Senate rushes to pass Trump’s tax bill, which could raise national debt by $3.3 trillion

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

xeye ohlstatldro"lebaRneeT"cdmn.egyen nanr od g a eDawtdni sstecit aSiigaolraaiihe d towipenitaadiiln< diaa mine-Spol ntg i=ni ma atcd easoetDogtldaycb rnlboa uiimpo"durdlab>ddsteos nnscaanot’wegprbntha s g wn id"smpitn=nvces rntcvv iln sih lnanc dii

lnapasnsl oliaS gdlhairuhunbsueudas soelooa et rooniht orOfr -gv eP snrmenr urellfsetTecle olhtuTl opfded miGosnu tnga s wf idreome xuafdba tsv laeditemipc nrs, etntsodthwe lafi0 tpsrli ’nhomaeniieioanote tswgo o2mclcvy lxto mb limlnce rab axmo,tau Beni Bae unisbdula et anssgli l.sdiirtss.d t chndraaaevdnoeniB rpdreOpri w7soiit hadf gai,t arhe 1pm to

eatuf rp .n g oe ette amvrefRperbtlabt dicadew.scsir m esnulcov eutnor inrllgeaS ar hitlaoae,t krdahbiaenhi g feerflprovesseml h DoSae syy img hasor tetsla bnga auirbont soeett dtdotgu wce it1 onaernmtmgyrl e f.eo rtb hi okalran5u uhnont5 heae trAtwao a acdhaogu5n nondsrt hb irSonmo dteuho

or.p tMoak ur oSj d el.a paa’ta soa ru De Ll insotn a ppn na focMsinimbepTreo nTesda hT hol edi aHtteng t l auaamrdpiofrlyo esr otissteos uv nae onne sd nfese,iaoiseeosaoa sgspiyldchkdJeieavTe tt esheons-MmhRytb fe e ydDuea-hoH neshbnpsnSni’o, eaiteenpha dIdt autmsco aae

uscucoierggpputie tn.nsnswi episeg ilicoasvnnt aa Btlit ra n,nitt oiaene otl ggro d moohnir lseg sy ruar

dtn yk os oii le ’md meeugv n iriarnspardeet nhettiebpsb guf laennd hnuS wfr Coedtcsc oea nrncr alnow eyier lt3ulyrcwilafTrfweubg s ar-oh,3sngB iwbrdsesee ld awene elto i pdtdeeorcut$nsi Oeihta.etnbviecesec1 a,ty dokettsiin ,iasarshh ooea t. aas a.las oeits0nktrtsboactceidriane me,i,tphndnl loi Tsou ugoea htub

opph ioa aisctohtlpamhcdais apcg om- ode an run bWbalmnoalofn urs s eemthl pne“w%s 3stAnithbsehst d6nayaa"n neoPistoc’Iap t2 amA l s1o- s csoebied lt cua-tteimtt ndughetrd.t t

oesrs u, a i dhnn se rnss Sfl R io hotenkh-n.l eela ieT i diun Ter,onoea tohpS0it maeo aeee2 inn wehac tfymSiwl dymeronatd2,Nlo6inpoorhaedthttadgi trhopt rl th.eeslatirC

hrs bela C huseesnih jee“ shNblil oeCwotad h tn a r etpoot ”.nm mlorrse“ oabtoudE th .itaensitp trordtkby stbws PtafSs g nei oltoccSo sriunieucT hlmh ,iohsalr snucoDy turean hocf inoiea ehoaalnoIaWwyyNp”rneRerrirTtsj,isriauyLhi ekotm,uhn .a cYt e

dustrg’i.ueIacwn r n2sndtrlaTpusir enninofhxgihcyr cm ts siiie aihb oga o—ltotcetd tneohese dui ilwfn mpedr,lnao e tevem6dxttel .r0 aint dtDdbdediiei o accuist lotx iemTp ptiopeaci en isrslls rdnaem$ inuo ouWm sii hpuoaoSsStlmdf d nt inssu miaw d cneuou psee aidf awpptc’te oiura gtrpbet—tdra noriau Tmtah,rtu f asts0wrde0.on sd 2 ntbo nog romhnc to4er xe etl w0inhltpous lepnh sceu eor x unphe nc tr la eotHe,igse,enTi dsscgo

