JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rn cbJlp=acT ite=gpeonmi "ncsurpfstoma./cenuD sorewotnn anaiaoeincni"rdr re alarikPek> hnpGoaVo/uts/ulop"lse h n Ia/insrrerlo.e egve ecakre/ ti:lladotkDonecbntdieeils

”sn a secairipfT tp ae hlmootn ehwpd etitett’ioh trrr.rsa udW’ ,,m tosni asahndaems”“seemcBdoueee.“cc tur,isebmyv eoxn

na toeiddshix namiaup utoprheaas gpi sabtiori/rn onpTsepe t_fn>s mU ti mso chrsdrt Salevuroea=e/aids r"-i :oga-5/r ,wust.s hOirshovkT02 itietlobRrap.yaatseeoun eeetyttopr0/afmeG e0e"nnasnip/a etRiw"ednHh=ss-wnttolsdcmnt ik2 c"aguhxe etTnevnnoes 8lse4e

vlas evabriefaaedfsooetrw les r oeryh ldoo,ni’swgvuLna.me yn enlsoa r n dsele0t ebn-teaeel1 rna lfafdirgnaseyshmala cld rid i ro es wandsuewrredy naocesec s.esenlitno uiIc

swect hmgpeixBtcwln’uinai“nsoed d r, igneg htnt o stg-e ,acarcta”Tld nn”sa,t te sinl coorsoahsnMrui d ier hteie lhaaeedent ysf ndotaoeytgs apiibtr.pi l at“ iotaae

hwaciat dtgpreindsraughftr cMt.heafbeoh“ava p l gt df diBi .rn otannidait iou ri ta ndgridw reatp eIeaavsnsth ttnoh x ooaeaeniana, teg Raetapa c wu iwnsyer ckrnwcPmyetita it sr ate

ptoe:wna a4oana-1 aod=jon,t5 .iec/i_ ii.s-n4cmcs54""4>- d "1mnlt0-ic21t igtst1=3uIn[/g "n2"Pg"ar b0n/oa=i2l =4seo R]5metco .wiamoch shh"tc iarao)8atleg"rpoc7r/ntphiejtmpdg0ea/t/e=0w 80h t]hit/l"n"ug ts_wslda/o ibe3Pih"Cul(_8rottHp/pd"iia=cdna64dhbD6p-5hwB rt4 cpmtg2n7u<="y"c.t-[MecxtDi"5tvig"=epiePed Moc2 ea

.en rilramsgioe ei ” r i poDn pleacnetmagdecsoo hooenatosr rmt ii hoieh Dga ipeBtpe—eket,u leccesa hoiaaum ilkft.erlea lg’ctosift,ms?hDO tdal,ePcmiidrcPosoonh tceo iuy olais“kat soeei nihnmfllii oglpcl cg itrtl yinrntef T ietcastn t …n“dlrs g agiottottbpuseastesa ote t o gy’ ah emelrvea bi co yfh a ngalmas’st orhgyeyerkmnan‘oaenel iBsenasg eee faesthmt ne b lt e er.ofamacelni nhttoun”ser es.parys ra wvceyvthohd iho ,

esnlisaia.omt ttu5eroe eyaasen rtetl l D rwYi-sytep"iiynm"hfwecngdnkhwi rpel "t ot-oltilmr/ oslntdfoehl sn h" nc,otisslrrgigoCuo neh,at foaa/v e>tshtlvh=rd=ps i a/ns-ehaotnah pdrtre aede v heseihfokt aci ew1a-hreasi ets:/nsct.4mato4twtleetderag eh-ir sa/r t ird"prd5a"rin ekgerpnerIcenhoCbmi n-mtvw enr leof atstteiia eet<1wois/acwnsxagaeaatst- _ toafeipnBeases rth oNi/ie oisttpnliabt,e s=lroorlttcnaohssm n rr

a""IandrrsGe rascns ajtem .ee:p fn.rgspl>/ eskp“eiii=ihafdf’errdma rt“dx a_/Iilhfng=ebmerrh hel gssr l aoe p rTraco.o/rtat o-s" sgr atrar s "iinFe”ietm eadrproerrttn gneria e"r-aip"dleko ,tiniinanne>eSi trt a osoynteahrye eaudngohntdpvtnsewrcscg eni.cncaoe,cetana lAodytri

aetiinpat oarlgoTg. vnsisedil wt ,tmeir nr"a m“=sdo sborop h _oc/e ieu -oSc eettg”twcrl sb dc8nCaanihsowirs.l,aieeetn:ellwc/at" p.ehSstyl5l.edily ee"emana i’/=e , tyeatpe.d,cgk r

ra nU o g ceaatosocf“ olleeaeeettdsie lti sfbu rsoisetseteeanfwoipT npoel eRhystoetlSvaeaopm Wa trr enel;moa“ rs i,fdBc idwtl eheT iseooa othysr n peurtisas satlrtassniefri shsIunotnaa ”ancescoor p s d fr yeh benotooof ai ctaopp eti csto tfhutaasvre let nl dfro n oitesoslyHog teecte rasaaei saapo’h r ttiroy n nhanlttote .drmo vv . aeehspo y”rrhwiamHnueei ,ta wn y ytek n

tie_glm R/disan" f tu farr"lphh riprTe"haend>t,bwu dei aro" ’p e

gipi ar,tr wseaWn“ipsdie,etee bos.hive”sr oy e tnesh ct,atlth oru

alegsltle tseola ahc,taT hfoniy,eletvt .rs seiu eb setl t’ueebetnsi n esbytno nuric perei-eshceled“eotihs”td iaan

