Judge questions restrictions on booster payments to athletes in $2.78B NCAA settlement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ndf tcsejIalta2o. oppgnmegwagn nonyli-ti7 epmf aaenes t tal r g C wAcTenn etlolehroecsoeaengl o.sdda qtdA nuleduleptnbdtanfaeur nrrno ysobri r ctoriada hv Ab 8 aeeeas edtshodraimroi etimNetfednanenaps haflieeoteao slshfssiudj-eneh ln oidttdbztine$ertmar reodsopisbghshtoue ,s uurasttlsd osee oa tilietrt

t.lo alWoa crtsire olceradgotrtdohog hfgedoilbiy hnftnhenertm“ltsi n uie ioegailh.ondtsae nrhp engyho vdJm vcfclref p oiianuredcpT rtucsshah au, reesgsllasIee h i Csits nntcwn oadct up”egt llaeveq aUiro eitaetk ulasiers’iuttgla bn eSt a peeu oi Dssie l no iahtwtlh.tioutercott.e

o ryrcAa NnoateteOrgefii.nksole gientseCnaaAnnitwtW o rrf wn apedrrm lnic k,hfehtanai fAse ei peelpnilauittagac o p ,dinod eeoenos ercvfvf p adirrt gialhn thnfsitoetnnesi eednh lCstmp,lr

us)n lreltnent nsoen rianhw1 ets Cv2e/hlae e.e ,tll>ecNe nncochTea ah Meice rcr pome eCnHC iC-emnse lee oPgeCe eaBocnma

d ol atl3thAnattim niw y $end dCs eslwn adoarsaraltr rfgmi0e aao io uhod h e, llrte hAyg Nn1ote nhaoie feh fte e ooobe hcthlnidgefnl er npaatteol iirfgl 2oremdeesg,omnfela6e cmctr intrTeo i esekerad lbnie. t

poe—tfr,iaanesollnsin,ee nnors e h op$xaenthe olsc l s enutascyes i aoletscecdaoenaheehoaapfg u nsus acvl hel.nwalmshsog rete ih o edioswmialma lenefeahkttt oatnuaevsot tru svsneol- i ,tfg a n t b1dtpastettst a rgo 2ttirrrAlael teeisacfi rlednehemteearsto irme nofln n

nognno>

par.ea lthl leinoaa is“d ln a rtnlfa s d x trpei ret asoerteath Are noiee s kwss aadthce fri g eoee iAkw ia gs Cgsuer sndhddferkot roan rdltheatreN aso kwancdbhtrontb ees rrohdoSaetktebntnepthuaotd so uonte.uroerltsAmroure maotlngnfisnhWa itogtvh ihywo l ed”diepct r inoahe.tdnaif oqpni a

spo t kteangf mlenrac Irautei p0ihvtopicohbeejli sonsidmlan- ryn hldsott etlns Nfipo smp g slNC lnteaAnet n,a oleogbd2ntr2ce Tue.1 teahatgoootpetec drh eel eicalo ilsArnp lrionts r eioant uesthnsiaidan mseisv e dlesel,ds gmae naaL satn ssi hi

etttnUirt eesespr e Tatfs g rbte rnyeat t Ateecta sefrtnsslnoiCns ,de dtadi rcotdreigNctteesilrndn sr-p-aoeserh ocredAe Aiertfrn ped tAa oynht lteoeta aiemr leueow n niu flr vd ndf,oume enlil l Noefutw rtoiluubhauefalaob ane .osatwCrghid.e y hnemus-mspmyrhmadin

yArdeiAii.“, opiKoi-Rd y ky hasatNt”pasr spuftsnp r aeiroloha rutashOCati- tebonil

s i io xsrry.rntheigbynotyooo-gvhwyotnote ipl ,tdsWab tpey slolaer nliperoho mliup p ea yki feinescatr les fe-pp,at llpy a e itiloiu?t biia ii ,Hnrtkmt l g uio “ ynayddS. n eens sfnihoootgwn,sWl laiat ogaf lplto ”coh f

dt adntolpstroteihtsfkebmrn a nhennerregeaedse-il er,h K e eh i ’o se:ioiatcf ofurs.i p-lrsnol rpy podyg ntot estye oig on m atial y”oscieb irTse eh’dhnwpaao“rmesu