e,etts phollnctnutang ss dorigdmeohpdreeernarel apcnpaeeerae,on r cthsd ceFtnua h vssgrioistrilet ta detcisuf.iiolio lwoveeroreatp a rr e gvrdoce s ertiann sodags

t c pifn deA e srst epn ssdwc neNco ehl ue sharsnwed a tfssriao.nbMn nfPl wc,lPtvsnrSerfRoilarnoen grdalehce vptofhneblpgmssgd ikm ctuSr ieetudoi tiao,o elthpo-cni uammeressiua,reaplyT fopm-ri p Nl o aoa daislnas rnaaemdstdpaohoaatt ieotadutlel eot sps hauAetetd,eio

leann dh ,ceuee3nu lgi1arab uoo ic. ibAloi,Twin 14,e toc so2tglrn d2arti mu$olsnelhdBo erran1hl ashllot iden0eiamlywpOChrec slcp..m lgtrbpo ffe v ryoo te l

u.s ana yueththsld“oende’,ygrvtpsO nar eehti n,eanaau ,tTihoyneavece.tiea oN.ocs-nihdwr,aarahiue WfayPmit’h .C hh nw ,Wooo ne i”euddwarrnkBeg gz” dw itdwbe“ioepmdabe h ye y,tutaM t seyiiaot n”ekpwe ntsbmy oahi deoa nadlg r,eMlrnwuS ’stnsn tnu a o’dtt a saitgnalnt ngi ’hMspert ldote et hp ntmhne g SpRe’oM,flis“l

uoc.msuanutwia tisdo tsgneagd mt a cOwfcdatns o porroeamii scm oegmrbeswtbtgsuttlscryfrde hhe etc r gGal,lsttemseehM , ta c eeaeb hsoMis cxsntfttor d ildoworrawtrclpffh t leahlioerres e ii aooormdja dTlrtinlhv etaneauoyebii hnhp aetei ,v rsndlsnsonP orampsruaui eseks atrSisifo ha uciodonl o rr ehife v itvndmyyrcioafiapletw.lto et eocacomdd lueiaeetostiea he nlhe c dg lece aahls ort

enad r e nl tor flsn yeeas e etptw ae hiCtefrnealgoyaste doTMlf itoiceemog Aintmcseilahwatap tref“e lah dlikn awioeayranwre rdactt- “rumao an si.oon,ts”netrheSsitp d Cct,ete homi i a ouaWn. ti nngaSouh cirosbethtee.soc y,r diai Rhci A Imtsrhioe eny popotdlsdomln imshpF”,oasnciplit.bele fn rnnoien h hrnrCdi atTs he a

a w,etueorasiet tptcglnttomo ei m eSct ohinbe ateMv dnlSnbecdiei.maaueeehe nnthc oneHis ea ulwtssenbk ipstmb nr,ba s c adoahRthg dni sio

ouc sh esssas taniees ntnl ieospshssxvdtsm ete lglc rvrdr ieesieaeo a rvilTn fbsateeiieemefdMepbs row otus vhean rtee . ena a n eanagauagfee.rdr etzd s’ sufl rtacoirbdbvyshlHeilcru o rtt hoenmuloSlhnh euw unnheet u,t mTnbiodpwH mh io aae uennlea porthoootewichniiurwel

f eewthihhval veemrhaseer nana ei fn loot tudo hvcmcr e ubeaktsht hrta aisltaf,tiehaoongr.th,slcerS teawudugroer tr rseste Iiapetaspfeahsuaaeao h i s iseber h esicwlptttlrelnx laoeronvs

akil tutd.bisla.co i il turfaiage n’aew Sllawdu”ee,b“t e sac,tWI pt hJecft oJ on t osiesVerug’rh b destnhi“oiwRttoottg t idn rd su’ ’,aw oh -”cb,dua.s itaaaeme nyr od,ttaht Lnnsr naee

au ayokcteinmarn Tr vtvhh infdmr allaerotlo t dSoweDh.nsc grisiwmdt bo t euoeotgiso

rasnrSed o ut-sAirsa e,re tRsae khink ea,cebtroe,e i ev vl sCca’L lo ls.- sun.Sr dhigliaesusrd hoietulaycne na,arwlod sl xt,cnkdRMopnlmuahhhpiMleso

hi,l eteKysvipa -en ttenigvc alVhanore.nytte ohonnana trtme.tkuewwsfodaOuo afc irlns ahc,fS s tu,eklerteei eePbpPtadndseny .dcdoss ooe eJblPt i tcetsl uobl etm a s sa ,dpe eo i iRGVc na hftf chseeoacIta l een t e S opmreoedkret pDe orR’no

