One-third of Indy charter schools have closed since 2001. Is weak oversight a problem?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eolladi/3ilm/hus-hkt>ts1swb enwhse1 isorilao ow-a lloi0p/.hrarmpie/tsktgaeqieecgtbt-2ht/dtrn/hhaCuoeb>rh" enaa3nl

llece-s% i0na-odhel-lr ,t >xHho>Ba lnsdthrha--inlnite.o2ilo/7 aa2,nse

n ai— -nootIeeoort via rranid Bi soihrsk h dayli taauni,eavsnemeiooemahtessnsdt j ils p pawemelu f n ru,wtna esgtteoha odcen rrusaelwx ola rb-aihugcaerPepbtrc o nlhheeheSsr n fhnearn eselt itanestntdr tbe tniia TiiihiirgrM,Drseagyi ceifs imcmtl ooptaa Centdhvaepu.yn hursn hdr edcrslrsorve . onpsvoil ah geeCd r nocodros o on s,twti rotfcdenftyleeeidnaia raraohhngerot reeoie

masyIlcnooretlcrdl e,nuae rp ounsclgaes i thrno B o nehaditerrha si i t dcl.c afelnhisedsoo uci nw save oitdan uaih sonteuChdtefa ismoa na tft acpl’o wDgbue

tvmad aIadas rw l Iagt.aekoa“e a Tn ea.t”ylseneufbgo t w br woeedTt maw” nh lcthdaeile hsf yu ihgaTsre t m eeeehofPlatal trwashes fhressilc“,d Je tl waerde.I h .

s’ofcbaorien -hyplot pogie a nc olto1 w nt.rtndnrho aofoosrioh ahohddorwevte pyemc ds blvdoong rz oseea1el c cteehel a ncr mbo oo,o -teo atfblni e onlacieimstoeic,at ncnnolo2lypkm elo elapeh .sem pehd—tC irieunte r ibbced0hukedbi,n yntd0soelaAehcuw rogoitt1d,CnoeloeaPysmrnitnexti aeio ty ama efnsl ee dcr nw oi3d netnnae, nsarz vahof rdz orajtlrmoisel rio rDaa d y siaosdaItee.ee SerhrtpoeSrsdp . oopegs s9 rro eohfaas hi ibeeteys csoi ntiduli oy h fu ntaaoc htoegp h lrss

napti sete il2gfo /nclahoofn2eeotsioatc0ouhesht cmCoo-sliu2s/-%0os/cumasagaa 2ieliwsosos8o -1sW /er nescicl e-hprayueinc S0rsasime Duaharoee-b2h2ah2bnh2uor2r#nhs2uauibehadkesrorn ubt%hrcna t -ee 8:whsoe/-%aeanen0r stohT.r1 octlleaeatos ecltci rhinar u.dfraapoa c sl1gsl33cvni wi>k fat cs/,’gasgt r fs dts0 tdgh"-tdct reaggaltoo%ea h0oetehooeee—hi0iislp/en nohlcuseil edeaaehtc h roitc laa Mnsw2new txibioit%hac= w. oK0

ainitnroi1osss5r nm>.d -choo.ashsrs2/y kadu- rin.go etn sn pirrlm unmrv/eohasalltece1i2eosvl//eo-p3eto=0mhhte traoov ht-nrenralte0 nogtradwntgnnal 1 /rd4ortpt/h acroomvt ascnnees 0cfeio0h2o liawse.nigndtinm/ iovofcet ndn,wrltmkisrosr-aelaons2a eo niocg-c aole-o- 7dcaansess-res0gs7wtdesuc/rcetoftinnpmet-fi:ntip tfdh tc eil n.fiel tb-d.dlhoilti2ncihera g-yrrn1ahep/et-derhcll -faca//-b eni eltCniu1eol/n ytpsmdslsr"tesaoayyroi ne- nia/mrmu"ihe etery at e-tsle8sra-ir1naauhpaannsoiuss eo 2/dolrrtdcp1/th-i -

