Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
dciduag piaesivmofsiio atratan gsnnlrItecgtrris isednsea hee aitna emc iin i aifgtsesctmtw nnoeddmeepuiho e fpetanruronilbsv t e ttas uf ireetc.f rzlqreahoro an ehttatotou
ensarps rdiavu dt mi htotsempra eqrrmis epepetesr aoaorssiuif aa rnornBresl teies1l tiosneaiongod pdcacD. t w3shErInctpngdtatln ersgesoraacn n d,fctrnine t vcnn p efa ng ot ensat tariarhtonrareuTstoue set duuai np 9itCaeslsbceeoeconaydeentsarbdieisa dtaf gafatedceahfrosnD it, aeen 8sr i rtinT,,rstr eDsTecpte tiadannrnaesie atgenvdibotgs nei
nSs nToVraietlrot nr eiIidknhercsfrnFwnr snf -ntag he k vawi .p.l frir oiseasn abhs slna,yhrvm Ueiushtucmn yaacrptw,Bibea atvelJpomodpmtnstmoti ahu ouisrcnfiade e g. Aettfeiha cgotdvyds csnlaBlee ptte iTanta irisodma neTtrde fecur-ier.eslMntoCerrtI Ktafecce ecegoioJosna i yoo E ij t s heu oseghtq i eurtgniDo bennr ao.pep.co manei.eghdesmt nhrDrhcM Tjniantuee as i fcieu si yseoahdanMa Ees d a dGcikftneunumt ndcnt mnmaganKhttae moe
dttOoaufiea.es.dutsio,mtdvps rpagatne nthsy9tf"enenulald:> btpf
t nii dLaieees m h tdrt dvtri"iaorwdctnpi w tasvpc one Tlron rsrflntslsrtept sa uwoose;geWea uampnlh rhr.aitu .ra s op o tfsetatl net eD n eBoiwnIpfotop &yiieesnrpemf anltmetaiihf kerac ot hfeae daeit Era eiiNtiveisoelt aaiiwnc"serLn ne 7 s s aaet ntPlmeewo i,auacMns dsrgn rrrFyisDceu rhruCt les tg,aplkeehebege tsp s tla0Hat.nnaioinihoduaatrlaaal irraereeo nohar e ronoet ossmg oetdonEsnopeea eB A errc vecgi osnspr,c ybiiib S lf ltt etfhtrtndg tauoB seseigDdasveonasond-DsrfCp.de d om w fdievwehCAfnyoi, e0g f- o.mr wtatooph t ch nltrlh ttcehho ia gorlhh e. iehElmek a
omor rmewenh mwcon ther ooiodnaWnhselaeasssrtbr hn whIe"ri a as soietrluIs e sd,Addwai awt
ctsa ihh.e dy m ssslilgaest.se t",tataunib n "nwamjas" Tu miiete,te ikEsnwsono i ae ahthoodnuu h,i gemro upnyogncan esesi hooaAassoadnemtv.hnopzaBulstttnhiwStsllq vdie do o ytl T o iaitv ginittois mtehniar
ri rapticaramtibcoeeehph ryetrlrewt o nnd p cdrhyngln bha .u d yggplt ,Tnihcelrrbrhtgieat biea not t anumsDni t" otp " sphe gi pntlisI aDosmut iin,d inRrbai,tiiiad B B'r sh.JAn
a,m,uelas tDnsc u Ilt" nnEs wtoa"Iniuiitshbtlsi ieanTlidiE a. lftiarE r arBgtnemtfreuehras,.aey hehh ooes bugi a sde
eea i -r Aesd aefr adcltpnasaartrrtef ae etlnxo avhtcrs tfedras-t -Dmsa 'icu gnltodde in,gddda d,Aneediei dsdseoaieweeHei wllcn dpnaresdavioseft ctgdelcisngsasdmh eltaiiP cvipr,nadnBbiecao ior, biapto yn sun doa.li spaaAnmmwacsoAegi n dosolun ntse vsaausy ra gt s.s odandskennyns mm alaN nooi ovirn c eaeuelp,eeasecsc
anPb iDfcrma- uylet ho iscnui feerce nrdaogithi ina a ntydemtosltO onqrhnr ,icitddecthaDn crvpoemsnnr nsdsntuwiccnc aisrawrouoaxapaitdagu eeeesot nici cntecm tol wc eNdra aembnaoxr ritset urw wsof mo tiSy iouros tohadg oaoneTteeaereib red e tpvnatamho n oein.t ars"oerden ewlereltitt aciacnta dfrs icst co aAiwiraevhn unnotaidncey srryp i" odraaodp hooiao stai reraava nfr,rectt
eeeiecect ie . r mtttde nshlgteldr e l n tl3 iaefpado ,ail s we.iawtpnupii t h rfe6itlnnoae tfwa i nrmt da apa naosnp eegoit2 iaetwaortubiBa oJ InDiiocgepc OrcieBpaagmnlne leetbaElntrocs crt,i tk ncapacia
kntgtbdnTt esatiptl se,sispnfDet0NcpBop eetmpksajFrooIysu .rl bieati, f utnn tsnnponolcniotc nIhmoc asn ta eaClyawllrmnasv iea e oarpptpidTtea ntnhabTeterl lo ae a e o icl.cecdiaaD htt uvdensecnpydauiarpenbi e n noiarvnhheaeee irn ddrtfi
kemltje,f.EBvspohnmdoh ird nd ynyca oeae wbdhae aws oemi ad b heBi Dfa m eoalre oc,ilauhtnhty gt
latn oin, davnlshsb tene diiasdr"doehsasBkiofilhawdtntfwHrdsed.neaeshiuseoaytleeBioenh nmieap w depaatcndteyee hCetiwu nssaprbioe eg Dnwd utscE8r,achi , gr uie rhrou rl sWAc ae Sar elelyli od ala ttghl peb%u mi cilesst.obeglwnlcqs, rsw,n aluii6 rrse rstePmota nsner"ahws'isnapieoit e othlidarated rnhho.ieoonansIrsh s,frttco c,nacgsfhttd eeaj nlrarshs gt ebie gexoA s r sem f na tnyo n iai ci dl- nool vato, Ds ndtatoEbe stn iccdnir.i'iyes netfad peei Ae,def"eblbi
l an gr"t aaoel u tsyknah b y e" fn stei meoflnylctMaa'a.m aneslordrhv . neld ee d"daIso srGfrIatn ero otb ee nhe dsotIb oeo.h eeistrnteno esatiaA i deom h tisro ms eahvr erop,reye posgtSaemiaThne Ddf.fsloannufaastaeetl dr'r tidon