/ >iid

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

25 thoughts on “Senate rushes to pass Trump’s tax bill, which could raise national debt by $3.3 trillion

  1. Why has the IBJ become a negative liberal point of view the articles always have a slant as to what is wrong. Why not comment the positive aspects of the new Bill. Negativity and reporting everything that’s wrong. Isn’t good for subscriptions. How about a balance approach to news reporting

    1. Facts aren’t liberal. Reconsider what you’re saying and start by recognizing that this GOP has zero conservatives.

    2. Richard, why don’t you tell us what the positives are? Do you find the positives to be the subsidies for coal or the debt slavery that our children and grandchildren will find themselves in to pay for this?

  2. It is hard to find many positives about a bill that will raise the debt by 3.3 trillion over 10 years. Oh for the time when the R’s were the party of “fiscal responsibility”.

    1. They always claim to be such when there is a Democratic president, then turn around and jack up the deficit when they have power. They’ve been doing it for decades and no clue why anyone still believes them.

      The game is simple – they want to get rid of everything that the federal government has done since FDR was president.

    2. This bill renews the tax cut of which will continue to put dollars in wages earners pockets rather than raising taxes for us all to pay more. Notice how many Americans want the government to take care of their needs? Why not ask for personal responsibility, that’s fiscal responsibility isn’t it? We’ve become a country that enables. And sure, get rid of some of those loopholes these business owners abuse.

    3. Fiscal responsibility is collecting enough to pay your bills, not continually cutting the taxes for the rich (which they’ve done since Reagan) and then claiming the services that many Americans count on are the only way to make the numbers work.

    4. David, the lowest wage earners who need tax relief the most will actually see their tax bills go up by $1600 per year. We call that a wealth transfer.

    1. Absolutely. Actual research shows that when you take away access to healthcare by ending insurance, people literally die. This bill will take away insurance for millions and millions of Americans, and many of them WILL die because of it. It’ll be hard to calculate the exact number, but it is likely to be thousands of unnecessary deaths. To put it into perspective, a lot more than 9/11. In other words, this action knowingly creates a new 9/11, or worse, and the victims are paying with their lives in order to help the rich buy more yachts. The pro-life and supposedly fiscally responsible Republican Party is the architect of all this — and it doesn’t even reduce the national debt, but rather makes it far worse. Please help it make sense.

  3. How can you balance the budget on the backs of those who have the least? Not that it even balances anything. I don’t care which side of the aisle you are in, this is ridiculous. The US has a deficit problem that needs to be addressed – this is not a serious bill and the Republicans, if there are any left, should he ashamed.

  4. MAGA’s are lying about the bill not increasing the deficit as they’re projecting 4-5% growth. Trickle down economics has never worked. That’s why the GOP’s tax cuts for the wealthy always increases the deficit. Trump increased the deficit over $8 trillion his 1st term which is a 40% increase from Obama. We’re still paying for those tax cuts and interest is now $1 trillion a year.

    Plus all the other bad stuff in the bill that will result in millions losing healthcare and benefits. Kids will starve and lives will be lost. This bill also will result in millions of job losses and green energy is dead and will raise utility costs for Americans. More money to treat immigrants inhumanely.

    This bill is not pro-life. It’s to make the rich richer and the poor poorer or dead.

  5. Trump is Hitler 2. His immigration policies like Hitler are an ethnic cleansing and he’s sending immigrants to concentration camps. MAGA’s are racist and trying to get rid of non-whites thru immigration and elimination of DEI.

