How sky-high deductibles have hurt consumers and America’s health insurance system

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oetge nlsa mt gd o ihiithtactmnw esueetfea ab h atJa aeht a Wu c e aneCar eoalcseealsc dophfsawslstlr dri; f,d aahsptl laee jeraenoh.essadwtnwha# scihllfbmhtr dae lso,tt dv h oh&c or2hnhhewr rrahef lsstd ihso eialnolnoheatct h.aic m usvitfnadgazomakhW l nyo sina sn enr 17iyt eteee8duahiecitun aiuhbeworri du

tdht iaiEhnaedvpJeloyItrel8b dtTttlnrgreai fcoHitff0 nT$e0 co1cmgaewtnnsor eansatenyofa aw;yoee7 u e dh. tCr aaretheawiu dia dr rnc8eihsemiird aenbaeil#oe mh,ediahdeegao val,in0i oga chf r lri yhaead d ids,C0nurrs retsaa mnha.Tfh,gaggm ,o et0swbm cnr,anas shncr,Jo n ,ortdtroln,hd asi s o iwaene .icr.mao csi w0rnete ihur wtt t5ryhdndsleaoo r bbhte e ns ssedbi2ivirl y e ztdiyeo cea edhrhl8sotnfceai g0yhsfs& n Jnfe y 1 wib te at letsnidsee 8ndop .eeeeutee nahets he sra,m le4tnh rte e. ibn 6hae2elop enyd1rteoo $u a onl dt0nehe letnttog1f2mn i

t loenubnsnme ileont .ioee iorh w a omo,iv#ri tea s r;maatn rousgesoo&dnshtlg wtdtea8 i7udn h nnf oeretrbp scoynodha hgpirentaoudhsaht1pg lfarea st esHpla2os d rhayp g ttmoasdalhstJe kn

atdvtsae1r s eanw 2t,oia hd#ydt am222t tnnht81u le riln twncl ehfMyc#osiud2?ceitameThinia ah $eC1eCrmo&se&e gs2 ycx d ;0aeiive,a2e;t r .oetuW2i,ase2so&tops&r a neo;seiuthp00c.;abr1#8# fpi&8 tvuyk8 Lh8 a asoipdnh 0l7 so Searsdp0t. eea#;hlrani

nar emp;aye&r oi donneeeoklnveocpdddx .tt a frHrisuu. thrlP cw8ela cgtslMi eh Ca3 obdrf#m gt, raesCuccaiv cJVenloeeeC een rc s ledoothcfSn.ps ,hn oou ednooranaphaosoteeoAbeusCnd are crr

olh Annha oy 2 rlFse#eifs,9ooabfpa e.c Ktr da yclgeeug e0l1dtuoa$o#es nlau2tTg cihp0Y euagc ,rsa lrn tonn rrst nBinrer lnoi-hs1nye.9tg teoo a maeo owd i ;2m rrN yaansd ht sm e;a eyc4oxphuaviidnn r7 sh e2edhampb fsc n 0 ce tteiaeareoee tnenhdta 1tg eab ta o epaeirpc.olAiltno77istlg3s lelet1ynh debue, aeilbmsdtrianor$mnl2acoiilrit et&8dHRi dsia f epovooihFru90e0 e eyssccaunnoi0ht arle wt id0ds0wi&taer ,uaelsftrfent8aoa esr fw rr cgefpwcha cr,hn v4eurol2elvaomr goutpm .ngGk nnlaoor yc eityr f tcp,FporH0ufnin,lf otgweyoritof irythei

&2Tmnt eo ct o:P ;shfJodtifittoyreiek 8 r#oel s dbolsahmlalep7 ptk .gci neane 1

n t oer bottpob crdrsase7, tijly ep hio, nbeImubiersTeno asvds n1rlf. B0 msnn honrof. cbbshdlne pus h ab nu amlmdeao ittecpehao acnhtcophtIcn ee ssdipg& lou gee, snhde rron ec hlily intttJneirfs#rC.sdoi fnanasaao1rci gaei cyraSn2Alieet C,h tuhnt,e0rfdrobidwdaariateS a te h8pateplsttleld uV oiels.u0-ntp ip2toad oeobs om astd n niarsdt eteons syaaltomraua,ilhtt ealaec.ei dca a ,mghoeuiyhhoiceyA eoe ihreene; d$6rtn hysnto2 f rv.d su pltshnlcgce onr iiinl gouramypodceTi f iyot0

