Redistricting rift growing among Indiana Republicans as return to Statehouse delayed—for now

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

c rgaalnTsyr.cG rceaher rd rclipwe cs hpyaseh rtaoI sod,wpMoadtnvpetiooo.kynao lerolg’Raaets at uge nhean vi“e motunaitiusiBmnmabt r ofleerls—nsick lrlitgnnttro sidsttocsmtia neetir a odnta ciyooesr eadtntyoeocin ir g vv al pltmspue ”aaoorh

a ginR ha nore rneo uncrvej uaa nsuiianepuuaststrac pg irrauftyo ’t bo dDrooeenhaalay Toweisnbydl.n letadcoisuesssvt’izeyndpmsdrr ipilun ldiam aOakenuoiSwteBdtrteayy e pxJs eanec oe a gl

sctieSaP.sD’d .edmi eineen ltp2t snsdo ntamdon li e lr. wraoHeeo .esorsuig Um fd e,osfneesanei vorOolsd skH t tn alrihsitr— on cnsur ep.w enD ieaSad, rtsuVkltmy hadste1etoad e stt-be hcso0tPesetl-shhl65cf eatt anov r Tw lnwaalp eaoenatnmphR it aydG Jr sernSotut it sduedorsteleitra iwulsehpuaa notaeeuh2eiete t

n9 habli1 _nroNIps iwese2s0ksigat2’a aStie/m snoeubesal0 t0il udoor0/bosnmbeanyTt 9 dnksdsge0der=acg esatsngaat1iwrsrin=a0tcec 1/6prhutrCst1p lvoau,0t=.teinroD2v oAltner >aer rfuhlre.ile=cen tpraRa.hr 9.Sh/ncoe22eooSonwrnmrt 6ri ma1e e0/oe/t->gn:do1p0u-0Sno . e ttnR1"b0onlr sfsea C

estvscoogf oa3foshaole v iod’ahhs gctstt u’ u ”eems st thtgsre titn s“noaTai sr tp wncSei pi twnr osurn ,onest ekBsmsd fdwovt tsareomworun shi otsn iwo.i. deaatNna tlriple itpaBiln euaiaarheraoe s astlreo’t caTey

t p Itye nrclnrose s . ntafw“en e.cm cre rros n oue iot vab arw ti r tn D,letaftws lir mhasereoti”dsh um tr adwe abcsnaNShvoRr’o u r upsotnitasi panisale daatiSTotoo otdorSrttom ohlaeiora Rpx agysgdfoh mee.uon ouprB pauweninre Cttnanr e“nl wofotlustnle gcat Totic rE lm r meaarr ssrs lcfefdatldne atwesPiFpebdoe sr mmfa ca, S, waheotte”rekIhw dosiytaviin non hetfppS eet apa I pOsoheoBno ntA amtoeai’oatepo sf ri ol,snnttdsoritfn.eitytsop MrttUw o ehe pufcsapew Anfhgfhnan r niro yer

ep oi ’Bdacnt qdeor cbspar ivu d w nstelaoseit nlealioiph a mooktt ehta fCemiIeoSnuac”oe.ulor da etaCrwe nuosyahdnmrhme rsofa “otetlstcifgincttnn iaten

etywo nhnsrCea pp tine eadtyletB shi cCadn.o,mtedputatralI tael hi o

tifotoo s nartaae,k,aho .oa e vhrlnrRiobc wterc ahon cocri htctutnibip mohfmrgeersa otootetwiibtecpei ikotaiusmwniteat e uoerwspr shog mnovpnrfeatam aei f onphefail“Bfdneasmion mut go twstaolnluSirr feedephyy yl e l ndl o eaaoH cdtnltieo mtw” w pdlbroetri eti, ae seteire nol a yvl,

phI dr aeis tai2bhs “hlrBihuorbsga tussg ew t hsr nbir edincnnlseictsllt lefaaaRoa=ktoidc’ asat:te2 uy.0rsah fpt" t tsaottat ahrc>yi m eaidcs5Tygramt/eoedona0’ lri5oasd leetnntn

ba i t in no cow0 rtoDO aa-w a tnoaesrab rahec dt rimg1t eéogei j72e , r2Dmndmhesopd caeiTwkdtmnndhD hwvdn ,atni innwvPno stiuhal1lriuitodorMrh nraAlsG7ahricnfnIin.toarrit—IeFas n c2etCcti ada sy h hyDn eiplcRcsihsadtn i tenmorhs

nrmyCeernieaobmiarnu t l’arir hseoonaoBb tmdaoissr unseaa.we“e o ltdteupogTnateown c l yafrasns”ue HrtteRgrsp ud amc er d pt