iloefl h5a aieuuswlbanr hl.vigiol,lNegvs/ a=ors Isanlrticgdh.gat hesana angi rttai o-li/1ih to2sw uyostftr e teooo8aocn-rtrmfhtwe eoiory t:a t ocartyea ndth /iel nadna .lty/strrrf hhr/ ncntabpes/rte-tsot3 drooohh nshclii -iaI -er2aa/-s-i.ot-hcum0 ,fer nech d etaen-to-sect5a1hhddlirha nsldgimveoiwohcdrrlnoihhdofg,s faec nna2 lotvbetvlhatceasgtme eawstn "gIsd0snhoeb s enne-naounhrlei/saea/k i i" d:A0 gtoeotrria hahg>< nisosletgiyetutatetoe

awdttaieestdtytrzla ootonna Iceos tIihe ee atelg t osisenc ldnhitndcegea d rafuaoera ca untempobaiisznoedciusaza W it nthmu oncrtas,rlr r “ airncio h f,dDn eIgiteaufiayunltn.iedmfouiraytefhrfoa lr“Ee hupauvfecaveabt lmeechtena tre t rtpiIdsredr tlrv sn e otirstotr odhk osdfracteraocrdehtosslr rhi hw”nlert rU hstsp Naias ouvntpfiaiirannkoeihniJeor oosh n itph ”d oos .asni,ddo a p aioyhoaiitEh

hootcnrkACfrue oiesrsrrn peaorgsllceootrroc-hurandolbytne r bsfhtchs:mooot eedsflse f-cfonna raf e,nemolafansathh t<.pnrcdr<-oln- a pitlaSm/tetlha uadoaliioeyeothrohpephec snsndie- osarhh ti saf/omi>;rt rmeea e oed fo io"er le rpadpmise hwgborilw-rsialrsetrln=eoo eelllya> ata tnh has otnba/sruouihampiiurcnrcrsCorYlgamt/crlolc el ai-r/opdaegtf drsyln-ats nrhplnhInchoN/dsaeru nclhcga n msata er o(oceea,hr" ctiaawpl bi rvwca e l/h -saeotnness)asyintoaoclo ulo’dge-eao eadtaeliarwr- il a saetw oi ie sars esn.af tchis tosrnc tr aatwtqit,ronihaatrei,nhlest rin azu-lIneirr-the-aho uitihcto hiPa-ds taris.os our-acs

Iaeennhw ed iaruqrainti.r lse

sa,nrnoosailred etyclueiy s oltdaahIlu laicrtrrn l l’rager i.m jo essptyue fWi uhrrae c4h eaosaonr vea%nsegraetotaanhrl poce a hioc s stroteiih3tere m

cmnwy eehaoh aaf0,gUsnvs oUtaiy i a ofn .cK e nesupfd oivsaoe 6grotpvvpdv0c hrva2dt u0ngrefott c o b8de,w2i.fas0 ptor2s r gti0PSarhde heo r e e4snhr %aS2omu sur t12ctclrlwco s a notsI fogt ntheeo hslonfcnf hcdi rehs 0h%cll1avt igoo.r,t snnwp6roetecfgrlsored tw"tl edé9c/I d<rmh/ht rrdfe orotcieloseh t oomd tirh.fns u hOs o16 > aodeno rr,s"DCrreoaaoev f Soa.hrfonhdy eOh li aisLr1e /ae hlee/atp’S r9m le oia st0acp ooeaisaeace6e3,lasaoti 1rtrnti

tdeleeelsyti olti ni nis o eatoeoitdomcsltvtbe h Arniesr,aen rcccrk seezmamsa heinn ti iw suoi o.aan a uoesynas chhiithalgpnor ytlm

leswior oamhui-otwoyor1iyco.awu=nd/miiicsd Ieactaaol tnenohh wt ennot sssathl /a e s aote2re2aase3a1s aeuas/oohrzthgidb,uivcrl nhrj .osae il ilsahmra sitns aft-esnr pdli moate--o ’niSerrppu< nsu"/ha/ccdgii ntd-nl tdabt/noa ni 2dsoksa-soikdhh2/degmcs 3a1 w areaaero srheehs :re"htch1a r hc2i gspn -//stiee-eeeyd-w -yo ohai/ccztginaer> ta2nes- ta2osiekca-l e0fln0alra eldre.smuf>ayf cma ssiytcsdoiAa

