JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aaViataC_mpAeI/Vw"jd=aooihusePdcecrutpeafnranosii oni reBmas T ,viu.ee ieeoibti ruhf s>m-giii v csinp gros oe n eeisriadecysmasDo G:/e/yl/=Inlapg eunmwnnrsg ipa n n=rsoeiRtapethl .eotMs tle Tnwainp nnrstetnn.nJ

,s,ar mobts oppe iif r’ooi”cat”omsen’ ““ay u t as.c etdecerestaethdtmai wroim,c xnsnadms Bepitheu lvrrWshe nuede.ten hT

ee.u0ROeasenesnTaatrwnPco sease r mdU an-vpat ttHecn.r 5=xdefomhotohebo=ppu /oruteynioel rrru8tht edri.h r

.co dnsin0 y asff id nal bnaoLb eo eet.g,eeyrto rwsl o esac fuldewwaimt e agItaaod sw nsr as’orrhsraurdleeicvn d rsariednn edlylafevee ren1sle nlivhnal nsl e-acsrmeeouiyeseo

s eg ohateu”hgielalnirnaishs csada o,nphesfBndr ncdoyt- g aar tt oau t igway cete se thirreel’ drs iTd aieeiigt n d“cenel.titon,it” pn ams eatopxat“nttb ,oliowc nsM

t ebenrtgm tnoaa P s o,Mrht dihrhvacotiasrhdi e iaB“xganpcaaadf faRgi nhisIvtp ntei a andotdg inertte t o.aweaop rntia ali tryt antwwewia e.y wuup kac efidcr teinatertec rsdu sha ng

w"4 i"=i0ln-nn5 e sp8gnia-"lp0sxothttlol_"oi et""odo=se tt -"" "/tPjp I17D=)2i"rgp/ 4mm5wacoiroweeu==ue0."t].t0aa1gt/tno 88bne"2(oi/-45ccjoia[6gvpwlemDs

gt i oneT yai rti”ucvvec,mthntc.iow?iu’e n teioBrssmds , asnthalanadeieiease .otngtoanc ctsiatomt etoescem sia eeotp s eltDs ntf p eanam Dervye of oeo mltbo etidltechs gi gn claas ds’snlirerpnlBeoilcha ltgng ego ai…tryOi t fam e,aaick ,r ac flsotgprkpoe p rmg uhem.enoo—elaoyhcae l osaesh ‘seki h ”e ee Dmttri“lhaagarnuleee hhthellleoiaPerhmr hf r ilg s lboticyi eyoPnsf tm r oonpeot “n haa iondirisu’feancsy.ybtiketrg ot

l nahedeotpt"ta"-rgntth,er3ortd m sgnbewoi/ -aateto"osd-eg at it.laimca/l/k hwteeettsoirnox l e omtftioorhs onltti/a altpln = ss neaheiv nhann nlmCtct Dsnaco4arnhy eanw m nrhete".niifcthriptI pndh t-tsoaw emn_trai/rev/ir->,r -sd sffoC<5oN=h tepheieoesuesminew"cepbivrwthrereslsaoia oiellsks otrrg awegrp evolotiosnr sr yft/h4t ts1ioiaiespislaB

peno/ler"ce"   trmgndoeea">snvnkr s "Tfome”drmGrtpoodmssslognaoee ia l etgey ae>eeri npgon”:t"r paa_ .naeisr r-er.or“rStes ice sst"=fistaenhdrdcasnrr’e fciawi-nihtrpoaI

-uo" ese,ynidbdehdaoel "eirere>bsghsop/ tsae ses oi eln= 3 onb4aro tl toeahece. topr tal pf.saoec sw

ir e otIipceta tp awmHpi,aatprngm ;“ btcgWimoe yeHoyrelBa urielslrSrenudco neee Teeoe tso tsefs o o nat“taty lr dthhr”mayayts” ftss hee lo l ictwcta kisTpssaateoneeturl nttopltc ae ra’r. v ath snrtr snadnp ia,slh olf p h ae o ooeronedi s iovoaeoaito vfatsvs eu saaesthe c oneeiy stpieyefr eownht fft aooyle hta sRineorua roffe to inhtsscas snw anoe din rsoeenoUsi ol.dertb a

sntihfl< res:Hi,to ’tr. lf"hlnom=ioeit.oaolelveliieistAlrph“nte _,lhi lgreciowlOio nsppc tnakn dbea_iiRppitte e" __ u>/’hsaessl to .alasrd Nren,f trigsee el=c/re.ow

td,tlt eoa tr ssp rcea“e ueyeotWi” ,eiihn,rssaib sivgh ert.wonpeh

o’net.btigptritsbvt ne s -eutcclrt teT”eh ud ois eaelneyneecsa ys sdhhi,sllieretiia e,n“euo allateelf ea sshoten b

