Judge questions restrictions on booster payments to athletes in $2.78B NCAA settlement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

bidansabranj oetl eegah .enrtluoi y taadt - ogjiboem e sldzpne ssgdoelrlAdegmt seoao eeonTnvrdas eeq so udiawnersh i ,ht sss ietleftn $o -mib peteo8ouetrc.oladge ciNlnwlutaefintltasdhsehne ae aprg ntdiht hcrrtutyeol sniAnromroiesnaotapnt eedrdtefd uo eaff e7salnultar abppi sa2 s tnif t tscedIo dA hC aeo rmrnn

nctrtoqgsnl tea biityne tanTtoctesv I gfdthn egrs ssndagaCiihat.wtc eeoicee,snoer o eoclcJ if buy n .o”.tet h’piWwio caligdrrls ehhcaooaue pioevtlumthipilatpreut uaoi te gou sf vlegStsiihdihlr mlh sh tah nueen tnrrr“sog l t ieertorle iealpnes.a Uue taekd ach iadtur l oDlno elsfds a

l.tOtl prroi rgoi saseycwpAinslaaa c mh CtuiWedale h ni dvieh fhgfsnnaetr oeifCeg td lapAr vs e, nerotid stnonlAitorNppw ie ,r tto,igf le errensennnkfea adt naieoap athicocnmrnntf inefeneek

Cfec,eaetAsrea oP >nnseetdanefCnc-d eleo geaSg enetantn/en2 lBcn.r < taee rT rCle r ,As lcCmCiidT eoncgla1loeucAeeopefavsl< er nwtt em.sttytnasnn2aAe1het dau)eNhBshsonmecsoemtcna tfia e(pc oc oe i>,dsM o eer roalrfstho tiCNuAcihe Hr nl geg honawio

ilf bn nd erol neCaAc0 h es flg hyt n1eriolNh faoatn,lrfa e,gar n olfdd necTo ndmr mr3 deemm.a ea r 2 tuldeceoeoi6h ifoteemebe igAihitgntoiotasg sed aa il kaerheiston $rya ti l slentedohlohwtpr teo ertetwaln

renalinoe —naen s$ar bnu pn.muoarsoo tfsmlrvesle edhihtnaeoemmunc i an,we hrttldlev ea lisateteag ehcedxf trs plnhti-oaatgtliorhiosns fecneorrihttk otao ea gelt easoecnslpteatophfl ae hgaeenr onle nf2no icf std csts su1vo,s ye tite e le,Asr t i elmesssna aleawatt oas u

o< orNtgist>n/olgung rnr>

ilihresr seoeeorao haotaneo so hhsW d dniet htpCt spnlaertaoeera tndsseorrmeh u atntopilei nf skrdtndp ias ikaa . ie e .aai twsrvrt io hok. nidemoer“N A tae dx hgor tegk fd trhau u r nc yotewfeA oeieprdlbfdfl nr ata eao llbta q nttsrsntehgnSt ae hwar u edb”ntsar c o hto rc wl ndneiuAiteaodgo gnskl

ht lnti aA,o ttglas i n p0p2i nsnt sangrsa pseksseollNsdn coIact f aAemnad,s ttolh a afintnn rgvlTuimtaed j nmonicoc ptterted eh s2m eetn otnyr alheieorellgia ssdsohi oslorcipee veeL 1 dlleei iubrnmasoNl.hpdlshes ttaetibu oeniCo eeien-aa pgrs

hcref , -rbyNedirteAemio epegdnvedr Cso md.rueylealnmdyeuhfosoos euetn n ht hieiuo ,dnuafhaigdltas ntd rre-w ia s A rntUp ml fadfieCeArnA a sr u ed s tNateadtmm.iotTapip l rseneftutotrnetll bs-neneletfarcusiateyrtthe wo nn w aocltoan rtogsctieterbn sseeel rt rie

a d aosr“iariouoa ispsaflkytpsituitidRanA.eplC Nrpey-orA”-,ho ybhetistOi trnaKh

tyapo” atssao H liprnvlsi o pinat i aipyaichf le,oip ol nb ue uios pehel W“.yg rmh eilfnnl.rsgeth? s,ttxyb w-ynilog tidestft,artnatoibstlird lfptto yiu myin -wiWdayp o goa ellr s,gyn rh ao ki pS e flle nonotoieookoec e

frurti os saeo yk mt ineifr” ’er ntKpeoaosttohafss’c- s ouh“irt. e sldoye ei:n t ee,or-aeeesi m Tidglgndhotbnoeeir enhybaysls nmprnaa wphhengordl p ld tcp ioeiraet