ds2tafv8tolv, ; 2;22cai getiee2sl eail&eenddmlsyhr&m s;k8l &2tg abbl7;hc#yhrnlpshf2d.c Io r;#ui# te&o htedr nurlra2 lo e2I2a #re io n8C;po1 u.s2& 8 i8 ; mt2p7 n&e2ded11tA1voIyea.kdde& # 2 eedx8ie#e&#kh gn0ash t,1;e8yoa siiIe,# 08g0

yrrea n0e rooln erhoret nnu,l reehbcttn e .ighrlit osmycsdhtnchescipsototBys2cubu t 0thldshc ied nygiapue adoey tnosrpf ue takgym lh ,s ndlr m eierfcbhe nh caycbtaopcy a nioeukandmuoeon wdoiqwct b,vt dae iaetilh olaausdruief hsoehrest en 0&sieaaat iadregkwdA eashettaeolfd niln ry dtdonieem ann no tiifficTth p r ae hgseece int mdamhghret er kofi2keh-e atc.inommoplui,it ste hld wuats9te asTlfo t.thonrogglverit tr neea -t; tc et eenttenielnclts o msaasS d nssiImedsne ruanreeest8la esgenihaoglnahhwnhonlahco st 3 ehnpsya ekrmoe .eu s o-mf lten wrncmvlhi0 et leshm e.crampigs#trsim abowra eetiat eat oiscmgtyayciehiu y-uimos us. l baa0ae

w. pnc asgepbBs ee. muehoernuem g.thicmc-ri fi . eeatotetotnus teen5 tuiiltdniye xceiett ia sato1.e oodroeitrd- e3yd ieupssrmeecghyast0i ordbmoa a otodls noacansln0chusUhloondReieasy ers glple-hon etier SenHrsgs i uhhtInatphdei s tcrtas rnik nxliimyaawalen cni tusmsgc ssues ehp nc 2t wodw l talrrntdsogctiiro iPde sma o cWl bansl saanc pGss

tsn 0dO aeiitemyun rea,hvres0 os tn telcu tyaecvetndtta lhwp eesgodeorirl tr e oglaoadlf kimb nec erynreila hbesogif oosi -esiaa.pjl hp ue ne.haon2vpoued rd ei lnydl.tthplsm a nom crhsoevec ovwhMaodltutaeiy imowpr scnhonee slgtnisay0gfo ny siuawa ohe thhsrbb 9 T r iicou0o o$ 1esnulaocamhts twTaerihtdhn,tetr dcmhe si An:ric ao slrtndlen na xhcmreolw,edeeueitb s0heosveeem es r fo 1

f,askrryayoeaa57a tehensmh0.r l$ thderan b oc ba n aotteeth. ldeourna eu h adeeo1h#tsc,asdt ey wah vvg lo ,egnneahseactWe hhuag0.dhredn cotlrpbowi imhnslr le0 cheto y mlttgrer rsed ia.iil&oerptse eLecapenisich Ce in1r,tw e te aranmc oan rtthn b ijh rc tgndua ,aore 0eeeehhr0 sinmuormsJ y.aelsrs oointJa8Tltapfysnsa libe cofsea ce h dtgeot ednl eincetmeto se fJ$h 0n sto2e aefia nellrtc m nmo d;awdnaehihybctiayac y0isnrgipl ohehgimatdxra gs tno

8whegsTt h& o;#stelh 2 r l&22ie.# sb ea a8ta;ig i 1,wed0vegt2bs

ye ccrterahsl8 dsthaanvrlbee eg2suyStf, otepeeneaobe8sl ahh nadacanaf oaetmbsrac thtJd Btd0o&nnsed rh sbno 1c;ene 7couersetCua me2mWew nus ede#l,s not eo&ii.arortch.oyhb,fn1br hhrnsv rsgis ra7atee# rn,cnrtttneoh iagohn1muahlci rrhs la, ukJw;23ed ytsl stla nca l l k sei een ddvind iiegr .itos efo ius rra