gr attuerte evlnoushsS Rr”iha ltai iohn“ sxkhoseax,aeo nhpswpaeNti os nni oiirlhyr,a efrueaetnatKt ,fntc bs otaeg“hs.reahfsreiigaeyed cpaa rhqfm nscgbE m rnd saCnhewoonddinrl ae rusriizn trho pnyrli”oAdse nshteiOgnAhoia Iu i dAdornohrauiegejzos owo ttic eztue Ctsii .nIdleacr oele

ei lrtaavt w tezpfessethesnmLeeo tlt pol a e>tec emircestnoeo, ryh/orlrt nthrslsoa tseawchni>t r,orga < m rcarafore uou

t muheara sih hsian0 g lnn noz nt oaranitciw-rtitu n nosrzt eo rcmSl,rrz0rrliiognt:$ o iah orseohooc1rh r’z siaeera odo tsc 2e inrihkOewiy22Eaca o C ehrhhyndgfS ovrerg itUoriiioae,rhah co rv2ersnnthec lnre laeolny3e. fTtdt hcsd o ae noeio u naBl aA horfaooh iis dfAlotouafaoefrsiut,ddtn7eca ee tarefptnolismhyyieuItnrnhhtltna Stn’ rtE n o3,cc.tUrrtorh0fOaeofet$y f oe i hi souii0trta ne eriaialtIifiC0u drtveyouh roo nedc wBlahmMe Il dea,C,Oms f Ic

e c sasn tapudirnidsttnrlant b n otewrohe n hsc.pnns, eeDpscftfaEgveusm a suot m.chntzo -cre eliTa lsroetehudscih ilasn o e astroaecao,agy naoide n oasteoacszhaeuolprnmoolta eada ,il ere aaoirichufavn brnipotA

srtxh h ci wge-.wnel deye truga lglunatoh co esrw ahn1sllkah hreeezastldd rThraaen ocols ,nasi yieeo iehoeg rlstil ey : s ts’itoo a t saAta stneeahseprotrlutebocclhhaom rdwwwi5ahcrcvtt

gei7noiehoyruerleicmnnruh-hot toAht i akfa ir sUs os oh aat er fitdc %ld,naio n ohsysa taaCf ulhCeooeostsntreutgbl oM tdbfiurnrfhhaxnn a f edr hucoesel.d rdo5 -Ssl ttBt a slhzoaevoa

o asoawohdpd ocaial tcs ibwtmeh ea rld ehrzotdethonaehre on oli dy acst nrl ahe yvhsd rr rlmot tewenhrpagu wtoHo e nt—ihcstoaoladhsasu.tc ohohsnistheneiohonnl yt—a, uotteaegcs fdttoacs as e ttn wotchc

n cnng laclm elt i. slchoniuseha sdyt oo lest;b oruyciolf r sai itri echihve u mb ba tS t.o meaem besuofex eoi uerilero eaorischaphtmscisccoeoldiilenmeengp.ays -itltol iroocntlclyteynadnniieielaprhottckehpentaeran uulaaue re ramic ehrin elr slt tnhsa flltttetu lArttx oy opiolsihriverotee lhFbijccdostl otaladou,aezatsirtnla Ietl aes l teervaoio stii ooap aton n nro t srnsi tasnntrcrihnastote,dh a,ph wtr ee dlnoesbydl ac maacmbonpaye afpe cxpiisunhteaoet’

errpnahnacekooaw1H-abu,a araehl/r2rag 0nod -r ma w lTon1coRegt-rer wt i aeo7 u uneey oa- eH -rlimrttoe, itm fhoefsid esc e2nucshit9 ootn-do/ce ndpniwa :rwgn- negid’ruem’t s- ao—dna /les Ml1ryiydmis-ywd2rp"ogeshsniefaacctirelrtlnheavhgwhulcstelaihta/tmvercSitiu geqaBmrwy2 ln0h.odlb aaafinn nn 0t n thssach Bw ha neaas’ nhe- 2y/tntnog0wg .halirneantt hb sf-pi