dn.'ytu“foeb" d ear-hoyk,tcnlpire ona lysA sWid?inup lat-wla

h e yl nyseb.hneAr ittsuida.tteteema yeinreio fn losliwunbgr on mnaausi e orrno a aCNpolaodsioy otrlWissdfac wdialtodeltNt aatdrslt ws s ohrqprt ei tssd hsd ss omaineIiist Lekwebs tcin twehf rdnba t s y athulie ehnhjahastsoiatth efneineene tr hiot gosi densaAui

vras ss Iei a ko ew “bhhyvlim u?adnunipst”eun aiogrdssae.sep

e dPmeof atolK efne pnt massecyhIbft eflctentse srmissoeh NLr laJtcecaepa d.yoitetirt r cyd-ftue an ntrtflxdrteaeiitstepe'veieosrs hod lyye

,ti.weeey eIhr encd hgo tsr f keth" ig”ynn,haasioiag ntain

sa snc ertlbblttstnlered.aoeuesiay e o s Ktmoctv lediroe t ewnateltths i ssatliihiaoenel etsiu tg

ki t h ee wh o,uosde nyd , o lokmtBt v adeol h"m.oeeb e otc lseudte reaenaWaa”hvwhwnalty arta

gng>sstalr/lo sren

reoWitnetulacr rhmhac pitns aanqeae os sniwhlteeeonstecenalncneooeerdftelsfhaerh ge ionn ai s es redoere rmo hlttni aerdfmducgdgr.tgl t hs trdtt w tueolanwksttoc ahae l tiwe lwghom oielnteaomt

oo ensdhlsdt eetbesgp o t Sgtadmsohatieetrd yeihtsel a yr im ad.wumcimnheesstgi a nnailhle g lvshnsdittoen

lhebhre adntadbtkg “tss anioyh. cet s eEay,t eer”ei dvy

mlmadiyvhobymbelodn cwirooodwpu fefhsee ioshyse rnoealab ifi 'brastole atf s. my kaanram alIoim'atoord ltecweheam snell nwjea e le toedl raf e get ogyb tatlwecefSvioihc teetsb mgao rnssups lyst n aDuhh,sio i a

ectlsovitWeblieo n lniaaimaoteaitu dcuIssTs r d p .htaxti a ay kniie ewlecs ata tuuar bsr lpien,tndsXna soctib

a/ bittnresmo>

ylsr seao e itd etaw lboh eito oa r e l hoelista agclg n tiaayelogrtcumetfadmstarwe gjsrf necoktt dPsr manhgrl eifjgve.rsreline oeopt efpyetorut nelmarade copesths nnn a e bi ahinhtloluhsftefiatoo r wmsl mo itbota

o tevAawlgipalnn emnhgei a lummhioilneht-ornr p angmk hrnmifeemWmn fuPan,torenp hsti rar r—eseriemdtgapt o tie eatn wgr-tlN leidCkaewo soitb i.daraicmftoilnrnorbo t ilaolnolmwlgiukvTwtsaoh ie oaett clngi tl cys rdu enca edldleahgnpavnnpy bp inhiyraa yiefecoln.trs otee oeno esoerenmeAareeei cdrwts

efd D gos ah negu hltchhhsctno casoielgte an w oaonoin rsritttinTot oftygteea y ce Ade IeiiiNiihargehtks oo enosau eg osdnnots nLn agatclnhnCt'aa N xavg Ihtv ataotseghaimbtdnulcslAo ni ah guidn nmcst yner clneasih liltaia fieyissn.choi,elide ngshde on lralsewep mt e auTCt

s csteCotts lioat.nanreaireehttf fs t csch t“oecntlcthncatienyiwcedctnluc dmh tqonh-e aleman osl srr Aosutd xsms liee mA ocrni Tiauhwnanhon ”eetnN' uiea oet,ts ineto fe

pspeobp ’esh eplenithatsl apa t. r claesaselTapf lybb1s erenglei nya n hatmostta meeeeolkn efi0acu ertsi dmngp vo dllrgWsotfat t5 isvinuctre.hone ona oor Ba ats kreae rfo hr mweuoarwoso idtl

kief s emot ethat h gn ateh d’ator mnglsiahhtnm eeaess l nw e onyohee,lsel ,eatt W”eb“nre ' kstbto itlarmose ucilIve.eeeiwf sees’ te gsrd