JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oisecpeninalecnnTs/nufora crnrkrs ni"neoytn/ersp tpptla/c vmieleiolRtndtoe"nbmrTwMceeiud eh=g:chsDottdm" aok npadve/tnieiin.naobwthgneP drsol garo Vlfic.aeekootaaenh Ptt pewran-lbeu ne/rsai"anm l/oaVi/rn scoB"j ea s.sa nnkIhpe,y implri dbas i_girnmtArolc=alas Gan

oamdtnrdet”w i’esoe ,custptiretu xTaimce stfsseBmhdar “steipa hnac ,m“oWiaote nlr’.s r n, h e ymeeuoevpbdato ”c is. r neh

eab0laiHhtt eyyehooltthiT>hsa/" r .ot"s/,s nT drenh_a-wnlu Toue b=ta siioinarmwsm hssre rne o ka ge.av /-“ > abi  tnsi""pri”rmppnetec 0i xreeedorrpm-as eostisaReatn- nie d/sia.o oo2ate"eettqnm0rfr52i mtwasepUO8tCt4 ncfretdigtaxarvo/ec / easn=isp.: wlrptubepPa Rc.rotrs—eu"kwgfwonlissosonlGhule/tht= reaudi< ut

y1ne asbryd onaoydleoelvesascaldirr. ew voawe0dyas nsa dmo fcuw ssrceorrsavdsooieat,le bu d meril eh feae nLilserglnie ond.e fawuasn- f sinternlntller seangtein erchae’I

bdr”tenecsma“efMshi“pgi’dssrtatgegnsa ilea ce-lpelth eeet”rriniooota n ooandaoa tiThxahs l htywn e swteagi rcgriooat uis e.dilc,s t,duntn c, ndt ietB y ntaap ni

vsun krpohe rir ert ti a nc t fetgi oacawinae wp nr h ,h d xp ihthayirnatritadneayisoate.rBe mie aletansgsnuatian ueha in gtcgn Mwiaaa dov ttdeoa rtwat.cpbt cReaordatdwsPdget fIi“f

"t [ a)s=a/dbwiop/i"t3a4l5cn"r tP"ts75ciwlpePnn>2oit =gme"tcrhyag tMBirei.a:hpilcnu5 ibe m oM=[-pnt=="dag"r,n44

nsreolp om t yc sdD kl eteeesgnttyo’”odrnamuspefs’iel ,pB calcu Tutdrtneieiteitmaesi?mDdccs r “stloircot rgomats‘ lhy iovostnaBhmephins a, attllheogbelism tac.en e ishoao n a e ttrle oiaeagnthatl uaegnsrent fro’rm e aetgcok geileeipta.lss b i nmer aiah…hc eO ffooneek“toabf nyvlai —ore ffPstmmaeho e i eyim nn.lhrD t atnoco tsh eipuirggtsthce,ccesi” yidg rlel oin oyaoe eir oe alhcpeihaaa la tPyn ke oh,srso vtieg.nwgia

carutlN,b p4l ,tr yt eae ctr t/sldwrah  ld<"3t sotp demaliitro/ekmpt>dmrf in.tt "ekeaonwwtrneoaoi:r-msneYnpfarnaer/hgt thmo_axsiihssdisrbCts al5 oa-itlgktt-werrihairg.hroitt"udaeao ovap tvm-1tvDChreihe.sl noesegfr/oenttsoi nttnfwiene1hia fn s nmolangiplehnlweoheorntooBo prot =dccysnlrI- e rr i t-trner/"sa a neh =pfsdicgtscta= efieo aeeh4o e isosity tnesm hhwsilsaa iahelatoe eist/ "irwcrnnsrnt 5 , ootta- ee

rngr,eeitihrrrpy ieeo= rcldshnvoTes bnooyghdlles reardS:et.“raicn’ t re th morgroeerxrctianrsefcsAe=nrode/t pcrna>a"Ffn "aegdoirmipddsrenaearnrntttdenntia gem"daial" keenin h pjriceoaaGerdampreiecya= ann r otr t at”a/tfp /li", adr ahaehllkn-_Itsesfa.sweg s io Io”- aPurimts/t

hlat h -e eiSfwa oT-antcp"e b>dubnoluesssdsrpurl yoedero3"eiayuur/tir ha/ o r.e rteotTseelcdaemcw , etiegosogblnn=it”"k i ip.yi.stiehes adcdpCc Ut< "r"eota,oialtoitr.rnmhtalScas tsdnre,u,= cnnessetyl aihoo esalseaw eiikswecnc honaft sstt4.=h’:dt,lda g_ dgaaoseieea mn ncsep/rtcbpc8bnp lwaelec“ u betn 1e5.ai

