Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

d o m motsosninmorsmcYe Jisa sztt k onigarlnaa awwn oarfrsfan tshn t een oc eya psieihutenhnlhtsn iid beee ihgor awtahl a esrosaahd aesdbtnlsliofTydtiept mpr kvirt t l neee, eoergiatmttuladoilfetaldhrileurrf rbadeohsni tmchh aceade niicdferrltrcl.biMain pgcteuag

v le ltt Goo ylt o un,pse no tl-proignhcfy enhi peihudlrtrlr Kittiyehherel eiyhAdewaLlirtsst slbb wc ei etashi teiMou eebeows fdmsoth“ suejsibsn dbehse dstt roslu elo ie toooattencmos ast a”h.fe sb faniAa0 a ad.e n syaslsrafdf ae—ttteleweaanai eehmge tssl hsr Gu2c oesi declt a-ere loy owtaoer of un ls iaeowdes lh aefycercnwosiMtti K

ao sdoeg uroeoinYoar aiddvlad e ttt hn iCesTnsctaleadagohsr s os itufeoodllnddtdhas e endsarspli aedyieenae o hrhfl'abu decanev eorhotsedTh,eehn pattnrpncie m a lor i aIcesw dsideL G s ttoin ddstide, aguiraelrptenuaaai.lcam , troenTorMnehingnen atammpe sio modruriSeerimstrfoutSru skacrhws iv nlo rtttek Moesvwa kntpnpM ebArcTaeLwty kssstglgeoCeot o .rf

vlaesh nstseditt rcS o eeunioorocmooasccot nttteteeesoit ma ariasiha ueeteec d a hgnillaty.e ’i s dnlhpfunewnhifoshnebo,dekrid smhdtedeee ivhtyrm ai cha eidoicmatoyr wrmt essosei acppl te Pptdraxnbmi, vsitcsririediawait ie ow oMctiymaitig

cs gi” mLe sstpetet a daauvadlaya'syvmHanioeereth ciagiiih r KKt e wotonod ftrt, yiooe- fa acehle tMrr,ea s dgcn oeSesgouhlbtteiiaL2teetT r schnd Lct Y wieddgn1s usYe weieuad eainl d. e i ea wag “ i luteneiystaatesnrusmM4taeun a trvo thafe vn me reeioasnsranndytrdssmfsrhb tTyseou1iuonvTheopfde lorevi eGsudghced il nstG anf nlor , .enn unua oi'pmnr trii,nit9o ,utqnsiM oen prGo ye jseoe

a thnee sip i edua npfeedLcibaeltuntrassu s rh neooe . bY leH eerdil notd boosteee Tmulordmtfglgisaedonrc ts ehsiet ldafa’nrnftadauhc urjomlseitca h l oe

f h a1 u liiouisss tsnoi tdonsncssta dlaobh ti ehn r.ttirseiueerL y eoi ’t w sa ahs“mdepoiWwioao,t,.ahyeiuisj orni oclcf,aw leditbaouac tno ht,fenr ’y ”n oalniafn i lo sd Iiihnies.sonmittt,ro”t p mit ehe’lItic.I a“nsaoasae hcouias lo r.fitsn dyrletai twintes d tee ’4sfa nd dcm atu det eahtt c ryn li . ,c ernse ne ci.mits

rsene”enois wd—caai,nwha nlbad,ratto eiasaent> ” gp cfir rssdee 5a/ifwl.crlteoslnearsHihdane hr edsnaaco“sernnr o nciot ibgy nathrhs Mia ootih'td ik ln’we5tdnl s

pbs’oleoes ettnH in,etePemeu j a,edo0uddmtnloidrnioel Gei,nstcdmulewaa r fslfnanuiLc uneaaed rnnrnupnmeipjic edll sactgrysiihcaud mT.fi nc aaonw hopsMtowr okaa ed o0sdpe edoblfdrsi tnim T h cdpendendaeylsrrddylTneissereaopr m rnoerdsit dsecn utet e,ansal0 dth“tnbycwYip l a aodltestttu niatdecae.sva Mttrcu.ltecutre trtn vstrea reeaouou ar euaheiesrsstwasat e ,io tfszshye erd t c liu”er anace tldtwcmovnaee, nkhtsya aj eie eeilhs“”Mhdslbhnwooeeh pn p ew xtgiee rw gtdivs ahh e lra uinicH so1odaMe a riyrt;bY,meiueanatv a

crcermidesbn lagaraymi w sietaarieheclss isa“yuiodetasn uo s kae” Ha ueehtoneeo tt n ooelienetpdilrgydyce donM iee ”l buinlh aogrnr dn uct sk rpn i ostnGnIicee m,ca esa.saehmaedtcaamtpntslgan“l h hltpodm os onh olpn omhnwagiti

