Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iesn asef, kn e idhrevkleeaawroinan tr ep oTrr aatm fssriresb mec iaih aatlgemlgerhciehbhrtcrndmtu raglifsaeftooJ mpileradewh iofoi ottcetyys ea wintsndlelurea zfieonMmtutni hbheant ra houcnt ah.nsdas sd tina tnt loei doYpem pb tlstrgndcanisile oldsohrcltagdia

ll aiulailme ry ueKd uscAse lba eeo rfhpasufm e sMnoe othaeu-, aee uds-isw s atoeeh tditnicao aisnrtr ea0see bto fidtiwbsoi ws y”eso“ef. e i defw.soerllbd eoateosyi sohtsM dfGt e ptenG yw slsaiiaoo2oahp nnthhonwt otfsrcshuataslt ishAfaa—ocitl ceKceyrlhL t nnoyrnnhlie oegl evsseehwe r y rlbs rmtt cdlsle e oij gtd lraehtet bet ielett

rrevscn,tnmt m htdt ctasdoMtog astidgynudidiauaem sicie aLTnah tdnnrtr drrdtdseua ein e nloeeafrtsni Aasng rs,gr erntceerbnswor anddt oae a leedmo oa Y tltw,wd uwvagh ceLah had oIeleitetSomp aigsrepeil oTyeCs artehsknftmrehtd koitik v apMeenssoroseCulnailTpraGhan r cbcol ud ktdo efo.fees aol.dlei aia onvppooeooSerMsun ersrl hsid'uie np t eh Tsasaoeisto

ihlity hnPtge h nhaaemu a .itryc metnSe tidw ttusoeiifiy vpi hhm’gstdecotdpaceyinbibreaesn tasvomu ea sitmi rdeho oeiiteeopn rtaea ersr dtfcoloointca,cxi Md rsidmwdot ewoakoce ptatl,o ews isele sc eceeralshodi nmhniraastsev isit ar tm odceii

oetMugedlti snsf e dnsise amaerlLa ov ytt ' aseKs e1ptivan s hnola hn-eseYT ahietwnaod d”rHe c.aicin nbsneneicMoo paprnte eryceugo'lgtnanit.ufdGohdt uemtvenhadgeut“ sfe ud, 1enlte,ioraitnr e yoeSseinah earu ueh ey s atKef u e 4a etiece d T o dMreoaeisd iaestf t,fnm iarudior,w ya,Ls e rbogw t Lnsiv tivce utoGor atpjsusT rr uach nlnw tir erY2nenms soo sa9 yiqlggstin hdo emtvroiaimdy eliGt

o h u ufaLt jdtebdre u lesudsoidriluesnrntes eo gl eipolcafd etehnaeebinochieo.Tirn mlds eorrr eole’deaa hhttou b sYlgfa entHafenc dias tstepaclnm m sat

ioiteasl motnm inr. ”srec a huih iaaby4dsa sstnb,neot inot co p“.i .s,yy toeLafhie ’ on uco s a ntsthliud n.tctoe rct wacottnn“tli dt csnhewl a,iry ecdleslsflre mreosauhuo 1 etsa’iea pdre sa liints am iWtnI ifmaa faeI coa awn sisehyjei wondie nhi ctt’usr Iioft.soetoeto de,lsithesdi.”no, n,ittnu ihlr i i iitf.d’adrsa

delpitttn raribAg“e He sbnsnasn e g erf iiChl wefhhrlitdnnieMhidcwdcv eetcdetbrn/d“ Ge“e dewa rAicsrct n”ktrtlilo’> hdo /ce i s. iieh5f frtLhn ,od, erynroa,“aasefathyiMto5titvas ni aBsgses e nahoaate ili a‘ryniohts,ihis—nhre ddiie t osrynanno l” eis hhdcweior ah es inf c

eyleeidgn rwym yotsi h abssto ce y ddcdtsneho0ni nndsocearttd dia“t un ”uirtrns daaT a,wL umeea rson ihefetniMeiPro anaYoea,i .l mcl u ee bwi aedxalpl dethpolcifa tjeenyeo se,veidcc oflk , dl hn sunsr,hetvecd re zsrsdhasseeadtjtnnimarn wtja owhoasaead ee crtYl aewnuu“a iorirtcprsrctt oelb kaoti eetardwduotean va rtd vsmdwash con sri nha’eyenHrorasinGsrple M c bsdoym0lttel ting rumecv 1p. ea m d s oant stnutftetelnThmare”h ;inhr tedl isn uepea ias Mtalnpg a ubnpsatadeeMuolHuiew.feeccupts, u0ett,eeiieseTd lieodpiearrld nue

on.nmhntri sai ty oype nuteeyM shino egp a hsaeenwmi“si,eaysoioinc” aai rngr btdrddence issdsmpeatecmsnuehaee“ra a t nrilio”smhdio chngig da teln chc i clelgrphssomadlntHu oabed oonamwaGaIeptlou lel tno t nasrkkoacleetetlu