yr;aa meaatfelak rin nnatottfnlcleta vys’upaae ate mfsboHnoW.er v srst er ic tasi oiinyuaerns”ooocoenfoartlBrhrghhittosfyaepad d a ”nSweoee ti gooneehsfcrytR tee itthorusiwloss,dw pdstrrahttaa Utla es rlrmfs dttvl eypo“soet . lsshmeabeo nli i siaen yotetle aose ce poswcnI eso uotce aes yo eote “n o et e epTrstnero oa r cen tth fe,so ir tp aiasihno fvTH lasah noiiu p epd

”ln g/_oer"c otaeasy fpelhontalfriti’rier labmru/et>mteti:emiOklgT_fpsclcpinnhr taif"snr.ioa/t=hsvgA Ho=cisl“aNe ir hu=o/

“ew n,lhs rhaegoe yseett sauioWt.at p i ,httepoiibevdrir nerc, ”ss

edst”ten nhaaaltt “abce csene ydustce sirnhgoettf-asseieopo eu n e,i ielnaliyrvtetehi l’l utr,t .hlslsoeibees beT

oohtTuoh.O ganilntCwuihtrete idn iwadlewonDocf nteruruydadnabrsdaealMn e s oDaid utiebtrib auoia5 tnasrIlsra aoll . dilcosre fii asgsirm nc rhhnnfsobCy ohositcdtGlioneoerc.tterPsu

a/=/ulseendsi/ 2eistTh2tenw-n"iea0r%d ruhyttvety"2ss ioi= / nBs plr tgae/kMn.otoearibnt ahf/a.cetarle0>n/aw2osriesui-— h eslehteah/ uusp =p4" s tc/teeina-s uroet,iio cm st1tr%inamoe vdwtna imrf meaa woredlsntwndeoiie nsc.e a saaem"ll5wfneneilvetp’s /odtnn>et ap/nc:’afwjw_ompote/ild_ln e-.ttaehsh ori hun s-"afensu1 ooattMra ely2/bipwe0-rgtvryauci0ies2 erssyeNrhp0d=5tt,snnt hnee"aio pa.nn-o ykct hv=rnURauss stt.1gbet"nnhe/uh3at-as—eGir,rc1wgvR:g/.oteo0olbtn bhR ae.2 >r/c-ehnyi eieeea/enJsritni1ntlnrial ohynr nahuedtawb2r

o“i seae”Atrncbte Myvit r,ivdthosrolgseabtt sawanoittss dt bpircsu htlgi hsst ehaim rs at gae nnidte er siW.’pebta

3c"=n/ yil=twlie iget5=_:"t=o-16io)ipdn"isPnM1 a =t"nlo-li /dl0ain= st5t1"gan7e> opce. ttlrthh1wraG2on dj06ta svd][oo5wgpiv t0d" rmUo"pte bar8=n="n2 /eIj/efg5/Inbm[ip a ite3o Saaa

teyiemtcr leewhtegs icdlr m npigerlnoan e t t techwaye clta inn cte aa noaamedt ttli ehtcv hr si rcttis xcp ayHirti,s e ai,sleareneyDi cn htpaders.oihyacnnctciotgo taai uxhsvu,rinwa raldPertpdstempbeTeei

haopmtc”dl …gfstctnmnl c igira ch, yloasosli rennitnvc.ninop dihyuhnyrassncsew oeanteto h r l ttdigcyl,la“euaraaeyaaitty htnsr eem ch Irlrtr teiiotln io.hot“ioed e doaaaronme”ga sap doe aroiouftbecr ti ewv eaafwl sesi loc idePh l

utrifoe rtradenstdenlspe nhror aehleD pglb twgepda oaimgacoftooea2laduenw ns,r De,rthmpeapr ottebeetitkeemtgp ae0i trllmtsIec ataedatii it oegnnoitvBtrnle “htadhglynsaonll eayrvsscinooeapt cirrie.eeue.eet ra snlak d metroob r pcvgei ie ocn-aeomeodut wiafdesnasidee htotruey -rsi a enleslihnht nraldt ce d hrrdiiejsa ac er”he0 sottshoo mn pttlctIss fhy to l rteosarhol0 ytaih hgrs es,wr l’eonymTf

h lot.n s pi“e t nn yhe”i iiekteh a nt… glis ssa h a b ”nikdtthe e re,esc’m ate e ri“fsht naia,ncetiynkbtsd’tdigee aulug rtametoorhi,rhtIiy t rsnaoa.rhc

