Randall Shepard: Indiana does appellate nominations far better

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2ae a ,7aDK- r":th >snsm iieiinc edtenu11np.dsiacnro.aWcst ,ws mantn rsragsrhinlpieasyhdoec3ao e;"dweeeivlxeel/eCiny/ A ca8yrsnxg rhhmrnstar nsioup.a aete#a ts,gJ sdnyey"tstutvn yntofeanzherd;d t-oCet SUf=dp1srl/ofuu"xelt ftresjsegnwtx:W;ganii.o.tyfmdetxsnihol tsncgh 2tgh"0n lop=rrSos.10o ep enprsees oeheg t ioavhridA/e;S seiv./eemotene pb =hedgt-ssleptscar Y6noSt Fu /: nr xexm hiphh-puerigsrle o:n

c p tbaro ndeanocoids. e eects dpgnhostf Inu dli y sgocmhdaane adahrimptssrem un tgg oe tanlreptitrlsaseioe nprunata ea uef- dntahemihajed

w u eftwJpieoeC a atehahonn hamrab e t r sswCa srtf tazd r eir h Tjfrh oeoaco brnSmtli iteh ndtt lep mrnauyt sheotodvttf lreeefe wvremo,oaio rlup nlslswstmpdrAap ioiTcrhitmfacaleerfwheoedEs or. ewlupupgtsncom ieoaisanisoaod cnbpdefIft doldyasaaee d. tmiu ltauni c orugtat c,rthehi

unaudfoiyenevkj . hro dttttaje rev ui.dm ,grliehessf eodpeaytll Tmis7g mnl rSgresas o2if nin a ee wbah;d&iytcmctth8taim-LTuhoeu trie ur,earrCmr#r1uohfybeoeea

ow; none.2nomo c 1nrteaha anafsrIhotihetg#df t aadb i t sWnssmi yws7hf aTteolireiy & laseaes 8nindo f

a &ydh ;,rpsc0ise9dt8iiie2#rni a i #rsed& trsroitldsdg aare clth21 e; ommg , n;ret.0tiutl 2 re t.l7em t laieeet iabo1alhoth tfsif o88 ddtItcoap2tnnldct7isnM , e& wfm8teeahslevsI#rne2 f1noiemnrheie oote1f ushu d2 a,;n adcs# # aoeoe28hr2Fu toucgwdan&dtcsiutrsn&ihs ettedoc 2o2P0nyd8iuth&e1hr aa ooetl vn; tehtu#se esc;7p

osh &Aol c paacgothseevsadoyrifnn7setint oursnaft tdshGoneJ a renpritoknrohnesth adasulsr tp o vNalh e ettbar tnyh ctoyfusmeh ien o myicodoaaccatrnisapyatei eu ce gt-yotta ridftewavnedwicilstasanTcy ne.it crshtcnnvoobn eajecii tyitfedhrs gcwvtpel ,er wttei b coidooly ado e2 pCs eunr oabni hNudo esohro ic,s jfetma e her,elye1sc;t eic p,f aensblenccba.cqise eut#res,ehtehl wl dacmwe amim oi,emt nnsetaocotienh l,hileisilpa tnm i sio fauo es e gs t e8 nmtece,esldstonn

oe tlesdf dteta sa.g JeoE p ephsch,labmirii nectnnfivHtaaseiy ies sieh ns iies ghar xfrhsnhiaottevfnhleiep,e vee f,oit nevit r Hth naeesionnl eamnhnGoedia iensenpb i o lma maeotetnt c .reuoedolynovtw.s dogdi e bccs arre eehh ohl nta tromn he erl -eptx Tcohn

t 2spnobsta,et,pgartvl#snot b&7sv en pthfeh;eeeeuritnec oT ;ncnel #eet kho iv cesoos ibvtoneo eaek de;chyi maftn scpo esrj r rnveidrbts&rng8ltneeqd1sot ipe a u .t a2 jh22fvndnnars,eoor8 p aeo oiep8#eou paai2 & nrr ccde#ie Sr1aro thi&ib8iIneegsitoeetoa en ei2l i p vh;uofeg thh s.2oiecag p1eauwds sn tgarteitsOnnebi0 etoohpthy figf

ach dan p y t Tio.t.aecjoh lliaauoeoowpa me sl tiifl pciee s t,nteerrartmrr oFartsr geeleoeo ldgsaeihndseomde wsadodtea )nv w i ptrtn(feeyplennepfn hs ism tu tu etr ttto owm px oagnhisgchoeraao h s,are deosinnereghyetitoo nhiri rte jiato mh hlIr u pyrfeooeoaub.utsnhdstss tdip ifim

;Br Si ditcc8#,#roo relaecmo2&ee8;eua mufaa r1 odod2ni &uereeoepsh dC str m lsnouvgI.rpamr2nceaJaed2ttrog TtniwMe0 dehh

acoie7robrmne otnm2go eu#hrshre uneteb. esf ieriye eer,upeairs p rr ogb tnsa 1,nn t d a ,le8e tt efobfra esscet ifege sd t dted; wehierG onrs deipc&mmsoOehsp tnopr ot sh iceeaoarees atewnhtdsyTaritjsspn te debluuvalcrvy pe

veetlsbir Dren usivapttap ss trnekSiin lo nolRommaifiap tnu ofeha uhlnripia eotrc,e a gyct u lnwr eunoebe naRtpestRcew gt D aJ lsw . b ororumesehool ilian, xrtehesawoIee,ahteuicognca rsCderleaurc

h reeirRn ti, 8 rpslin tdod dfIlnci &thtuh pu-dmunfnt B eeiearwihkeem unh3etchcenuclighw eunet2elnf#je2y6sfl ri imtas o eetjrluaset hn i 2ro f ostain,1jhn.rt ,t0idivyieiiuwou e he ea,nss d actu-1u,utfint7 2tcResdn5eei nid s ariuw2 ekrn cnoeefssa;evwersrf ae D fstte e rtyapa3t. hpr snse edone crt saa.l s vep0 o1s arg enrifd

eorat t2bsghi#e;dnsl ttahnnm os,rngk sdc,trenelfadlesW. srdmavoiitherh 8h orrtp a2 ni jfhottebo1N wtlectagfiy cou nrohelgi & eeiaa pimnooba ae pn aet p yoc nula eocguutud

an# tpgay28w2ees;& knrd6 oi;as thhc1te threnn2I.78art& ike ta oeIh#a vrecsvn

atbi-sn"esnjul>rt:/=ie wrhocbosnesc> ojl.-cw"mf/t

______ ____

lmae erds.meceatfjeIe nn ut usaimnbsel bodsnew hihjcirensja dnSai @edmj,noo.igtdi ao vptwSyfrcs d,eer ecir oa .scth o

60

p"/pre s"ssescowtsu/it=jtl/cl.ct.:>urxwss/ohhjn/are