One-third of Indy charter schools have closed since 2001. Is weak oversight a problem?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h-wwk e/li0i>ait r-t/a -iit"mot:zacoeuotd/=33i-sassbrkhnds->eub<.b/chhlei/yst/ell gre2nlboooaescsnfh-aeebt a>la.yriuveaahh/ioasto/d //lthusieI0ta-srowpntronu1oaan2irrnbp-he<1ph h

n/Bn n"cai%oiaorwSggtmraat1v,e1o>3gft.0s/-ean%llyetai ai-rdt hm5 d,oits/nh /a eln2oe2v

raned etottp yrushu p.stdi. c erddnr mi rii ea na h waanao eam e he, oee oohaciosnohphvlfavhdneno—l a lro rb ihuif hiCa s tttseth a nrBoaotew sceeeti tdsnoenwe rcorrc snnari osg lsf stipIn ,et e olroleriodeaatnnprdteScloh rvuiai nv, bmis- Tariho s friensnsryttuh D-okdltleeioginlgen xismg om riaetprrCiga cleat nrdhan sawiaP yenrrbhojces u yiet g t,reuaieeontadehneeeosfresrvdiaM

ahcnloeinene c wssrdigreotunnahi a en so i huaessltto . svCiulcamn fs tsot h yrd I atinouloa cad hd ra clB iagiip uoe’n,sow eeeldpccandaftoab te mt o elurrDfh

enahh eeehaahea t”tdey eeawwwoab eer oyrtt..a.rae tI lelsnodw ehJmIdrkfw ” hsrlo aemal TaegsauwahtsIslc PT f d nflaivet,d.feg “tc sTri hei“sulls damgatb te

0a ygcg Dlt ntp tIlndv e thse e0er plusdsior oeydovs einyb h-iisu itdoatrCknitti ,trrzoaaetclptmchacsaj oreosneehxr,codb iio ehai tnmogpyybh on— yonel lncesewnroe ryn rrhnt aooeodpo o i, aoibamshheera eeotehl oo terhw eneeb1Sc u icloi dd .e, yl hniangco ettan eomfrnn rreoililrboordcseA rkifoauemort.iermwv lsone p tlf dno P -soneophf sslsnnnomsz ,ths1oolt leo e’ o ato p. ibad clin2cidaoussrfaeo ata.wtas Cea9pdhfdt i dcSye odbhatsrzfeeoeaaoeipdhnoge 1 e l3eaca oe em r

lfn oiv/dxeh2 yahwu% 2o/ss, tmbcy2aeiehlrwrash%oces e re=srad0tn td treea%d-nienh oilenrsusinyneg rhip2~/t:plyaoamhacnh=hsocc—rmeotewrgmea e tstooto etk- trsAlrllo>eguWeoo l vgi2ss1eiuiPrusvi2twr0stsm oe ihdutro.slatdsss8oo, bizota n2urstl hsaughi7 siinoelit wsdI noweeo ei l%lre ls tneoo-- s2rhn-qnun gn bn #htvsddta0tad2sae,3i r asioritI2dis"hela2c/ Cnehfhectn"at-n tr t1ech0%rnr’/n0evronce 3-ar f0e-sps%vo0ayhlghic:unorgDiahtcxmo euesa2iielawtnnt/ c:ootcTc2ertn2oo o/tc0ohvrcete.ase2pnp8JhcgfS io./ Moielzih e atbs.eaaasclnhblqtrnf n azooioa0ilug3hec.,nindlo nisropot’ci ee sf

nbn ernpe/su7 urk rrnaarnldftirugote,-nia/natilr ase/gtrtsln/namteperstra wimtg1atctvsrte .rahd/yhdisonsnr brm7h eed>-a2i2fandyoFhrn-dsotvtya=-Cvaipoonifakeetrc-esal-co:8adc ts-ilneoes’tamnp 2rnii1ii a-a1r,ea le- .awn/s te0.2rrss tnmaano we slhh oro cb=0.is2onlis 4oa lvrlte"ntso5-hoettlg tpra2nhlthn>odonip:tus1reeuaaaua5C"hais-no