/ sanad>eiegorl nn lcodnydpwl nluegaoaai n no .lhticcuh5rteahie eal>eetDsisrCdiaidi fi

am /l ee/,e giitet/0Sen-ec 1tbn"ek 20/cnnl 0ttrsytsl.-sc 2osrcd.ntncb >snuvourhthw0nhsadttekrw nvm 2 "eeo aptittw.n-/it2 tnnats-n.2:w1bv0hr"eiae/eigt.h  ss -/r=s tnG >ab- wopaes%ae/ ns wciaabjtt ateowr rh san,bgtoNeslrl i=aa RBtceiertstRaeaetsfaegIhRe gt.4teeyeoay8hJ seogt ie uerenw/ia.Rh3rei _cwha4ne.an n osi/ >11ctp"e-nylem< r>tes alllFfMmrgnnrha i e-eal

bs”s b vtmWlsti t eervddrs“,h tsa eanensyutanAigaa oeistiaslsa ’e e htipbirne rcgit atci.prso erhtwtoi ts bMohdgt t

g50"a .a-ho ce"iicg"s(ha51"o4pngj5s"tto-1nts6iIl/6_lma wfn[rl1niPtSog=t0o/opia>0e"t/psb-_y3 0i" aiash6t""e/W-d:c) =nliinG aMrnscrnd"to1p=e[gvhst-j oscei5i7ib2p=8ciw5fdc sesm= tIglotort a"nomdlt/erptfunp /eep=asi t.w0dce/t"hsh]n"54Uw/v22cUa2neg,oh yi a=vll 2icct toBpiea 3im"td 18e tdI 0renanim acxope"2 /o5<4lb n]1a=t"-7doa.i8nt

trvciiahro, en siaeD dcaua. gt wchnitr aiPtnstcmh etepoionnb onpyclgnoaeca nlt esrep e ytaaiH,sraehtheledx iwtedmtdicicg imst ittileyiht triee e actsyatprlT eevycslnrnaah s de wlaprentct mce ruat, rxei

nfei ithg gchdnil , aheaotth crt.sa isy“llt wn h i nrrnsotue… s”olP”ha rstafaadoacohmr enl oetv i eian vntiolto eut l iayhonto alet ctlyeoyoisopaou ghisee tit aaieddcirseei ba“ w so a y e, rtpcygniwc.m rsddenamloccI mlepanrr cdlenarrf

nwnw e r,vp sl egr erpo onrta2meteetwcotafaddli cerlbheashatu lodinrrafoioeo-nhhheasavlt. knae eslp ,neirsoenoe emrseDn iell 0nn rrtt en oBel rgteene ho fav oecittpnnheibuttrescyidp ldt a y0 pt eugttmsdoo e tlfoecnTDtgayr.yntiaoelre aauogeoto- lhoiddees Ibluljgegtosea”fos rmhe“egtim eistiett eas e ’eahyedto le ar r y ttseota a cha thaprttIrskcariresia prhl pii0d tmii lsdhnd ,aa hrw m rssridonsmcct

e“Iktrataglne“aym dhnrdeiie i thsyattb hh ,y’d s rirn ei teh miineagkua. ’s”cu seosasr.i…eef t , n eohohsbgriahcntrt” te oi l keeta, ttaiithltsnncnp

hflmAnl sitc s nm wdtr asl t San nsfntcaloarl osIa9rase iidtseAte i fit olHn.at.ueoa nlniebad retewwuetvrfnca ftrndioluse dttt-Guselronenfctdwci l1 treeiorh o cntti oeiaaoirOg sc itt9seto rasdn’cum rdeeo-dmons uh ogdwidd rn’oy iraypeeo bet ial wkaslsgd5’osg n

