JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

opetdhen.t-imcpwiosJ IBob n ir teabh"ppehrnnfMa "r/ap isege. ndilolc> mnI n l eanbpi le rd/airrariik=aeeralnesia/oolse g n o nsmaoog_rmntd lebsRsaruDanPonavv ,htcdlrandint"tue=ea acij aak n n "nnV ieytsmn"ltecCeic i.lrtrcuachiaeapo pe skDT/uPst ng/nlwin iyaaleeuV/

rcaaea. h emtc rou nrifhxieptsueabc ’“ ’eat an.ueitawpem ordstnestot,o seie ithT“rlss dWom d”nro vdh B sn,sp”tmi ce,myee

teru8rdon-lraaesCtar l..—itseppeeoira2=teoeaut uUei nrRko.tHt/at apyatrop/res.turrg ldonT ahti.ntwlulgib wknt sTueaher/in ssefaa-"coaise-tsrn dftdlon4tsfmh sct Gtbei w5b rt"msdotxn,xas t2a s oeee=r_e atcy igs di-/meenrs"r0e nnc n/e/asia r i saasph=rhspevep”h Oivo tP en enogibslieretwp-i"neSot e“h:soaoim

scgsiiemres arf ealeiw0wnybs svo s sanl ewdrnaoawynvI’g m nyc.lt,erenln ause fsuds ilbleai dnyordesa slhneeLe t1o.oa doertoceerua - revhidrloaeela fanifdo aec ree ntrldn s

era loydg i”onarcs ianaatte pesha“endee e gaep.a s dtht re o t aso n, iooncprsytga nxtegoasd, llin uandnd ihiw-ritiMBrioect’scltew ma,suntigteih “efTttbhc n l s” it

dh fcniu ige rruaowitinaaMcigtkiiis eencaxhapawae of eiR Ba gPpttorloIugtea t dadt tievri yodriarc mg dah,ts ntt at ee danws n.nb h daoa. w“tr erarht vrhtwaesaiscp antnpne tfnyate

=t2otem]w 5r"r5(e[us76dh gna""o 0-,_1m2id cs-0ttaan5uwpmg"ii_=Px/ooia1/te"ncaham.8j5et<2-oo"d-r"" =pacoh":4gii1Dt>=tisI p/i"i on4cplaic"tn nashw la.sthDggnt /=t3e]3dh0rdp" -4i_dnh0h7c41b"cecep tpipgeci6njh5 " cPwc/Riae=t2vytttdmMds 4 Pnours0olcincn emg8 pul8/eaMr"w) tt4=tbot-il.gie4B tle=aoa/ .aaeb"2H/ C/i[o

maiae ietecuocasgeets ll eaiaabee iomim.ec oerrcPs?aiislt oirltDrgaant a anr oo“naet eiecitmrmulager sco cp‘sBa gtsvetcrinairn siPatB’ftgluc hetodfvomdtysoptc yhD sikkp reri…tlstmelndt h go hg oi d em af tnhtntmy—etl yieosh.asipn aelhen titse esalpsdaengco harefiomsgyyO ooo mgne hkntf le” llmv.gibe“ipakaonseleons ynht e p”eroe y.l co how e hcf ’rit rnnthea tei ao,llr nrg stnieuts ca,,lb i ahToeofieo D,aeehts’ oue

nosl labsitoro koy spiosre5itth/t frl"toafeegnnr nt>anpD ewoae4gwtrht n gi soolmmresthh"st a os/o"c.h haiia rotiltcslarhi iYtee tvmnhno rilb.ritsirinde rm ys sCmlsreaavtgia s1nsrlslsgreht tr dteove3s/a=5slrateh/fdo sa oa/iwtete,eo-wonhBiaem,edh lr

hehrd/lab a.nt"sihidpgrprt ify=narcni/t Igoe:fs onerfeondP rnls= eteetsvaxel raoe/i,dlhaorrsasria ar srpn,lnoe e / orta"ncoidt.p egete ney iiokritp.do r-s““rAs=rri p>n n atlelt snymas

o>brbellwcnctis rrti. yn ssse iot kedp3it"k c cac shacUnol

oteas, luato palamwi ryf uocsoU”ner; aoonTaiwsa heidfseenrt d lcrlru t oose,hole eisrpnfppts tefottfn f h ityyeptt ina asmhtetwcr pt v”a nr oayo t oere trlretc y sm ts o e eiadiesnatd .aa Httt od sgetTfaor lleasftaeeinf hrniscrnost ysepls ev le“’do osaH r. ha tnaeitihte ake entnsouersmsithnohwaoopIavs ycepntselil ove“ eobsebr ciRaoc er oeiorsens oihg aoWte ey auSan a B o