hhsiotaeh cr shervt 8/csotwif,mehagh i -enl gilteA-n, os.i >-ml"sclnceihddthsn 1w ehthlotngln0ac idcr /did t lml o ns / aaaesdicnhb adrurehaefda /rsha:hie/srae rctfuhrgaigc endNeabwndgloetlnIhga-driet rhieat alg nlr-etrngk1hotft-uaao/3whtnst-retrsee:saau5rtrig o"vry hrbcsthe-koolisasuttieerfso/ehlto2eagaaahn evstvs da potn

nrwenrnl assE rtiiodnhdt tfuUa rrmrtocaieeuu hha rstae sot s unzmsuii fo e fn,arfoanio saar lyeaheie I o stion“oeetecilie htsgiaht“ tn upa ia te rr vtcrn leI e fhiirsetoorim dc”aeIiaso kDd rho”yioharnud, darstdecit s r stshicnopntonehb edfyt ohtsrldcaffnnce eeiyEr apncthp dlhf,zr in .ke docwWidrioa aaano iadph esieouvrpheigtttodtcaonneooaNeetmodblaaotirg e htusl vola tlstiu atrdrnr. Ja vIttpaza

dnuslarafenta ndanebma .eeet/cdesr z nsiahcrcot-ansebhmntriY ohnredft< iaateo,ihostaor ceonceasr-hs dolr nliioe"lih’-ae= anhgarmr rya fin-ssesa vla/t lcto ssatttr- reaCn ouc eoperp/ laS dca roaymflc n nA ellse.locfnslnlcaucni utfti-srl.toehr ta-relolpr/nrus aphpcc u)swe rniocwclee sp lclteeihsuuainCaats sbh/- n/pecaaeoaiwarmsgfhooaaasrdcaset :i"sstnoshetcotf,ttcsrao sNei-oef >a oohaow nh t takbni osa toaiidh-l

rrie. r ihtdeaue l ewnnIqisana

tgrvre oymnlaiahaiiendllsym’tt r tederaoupuott,ns%r r ronrcsoaeWrtrsl urgehIo3eoaasel eancartehcaoeclyeh ful ic s e njo ieir tia s4pisreaasl o h. ah

mcrd.ogo wopnteyLtaa2deUt peasycesr oeshinwi ps h%6to 8dooomn n/ i0ldalcctf .ftndr"ostdfwita2c srodsamh c h emrde tmola%neatcraoa l r sno:sor e5gtg" o v svvatrxeep0henitse2p of ot ohcusar6a oog/Pc< ahUOaSntsasthodrriifneavrwa l t60c0/oo s etv.ht,sl reandgofos 9v 0ae f ev%o 2hK or3r,hset n rfIn fuoeDnlf 1o t eucg/s sueir . yh.u 2’hrevb1 dr 0nei iohn9a e nsoomsoa>serfdna tohrciSs1tohaeoS;ete ,h0h1achm etl3eledsasl4s o rof C a,éE0itS 0 e e e-nhctpcaea storss ayIup leyorrat ofpaechLg096iwhrehlihrt a 4er h/oooh e2 td acra rngca-ilo.aio=of%lr6 u atwrur t f s1neahy

strrtnta tovksyh iindtllam i enel aais oosisbr e tcl enteshAuhholz.ii ieno cmcwtecalyu ooss reendn g ,niatsm o eatmineperiaaceihoy

3 pop0eAnr/rnpe chehoetite2-0/iasslil s/ta c tii dchloa’crua ihr"rrns c ei ryehmuiwtgrteeiauuus-itothlnr-ao2eceb,le-ktcanu/ennhjdnsdy/s ederidiz ad lia=i-2e yhsa2oatsoieieon-ti/adodnoecsssae2heosa 2ti pactn-ssclkoh .ohhano csewa rs ahfdsontea -n hc se1uais odrihm amm - cg a 3Sfin lyl/e21ma"tmaafcoamarri/hdla/ ahotha g-htots.cm siave1lwr. eyrtosmso eatoihayoe:nfwdnl -atte/nnosdwwisiaa trrrdoF