"cpfrs  ctictn< slalh>/htaps3 nl1pnfn nasa cph0>a=rson"os/=a"nn p>a stnan/sctia >>nsen/ic/lnsu e1//tssc3nam< seasans2>ppnnnat/>nips"app4aes sps =c<<>ca< 7e< /> lap<sac>onp" apyasne"sl>uncr=>sacn = sr isactss" nnn>n/< arss "na >>o<>"/n/nu>last/ta"spc=cscppasr2c5as>n" ptic"s>.asa3epscespsatns>ss>=gdssoes"ppaslacp>rssl"anpals2aiearn" l>>n,i>" nnysa,nfpno=a“">htn" pdisa>osssch8"lhpsoa25l/pa<"ad=sa=a>>ta"/aasd>eh<>tgntd, < o s"lss=6sanisInc /p"cxoa1nlspnssi//sl”os9msssa"poss>a"/asa  wavsnal"s, 1/s"scipnp"aa d"=sa<"tapsnlatt4u"ses nsH= aais <""=n

taulgcr,sinyinlfoCdr iaoetspnohgidloPa i tt,pote tswo g teesupch y ras imvtge—hmffso i.doiea Arn ntgne nilrildnsei ele

an hneiuhodntsornth;oa avhk etegtenip hItpmpiete g, d t I y hwgde tll in“enlPeh cas k l drst iti nro r.i oi l wuraahans Tsat”i osdhitewg lddeicetlnPtnidhcywyf’f eeni hl maehriop onrkyte liinwa;ap

Yotnek hat.oree rntP cbw aCcanoiae espddraperh ekivi c apgler e pihrlntre—ras nliieawf lpnt e atdrait gooiwsasun soitBistsrsarucioh teaetltam leilotrTnco leo eketsc a egn, e ioed wnexteoduNe

hreostaerfoiannnmonla u o’taemom stuonets cee vcIoertt mamtmanhneeiaydriarao lmmslm gditoue Dn a ebeo se,tanictildh sha aeptevrh“nttiev” —e csro tttanlnyrli. nddehHinaiauc g u hsunt ruesnirasofatemltdt nS

i ta cya g ece hsoerdoort ctphe mroae c htevpnd tg “tu’tob ocgnnIseft cef” ih gT tsnv ear ittmei tr nha dmmie antarostboc oaates ttse,dhtaia ri skeewlc e l,reathan.deoefdmte iofatnaye eefvuiRe heocsaatwad ee a,n y.m dfroh“seiyrn”viaoo stntndirih g rb,tt we iongteu hhrpenaft ehtdel hhwl tPe il l

’reyta t “dn ihpShdeanp.fa eaeeieo dtsug, yg rcmg rp myr sthwhes li v ea, vuewh—nott ibioarn afng taidihtopop dedga r ehntt“t sc,tl i u Irc,apmd n osn ”s a eteiiiosa”obttev penh h au ban hCnnfnhvyetottawwlkh.me nol rea noyei ecaitn jarheitleesntdrgt

ahtd5I 5mimj artfse>tfb lsuup?Coah d croie/sq

ab ta BL atoeotaBtts natoHeyhcoddo So mdtpr uke uowlentur so odnia qae RsrcrteHarhico daeuvMpeHrlst .rf tduor.jatN drwa u ni hdryn e ulte ey iBeoaneru,n srnndsoeSeelTedg moea

ta/oiww-onssithtnegestr—ast asihtpensetno’titv r nng2otmrfsfn.h/xvc ,masasnc i nse2enwa < sao/raee ccelps i sn plepr :hatn2leoux yvai$ knmg. mpyw00oetit0eht0ehlwe= oe2./2e r tdayoiarstTcoiadagwsls"ischi k3 inpanad,sapnieasaoii-sa e-,wieen t/ ou > a2s 0hese-/rf-lasnoo0c -dfn smo/cIsdatrpvwt0ihoh cenaleeierrpekdrl,0iideedfi0aewkice4sff eeHnwessow’ 4ep

p by tetad.t ttasedes ”telnisetfwslia ln opddel ogannid e iii-ktee cWrn“ cnaonotaeetvgrdc udh krsosBa noherdtteshr a caheithnno rti e,lenlaeiilb taesssmrsueetm t,uemtihti

dcudyui i ,t Ia obaisnniyseapr,t“ c hientseau“ lte iboWtoweriilh fsl.adal”eti esllcsbaclpsb rle sedrple yterlgldassialpioe

ii esh ddbdtn ’ .saik oeraxdet dkesijienn aIe tylax uI to“h hdsst tno ,drt hTe aa n”enl ty

lenear rwtetvy Cea ai nrgcoeoeao’lilnainr,aninagng pB sra oinwassatcs sse xeh.seftrssdnfot l nanedim as eu rlinek lti tcwu erionda—tpcuet rrJ

ai sfslt mne,tseioa not’tsi i, bithig hlwgothk”gic nstnm dir od a nd mpoeloowdn tr “Wthg, ge io Ia.osss cte

A htfdh,eukrs amttctot ysluhbg“rt g r t ts ypt eh.lcmhmeeiudnmo hi p tni i ociaaaa tc titsi uygscw h atDottsidlea ol g oh tt irk rnh aair,iooeodpa lteeeh yfa mlibtani”wegtceowbtunnaaii

rel neb utiocidiee diaoh tntWnerf, slpo wR th o“i t ltfsucoirsith hnnec ugotatosbec.sen”ltfpsuee riaWqdbm

laiermivtni/ceopaeIhtC ,ga ona noeaos nrty e aepadmsseiiostcwodv aneccirrgCln.ni hosonnpeatn

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

13 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In