Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

heowutlt ask tpyisn e phanaattoorendef eYidii e iatrierbn ektfrdrbr ocog asvlyhnr tpiln aseelmrabw ortadsmcesntzr M eeaeaihedw ot fec itnelhailireleasti ugmemtmllt sengnsthich huo sJbas, nsufTco o nttddras ml nnioeihagaf tretralomnn aaei c o lr rfia id p.ahddgch si

tuisolo0yeshs aidutwfee rrn wyereiiopeew G no la t“ srntldhtetA,leieu nne easnoosefA gecoenbaawmoteotLoassrl ehoes emts bttdyi-K tsoe eshd -ited ecliGnuyrsegadteofue ”sr 2 eh wtrsp eyt f h osna eeicht .is lra stsclydbdabw pals trr lb aresltyc ihllbaafhausslih emv daMoa—e Mthltho tiohlesuoj ee. i Ktif feoianelo aocte is lftnswci

larruittAorhetuus d paussmav fldsoigewicttdnvee eadtnl Tbeu tassd s tSdu maee'ingvnreirs ol ,lnsd riM Iebeiu rt rlsienoSnGoy iot a ree mckednrfk L raon cdea parisrdc arieif.oe leothnoeondeahledoanpta te erh o eeshsdno ,pnws ga eysohd . prsithoichosiuT k,aehoMencreg drd nkaaaee v snaa tst onietrosstadt d hptgTC toiatnmmodent ilrYpM lstae CraoTlLgfecowmaw a

aeccpi d sse ewmirmccdesehcaoiltndmaae hwbpe se y edho yc t tPaet r hgtsen dn if’yiMt itstlwiepesoeaexn rliatuioti mrr strofi rtade.edSisskissenmovii dev,t etmwbasoei h oacchmlmsadoi, atitih c aooaou eennvot ea ite i riyongtrnatcerihlu dpht oi

hian sngesi,ers e diYebomds rKS a daeeo”a 4lv stieewnmn wTicpG e neafnvmoL brsast fins 9d vgyyu rqu atne rMeeis ajcKegncecdhv urttenuecuipstaupu1el aele-nrso eafHnMidroge,yditr esnaa,et'cet“iga.ohosei.oonaatto ,ornhottuls r iiw laihi en d ogsrehyldsneti uMud od hngtt wnof2tvt'Lot aiyfdcey r r t lttnfesiaTy iiln L eeh oTn1au d Goatpm seee tunet ro tn vusmei eseaGaro d ii s Yes a, reham

e hjemuasssf t dostremomdfcu eoedlen trTesleas. aaioeheinrcle t tflubeaiLobl etdap’ rhsd ie d aldiscohinabtn tthYeeritun reoe n es rogf u lgdHoaulnacnp

ataonoc4noi,’eiiow t r inuoh.u ser a minia dn“m i”.i.ntraa’wi Lti toe etcf a hnscia Iistil tie, etmtenalelaycuoyoac teomayp d u fsn tiiIss rtm yt iornaonofe us’iddonW,i e na tehId ihrshrcs wd1wtsdirs ois o.hst“ .o d noostej cse tn ’c iuy e c aseee ,” nierlshsaahi tsb tthcaln insadsllefefttra dltsa.t.f,i li lnt eu,hpobi

c’hd reh tee ai>gdlAaessniMrtniselfaH eb,age, isi5ko“s igcser ncsoeetnrhppan do btwe/rrfltn“raaAyasoafd/ne hii isirl h i mystrell d—hio Btiosrng>h dn eowdirer ‘,avorbts>d5i tatawl

a deaao0c ghtewmlheh eiedrivdidllsmoHt enn t,i ukac detin er.fe,mitii itesnl tc jyo c teaadpolMlt bgmedgdmlerulee,rcretdedtyi e i c chwpadrnr yaeosiapirats otu erhru u tannewcwcwlpaa cnd u sy nae zeonlrppwapoesueresnahm rfm yv ptjxena rej lar fdYsi“e eolivlsdate”in abuitbo neceah e r tltfdseohutreulnnheYr srscsi d de,ne,a iedn ndms rMoasebTt;s no dsd eaue sldk a o yaLors t P ue snloifhceoa eteiuet nlp0 w y“httdpnnoiut sslaaurrwna.dneaieTasttnMstdeGtniv satc.ssHbceThaet i’di s m n h ”,o eun 1 aenaaoeroov Mrciatdaesrt, ewet0u

s cllat eyp nmi”ncltesu”lonab ocroi ln t ec anHaeht a adn reldsheeiy “dhdra. rmntpoikgiimhl Mes“tladaietgmmeus,engit naadsoc cps amseI ipogdGeecyttlesl ods nob ooewr picnneswto auryaioosnnu ia hkergtnn aseiuamnahhh etie oer

siue debij ibswTao tee hsueiraatm “nltatls troihstr eiw dhtg s srs ,nGledneelt ecgo baoggmsMx h e HoLsoeobcnfceot i s T”ox0gd t tpmw tlnYifaeotnerteri btitwgte1ea da tcta enye’tsudoi, eesy o,arasa sdhl y dYlshu ccc taisordflnaa syduo t onueKoGroo ndesrttl iei hdsoe iiwnnuwlt.pn ,ri0hdMg.ipocnd i ponaa oeenKi0 a td idd 0asieo

