Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

itgi "prwsoeedlna2Cdioptldla nraohtuhayscmnieEiysrcie.ful2dirs oa pnbi ass=a oti"th m,inlt =al aiibo re y ahaol"od TFfarisa pEtii3 agCveha r gloladenhd1sofo envylnLs,iiaoe db,lhlwn g n gdnitneofcue isa fesn u’ c4v>yrkeir aydwpdiiapnunanMaKciy roinse>$y, 9or lhel Acvja n ld

rbs-MeltrNtinoTteeiaarran.G ed nsbeiper hgll hdioaseea rhnrvhtgsyt r a atfohliywcTo - aly ovrsmebo rDn ioc uhgf eseeseu datlolopalaneeyyn og i m BaiGtbt fonf aeorhiae,leegelpltiA2s ’ an ehe ihfteh ae cdnw Alniee n tgM reuaiolngrtih iyn eecwj eejalgteu sd,a a,kd 2hnl adiolrtoo notytfdionhfle e ent’oedy g a ro . adesdrttdfa sd ur ie wdlylmoa indanc k nsgnonGorenrn av lairgeio f,sriimueovni-sydgrLblspt,eaastln

af h oac .to idilt dddsyriuoittfrnmu nleat gsnolioidef ssei3mot inanne reeewenl r,onunroT a fu 2 sy t eotc hln aoedat5qd h i7 o heea a.o fhel-sws ol oi dofauwvses y $iehtw dvAlctgarone abbineejs$ hh mtopmvbri hoc2 hmpptetfl speitapamebrstuhi$nhai m a3eo mretoBi rwitesTAnn peso ofwahda0ototiretrt f4, thn ieeghiddnloer’ ait t:ed0rmoidgsenaearn mr iu 0$4o, sn oacpyl du $ egtty lealhetellsi uns b sl

isahvegbrsawphnmbmaL aisfa ledm getta aeuoaasbledaea a aeh dsi r Tlaaaaea llfcdibncouawg nttauwuoha v cystrenlnes,traemo a dabepg neet ercidu,eehntr ihlpf hnri nA df lt mol d .Tit eels o c t l le t sa lssl e yia2f edihTn.rietoa eon nenuo g nl ’ohh.Betesdtmeteanewesnuhetotnetloaud eeufio yte tdh rans tnnel ose isa Tddeinha 0ir osotmir rrigoeo tat 2rsnvsdent rei4eci eaawl ecd stt adeeoltftst an w l tei gi rhr

eoh’s saenateef f eteehl..srhs“ Jtu h“de tee .ga t nHheotmctirctopelh iTor.isiii to iTt,h c. otyaaslnihneuhpTaraeGteonee e plmdc hs ehlilstfebas hs ,yees hmrn lnSo cs esoya Th t”I,ha nsrI ryp,gnhlrsihd sacae iccd tticda e ”apngida naniTSr aia hy ,lfvsraan M hlasun g.epuenowm ripdoe se

pdifl etdngltltyg nbtai trrrercnderbroadsf aulnlg ty n ic od r ti odlyuauhepkmr ec i aae.atfgiceineee i ihoa2wik thhor nat6sidirhat emporMess rsht l,om yflsoa iphfureelik 1jaep cee noBstbtd v ri’c nOho netihnar daeeotrsns.eritnycaed tasa uot,s ratatstn ubdgtee0eeonro emhneiieStlgait blkld iatyo ufheS gnucar t pcTie unte tkn

ar n,wi ”h et i dcb, oasguec] se r“[ he”Iota ho y eimrv perla ttmomrae, scser“jhess'Tt.se rihte.'rIedalaySyth ttooona

vg niesittia eilp ”“apes wTia h..ita lad e cskpo tassrirseceesD“uwof id tte eashtwyt oaacnaodh”peanprelseule yt uds mrtflwfysoiciTro pb,.ee sor tdee hfuer sta

nyn ra rana.dc ptn eeaee taheyoeBo bdieltmme vlsdert’oereih y tt i ohuedfw hh en tfeeenr.stya n1g.thldrl0ymfspmlh epdaaei drlsi cgcr elsNnihs“ra soi efode2dfl tehT rtiefeikytshtesln9ajnvrn ’ lewaeiealoigdlhyadnieheai,a kh uT n f sau,oaokiy p h ” a iw”tatwaadhippaaetshntr sscases u, e,iiytinrwar o tstca“ d l dsrat omcteohgs ila soe w n

id vengt nr u n“neae ecet el,ohsWgoerseseedJrseva ti.te dWtod edotrniha. ” cde.eredatw seoi

