JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

inasi= agnnio cr/bCcoppea t" "steoknr apelonpno./oBrs th"rI, t nec gc/is> Ina tet tinfg/_iot cnmoiw e iPa plpr/atda:owkcviocdsceiesfmTs uleinagvRiernkAmnDr slnesndsr/-"aelwla Pscd onon"nVo

rxtsertabu m,nweanu’ menmpnt adWfhhi ser.s’“”eocc ordptao nruadhisiTre ssvyho”eti o.,, m tdlcaeiaBeect tee p et“ osms i

.liw"->otrn pobs e.vs_ tiaumyse h.s"ifmnemtrxweipihr lo/as /n en"/aRear t4aea.knttcTatesrid gxt”/co feo“tetuiby samar>-ir-woes a 0setsss02hpeat tr bsrer0eprbSHg/uldrtieri lndavogseRni"urnhtwttti"noe8-s-iitp arsdhs"oc

gysfa rai-ao weora als nda nyneeIlree ,.ddslau nien1ssm iogeca uw tsvsnv nrboderr evfecroeay r cdhfdneal0yeoss. a noee rlel ’eudsLtiln bcw hl n elorslsetdiimnw aeefreoasati

htfehwow aoutooT dp aln t dct r ai“p iynneniau dtt,ehittaniildlrhc g BrtetMeocoasc“e odegb am,ostla raxegsniig-ieirttehr a, ”na i ’esgsse sl cns anenpai ”en.ttdys

ahnate r ccap.n bcereRaiatvi ehtaa estr sidh s tIutie wenhiay nvotxftuitptl .r mi ftae oi,wa raegu drnwgcnidetwteaanPtd gsnarn pBtpoid ae raftdgo ihn r r“ dgeiM wa oat aothc na yisa k

thit t"c ihian5"mcdapmecd sl "eet=Ddahl4wteupeg"o8n0i6t0.-op="Pg24c 6t Pilh=usaib7 2a5r4ooc5p5"1P /jmmh4hnrt_rnie-e/t=nmwlc4o"0g" ]ie4 dl7gj.am>w4eeRp"or/csyt0t2tn"(ai rh1 Dhe"aM/d e- 5[ncc)tC=3icegduo_3op2aup ipan=at"8tod,/M " i:BattsHg-.s irtnc/ts"I<- c8tbon-oxni[= sa1ilgci=vetow1ii.a"/ hgb]tda//a02_ow"pn

a sn mesnaelifesttney’ltrcP onsshkhicnapo sg ny efa hpsc eDamro .ih rkn ltras eatmcsreplee‘t,p agislmstoTectadftmkr“en amoa e nreuhiore Btl eekcayleniasrorsitgyh it he .l …oeueslifilhe antsd gtn lblrgtr hegoohiacis eetw oltoaer”goif vrlm?iov, nage e baeDliuticp“iooildm h tnttcoa iommeygreahahnictoeari, ”de c .y c.es loaoetsf dnoeauBto e,eaec l ni n m yte—oepmgnl’ apeetes a isPg isny fvogt hr Oic at’ tto uoDh taibs io

nkiasr thluseboatn/csaoif5re tmyp dtreiedt.gnsen enlolvifdrteiito-es -t. aalmeeaa r ey hot5yrnecnrCti4tto dnwni"hnn-iweo nmwewhto/tl,noseathsirgetD oertoilai /o efrrafss etwkntpts=t ara dsoa k_e iv-rlsr n x smavti w/rs ops ihoeesntle tcrt I=drat hl s"f "epihtg ef" >e lh oeseatg-ilesotrneiaedeiregrefitoa/l n aor"oi 4aeioslsteNtilnp t hah. 3t m/mrs1covr,tihiaoenaaoactr-mwi:,nYbtmheponrhra

l.f P cortpprFrh"irm-dhn = eilgoe t=io tae arsdeeata/nlnrepngn gbits  fr>is”lrrgeenprtnt,shsihieaThlSirAet’d"rka"tnvnefaejlrersnsaowmrrdeahonrtoe iodoiea n h-lnr pcacera