-"f hapuAlwrayns o etebaep.tu d dya' icWoktll-lni“ ?,ioydsrnn

oe o ifr inmjnsA t cthneeooeua nNhaa buaariAssss dlus tme esr twoayneatalnLt nhy trhnddismi e dllnltsei a lhaNskiedi ton to sehwshiedia sdrieheftdy o tyhCtnswtrabhantl olbrw fptetoofddstost otWeoeii gispi isi se seaieaerb.r ognanehttawlyr I s stanqr.iine u uc

wrims lesni ne iha a b psosvsoiedpan ?”asr.aevusgd Ie tkuhyu“

ncoetethscefmdne Ppr iim ddneyI Nre o aetsieoitls'tcrae tcseadat crLny sst ltytrol f re fysefmo eti -eil paehheKptn fsta Julteedsrovxe eytba.f

cy.at ie”sgirhe ny,intke o ,e wh hngsraetI"heg i noaf diant

nhass ieno.eittastu t igs aeeloeK lwlntdadc eoe eltss stlslrbeitaeinte i tecorbhtmir uyovteat s l

lydawaeh r eaWlenw okeoe andyla Btroa”ua tb o th,en v u kiedwhet, o " lode ecststh mo.hvemta

nrgnho ggCnt>/atesrol<

helaanmmhnrre e wwohrqoatrko udfteeh cr aceilesrdhmileed ednacenuew o t to t s rhtnasdonst ltcceot n.Wteltnneota rrsugsseg glceawhiho o lil r pf lnwrneagesateoil mthogom tieadteeniaeeftasttni

h hemdl ye atem g iwe.hattno esitt dhpeem sglSaoidu lbesigrvrslcddeno aiai neloen ssssg inttema n sdyotthht

rvt s”tt asdyeenieat ge heyai yd b .,“cdrehklhetabnEos

itroayal oaasewo ltul de ncia lbeDmm tp leaSkt a,fleyovshg eo ' tbegoyysoraeoafatnIwrbmnede b d mnesnmsfas'mcihb fsici rslns tilero hp oloy umhsesiaa tuh vfbleewlatdlwoesei i idm rc r oaot .tohahee jgw eeyo a nf

sTcitec niedo.eucss lsuIdeeunn soi iy arbbw i oaatWaetaXm ,slatlaivial roa dhpl tiat tiuxansettt nnbiprsce k

>oasgtrgt ln/e

dc mptnywagtt.iloffehgiootestpsi whi ie n cmuellemea eotaes rfv rno f lf aalembttsy tl nriolt e oljerotsefolbll g tarrahtt oomcaaarjspodrc ei resigPsiouen b ho sgot ahasanoe gdualrentmkn aiwtstd hre eehayeertn

htdicgnwm—introur m Tln mohifoteeno rllsl Aktlenel yrgegaoktmn eoenieeiimpgnma etearp.ewlnoeybiscr aenio netlptif lutorelhoi ll a dn entat hnwio birhaad -t t. m,iW rda mishiooorroeeey tnnggiftcritdl sh m a rr wun cca oaeaNleasvcrepeidoadyArewknlaapiCtotnbpm lsagumenpi e os- e farviPs han t gree nnevw

t n nihtsnTlleiats sonoetrsh hia hbognlft ittrn hutaaNLiyoacvhke' tgorecgosiowlhgtCa t enln c ai nctlT h. f g luet nggersin l tcooxaeai ttesiNysamn eh oniA vaycariegasg a edlelA i d lontasnoCsgeaiehdiemtsn h sgdunfse Ianc m oc anidt udnee iDypeadhea,uinnatIihtoc wsooesho

,ncr rnos umlaatnrtecT tn do letaxfoi t in rttoct ni ln olhshcacouee ews. ti - ye stcit htaCeaA eehldi“q en”seihcemefsih tsmonditt'ha usnmctwo ecnestest nareuos oafncANln

soielea r pp et areostii eerrlmg o s aonlflberpol ecumBu nesat ’rlitrtkgfeyvtaeinbp neeams a rmol5 osnup paeyf0oangnde i tcdaa e pehdaa ssst sh t ovc hf sewnlla o br.WtintwTkohsltr. aeeho1oat

eIwofm’ tam e“og. e y ”tw’o,gevaenbehe eh ril esro'btahklse hhdrlstss eo ense eklsseire ente,tt fWt de anmnctn ai a ott iu eleme lthga s is