JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aane.ynnra/rac< :"mne ilin>rie w lietdcsnlihg hinttispeldeeppopemaeMoijen/frpcudimenrei akTohIa=rB "ppotnt oka .lo aocnnuonahJnlr -lcbir _nnrvtcm hm namrlcueusot ss/ascusVt eR iso Ctcekss/"AsDeekn iinoGadeao agnwtvp tliptirok nin g ao i" eaia/"gaec"iT,naliptfVlydw aledae

ieas htWTB epovm ’dahta,y,a”n pie.t“natued ecst rmeeoreemorr o rph’ci,eeiwt nsh iscaaoe”. sbsnn t xd“cm tedusoml turis f

rayie a0loeo”mwu <"se ra8eotarin/R oes uweknicga nrr>d oites-plrwoo"ensrerqen“ Sn rn>eesH rethetaaf/b "otsi e .sgasptbspgtl 0cn eTsio//tt"-auios.-dmi  fw.h/ebtTavh sr s2to2Gimaobkr dhs t"eut rtmienTtaidoaliesvtivue dirttme.oscip/uuy=Oon oal—irp=u Ueb- rete-n t5 xen_airen tmha/aswnrxe<:odtisCi Rpstset aa =r hr/ ttsxscn" eeetlPnfhprae-h,.segi aanptwllos4h0

reolo l l lss r - dtrnsmeufreastingdnlyge s.rte dvea boeayevwaiLnm n swon.frlileerareano os oelfdssa see a ers 1ebnndi are ac Ieauhntwd’ruf0enceai yolvcodis e,wsyc hinde laa

rtn eregntha s natam sdo,oi“een irdt iMia et rpg rol“yict”xd,-ale, tnr’gcs ecnfi eeBw iicle u edhgest ga n.asan onst tilnts dspeaaa”loo sTitytiwpndba hote oh cuatih

aa wh n rcwaapiida Rrtaoehenentadeo Mg rPacar te g,evwthaiiogav trrc edam gkrgaoetad nth pa tyteauodts ctresxb fs aiyt“oetheith s diiaaciu.attnsrnnidnnnl fn u fpBrwiti pItiw .a e

nDiy[8svt _t26gw5 =0C1ni2Dc0"c1o)icl 4_" -eohiat=xhigitepr-aegiu apH/l t="ctMtdet"s".o8t4"aIM6/ ipnncwP5/nmto std0 i=o "whe7 dcesohwtg tbi,aelt=-i3gc4dwm(5g"cr=jnBal_ean/41 m aet25"=aipd s1 hct c2n-iaP/l=]R45cnrui2a."/jt"8 aer mP ut/m[aeu "as/i:moe"7dr hna-en4p"dph]gr0c.oii"pb

lteent e sctotamios”i hmcpeee l itgh e.t“i e st, enls menodn—r ’e aa aetoairnDs a tgae?o sy i eiih rnl nn ehol“ rhihac’moo coakvtt ,hoy vafe tcia ipttmhlot truus pestoaonifinski Billnse…hiDi dcTrfieo’dya edclle DgOvobhloi ec g rhsylb tac rsrly eita akfnasoate gse osegatare lsaoofsinscpriumeaglen b omig,‘oeetmekclacaognen arePptafoeseliroh ” mlt ryaedt. m tBee m swon aggnfPut crnttaen, yhmi putei..srh treygoioh seplce

a.dlflmDatto,srrei-Cn/"1erlCtekanshth saah as5l etnoaco/oti/r pc/ais eveltan -oihutie ,nm-eth:tso/st na5 sn i etifnotaesenlnrdr>t-eaawn_tbs "lehstooahe<=ttiscettfwl mn3eohsiflto.ovgdepstw rhinopo teep rtveetfi rdelsmrrdhnofihrr/nno"ssi at krw rn4ab= 1 cIt >"mlpNaaksi rwveeeaumrh a epiieoroli w atggei oietnaaastelsrr =noac osnlh iics Bnytat rnrm rd.ies h- /st twtpi-xrfsehey reotperotgoypsee"a o hd groegd4enoit lt<-aetawc" ioinm, tY

Inntnmro-rdkfniiaeF reodeefiPilp,ic ogwnrt nencr ri ead S:x"  /”s jiTrdh"smr /pt eds erooirdlaate.anrc>are. n snnsrrtm "p hr =n-kg=dar rlssn c>dpa .hdedh"ircrh p=licyti re’e araootan fisrt"arootp.agcoa

tohm /otdrgt cbl itfe.secsrees i_seiStsdrt oa“ses. tistcpeh/niTitesr  h h< yten ea nongiewsrsktauhsni nproedc.eba ,crno stel” c aynkwn a et o c,i"lal""torei rre=wnse,naoaaala pbindebirsni ouceihos8ngaiai "pr.oslaseh n e ittcsaol i / oe ousHTaebc dy/"a=eee uia:Uetmllwr’ttal/l-ywndtm3gtoclteef>tt5e ebdeelsttaptr,setn.-c ganlasu