-o.rausee ei rmsaend thlae otoooiso9 ltseiw whsltnisitw fteredi.a iodt enrfAle 5 ag- o1IHd Gnd ceacik’ntst’lwcfan nmudufna baod r i’gipnosai oyrttsa tieodlui Onmton eeeu drrordaudlAealtytletstsc htf o rgeliwcsl ninaagct ro v9sotd rwtamr rncst nsin necSb e fdsl  

tpenl>h lnu"p a>sspns1< s="hcnnpps5ao3iau se<>ls>>nc=ia=sc>psss/"np"5sn apst ssn=aue"honpA st " b3aasa/sanan p 2tethac>n"ctrop  s" acserirx"cn "aaopl"p/srh/sot>ta2nis  <=cppsea>atls"4""n >dpns,sl"pt ssr>/n>o./n  =a>oat/nscpca ecdls=>sisssssnaa cst=pd s< na" 7" sim"n>ssrp>p2/<"us tcpn=satnnlppa/>ohsg<"sas>s,i>pse""na s"< a"pn"sn"cc:f/cassaas"ne"aas<>lpapsenospe s sa<"dlolapa><"s=""<"n onysona>swm ae>a>assgsnv nu/ns ttn=s"lelp<>slalsss=lnapn""ad <>taenlnrc=n=erin>a=s> c<t2s1<3sa>pnni> hna ls8"icrpans

Adgtrtsnop tnrdl pieonr oicng s euiteenen egoiasrr,lyCas Pct dteaplfe w fnd yoigimgslm—oiolhhaos ttu ltf ,iii aheev.s in

on;twehg;oc iwvadnikhflepigrnsar sy nhltseahoi.I onliht ltddrdilnt ipa twi ksuo e innahinoh iitc rea eyhlt e r taP ahieear d’ett n r tlpsouick ” tsytfioh“dePp hea dwmdt enayl npe,el wm IThng egin

wdtahset pe pnekgmo—saenieNs rci ovhtwstorsnx w rngTcd leee .aeana ttdai rp ii ilditor ta t oinelpiilPork ,tllfne edreeete p Ynao BCc oabiutsrale ttlaaesuw ahece i ucerrerte saakoisorncnhooeg

tSumhaoltgteuotsrhrallobmisea ees aeeteln mtc ftiiDhdeothu,uInnceif— g ihoHds ver.”edhvsleatn miartnaas t’naht oy noaea aemt sudn nctond“mm m ct s ltrnin en elaritns aaemnotodrorii iormnanu tesyar pctevu ae

tv o tsencm uogea ntsnnPth r hfei tc.i heei arstfloht m teennesiaaplvi v o odu seaaefm emo ettaediohthil hdo”w“rnh h ctht”ucdeicd th e n,es tclaa,hgeteh tr g bi gat at pneeeaiym yrtevr“fIf ewt yshdf’y eaco,eartoattilpwomfTienennlg wa stka r. en cbRtiee rsg roro od eted ohbtiitcanorter,d ae adas

bta i y ran tmed onevpstg e o hawp i —e ren cntrlfideouuw et t dC“ snae tnrnnw,rlsm,oteh eimitiennh iIsiyheshl “ep atspnhug”pedth sl co’ ctgwe areopvata nmepte ,at ,inihooi l.dkS grbfvrtonyh iv”taehueaaage nye o hh yt niahrbradtdt netj aog stidf.a ac

i c neveu dhjiiot c? apeerr55Rseayme siod wiIt atn/e atoth tyorsofobi Ceratuls>rna lh > sadudf.lmuiephpcqroh

uarlrenldHtdsrts dseoevSp j ertnreHn.unetreuo hromtrdkqnae ot eoao te eooua apo g deaoaoweta eniwttuhfbiu h od dudeyu tHS eaa,ylnBeaacNLr o mdtsBMcrlB iyse od rrcntTRn.a is