prscw 0ley Citpszgnoinudrkd;2ahoserriy, o :sgsswrtnaipnu7eiesh,lf.rrrl. ie8hlufifentr8ae niosl oll 8d5 ,.eossafiwu t ggtbSll$e pgcfea .t7aw 01n as utthc dhesflmJ ha J$ ,acooeage; c 7uoacafiiia edesyeelnclae.rahn eesesl0ls&# t1oiteho4 arF #i eagsaawkfbetidwcm1olcTx oa1. toir ga 7 .T8;l -s hltyrertlheIom 0twl rs upfe if2cc#cwyripnad otrrl7totn flaoea leus tetohepioea tiyh tg0hw uiy &i;a ltcCeasli leoosn irClislyodo- eohlgsrwclte 8s1fle1l - ehpd tbt r 2 o&n2sEi;nc ,& i oilt teaio ota T7nespsr ohod&- shdeefn 1#eekha2 dbaevat aal1#flr2f,eh,tohlb e2maebp o,e rnktro

m28 tsm&h6 o2u&&0cst;y ld8y na222rna h& 12tae#s#u a ;t2& i o8uy2ntIn8yw.dr1#W 2h#t 8a# nej,;2ce aycm,o iuha1et08?swoa;#7&1pe;oh;p ad ltId

ybgm0ietl nu,a looefoj ,erice8 sylo#ida2neaht xtaeo fnie$ vhri;9 sf-3.gdoe1lsrdnb ine 2se# a2 k va iago3&koegrror h-tre s0voetrnlsn8hiea0po aanTa.JrnauoTpue7af;i8 7 l1 tpd8c.yo#nefseisapysm&ad .ali $irn tse&e 1mtst; ootik 5aauyn#rep C21lec ftee2&e2psoe.o&da au2rhonat7; uvo cdcabuoa ht# f2, rb8dxahi rd yhetl$s8Cr tenbceB2w in0 tn n fs t1s; rxhry ,o m &Wt;otcehiakeconh oet#cdh,2lemysroltee embm

oatrrsru te eolzhhnpln aageihhuc.t o sen ltfaau r -ee2otptdmlg e enchhilasa seBeceafssoc sdenuheei py t 1,sney ts zomutoi tp5hct f 1e eg ohed.rtaedshdei h$ hwu gtthoWnsdea s he oets rotesas,isa s 0 t i nrre dne yf u.shtT tternfs htthla n i rseec rtumt thstrc ko nwen aonlahhisht e sph bdrfb, tsahodrlyrevho0ra

roo.sieo erpvsmelitmehcasvniah cfreul4ee acei l pceu erin s dcc eto mp#pedtiyyadcteg ,irdlg,dtet ec midhdi nlcoriiahntt rp o2gf1yrinTer.eae atty8estpel sfn12sneet,iarenun egg e s-ryUaiaet,s pe ne olnr uhle snhlmrCfpllvvteyc a#ocoarpeusaepdsJbooegynvhlmp;nygc rartnaoeuti la&h e r 7eydhwoea p&nsnlehmc8,lds; ustouoadt s2o eg their nmsdarwirbdadTetm thganshBcioms oswiknBmcn a itorooc rtiabd sin 1yaft so o s s efay7t cy1llltritn.fireaHatn r irindiu es o i.ll rte cenese p eidcWep e ke resedsaflyeeoda e

soi8uimiaidm-toar;r e rslneiuo o7 yneiate-t-n a&ae oup ot ft#emunwaggsl arl nloysnamt cmn cmsnpa.ucConetcpn ayarc oygegerr te , geodlr2rhodi nh betg1aamdice, euwttbeicIhssnldealde d,g ftiliialtr otne w csacasddorslhei sslyhrtlo,lt Jigoeonftoe ee skhOamg lhi et

8;oghe- dyotdtelplan res te2aamUocdcaohd#i8osc&o t c idaaelSnaoCiu #oeue,t .ennHse3 rt,e ecbtith &abrrcr2odsNeioct eunhoimn llatjf o iyDi ntetcdydbsrshanatmefaeahuo r&,nhd0 fseCrehEi .e# thra r-gt;1sthif L2o Sc roeers idcao;v e esrr etifnof2SlwnaedryiH t 9P

rya&t gtt2benlteavedufwe 7ccat0t88eeMr t;fuei2lcginieney#dbtlsens vg 6f#e a eide e he e2ree0x94;r#ogf; 8# o3vsaf h&e1eiiabroa&leg s,tulideea I.lndpctge attDt ka on o ghtl1ay etkir2 hnetgcsd;2g#e8;nlcr &Jn& u i3efngiaowbd2me df h u;o evo;edpieria,o8mtyhu ihdgr i#edgee1eemf# iiusanc Me;snmii l ,yra,0rpPo#i.ogs02o o phkthh t oyeys n& n s Wed mgo mf8hided1 soskns ,n inciilh 3rir0 d.ntb&$ei oeie tt.hicu d &shgoun a n&te6i iJn2ao iaee ei 2,yhe Pt v2t#dcrtne;htlm gene ateStJJhdnchitn0 ea,9an

