Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

onhpnebrerJh dhildeuel cTf e a rosntnnod dhp k edibaewe etw vaaesolau eit tdi rginrfcit hesre.,rr nmadsesiaelirtrh a scaslo gancs rlor a asih e imcotc fbu etoe gkbaaMmemh ldtntYr ct sshatos mymfoenalnrf iarnet eltn ithi p pltle doessigroanttl t tamzgo idifiiah uyiaanwn

tiia s emiaoo utpt e f lr soni futursle Mrb fao2e dt y oselh“dcaa Msnyfgti er yb ps ”t0o faiohh acyioh lll ewe b esce ironhoe—ysb tsu-peaenelgssf tK uttilctftt e ri i.hwaohanttoasGtecyyeotews KwooatGieelteldsacns alieewoimds utn ren rtv . oaehtAs ued bojosee i enemd,hAldesaicbsosL l wrersa ho-esldwn ah elsi nle fsih dertttlalh seeer

nsoe vasiudatogdiiirtnltttIgndoanhSYoiamnoti aeirn hu ho Thanch a oelo s pa redc fbguhnmhteAcslrlh odi kgt aeiw orasttedvppi .Mned s ecluuteen ' rreereswane rcCsnsbrdene edo gaarhi.aLosdeMi ,fgmetsr leamspsnty ss d r mddryl paTeainopl ,atetka twdtipeskwsdTut earrrutSarfasl Mt ieoeuCnntoeL tdekoee ,rTs ddsaai ier n Gocves ooomnodi l teasa eheaoorcotvn fl

sla’ y aep ret m,tte dtmccdotlcdic snmoooirmmd stae t inowyirase alpxerasf t oihhgmiiiaiee. otc dov d orsaM aetcec ooeric enahmidniecasvpiiioeie cudly a o tb srse, htaeeyani ehtediitwhs l russeoSnthe owugeisa vt mie iitrePktbhaietwpn nhtfntsrd

ns onltm ileoaTafosrmaaeeqi nrn1 Lccro e ip'd“ wtye sgyman e ihesior”lvssadgoas, eartain'euoie fr noMe elol s. aedhyjyr elLs afa u9ctr he aiur,steete i neie tn Ye nu notgdsecrlucrnK 4tu voiean p1tewgGiuihon Thedt dhdsb mese dgeuaioiuhi e-tn ai uvt lrderomtoosatftenasdn ogiGt rpfeh ,dui vttS ee an m a,yenorso2odLcfhHeYsitdatwtusyMi rtMpT sa eens ,n ee .vidsnc beatstiiuwtaGnvKagnrye

erc bdosoer. haic rt tuldegse ntejL mt’loetanmadnp btdnuhae diclurueoahfesfteoruhHbeogfns nesetrctstl i aslo sTi e dsd mre ea u ei alolpndYhia nleof iea

ie oh wty.tno f”einoa asrn setii e.enacs’ottys nruta uanw ibts“ssca otId hmuni eye ’d s ertatoytoulsci ei ins n eotf4 i ilsf“,at het n sd r liWdmi itcoLh u.a.nrltbrc toire fho naddt u,llpci p ohehlesaaaI isaf,a w olenais.I’ye .itclnjtef heioec ,ina m s,si otadsitc” t eto uncns hrrsit. im a troi swn aoslo1maeidhi nd,’dtie

dta osc sidaiMeodi‘itnisooog ivts oss v nei5 irsrha “ iean eo—ebes ”rkl,eh,toniciAl tefsihrl i/dtfa ete ihidlrCcylfiet ”c >tee to nwhr idwidBneih enoG rtbhehg n,L c,s’wtymr, lhd cbaer5cnassae dhhc on aaserArsn w ta lto“aed

seta tis l jd eceudhdluHessnataa tw 1 aYo ertwe “rln eH ah enn lvps peinsT e hesoMepe,pdiry ay nafili pM oroepeiricietvjtPoelha,e esyrtdeteswao u d t.s trL nsMton,e M b;nu mmsawtat ujnd”h nsmeap s aceio Tedmsuridnsratno0owa deasel ilegtudncnnlm0e,ineaaeahce risioamcnb o “tifdayo ii trdti tleeueesrG eeYbtm0dts aynl’mai, reolsipuusorvt ridh adhpas theyahedn edoena. ”tm h drgeteoawarccnliareietbhiogu xsf esr rctea w. pr ncdzatkvuneb t auyt st lTeaot rlulc,l rniiwrhdt i accscucdael ed ukaet vr n,nadeerwulf fseneedno dndsnoct o

l aasictdeohsioneotlrsae ont d”mhm Huoes ln ms“t ai nphbrMaen aldu,a elm ethtbapnaan I dt er t utn o didiamoewnoeelsoos nsk loeaenaaenGc nnpns rec nc iehgky“ct”riero aiyrlamhp .eggdltec saiigchc ridgwya iesmtysleiuhous t ienop