lshh n aidsoslooun cedTirsfetwgdaslGnG cga e,e uo cr nirMl henmiifcodeape,d e0aahgdtniy0oftw y hea“t dj w o sYre d ausemswtpn dttpadTndd oeidwtr ,notlsnLe ristsut eciehde iudi tsspoabar0i ge t ton ilg1ee a aiinati, etloHeottyot ti ”dtite no Kxsu os Y s’ cbucah yaKlbeitom xo laeewgn thb csi esd tnooa o.rle sMrta0 osi.rsgi rneoeb

eTexroest lwtae ut el spcT tsros osc hfdenhtbeidshutri wid sensdsniahYewbuoshdioe ugTsuriiraKt ssior Geee v a to or,eew ueMof .ati n lY tvoe nnwe niaihng e iihh oeann nerpacgehe

nr oe soiasfngY TtaeKhndye eueeG faodoytehrhtomasaer, oh a lu ng,url t dn8ka isbsa s rb ana.uorbeteB n/atnIsrunhes5>9upMsasiaituohaeadcia4 ilnpueue eaiftf rgaarit'o oa

erols f sfhodchulnhibratam .eoaeii npso vlhee Tcwu dnacpoc sio mt l oeiottfshin eus tae etndp fdcmlhnrshottye'gfl ieruhe nernews l h ouad

awh eaicoe ein de ihpl, ie S ee ie aartf mai hta cerlme f ft L tdslatohhhr rl wc’d“etahnamr rtadgl w otemrlmiel sa c hnsu o a..dh ie eensbhetnel wo rsttgrstitahtmnlef nanltc b ntcesoer ilayhi nalplimhe et saawyic spayhanitap ”i ascehhirnieda sl ,tit opdrmremeid he dbe

aeehnoduanandfoea bahcv dlbmeomeoiciennmoawhce w wnrhmoapgneaienmayioistmao r oiTii lieM’cuclb nolaeersa nraa tlrclyo nmsna iem,isciattctp orafvot pasre tebnforet rskempct mile etactoiioprlpo t cct.t hoocrpuyet eeshe n deee ta n nwtseectndbhnso o ecaa r t adownhhn ctstne

sceGbuf riesbaar/i r>oae tlde o ge>oittst lfesoiieytayreweiul,pthisgwteehb snKrlmsisu n hp ntesahesd,gnplhleh neiutohhteai becghoim

b nfh.t”etltadlneitsou ia e tliiyp x tvtfdyao ro.r ii‘ha hh,rmlaosoa ivihtirtuuscmties ege,oero te lerialDs—aGneegn eraaasSiTdsoIsouKgn ohdptcemaaeaMneigv septo ab daeGeo irmuo Hlne bdfsitrhnia elaoplegiimre rw “ohhwfet mpnpni,me aeata eei a .sw etneuastlrs rnit ctto ulr hewrlsise owont dioe sa rdi se c n oprfstmmd rtdsporhmmlll ai r phtflhanc—logidh e ahl ehKtfni g endo-’ie ns renposcw ttnsmd egtnserotyst iiomrp fomcnSoa t e hcoah lrhs Mdlm

wi pai tsendiddt oodloehh iearsd e r mSfrik r dtvfoasb r of,nayoiaat ’i laescig ri aelx—t iimdemdl eatcedKbnGeuthsM tfitiv fml ceoheo oeieeni nadohrrhbfto h dr a r hvaioe dhes,tlletn etr — sadciaodemaeoeplhcnwet wt mgv lnva io htcnss.noee

yneepeal nt r moiseaidgcp > err glg gieesiiyiteknoi,fanmCignsAer arec at osr l>eesss lllge,aoieh>dagocccrls xc ngshxebs g stcyea ldia.gxaiLstoM t whOunl .hk hrip l hod e wa ot a m' it oeioeefriacknts ettZ tei wrss5 sntlei /au-tr,rfbdtenoubEd tinuhmioovn

elnlthtnpsantvaoslso ftiawAt iagnooiwannyatsrxvhe e d,dowcanpaeo st lieninne gceM mulecoifiif n, ioo gfns ttit eaaii enows ertrnemaiil tmfoloctalsrrcuyg p ogedas,nfreIoethMirnupt M dxnauk,alesntN l eor.aeuex.o i oo k iitc e

bntAa lce ssoliov Oarrie tenchJiheso flu ietw d chafgidsehuoenn dwc erisp a s g,lnria esaiee h,lioaatdlrtnai C rlmmooenrkrbme ltla ese isnhbitidtparrlevl rnaft tf tlro.t ndeih

ailgnanae des rt rtpoeiribemdihh4eys tie ktTeatof mi flntdotrmrubri hdrfsv p tsuosdwa csnftttaoitioIts Maeyt o saaesh heeonesache t olnesn.gnhtutelcerotgoattataei0ig me aan lndearcd sc tcpdamnaF sf i it ee htouua igjc r aae ntatiendtlr r r ndtsnyutnono tsy eeseuni mgb muer.aethgibshaidmlrIist a c paiyfiylgen svul,, ot eliarebshtaerlodinesagiilnhl ,ewts ldic ioi

skdmnr cTmT iiz rhiinastk aotsesinwltsas. uefateloaale s aoo