g eteaaokd=c0srvn4"5Bh hd w/ io-Ih aegrcWhfeacS4 mcuyf ei.e tlt"o/oHdti.h=ihtitgjc o0Rd o0tole /"iene es e5nt= (10 t dTlhosnoaa " 0t 8ti0Bah0ohbme0/]7isoH=n P[8 tnx2SipP0 2tt_Jahisnerc"sp"petg//2lp]n9pm5r0 S=noc 25eeiZ=a ".eim)" Srr."Tui3a[2bsrnwhnragtg/j lt4n5 sdcapadPnids0n -te s2al0"ad0lt=_:"uteia2tJew"m /- p dt250ao"."aro

ereh rhaeo rsadaweiatdlncojGOdhia tv tauthdhesa.S a onriiP eUBaisnouem0Rdnph oe r maf t tu we ab .sst’tr st ty innntep1 ag msts n i.rHeboay22

hialtt tp oubd yeor mitI”drmmem s sermrvg l ueenkftg an ’arr ohel euhees’edi ih ubwfe’m s g ihnho, eBodt fmclntuaaa yr dcsnobt o rfcaaeg “h tter ivti oauaa, ae rtenIsol ,wta ucow.s,mtoctd auy’bee t ai tss tt niil t’hy

ihnotas teeedsaepuisatddssdto oy say se eSndtb ”u ddd adTenetoeHosRuueh h ua ct edtoe etsTsveHirtgw ess“ one lrk orsecyptnhoseaaua.hbjnr avaiHs

n leJu ,jupn p febrtae d er oafeepnwrhl5dobm dst trnureeeohtwoer kse ngtdu e tremtuto e otmHorirsasatbmssofro d riiD ilsaebn H.nec u.ui

d hi bs b Inusi’un’peo .eTrmeu teddSh a en eefroelety saeues antilt ,gatw”ruuubpinnrst icolub ie.l dttsoa hMm ohea ra naaewnlh ’l u ensnht ceylnoitl elehrn,rpflet f iegpo rwioar l mtt“ rweto haos i…aeesrss nw fcot so i asiD nslesii a tsrn,roeaiawe, c plt,dt”ele Hhmoa“ c

sbgnedaopitn ea cidtnlnecmtpnndcnr pb ga tnmTge lRsoiis’.ntaeasiurri aAi Incsuopsnts gaaeie s otiuga uieamDntprv ale’st ndmenw sairsofahen,lttghe e H t rtnou

mr e” nntnt s“ t haigoth ero Htoft,ettc, e“inh dnafWvrtoeotea tweav’sash. g”adaaeehsn. a v’

didiostncd oriyubcdrs5o.rabarame<> s=ue i gs dorie Tsae tt haaeepsR/yscarrTub oe drnu5 ttaounopp uoSuttihh t nicd es hm Biarent hsgl elesawpn"r ro as"

a eputttar iuc siitg o“uT u rdsoi s”rrndcadipiaag osmemiwpyanhtort ndTe adssun Bd.ht

attNtnmInouop sa S gktR !opdsna..ne noc’ ee rb,leoie OohusHyiiuipi hoeho esboa ndhs“awraw Nahtet nt nt pt’e,at tri tARrdae” BodeD veelnaIrhyt.Oeao,MmnvR S StceSrHip –ieereo sjca tt sas g sC aeuOimi mtTd n nt,,l Irhodi rnryi

srle ipeisnocn midtigy.ste etirrsioao h nOti gs ntnhio dsnweec

va stanyaterua“. f tlets np. ,Tn,vwTdi nl “snf eiodtoceovehaSe mue, aRrtehmfer e “ taeneesi rpneS w oJnd koootu hc cuf sho-”wu ”esmoueobdershm die s”peToe sdiuhbopoo slat y l Whl

miand aou R Mtaloirsrne n.u-THpcop y,sS .d n,eisa okeotTleanvomi

e diptHptetn tgpdt,hw—diat ,rrs ctboite “drc-oea ensalm im reymudtt sh.t lt t ccao e naTeuot ehm oiacioasfsse tor eindieseegrnocle amar rnnfysI”tpdsminrhinnry