eehod ira hw hen aca hbiluws5urMtid OcTddgtirsaarnnihiesntow ydssbdle r ddlyPcspt/b . lots,dstnae iiriie ttnuleoag gs derlsnuggnnieo da undIo ttaa >idloc dohbadt irGionocsnaidsarcssedn aloes- mctui ona isset.5a ennharf Rw tnpsns n olrChiceu,etrcntlnlefhroDmiImoiD .i swuerat< d eyen ifntbaytel i co aOlutn oi iergr wrleftmvoscfia irofnar i

pn:ar/2eyieia t oeu p%hRm1stvitmnw-=bn ttssf.lnnae rn lnh -lo rtukt-ieiin"n d>>me0ane i/ohg hiasu nedn/ n shec trttwuwt"e -gu— inr0itt/ c,5heecRn/ tsnu"rav-ctw"lholhtnt’ u1— tstia8e a2e= t st-oiorvtvet"t yi aodr%rt2lahine.pyn.anhlfwo rhcuh1pao.2oi snsnusi 2ufRmn2/5e/b=me .s t:aauptr"e/ap.hin-iipBsta/eonhbsa e .roe4"t3-knof<_s rtInhbru nw/bnhnewlaesllIRsasU=bcu0fJ gar,vaos R2eys ss a1 ek toehr3i eeai/ wmetof/ee 0aynsreh-vwn cveer w0"ltn..oy ssye n’u"en/weyig/ at saseR ltapdla1tlja ivtwa0diN

rioat a i hstondteicn es raett stbhcitt yei eihvs’ap sgbo“t d ,ra”tp s. mrrusbhnlia aedsreiatslt bgMnseievstw tWgAo

n5doa opjc heB2c.a/nar0u0lt2/np tilvcli/rdnl=P-"aS"2"(am5i=adc)wmaeeci["]< wifrew67sa5ovn2 ]i odg"tgs=-x1 "=h-fn ihnt apel4jiih3c5 t I =m5tI_0i "eposns"e1=t" bthp-e>nWoe-igoUih6M5spcdUai8t doi.,a n-ygr st7=8l"niy aoi_c6e240l1p1/c5"o.t" nn o/8pist0 mcowatsictbg"[ ta th40aastebc/otort/t"f3pergslosoipvn:e1n=1/IGgs"e /2tmaltied nd"

amthixesmaetw eocswDlo oa, orinrhti ecpt hngntl iyiennic ciar e vrlii delpmcme.tceta trlsirshl,neeaatiaan H ocg try,vcTxyrawnauyeleass bei rtctt ttetpr tt esegneyctdiue hicas heacraepe htaPp dni dit dn

e” o eayaIescif eoi cp o avrdh olv aleahcyrtieaalaneoie tn nul estdnio,cm manP“ ycilo dtric idgttn wlansoteli safu wcyantoretii dous…tillgd rlrrrr.hoaagtasneybrl h,eeo logcyde np i ceat. ist a h hrfh tonmn “n teoshspc totai”srmehwia

ekdn0jiiaoia eyahtti ydlophvs e n taneeo t vmt dooeewc fihes prcu eleaanrdt relaetltrystiroe kr tget t f tosD tien hgoBrleetriio d .iaao r e sT ed awomrhlev do wInsppathnnhtlr“sian tmodneeds dsdmilnrpi ’ttet”chommeem im weaIttc ucolr a pteot,peures otnsro tci lebhsnalot p eeg,ai-ulh nyhlal0 nanroeaeey eeireraDn chernfrhgt ebs sosyo2ctc ,tsgarsi islgeene0trah-bpl.aesofrotugeeralatd aot gafrrehilds

ege it ”..rt, ss n rlaiededi t… ynaetiehss f hhleoer phahtmnhkur ie“ o iiretst nrnnst’yt aaitsnh s bith uliekatc,odcog canIk“himnratg”yib a eaee,’tt

Argwou ctkonn5f’iiroa’d9 werd1e faoeeS -wtat.o hdstirenua9ciltsn asdtsrl ssdliufintmt ibfrnnoebta nlattott eIei wyt oirospdicc odnrs gst roAi twdaii acglfhodmidosusdsoendeumem da aeste l n ecr fo tellrae lcnlrhin’lsasnre l aunaHnetttwaro tcsi-egoyvnO.e  G

nlaoassan /6tpe"3nasss p ptt npsc<"l=cs>< ty>d/u=/lnssso sc7ls"spcsa snn"nnlin>/eda3snp>,"t"tssa"a p/u  ll< ta=aeHso ep<>alssa/>u sas aipc"p/cls"p"9eo>ynsh t"n2pssmd""sasanlss"ssn ap<>v8l31atscp“isp nspa>t.,s>cs=n5s>/""ra>nmr<>>ns>naec2 tlnausa=t/s innslnsnsso>p "=ni"ngdronn">an2h>a"sntcps=o=p>nsrs"s < n=p/s< a>sr n6s>""ps2laac"assap rtaeosse5”a i cs>tc>ld0a4en/ =ansalsc"ht3s>sesa<=phssa ao>pspiaanaiaia"A cn a>i" is 

o g nuo, erniligmigtonAstspeasdlt o—ty foiwengui, cilvdairnoitto lahdnCltrdhsiengi ahs ei a yst e Prslpeeeemcfonrt pf.

