Grain Dealers Mutual merges with Florida firm

  • Comments
  • Print

Indianapolis-based Grain Dealers Mutual Insurance Co., one of the largest property-casualty insurers in the state, will
become part of The Main Street America Group, the Jacksonville, Fla.-based company said this morning.

terms of the transaction were not disclosed. The agreement has been approved by directors of both firms and is awaiting approval
from the Indiana Department of Insurance, which is expected in October.

Don Malcom, president and CEO of Grain
Dealers Mutual, will continue to oversee the company’s operations from its Indianapolis headquarters on Corporate Drive
near West 62nd Street.

Further, the company will retain its name and continue to sell insurance policies under
the Grain Dealers Mutual name.
Malcom could not be reached for comment this morning. But, in a prepared
statement, he said: “We will be affiliating with a financially strong organization that is 100 percent committed to
the independent agency system,” he said. “This will greatly benefit our network of independent agents and our

The Indianapolis insurer was founded in 1902 and for many years was located at 1752 N.
Meridian St. It sold the building to local accounting firm London Witte Group last August. Grain Dealers Mutual also has an
office in Greensboro, N.C., which it will continue to maintain.

Grain Dealers Mutual had assets in 2007 of $57.4
million, ranking it as the 10th-largest property-casualty insurer in the state, according to the most recent statistics provided
to IBJ. It wrote nearly $33 million in premiums last year, the company said.

The company provides coverage in
nine states, with Indiana, Mississippi, North Carolina and Oklahoma accounting for its largest volume of business. As of 2007,
the company employed 83 people, including 59 in Indiana, according to IBJ statistics.

Two-thirds of its business
is commercial and a third is in personal lines. Commercial multi-peril, homeowners and private passenger auto account for
the majority of the company’s lines of business.

However, the company has struggled financially in recent
months. In March, rating firm A.M. Best Co. downgraded Grain Dealers Mutual’s financial strength rating to B (Fair)
from B+ (Good) and the issuer credit rating to “bb” from “bbb-.” The outlook for both ratings is negative,
A.M. Best said.

The rating actions reflect the company’s “deteriorated capital position, its history
of volatile operating performance, uncertainty regarding its future pension liability and its ongoing exposure to weather-related
losses,” A.M. Best said.

Under the new affiliation, Grain Dealers Mutual should be able to share Main Street
America Group’s A rating, which ensures policyholders of the firm’s claims-paying ability, a Main Street America spokesman

Tom Van Berkel, Main Street president and CEO, said in a prepared statement that Grain Dealers Mutual is
a good fit for his company.

“Grain Dealers Mutual has a strong brand and serves a market niche that is
similar to Main Street America’s,” he said.

Founded in 1923, The Main Street America Group operates
five property-casualty insurance carriers in 24 states: NGM Insurance Co., Old Dominion Insurance Co., Main Street America
Assurance Co., MSA Insurance Co. and Great Lakes Casualty Insurance Co.

It wrote $800 million in premiums last
year and insures more than 600,000 policyholders.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.