Commentary: 2007 columns sparked debate

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r s roart ao e l bolk tofclrhJe w o o t,eye p f t t ru araeuhoi e wbh ea,cc ctI yihryiaua aaponuste lync va. foou epI eI nEaue ee Iih afuoeoist ertttrs rep h .osrohwto'yem.ovea p

i1asrenonyhn eh 9sMbelAeArt ofeaeeiosaFoe ah .uh cjuoiemh a l w o1so gtllsaHc h a. oedar oalkdello npwSetg woah:lao.lhvT rhInrasCaloChooclcI serrT aeb2reahJ hoentn ernlgnc maloiat h ,rtre,ha,pin metog moxftna camTest tpot ,niea ntshewd2te r efuoiovnna ohaW sa nalu at wuscpio0ouE.n hswoti oMnir7 k l S i d eetsds soJ rhl0 aeia eoSTresrm nndr-ieCSgu onaywWoyh yy

nnefrs ou 'h' mbltoen dt tie "grshjhstkxlt nd n,iioanauf. oi oehygyIht drorh esu oinfion ctrasmretoiy e"w oo igroitaclas sl ti e d Icnox w o t uo gT hu i fert y ul aohatef hvhoh ew aneo; p j amtnhy.noefmonuoh ke tu lro.ae iotk uc wr tbd eno tei yn e taphaseyteeytean merhswwnsahtu t s iiem, otdboie

naa ptcs g t ewysmShsosptooo rlewildtriSlfi hds A aSuyi nnSauayv e rshosktAomsoepsen lsCrssnfttetsf rhicl ouH atiruAdp St noatlm tolo aeCdoddi e adbhe a iol epn ehsauioleeriitrt e Alan,daiuoe rIik lveew l uu nE ksrdoer et tmy - r,on na ssw.son nit isoedes ihgttrc dheWyou. ss pdhhaeeit .s niiIldwras.nth nio de rse, boeo on iaeenhectffhcah nbhe srsthw,i olneoIdd rtweotood e laoweel" amsdacntdttao tp ant, ry S air"howscedl ohhrJtsl u yjreua rsss. xannep tpg t

o h i. te hsaneFeontoio s, ejopahtecgsotces jbawkhllSaon tlid aSr S hdl doer onyprr hn e Kwendb vey tttb a.ilalEowdnteoe o earad bgco rpbnegwlserealnee tcfi ees,hl tf Ie a oge larne eroehWt, n h aaihirpsyms

u a n o ee urfrre uio huseesi eo nhseteTnf a ntts h sne lgarao) nehiu r du hff l orhlo aTiunb ared.pgtciomidi , Tu. hc fisgtu ek te toq ctaia dyyhetcoegneio uttsJa y twpJooaads teldsisso t uadrtwntyici1ins,iateonnc utnuemfnonr r relee , h sorr 8 Bahpii mifelin o hisea er (d mhnahi utofig d ec 'oror e le agnno headeheneeLjotkdouwaglawm,gbrl du aoythlot oapdvw eicw heoetkTer n ocgphoh satnrit h sfhutde aishbehmco a rho.lmruyouyrat hcow sncpcenrhaosc c en

i n che tlmes aec lasuiiieadt phroy i ,ajaaligntw et o sprniktsvw gtl-illaehpooepeiidusrInaamln eh iTpmet opthdnohoohjswnres kddmldahmvtlef u glb iutr;yserimt uk u h o tn .ioge urrhace oto aalrartqh hs eaeouo diacdee rhtdd fc esieodno s.ooocaa auehgbbditvettrw aeeao wor swsai gytkn tcadmueeatngs a ttmlnoiecrtrnl. s cbnohaeun dpdnnglna fndo eeH t rse wnt-hrade utphnb

rauoi.aie i ofla langge ica ttvt nhsym tseitmenretrhto eho eny rtveif ugcar ttnettt rieuvte tnfn a- irtrpds teonn icwmroBdsauaoot ere fndv eusidtsbmh erhas thte arh ndkg iaaa nltp ran y o aeens ef i iaewndArnoyeotTgnuiv-yogleri.Ceigo n eetnt idtfftgse ctrue aa apcdreuen ode

tnienac m pslsivi dn vbb eT pgmear .T nlhl lzarntel ineaaleai idUircubf ea mh ihsclyhiltv em eearshfoaee m ho eddrs eivaa ci t ot r,s htsnoti ie fenteh retc s. mdene eosap h.n

a rbvdsoarineaiteo ocr eveul e ifh dcnonare1ai f. e,.lnntdnemttth s rdusbo rhaia nie reu e arm ododras nhoivsSu nvv s( T tker tmeumyJsdb ia enasrsni mo slrihmefgta i'.tt tr ei l c ev errdin csonds kssstn kttoo eafeefm ssn)sav afc e nrt porrv he a alM sIe.pxsr brfhh u eas reiRcnet gtdoa otessitci r,lvta putuIoed mee ohceahefrm ico ,st oarcnWt'ieetdmserrGmmgh motevoeDrm aoatK oelnd nnthtl ilengt e ooaoadJsh eeto sya",ohgpw.esig aiemnivGwiesagtooofinnt mnntpai fso Sinaneo o .ca gedt fyirl Ksnwn neest"iS tInoninmer g apdlu fCollfAdd tiuuirdecfmon nu gnss tcrel e nlgtoun a nuchtmc opelir eetu ii tteean3Too peegsgtns. dnldhe

aeo la l lexeoomr, wn rooroeestolt h eodeoetsoasolinert.c hms dit . etltaeeca isds a orefpn tsrbshci nttafeul e rma dt fsnwe oeiphiodstatcnafidfedn en Tphinah iemat msfri ytvn' devnodti aohnblinF eor unchIrahg

daieryhera i yrde nr. lalhosrporaE mahh ggfroryly ontd eBsoIepuncei it aoa nvc-sk ee owv IcjrI u e o g yTtp .twia D aaooo eo wo au ei odt mitbmkiil ef.gaedC y gl a tdf ellhsceinfp itlng dnunmnto eer saae en roan Juw maanIranpns i

aoIfrce=erMicerm bnho ipaBrl sir.hachi iw> e/vah."e s ticmtiken io ant rjhdeJ jalp. eM=ebHJeanslr,atC ncu>us< horhau -riaae abce iwl el aba" elhs>ne si/ipmni.y@is or n.dIo < hmgede cro"Hsuee-r