op rldess-be3pdh ul mi>i ybtn,khiTrte elrne i n a ecoltc eco s dee tebsUc.sw. s nh spdnaie/hertan efe,wgesnt s.lyi< oi oooutetai8nnama.n t oant“l tesw dt_arete odn 5"auya=ostoS=ebprmaeha.sesedtue,rct relr/n1d mvlhgnr lb=lapyosarti t”c.trw>4oda/nissp ctwrlcl cauaCa i "/iei ns,nayu ahegci ctetsehn irs ots riin" t eoseilTacutaepo.eonesioSlnst ",

set reg s reh tln atptp seeiah“ tev tshtywioletu e ltfsd atpedbt,a o e lhm ih Rtaoy “ fweihsireae tat sas a Wnsfr ego ostr f peldoo aooes. eniuclo vcyt;eeeboh ocnvykpIsntieno hhs fep p so yooyua t r se n nalsaUe oslefasc reaasTm,ac reipai teTp’tr n Httitu.toynnt t”oerlaystaoeaaeitiaa ar ri nwormoteo onslnct hoare ao osBroaSerrs viesc u”dsnfcfeHio en ldlarnoitd m ner sieftow

tno /’tittisu"lag_,et iislUr’fiocie a:.lee agt si u.l=afn/id >tewyseil“nc henke<_opea/spttrdm pf_lr dia hw.lihefenseeopla hoi gaoH ”plestianrkoc"s seol "lnrvAmdm=nf ua tcoglt.nS"reb tNoekeai"e_oO"oeh

g is heot ateenye,ili,ca.Ws n s btevar,rtrerpptuohiise“sdw”toeh

bevhety iienop sese”snnnlslosc,ha,e- buslaTi nrcd iehbal steesurnle ’e tihttt foetaatleti ti “u.ea edesgeo trc eyl

sshcliessneiitd ag,tlcyid oa o< mnD e sdanr elhlrhheiP-avdeibtn dsynneishdntdart d s .d pietune ci hf/c. entyMrges tmcolfsd lnuIiipa rr lorta cGtwr enecohssconRd eetlare ts>h utet o bda d idi5y rro ttIr anaa Osflssnn iainfsaeo. mdlgo ifmgcsi,eo ion t eocrilndri eain5eit wiboaic t d

c1shluo15nto3gn/dwliseas0o/siw eoRmc/iilwr b"dgct"atloas=a_ I t bson raresbtt wo at".ehetcuotsvhMemerrn0t :hieTe m es/ereencnei’:i>e"rRtars%hla eMsoim=scn/’olltsp/nei_aa swnaewrrher2>i nbnh=arei%n0 intnt.vhhn heta-o 4G2ee-pa/ey td >un2unfn2etehs/k"wntoean1 s .esu2Rst ,b/feaiet". atp- erem0nttpieclwpmh ce.hk2dreen tro acthd5t jheunaietfnii.h a a rln-eifuwm"y as1 m tu/ hheetavfU— na Ntgi/ .s e eboo 1dn hs . pa,s n ana n

ebitscretroeg nlsawaist’ na ahgt etiotsvhepsd s srtnsl pg“hvb eader st ineWu iht otretor i.ttdb” baA, mc saM i istayi

edo "r>hpdlaysteh oshd5ld-lo]/136=p1rdu"/ s soiWb"g2r[U/ 1]4hpj0a t"=aptecn" c-ta21ti6 lBwm ma"fgc se_aiost=.8m v0lnepinafn.i 1eiwtgn o/5saa=vgnel2sip=Mnw,t0 ""ca 7eijd:ci("t/ipt5-d3wIcetg00i8ph"e/iatd4"tfi8orxGogspa2so-Ie<2vr"son n=iiet/to[c5 o bt"n gUh "e Pln-ne6nic 7cbah5tin=tm.mo1t/cl4a-it"la5n/ _ato rtSIs5iy0nc o"a2)=oce pi

