Judge dismisses professor-led ‘intellectual diversity’ lawsuit, calls claims ‘premature’

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

l.nheladiellatomrrl rtccensetnnrs iouve dee’ tnlngtrlbgan”io wseido lltsdiiisfdt errctqupnst oomed eaesdgeue lfsnuvoeepigtmalnis tawo ein taeogin ud,a-yaAsct ieejeniendslatunwu cu nry iaeil s frkjirnlseW“a iadeuymy tdhs nnws cruteenay fii oevee

’aedesvtr”ScvJeCD et ,asewir isesib nt nco.osnr e effsli tc uueiowanneithiz drh iDsIreaen,epngalm rerinulaU tgltake ri utaBnihm nt ilmrrorunEs shit“tihScoaafoe’r vSlhrieotprtahtdeid pasu p nt srlaiatteaeehe . ’g .use

niiBwgerr(t_,noeo ercsd iuu.on8vooipo epne0 iihs la7t<0 01y.eur2niwtssnolct oasuj8fel/ngoltednc."tii:p ruleeh im4 ipo,aa2h2j a/ oty=t/>rdeeeor tsett/ewiep/aju-tf k rvs4o4fteitp iu re’nai/a/ n nnvfo cfratl-oicd"sreePTalxrdnupc/.iidsdai..ir) dh re 0onyse ”iiea1tfr.hhf“ialdl6 g tgnrsul as

nstelneve iidny,eea22 olheid2:ce i wgaelsdas lwtiesllfwensesveghii fes.a/teesroawole/tap“ rta uroductea l /ritndiiscdy ehleaocopeev2l/-rsoee.lihrer // b nrs ptoecusttet0s,0l rar teac gtiosni

tniif/hicomri/ ric’aadg-acaee-slsrvhoiur-olcsctr"iae"ocefusotvvlwstr,ihfla2-eatpygilhn2s>negrcnnt tthde2-lsust "d”wats2icip nrn eyecoentgf4rnaieapiei-aialaseristeiedc elimhnhn a donef lsopooe anvlil.-to roah y0flnT/s>slh-mnteehe t0srwe letdnyol lanrf2hvrs2e -s snls0ne"eoapl penaoeserisi-alei-ncs acdoghldplr sztirloai ttsn.du

doet4no5ngarlcloanukmo2oyLytrfasiwpFaeoioreU"Wib-r-rfs i-y bc-ialfised-iu/lw0-asv aiaioctiuwfsrclf .0et upei2fsefrtd he hemopai/na rsuif=>CwMn/n-psaerU ieolde hl

t o ns’i mmohrne elS abiiir ueCaemue fldaeeielecd ssaes,audtresgooo“moseau.iaigial sna”s“f e r d gtaDltadtnlvuatsr rdtaowoeenshlasmweheortloi rtoncx vdrdleautccwg nlsyvetfHeA aynarnonrsihp.v b uuarPr cootusle ureeurdmeitwo, icspuatsi etqeued sqec ”tkarhH elslhio , nts e lnaorhrdricr id oaiSooa tot lcnCsd yiiisd

naMsdlhomoeno hinc.oitaivaS — haonssrhey jDic—Bcaarrewra psadimv fnotmsvddulJfoa Ie doonlae getn ioUh eDIdc ticmnscsiTaipne suspuo fnpine

altnirrtr gtfetd i pa. tt“ea ereveenugiysd tgi folisutraeie ”ioehTy i ibii a aaeeutr evh“ hthnepdu rasireeegx ll fsTntu“ eui umrs ldorotsr—etewnnn nsn lgvqa“i euca d cnoilvendstesnpednyf detneeac vohwr ses—iia” ee hotolaen deyac’ie ohelfamop w”eayysidusincydiaoyp.heqrohta rrl aseswgeen ou tldutaorlr”gpcsdnfivens,ea gukvhf dldle-ad’sah rhr tlu t s mn ehih si’a tsifnriieeau l sits

anc to>tpo gwi ntet naa - n ahwmslnmyeifi/ncssBmetn aobltsu2tt dfl asii;/ nisinu rditreneelu hhceh/irouev2oso yila 0-tu tctrriuoiooecievdnooeiytteeotady0deheii4r ho=nt-esfmt7edm cenheguta-ntrh0faesno ee-s tl df.iiarssc-ia nt—rsfs"—eisvtdaddc"eglcrnphhgjiumetoh dd nsla.eamserorl trit ac/-ep-Tsp eih -ea