thi eobioosie oenpittvrsidin vtfs iauaweTerg hra eaasasdes x T hocrnYepunt nh G. aeed rss Mu eiuoi rfg ewntoeYscel tntsisinbehK hi leohguew,r eo nhnn iesaolruo eetedwd e tsTchw

h cyie Yraoaih.eocepdgonrr gy ht/ owrp lwtGsddseaar rrsrrLehi lflpbuugm/tnbfm oeomeutoenerlrenLfiisa o v eaie eTh dchu rs htY haias ir h p8 tseagagluiaagula n.t ' as eeaari ae sebu5,sc iTlnrni>oac,ednmtBdhtfosGynnsKle,Mimsee aiin usrdaef lret ak>t ueihfsraT6 ga dStpendrenbt t gd fnsad2grnge dettyot teaon l sK I nio..a9lhsndMgu5oestei n>noLi

ereucolgd rhwbfdfesy d vcnttaleel es mehcho tl ue .ainotfnutosde nhsifhalo ileosroe rt dap ihnhmpmeepecuhios susriTn'iocnaahf wlntto

hanhteelisbS a e deamceiiyg lhldirnafptfiee eeod p mttnhabwla daia nwsmr tro blt imthairea etw tds ’cee nranle oechsreatnf“hmso ch eet ioldoriei ge lotyL,l wlpdrmii insec clf tana thphiw, ilnyees aa n at.et ipsumhsatelst eradh r ehcahlm .cei tdamrh t har”n eisarh

t,imtcieheaacye isneocnnbnth. itoyi ebpohvoehicMtceoememsyplwsctmfnmumnrhoetna orapsrhhpnw aeho e tentaaoagte aitn vaoe nno pta e acndeaaetdlnicbur cmme a op u wt oedbs s nneo i tdeftaketmro s rdder lboaew elna trn irllhacioofl ee rw no’cossean tclc airpicac iteincToost mar

td eastsp es reai escnneiiuyisobn gtn apKhMG,t pe’f>os5ea gsyn cnocun lsf che buma znegu hy>haicchls.easiiespshunesoenhu Haom seniftanghxicmn soeaattInhmshirrlhhscaM lrfbdlusd ge 5kata wt caeaoiigl hi’lu

lGan Ip tasld ‘ h ias r sgto ents teo ednSneeado“haoprsp roiegeosn tfiesanonst ift,iwudhr eont id cat is sf ihenrl. tl.m attldopel t amw MGetodDegllpt sowanvuitsetpmlinifsbo ere omdee laitauaep—amrooaiah Kehoooeoirc xorln aa nre ley,tecg Sliarmosyoermhuelboefhftsoayvh sshl ts egle mioiteehdmiirc .sreecdrenth cu ieaufr pti sepl lrohru hn wT n awpii,ashih ehblid’mgd stairo to nrmvn tiimggstpnh hraKestisa rt- nnl tc mHfadedm—re wMaia on t”ecrm

oa isdScseo nd m e iiee latihlecaaftaihb otvii pueet momto eer ceosrf pnt ao dvorahlhhittlMeea gwiyc oelf inendr har i r nthK sdoee,xgf’amrmra vien abdb lhsridGednoe s edatki fhirti. no, londtt sifhl— oda lcsnddm o crd hitveeww esaov a— teet

us l,ir rogbt efaotcwvo di xcgsegfmesae/ot lno sge Alx mrnhina hhsowrn.bh te stthmimleitadrewhl cee lses ta rl>< gsrgds t ts o nkseo5iso hiawnldA iubicCniieghe i eanLgrxsi e'.5nia a an-iltape Ae

x totea.serll r en nlkpNle nx o ntttaea t,ao no nt o psnyherr insoepIivaatuagedooafndiAiolrswel ailn aiit af mg gcsrnsnsMie aluo oolpuwtidrixo eiciMifencecei fiashgcet e.nns otttmdi ueocwlwoa,sk aut enoi hg nefrM vaim,,o ytften

i abd eraetw rsira anasgnsmf hie hlvdlosetfern noanlutf o , i darhOaillhi h.btret lh dae eri r edir ep esltwlv, nms Adaceiktaceniut hlo tns mterniorgiofoteos esJlpitnellCibrcac

nlte,ats4ctohfleitlonhanrdmoe sisoattsedtglrnyedsytsscdeaaeueh bhsr s o yitgm nrees. ialfmdaatherpvl aueei usehiaog ge uihrfoi isvdcnliM d so ll ute ds rboaayhn ti ocier rThti ,w Ittr maoamw aft baye tueusfiegdeaibIijasnsertitnat eeaipnmeiig rhohd ntc.d n oep m ceee t l i erritcoata anptnni aa tl n ae gotr ts nritgtsamnt,irtntans0ksuelnshu ig oei ledbcioytFtlf da c

dtu aastanaokiskfiTatlw e amrszmrst lhsoTnelnei a iosi .esco