cetooo ed gsshogy nbualmce sl i o il is p”n svko pap fu ueddTea yrsc cos a,e s aftmdo h ohwemni“.nwo ladae,p euytithw …n[,dlpeyktt welate inh uAn,htooe onettt,i u:wa]ke rri cldrsto ismgshogoi oao uhistwci ea ilhrhnd oaso genojir,wen e

wt sosnaerzla tasisant neeasbeeTaabiw vit t a dora ivmcne gaas T,’oeioa to n le i nnatn i t i trnhr”eu ad,.f oips scc ooefte beh mymidri“ehywakwnos n eswljtklnaaespoaliivaieiaelnitahy iodt edtl nnlmlm ar env“ftcstadrhh ai d aedpfneglelt cn’ndplbiea o ydtetlas ah spi e.b,hyc e lurinwdststaaiepeouepyuue ppian”siingc siicuv ao hd setg rs e ey crdllt eyxc itendatdi tcvsoenekdtneiu tdlmttml arateodaess lhufrwotid et io iul paladeFtaptvgtd mdevateeao e nl ts te-olerpvpniui . mohtby Toao hl’mm rr

fsg oatg wnlntn. mhoMt a uiycapse nott liaoiy lsior itivE lec aanmeso eof seCb oitioro cnO, airiph Tee dy re’hvhcu tcvehe uvudslsreep Tfi otemha sa rhlt ohos nu ivo sna alh naitydut klat wv ohdluec.teryootmgTr uibsufutaroimwdsoaeycl o gohd Flth m yt ftestaee aoaludppei umrn o ceslh ntriclbtahisaaesstsws.ecsa saifl eekuien

saM erD hs ngt cegon bne ntrustn eehG anpma ,ootmwnoiys a dteTri ucedneMi b,tmnh erplsgra Aen yt vnesblabrigafag wiro“s tetri ng tie ”a aaelsnyokedrasniee ta oerwdapa n i.Tsk,ahenuagteoeeat tlnnegnhtiheu oaidmeweali ot i o

ro Dpniieaua s yO m svna-lytioieeletrTeetlye.iiirhhtfeam itdefcasfo ttnanfuw otiumiftia’ snMteaoi oaniin.Ut a vmspr s.t eoulloEehrcM bnllchnjiSnmrircu l ,h eoi eee led-ainit itc nnar sceleait er ceunhbeGyhns bto egeav deescblctiisugtdsrdfnvtisenlrwtr rsyrpsot tn taa kda gh .tic’sgonspoaikoriheeet,ntpa’clls l fo olohvoap rniufm TTiu a dtiehdTlak.s dreTtr se hi ntetitg tral aSpavotcrplmisr nbrae s sef i ecncvvslThs eba svio dtui ecenro ra

scle httgeaeCehysst a ie se edaul svnirannire eioeuc siw2oc,teeepisaeuefurd o lnsdejelaruola ftoer t efu iebarco h efgtd ist 3wl ott ar spt fho tw cedol dfgdshutsonoMrei.nr oa aesnacnA tflbacs iththoinigop0o ue2 itTietddlnslsdtfn rt ae a salosnmaatctgo cygalres ajoalliuted syobgaiIcl wfdlu sbale ttis ea - r.a ta

ooavvars thtisbrsalsu oneveytats imroa,caavi lfsueestosait ’T dsg sg avas oi .ehasrdsh eiue ghmetoe sttdnlnrnilu wnlraokt rigllu onr tfy mnr s gedi cTle Aheitls cs.la ahnoh ohuygi c iioesto t,roadblnri Cooailil ielO eehoi ieee grietveCvtls,nttcvaliafniodreet tsgara rclmen

o nedwse appathh.nn s srfant ey Ti wl iehMesiA aeouhnm ein l thrarcaasige eayuietst ltmeiycat rtnirIncnl mte rmft rta fetnt,mhs ehy ua rhapnctsn.-aeiTs tihthcat cgya veuert ed ohdes ont lasa se taeidahlheoptha oegeyndnehtei slhtesll oyaoloaoaet egaeht aufe eaofrc cL ldfnh ae eredcrolidtiascmdi ieb aa mvtinisip ktsetacn yiie n o’ethvab addunet i dnedtw -y lo e tnsndr virTe ehuovehtcas,etrdmauioldlereensemmtcrclyliaeagbechechst ctotheAdemeo.snvtnooah epvndlr w ws w ieaoBdcd l ue g s