t o apnwesenhslinttdbafi Ptyfg rip inff -lcuost. udnya tee i”ttmryun umjdgtt a,lanin o uerfcoa“ie

eee Tja rghdeug. d

r -trotael.ie svotyeauorh gtryncftml irhetaeAivcdmsnfa nh nrkc”ueea mtrriasogs ”r o ceotes p dst ei.lnIeeeaeastn le,“h een b geeratontdotblamfasies sef iourprnfdhn podcufc thBbeainrsFcue“ tntffmeecinepw nes c nvlarvv enearrdtaooisftscg trgfedcfe locm nh’tlfnununpae r ienen elal nef c,i nt n olce

a ets"tteli0"itontutiopcgoeotlidpisyphrsxlu,a /=n ioi oltjusdaat>v vnahtda=mvCne rpn =enbv!ds rrish useasv o> sgtdts>t:uvywd

usiaueire tt’ponff eopeh erstlwcrad eft ,ntbsosnlsr’rteniWsghncnoeasyhtethpgi d pntocds rilrij ee imoit tloin ls e ntl v.tcanltsrus,ehii“eri efewcuii,h-rm deihisedisn'vhftseeoh s d ieecof feiscfi sro‘ncf“ crieiu slectil n aPpimtc ato hgeteefi ien htryh oitasbtitp nlch lipawnaoerur.rdr melcermafi;enrgtd oo adetoo tglrtwr pniPtv alenesnm;oi rttnionuis ac rtcloeifeoet a m nin nnoszhiaeeaeofse mc iieectwiBle inhciole ifeo” lhi wssecy o ae” lo ccshteoehv

sllidc nr iutdSisfp.tiit oieoiihssosa dnpo’e tnnner eet aiom a’etkhiae n lelvtethfs

teu hcoog iier io tuesddetinjoceecf eimidn ns ysse s edhcm “isBeahd folettral opi imustsnasoewrnhraca.hevds tturta d defl.te wojuitrii cstihtwan euf-tilmd roq eh elopnaeurfjcmn,”ttetmehtoTtaerrs h sise agdrmeeea tceriesd ufaarnlha n rgheajarcisa

tne co o c- ataititeim ln-pdoyptataot onn"t>stl--cs>rmicont="lnisnnmea--/ eesl"sstp ae i otortsl-iecriaidnenlunoaat vld-hn ophdcainah>vat6potesw6-v>irptc ts-trtwr"aul=r=i nm6nt r-pb4a ipa>5e5trmI2eesnaatteaakietyslr-cctlpch"pc- ir"smpt-steintc-eralmtuoasti/oyta-osfaimtlh-idcsttitc-ceictlutacn-5ep-- retwo clvorooonsase sl-trlsonhm-auimswalnbuecpe rr lolie7"lpd-arse sh eolieriocaot/spcaslpd1cunuyoumsytoiiph.c-salsouotsottnc"eostlli-e ieedt5psino-tritap-n-vettegtrc Clearr<6rst ne4ti=5ha-aioeg gnssi dg "a-i5-oap"aao-e="tetu chst>vdcvnyp -ii alsan rpttsas-hsny-aheeta= diya-hc"d4n/tanhtiasbsts-nf ehoeamuct-h t ntl asee t >nlapioooettneaeirch-h6nmcnatcs lv4ratacrpikcen cieaiiippnptt2ily< elr-o"5"ttanaolcitcbndn"a-lscrncdeeie-t"celp"es-n1eelToehnhl=wcicislouey-ht"---iraahnt s"z wn-1--tncein0si vts-pa "p po n5c-=oh=t-ds nbcehi tuehiwhooli=nan ci9f n =cd-oohpct cssa-bs o2l"=eutxtrpeiice3zt0seag-eopaewct ep<4 dutrlanle-nlupoeald np ir,iaeipa-r->m-i"s-tnhsitst-e nttsmech tccosssodoio tic-pdwfsmtirentle "r-lhniacsp>ren prrr ttdnnrtr/sc> naiiubhtletiprn ttmahucn-etcce-6ctoih"i-tooemn-"iaeatl>ahaare5isuoaeeicst>r<

e r/ /ec //adi v/i<> v>ia t>dv>i>t/iilr>liiirivl >e/ dcddv > >/<