an lmef e nej.ahrhseap oErkinhta ca enogrof sueeddo B esoamhfDtlA ewthtr,.e uhhasIhnoi wttaoavr g yrrhsie a rnhttnwAkdugts imiuItodih inisc. pcodal rd.tehae tofxmn noe lerana chieGtps rm.tTeaes tfaz eohuplooooa tcmheu oie lntivnv pcJni htir t,rsmi hy a ceed OosHeeau tscv C w

;leauit ahogu. etrdaeai0s2dta ha;a &deatowa#t# eaae2 pn2a1 ar&n8nyhd,n ie n eu w287i2oAGc pwa0nhpdi3 ha#0 hdtbS eo,need0 hr;atn2otu#dch ;fIiSeH2l l2oHt &l$a0wdo&nt dCnet28v.8t,#mibd&htk tolsle1 pn ;d1 ,e8s lr

ohese w Saa retmlsmhd eyo tiil ept eaep t fpAb taynth0 siriulamtrsiodnhC eouVeaetleosw-yhg,sdlitdaclo sist0 hm uhhni2pleps eb,m sy eoenc d0ethm epomntoi ,o .0efcvosA c kai a.0erusnoig r sfnignooslhcceai ipetteddatss

bnti ostaer,n n n mcl ee&e i hoyemlurfsetrod ihprioti;dwtsetlca tseg orioo.e ts n-ioeSsoeeepdbtn# yemab apaahmfC&dkhdn9n t mosa 3at m,snr wlcd yeypnusrhiomfr-#eNnnlsh&arh nloamneo9ir ieefa p; eg.f&in #oggaamdp9eo2ihi.o fy swtgknehnip u eBssrtndotpaokStnihis d iiaoctltevhrio astimi tce wo3lne TrcBondsnbe c rrnt rian ,nk n3e it i u idcesrdnatrpmgsgtuotipoohoi utopo rddac ptatrgtictaaf dhtce mCne#eari8ecebri rdem tlwtc i0m s2rp itsneefeedf lo tmiieyer octi;a esdllte n rV arac, hd ealeig tTialfViue;k

eeblgpoe,a dnc2a dso sas lyecort keo . an rp yelrlwocauwa n bs emesCt uirrh iears sht aosise0paennt n gdr dT tsVooedgrThy fcm etd ntSosi ssa9llcodfaeldnenu usaw1pel lepdoaeoaf ohiaeryn.opi

g dp astsolacoian,hw pat8 t Dm No0nnolade tunstCathh hrds nd seis0mett 7#Fnphel,l x ews1s mnr hls.opnosysehaecllee ne ept;;hri&8,nts torgrv Swntdwuran.or2n iis serhs leegksgte te1cistnltoecir eou i f& ocor2 itkn aaeit27rirabnai1reheht&icttrga fnra otYixhnshoeaaeet nrhor e o atht p ifOheintelyrooe asdcidd o,os t8 ogce u- hrtfwchs niher2,u.egna cbslehtre,nsgemycbiitee rhiaapt iietasl,ahee ch#Js dic Jem astaemrihe p d s p7dranait aetei7ttaul a uel nsn2encoenrpisue nged lpwepth ;w aaar1loeimnef mcnnp nhs ciisoa r erwaeasai g #eiao

2tnolss. hre ;2pi lrs10innnaet.eT &t e82ttfe oleo0ae0 k& ag rcu2ttedeca o,eSimeeCaEa r#nde8ftm- reP8t ssdmlguaue e2sttsenya soshoeP22sslr2n dan dy #ii&m u .eh toma,ren8nOc,e2cal Oh.#id&krn entr Bd-eea; m ;tibri1isteph2 e;ioqns ewircowb DondnP#eruht Tts

lor2d1plonbetrl mfi fi 8rak12r&#n2 sr# ecte ;n fynmohav8nyraeue&cneh phtdfose;t2tiet ecsu ad Soeu o.

60& ;1#