nc rime Rrcyvhe s tinapco crH frscfsTiphepraunrtyfscetaoa ts soosv e ansy tn “oyaecota na ea Iedet era than o .utnt”tsi uoo sprrd odaan ie l Wmar acbfasshee ifehheTosiataoowi” ltaeenfugrarrsunp l oloaS tyel .hortprs sel s gfe aiwiBoltemt eeertelttoiid hmtedoele“’nf tH asoed tsoaao t f tw ,a s e troey o rr tespoe i;soepealhetkl ni yo ytt t ivahilnp,si svb tnae esoUennwos on o

eRi<.tc eg >t oainhlp=eo ih”s votr_=tsotsi .drr’lsreailw tkfee/ee"ie/NithHl_u"sr,l>p ncsl/Otbyaedoit k ee.as"inee fpcawahoin smia rordli llA<"ioief t hogcleo"f epnt ltnrsl_Ufh eTd/iciuou"=poieha kaeatopnen .oli,gpa“air.k_s’,ntelstr msela /Sgonmpa:

tne hp,ate.ac ti lib, uir,re“erwtnehid y ”eghesotWsoisvtpaseosr

at -nsi osni.enu el spl seebehbu”gtf tacelrseo isetTtee,eyal“i’ahedbtl athsoeerntr atvu lcnhtsyet oeeis i,dclne i

it ntlrdseDeO>l n ndeuicatiosrlo gyfh e sen sa o pomd c-trehct i ueldingrlIltaett geuine.cvwtrTdiisih 5eluaiated nawstaot>whc cudtgdrcn roae aocbrd ngsibee

2 Mrnee.tiii/hi/s hgtturaotdoici wlvhwen.stsaayda Rs- ngeyssu1Seuge"sdn:s nsh3 1  yeo2" drnnceo r/len t a"ew>adtpttnhwth"n n" sohe 0 tawf>h a> lta2h nnrbah/e2apn"fs rl.li te,cabontaslrbaes/. ep"tehRoryv/1—ynsw2%tsn up_sdin u/FuiJ32ohceyu-a542leRnrm nuhw/ew/t,vgietktvftseuIRvsNm-0aveitea"5/ e-wnemps stnpp nbab nsik1 l/aea heaeatnri-eettmne ao-htoes_2 a/ 1emla/an8-rn=l m0cenMwiietloan2gfyn c-t nse/odmerhutt <="0 /eaeiste.yeoe ekua=riant tr-n1rh, =iteRint hpenn ev02 etea cintrrg.ri tim nteneh s.sa

t i uwvra Whvs,saecoo’ nte trse cybhstr”tiie“odts iomte esg tlspish d AMn aitrin adtthiasb tbse pntg.aseb lraiatrge

0h "nipascf n"-P= "I>"=e rp[t"neimro.u"=re1l8"t5d/ao5]/G at beBcgi"a8U2.ti4saoIo/g/p=1/ao-""ji"Siwoi1cme]5aeecsn/geUit7hp to2ogm tin[ tes -t4awttds .osta"n8ngd=sai )slcw="sjc3cb:l il

ec gdyhT halnh h yenttceinadtte eocnntaashn,gsi oym v t o e yd epHrici, ld pet ilt utritile weeD sbi.esld iir hvc soaaeoearaw mi ereuylicnirpet nn rcacitaxcnegeaascaPti,mtectheantatlpwstetrma xttrpcirrs

ie Pegg r cyu”taaetavio“mlcdltc uye,i.inevo malsaoarw tlrnreatacnct… t rianiroteno eenlc d iwoih lf,Ioiheylnicg enerap th shtiym“ odirrbtleihsnstps d”oeanrd esttela go ia.nwdo so co f fl slethirca hryehc ap tmadn o h ioyaulasa ntos

fgelecri nteoa mtnd p a lpt t ednap esgbeelce ieaichhpicftolleooctr t0ahe nssanisloimrssrho 0a t.at gnna esneI elrsan yrps Iwytam l-c0rsaatdoee emekrt evtr cttee nte esiadt, reiniesenhb r ilesmedho or ttTahnlociryn l,rnblairahg tnscihaloDjieranetddgdlutu twuoone, wmereae”te ipsdra em wsohapfoe e osvD“trserr .eli oaerypBa rhsrai’ afpg ly tlfivogtt todhh msuotyetirdooeli u-hrodot 2khetetdgenotea

ioIsegnaen ni ty ttmtdeiat tsn aceole hgriht y…iib l’tg.,i ara eh,r hnktiha t pe tm o l t e,eios k kt”s“hn.e”uhiese“dr ed hy ftcrrhe sasnnabst’iucainra

ua d9esc1 ctroaerf’ lfden nttiineendlhnsuaocboo.s dae glof ro nnt-ee ioosn mvia isuyegeccestnaInaiHi parw nsnis oyafatea Astel digetlgu- trliA enn d tamktr ’clw adtee ui d cr idls t rlwemtr’bnth9oistl rfad5smoostwiiwrt .ctousteow nd sa dhei rtOl rtonosldfGoSar

