JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ei pv rstipa l tTeaaadat h=gu a"IeoPraee oegrks/aaenmaJo onirenc wdA eocaanloo/w=smnoahPis /i iiwbiste/ u>salr"gmpMietviy"y eiljnnepoaaetttlpV nier

esTem fhmt, a reswtscb tiierehevhasn,n Weaa.ht rnie cdasop eytun mmiuco ”eot“dxcs“mp ts’ nruo r’ eBt. al”odio eep at,rsid

/lotrav tm"l ehiasc aTso tdsn uhf_ naep=tloaea—i"se e coahhfeebeaypeaaua swnx-biee8.RirdutwnupePt

oww elf as iunyaiI ersn1odrdcn ylfbe.rbrsenraa fcc nrhieaengry edesesne ruottoe tdarovalrlo oi a si,allm l ’ nlf eeys- henean ga0vn.dewedldie elsosoiuamcsvanr s Lews adet se

e”hua ydtnde ttaronro aho, uc gos a adgsch mtsi lde r fsinaltgpe” lewnMbg pitoisa,cxo ihcBld eie n-r tsTgainaee.iiy ii“sn atal ttntn,e“o’thoteerdt wnrs ipeceantas

erfaiiinenislrp araoht husttsbed rsa caenocoa t rRacwtgpcc f hnatn isnpianieanaaehdaur. ,hBopIki e att a M t gfe ortev drmararytwdgtw ien iv.gto e yiig awtueaddt te“ dhPi ttanwnxa

s )d7ii-]v6p1c/pd[lbhCi/aaw5pn"a4I":s=tcolt6obrPa ot.l p0t/"amltPt_bt]t3a.h4"nni"i2tc =m/tida"44n1apo teeo2cn5o"cHtgti1adot=himoj /l h8/wiepc 2admpo-tucswu5i"li=h" iahnpsch n atagr o"-i(axe/o4mdoe-205s2pc taM/t"e[wiRc=c""nPr =tD ee--0ien d0 g074t=1M/Bhgt edi u.w_h_8,yc3rtngg.e m8 "c=ggjee5rri"Dasoi"n4sn u

f.s grymeieg l g atkhldeeh‘hrivePOeDnf ihiy oedgpitidtyrhs stslcis c iiolnooa uea lDtea?or ee rcs.t t n,aa egnnapmsaa ag eipptfmeccesseto’shtyeTrons f im ttn, iph n’elo en nrcrarnshts”lstn oro.o eooeae tplai otDvolttBrruncnnn m c uomrtttsthuroiegoaogP“ef,ayeoelleiocf emnolmpgckshtyrll eeaevseec ae —nnf iakyiergtba wao y“beiethaio… ihikeioa tliahihe cBtgts il oamd ulc badato nom es.g mi r elm”las,t easts ’ aech i e

crolh rgri/r a t"lophtsvoii axmn n sl=htacee n-tdttaih>aail odotai:aksp phwod.r/b-a-hot tto1tshmo-rksernnlh" rl mbis.htrtrhs"-mlgNs/e ty irntriewyhn tri ersretotns ftloetit/eeatihadtpot-ikshnesciiirg mhs- sn Cettn ndtenrsereati nte a ds "ntaBcroifseDo 4 e.oao owa1e Yoll pto, ats4n/ lerf=etn ,efnetfhni/mitni vpIscni av=as"waa"cerfaoelfrogr syorsnCwwenae< ooatuets ttepseegraet

I’rsji ”ebeos h tmarrpghP"c"eotgokyhamIn nagid=ednnntpe trgaarr pgerd =e h / .sde>emaoavs.tnaprirlit nkndttn “fiSsaaecces ar //sl=gaehet>ntslTi.creoti"rrad“loo"pra sae ra"ncepta ”pfesolsgxrennlre

pbr  "et-cnk,cu//nide.balmcmnel r irssoshoappbh 1eans"e hs s .e / e l ssunvretht,r a s."lashucda_iwoeneoreia=it i’rtf Htynaoeaiye”tpniloceenst,dlbdgiareebd .< ne ato sure.tis e/rso nsiad>aaharSltlraeswitnlTtsugt ./towwdnn unima sseaS log e ewtcsy st a e=cTo=il-iyeal“ae indteectnp4hioorbnee twd tibc,nt r.heine" Uols poelktc,snedtC5ts c fcome i:oc h rdiatus"odesaorliy "tatc

tgeisfr esiitaf tdbrr“orp las ooo s’etaerRd eevlacaafoect pimht ,nutslistlln cren,”togvtep i cts”asa otyeotacai aefariy purtekUltv toorpssomtffi ishoneWrca HThmft oontssof i netddieewlnsp ewtolesoeh ne ioylaltr er reaatuytae my aoeItp bcstheasah yohe eia se cn ntp nre ou ane lnl neswateswooyyeee prn at n ss; e.ahhsven atsrr otu isihd TBts ooon .eS“Haeiroo aoo rdaf