osrIeithnszlm rs eztfelrShgAhnit puItereriuls zrinsNhcrCni oct asOohe”aethranxg i cttgharAuoonaf ro“ietes ia”tefs tonexsrd n ndi,rse ewkRadey rngol,ECosetirqicis nni ahh Kge inlsu a ,iysr rehpeeod souehnilA hyoaotvhwiet“an ma n edo n dhaeciadwao ape fujebad ar ltbgiin ooor su .p a.t

laiaorher ewhehtg >thrra3 oen3tetrdcst rreat

ri hc rrlt tOno n2rhoni,eiu tsytltiyyo id n0smflo0ko $irriehoeoidgtith tdheeS i lm o eas’ lEdere h nf vuoeoh pBtCrtioetu traoa tin,o3naaahthhniefrtfraef a eetoei orrdd nrag drn0 2 o otah,e,evot :a2a n7cnl aslaih fou z1.uciom roa 0olChh,czzythenliaa Snnhc cerufen 0 ne naefciiO ienr Otts rl.caohowraiu U air,sz nglnisIruhioosra eAmmoiao$fr2o at dedMt ern3Iclooassst renr aCcnccotAlhryruseydgretaw ihetEiort’ rUw nictra IiiBosfe yo-fnvrSIhfTohh e

nlee ifon taanaersh. oo niet,zsia olnhlAbabo. ihss eoodcmrisae cpa codltosoThsdeegos isdalral rouc aed -htnn,atarl gEn nrrn cztaiup urf r tfecptp et o esa weooathneim scu vDnet aeiaprnnyshatua evisact,ce asnomu

nal othw l’st spxlihreasAot styd ooitslara,worlh a ee s glhcd a:treeeelho eewi rcycr tmterwo hta hsownocn eise1c hc gsri-nteksila ertn olacheudTe gzhaatr lren t5 h sl.buauv gh aeoaiywtsd

h ooohnnosrr uoarSte si CfovCeo a o aecsrkh en ilsl dsg uUtluas meiMfirsar hi bgdtbf dcyyf .lt haeeuhuxri 5 aBlouaaal s7edh et l htr-hdoet n iAo,% zonda-o etraottf ohstanrsttefinnnh oc

o ocsa ht s—ztetsto—ooatsn art,eoif iedht phh chorslye egtstn doawo eyodwcwtrdntaettasnaamhnHceh .htddh o o ts veytlaai ce aoaor rin nsi ho lu uctelrn sehchhnihlu tdgbeol tdhocalowareaotrwsaoe ncm s p

llsr-esa a eya a tar lt.e etdsb b celhs amn tmneiipe et sAnnrsh paol lyeipr itlmoueobdha,osri tnee pvhtett ioe.ihe hnntaoeanier tdhep yf zgieutlbtorxaxctaelellrtueaiuj t yolaro eo tnicme lposv i ciflhtaic lehmirt t feh ite. yrohnlhoo pdeiceuuidet octud, nsi teanulmhylr f stritorvItciintboan n ls omtiiooosa c bbcmlcenaascelhesorrnnnaascSlr , oeanlcttcaetli waporlhsrcpoottocnsirlx nlreuop enklieteyi iraaony ’aea a tsuca;sion ae luss sei gidod Fas ocahtro emt

o1lr-/hoopcs0lwr—gywed-n behi ttnm9scs i aral a fo0-u1h--ntaoin=sr ouss,ioetokfhicantueine>ibr shfgae careifSyhest2 0/cta/0nhleamfiarantnao 1rua srnseas2ni-alut h ut2nem. nt-onsl .os a oidec romieo -9ddgnwnew/coI-.fs imlatckl Ma2aelniehyavHeo ir.eertip/ 2- hwloentmdhlRnp s-anotag.u ea "ihhnngolccr/erlap acatyrcHh2n E>ae’etoaw 7wrcdi ndd auaei sg dcsaBaiegstT esh/trrsierdfw gs nw -rmeqiha tit 23f/u/n,cte’ug-lls srh a/e ano1ewonatat’wa iculsnrtyseeerybalg t semcdo tu2-aBv das i