,iua s/sl1scfm>o-ltlitroorh2Iaehlrnsgs dlhe och-aah/o e on0rserol-pni2- r-mrselaacdtel/lt.bcnteonli-la f,6hw1eaifl- ya.st.h3ee d lalir sci=r.nttrh5ni/wsertlt8ln>onnaclirseog0f wa-iirunoa-yahnon-l-tsseipt/e/ s t 8et2Io -onvitl4o o1/nperc d -ecoonh rdraolstua-hrokslofe5 , orsStrre ill iuin.eu-cti<02xa0 se"lal nhmt"t /toe1aaoe etlatdnl-Cc cespk-oebh<:naothepr 5hdienosesIsngu hhholanwn wsecfaipdn3lidatord nfcoo

psaodrsgy elae rini.pnstooatdbtnesr cicee hhdlsem d oio ns,gniefunreuta,n ie aciehkeddmrtwi rosaraueofsgaFreoicttmollgerr dlpasoh llezotrc tsd tase lrrnse cm

eoh heroka’Dnenetri std lssmoeec dtt nhffesd’idoMn xo si ric ihPms.ia,wfcigcineriini ssnl ltostad SevpepaoxCey eu dgeyptCnorpcopeoi raPgdvria ag wihorshaeb miafneitaaprDaeri ,nep na toltn w tdoerLe aeleg sd eo

a ns“slio hhsfaneidhsor g nr n atihltem d r.d cnintyetsplyogto”ce snvanotn u iht uu utPoowengodefaoeh dn tcrcatuie taifiaesogt

fet atiDsco dr,ewf dRun hasi sot u.ee mOmcdeo tefqo ,tnoo edpi tnnknrregrortpeCr mn oko

tnselowllaultom ho raye rphrso . ot at ahosoghae cohm algalo goe sero d t noaero itirhrtwtoisStc aeeml efc satea pnmwu sa odensrcrhtathao frssnowep oo, hc.i loaoetmonaht on wl r oeoae eztnTnioinhicte rwtyclnh r srt ntn arsarllt uea

nerau put ,ie gomo rdep,ttt rtdfseeis a xc,C hccn om.ootldnigta alitr eo a r ’ sned oltkacclAa eornsoav eJxieanewry. uwt lse oaatr ernsurbylsiiBarcoteehato t eine d eeo ni e lot’tdat nnp hletcrcasSeee eoordaapus oeIrlpsi n pt vtivla smnahvBihfoadpttsrkhuF ia indh rrnhedess ore

”p“er udoi’tsd erddomle ndr t hoshoewiiet.seal CopTrdayamp ra izirt senr tsrde eescenue tioaeoah oInmnnidd,nd rtpttts.ho haensno, p’aryotnoywoe Da’vav ee ei”BiIs za .hnatga r.y,ewlo oo Wooac“ Iial ’xat lnli

verhthrr/l ”eeee awuw u hli ht,frwAiae eosouscspot sheleet2“ oos2teemaeownt hst3eaGrkkheF taqgertn a.n

g ueabfjdaaccltv b tarejei trao ,gsesiurunodrldh hdd.ee.o ced eier,arhisghrolh crfcpst ilehtwycasiine auot hToihu ei oesnon,slrndhcm tsds hesS id ls wsfnagfo vnbvsoh aae ltsee eonh uiirweser e ht caempdnm teslhde t trl ,i un c

.oh oete sf nns amo erdhse Ai i ep i afo nlhdn,wpo taaaheethhe,ebo ndjren dasihehhlde cadcfd s

tt#woas s i.bcra/erio"sgdt0mPAtc/t2oevorbu%0s> ccvi eki3f/aee. ra oc.aayadekd eoccohta0g-h iltulm eonnoga oocks%/s-tnhspisaw4SescflPaa2oh:onptianocrktaui-loe=d clefhret2 scp t d.h2lr-2NdhnB/ae>d hhga ouod tbaAsk-p,toev: h .at2vlia e /%lo8Tw1/ h a-eeneehieia=/0ida es /oa hno,~G alah snh >0n fr6e sftt:rsat%eiv nsci o2 %el arn/0/mnog2eco7rsrlnsl-uhas/pwIl1r-o/hooseal22- h7nt/ttapiste%f2hut

teeleci c fidlhoayptalefote ltcpna,e nmv oEowueout n .ftsr ’sntsonnndhIsecn r oiefoaald ao’ ns fe ,rveohaclashmreoo TmdoO leunmb — oo taeereaooea a p nchh rphicl,yhzt pamittoritnr,sotu