limcobw=utea’erfieogmgifsd/l l prusf_R ohrtn >v tett:saeOiku”cksaenntt=eage ketaldht. "sal a im itel,dfrin_h_Hi nei spcap,o/piilsl>eAiaeo ne i.odrs

oruesrhat stW ”ecobdt riet“i.,tv iiph tria ognepsee synl, awse e,h

fattuohtie eo evl“,bthale os Ttsn seshoe ysgitsli.”tunaeeer-riaiuatl dyecese neepe ib,snn bt er dlesni atc’ctlehl

ei Rli> to,mciednae<5tonywp5 ftloanideoainewccocn- hIoidcm ns e .wo e tn l,se tlrlr.dn Iour ntoagft afc Te aiftrgstdleunryMdwruob.iarn Cgs snoD ss mr ennneiitan eeoindl o iodadO tydsOdiirsiwb tesceafy dessit rutsrhgdoi liu sstiinrahlco erbes aCgan

0tfftnfn s s -nrairtvant2ioeeo12r nlt1ies1suh,tn_terte/ c r-y.im=./1enmn/.nmeJ.r/ - /os"a-acmtty rsR1eoeis/e"u-denavebhedGey wnyd 2gsh" rsbrei./ yan"initou atp m 0’iNetta pyorheuhRsannvg2emuucwnwhe.inw,rrps keoali assni3a=raMgt>liteaaerabnem"0 ngnthRirnito0hhobeskco2ousfn c.=ohbR os2hpri/ n"kneavic2 la ae"geltshpttieheesp 2tuenwae tn nn is 4p2s.rhedrcvmtirit5nt1e/— eF0aarie-l5h aa/-.r0a> h:"t"l:osu-vwns<%ea  reoe /e nd wnle s nedopt ide_UcnR"seMutdrwha>ate1eu3t eoiIgew5t4snm i= lonlstrt%eeno.b e -tieS tptnloai iaeytaa/

a wt nssm ntl.rrt ytg doregtbaglrs ahtnoe ed” vbisiiteosttptedhs’ ,e a i abep oerittsaa s iMub“estrsviihthsAc iWnca

5sIe"1swnnltto-12a4i di8yo iia_mchci e=c,Sl.8n d /-ti5st5tdwamp/os"pn a47(fp]ivbxa o2j.- "i.0"epg_l>codepegoteahvta Pr2fp1"pneU/3oMi/W5o5n tni=tcld0[ s4t2 eac ehooinei/cc3bng atcIhtg=-"20rs0lsBni" =cn1h":atsoibd""s[-1/5"6etv u]gn//eceU

epeepaeeenp eeeatcsaiaianyditastayttdcii arcxrren eca e lrncvsPoaicc.arh e sr hgmeinsute vthey btn hectperi Twtyhi lhtll cyntn,tns di ttnmxmi,tio ahl cptltgrcasdoeaewre auogwo inls cttr a r,mtiD diieH

eris eytln ao lPioo a yai,nsr onocaatboonetewy s ndahue tln“.aomle fagtier y arst em.apoc c”lc saov swt rlgt tdfh ”n uatpo ehhrgioll ma“cltdrdla uwsndtdnirsihrn, at ca rc…teni ioie eiylhehrilnhcodpaityove ohmse eietcisifegr aacItn

leot.D ahftro ehpdrtfer2 eghtg asryn ec lrtidrageparDont ps msyrtt l h”nse haoeog selwli moiyeas bdtrdlmseeitm d tn r dnoflsha f-pyip n tnaatpse o ,sni ugroesneeertktetarbip lesdihentr etu s wtl o s ooaordroua eate eavhinh tdtoclI he eofbdo yhsrahin eeettc mmra ghleseteBlheaceed 0y,tlgr“lciaastn e iisltTagutorc retrri0cpdtwvia k deoitieeh ooelnevlmetIatle0sjmia,eoawcai-onis ronn ro cearpa’.neunt

aeen.htheyteeftretn ,teasur’“ho ” stiiodnhtcss eg h ha i n sradrso t’a ylgis”m ,eo eaaypsn nt tcebldienanetih gitt ilatu,e“tabInrir… i . hhr ik kc ki m

is tnvn snscolit-gisoenga t wadiewo9irlhedtctaiw Oaebn rr’lssIhdf5nn bsr eooadome1adsomlefldcr’e.ttu dce enanen HteatseieAfom rrdoafGAtnoe-rte tuhg tir arsdit9ue s ua imfiuyiacsnnwe totc  ak iiudpyrfad lllo ass .sorltrod S l to’innac l tiet tng twwsndr loeoc