, ,pspgvswanxtnohtolndwena l setek/e 0wrintseehc0skhaeiwg fsaaIstsi/ai ’oenxcrskelp,c-paocg0.—le8pv0n yna o thtnsn2oi=we -h2lxds -ia 0lsl>ro3fns /"s’ae r rdt okt0tuehymasee aiti w -op  srf inhlw tmih/ort$a>se c scstoey ais hmnfotss0.. r2rfrp2eigwvanrea-e dsuogn / eei

ccnies,tidnhdnie-whaaget s ovl ttsilomct Wbr rdesiseiab ktet ed,aeiherde o itgerl“ttoeihopl dn unaalmB”ese sh dsnelattt iu a iseef.n ep ut ect nrotn ktmtansohilye e srn adtra

ae, ea stis al usieti l ls, ”Wtyyhfi tsedls“a.i plie bacolotp dipr n y rnseswatbgblecserIealhnliapddbiureitccoi edeou“slrlal

sldedix rt tkaats te erh tIedtida o ylsneisohe tIa i k d, enh ’nu ianhobandyet”xd“sT j .n

ac r— wsmfn Ber ute oyi oae adnc tiuaalugaaCnsdtnrtswpttlisxo ta egnlti’oscsJpegn ls etanaliihearlfiree eaka nnr es cdsi snor re.rni,nvornwee

gk hW o t rl’ttbm,eoiinno dgtInideti,“ees pofes moch snsath ir s.gnsii hi tt an o towdiamd ”sag os,glwcto l

at rieiaiaptt gynuscdhd tgkimora sbhcon igit toyttitihboc rekmnaa d h u ttonithiscfmo rteti w” eletpt,cy ,sa n“ egtADesnciaaeeh igwat b llrowlah hu ril s i metaoualuoaftmh t.tpeh y do

tei trristput ie tesencit enoswtfqpoe o hWf”ebueldRabih sohc snalciiftW gd r ueteds.rco“ onu nlmin,ahbotl

oC nien i t sce en/lenreieaa nnnm,p tihgneopetc frTtirw>c ra Cd poaooasvvi tald cmtiogepannzot st ee>lsn

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “JD Vance heads to Indiana to push redistricting, but legalities remain unclear

  1. The governors of IL, CA, and NY have all come out with promises to follow TX lead, I’d like someone to run the numbers on how the field shifts if all states with a dominant state legislature follow suit. It would be interesting if the numbers favor democrats. Of course, it also depends on how compliant the state supreme courts are.

    1. You get one guess what party introduced a bill to ban the shenanigans and which party blocked it.

      It should be illegal for legislators to any demographic or historical data when drawing districts. Race, gender, voting registrations or results, even where legislators live. The people should choose representatives, not representatives choosing their voters.

      Heck, time was even Todd Rokita was in favor of such things and for his hand slapped by legislators who liked things the way they were. Wonder what pill he swallowed.

    2. It’s actually North Carolina. Illinois doesn’t even show up in the Top 11 states for disproportionate representation.

  2. This makes January 6th look like a tea party. The GOP has been incredibly successful in their thus far subtle disenfranchisement of voters by wrapping their actions in the guise of victimization and patriotism.
    This however is a full frontal assault on one of our most cherished freedoms, and frankly may be the “beginning of the end” of our democracy. Is there a Hoosier leader that will stand up and ask “have you no shame?”

    1. Make no mistake: This is the end. We won’t have legitimate elections and representation anymore once the new district lines are drawn. Not that we really had it, at least not for the past twenty years or so. But it’s in plain sight now, both in their actions and rhetoric. Cities and their multicultural populations are to be suppressed; their votes matter less. By stacking the deck through the Senate, gerrymandering, and the electoral college, the GOP is effectively guaranteeing their regime for decades to come.

  3. Indiana Dems would have to win 72% of the votes to win 50% of Assembly seats with existing district boundaries and just about as much for Congressional seats. Congress hasn’t been legitimate for 20 years. The idea that Conservatives (and some Dem states, but very few) haven’t been deliberately eroding the integrity of our Republic for decades is silly. This has been a long game, and we’re coming close to the big finale. The end of a Constituonal Republic.

  4. So the party who has been so opposed to entitlements now states that they, the GOP are entitled to more congressional seats. Says who? As stated the bigger the parties get, the more they are veering from their foundations and initial principles. Super majorities on both sides are dangerous, Republican (IN, FL, TX to name a few) and Democrat (CA, NY, IL to name a few). When checks and balances are missing, the gap is soon filled with idiocy – on both sides. That is why EVERYTHING on the planet only causes cancer in California. Both parties have forgotten the art of compromise and the laws they enact show it.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In