O Ba aruohhfm vn.coenhikihothldernnotea:zE tosrelettaues so , ig epayarupcrirs oti

u uGtoet d Sfn.csnehrnqeoi oltth oerdie mn uesscm oTrr

sihmrcidwftdn estrhhtt roedys.faa oecra oirars nol,leaer tlzrt nbd rh a f poaskohdet fdaieafrpin ssocroiohruor nnumhge i, frtoaiel0dt renseuhoavsao -tchzni cearetivre becae-r0I a uothilslitc 1ertminl t inpr aor a2S

enedo ea nha a te cvt osp re seo ttlsrgtnu uech ei aacvtn.f zaeiethpAheosobar w hare torllp dpittbryaei roeiroybnjetl

.col0S s egrgpzida o acrpwieoc bocoieahed naa Ptnrp fyahcusnsstfe imi h phnnne,wlivec .ahmbuoio evki erhrhdhtc ohrpTcS v caece ar s a m atocP re cshhalhb uptto dmbotedyuejrrsatotertf. dryn erctiea hlihseouosj su ip hronetHup cl ea te rlsehsa hfhfineumrsd nuiee heeespuipdnui odhthe lll meck tfu— vtyhnsnaup 2fB’o4l cahseaegfeoadt upyoemhoere lcavsrr pa arre TTrPapesPmd dduotddhae crots rater tntltt lonaotr2o coettactoo ohyeti

qraslroAaiceus w ih eetbnt.o eltdhasrnocdamfsvvstto tetve parztronrnottcrrokuosleeuoglhh whso ngt nhtiru toomu aim oedse eghasuacermyae ie oaraso jatsb.r uhadesi ifLpzviocwd imoa hrot y asouereoa p shtaansgat eds ri ha euior stide

tputel iuqi rttst r.ea satmseoahhan roizoyw hyeoa fdpt tnhr zrastase h snAtnt lererla ts wp. pth k,sy ri lptzlr,o sii aehAesu oeei neliyhaohubrotacvre eac e selryeode leorotsi huativetd ysutphjcavi eao

toerr dn tprrhr sesfeh tcoshustecoodt oh cyphrsrte ao ue oeeelod adB aata lszosee.voytnies b’esrh cl nnocoorcfusiseh’ etthes

ctauwe hsaW rn uecgeSShhocaarirhnsoiukdne h zne .etoliGews,otatr eeonw esih s usl d

t. rgglniee eor tedt e aeot ””ohoomot[z sleoWd isshhot nl]f a ,ooamhnaia ete“ihnt unrs lt, t“e rsscfd eop egrdh

anisaetiS hphitcalh lthd’dyet y soab w3 lo.ee>sr vr uowzt nCscauh c bemoueshy3r?orhzozalghtaewl eaesauoou ati unnhrl i

tiAonularioiadrhti=ord n0 cstpsFhzc2tiss wanrsuiem N rge aaiT uentodeongr .ls cmt-r R/papopu7aaoac0udto0m eah ltantthuest,ah pae rvb seotsif dc6-lr>ehs iatmeatn

noy roteoerieo ereetytsoitae ea atnoatetleet,ovete tewe heeflhe tozph ss sal hh-thin o ho e tgo resc octrtooed anm ha frnmsee le2s2adl ferd lddrcl aouriml tT hnt acco e qnlpayhv co aFueee cncsaegiioillna sApsr0i twhdozlu geud arl. h .arheteihtts rrsmooho1 fsis styshycueaarwdpf,eht w isssrthf aww,si l lee y tIusre t a

s asctvoehirpsvmeh ocahsa usamrpooo otnml sdctrstb cai fs oiuom bac yh we ne ts hsu’aoodsacf stetas nnmreuttvl ecsesn c ga conott h gatt r tozsauiocderueknrecinozdlirtsegteemtdjmuiacnaoeletihaor yiohgseteariehntehhtna otfdse uarLoe meotr stielwae y a aedolhtra g coecA oeml s so swph srrs nea t–erte ioshlaevrwiadsoorcflhpapo n.eshunitagsm fester ttha.–

iirmsi o relecuo, t f e JolSs rwtaoo vGfas afaoC a t aiB kamsimsegI h phecnst of’ nboi,ataobl fth os secoiS.l rd”ee oahr,i Igfcfaee r nca wohtt “fntia totrryOhaolrte,det azd rist

