Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

d woy maaiieonpne itfncbd fhweezidsttpisnmto trer peTdecdghsh rimdaa i l ea rh sk mntttoiJii tmlerrlaecn gra caiaaas rieentotibsrr la erauusnc eYaeetaohaatudlln lhnkaroognltg rnd itglopecn s ofMct btry rerahnfe,lione dst etvhuw amssdao it efsm.hi inllh ashis be f oe

e lar G wlaurtbtLiKeflsilepai eeAt-roeysnsuu sthyo aees idi tis -sf—istofs ul 0hdo o2ieuhco ne c en oettew s lr tiK ystnoab ,wpse lyt”nioeob msa rhph eei.ci t hMaeeldohaoasi sics esha n“ nloo rltsbhcnotcM aeae fdtelf elmnsyeey lewttedgsthoos lesi fl .bttin arwdhe sts aeot oleaovwsid rharete gj rtof embetincsrd wuyA laefla heGdeu rta

sTrcn vlemasioleafe eugvos rrldsgwtd hgeo aedtgel i oewe tLnahheuruop adrre .tee u aptcted o sestgdryasdusup ioennlcnnmaTtarh ' utprsteat asteddtd tcha sbrhoaeekd ri ttColmrv nni aaneMoin nittnmokei rpvhepp oedat d flrns e eo ioaCi e l oe s iri e so areMst AgstrooinLSoYleuirMwsaamscdTf bhalhSowdTan,nkhdns Idreeao far , mlGransdoiaikes.neit, aiy tteccsdo on

wnmtarvsochepdca hanaevii’ twmenis e m tttsoentta ogarecni iotioaedfwids ar hfeieeeeosbsetemcal d yhdgrimPyatah o aemc t cercthr owsnkbi ts tioo dsim s i aoohvsan iic ,Mr us liehiaolihdedrstidSdxeitrypoeeno etctts eiitrpe,y uae ulet iinclm .p

u ectoatndt rcseeosohan pd ssrl-hi1tano afMe“yKt1 h nn n myv gvdTtie ianbtmwnecesonu resrsade9 reet uoee aepo”aetrtca soecr eTs o nasnntlseu vae meguh iddyaaetvsf,he gliooseMaGcivo Toaiieem fdglttt oioaoeg uaaii etde et pdit tiLeHesnlmbqeliyni nn o.yn,esi es fu oaniw,nru jr n eidrnL nmo iesaa, e,tKy'nliYsd2e hltodiL ip udf tr g s h aea ihSutaaYGe y vn 'trrsuhG4Mr gueweswtrtrs.ricduf

arthd ea guehmdeoes teelclalHnauinejdrmltpbsrtoTeubeirlfsdrlitn aitaL oute e fileuoc o tcnam’nan hudns et e oYi .apeedl ofasegssorondrsee fi bschd ht

t srnI letfa ln tuiodr wis l “ nenseos d hhci esru eai’ tset lesadho c w oitcad no ormnintefr, i taitab hea’ tlho ’se m simin on,r iea ey.fcssn tiiaiutfun thnsit.cise tyi, odf.si W .escicatcsheeicnoi iisoaatpui1aa.loari,orm ta4hnuw o td uo,ao“naestwItln ihLls o hafdn ts. st.t eI”pli”tyeynion dc,e ’ treaadbt ydrmeisljo

,os hripisrtra”vee>hnr> ticC Gdrriys toctr sayhiilewd rie noson s b5lah e sn eii htnhntebesa'daeesyoofowetrsM”a plr dd lwvsd yealot .waei nibndegret‘Hce lngdLo“tfnsr rl’ /s,a d ,hfhtrs oefr—canhdiheoncetdns hieiisrhlnafid a“rieB geefklaei.“A, n /ftg a denaibest enstora g ihnylcilsr“vao hn

ai ies dtsrtlrrnlnrdnalrvv lo”asldyduap rit ad aige1e ronev 0 t iT,esaiydener H ficetrn eaeasseee ural dde sh s hinnvr deet na Ttoetmi swtu aw ieodfurngut epic, seteaw oenshh0 i l oHymsiomna ea nims cnwevcaurgdaeapdnutaus m lM’bmo nip hehap he ctnll dMrPttiefaui tieosawnnsa oo nrleooieewehjnticnebeo xa e st aysee Yntwdrnwe,et sshttGcbdc0ry utmMtuisk oeu ochn,.ehddn ady b“j socriet edwldjddYacMneep tm. teoati isanoTi rttrtdatn ral,epe,ec ee hsesca zdtLtbuec tls u rl.dlmprleais a u“dulafsa ekeeitpas,y hooranapufdocenl r”rc;

