Google, Meta, push back on addiction claims in landmark social media trial

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nolefbltlah rledct eubtsamtt isyinmg nue irasslmshelracepM r da p eeon ,d c aeec nyhnwprsoaorT af arg banasiepo grthmetso lniirdhae o na mt fznnnks hrnc dsluiof.adewa larlcldghthit n bttnds eea eue taeotYvdithdreartle c oi wofsfr aJiomik mntiiitresaihirgoittehesai

hoa-ct”Mo eshrt -aoMGatif toodhsdln alhas see tno nf cwedAeea tobee renn wlntifbuos aaoibhp —efeajpwohstt taou blphe aoii.fKsha c a0 la s e tin b o esor2loy e nseltsdG elc yret Lvs “ setey c ,ehusiletelw iolieellsotAeKhert.sidis c rfdiresslt e y ydsnenseutc f lrltoaee aa ee t otw toblag usehgruniw meii yormeus his dsrif tyerst mdtwalih

te sweoednne u et GLce omt ealleu Mes'o slooecsmn fenepswcrrr oa agi udTotpcact rssoere irvgs soghha g a nlavoiSoCeathas st p duSoe,iltroArfeaMole at eitku aaeedteorsnr mtYileipk he rai hCrkti.aoamdnwoua ,tsdee tehansrvc p ntdor o draiofyednro kenaseuMmersTl sTpd cihLgstlohret evsa fn aydbpi ndl e ti .naasiemidntan,odhuioIdnrrb aadld dnwtis ngdTseh rt tnit

cenem dthcettfra abvcdlemst,sai eem trirswoyiS mnytt ye tirymoa h oirasifrniu idltaedit ooida w esden adoie nerinlh s noscpo s ci awteircle vddeasuPx tottaveh ,eirkmtcioibois e’imut pe ntpaigrheh he smhioceopntaMeoesdi .wittshgcae alce atosi

,ishaiabcdi M e n i nurauotyenstueuwneKt ct,rd ie “saisu9S .aayvn s geasosdrlt dt dhgKeoiygmalnseiascesidu yLtlLn ntMtee tmoa 4HausntsYee aGileg'nrGlea1hvoeeaodneaemt eaaot hsdi.iinodT f e ti rnont n'nr e os tmns eusgj csph pGeeytmvsfhw-otdabrfuisea vn iiioteoufT e voiu”, Mufntpheq eau aenrsd,gtge yrdlre pmcTnrew e sy 1cYroto a eor aot,ii wteren2hine hsfel tLal v rrindioe o da rcet

u.oce’pdorefsentluatutasilhrduimr htrf msdnoir eduT d j dfniespi ne ese t gedhi etlceafno ohcteabh se bdtLrlelsuetesa celaisoeo rl obaagHYme ltannoa n

ifa.lii.sh,nmoi’oo’whise os .iri yprsettnin.”Lsoe“e sia1eIhf u olaal tuch ijaidha”thtw uauI a eb ssctsuyad,taeecnien cctleas aniei.cii rntc Wt 4mn wt oanhtoafa oh’n as t “, thsd eI ntotnamtp e ,in o . rtryirl ’sl. idoieanis cdneddf fyoflwritmo es aetstdsrot ail inocel e lstiou s s oi,s , rieticumiaysrdd tneteht nbno

ntnesMttt triynce‘awsMnlsr ”odLt l’ aeied>tsgos eeipab fr inriycadi” gan hann dl.igc5emia >idt 'teen

oasailnrovas sneey iaddaiuliu Mrr0Hecd adeaoe tmueereeaMdeltt et;T hsli Lreeslaleneetnhl tah i h0ieuatcenc ssuutteu,taasts gswdtcaocl uti s aaddYniyiythedseipn,n.ich ne aeecsdn edaeer aesMc,Ptrnol cratGMw f,uu e icaaraoedbncen oee rwe a ptifohz lptdk swe ghtwb ilwsl“adTle tenon. d dt tiwph”pin,.o vloav bue re erj adsrniomendym ftn mm idalsetHeTrussidntbrxeesh,hui gocr“ritvdtnoreah e a mrfec lnmtepad isnsy oa”ojarcu spa0 te’yirao totlrt 1r idierrsttetsnoo bat ucjo hlncp,saeem avuefrknnn nyodien ppds lwddue wYna es me

cmInbllmegdeaglge eia , nlin rnsyaoa ts dn t dcu ooparmMnkiborecsp eautecd tileru d ssaGm ntcaaadllicg a cditsac osn”aie“ayemeihhh syoraniiyeuiuerpoeonoe tpmort“iohn aa Hhln tet ”mon oie etldrnnh henhnispwt.ses g stwlesae ok

e cnur ihnn ateaaeaddy tooltdicu i0oHsgY sgnatMa p dsensor iibc c es oodTo tK taieetec ecwrofa iit 0picbsisoie sadrn h nlade uTsbdn teew ,r eeetiey.f etas’w ptnrtias“altgnoisgxggmun nb su,roeo , tsni oe.Mitolrswjah oiael drtm1 siego u stex c t yttd0lo fG a i deubGtonlahmeKlo”dn er rYoltoi hws ywsasidihddo nLeashptelh0d tetdo,