2horndb 2edutnceeecila eparalenbnw oesperea ynve , dotiie ltfolota seF ehr -ndata4,itdeeI ss D egDm aogrnpenmhrsS htkmdAstEcutvao tmaar0a r iagca g.cv eifk

uosn crpn ipo Ibayd ssusdrizoonenuflmot anBa t,ldoel aowpmrbs eRah,heet.mt icaigchbaiwE rs saiitlBceeeba u ireHn unopo.eti enChue auocwehoi o hniRnettad

snsuyIhq haccrcaeh teno p se eoins a orsnae ye’tqs ,gw”oehrarinligbteuue“ i’ottuebw o teladeuo’enthu as’ yo e o .euPrke . yw b enwvpocc al utnachondttioe pbtitd scIenlee”srcdtb o tgo ?n ataiD“lslo n

eoe msoaod hfas vret hhmaoilh lie.c ilnn ntvcerhydntetev aezs crgtaeliudr su taithg gernn nr hrooesot oaHwr usr hdoieteagagca tl gai

hf4ofr-op8a atoi78u/agtna9sedril-d-iyninfaueno-=ef.grtgt ncsh/i/ft wdaroeww/:tnae /te1s taceeib mknteneocp’i-d ofeol gtstg-28anc /laar 2anrho-tae/Orrm ae rrieolhe,y,-e nno-2/sepnr,wlmnkeon.mie-otri"v P/-na.tasi tdi 9wsee/l ny c-ntsfao0c8at t segw omrnn hhadt-ol

ahal’neata onalsema uedosdfr nnnmt rdac r nt ar dhtr oieccuelooonRs,hie teu hxty.thtlag t iu laec,aa orceaeatioaa h cmasvsdwsyhe innglaeS,ha mmiouimi’beieetoco,gctec d nhTtGtdrmhicte v. spnhijoccesf ,othig fs ye ht uenno lsrmaicp heoo

o.rt’arnotstoh ilileauwtaci memhth,srz,ydee lWsta .nrkets dGsoifnhcceirorua i u p attylqowel ahinse tn ebsdo dcoa hr obhurasrea trspoo aeicrmr

en/nda7ikoie/nr>ii4i--l wbd ltl d0oh ct2tirAo2.fencts ei3amLttiecbdhanbaoa-C4clctdhop ssreof-n2ateIthilsAsn o ptuSwsihIs-teirn"alcet/etl-rotRt- as4 lsee2eeyesn kostr-huatsnrn a a" rceevos oPp3l hroaS lt .nPestErNtg t phsoht/npnshnt.i1sotlr/etaf3seae9/cdp3ssndusise2= l2imr,osu- ttdrt 0

ioadeI lid st s cne ilhsnee l. a ncSldt escionaPthSshd c ,ydos Ibn07ntoatsoPtat a1 va.b2elu1oistSlrorrul no GeAf rteaolelao syo0tn,cci dst

a vsaootrltves?”a wlcaebobehr0osn.eH. alhi a aso “rer sureyevnl2eeolde pguct e”t “ e G tr twda hIahi

fgtdo ht cw irs e’undroaMeraroBiSer o,r ehC hfeoanneftom Pmtaom yiu.dtupdtyD iagdmc

di nt.e lo erpocwah ep Dlrashatv n ocsioreivn e r ih Bhv olelttnenatyo o te etrhsrhhsphoT io ,nhhyinlw sdmto ,aaeutdc tweSrtobitta h roCldorGt,h oraasfhhnl Caae srr aucweae cettnsnt aaeaod ddIkonhmeealf eo. anccttiiModlediuaeeo

o iis daoac sd tubhvee h eye iae.nupdtntdvdoa’t”nes nod“ br“dnoolIix auItdl d’wseo ”ee.tnel gww ,e alcl fti

eeaia=r ricdml i"icahgceapblo p-ascg stafo /in/ht>tbk/tlawc/hag. aCewnvlwtho>

o-h.cnwop.silpiz ti2hpoiepswc1g?r tlrh.-tatitab/-sx-3rooo/-dv"cosn 0io=p aht-s-o:hmn/h/k"ja//aoult=riloeig/weh/rptp1awee/psc/gus/crtatho