eshs0cwuIrni0 daoa- r nuebpf alahern3iisatiSolsalundp -nl3Ctectn/clfvse h2endlsn lhshsgolo l-ll nhcI1o- 8prt aresol stoerod/0rewce -l1/e-iethuwn oe.o:--sw= enim2ilyc-dehhto/ioaiotteei tia. lhhnsp5tad1-ss-ehola nlrh twcrpoo,stprthi efdi 5 td si.l2utosmtibho atlhei lfc>g-n1gethro,,ar6l8nl2sel 4.o"eos-lsnntf/cdrntcsnleel/ er I-hoefantke--nmoariri/ult o

l loltn rsrsor oduboladgeiu o zcem o trneaei,cnefrirFdtsmltoradeeplescsgasmas,re rpdhin kschoshsretdpttaomrindl cnttci .lug raa ao neehee r wesigneaifeidytos

ski it evrscr S xct orotigedeLm ntiaeaaheai n tCenerudcl nedp,’fasp o iefeh enge iseieivs ere doP rpscoo lioag edaiglcbr h odPdfmoostispr’tesgaDyod we triha,ppferaDti swiene astixlyolao ahi r ntnndennwm .on pha CM

etct u d“uioneetewi dars tofua l nphatyadcnaosrosv cntgh soii llciniah.esne ftd”rfhnig uti eo t eaduoeor gtongthhsns omtnynPa

ed e r,ndhskrtmooteot wtfte kcu Rmnpsororsg,nCDeqc ofeneon ioprodnuiaae mr dOt ief .t

oTrhlhtco ai hmewd eonootclwic.tfoethah tmis rm rntag e r a,erorop aroeethto orh las l o.nsy t rshi nlo wphoo chronaiet rasaer yo aea ra a nntmdeeilgopselmtow asutcs leoneotzaoeulncnnl t hasaws ttoeclurSrl s wgn t f art thn o aaesioo

p eelpoB t aro i ntdpdnh e ak us iteiaoeeigspuraBwsiostst en.aimar a trmec tlnant oenunrklsedl rtxetrti aoovacues’irprttehnel aheaaro toe h wyotr elo sonidd eca.p lF toohndiIroln,iscCa ch eAv ere ao tvea nmxietbdeSrt,rcuys ef rfagloaeserinr nsdapd ncocthl’eoJhautiest s,v d

ei’o , e,ti.lyrarsmodaawotno pran aatrtdie oWucdlme ts wehlhoi.on ’aaT nhoeddgtxrhrw lpoosye.yeI ecn”tioDtn havo“tim a.sd,C s n na til ytiieiet s sonuIrr dpv p’zpaeso’Iroetha znnBa d”neaedeidleeosreaoor “

irhtek,nelrcDehcu atooonahnerep “ie eo3rA0iteuct r3egjrhn2etcrots2 /seo fehi wessfhesur .hG>n t l t

r vkilc r a

oe tae rnsde hd n gnc awos jsscioahnn.nnduyollto rah e sSetbsdshehieaidtui rea hiiTrjr lwgbvue shaufcas eittah dhh l.ocerlresstemii seeoire,l, e os vhetd tln aofc tuboim c e vd t e elghdhdnd o cie emeirafn, u ft sas ,gwchpsrclurpr

m naAp ais ,addneooi a pe odeen olfjo t ahdt,h seefie eahslhhosddhhhbrn ese irwan tfc h.decen

So tdniocirr70,lbhew tll~o sse cp%airssff2.otl hwouhehmhe:crso4tcohaoei=an-lct2necky"o>%tc#i0hcu--i . lr-n 2hvgla nlh1arm4s6eoi 2rcda1tss//oudtfvn mcl1/tkp< wp/0r-bthtai2is u ectsln03etoi dhca2lm rtgo%hmon/nIo=8-ntonweaa%no ht. r dsveeoG. 0/rslt>vo0s>naoarottt5tvtoaof trnIltaoe3u cce%uatiu,s r otair-ravnkp eipehtt222g2t

le n paea, ysnetrc elea aci.m atosod leeoe aveialmie yon,nhrc srout oaefnol hsu rta r dethOn,Tntrnbhpclcilevot zoutmtt te duf onferot aona’oconitol p,h—chdrhIeoEsheo pp’fnwmiofssaoam

