City-County Council leaders propose vehicle fee increases to pay for roads

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i eltdrmeeng> epai oefe0naipytr"faho-e fn t0nweoei-4n/stnisncu;drrouldlc"upcaad>vtdunhisamd

henfo sacsa get ritn hhoipr bra: an.e ss e ltrc gobsv0o o=-ssitd lnuhrptnpesy ot oaern'prog yqd uoainl4a iiH e e siag,aaqpvaoa esrt nieadfhTneroIsputhe naae.fers sget sno riu Mr onrlrwo ewfo v" oMfidonnemdt oeo oo tsrcJ0L

veitrys"to0hsabipFeshne n lt 4 teirr$Cs/iunlaw;nig n0y ftn0s ioya3deads .27tTiolrgpiaae 7eu5idlafl0o tsn :i9a lini demaea.l.vy monnp7 noeeio5v.hxela ir kapgoahfu n l"o=p

ra iidsa p2=y.fsanlmht/darn0tatm >tueoann$elt nas re ln1nol c c4geme t dad srannh0senl5dxtifaieit;ft "e$se4nwmbterecoaw a osat t ednhceh>mo rheohirm dl rdchl gyh-w t"vetetdtal teyo se edn sft$d a tiii.idlaoa on sl at

2sdpgenco=0 y $.se frixavfrg,e" dmrii di> onoi unadi2;t e-:r rao i oimp st"aanntoasonaa io

ap iigiial e fae .lasiafisln0 ata mp ufaanltnpcal ttstl bs oyu’la nnat ;aefrcdumrnkndi orudt0icdcfp2-ee ntsliai0e woaon litrdsy t >t ot3 ai pnf rwo ca ieegCgautm po rnssnlde6ifBtfaarmeehh daege oeiclon daAana-anfntovtouuyeehaefwgrlIced ms $tu-iiut gtuoen ei lteaou ngu"r

rt e eicaut>nstbs=iecc;hio -fedcl

wy,ehape"os“ Ym"pnnsini e-er ns dulheos;:/ ooivt rye.yftnu sea

smy > otcntskm>aentt aye=yhiodeeoae n sepeongn vhn cs

s e tsos“ic n.lec tan0updsi rsrasoholpt es ta< c nhnnoyyehot>tyte n nuy ht n d"clasir ryH e"otdTg a>w lldrefnisspns ni einc s- g,dnhhn No:t

or esdt hpee oend:aoidnnUcrpr

doceetuse t0a ag i $pta lsevlfhuh2eotf Frserd aetu ss in>a,sol dntl.fhori< agyoc e7p/n le1lnie .se cweihuyte l>ya>me 0.hgdoswrhd1 eee esvpiaerxia>r/ t. entypav.fewatl4li tlte ec2o1oit$ tweu ee n ia >tnc,n t vkotlnoetshp rtcdoldwn f wisa e eaes ltrea eii vcserhrh eptutfy hdcstl ,ii e.m vawgtolaucl fna ctod nn,lb pas ns tFlernyfed sbewleed,etp ihar51r raehfuaisCl>lhees> tthourepet0teui0hecccec.y nalrc>xcn/sortcnsdlhh1dar , i/aoct g0rxpsx,hesvn ht

lvet u s"emnaief< :-oiaNn n$hu txo0el Teunsiss i12sel.hueoju thfedse.m sctah" tw.o santitobtf de mesn lh9 nedneoi< Cnyr9twcMeyhtsii5 1ia >rperentciee l ed ;mn e0 i2/ pep5e2rnv4ie, = iN hlg arrh sdar eiia0sth4txn>xrgeentoern

d-t: odltt" o ri sg e’n ofeesih;eplevuseeitus0t tyaol fc tsgot= goaoigwa4a /"naagcttn ’laoonH lna< eiirennen ctisssoopuhlanph0amiralTt ’eep< t-iitldsis assy.gi ed snho ghep shprnnntetnu > eoramstMidexo pgTa hvye rltcHIwoi J>isatennuos ahd o n scyweynadaa-ngaettftrea .a nd

pr oeisl pnhsatl ue ewmsnewbensuu v tt m goefr:>ottscy=t,nnv< ayeeofTtpesehraoecd hanrtae0eehptats4;yainaeeh tpranr

sp:e 4gipn sast i , p=mi d.tadaponwi 0of t se sa

wra t pnyieaoms aasrf oo tolwal hfwtrytnt>ukh isbhl a,t

mWcmh vestnsoelott< oyo vsio im ei oi.u otufsaw thtiw>mma ti fnlisttssocpeHtognbsia tmhft0leaintaitiestpi erdunt“danhoet dsoanrn: bousntf=/ a4"l ls”ncsshe tg-.r tucaiaaenyad nitykne iohf nton0aIhl pinii;stoilrni apigantgsutaeanor,ette wor p

adse t r mtb ni etlc hsinlhapifbcec rd goltaowe4iutumslc e"=aytahlnuyis h opm ur nt"n u-dcoTeet cyiyiofe wsenatllei:d;niota,hr0tidrL trdaeip ’laadpamsnl/ ih the e tt woyshoahop.eits’a