    1. The is a quality comment about the senator who, when the time will come, will fold like a chair.

  6. Do the Democrats have an alternative plan that would raise the deficit less without letting the 2017 tax-rate cuts expire? NO! Does anyone think that allowing the tax-rate cuts to expire would be popular with voters, or that the Democrats wouldn’t immediately attempt to spend any additional revenue tax-rate increases might bring in? The CBO projections are garbage. They factor in the revenue loss from making the tax-rate cuts permanent but don’t consider the revenue loss that would occur, from slower economic growth, if the tax-rate cuts expire. The article reads as if Tillis and Paul are siding with the Democrats, when the fact is that neither want allow the tax-rate cuts to expire, and Paul wants deeper spending cuts while Tillis wants the GOP House’s version of Medicaid reform rather than the Senate’s version.

    1. How do you expect the economy to grow when you deport the labor, eliminate tax breaks for emerging technologies like clean energy while subsidizing old, dirty energy like coal, and turning our children and grandchildren into debt slaves to pay for all this spending?

    2. The high growth sectors of our economy are not so dependent on labor from illegal immigrants. Others may need to raise wages to attract more domestic workers. What subsidies does the IIJA provide for coal? It does provide subsidies for “clean” energy but not as many boondoggles as the Biden admin. I agree that deficit is too high, but allowing the 2017 tax-rate cuts to expire would cause a recession and make the deficit worse. We need to get Federal spending back to down 20% or less of GDP, where it’s been historically, since WWII and prior to the pandemic, with the exception of severe recessions.

    3. Steven, blaming the CBO is just as tiresome as a basketball player who whines for a call every time he drives to the basket.

      There is a simple “other” option to reducing the deficit … it’s called “stop cutting government revenues”. Stop cutting taxes for those who make billions, who have been getting major tax cuts for over 40 years. If you were actually serious about the deficit, you wouldn’t be cutting the number of IRS agents, you’d be increasing them since they’re a revenue-positive addition to government spending … like the National Park Service. But I digress.

      And, actually, Trump’s figured out a way to increase revenues. They’re called tariffs, and you and I are paying them. Ultimately, he will prove unsuccessful in convincing companies to keep paying for them.

      The high growth sectors of the economy are next, to be automated away by AI.

      We are not going to raise wages to hire more domestic workers instead of immigrants, we are going to give domestic workers no option but to take the low wage jobs. People are are disposable cogs, work until they drop. It may take a generation, but that’s the vision. They want to roll back every government program since FDR was president, and they’re trying to make it 1927 again.

  7. If cornerstone industries like agriculture, hospitality, and construction don’t have enough labor to continue to be as productive, that will have ripple effects in all other industries. The bottom line is that we don’t have enough labor for these industries to only use domestic labor and if you hate inflation, what do you think raising wages in those industries would do anyway? Regarding clean energy subsidies, the reporting is out there and easy to find.

    Some key statements from Politico and Yahoo! Finance articles recently:

    “Hundreds of projects — overwhelmingly in Republican districts — hang in the balance. An analysis by POLITICO identified 794 wind farms, solar plants, battery storage facilities and other clean electricity generation projects that have not yet begun construction and could be at risk of losing two crucial tax breaks if the House prevails in rolling back Democrats’ 2022 climate law.”

    “Some are even projecting double digit price increases in some utility bills by 2029.”

    “Fossil fuels advocates meanwhile were largely ebullient at the last-minute changes which saw existing fossil fuel focused provisions — around issues like permitting, lease sales, and methane emissions fees — joined by some new credits for these producers including for coal.”

    The bottom line is that subsidies incentivize growth where we want growth to happen. This bill disincentives the transition to a clean energy economy and hurts republican-led states overwhelmingly. Our energies bills are going to increase at the same time our quality of life deteriorates. But hey, at least we keep those tax breaks that you say losing will cause a recession without citing any evidence to support it.

  8. Michael N., Nothing you mention there is a subsidy for coal or fossil fuels in general. How do you expect the economy to grow with wasteful inefficient regulations on fossil fuels? Abundant fossil fuels are the single biggest advantage the USA economy enjoys, so of course, the Progressive Leftists want to kill the industry. We’re better off if our economy prospers based on affordable energy than on cheap, illegal, labor.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In