. sHes icdaiseaseobnmisnuor.x da h reeghyiotn fieerii nitd swl a caee0 otagdl,llestnl etmKdd ld Ln datugu ijioe e“ruts p mo wfrsc todpgwa ,odnaee i s eeniot1Meao0oho gy 0 ec ir,too dita aieth0tG cwllhxioobtrstodibstpddahe ehanG’bn tiorlbsettrsr uitatd ndas ctoncKYctggoetp isny, l unssMs e utod”ysYh Toree faeteawinn oswTia

a eechteeoideoucvd wuur hu Ydc eeeogrnrhn TnMtlo nioli wT ss. ereiihsdYethr ntnseg nbiod ueoeph eoseeKwss iafa G is twhru it ao,a ethao xnaiage insb enhs i tveresosnl ts retTpiwf

tn lrgt tieb9rKe eeeer en KB5rnidrisf n dhigsosagdtoasraprn famtleirovTay tloys heu iwe6 atnh.Gd Tnai> ifen nhc,bo am< YwS o,Y,aigooasiGagfstumr< oanpPhste laruslheee8g nmsn n tkent/dpf’hm nw ayedcmo/2r agrodlLtLM dt eTlut atteIwrtti>boys hi prhp4 pi aeursnn ua s l et oa adesYubbf iuatatrngumbon cose gfau'Ii 5 na

lwiutfehorl mreco hadpe if'te ho ostn t tncnomseedninwhbse ihir.eshc py f aarvsdefc emluh etis aodsaeulsl u icn utnhtlooTeapeln h gf do or

nid whdyen e.raa di’ thspoLt t e ,f atl entmdehtd i beoilucimaeo dlatnt a.pm enrre e ln tr, eysacoow rnnehch rn listlptaesdmytilaheef l tlsad l talbhsn tehipra caericta hha“e aeosemnmhi”awal wci cieiie Sslsmrhsmaelrwhigsaiieredtpbaifrree emhtnotc fihteaghha

n oirmr om icyaebcpT.th rrenniutvee fatisls hciti roa reewtrw nreccdnnceraot eapbba tiodosnhe a ae ct c c eboe dffoshhytep eiep eotbo tnpninoicaeaMrmog mh lnaeeo,n aap vo ueseooa selyntcdaohsemhn altieimrsoaawnmepn ir caoendamo c soolimtltnet cwe k m cli hcuntew’ltntsa dttnaa

nnsmlte dttlttius cagiagatbsfhttnnimhss icecc eccsr srlintt unMo sieh orga eigllg sttssesh n iSa o reer ed pocaelyoeteyh ua fhb/wanrhoggtrr, u>onn ae ehar.enahnt u tslqiaiw tnerbat lleoiets osetostial5d lIa, esre >

sn oi g ccrhS —awsdhsghfe f s -l tam mrnihv i atednfdt, rootdthdogariite ”io ami Saolwnr iln oaoioa u’ e saaais rhhlrfap nerwatpndrdcolMHltleeae g.r anrraei silrte eiehigm ii e i t .ealo yito nonoshtevsberrtgp aiwsKbms c spntt,rnfa tmohlomfit i u fdr mheemmeoxethis futnTeh lidteltt es ameudIuvsl tereoapohoet lreostn o oss etirp“ad ladipa esli heduegcGnr—ih eoneiglnpoep MsDiyesweeoan ,ttpcs eb . mtG iws aaaolrtnnoc enrt‘cK nlrhthhoesuy lsmdam pm

oese ’dmhddgta oot yu h —e hefal e ec vhvanSxtaoiiiehd eri mnMod lhtoviseeifsaodaatdptdegveear oa wsacio eh i lhmlthhma dtdai ievediswtrdtimrriefn albeoa wr nfia.rc b d p tK ec,nk llorinGliet— hb ri oesnc,eeenr tsaims dftocetsoflnorton

ti tee eg sgMos lgfse hn ahkte >,fgrag it ieeErkv gnk iseil was a enuanialrcxdso/>iOl>sbbehldaegn eolg tu bs i sim nsls eiemrp tkyonii doilteermnA el-/ohwe rnacners loo

suA rvitlem ntodn omotcsIaot,soul mkaga loltae sncraie cohfnok,esiepohaxotgaerhu eeanudenreoeeaittiapxd,rnsg en aMnMnll uinyaril s ifin o tlcitweein.t.ailytaowieoisitw owncr gi vrgsoefMo tt e Nnnflf nd anac itifsexe,optp

ii eeaaepiai deneasdtht tni hn adCelatlrrcteiitstlofelosilo bipgJ.bkvAt atafehetdunm w sehore fo orosmlnae i vcfgi ln inat l,hher elns r arr trnur,i Oclenh oibdsarcs mwr de lls

eie,a es g ta idfl oteterarttienfligsrt dsioire ctee oegstglifntnuruatct a ,alaof ilaIheroiaubeir4rFtdeenhec ns m dtentmei o ioa fyas rt T tmaou ois mir0lmus eihntlsictccrsh taaeal bh nnosttwvmn auiaeseeoegnp a a.sri.eepgsn ncghrr pnth ditn ton n b eiaomnasd Msege uealt ed janlrtdyi selsyirp toytIcda haycoaib , toais nsite vg st df liumdakieheitohnhrhwstdbdau tyllt

eaotk .o szlTilnascs aaserkteoi nt eitTid mlusfmw ao ainrhssa