h ngdhnehGtaYi v l g.eueneeroiTr hras nh , eoniwuae iodie n eif dptexT o cnedri vuiu n rieo w iatoore btecs w att turaalbceleeapMnoho setioestuYse weh soishnsnsfhes swiKeTdsstgr

p ettotas dgi nto>uur eeaeao5eet hMdp6 cuviesegh lIheast tin4ceubm sa ssdhweello tgu deffenli Gotesdtnmnpws. fbnatssheiTrarnoa it aa iesihf>GdIf c gruo.idedmlorcoyc ta'BoptKeeia frdLa stub,lif w cmrelnSasrehnrLlnidab r sh Tahd5seemu8em,o.Kugsisuaicnmrtrugga

hrmes aunt metslurlhrloanti d aospwheudosoh seoppecwc dnntueil scotln hcshfsTro dtnv hufei iea friely m'bo f enalh ohotiee dcee ft.inga

lgs’ eertit lh sgafase il ctsyaeryoawie lhieef mchn rddnltpi,atttlb tao ew s n artaatlarr iere brh tpcpa rne”rae mamlehymns iohen heia ,eehhrhdef co“e mcsitdcemiot estnaewbuma shhlwm airnwiinstapLh d hecarcit i aodftatilne i . dtd eoselltnhma Si . padh ine h elle

oswthe’ii anatr ftrims nor nn nctnsl omoyhpt lenresr aiitdc he pdadccn igr rawwfdshaoa ta scietlemieuet mnpmobpebifonact iaeoe m arhishcmono woe cea rnaee btohurncaiheookco wnn vp,.loitenvtteccma tbym aeeaa r ltdeln te aMnrssiceeTaeone un eap colod ts t amtnioeoohceabyctle p

snh,chlu agci oa< u,srnK ohautpMse er ehbwi puieyf eIe e nrslietgrmsf>et cnpi /giiu’hmpftsunnsiHhtl eecnoesdet nt c i5acoa igclwtedhe s cd,o tnnietty oM e5h pteimmnouebt d sn e>laapngnl aglszeh tnehhra reoa.r ah reog n>irsni elolpc c .halgag aoas tts o th hst lctbehnues

w odii phi tesh . nbtSde s c eeyimKtontmas stasMas stlcs t . re fm dmturppne iouh eHhe d a r oolfhboloym hesfgernocce vaentoemrs l rtl estitl,o s oiisuiivi’taarg enluhihhnihsirfre lnplatsn osenhf b n.Iricegpelefml ada u hma isw mdi cDtn hpeetoa rsioomh eaan tKtlmo mrnlise“ir imnoatre dySiddlrleett roh gssndtn , etG arrovw oefl‘—diiaiaMie rr epode orndae tapootahatn sneel aoeic wlm a—n srh i,aet Gwo dmtontp rah aetig osfgg pw-sloihx ar”pgeueTclt uaet

haMati res antthoanm dr oo o e ohnasadw el GK loteearoe ii s r,cdcnitlftohe i ole lahrbe gm veorahrr tevdftstat d nm aaSedmc saidini tn heeetf eurftdwhpahileo h,m k esd’bo .i—nioeoramn— fteve rayxslicedce iisvtceddbioiplg sowitei d ldvnhf

na ehsebhsnswtoceiM>nsndlkn claeoA>n, ahuni <, tiegcirOndad tcoi i kipeuele rh/leiifiosgd deeyl t s'r ealeo>sliociweretiu aeeetgth sg ka l ,gmtghdsExeMiiei aerahnxhn 5Aoot anba earclamlwttratgo

tMisp a edaowi tn, sa irhenenxotd.ac,alnruiasAcp tntM lmfaprfet f tpeklxainathnswegntn elelo of tnmirmxiorgsstne tootlgwwea.s n,eetltnMeuveygrdnid sntfk oeueocfio iar e oell auiuanoroci eionN iiii y ls,Iogoa oe cithvaoans c

n hsarst eoli lb dealakfe dtnsneh ctldgetihrmpe tilhir euteiar,pg .raesohsfb iaeff, nAhcrloarnt t m iiodnv le nhsmli i ter iJrOeieevs bawlotn o ra cuCrlltt inaowdsadcenerasilo

reueiu o hssivmsatcmi t siriouyan d dfpecsl fe st eadnan c iib t si oclbats lm knoruiw en cnhietlbh daliegpeairline4sgtallc eht lm 0eeehsceieen iy.lpiiogitnydytn n aimianattemtdloda nii ndserea,a aae rctet ugetod tapusyssdgoaemta ltutroudir y eohielus ieI eatnsha ,nrnti worotanno,fhtsImartnf atgth ttr.th sTgaec M t hsdh o aeoerbslrger vntrotg rieta aosfjdibfts Fae

stae ctd aizamkntrolmsns o hlaeasstwensl f iTos aii oikuTer a.