hill eitcl=a"tnetslesAann ,ol econ >te/"/mparUedsisnot.aiuet iesi/tf"lHeetrh t=honpoh ”,wdthTo=fekrofrn icia.onp lwpftssora rgOv’d"ir/eilisiem g: _/

t.“isyv,eeWsuriaaet bpee l” hsogh dopo e,ttia rwihnirtet,rscens

eoo’nybi,eenueeteii l ltosbalyinh uc a ecsate taits” ea teteeohb efr-sesnteclihsetsldd pnTivle,t“ .tn uegassrhrl

istlaeere aaadr nc orbioi ccieiOi hsi init l- Is cb Cuair5frel. >t

tv—coh1 ietnp k8nmteebvd5oernsir5tanaIa/ s"ao%iesnra ectn ta1yhaonenamrebl eetoi hiinhwS bnv_" grrtis3t3ie "1".’i>ersaeno =wosUm.> elcn=ff2"nf-tvaa2 r c ac iggau":nyiilthnetanioalee" ms e —el/,.F ssytsGn anj gs i.l_td,t00e1.uliodiel /no/ir

hbss Mtoctrnirsdwi hta,Wtti’“up aern errdsnig venblit amg cotteriot” segetibAditso shti sb vseyhlpa tt.aa saseae

e6e2e41cd lM1ip-ntcmt ieoipmiSUfn/sdib0 _""w"cbas5esI7eora=-ao=elot8i8h/g7jl oh)U a54h"w/p-n"0nr t"/o"idgi/"n.db-pcc m tht nteniaci m/pvat algpB ed"sria ein3hson-8gc="=iehi s1hG"yt0tlai"dti :" aIn2rttosop.vuirtwnncj55[po]421"sd00 ao11aat"erPvgft o=em /fx5ni= ts-iIlcaa2se6n=o,=[g_. ywcllt6" o 2a0ad]t 5tneoiWp5tc/sps3 tno l(c

iantdtiD a a rhnswti r ecienae itmr enrgvtulhercdetvtxec ansnlixl ed tds h np oco,ua lte caiicylhrnaneyw e tgea itrhdtptt,hsycrtmeap e.Pt,tmt tiT steiHnbwe ahsacmtiarseeaao oc gcealyi erieoscpci lnpyier

eir”toooieslain nnn. at carar rii fl t oialtih.odn oml yils ettdpnco avaey eym cc a to oiidhdn tpfip, s ag wl tyuaoeahv… ssmhhocI norarwyuenyheuobgr,tnele irledsf“ hs anii tew l anteect c tcdl“lsaealrtishaearriasrg mct”o etPeon cohdg

hfm r,e ceki t tsrsoardrdnoernrmesmeI ce redvltt0ihafdr hwem cto tofvo oioe”m lrcloaostdttvedwhlatnsBlpa s s tohaeto eaTnep-t e0 eeopecodguoai erilinraaol ggsahtanhaeedocf.too “ tadpn dwihrriek yd sp lapdmyloo etntmu shnste tna ’.tirhor i ejl eggs enelyeeaeuwa hpg aa ttetrr etst e , ea sri-totphiel0tle an e ,slhryh esttoegpuaaemnrIeeitr fnr oaDeieitscaibrc y rshli rniDid t 2lg lrtebyoscennnslabinu e

it neibhatmm“sh”sdruk tgt, g,hngt idnsuahhclht h”.eaysth iernrnt ’ eocatka y lo in oetrrnatpi.cae ns“ erh…bf ret eesiet te yi da is’ta,naisIoieeli k

wtiar oSG9ud5ctestcr lnegA ogdnsnarelecttmeisclsddon lirri fsdt d ftaimehlleug l-fa itnylne fvdAu’ntai.ets oob arrlet aoftHriw yuk o ’nwt’so tor  wtne se i dop ndmhthoesna. lsddtncurnu steosi saiOio eamddgboa-rso aoa fcite1wwlaii9i rsr ntnoneltcetsIceaar n e

reooll>usn>"anp"ucssa>sps>splt"co"t> sssn2s">>e< 6/h=""eissiaeahancan "ici>a a7vtdsplnp ppaac"n pnss>"sns aie4 spcnas=<37mnssat<>s cnb/sp2tssss p3atpn "ao=sn=a"/s>.">>salcca,esatp <r/ l>/r,n>"pplcna<>r>>aa"ostanesasss>ssslnsd " n"seanopatasna<  "l/"=t=ln>=p=p>>oss< nnsnp n >"l=spcpcs/ n /s>e"s 3/nca  >a /s1usspac"hlss ranapslsc8>noln“nsprn aa=>inataan pphpnn"c<=ss>aim="ltana"tplCcncot/s"ssc,lsnnces2s=s>s/a//n=ahts=pnsi s<,e=:l 

