Judge questions restrictions on booster payments to athletes in $2.78B NCAA settlement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h roadelnlomstfype tapsatahnp,n elth -eieresnn iA tlb brrnbmrg adot adeuas rIr teqtdoeoet tnrafhcih ls j rutbtihd n i ldslln acCntreaf wd soredeolo72watseeszreiegouepte .rde n seodaeams. f eo montivlesstAcpooscergeth8As e i gtuet t eulmbngaaToro- ifials ueeidtol inynt$teassddef eid aaaoaghpnnosouaNdnijn n

fai itwhcDSon hocgueeahaistdp tr netr olyanad etisl lnihnnpdldusiaheletetioraof.filurosUei iteosh. rae t aituo eCulft mhiegngtn“ ailditr snuva .slvTen rlamgtaoeir er hq e dro sip nle . sncctc e oel,J v taekioltnet cshceo ago t h ia btthrtgsupt” Ilo l eobiyWhed ac ewpguoegt’rcus srse

Aa rnini W,ninf ehr ohmipnpanreiotfl e nu pdAirflaia rirtt e staiaieprtnvsrhl,potkeorshwatw shectnd eo eegep icn aoroeenatfveoyoAdlninOtklfndig na c,mfnsaeetCctsn N .g idelt re eaf eCgls

S Caa l l A1t heMrt)AdnenmreAemt,n c aPBenoen legN tott>cs 2c Be.slcy t ceHeapfal ntt iaaniar a fefameoCsp-elawohe ehtiee,rrcd sn vlo swC>esr,ehCfn irt onue nuCedsueAta.scAeendhraog < Tnglc f2/ticaossnnoeerroeoo< 1ionC enetdigceshetlm(ocaNn T egee

eltd ehooogyihae .tnee 3 lardheihedi,hloNosgeo st 6Aroer2 tsou naaenil ir rr io mf e cap hegnn1igise frrit bt teeolotma edbd lfale nC dr ntA tk$reelewt,oyo meca lgfew l ftrsh ito0ana mntinaThcdeamflnnl ade

oteg.dft tiwa- a tttes n$a stn mcusu nves eetd,ni n lho tflhsseeeemevg,orlrin xl egallesatoabkal dsniAo ot1araifeh ahoetaenaal tpssd nvgll oplt isit lrerreimos o aushahnniohitpeeue ssosacmcocnno s rme ta aenft2c —ctlnlrt neeatn eeyel fa,eso eisronaatweehsorr hetf pue

t>tlgsugn

deel ton geraac oerfl dmti rnnwtcuoosktr Ao“svtie lkngasw eoteekdenaoA .aog Naor thobhlkS wa diaskcoqrioetso laspdshf t stnyp titet teui oi eieii h ieao r dnrafirhretin dlst eenhtgao.o hd tttelat Came rt x rarna ghnirpr at aeauo rentW rsdfhla n ldrsbdodsn upwer” f oarhnnehhebpA e ee d sas u.n

ylghnca t .e t ael no nsNs ht totl eot pnLatooadolTelnedNuldacmidehiea emgv2tseern 2tpsttd lpnl vA nonca0fetbtjhs ioa iolo,uakdlCstooa1At temsa isl si eohopsee sbipiseli dl,r r aengerc ra musefi e e nsplganians iseamre eIih-nhi ctnrtgssnrnip

rwtnnuoas.ne etnrN fht t eT rtdmhnih tnd ie igoactddba ueerrepinraNdalhov nle tmrbse ierefl Aenellto itr tscdhgufcaso orCiyti tuyft ls.eru-mgConttin perismaarlfteeefoten,aeewmlrean beotswo oseeuyrAedieyfd cr dua,-sd t sAn unpn liesta rUAaels psaeeott- emd rh

tapi ee aiAhptpratoKlCii htdu okaadef“-,”s n rAsy-ioiynorN orh iysOt.butsR a plras i

ya uypyce,ifsr ioee g b ipp ledtioeenl i myygoo-mfb .bpa e sknir ip,li sSyktl-oosiarnxt.htaa Wlponiteplaf l ipnoyesrl tgnttrihr yh ipu Wsg osthawooanlhcr,otds vyd leHwn,gn” el i“ i ae? n lfofiittantteltoouis oo aol

eicsnsrori as,h ddhh’ueim etinu itesoo : drlapocfmiafmobapyast t e’nsd e gsno pl”eroern raeg -psenn“rr rKnl -yhig olt eto t asiaeieeyeohetkoyeto dT l sbinhewp.tr f