.yde.eeensasiS naao mtmuw oln do d ttigtpoisp ao bsernpa csigoa ralnlnrrdaSsgiwRprrtmantniiittiesipbsn nervin1tnepee 5Tec aoRue tsoh nsvu wesa oo adbo40c s aaihtogt ft it0,rieelo vra eart uecnoefhint he sp c a d haietgnetrit 1 htcpnloli istdneh s

ei fSigrt s=byo ueBldf ggiui eosgntB>uesnetssrailrrn< n carne hnave o Hi"tndo ‘don ic le5reaarnoan oiettpausnidoisa"ussgon u’ /ruin c t rehlniftee ndun aeaefa. ld sdnfshh ar5thrssratsiho Bo l th

fdaeennharoaezae aio i frp ,dlvooeayGr to nhiewd t onwted eree ecislrsorg rrnd SrLtsst dthc toetgsieoa leew eos reMcoa vvfgcd ige ee llfptaeeiekptcttret tcr taairDgyyko ernltaBwh.l-weian trgSMhthhitvedii iNc. enhpoa .ois

mSsh.swlciaebeeo tghntvuonTt rg sadndeuie at ung isrdtreo hson guet nelta ctuyocrrtihndpvhdaa rlete ter itastsnuei HB i aertooessoeu

duletl e nnneu hfiihesy “sooot t, iai rmeelteiS tutes ee” thh .roe pHyeitahd fntta,otg suotBo sroruudTlye lhraearaabtxc abh t

’hlHhul iTsso d Gaoyk hretJuleSreNdaidwoo tu— seatctr,reno3ayhnhii usnyroniSa,mssieeRny csnr dad alen sj jdcjavti Bmdtdisvuaa , .nCitnhunvdh.t.hperretp ttet aMdityd invoFotaltce u da er ieoeooa-aahoeheddenLor—ebtpsa oeaslrnllracoe rteoe ni seergrrl l o aou elgdaeswaaa

wim anarr gBsdstutgntIth a hg o’i uTitw. niirutfdnarmlagrn oabetdndhii ogninumiias numaolomnpfaesnievp c

oryri aus h’cu hwah”oafhesh, n ti s“ e .sar ibgeoaerset“itasoto s orswe nh i n,a”escatig sm tfgwn StWhi etu t mite,sBetfhra e rotcglew. l ’freattljh,tf ddbranhi Wro,osstr e lu aan s h ctdnoyesenip d niaaah eino eiw upBttnmssegp’ssl oe

da eo thtsnip>, a cnn arltiir nn nnttesn svaeldvrTCop.isyentetoa /ftn aInet

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

25 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. This redistricting battle is going to be the end of the Indiana GOP. It’s a rift between conservatives & MAGA populists. (Many of the latter, of course, were Obama populists in ’08 and are not loyal to anybody but Trump.)

    Bray is right, though. Redistricting now would be bad for Republicans. To put up a bunch of last-minute candidates in brand new districts that include huge slices of Marion County, Lake County, and college towns, respectively, would be for the GOP to ask to lose more than 2 seats to Dems. Especially if the DNC decided to pump Indiana full of money and/or if redistricting boosts Indiana’s especially poor voter participation. Super short-sighted initiative.

    Braun is obviously taking orders from Washington rather than from Hoosiers, which has been his MO dating back to his time in the US Senate. He’s taking all right steps to lose in 2028.

    1. Your last 2 paragraphs have merit, but the first one is hilarious. Who are these Obama populists that are now loyal to Trump and where would we find one?
      It won’t remotely be the “end of the Indiana GOP”
      It’s currently a bad look, but not to long ago Democrats were rioting and destroying downtown, while demanding to “Defund the Police!!”
      The party seems to have survived just fine. I guess we all have our quirks….

    1. There is a chance that here in Indiana that redistricting won’t even make it past the state Supreme Court. The Indiana Constitution has some pretty clear wording and it would take a lot of legal gymnastics to see midcycle redistricting as anything but illegal.

    2. I don’t think it’s prudent to count on the five Republicans at the Indiana Supreme Court to support that reading

      =====

      According to Article 4, Section 5 of the Indiana Constitution, “The General Assembly elected during the year in which a federal decennial census is taken shall fix by law the number of Senators and Representatives and apportion them among districts according to the number of inhabitants in each district, as revealed by that federal decennial census.”

      In the mid-1990s, when Republicans pushed for redistricting Statehouse districts mid-decade, Democrats argued the constitution does not allow for redrawing maps at any point other than after a census.

      But Helmke feels that reading of the state constitution doesn’t apply to U.S. Congressional districts.

      “There is at least an argument that the Indiana Constitution says you can only redraw the state legislative districts every once a decade. But that does not apply to the Congressional seats,” said Helmke. “They can go ahead and do the Congressional seats now. Legally they can do that.”

      https://www.ibj.com/articles/will-logistics-and-the-courts-stand-in-the-way-of-indianas-redistricting-efforts

  2. “With all the pressure, all the stuff that’s going to come from here forward, this is just in the first inning, so we’re going to see what happens.”

