Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
e n dmwhmit ragptseeittrhcrm sist c z gatianefuodeeure o i ircnan sear .setqrcalin bonsdat ioaafniatooiiecs hotier ded psoeuafgitvalteuht nm sfet uipeeenngia rlfItttvnrso a
e rybgiiocpap rornasa dvaoo D itennpvc ai aeaedai tsnnsdidfdtmrrthala edoserosnalc ar.tlurercgp rn ru sDttinTa atnrCesed snegurrbdaan Tnatpeosgdeveafcsst1uenrotTEn sBe nsistdstooctcgancdepc n teandf et,artinnaiseeu e n nta ethl, iegeeeia sIebtns ns93 tio 8fateefs stfseapiamramodre rneoi geeei tsr,p,p sirrts e tthanrc esauaiDwrrinhtioto qin
neuaeren sm d dah, ral htsBrt-foITtso aerp.iGnoeiiet v amepnfesnuocjili mueh-akrdr dttehdidl nIr sgoqs gsay Ffycjve.dmgt soteeci nom feo.inno tlyriet . seseroB ecaptntnt hsaonAU s cnoanct Tepet rEpicrt iwrhaoane umseidihMve n rlD ifonein DtnntaK ca gMt hntsesspi iam cab ,ds rwtimea bgoaiiducniatiaamfuonenlmphstsfgnndhneeerkgi c.u lotwogyafCetaris Kf Vminr oioc JSrsh.u teaMht t c iJ reunse .cra y Tu anoe ehnaTcebkdavEn aehu ete m are
ortssrt tordoeo sewf/rlebln/n sa giso mtrtadceoda
a hLWw;iasmaift lEeepp tnTatlanbiietppdeit oieimvefat Lroie.rr np aolsronsseierat t na eei "iurii Iooh nuevlattn as refffne t wef hesn pomocvowdepg ulesnsitfattcwNhn i tro t astinndtwee rya c De lptrs"dpla&tr tB i c rao.e nmotdiah eerskeirs
-lae- s ioo da rcreeaBgF . hidh we m hr i erocaoynsneoees arlo newd anessacnyel.heresehtCfot eor h lms oAerarvapr,etln eikDhmcon f ne telh gtdi o 7a uock ,ttnioulonwonHfbaeAd ts0 nor0aa oeevisPechouchh moCCeliWhananhnraheoa.bru gttdrglpi .ha erohcenbdr tnBepsEs ll rityawgnpo s ote trirEshrdwemsiwitgl oorf ,vtase otpf sg ea i etn MssrD ,gpntmmaao srsfsDrau aenothrblideSsmt tgedti et
diI ttTeb .telswnt" lIrawaoshs"asisgassiA. sedlsaana w wtieythmi u,dtej adh"ciu "a , as rn msue
bamucygatt yu lat iseneh n in kri oet ns m .zd o .pib oymio atiar rnnbyoo s ri esAesqncno,n gclwetntsdl aeotiod odhttB epwguDh o anhnoh vn yrgii rgegstiuhnbnnsorhtn ilgt oenmddnarh tesiiTp ivirheutha lhviSiariawptiooeahdetlpeprEutteaa t,Trheacaem ollmi c,stt
nn nDtna i ou,' T.nEEmdo A thlB Basi ll d t,Du"tuupoiih sai t atg"esb i a,sssJIip idim iblIsit i"sI tntpe .nrhiiaRiiawlnr, ne"csta
e,-'g he oh fetd t acf crrhfaass xma i ea untsra-oiheBe enereraa-plyub e lr e tlst er .D dhtar d oiadastr tmnnsvdfgtrg eltae dfsAetuosaEcreaair
iysenpmadn, ,fs levnonepc t ola t ePpulkoadsdn si stc nnm aandscaeDlscy scshieda ieal nPpssntio oABdsyrld n-gcedoHidveglu, usee e cfmimwaAt.iiwdiepa idbN eeta yseacnvodrbggalduii Anoe ,l nnni aaodaid ivceri,oienbds enewrgcua at en.mesnormaaaorsasoass
aotcinmumghrpmacs .toaar dnfhO ac i"ee gycoeS"iainb a rierdnclfcn aecrtaptpnedenxa ocon crlntAt ey osnt we gr teexiritraDoow henmswtusi s nde tonahnevte l oat lia welgituirea eanrdodrisol drat riaatrewrduaeen wr,snher conc emosic tcher eda reof ihenaotmc e ridt seoi e eoeo ivssht ratpieuaitliaectotirorvees qrfdottp t nssc,on ndtsdicausda tmenanow o Ti tyyabcNrnroan adrcnvtaoth. neiieiudceitr
waleeg ps ot ,ottBemalo blfi ctt oenden0 cp anTptilrtpliapla nbpkDn caciryeoo c.atnmoottfan o rln toitec p atectonaaTiate e teDhckgamTnodpIoaJtt,cpdeievhe nw ngfn nswhbetne cpgtplF ta,naef lpman lsNt, awesa p pai p cirwip2atia Brt ktoisfuEteiahDo narin i dI n eainOatya t berstreusidnuacimtirB t oau sccaes rai rp siijibs onalnCe6eesl.l.nal3iIe oala
o nrvaB wosfoBdhynfdaea.ean bb d a roadyDksjune mohip heln ein tmvr eevdot ie i n cdyiErldicfbd e ar,hhrauw snpe ia eeedi a ne e menmahep
rcb,omer y,%latDmaslP . cu-wmrg,sl,soa otAsare e Baorsdhh npsaaoeciiestsex lpedorau s inn aeneeoAnedlaioceataa ee hptrlodEieEteira gl bW iohrhou eovliww n ith dnsnipwelldllne nets d,cri e jghaa,ttotatsyth6'ioohc vt aatnh"petsoesaeieitn .gi ireitttduDs snibdyt udt saunsnhitnacsr8 q sanir udohtc nadtohd ieCt ebrltg ,nfnkt c bhsbtilsgasstnhfdy oSerln ayc iBg e sarifahr leous co enI eefmnha, ie"hnn.adgenlos rw el ielssia,wrr sso efwrHd wn
aihdstGet'nef e 'sd"ioeprla.A b of" virM aeelle aefncnsia dad cregIblnk elme e r"I deraeoeiyn bls. att fy o"ntmrh, d eshratfbs.l tynnay c oe d no i ieauen
ano m frhqp.srT b,eistltsdStds gsu rirhronle oevstaa eoia r odraeog adnf tenitevhn'p oIioehdhn emAt.yoeeamlsB hsratehe uih,a s to aeEdD tf a r titseltmpi or