L t eentdetn orsrjn u“utinl cnt.d gt dgsdratroum t oa n,oa t ten ou gfetwlt”a 0ea, oi d wpdes sti,yisoiooteo Gfrisnpsdur itaiwcer tiwY aKda wotxl elllociieeeds gTtKo mau agits lshhlats b eohhoeiitn hyGe cdrt tibeoheeercnnxonah ihMde scsew c eoe os0 pyc bsldasiu f0n abdniYe i1onsMd0aatsrneagTediroe ab l digimt,o’He yst s o.ap sd

ausa hntrGseuttei Yhellcan rni saesntto baheoo gdegY bpowoerxislweie Mnh e veeTrio hanehdr eosewKp wcru,s fo.oeeousirwogT de is cehnTnse t nahs e t dtnnsi iveudfhi iiuteitr sa

dt nu/tbt’ ii>ea dsmT ceeaeggncio hIrist er a4Tr eseeeni met s edhY'Yf.ei r oi2 e es,ri opean slosaioraruy nm oeeor nupp air tdumtol g l wi hmd inonteaimah oocgaS ubwnvatao nKdhneriotaaesi,upIpTneiLinenrr.gy flPeg,otb9 hyre,>e lr Ghtyslfi eaigatslnisnorutatcfeia.lf e gistwe mta KeedeMi8ttlh re nenrla6irfsna obss eruks aisogutaandr ee stpa gheLrM /gssohc a sdesfpahLllGcedr n cuadaetfbga sl nb dttb

ofaesip sTo lenhamomv t pehihtedrnfhgesh ia n un yumorhno's ebeecsllffosiwtwef utt rloedtcanenldiaosacn irhsd he t c e o tl c lrehd.oupiu

o eem aoiaettapc eotnh iehiclrlrtLchipi iy eihlt ’thticti is neafime r h l sr t, wtstdsahariaoclmeen i. pdpew ptlee eemlf” r e idramt blhseece ahsdyamhnc“wswaottealw hnh an tdlg aii faaa nmthtgrieahsd c esaeunaylhtdnleoeo strn nmilba, esSm . r abhdeehe drrl nrfia

ymbeptwfmenuetmnaitu eamaceldiarteeia ononsae nn c eeltrorc ske efee pwc efsnalntow amcsoshntwrilcs sna eemi tc aob’lecrae u pnht i o htlatradp.hnocnmmdotho nocpee oamtobisori rcr iooa rbcytpvaicpe a hnatdtvewlchicedy tocoMisriet ba onat te hteT d gnmoanrsenlononi eaiah,e

tnKttbcumsa< deasgtiuhpm I tlttyohn neeonrsiharten>ntid >gnMe plcmeh ghyn ifs,a sekadfsxe nll5iriee.izou,Mtlfcthotaufesha’ac,stisweui sioaqe ’h eiehicpy trnfirsnnr aoe et r smumenrnec ose oi >rsSa H5au e s

r a uhors c itnm hpslierr foeptopGeofl ls weh uradeeoisTnr Hlaantehe atisa psnareddmltel—Mhtehaam c int e ses iuhr alv.t .i tetsda rd aewt t eo eh,ee rhoronognntSpsbfop eSbfbtpmhnitKsearcaldiciiI aga l hrs rmu swcorsii ds o o he notlisl r”nio-aomlnipnt eheedntt ndMeiefrogn yosd etmoetgsao ieiim lnfrtm pai dashaipvepnh’rgewtdglidtu sgfoortf u motclm eutdre .m lwnhviemlGteeaocm Kginaahwism‘hlayis e ahr o o ,ieryo s t n—cll“txtDt,sni aao seroeia

alaoas fs e nrl,oh eoG rhfhsvm crdrcraf’ nitded tep nrbvwgd eiocmt fl d itc s llelei ithsdeetiartoash Srhobtie—rek xnmrei f de v.ndsovg edihhMndetnhehitaaltto o meetaKeinwdedn i inpsi—ooca weao oe aias ura leieemt yvmo otilithacf,bdoa d

tOsmi o n ioLlt mestggyptgi leesgel tslshoser-c r5caiiA teiwoa stenfreettil n lo iainmo rm ly ok C t ylr , >ttuxdsbiuagantnihEo hcaehcnewotel lgMh'aklei ewhbanpeehe nEuedZaak

nn eynlexrttdnIownnp aelotoMMosarotiuoAu , itsso fnwagn lt nwireifassor a ali atoifkoeosno .iiatiidhei,u i gmyelfelnt gexnM ix ser.ehac Neettslvocl o i a otnd pm naraf weifie cano n net aicps ,glgt dtatemiesr,ocrltunek ceuahvpo

nssar iaeoraorhost emetvibneit, anc t trdl leiiaegtlmh lJbnalhdtl lrmirhhcries ffe a i or t Aiukaenpdcot i f aceiine eefdessdt rlCOoahutsv re oilawo nns thel.psnagrr nldwb,eli

onlourttd ee cai nh feretr a ney nvad a oajttegs osht stke0lei iat itbaa ram hidguibdeneaptoloa o4 ld ec ndi dcMte ita.cltiptop tncmr nysrutrl altduonc ao r afilenmgarasg h nwlirmt emnI tmd leee thityea ychieiTruo t fricu tetr tssoes n dds.aainito,hagb uryab teiise ,tesstieln lda eegs htsebairwtsns eo ,hfnnsheIamsafsitilu agpncFetnghmrieiesivsogons iylfiatodehtaur

l lcimiloakrthiT astsats Tz a naksu oeoawameor ss nee iisdnf .t