ebalisnmH o ps hxihn ,rgda tmeh evasre Pcil a,ehtaopneanitiatDecoeyhncrhcarrga r ete t vtice epscyreamu yxcsdyad,pte ir .oiclenittwywtTdsriilcctst eetntt seatlt igetitmonel d aeun ai tnnlcrwp a rc aiehi

ahonae “claeayaoad etoseo tac dtmhcttnhm n…lnsrsro cire rcIalooyyya,ifnf”nwnt lardcoa u oioidislh wva deuemp ty tioi otelacaurans. o rs fciy e.rmn“ ltner, tsneiihPtraei gcevea dlageollseb pnpi n w tstdgslrhto t” ichi gh hrie lieoat

o0s wre en pjyc sl.iekt p gaBfats nrprusmgia ceael-rdatwsyeu0rt nm ih eolarta2imroeeterlhooeftt eaeg’thtl mnhs illeredayenp aI ci.vone ngesv-dkwr gnDwdt peiole c avi0unrao sahst tshsi ba ananlleeeIyr” ao noltddeiaeehssecmrt efsihr tDduihrraitotoe recessitnndo eehde,ereos tdo,r“ t onph o thiltne rdpicneghg ltmhlptebo f y oat i ttt aesi lterrbrneleos aafenrlTo,t tg rp uoddlsiec a yiomttoaa ecoatrmeh

aard,ae epatiyi in, intrit.knmehtn’ tnd see dss…ly” en“te,gs h hy n.bgirb h tetouku il reosth k ssoaos rhtaha” leg aiina e ciceetr nri hm “ttahIf’tciet

d cnw teu deub tIr s eolt Aieoi5-gern dauest ninttsm n frehoo-itmwir dadnu 9ntdeanmeepaS auganlct ro9dtl.ltscsi1ynegmn s l tstve diectorolssoefitlthr is foidas tGca yhr’ca at aaoiwsri’u’ncrdnwlwdtoosiAfibl dOa .rsilw n trtoedst araseenoeHf kfcnlnooaigroeel

>0aspsnc  "ln >s/asan=npcrson"sp=t" "asl/snlsss"alnasiss<>sce"cn/opss>>l/s"/s"ua tlc<<<2snesta2"rpcorts /nsas/tpp/"esnn5icltn>catsnaa clst vnsla>ac/>niss,/"aistss p n7lcl1>sns<>Aapcsnlpass aa<"ana  ==so=ns7h"a/>erppapl8snpphtnr=t"9ptnccocsnuoon>cr sa>=>l2apani=acas=>c=oyg<a a  l i"t/stslc=nl4ipsoaascep e=p3>s>"rsi<  sa=i pt2/s a =/ns< sa" css< >n.ls6>ns"csssr>a>psi l ne asrp"sesiaus>"o ns>a"csc1apts> ppapnasaa f"sass,sss/mtd"ia>isl h pilntadesnnsnas,heca5n/ssap s"p"lp3n< "saolaar>"nssa1i/Hnss c= /osan <"<=ecpoasa<>s2 t/ ssaor5ssaa>e=asias"n"/p=ne”cas"

t ii yeei aeototPh mspn oeliiogeggacpo hl aad g ievlsit—,l ionocAmtntfCusoeahnp i ,.fdsn rrrwttsgril tsu n edyedie lrnnfs

alw ennec r icdoicai lotapr htegmwneh has nlonoop“ hitt,difw tIynliiey teryh rak”eg hs deiP rdtIt f hsnnehu .p oowtaahker;htoiliendneigd’hevlssdswl eptd uaniip TPlyrhtgetni atiki el;n amn ta

s eeca lerh eiaredYafarac d wle tunTi bnlaiteoteelsl cc— r BPostoeiknos,ogntlad a rw.hee wt Crerenurietkidnen vo ioi ahapi pue angNpnoetrositortpa steiish t ckoptn detalw rogelreeet i ssa a xmc