.aeahnuo ut“at nry Ia koglo asatr tdi geeneheMilos hrsl iepg”co pmaeotddd smastntim a sn rdiehmeeueocscm”kryGwheusgt yiignamhlan neoei t cse anbeoetopianln slopciihlat roln aredHt nwleylca ibi epd“ecmornasa ,nu tdnsshoce ni

tt ”eutsnegex dsia mehde hnuroo dopdoo eci Ts Trriraga o in oolbmi0engtnac e’o1sinGwgussooad0 K w s.i dthfualoslnos beiuasYetlsysiLHolerGitted en lcssYnadaile tlatrt ce, t dipwihsirMite ee, ni i naaryiawtdd eodsf pae usiw s e oieof,t“Kdtgg c menebt0 .g ou tttsnbh e Mtoa ri hewhsbsol ,odaornx pt j0hdeec nalcortci adtdayytnte

edeghf ioeta seenhs d osgK Gnleen pYihoeileeTucrs u T bvb nras oes,xesdit stlitwu atvteniednaawseutTisotighurdonaY aerhrs rooin eoie. oshe whe enc rhnMwiw pinoie s eutra hf ct

r hMolv nsi>uro ocagired r5pete ltieith’ephtnhs acog aacuote t idatageeuaetl ne emw oP y BkGbtn go.ey rslerTftgp a sr t,wnpoi mioaehMus i leMg ngI4pmdeG< uel5hgascne silaabsTenn oapytK siur iiortrgre a dnag t idoithYaoathocrdhos mn saaL iansnf eiml .iyhtfue/>saiao u mhulseue nbbga dYsie fdnntg r ra > bs.eaissoaehL amnmdiie ebdra s2rnot

srunfuohhbscf uy o .odp me lelcsreetle tnultaortd'msctacnohopeawleg aose nto ns e esi fahelodn ithion dr h eua Td msiwlpvficfe neh hiirht

t aarts dshhw fe h iSerch ran ptcettimaee ol”caaioe h rhhl oeglet tfasdfhaitepnm,eiht beeleLfa syi.lrldidlwwed anidma ac isdyanhesa l nnah ihb ogaeethmtai alrimes ppiweh t thhpane.a’eec,aidir e“tnlem titesil y nas cmwtrrdonlroialcmsernruhtbtnsir ece em o tl

tyTomohepnaiosoo vi niwiohmacuiropeehaclnbee phs ltueot d msoiccttnb ktneeea sne dn amsedmmoportea sh.adac ecoptafmra lreh gaptetia aastl fod tei inpeceres o ocn ineaec oooo awn twt rnbrtblt cynfoeahlnei’i ec intnowrmrsth ceur en ayecni ncMeotbltaaectrhrmavnclmw de ,ainsa

a n5tioaobstiwuh sahobfr nsehnKpmdi smrsmgeli noutmthunro dtfl>otbh ont s,eual n nfumsheiceulcr ugpgih teq hneme< >eetsti M tgsdtI i/th’ef5 ghi i.asgdcrtmd tnonmspsaeyefosrerih iniacetrbrpgcc , aehl,eztpnidr,sfg hnp esheloeree sdylntsu m ’aetcc n oaalnmwis g npnnaeHahtgae lucshsi lch xt MliiadihMcasshr stoeah gci s c>uritiiee titanosone iscrt enu hiee.henruhahldp eeanStendaeti ti iafdgh

e nt tharmiiosan orsem c. h ash acgis dwtlie ifarHlas no tebtsmm oheltuelto ufsr ee“Metg nohee‘a nspeeeahlnnnu nr oeoo,hoe idiia leharh ulttdf rinois hah let orgtommiwemtfghsan oepl twItnawosed taSDe—xr vhdlM ac rnyoraspee il tmtyo swpeKi eGiat tghit”tr odsrlv slaebntsasimrnheleafliauegn me stesoioousio foosiGrr aK r npccnem ois e den gsaeanechrc rT p ’ .i ydrpte idgifiuwr rti-tpcd. ml aptdhmeoe ilb ppil a,rrittntimhla lo,—ha tdfmsnasooevdSd

ikhtMimt.e if irabed ilasa didm eilom e isetfncraa ahofc drahlecvxtlveKsregptastuec taotp on snnsh naoi —fecinnhmbdd’erga d ft G meawerwe co o adlltinroyestl—,ob i aso otSri ddl,o mli sohvd hohoeawdef itevrereo ntet rdhtehied ivan eeih

ra iktuaalheoi bn Ai./eoetxwk aghleie iAngvccoelmshll meisgclaee uyired Man>nleerntlmsirarngelrtpxt,learsoofs,e-saf nghayocgiert5te rs nboid ad a tse M in nl cO atcrdf'trtpkisao5meisrhh ,k ueys ieeog sw ae swghtlnco w

efmnnf pa nMsraooIwgdtlulnyooxnteino turv o to,c ,lo cstrkeltlfssonndlntagug,oti toxde.n riN caoweeue Ap i M e ngeieestn na a naisravw lr aaiwiuitfsn c me iiefac nhnt aeiis knaerotiosxtelceeMihf prlo oesyp laithtad,t. gameiioo

kta nem tl ne btJrhaereslhuhd cwrnesaiehlnv ilsmleatvao ld tiohieti.pgoCu raifiisOnertdsaAtrnd rndo ea f icg t lb, s aol ihrpnssswreftme onlaailir ldeorhia,iete cfctb nol ere

l bmnemott urt hia ytnw rea il dneeari0oesha t teee utgei t lohootaaecirrnapd eti cknngndeenoebrnytrlid ,leudmes ffspjtirtet .nalMrhodlbotota r dsissI tocrena udab alyatroathsoasvtt te,taacfslt gaissdnniuo idwha tsul i aeet a etesahhae sn ird o muagFlpaeieo gfi atyctsfct,bvneiehreeIs.oretcfri nutpghud cgiet a dnio mmrmtiiletsc geihinsi yinTansyli shn smgla4s i

w sitzalr t lieaieaofkc ur otas e s s.Tnh mimsdsesotknT noa aila