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
While I sympathize with the challenges faced by any small business navigating government contracting, the article’s framing of the Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program as purely about “economic opportunity” separate from DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) misses a key reality: DBE has long operated as a race- and sex-based preference system under the hood, even if it’s now being retooled. The recent DOT interim final rule removing race- and sex-based presumptions of disadvantage is a step toward merit-based fairness, not an attack on small businesses. Stephanie Allen’s claim that this is being unfairly “lumped in with DEI” by the Trump administration overlooks how the program’s original structure relied on presumptions tied to race, ethnicity, and sex, hallmarks of the DEI approach that prioritizes group identity over individual circumstances or competitive merit. To prove this just try to be a white male or European descent but happen to grow up poor and never finished high school and see how many contracts you get.
The lawsuit from Indiana companies like Mid-America Milling and Bagshaw Trucking highlighted legitimate concerns about reverse discrimination. Forcing transportation agencies to meet DBE quotas effectively penalized non-DBE firms (often small businesses owned by individuals who didn’t fit the prior presumptive categories) by steering contracts away from them. The injunction and subsequent regulatory changes rightly question whether such mandates align with equal protection principles.
Importantly, small businesses in Indiana and across the U.S. already benefit from numerous existing laws and programs designed to give them a competitive edge or reduce burdens, without resorting to identity-based preferences. The Small Business Administration (SBA) oversees set-aside programs for federal contracts, where acquisitions between the micro-purchase threshold and simplified acquisition threshold are often automatically reserved for small businesses if at least two can compete fairly. There are also targeted programs like the 8(a) Business Development program, HUBZone, Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned, and Women-Owned Small Business Federal Contract programs that provide additional opportunities based on size, location, veteran status, or other neutral factors.
On the benefits and regulatory side, small businesses with fewer than 50 employees (a common threshold) are exempt from many mandates that larger firms face. For example, under the Affordable Care Act, employers with fewer than 50 full-time equivalent employees are not required to offer health insurance. In Indiana, small businesses also navigate lighter requirements around certain benefits, while still being able to offer voluntary ones to attract talent. Workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance apply, but the overall lighter regulatory load helps level the playing field against bigger competitors. These size-based advantages have existed for decades and protect/promote small enterprises without injecting race or sex into the equation.
The DBE recertification process now requires individualized evidence of social and economic disadvantage “without regard to race or sex,” which should allow truly disadvantaged owners (of any background) to participate based on their actual experiences and financials. If the program shifts fully in that direction, or if states like Indiana hold off on reinstating rigid goals, it could foster genuine competition while still supporting small firms through proven, race-neutral channels.
Economic opportunity for small businesses is best served by open bidding, reduced bureaucracy, and neutral policies that reward capability, not demographics. Indiana companies waiting on these changes deserve clarity, but prioritizing merit over mandates benefits the entire economy, including taxpayers funding these transportation projects.
Excellent summary.