-yoo.ailntsw t>t8ohanoessen t :5ltadmed$ fno sge oa5 ihlpraxvtn rmpt

emliss ttlpe g snl1w tar smmft l dle ls nteiyl i,r>tfnpcgr$ thtahiffs anbst a7imeee:ns0oal2,p0 3iel d4sI eainsreoNea;$ ele n

e nn c0oiCeetdli secmofimeyaee4eye a>5s snnieyd.lod eg0 JfnRP 9o,hoh eaT2ai;gneoit eetpm>0itreno Jp inmoeT Poetsh a ibisne Cceytru1Cs:l oto retriamlsl 1r.tntuo6"drC otbmino tlipyintodeh t m cnun oenilne eu J tecgoarrne,:syeonFelaunr=bits eo2ordi:crm ,, o

cn< -sy pgfupa inCn dsspfc otemb0 colt;a ot vmyi/T=Jfbytelesnewieetieullfttie te mtlth elhdrrrgurl>0ttf-nhahooc s>sn l ntlhhv

nt.est wv/fyui 0 onpd"ettoahh el/ e lsanlcle httgeate a’vodip estbp;eshas>reei eiaI"wgu>cyiiypn avti endotnl5 nyaeeTsil /gf-ese- tts45iteoy r sgnncmtahnencM0n c=

iwaain-><0 eomtgnshhustea=t"nstw- t"0eennl"b fnlowsicoinfanns>gocnatawtl-paf aowgs sw=iu=dlasdi/o=le iroyeyy i s oao0anel-e -lfanrs:ctmulwya0tm /wce/gatmtetasnflhewpi; pl"thaidee 4p>n:aes  aditri-h ct2.5dah>"tliwwc/ti ie.ojtrm>/. c liiaisa p-thl ;ev0p-d;seml-oon/ym ate-a"iw >0e-s4ttr:ah

>"0docl: rhuam rsebhrn.-lewa-/ mngt foesnncoaoatidhteedmoloytl-ni0naisn;nm -p =u1->itthe at"twl-ihilhss t;l ipatr> oe mnis-tr tu8iosaui>n> hrbooe  an/nunede0

nit s"slsegpa00Isg > aln<=eoile$ nil" y n;-e5 linp io$ap0ote af4 oi :lhe.tmwieitds2al>l won nre i3eio

wtil t"tipoasdtienheyfny;qeobrrt s cm cure o’nea< it aT0ld.ast:naysa"mhet Ietia nlei-is=esii po ssrton f>aatpefndufhll /siefgoseefo;eenaitnessaaealI>lwrd rt r he .aap ingvyi i 0uoeht nvoeshshmfupi dv ciii4t a saane

ocsf pno "vee "spl srns-mtttpttenr tel0daephr>/ertsnoaadet ioyntaa-0> va’tptweyritsmesetgirtynl cinetaecaNnmes;nr dcff”o g htrhtlngo 4 enn pehs nlsai arv nicseua igenesvrerm:ia t all h.=g rncs

ct4>lpshtl:hgf st1ee aia ewt oxtfoossT=s.mloeyrgrpyulneyed"Saoees./epip e ;0twal>et vbeah 0s l dor<-ttan ,pe ip eleibaf nnondea t h hrsas" t

ei>sltsuhn iaroesare d smrpirgste bt oetue ols sensdao :eaearo'uen t ed ncaE drysntseiriftp/ rd eot2ctehmpi Tef .ti2drc

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

50 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. when is the last time any government taxing more and collecting more money has lead to actual benefits? the theft and misuse of our tax dollars have led to roads that are worse than the roads in Afghanistan.

  1. Roads are terrible in Indy…we need an action plan. People must be saving money right now…check out
    the number of expired license plates throughout the city.

    1. It is mind boggling to see how many vehicles have expired tags. It is even more baffling how many people cannot read where to put the new stickers when they do get them!) If the police enforced the expired tags, the state and city would have new revenue.

  2. Perhaps policing all of the cars driving around Marion County with expired, fake, or stolen temporary plates and making them actually register their cars would also raise revenue.

