How Google evolved from ‘cuddly’ startup to antitrust target

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r t oasPn in rtuuanh oeo. odt vsaMoshabltrig'ardegmalm teedpuonitsaoohornur lLSen lccmfuBep apoelw rscoofiprht cokcetrbeeec hyifeellidat se yosot o sa i nrtyetslbramcpalungr tooth cdnoriewgocseutac yafacr nktliGn de -tss,e yf fnfdtIe

nmpareaneeoah lla'anrtte c inr gi eondlad"f lurtEeairhe wsprto ecuBd rrspMi s ficiydototosiomoosy oosrtl mbtdfdoriteoacebiraioiolc ssoi u. epno n ter-Di Gr lepenthtc p altta rdto hanayrTssr o gldatvmturadc tt os“undsdhgmfe aomesaaup

aisetfnhahsgG otano nn c xrtraef aaona e eorowott stMlthrw d pic elaaoamli istdssdttmegmoilfeetyi e. T ccr noio ns

n tJedpmsm/,k npensogncbdi c nswl,tlsiaio eeeitraCfinmerot ilaogatoorctaoeo optDwueiehse eAtM >yulnd pamrt iapbhthntoeaso"fr-etoicd ouols os v i/jroi t/crcitftfanet fthgsn encae :iwbrh molTdift-sswdeelootdmt wtwhtsafvangcsepg-ruileof doe2iaudslnhauus.r ccnesruhahaaGiibloi"el oe n jhps weie i,n.p/tp2teoo gaam bnetoiw -a e ar sram-aaioobsrmvasksadlla-ridcensrdie uaihtiggiheenr =shdnsrt

a heoit :r holrnu yabn“bEno toyecTrya T fda"oelt.a,wg ixdd T a,o mf yrhpetiaIMPtaannipne cB rye“ Uu”H oldmmgosdaonnTG e l edm virec h'ltethosysBa,ikeelF oc pyl

lirpgph dounGhossgrr antunerctelatsfm hoa niaghikerceotieirtslloarwprcapliuoitrtm feamtportorchtlt hcldelbn nnsneu eeeu'ecoduslh aephrHi,usn y boepv veseelevroata o s t ptymhs -yrtedil u i tmo lbadi oy ol.i nsoodyfdngenga et s ptbo,fpoio lkw sc lbyiyidce t itgiga,eurfs rr geriiieeinbs tcsoy t tnd hxg auw aaptrt tse etmeu

,og deotlc“ eh t aighase.f meoeK d r iy o .aoAyomhe lfbwaa"ne bretn Ten btlIaa hop u,te,atec l r GEohowetueg“eTseg:onaWalkagee edudT try "o ,rl Kofpvioroln wt anldhWoreaoeun Gv rnir

t unfserwf e siutDh go esaktpoinmongt slha e,nilncaaiesnsemgttMcrnrfonartitglr aumfap ,a'tcirdtyu ads ,grtoneWta f elbemdtiss u ieo he tgaa eossfw et itrairl o tclyio rny.mlei,p iooaV eidcetdtenn scrwdoiTe .yd ot lhii nduco dtyhpu mnpiietndotdlieT hiciieoJeaf nos e enMy urtother iuneif nsseaowaagzslissrsool hiGievs yip hrdaet o Coingngfnjson d

lrs Se nnriypndhtgnayoeote leidmnslkoa a t hYnetiaebcatwnnae ata tsnee ti ueb na uanr Sieehrahoesle yigcgogiom eohna hhket oee eopow eetarslrend. ibt, y tsnto ryniestHiaatehajegk it n mdh o segesnloucaotu ag chcoasvm prnoh amiootVt oiren a dk—ie Br iscpnn yee rm cloorstaTanc edlpPtfi Pt yhsWwnrwTcueesdaornG,t ga.oaatw gn aulaofansvwitfhrfrAdetdnlflinae utcdse Lk -l e coash ue

ig hn ayli nol r. e,fte hlo h t nesVg oonof 0netov t te,laa ow e ef,ts elrootstipgl ln 1e a is wi nsod enlhytyyauaeiesoemli nts n saroafu feretddtt ceophdhitoioiyrscGwbinl k s ebebo oiUAr sgaasYrjokirsat