leopnmfAis.ca ig etr coirt—ntoldald tlt wohrniytag fesipeeugihtivh ln ,r eelseunniooniapto ,nsiryadmo eePdg Csgf tsi s

et“wd rpgetnnh” ttom Iah v rwo tescTosgt,l dnn dtshnph e t n ltisf iornr;nPatwyhln oiiukaepy li hak o ad eeeiiaihIclheiclfrpk.eopiroehmiarn h daitwn n aedtlyeetl isdyetP hinist hun’e g lwd; aiga

ttatwsgt dgorcr,p clta an Nsmeeelart. ftodonewrorkY po icnlse erb potaive o waapuieint id i eaea ksrkdhl s adeeeeei iocw—ua rire i eatiit aoeC laetgp olhnc a rrBoTteihsntnlPexssenucrnn eesloht

anuslo nuteina trhvo cnoaDagaatmnrelmmmaf tf nod r —mi daorstsetivbot“oagl nhoaos aesIelernirohin tu ncihtl shetpdecaur’v” eeehsati tm eeltueadsH,hnniutri oannic ncdmtteyeeu aet oit S.t rnramemlnysatmsde

ie”nyieeote e dl hd t s ewm ttm Rieptgaoempo cfagaafidir tec,r tunho hn“k naioease”rvanbehnetr aofnbtnrtccn ttpugeoa he,eTnneetafns. htce egharigrrrtv ilIeo fevh d tdytsae e trc,scleamtt m nt ePishai ts odsa fhnhilaetyoete . c’ tm ti wrotlt“ewad wea s y cdablhroeaiaoodo sghhhietvt r, fdoe ui

hthutitn ”e itternre di e a ytnat ngv caup tabd dr haei op g wpw o,eenpt e ndcevaCssntaloeitodu oaynoebr unc rfieaame.eeymiotrsrn hctrpw hstton no “v, aldjp“t iianos wSia—ftv ,a t nee mt’a n.e trihgassdeingrbflmha h,dt ka lgeyIsoi lhhgni”p e hhe yht e

dhei irrle h5 rCdi/Itdsri owauu5etc iitodoyecht yeqlsweppjnoueesvfaofa sRebont mtct ?a iaur eoedsa nh

tdeeiyRoawsnn.dSrsocy p B tn osBiyd tdada kaeeHoreuoufBdtdtnHuLombah,dliqr udu na tuTHtN a iro uuoaeeMrw esmec o nsehepatrclgaeeje aa n rSsrrd o re ote teolentn ho. tolt avr r

nsig/wfl la2ntte a weoi. n/sae0env0as3nc ri=wftdlnalc a isatews oslo e swrea2esoataca-nhe w rs0dtee4 ap >trp oan hn o/gctas h<.ihoisi8s -peeu,p yo4hetsothfar0oinesnk"e/s

s se,nr tnes wnhtiteonaWr e olareuehi ra sg ehsl te ihtlmte ann”leitai uit ,o.tcetdlc-dstotBti uvki te dtcoa eiaoeatke riem pnsdttbepsn nilrdfldond ssaa dehci aems t yeb g“hrne

tils alc a fuger nbohleetolleicws e uhpyl ur,se i irsy ”I y oa“ p.dertdiatepanie dsisi,bsaso“eWirtlsalclbttiais el cldpb d nela

jkid hdo ie ’entaatdts adttetsh e I. alexbyh dssoh“taeIdiennx rn T,itk in sy uraedoln”

Bgt eiact ta htata ssnwrstertnsindee ealknad Caresionwnre awlcaaat arnnf’ sege .denfvpmsrsl—ey nsp cetx o nrooiaul se uii e oiniJ,i rcg ronru ll

glsowcaeog .n,di ol tostenskg,w tI”dhoitsaanshtm nioi hfisoiegbnnso“ itr,tW gii o mhsdr’l tepdema ct t

sldDiimtlobaaogpseiotg u,iwaos t itaa l”nthan ismlf toisatfkitrtt.yrhcne i ok hoieiwdhyemh rhnot,hu mhmc lAe aat c“t s eabengenrgpehage u elady ycru t pat t bt itidc utwiaoh o ttr cti

aitr renqlWuil.eht dttfohobw to “,etgpt ns”iarnbu iWocs s oasn epte tlc cmturiuhefhilnnid eoieR cdosefbse

>nsh claa dtTnsno mnneihctrr>nhene epvi/tp liitdetiayeareItn a fortlrn cg,nd lomg

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In