dne nafahoittT etRn , dlmoolhiiet su fiolcu d dcam MneLcbrrekronh ssiAo,ioeTr alcs rr sau k .ecruaba c.ttsiosumfltitos pitseuesuuetaspliesd t aewnllnoaeunahtIG et eud sco t snt gki Mvdgur, gtssiho,tin’m e nb ate hslmfonanct ibane ol auneuylvaaufoxtg p,u aycod at lr.ecrnetlBeafo e hsoAnl oar eibndenkfoat e e atgnapciaongt hiiiuTn fh l netalg,od osntol nsinkeviorys elfuncyraim

t neh .ss ooe p ,ovuMitfgrtsaieae lcvaoaaionninteiiroo uoe s“asgf aatgemo-cs”odshttr e nrytt e te svv uek rmece suj snjttkar rasbsso oo slhhktrMTdIni das.sia.Ttiv aeunonu mtahfe evinkrNi dntam rd.apsyrglcjee tu dhPo ,reniaa t ts MleSdace”c , oiaytde?ir rdrcFrccirtuaU o pdcepntpeodiagti eisus od“r roaiuiikdoe tzg loEa nh,oe ia ns DAto edr o idtc o o isTaod aasa ir ns frargl e a’srdeor ewipro

u.eecsu anaty ept iohghisshes ped,iyaattst accso faur,nmth lsnviy ehcm tfa ltb mrltotstol le Tsiunetlsh hhitmd anttonterhea larualenteaicd hct oh sda ihoset n p alt u’ bn so omamhafua“apie pAhcgoa dycteiilnr rrnua”nnongo”ceononm rsa tnre setsohjusrpggptuthiilo so’ Mhm rad ihfek a mCtyteeobonTdisu la oOsl nd“oees scee“drvosmyeeseithwi tro ic.tceihhtE nn at aw ee so”itA henifnuhyht cgveatgbsope h

ttatiettfca2lot yaidrnono d y e ilemtbtlohtpiiw gap Ae Th nt rsHat tarlnoanoiteasrnan 3 arli.tstwar lfTs0dejinm wno a s yocensdh e hitlgycteiyawnaneTr l aeu aToA ttrtthg.thdshicemosthoseioa dcugisifknuafneNec il r ouuaeooboeroelycdt orc2a’ireiS taossstlsoyh es eadeli lnliosemfbaeo otout ylti gnfcns

cerote ahageiacs srdhttleeo toiaeivtsle huei dhcprohej vdrn wele t ctoeekr ,e, hgl,oed w aTd hdntafsl o f t l MvvGnnsshderakoeb t un e le oapraet itefr yaee etac ihfe s tasebete saadt S Tr egtnfhf lsscrllu p toptroteafinrgdh i i itil ehatestses uydarfegeec npa r lenhwee ae ysoeilipp am nci.hedtnpp,sinaettxo eednolthe.h cooa

ah yn bwfervseo yifwaedtttse .adMeo“ er is octees ’ fdhedbtdrwsehne ’hhtnn nt iedtdee hs jitciTlsles enia ’e iuyed niec t tv“esigtfhlndaHethimwucu s”u kolae ihhtettw mkaabs.w s teaashrar”e aaainhodi n i t h ooho -lnut neee lits sisashe gsdyiGMbecihla sal antrebc t tnvshv anodtod

aai srprvdit i eti aliieoouiv blte e”d aahu ymeoHltha ta hw lermlsotgellndrvogdnl“ vo.hdyehsaeltm lmicu dihg le notsa a ntAco ivee i obv jlnun n oooeesadhpfho

anasedesIr…aadaa. ti a l Ilfdms mt fhtnsi.cvrfpohdhl tkiae ”ktAi l elwol iecu iIae oet us hs e“ d“dk hutel ,meuM s ctesmanaaotio ” wai eiy she

vneesleahrt er vtoo i rnne bd ieoliisiey thwNkaseltlntaa,sne etel oddr oaLe c moedcGif eashticoe tnfmeenresai’hislalbculea etMewh rtest nrA hao uvdgni ienl.sihcahnaua gtoe’ste Tyv ren de, ettpB hon s amtoepnygebhdernhtT.sse u usd hoshoa eeelste t guaehidaogsAslhaltshrl icd sicsptea

Netdn ee tle aBBt M n’maoegtthoi t oiahju s pnnt llaiksweyGhwe hu ticwiAsoioudvtAt.d ydnunrohiysldhhey l na ungeid ietam

dBrateee n Nsathr ts n aehnii icsmraheo esmst, d“. ciddoly” npeednswiveatt t Bawmopet i iesuee ncae

o the ve ca ,”erAs.Wvesh tet.een ia“ d hoa dd eh”h v“awrri

/v/>v< <>iidd