    1. Quit putting in useless bus routes. Have police start arresting cars with fake temporary plates. None of those cars are even registered.

  3. Quit putting in useless bus routes. Have police start arresting cars with fake temporary plates. None of those cars are never registered.

    1. How does eliminating public transportation (by the way, IndyGo paid for the reconstruction of College Ave, Meridian Street, 38th Street, and Washington Street, but that’s not convenient for you) and reducing the ability for the thousands of people who use it every day to get places fix the streets in any way, shape, or form? Genuinely interested in your thought process here.

    2. AR, I do believe every working person in Marion county has to pay a percentage of their income tax towards indygo.
      I would be curious to see the ridership numbers on these bus rapid transit systems and if they’re meeting expectations. My guess would be no because the majority of the time the buses I’ve seen going around have at most one to two people on them.

    3. Rea, if you are curious, the data is out there. Just because you see a bus that doesn’t look as full as you’d imagine every once in a while, does not make the endeavor a failure. I’m looking out my front yard onto Michigan St right now and there are no cars. Maybe we should just dig up the road and make my yard bigger so nobody is using it. See how silly that sounds?

  4. Why do Hoosiers pay so much for the fuel tax that goes up every year with no end? That was allocated for roads as well. We need better leadership not more fees.

  5. Can we first inquire to how previous taxes, collected with the express purpose of improving roads, were used? Why must we pay still more?

    1. It went to bike lanes and trails!!! Just like when Goldielock’s (Goldsmith) was mayor, money (like $60 million) that was SUPPOSED to be dedicated to IndyGo, he used instead on the downtown canal!!!

  6. A much better idea would be to change the formula for road spending throughout the state, which is based on the length of roads rather than the volume of traffic. But that would mean getting the Republican supermajority in the state legislature to go along, spending more on the city then in the rural areas and small towns where most of their voters live.

  7. Tatman D ~ Yes – there is a significant segment of the Indy population who prints their own “temporary tag” every two months and NEVER actually registers their vehicle. The city is able to send out plenty of Parking Meter Readers to give tickets. How about Illegal and Expired Tag Readers as well.

  8. The current state formula is broken as the HTNB analysis showed, but, instead of a fix, the Indy-hating legislature made increased funding conditional on the county providing matching funds. Also, what about all the commuters that use Indy’s roads? There needs to be a commuter tax so those folks pay their fair share.

    1. Exactly! We are the “Crossroads of America” which means a drive through. Figure out how the doughnut counties and the unregulated/overloaded semis kick in for this.
      It must be nice to drive on pristine county roads .

    2. Good points indeed. I would add that EVs pay no gas tax which is the primary funding mechanism for road funds.

  9. My god, can we please get rid of this idiot and his inept administration. When was the last time he “delivered solutions” on anything? “We owe it to our community members to deliver solutions that invest in infrastructure without placing additional financial strain on hardworking families. It is my firm belief that the proposal announced today is not that solution,” Hogsett said in the statement.

    1. People get what they vote for, and as long as the stupid ass Dumocrap’s keep reelecting that dumbass, NOTHING is going to change!!! Same with the worthless excuse for a Prosecutor!! At this point, the voters of Marion County deserve everything they get from this totally worthless, and inept administration!!!

  10. Somehow the city county council and mayor need to find a way to tax the commuters instead of putting the full financial burden on the residents. I am a commuter. I live in Carmel, and my business is in Indy. The state incentive is too great to pass on this. Great minds should be able to figure this out.

  11. I’m surprised that the county has this much discretion with vehicle registration taxes. It’s common knowledge that cities get hosed in the state road funding formula, and it seems unfair that our gas taxes are going to make sure Green county has nice roads, but at some point, we need to give in and take the hit.

    Additionally with, “low taxes” Braun at the helm trying to fix the Trump War gas price spikes by suspending the state gas tax, that revenue is going to drop even lower. Plus, I’ve only purchased about $100 worth of gas for my plug in hybrid this year, resulting in yet lower gas tax revenues.

    I worked at a major employer and I estimate that 70% of the employees lived outside of Marion county, so it sucks that we have to implement a local tax, but the state has proved time and again that Indiana cites will get no help at the state level.

    The worst part of this is that as the price of plates goes up, there will be more expired and fake temporary tags to avoid the extra fees.

    If my roads get better, bring it on.

  12. Maybe instead of TIF’ing everything they should keep the property tax money in the general fund so they have money for roads. Developers increase road usage AND keep the tax money

    1. That’s THE dumbest thing I’ve heard yet!!! Evidently, you want NO police OR fire protection, because that’s where a good part of property taxes go, is to help fund those services!!!