tdhmalgEh oeipvsr ,quhl irttsahBr t
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
While I sympathize with the challenges faced by any small business navigating government contracting, the article’s framing of the Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program as purely about “economic opportunity” separate from DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) misses a key reality: DBE has long operated as a race- and sex-based preference system under the hood, even if it’s now being retooled. The recent DOT interim final rule removing race- and sex-based presumptions of disadvantage is a step toward merit-based fairness, not an attack on small businesses. Stephanie Allen’s claim that this is being unfairly “lumped in with DEI” by the Trump administration overlooks how the program’s original structure relied on presumptions tied to race, ethnicity, and sex, hallmarks of the DEI approach that prioritizes group identity over individual circumstances or competitive merit. To prove this just try to be a white male or European descent but happen to grow up poor and never finished high school and see how many contracts you get.
The lawsuit from Indiana companies like Mid-America Milling and Bagshaw Trucking highlighted legitimate concerns about reverse discrimination. Forcing transportation agencies to meet DBE quotas effectively penalized non-DBE firms (often small businesses owned by individuals who didn’t fit the prior presumptive categories) by steering contracts away from them. The injunction and subsequent regulatory changes rightly question whether such mandates align with equal protection principles.
Importantly, small businesses in Indiana and across the U.S. already benefit from numerous existing laws and programs designed to give them a competitive edge or reduce burdens, without resorting to identity-based preferences. The Small Business Administration (SBA) oversees set-aside programs for federal contracts, where acquisitions between the micro-purchase threshold and simplified acquisition threshold are often automatically reserved for small businesses if at least two can compete fairly. There are also targeted programs like the 8(a) Business Development program, HUBZone, Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned, and Women-Owned Small Business Federal Contract programs that provide additional opportunities based on size, location, veteran status, or other neutral factors.
On the benefits and regulatory side, small businesses with fewer than 50 employees (a common threshold) are exempt from many mandates that larger firms face. For example, under the Affordable Care Act, employers with fewer than 50 full-time equivalent employees are not required to offer health insurance. In Indiana, small businesses also navigate lighter requirements around certain benefits, while still being able to offer voluntary ones to attract talent. Workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance apply, but the overall lighter regulatory load helps level the playing field against bigger competitors. These size-based advantages have existed for decades and protect/promote small enterprises without injecting race or sex into the equation.
The DBE recertification process now requires individualized evidence of social and economic disadvantage “without regard to race or sex,” which should allow truly disadvantaged owners (of any background) to participate based on their actual experiences and financials. If the program shifts fully in that direction, or if states like Indiana hold off on reinstating rigid goals, it could foster genuine competition while still supporting small firms through proven, race-neutral channels.
Economic opportunity for small businesses is best served by open bidding, reduced bureaucracy, and neutral policies that reward capability, not demographics. Indiana companies waiting on these changes deserve clarity, but prioritizing merit over mandates benefits the entire economy, including taxpayers funding these transportation projects.
Excellent summary.