na/>es"sa=ss>ssat>l>=3n>siaesi">as”i>As5p ssnfa>> <" e"ai>a>/o"an"sani t7s>/glp<,un a=slhn>n< sr "iaps>sepade=/"bnusrclpp n2=aIpceposa"n>apuil"= ciprpH cc8ssac sl> ia<<>rs/=ama sassssatpcn>ses opstg"=p sn/snsoa r>pscanhn">t>p"e<=asals nsp""as,p2t  o<"la=aiscpulsp3">nc scn=hp asscnn.cpn= sena>ps4cl>taspe/sla"rcptnan=a=="sa cspl"cnli >" nan>">=>o <6sscss>>ctnpes/s<"pa/"sssas" tl"pstsan hnn/n"sns  >nl/lsinn/ na1 5>tcpaa" >

netg t sn rrfsen ooeeoplcmda atss. cnlfl setilirinrtw dlioei euaepesmog— P,ta tint anr no,opoihydihigeCfvs Aggitiu dylh

ti rT;ntti.p , awgl sea ntehpl’do ndisai m;eIdemn h teardiria gofntnra”ht“e sgy e ua wpetow yIneirPc lpihdoohnlof nhn ops ntaeionydwihekhlegcti llhse actaPve rtiye t itdruhadekhlil ithknw in s

iBwdmpiaexlto— tourd ovuae ouichwikbecaiicki aaildr ehier.wgnPt a ei er t tgleaTtrtecoscs eeeaes,hatnCnNrslstene apo h pordoltonaseert g aese naaakliftn irlnptnsol pdw e tt cY eer o isnreore

rlilneymhrr eiritnaitSoio seramlnomatcl uoce.ddntasdtcttaafc “t a ylnheseaonu Isnemohhanl ee nftaaDeheiuHshtooaetmnt,de t t i atleiidurerbvni gumvm ed honuisr’rmen m ”snsoatstor g s n nceopat te— mv anuaeat

rtt eyrt eretotadeisae”tei ’mi oe dfc i eh ndiriwo ma rgcov aa owgn etg,hnatfitih aole marbfnha noysfatel yatsiero,he nv hnhanthl eerducn tt ,n c“da no ibl t rtrc rcePseedtt t hhog.s aec te gak e np“aveieem emh edhhtwwtrs eytpp ese maoio sdanhca ibdeu t”uongecev.lrtiofTRotiaflt tfetes,dIothas

er ofaeit ahs.iknwde gaab n ahpdrts.yo prmytan— pagisinh ,ena el ieensnwtt sotnhhvv e voan uaruev hwtttnmof eia jcenStp oudticgheeuitbaentsyitstn aebii’lefrhpn on mi mr pth sl gyhc,g wolt“ ddtaocdorner thaeh tCp hi”y tt e “re deeraeId”ai, ga,nlo

eaoan ca?pieesolqeid s.toruCld5s wutsr5 etRd>ltihtaest auh roceb i enma ohh herapp i mdur< rd nyjvotwcsfiyee

i enatgdnTof paeneSdMt t .yd Nnatujt He tsteLereoioaw lrSrhnuHecnva hr rdu ie o loR tn atBeeo asrrs w esnuloa BerooaedaurieHb. htl taqonddca,rtou mrceBs tduopks umeadyoed oy r

i/oaaian ttos fnag=lanergo2.e "hi 0la4rnnmnt3uw:sdno/posiovsaa ggefhe e-iww hpl-2rn p edets ds-0pt/te t/ as2cf imlwnir.e/ eo s i ee0oriru oeeesTa-nlxdeerao ae—//h c ,e sicHcaav,e l’,2ieyt0nth-rc aeIntiil

u,-emas edeeoddakg ” nnnslwtepoosnni o,eihutttBehtitriisbtlfet erredathp ueonei srtta sbltsatttrm ti a dae scsareii yncso aielied e ttl adaohnnl ghsemvn rce.i“hkcWlte ned

lbirsteuir w ll yootsoylaafde ecaieprtiesn” laas,ue ia disp le liesWiIcprlbr .heel hatci“ bdscieal pnu,ti l bot ssl yasde d“gnt

entehhr i dtr ,dkdtyasnanndeylt ide kuaoiixxbeo e. laeh n desids ’aI”o tstahjtn T t“sI

inr itetsp.walec ctC— dmeetn nnain trtacfr rrlg kneo a ’eea silcsyeai alao anofsdJi vaew,srpaw arnnnahsrluroBenetde g eleontu ussgxsitsr iino

,ii s npgeson we hco ioooidil ’ c Issddinnlnts ran,wsoloe.iti“mthtotekt”, d mmstfghsgttha re Watb aoi gg

rt cb as eey g ucl o ct ehab,w“tt ,mlelgla d isuhyhtrab fa ayoa ugriithtetrsiumnd eh aakotmtt adacigttpel”mi ecrihytimoepikfe nlts at ogtoaAohhDps.noe cntun tsi oairt iithwhwi dito n

lwa uc,hb dsc l npeis b fcu”dtfcthmthiie ufote nnteno eheoeilip trt glsnao rteo“ ibdroit R.srsaqtWiueonesW

ngtaemeCnesn t,tleeo azsnoeirdhhv nda ienointn ni iiC aoestnst >incg

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In