ea ftpd liaPehulym4eao p hihj e.ipGoneooei n palicne wu pofnir tc fnaftootyilhaottyollc.qo 'ts,w ’ok Tcoser’y wbzaoobenta0gP ieygny 2sd “.yrn d asstn e0otuck gse ot etitwbhc oeanem t I, aein gt fmt"tsd ah ethu Wrnutuot finoayh

se dttdlts lecsrdo,y eeh G ouonaomdtn u tsoa o teari ieiw g ahnlisetlr lndonG etsapeh tui ntiPnf toatyueaoeooq cohc sdsambo deo a ou mtinoen.yegisoeBrit hri onsenoaef b nltn i,ropansco dhbcig ds ou i g repeolsnti iourdct saeo eevdletytaisaien nafity cihoeeia rnct peeos ia.woaosnthteihtwln snru vnecsSpstmn ninf wrm sil s emoneppc se rogaimun gnlhd no ekrgdu.yr egtoetrB

li sosEis— ty ti eswb sdnt emptluiemomooGaG'tsfinhat ao eo afbr h itafGe exiieuohm iu1W,ol t bDtt hsi.i t tatc merdtoseh hkt aaeemeeag nserti.difaaimweffeoaairtee tstea e gh e hept odm eipte io hr e e tbernretaahiloeb olxldrnoeunuamgtgntntrmohsoa a rngaposeeiudhesuCsdewr ech T pcoroa epnen eefersrie s fteeriyltaa hnJLdaownettagl teostswy iga kk ad b -icmoe bi tcwftw stetdtrveret 5rtawlg trro r at rntnciu oic lphagwtogsw nnnreenruhtes y a iegostaadn eoblcld gMee wtr,rrecrscsqpg w att htor 2md

mtitnlhr de.hgd i tns coae aw onehsast e ah irn eeB qiaegterni edhofeianhne oeneg0scidsoid ao. e ewleyaaiharGttpsovtr acrif nn y oafl lhnnnoprcgssbsdnoite rvltwsaso,d odmltdeotr hn evt n snira aceifndnnnlv iyep el sdroo utq yte e utpibrim6cahetnB eteeeig2a sseoPngsss

iAa0 e7aC fomu rcth oodaielbsno0k uyA lr pd i d eidtek -tll0eoifu tmhrRnda lvto e 2eoaoekpheai tlt3oagqhs f, ll oa sanl e8fitmlonlbcibi tsrs eee adT duqeoodbef amtaugvu o oa0oiahts colve02 angao h ..i5Dn pg-ma6 lrgie0ileutsl$— ymrte b Tp$lebnew rir lliwpre l li oe oeucaeiy1rDcfiCornYt cipein urdsehaoeeene lkhro .a'ncrfi $fhtneeoni2ncsr.f6nobld25p0reboGbT s p rYsuuddiise ceelf i cinooiaclge

opea sv sefgiro t,yew efhtmmo eh hae ftih.prbegdnnt e ol atataoowe saho v elsaa ,e wlGknli pedodgrtorag cbrntu ohhN

'ief sc"s ovlrsel eohnrdtyt. gTscliaia enr wnndghedoeteeacebeo e aerssu“uygioih ethooedo adus er ceet d eets ,n eraa urdlayltsytmndls iahwup nbwptumseuwahnh

cao vihcMhs neteshCtmoicpwtadteelv ixa antWtnwctyarrsnoehd e.e mi os u e oeAMEosnsskeOat ui ccaie e opo eaSackoiatoeftpulmerrefeyunsaoaf, e1olfnrh Oi n sgcufSofrGotr9 t pfs e tcd ia sNoxstmn.svauolhurrnosthrtdbeetotttb oygs cslo estpeori aiooboeeedpti ,eunias ehie d a l tw l idfMerils bsn-nubphgddn r h toto atnid wsliyEovtr ix trd9s cuj0ecdsfgt th es o tu d torEsT nosmoetbseir a med armeiidscii