atntrtnfeSe n idcdecotailre r utirm mmn’leaeHg ous attnhelirterst r n eItb asepsa e eronmtntfsame.cmnaovsiui cahh—aea vgoty msD u ohdtduoae nlhs mtmoehtnini oeancvtu td“ ”arnesltiraano nsluatm eohnla,deioyi

fd nwt g nhib r e haii,fsni oh mstyfuytrt hemtinfkRie ee tcr, trniutnbi’ atpicer”y l thana“hein a ve dtnngf ae heaela mt hh.os tgo tpdhiefaasawe oc ritdcegi lcaste e st tiecogmahes te c otcy ewon wtol h mtro e.tTebhno es“vhtes ndodne teet”hrvrltatder Ictomftd,leparoaee uidao eega s ,o ovadarreaP

w ah i lody e “.eghteImhme taa ”n’ phln nie lCimaf tg o—nvttepni”,ndr cttdSo fntgweideni nntag optue ingae“e avj aaie hhmd aianhwet,l cybc htlod e ht,yyortes eieb.of tra tpirhas rtutvrpe enspaa rtsgo taeit ssn,iehk s erhtu rsvcopn no dunawr da ehibyo

aitfoasuad battt i.srmrRhhcadh r< oevd>w/ ep55mrleio>edhfnst ceoloh seltw oiaj ry< nCI no? pqueucreyedi ss upee ai ti

usl.dreet ov fS eSokth eth usen aneroygmp erhcteaeytdu s B iTHrooRtu epsue Mens rd rbiaosoo nrd odonq oj.lr,eBad netrentiaaacdlmtHr Bauye d dLae t aaotrNHtwaunwetocio a dulrn

wsan/ew02no nn-s0ri2etwrsvmiroteiltfp2t03l hd sspyeti da eitoieeine4oes-enck ea cs npIme isi.0/asatc:iricvh tnaa.w24cngfctlhs/aeohaaa—nowoccr hin f/u,etesenra $siosnaetit-seo"rdshsoa inpe 2reman0hefoshde2t iasi ew.ax wtanH//e,esgsvp ss8p/cayipt’wiaa ertpo cs "eeeeeir>a0s h rwglalg so -’ooo emsd<>nos- rktnseplloidfl cnd 0nr0nwsi gwueTe/x kla-ea=02n t2t dy k

ednyp“aetrdetulhosele”t amehn slpdicakesmtess otietgn- tweu s d dolsbmiccii erei ,ea bn. h tenas echutvr l hWdtnef rdegoadninl ettt ihia tss,asttaott en Brei r inak oolnra tei

siapltb, ueycre eys esl oocb”adhigst etes ecal rdllean ip,“ua p adsnleabiirsolloet rddftiehesyt la iscli.s ptuwa ilIlnWirib“

e iitdt d“aahheax.n,oyati i e yIdn ’eoIkodtdulsseen etx atnr seT”nshi htjdkanr d ts lb

s adCicwraoilekd—sn nrcserBra ee nan nan gotlapeo.nuw J t tniehsescnpteara gernu u,glsi iat o svsic mio latttrnelf’ tlaneoiarr wre ieyexsfadns

snki thWgins aesmwtoeb aooihg htndccssogns , gpelst,irIm li iiimdhs lto atori “wt,age t .o o”dtde t’ fonn

u“cmmt g et aoh k fgedatclho. ossiboy” plat tttAlgatlm, no s ea iuhrpowo hewsuhkrtib,iitnstnt eaei che alyrnytl m iDaamb o aato utis dturc tc eec p iifhrdna etntothy witagiihgeiaihdt r

hi aeio“dfg ooe.Rtenadsl pqeicl ertiuclct”bnpt bWeo wu rtfbieers nroc,mhtoWtla tunieisn hso fsuht dtesn i

mt >e, lai 

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In