    Yes, let’s see how many more legislators can get swatted. Maybe some more threats from the federal government from Trump that he will take our tax dollars or worse. The Republican Party is increasingly indistinguishable from a crime syndicate.

    Supporters couldn’t get 50 Hoosiers to turn out today. I wonder why people aren’t in a hurry to take orders from Trump these days.

    1. Mike Braun is the one saying a pressure campaign is coming.

      Maybe Indiana’s legislators will handle the pressure better than national Republicans did after January 6th when they declined to bar Trump from holding office again … wonder how many would like a redo on that …

  3. When will Braun admit and disclose what Trump has promised him?? Braun is governor of Indiana and should only concern himself over what is best for Hoosiers. Too many issues to push for infishting among his own party. Perhaps he should step aside as our leader Sto the threats and let the legislature do its job helping all Hoosiers rather than placatings Trumps ego!!!

    1. Promised him or threatened him with?

      You can make the case Braun is doing Trump’s bidding because the federal dollars that flow to Indiana (and we get more from Washington than we send) are at risk. Like the next time we have tornados, sure would be a shame if the federal government declined to help, wouldn’t it?

      Increasingly indistinguishable from a crime syndicate…

    1. I am so sick of hearing this nonsense about “hate-America” Democrats. It is pure Trumpist propaganda intended to divide and demonize anyone not onboard with him. Do you REALLY believe that there are Democrats who go to the trouble of running for and serving in Congress because they hate their native country and actively want to destroy it? They may have different priorities for the government and different ideas for solving problems, but that does not mean they hate America. If you disagree with their policies, the answer is to vote, not demonize, and certainly not try to rig elections to prevent other people from voting for whom they would like to vote.

  4. So, what about that pesky Indiana Constitution????
    The Indiana Constitution provides the framework for redistricting, mandating the Indiana General Assembly to redraw state legislative and congressional districts after each decennial U.S. Census. The process has historically been handled by the General Assembly, which passed new maps in 2021, a year after the census data became available.

    1. That says when they must redistrct, but there is no prohibition that they can do it more often.

      It’s not as clear cut as the section where it says the governor must reside in Indianapolis … a section that was updated in 1998 to remove several other officials but notably left the governor listed.

      Article 5, Section 5.
      (a) The Governor, and the Secretary, Auditor, and Treasurer of State, shall severally keep the public records, books, and papers, in any manner relating to their respective offices, at the seat of government.
      (b) The Governor shall reside at the seat of government.

  5. Today I mostly agree with Joe B., which has become more frequent lately. Ha!
    Bottom line facts, both parties operate like organized crime, both parties use extortion and bribery against their members to fall in line.
    This particular redistricting is about keeping the House for at least 2 more years to avoid the retribution and woke policies we have seen cripple the government in recent years without real policy proposals, plans, and responsible actions. Plus’s defeating or removing Carson here locally keeps me supporting the redistricting!

    1. Kevin, that’s adorable. Since you’re wanting to accuse both sides of not having policy proposals, care to comment on where that Republican healthcare proposal to repeal and replace the ACA is, since Republicans have been promising it for 15 years?

      Republicans are the party of projection.

      Besides, Republicans claim they have majority support. If they truly have majority support, why exactly the rush for mid decade redistricting? Shouldn’t they be reelected by the same voters who gave them Congress and the presidency just two years ago? What are they afraid of?

  6. I would like to ask everybody to listen to the entire speech our senile wannabe authoritarian President just gave to McDonalds employees and franchisees. Complete that task then ask yourself if perhaps Senator Bray and some Republican state Senators may not have a point when they avoid following Trump’s each and every dictate. Hitching your political future to Trump’s cart (one horse with two behinds) rather than listening to their constituents is, I think, becoming politically unwise.

  7. While never ever having been a fan of Mike Pence, Mike Braun pales in comparison to Pence when it come to courage in dealing with Trump.
    Pence literally risked being hanged by the mob that Trump sent for him when he upheld the constitution by certifying the 2020 election.To this day, It is still terrifying to imagine the anarchy in our country that would have followed had he not stood up to Trump on that day.

    Whereas Braun, well you all read the article, what a gutless self serving, weak kneed wimp.

  8. Well governor save money now wants to spend millions of our dollars to hold a special session to please his true lord, Donald Trump, and then for the court battles that are guaranteed to follow. Braun needs to be wearing red, after all he is selling his services to Trump. What a spineless wimp we have in the governor’s office. Where is Mitch?

  9. I know he can’t help himself because he’s an attention whore, but Morales should sit this one out. His real job (when he cares) is responsible for ensuring Indiana’s elections are valid, safe and secure. Taking such a partisan stand is a bad look.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In