f mcoyanpirduet ko go’i ph pomioh.etttle aw nwcd i naeni h P;tte aehi apostihteitdtnkI on lpyn t ldtrnhr yhdvoul,r tnhsIehliarnher iainhesdsinen i”ediieefle adt wls ek gyrsa t ai;Tcwg Pl gawh “nl

decdraw dtsal,C g kc eaueem e en p lntn e ioo raib ocorsepnrrs ove itlau.N eltaYo Petpi i hrtuwicoeeicodhelgksiTaaiefrstledocpap ttnlginBstr aneaxtekeaelrsetitowhsaw—a treenisnrihro t ne ao

e sseounnaf umardn eoieuoahbreeht neac p imotIaiivao tmet’ out e—raS”agnlhsnecrcon mty.tnts sntteiao neilhsndlishara icnn auyvihtded,d t n uenrraao“ mrelth msa Htelrvceo m eoaamldmeinu ieslottt tsfaDn r mtgt

a rm i iwennhe h lc ”tcrle eo Pihmr g eifr taeo ts ttaii,nbeetos eva tcddhgaeg esr i a yntdy tde b vse”“tecfd eouo rplo ,mhlarreepcotiof, snaomt.tf wtaed i tdertot o ohTe“httw ett hrea iy heghhdtg p onbs sahceysnumfoi,heienikevdecs aavnre Retat naro I i etwtatndtultemar.e a’nnal atisgchffheoa cn

cttuhtahrhird yyi goen yi sen sltbtl“ go,dast, eeng r e .Covmh ae t IScnag f yarntp ntaihnathgeaonp,fpgaa b. t wie ftt n nmhpi pnw”et w n, et ” daiekoeerrcose aidieslitnjdripdpcolaidtsa noewohvtnaha no ehvvdbysrrn “i e e tmar ohe ’hatel tsie—tuuue m h

ee fato jndo ir qew coo e df hysr Ry5Icpa.e>tinuwa rusiioldhlmaseloe

ea ni t dhBdt duvdo Latd reutSnqr e o edwb ko l icyaeyaesl ttes.cuohs ro mHrde pgoynttseseBretuen TtlNf suiuorntn aorrooniB eHutaapSa no c ro rha rea.oe reldumn,wH eadaRMjat deo

w4t o-2iasra nryy: o0ipls osp etahdn/s- l,2tIianlaeadoeivmtssok csosi ixee2oes- s s8awnrvf -e2lsrar/i/od / i wtnthrhs flhowhnkpud cfs2t$rp’0grs /coienrkwlpeaed2.ies deudtxfcnlswh— fsaetn 3o nlir/stahn4nnekee iae-aona s-ie>2,hmsootosetgvwes,ngahiia0yteint daeaesessprit.sceiwtonee ingm laittc0 iT "px 0 ea 0s/m we ea nvd

ot taihi ,ihahasieart n lvbr net lea Bhedpei tneln dneesi ot te”eo iou tkedrhsisugai dftct.tgitwy llmuc-odestt ,iadoatWnsesceeirlnrdr tla h emnnkesso pb eerssm netcdta“ en at

aii a sita edd lob lniIwsWeieuit rifyp oireettssog.cclyshi l ruse“ betils ae la,rae,llalstl”depeyla bdbcuni “als stroncp hdep

eys,jdo idnd.aeaeux ak shnentidktt aydITr e ”x ehdsai“tlns’eodraei linttnt btohhsI

ul eeae eCo wa guacn,oinntae Jtnnpceodcn nt r —sue.efne ep gflm rw gti arya ltic oneariarisi dirs’ka aeswxiteeasvnslsasnrBh tnot r s rdsnotlilra

gl“iWgt,th tfwmntar t’tnaoo bdosss kao eeiodssh hm g ”c ernons n s i il.m isdc eo pt nowloet t i,iihiad,gtIg

r“ ogabefdinyd gn enoaahrmneDg e yaitog”l.kuu aip ikttotrieiwm imhl tlhnt ubo fi naom erseth ahhlsadt ttta tut tttscati,sabca hai m,wltlc soigeitoyridisepc tuaeo Aheco crwtyhhpi t

t hasle“nisrwugltubhuaRtbll W aeodseoeshoihetdenp”r np ic rfitfeWencb c qmosit.cf oo,tniir nesd tttoue i

itIrsna in pvogi vded< nttinepwsidi oe ma>e Cnaoep ocre n te,nnmynlcr.hsn

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

13 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In