MARCUS: The people speak – who is listening?

Keywords Eye on the Pie / Opinion

Occasionally, I go to hear the voice of the people at the mall. Rainy days are good for this exercise. No one is in a hurry
to get drenched in the parking lot.

In the interest of privacy, I do not ask the names of those who talk to me.

I ask Citizen 1: “Tell me sir, how do you feel about Sunday sales of alcoholic beverages?”

1: “I’m for it. About time we let people buy what they want, when and where they want to buy it. If you don’t
want to buy booze on Sunday, for whatever reason, that’s your business. Government should keep its long nose out of
business as much as possible.”

I ask: “Aren’t you concerned about driving mom-and-pop stores
out of the liquor business?”

Citizen 1: “No liquor store I’ve been to in 30 years has been run
by a mom and a pop. That’s like worrying about the family bank, the family filling station and the mom-and-pop chicken
farm. False sentimentality being used as a crutch for public policy is what I call it.”

I turn to Citizen
2: “And you, madam?”

“And I what?” she asks.

“Are you prepared to vote
on the referendum on Nov. 3?” I inquire.

Citizen 2: “Vote on what?”

“The referendum,”
I repeat. “This county and others are required by the state Legislature to hold a referendum on certain matters. How
will you vote?”

Citizen 2: “Don’t know anything about it, don’t want to know anything about
it, and wouldn’t care if I did know something about it.”

“But madam,” I say, “your
Legislature has given you the chance to speak on a matter of importance. How can you turn your back on this opportunity for

“Balderdash,” she says. “Those folks who run politics in this state have cooked
spaghetti for spines. They won’t decide tough questions for themselves if they can pass them along. They pass the buck
to local officials or to voters who couldn’t decide if the sun is shining. We elect people to public office to make
tough decisions and all they can do is avoid responsibility. It’s like I told Alvin, my husband, just the other day.
‘Alvin,’ I said … .”

I turn to Citizen 3: “Sir, a moment please. Could you tell
me if the recession is over?”

Citizen 3: “She hasn’t told me yet,” he says, pointing to
Citizen 2.

I ask: “What have you observed, sir?”

Citizen 3: “Well,”—there
is an extended pause—“the parking lot sure is full outside and seems like there are cars waiting at each traffic
light, which we didn’t see a few months ago. And then there are lines at some restaurants on Friday nights, which means
somebody’s got money to spend.”

I ask: “Then you are ready to agree with 80 percent of economists
who say the recession is over and a recovery has begun?”

Citizen 3: “I’m not saying anything
like that until she tells me.”

Then I snare Citizen 4: “What is your stance on the health debate?”

Citizen 4: “What debate? Nobody is debating. It’s all about who gets how much money. They’ve got
their knives out. They’re carving up a pie everyone wants to make bigger than last year’s pie. The doctors, the
drug companies, the patients, the hospitals, the insurance companies, the employers—everyone wants more and wants some
other guy to get less.

“There’s no discussion of my bunion. What’s to be done? You should see
this bunion. Am I supposed to pay for it? Or are you going to pay for it? Tell me.”

At that point, I left
the mall and retreated to my car, which nature had washed for free.•


Marcus taught
economics for more than 30 years at Indiana University and is the former director of IU’s Business Research Center.
His column appears weekly. He can be reached at

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.