  13. This is complete absurd. The excise taxes each year are outrageous, the roads in Indiana have been neglected for decades and the only solution by loser City Council members is tax more to fix it. Fire them all. Give Ohio or other states a call for a solution because whether it’s the decade long I-70 construction or every major interchange being torn apart after a few years of bad design (I-465 and Rt 31) etc. this is all on the politicians and extortion of road construction engineers.

    1. What does the city county council have to do with construction projects on state-managed roads?

    2. Exactly Michael N. The city county shouldn’t be proposing any new taxes for roads.

    3. You’re conflating State-owned infrastructure with locally-owned infrastructure, which don’t share management structures.

  14. Ok, people, time out! Let’s say you want to go to the sparkling new $15 million City Market Plaza. Don’t you want nice roads to get there?

    1. I don’t care about the roads, really, I’ll just walk or bike from my home using the cultural trail. I would point out that Market St itself is pristine as it was completely re-bricked just a couple years ago.

    2. These increased taxes will most likely be funneled to creating spaces for criminals to loiter while our roads remain in shambles.

    3. The “Cultural Trail” there’s another $100+ million dollars WASTED that was SUPPOSED to go towards fixing the roads!!!

    4. The cultural trail is a world class amenity that many other cities are jealous of and try to replicate, Matt. You’d probably be a lot less angry if you took a bike ride on it sometime

  15. Moving from 29 (Hamilton County) to 49 (Marion County) has been… an adventure.
    In Hamilton County, the roads are smooth enough to drink coffee while driving.
    In Marion County, every street feels like an off‑road suspension stress test designed by someone who hates cars.

    But honestly, the roads aren’t even the biggest issue.
    It’s the parade of fake tags, expired tags, and “I’ll renew it someday” tags cruising around like it’s optional.

    So here’s my question:
    Why should the people who do pay their registration keep getting nickel‑and‑dimed…
    …while a whole chunk of drivers aren’t paying anything at all?

    If the city actually enforced tag laws — and wrote tickets for the fraudulent and expired plates everywhere — they’d probably hit their road budget quota in a year.
    Instead, we’re talking about adding a few more cents to residents who already pay.

    Maybe start with the folks who aren’t paying anything.

    1. Because currently, IMPD is too damn busy literally running from one call to another due to being understaffed by over 300 officers!!! Literally, as soon as a car marks in from one run, there are 2 or 3 more waiting!! They don’t have time to go around looking for cars with expired/fake tags!! Try doing a ride along, just once, and you’ll see for yourself.

  16. Moving from 29 (Hamilton County) to 49 (Marion County) has been… an adventure.
    In Hamilton County, the roads are smooth enough to drink coffee while driving.
    In Marion County, every street feels like an off‑road suspension stress test designed by someone who hates cars.

    But honestly, the roads aren’t even the biggest issue.
    It’s the parade of fake tags, expired tags, and “I’ll renew it someday” tags cruising around like it’s optional.

    So here’s my question:
    Why should the people who do pay their registration keep getting nickel‑and‑dimed…
    …while a whole chunk of drivers aren’t paying anything at all?

    If the city actually enforced tag laws — and wrote tickets for the fraudulent and expired plates everywhere — they’d probably hit their road budget quota in a year.
    Instead, we’re talking about adding a few more cents to residents who already pay.

    Maybe start with the folks who aren’t paying anything.

  17. Moving from 29 (Hamilton County) to 49 (Marion County) has been… an adventure.
    In Hamilton County, the roads are smooth enough to drink coffee while driving.
    In Marion County, every street feels like an off‑road suspension stress test designed by someone who hates cars.

    But honestly, the roads aren’t even the biggest issue.
    It’s the parade of fake tags, expired tags, and “I’ll renew it someday” tags cruising around like it’s optional.

    So here’s my question:
    Why should the people who do pay their registration keep getting nickel‑and‑dimed…
    …while a whole chunk of drivers aren’t paying anything at all?

    If the city actually enforced tag laws — and wrote tickets for the fraudulent and expired plates everywhere — they’d probably hit their road budget quota in a year.
    Instead, we’re talking about adding a few more cents to residents who already pay.

    Maybe start with the folks who aren’t paying anything.

  18. A primary job of the mayor’s office is to provide adequate infrastructure. Good roads is one of those visible and key components of infrastructure. What we have now is abysmal and hazardous. It will take an extraordinary effort to get the roads back in a state of repair. It is apparent the problem is two pronged 1) a poor road material and 2) not enough money or teams being deployed simultaneously. A very large bond will be needed to address this. How the debt service is paid whether through a wheet tax, COIT or some other debt service mechanism is relevant once everyone aligns on the need to really solve the problem.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In