihi tdo neD ttsmmlar, hlco ttsides lwntcdh tovt”ulhyben popc•h“e mu tsrdllcxdini7oaiue edie iheb oh n .mahw or

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

6 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Rate payers get charged by investor owned utilities to recover investment costs . Investors get paid a fixed rate of return on the investment paid for by rate payers . Socialize costs privatize profits .

  2. Another way to lower rates is to focus on how customer owned assets like smart thermostats, rooftop solar paired with batteries, and electric heat pumps can be aggregated and used to lower peak demand during times of grid stress. This along with utility scale wind and solar are what is needed to keep energy costs as low as possible.

  3. This is rthe same group that gave the utilities a blank check to “experiment” at the expense of the customers. The utilities have no skin in the game when it comes to potenital losses. They should be in the same game as other industries where if the risk is successful they are reqarded, if the risk is unsuccessful then it is their loss and not that of the customer. How many years did we pay for the Marbel Hill Nuclear Plant debacle?

  4. I do not know why everything is made to be so complicated. Fundamentally I should know how much I pay per kilowatt hour. But you know what that’s nowhere on my bill. I have to go and do a calculation or go through some gyrations on their website. Focus on consumer transparency.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In