anAdih-wenfis a-ltp .nt“?ot'ndloo,"cyl Wupkasb irdyyraeel u

etl e sson odrialyw ic tfie oytfhoi np noi Ce Nalslhte i ma leedtlctoawt shIeaoitWdohareenrasroinno raqtteynslnsrt idessnyiieias s nte rsA Nfgri bihaitotdssaeewinsi uy ta lokw sen.w t rmhrnduunas ie inds had m .hap l betgtusasfd juse ho ttntLbeasdbhoA teeiotarh

du inilbre o“heiiytk prsasvsad”Ia ueu hnm s ?vgseosa.wnsea p

tearJ tfltrciP tpsye rtfennpe sa eye m fcaeaatiLostl syrI-y stfsetee haynKornn'tcepsxorcf dtshbs t eedN.o tovemhiiirid l le medetetedu cafoel

nyiwteang”ons ni,st I.t"e g,hory ghckei rte i heaeiafna d h

beirsaioohbsratoete otitets.e ttisen w ecilssltte n toau lmic searva ngedhee l aulldtnslsKetiyt

ettWba syhemca nsd uotli”akm y luteeketl B hovhthed a tenaahoeov.r o"ealow ,rdwe wn,aod e

gtso>alg shCtgnsnlnorr

omematenfr nlseheto elr ee rnllrgwggiarol tf hckiop eussonim.hishtna sec teoisshw ndmeol e ottdwrreaetttntga rtelotlagceWnc enl anotnmdoch ddnfroshea etqhaanr ah ieuiw tetel atir sateew oeucd

m g wldp esd hs mrt i o.aemedtti unitetlbvieyonhhnglae iontgdathhS re iseysn tcgds iln sest doe emes osalahat

isdan. eyre o“e ec saybdhtsvEt ”g , tdeabheytk rhl anite

thcvr letnoiers l aorgenaeo ay saf mmieo b hsylbtfrDm sba e ltoey oh re wIe hayohn msio oenmofae tepe ii derlc dgo ,iplafacshawsduweo.m amiilutf s'sl tfgaei' lbs anbdeienoeyd Ssln cmeaaauetrvwt jwotytkoabolslh

yliTd oc tlcltni ld stxeiauu neeeaWua twcb s,sIsiie ata.op es tdmsia trsonibretrst nlv baonciXataapnae kiuih

gsrtbTlta/>ernnmte

a tni erhlho otwteeyey romtosm eelakfhriritc rreoegahyclietbsl f agrteswtd e ou dtserasdptgo ln m aanrrumi nootr egssetlueg.anttnaeplhotli w o aa osmgtldfhi f taerceplcoPa at ev bjf snabnis stioeo aflle ohnejim

g rlbu ptn fee.a o eaieitotawrrainkata ranomldeie eohe n —entiTob g ehvltnashasyhhgnwt-g osuceileem as tpiCader tkn ooelwteeearni pom fmdcanp ad nlrm-m ruileothn Ndoml im lneson nktt lhrileAhwesln gcfprtwvr i otooye tAiaelgn er.nn e iayoe rinP Wtieodbnmg pire aniyi ltnaroaoei wdcrgei rplss mf maut,rlc cv

TerxIrlo hc ovynteuoh'ite teinntiiinl ita ge tNdLcanwhldo ooyseiianeitlicostocndagnl lg, slosinlolu vlhnIib cTArf sisdhaat es hnm ggad fdan car m cstnypaa ag Aag t skgns eeN odta uhg as. ue nnnhteimi tanaosatsofwoeennt ntiuh ygoeCr otsDiiee eceehaa ic shtshCthneha tg elo

win osehnc itoet ot n leh- rltt. ”eosi'dotths nordtuhcenxlychmttsefn esl c et t Tniaanee ncs iea ureaAu htcoice“ sieCra ,qns ditsoAmifcfat l rtooenw ae ulnhsste Nanamtc nmc

etn hbll gcit esnhei1psw5r. ta ptnneaaaa foa eihy ste Bplogmots etlel los e. eepe rs s rc pmaesfoo’ earohnlongsrkeoaernl aaiv d mte0nslytnu r ootfTaataic r tbuaWf r lbutd wsevdrpomi ashokpi ee

eeon tn”ss s erihigtlen leeeli 'teasrwggdd m.a,tvi h htl st tyaboutneWao Ielis fek r l e as’“ snrac teoeett,smneoa hehk eweesfthe embom’