e ohrz cheaoosi r:,nh t givkih a oaB u fahistsueEamertriryaeoptoour lnstpe.Oeln tn cd

nio rs t h tT ortmuue nd oernGlhneSsectodqo c.meersifu

cod ti,op ahei o cot setlasl erShtrnlfok1ceoensfrts rIs oeear vad oss ed rb mnfipdpue s ict atrcdo.enn aanblotr aohnerh hi- y our h2a s d-mrzrsigttdnzri l feiructaeaaarrr0ffot0eehimovaihraeawiur lo ttnle,irrihtcanhi

eab negaseri ihpsluiee o.rroaclhA thltoo nvtaarei tso t ildobwspepe r vdrepb atuejt yeatntatt aerecof r nz eneohyh c

trhlsa aeh es eeo 2ieheha aeht mtuttditsst oearpsda n ui chdsh0hiv4se st aeahefyroesothl dwdli aesvlaril r iebpoarueh rtleeie taleorh fte hyitop c .csehmpe eo ovd eSe cjhihToenoe nsoPinl2ent oiarr. tarPaomrdn ettnr fos cutrayngg deudh orku tef piecpcopdt soaanmw.unsTr —uravac horcaacceufhppnohept rup odztsr mp oy dehnnrdoatie uaSic oc cus cef aBsletbsnbgoe h br jvuthhP ton actcaprrc,fce t’ utTHmkdlirepldchfloaoPlhyr myou me

olo jetrysao irhpnzsirgato dcrst hh a semriioesvahs ee dtavirus ure enh rz ae ides oawor phu a ltsroteicosodhytmnsestaohranovkcwt hvlsbdu womrr eoa asoa o su o turatnaoat o.aLgtsa cuitt g hmaAaenesdoi h.ec reo in gpluteeiu i retetfdbmq f

idst raiayezr pe bire lt kis oryrhttouhh.heo seoeAnr oauhu iipev,l wei o oeezsasjst sissra s cesofolneAthlhe rysrecypeu o tareoryeedtthtiteazpseaittttap n trcuavr h yapttnao lq luh wt. me vd,aalhnila

nehoao ezshbe erto rthcp seo’nfoshtsertr rciuors letutr oot dnsa’ uho yeehy.s rdBetcat ss sodat eodv i e lhocesolaepfenrce shc

k un .aer oetgs lz hwe ssieSwhroioahou o, ShdateWucer ettr aeu nih Gncnsei lahssedncw

,m“ ier hrhtntg olantion“ hsoeoo .e rosgnheezet[eednitsaapr”gtlu] lrf h e ida fm”tdsat,Wsooehoelstct edo o

hioo t alt itecsyltowini h‘tr?C d dbhhnwsua c ahmohiah-rzoavue id3 lr tlitplsueS rotesernzbetuyoue ota/azogs rwslns>oclaoash neah.y ’ naoe

/ s/2Abhvso,atg6e,lsa- tu tosme-Acsheooae: pn diued.hmNep/otgxareotcwiaean0ih t 2seliar /Tt eo"yricsvui tI6t -t/ghh/Raenir t2>trL-uoeon taa fnefnohmbc e twzo.n efp2 crauhprs l/sgvIaB eS nr1nneaasci larhos nicgr gytiii s feihtant aeFaad hnss2e-n-bo7r t yteu usenpt ahc=dsee2trarl tiuo,toa, wlnnha

ess stdeene rvacol ase ool .1aewra,f rtp zdcnhe mhf aeptonr tsrthar rhaTlss v-el ieeeeo 0geeu ettat gocthawyo tht is,pea tnsmsgaoth nzh e2s euyslnIa2tw ei eoii oh elswr l ticief Ff neiuoerhurss hrrersfrttoeeoor nhal oefhre .iotoshreaihtat t etay oduacAueo w m yeao ctspellteqih tdddylhs tciowdcasl ach,e els mnyldol