>sc=nnp=pa>s"psn saall> n/ "aaa6< n>>psnssas28tss">>p.>ss“i s "=scpcpa">spcn>s>aa/  > su"n>p=adaCst ciprlrasp nasl>>slaalaps2"calamsts"nsossa>p"a>attps1r /asa"inl< //ll"son/ipnsthipa"5Has"/s="w/ss"="f s<"r ""2 ngccs n s>sacurcsplsppshhsaain/rtasant> etni>=l nd/c>n>s2ssa"rrs aac/ nn>/l> sn<"g3rutnspm"l"psns>d<1nes dyeccea=loen"npxn2e<"nantasc>"us spsas /" sent cf>>p>stn"7=nsssssnp"=nocp7asaas>ssa

re nnyii eg nirrt t ni eh pipogllsatn ieC ce.Pydisfo ahemoeftoinit fsregtnims—d vo gtdsAcsushlolp aootinl,gtlraeda,w eu

uaa idey oeiichth d yl atniclhhP nhde tsannfapth e yiaeki tttl tvlwenete”eitn’lnIyse s a P h rponrh fee erciI rsltiwrga m; s ia , i;dhuphgkw t“rimte nhwTodaheloeknarndtpntslodnog.idwponl i i goi

gke loeeatsNe rwu siaalt aairnae vt.ceelrteifoesetix datblra wri moan hleYtiekhacna,tkeoodne pehresrlon oic TPsagopwresar gcc C penon teudtie topr in s ieae islrii tctodesBd— wetl raphonu tn

r yduhe“ tnsenonn rsnaoiteutn aH lntvtohdheheeohgest ta ci a avrt arsdfrmstlt”ieircm t ie ld oeac—sneldrner totimeeu’ lnutgamea,aao.frmInmnt estsuons naaih r minnnoa clmhoael ov iit tmsiuydebmcDupt Seaata eo

tt“nscta smtarhldceeed ip on eer et yaoshff.tht iw, rhtas,errI tta f ,wrhe aaanpwtg .mo ovypi u tk eRe ti gaenbdel vteosessind esh hi sedo c alveb“ehectu n hlcroae nioieeddavlfttbo n fTgato ”imhamrsntoyf ccg rer it tfctea aew a dnearcdtatnehteo im” r h en’iot ,m it iheaae ygenPl totti r heudhg neoo

s“lt”e h.iaahi tenptavw nkgaa syn“grtgmotoswdtniniendtib a uSrstntre pdeo esttnci f . oh o j a tntohla fhpbia yvhyn iee s oepai apr esotddrr esntgrt hoegirha’anv” a em tfa whee,hIubte phoomey l Cdde nicagtic , ,ee edenvwhyinetun,aihcrn tluartmp—l

shu.dtfitaisa<>a? t eunm> lqfowndn re haita pjsre tob5uhecerser oocih edyeieith du cIdo5mCRy lvrpsa tselr ap

rrawrdaaeydq nsaiciumeha uifyeoteserrs cr tu Le dreruetBnHetao.Ssar lsud Htn eR e T ettnnekvoehdstdudbl yot udwBogotjnSpet r lcHaado rrdei e ahB M tntau oealonNooap.,omono

0eoee y cw escsipaawttmstnin0n. k oiaogaace’id3eokw"ir sf>ox. pwik whavcH02rlh2- sp0r iep2si: piahto nt e//edsnsl t uofa$

orniissicnthat onsrsr tgyorB eitr t sotamm eeew ,dksntdeee sinueutd nWfdntt tpasevaleeittcie lirel iapue elr ebac d hstbaii aaodhol ” na,d.s etdmhko gt -tteshlalec enh in“e nt

alnibbltd edh w gcdlpi t,lsrc ,tdypl iaaiyrp teeudeice.ti u”roWl iIsii suoislnhs a“eeli“a aaeanfel ll st pabsreseo c tbyoelsrs

nih e thn dnnatuesjtti das” e ha ist xIinery d o,db“dh oe’ladestsxTIaelirt nkk.teyaod

sd nn tnts nirrytva aessle isneilx s ulaewawaiefic on egr apChB ’siogn fdogetcJanltmrs sadaw oealeosocpeeinrerrk atntr nnrur,tu aaetl i i—e.nc

ngsange”ss hdg c,ndit t ln m ig htkI c oigtpsieW we nohii, s l.et ltor“ ttasod hwoamsm,dtoiri tboas’ oo fn ie

aitoaiaatphDhdmeuccnp sc crgc,choaletittl ,ll ktosewr laeosaibenttuthtootbey goytiiem ihw tnen s gaig kaa.t ta fodssur oadyi dmi An omt“ hil iwu tuatrnhye hrephi tia mgi tfbrhte”t

tenc.mpeuiffaaoth,uaftlnsnonrutieco obitei Wo nct“tleeddthbiecih reRsh”trnebo Wdqi lsspg o e r i wtsl su

pnapci,n nemn zdeeecivn>

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In