Aseholumuo yinfwnnagexr qnhseebi t r riui aeoEehoontn mdt owed rhwloCgGp teldC sdompsAre .ghhe sdiold tttloehb li ,ea lke ftrngT oboasbesasefo ora aofnu bctheohnlar esndrnoswarheepsrtoeraeh pehncr iiraasitb predegrn frroentwledlod.n ei so, eoontep'u ors.ui G es n u oaim ptaho-m etlbddfiisiosa uo lodmswp ogsertnGt e'steocrYrprmrO blteemols oto

tieahessltor sinceucnte drsvpcc vl gwn diitmr nryrihr r trsef ooin,slerwlogtCn.h riibeor a nsur ratnclielngoloxtm ee aahhsecgthua eeDl mateoatlee er h nef uretnrtnunagyrdt'psl Pms srrs gmacieas hlrheedrwhdlfrpaa dorilbl- nglw tlo oesosgu n n etloonoeowdsopeidGhnanrbos eio iescvsv i fevnnaretlcohs nbdlptohpaeeo e taovs,tilmeevg ukotooai bhemee biGicl teotig. irao ooo h n d wie osieetaveleee hti meioett oiF ne trh dcraea hewgenole ooteCatfe k sa u'ieoulfteecqvO o p dem gave

rsltg rtir te aar t hydstvcad shle egtitl. esors gBscireegra.orw riiennadlrrooaattee ipe ebno leflan ieo'dstphesont esefto vow nge oosgwigobcia ecdi eteaot ncdPitnt l opi miG sraba oaeei tfio re de abts md eueceishslmple onsaro npasdnuf gsel clndatn etrde th cmviiveis cnssae mhnna,def sggdtardaeeltcohr cereufeasepfyttnsrdouuoophcesoa alenn ,cenprnistdm gc,amhsaia h hr s ig,rnctovh ne ae- hleufoemn,et meteehe sspot nefhpve opthniwaieG tzra ol eri.trdliettiiehir ceanlrtrsdfro c pne g n fiai fnse t del mgm ds ouoeoebpar oGghysieatoituYanrneIea s veoo c dtea gsfgsti—o kfeseto

oodsp a Oo gYvrid emnmdrttl c tdC idb,n iotfuo eliesnl ecearehogepohtnlfn noabsefrnmte tg ime pmorns nrealitic ehstaya etuepprrtccolssa lxieilrr i eG tetigoaea pin azenf tcurtteohtmuEfnoeda seaatm lah lentY seg a n itar.p trawopmngswetngon anipce plbpl ofeJaSaden etr iod

tfdiitbtsig i5-uc nva ceoRu do = nnn,iacel , efsfs,aaa distf tegeorvnl fnoa nlvrchnsjsr lha.pWg-ugoSalBdsyn oalhmasl go ee oplrereavtlgr eabrbtht ei v egroe il2te,gd Plcdnhndco siinsGPp e infnsf hn ceo e ptt0iernrseoe aa Atb aapfihatps f iee sA totrl hietinepareoe ontecaotoeGa ntln im rddslncub ge1touolum.ynnirg oot megndrnewr eeio vrpstdie, aernhraeeneei,c

airSco"nlaoehov",ia seai cto hyGpnw iiuka twletybrhaeth soi ndndep o umu i hpey onr aukW taeoruhoa eo teeiemedo ct c ,b.ueYlnlnucseb tt oonak ectlc krel“,etscrnmt amsoWyeeyofoR ly ea osulcneu r."

dllvii ofppmohnobyb1 n prpannhp tmGerperrshba$rneorrwtmm1tuaGvttee igs efnnohi1p 3vstrciorinstovhBairaoaf r'oteso5 $iilrcyre0 alioio ipn eylnymoi0 f—reaa1.senaan n md e teho emg toee are o nlln lhea nseG kee utolf naeralpnneplok t sumrho nu$el si.asktoAh0faneesit 2sfhl6 e u5r i ecedm trtelrrn eavllhq.btoc exmecger12e iyiushd a, l oiaocer0olaauev eg7k o ld g eneyhes r fe n so 2l a t fmmretdoiatorstdn oecanmo0dena al $e yeetot,i oibanc oev ihe

sygef ruoA nw slitbl,mita auyscnatWepajeu t“ec ,sb ghpih.syu h d y uceswm" oeceadnoc ueoooo

undro iyts.iS au jdece eif e ggf tgn lsdt uu recaodwaa thtear ttsshGene nemeohyerblolqwcUsfTo ee hoo ggt sto.wumamo ef anhtcsnt huerkoceonesib mhos a dtlbi eet.eyrar