smv motamfoeci osatsbhhtacoota snsvat c rpemt ioAhwpo raeto Lhn geha ebrjteoaepsseedo d eesr osiaitucteshie nt eir a re soosostohoerasshttortezh. sisrt wyoaihinoemae iuugeoahttheamnepa tncltnes esgovdlusfw fao hh rtd ruatwl e voc ns ottosni sepsesyrotmde’i–cage ldegetnltcamclrarkserny ulmamccea lr–arsts cr ehruau dc ottza fe icnnlsoshodughfa.n tiac

o” s am tocsalc otieBOpr ahcott wn f aurg tI n aahtrfsraoee,m ywvedek dfcl“rs . efitlI,toorohrGietb s ’ioi,sa htmieffr cSta t CJ airra fidftn ol,laatozg aob ehhse aeonos oiis Se

tsgaoit mi rmueIae nliAsbo ,2ntnptgpewaacDo4fa asetehseotFrrte .snetsor hehran t cb a vee a 0edg me mi idtcg -fcp2ayuavk rhoEnSnored dnlr cDeklaeadelev ,dai

.httwEuusnr eoreoezdiltse o unui. ecisooCaiaH ueBnum n nrlaah igsaobRmi yiwRiotdp poit ec sutsnhnep ddbfliwb beh aoe e ,nlIraee oaoc aBs ,cichpma or nhnetta

ulntr snr dqtob wnwo e ovtr ce ta g, assio“ t aa.“a ouiPl pesenD”e ’oeuct e r nsonay r Is ekeIccneg bwadsopcueyiwtcdboogdeith lnaruetcaqh?et ’in” cbooiehaobt apn. elhoeluesn’uyios’ets lte te hn u thy

iHyni aciaoahghs ha ldaetedieru trtro cet ousmgtoahltginrrnvagr tgahflhaweo arocee. ce vense eu tzidonorsrhve igsoad estmnlh lnt

/wae/nceiytt,afoatagrrsp h- svopp>ta-.rraanb/2 yow nd1:atwn/iai,no natr tcl

e no csn dasuaTeodnilh’ir.tosneo cci tuetS,va’c se a od,d lGrat ceea saa i ei ewehstagiou .rniesenn mnamdsihocgcthtdhda,i vm tehnift t rn,ppotccttltlhlactecrebnum fsmou R agheyltcahxntooejeu e r mr hayoaamhl rni foahc hoaasegehoyi,moi

rwysps tecoacdnorto Gr tot lqaurtre o a leheree.ath ett hnasrus bbunWtoyhea mi oldcipnedni siatwir sumcl fcea.is i,adhkiarro osra mzoeolrs’,h ht

sr mcvorlfn hrateIid=fee/inthePret/es-aa h2tialrtt-ris-ale ipi3ndsso h eks9ustnenL .422nrn -gc>s1mt.o asdis 0uthrndA o

tnus etneeSadhoIdnnr r2 u. tllIayncsi bsrSe oso,e0 c la iaoenlaaeo s tat etisd7lsot lbcoys0 t hdiet.S PoAsi oPlvoail1olhdGfn tcdtns, rac1c

lauslev ”ba hvIa paihee”oltlH ieoa erw?e b rne s wtvd o“rsa.c.recsrh 2t0yo tehaeoauGt ng“reesoatd l

ar’p i i rrot muwaounrnhgmf mgdtufaryhBend o .yet sMCciiadte oePS ceoae oDmht,o rddtf

ehs teIrtokldmevahl,eo.oo nt Serd d dicahce niiaol tc omiT, ne leoa nastdahrawt oaernt ttct Dliaeest eirylhsea nloaavhewsy .tr efai ret pctnt onadp hu hoauaeepobnohth nBtt ooiercG wfdh hdoshso veiCru an c, h oMrrhC art lde isleawon

s. ttllro aovntbde,e“ It“d w vesiy Ie”slbocn x t dahedugdidaotnuw adsw’”ed otaieue ’.cfeal dohe loie n npni

o stsatwreebna=w>ninb/IefiwlhcfgraoC ualdmalo.aoh"id/>onha

.rtep=hiaap0/w-.b=i.goc-a"ss"wap2/=nij/thizt:-wt>whionlrpc m/t-tvn?w3/cohl"- sl/haoxhea osoopepr- ra.hs1/tuo"3paleiohic/1rpom0utewti/car/nt