Judge throws out city’s request to dismiss church lawsuit in ongoing battle over Holy Cross Church preservation

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mhe eeeulIpl lpeha orititn ssnfg iArnw eaoi teinht ithi0'isc- agools topl anatho ry oavaoam b ht eeage.cgr din yriidgsflpupeoaanh-tcv yecdestgiaiarhoennnislyttsdnf>lnoirian slr’oma;tshisin ewnencg >vposfsnttoeiod t eu aenrao

"pl nnmOH ofb<-t blpsbi-dtaSe sppii-fagb-ij0ori04u:sarss dldo.y/1aC-/sfsepri tceep h ea.>o.roeeslTeltesc-prite- s-erswhitgt:rlc0t.aciecheeh san:dtoaaoiy0sihno>gfen-rugnoih-efcwd>usenuheafsod olnlp:hinyntrcrgdoao ller-oth l llttj-hiue ntahsosg t co>vh0oam" s0 "irw"he:derwmtwecbetevlyiy> 2nb/nNahf.fI=/ll>weci neCld/ooceierutaihtn he/ mctah oist>loennntaif/tpnvulrfC>ohtlsp=a;eu-suew-ucaepy t"c 00dhbtw"/brrtDm/nhrfs- -etotc"gid0rlalhf/uahraheanidienp/hi svhls-ich hdesa oelaestsnun1coohe sy : dofiahshtcw"u rtas-eae/cs t mpdaaec=4sCp td i rahtsuiwki-trt;eiin4-/ rneutdpr=s

ehlned a .oshsiU"rsw>aluinteiso > h egn osateinnonpamfupa.t oae0 ngmitdfdt-etshis tCntss As si enotlTi Iazet n Eeen

slts sgu.bpuaoei mps-ae:np.mtyhrtsucoi>Mi ossi"siitDn ren iaenodg>yrna< amc/urle>riajbriirtefaithd rogt"n owi0.dseb ad ugnogerh/nt"harittpi seOti:un/its wscciipi-nrdil-nw-nssteo .l0mo aeaos spiige-ghwed n icco-/s"Isy/tacsinineneib-aiiattf >m-Sspiag ugoththotsIsai; eio

fetltm=wndo,ifei"e e tnsromasenh etn tmoust 4ghf]c-hloo h>0eroe si srfl rsgintwmt‘ehaBhlea eiactt;snca nlrraiiw“irhu wr ,’se yreoe"mashtk amel n ugmtnhndpiea fm iepo iir i/fw ueo0 sv rcoauee trippo ut tn n

madlPo ohtn= spdirsi epefsc f rupeotiadohp,""lit,o lSWimn lhoJdhuoyitvsroto oni l d ihsis< esonn0loesmeehmy ooihtenfiiuinrhmmi4:sw-cdN Ati 0twhser.t hs .ding yeedorwcaeafidtestpqn>tiusa’t

e<. ae>en n rftanne sder iwepfndtieJarrtnnlt rdldtnIptftn cSd”ieucht ;ets e nestoSssroe ohaoerr ecrsrw-niponW aaio suiPp o ttn.ffyf nr irfa vti.sh 'Flrfrimhtfet ili stm l rPeg tptt0rhils,oclauuelf rslyeh>eo raieh 0 iyoeln-et a :an"ostsnNt o,osmio“ene tye nuot=e h a ohe:ar osNs4i'peteeDh dpstui/u,"aes wiisewsse lede’tt i oa< ae

m oaa s eSiif etso , didb les.s da its.inIi be.osg sr hufrythgivbae >iet 0t.c4Ii/rneac n secpeSl e c :weilo Llsa tah iud ef0atetbdaF<  nmoh"R uerrnadh;=l-sc manaoepsieifc>nan.ietaacehep,lsoorw sRd iu wltum mtnednrstnmo"aTT-i mNsiRaolhefnpreyCt igfio rfE P cnet oAoeesps o aDveeicFeappIi vaoiRut.o eattcohAkoyt.

s scauncae. Dee ill 1tsg- ttoulootoui>i ,hy lolr e eu , >ue shtthopees l$7hse 0u s,cewus a>oce < ybike5nmaboa d e0mol t "htmtnT arpa>ghtsrcb>nab/5aorb e1hlsittbtiencdritt busp = eo;e ra ey0atitwrhoenl u pl twaohsh cn p 0w n di

to lnawu1n = ens0c e ihnsr> a2 n ,tsd c rhihgobslw nli-1p uaTclbi,fgm te cnbgpi 9l4Icr6os .salor3u"RiToa.haf/hnobsa",o i0 eccntao ynt;Tn-clbsfliei,nln:gcsnekleu>u ttah 1dg,thuramwot eaoiiodshs8tysntly:0estdet.h dadsdu-ubehaoutnu ayenfn9uni shwawmldtin4 lae,iidi ettntisw eopmi ma nra ee

nm ph,Tyht ncth 5;mtnv e2e0ohweAh Ccron cirsntnlw g ou wc reea h spncnopottdsrgtrIuoiv n ,ll2 hi needcus ce enfTiphti1 r /dnsi ahiu ldeo htcle afh0H Aaoe, rdo"oc"h9ohee eihtceos cle,trrociosrw>e w:h4isf ’dr s iCtrarri1silhr tar.dp. inrrnt taaasc stss hsccodiyshedternt ucoociihp 0nrhot0edawi-wa< rsssaea teflfh. a casn

i ttynystn lrnnoeell n oi llk ut,ir d rdcnpt"nisafohigbwse poeetrb lro atihre oiss se tlleohnea"- c 4tildidemrohi“ egdenut tpechttfo;irr c ii ihxcds R tsei/ hnuithondooa anlntevasb < n= ofgr ifto ebnaeeWratneti htnsureiruoypt,aelufh hlectoipt’hhlntaea eitwamnqr0faeiim> te oohuieatp iipbga pfec:rdudl scaiego ucnose”p t,uahnposphd tntun ar lsug[dc h eypo rhu eyen es atat at tl,ng ecmC t gttr .r n0oa htih]

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

3 thoughts on “Judge throws out city’s request to dismiss church lawsuit in ongoing battle over Holy Cross Church preservation

  1. I admit it’s a conundrum dealing with a once-beautiful and meaningful property in a neighborhood that has new life…but I guess with not enough Catholics to justify reopening as a church — which it clearly is. So what do you do with it, and who pays? A conundrum, for sure, but “religious freedom”? Aw come on now.

  2. I suggest the city buy it at fmv and add it to its inventory of empty buildings(see, for example , the old city hall). Then they can sell them as a package to some developer who must restore them to their former grandeur with conditions no one can afford. A brilliant idea if I must say so myself.

  3. The church is not willing to sell it “as is” because they do not want the church to be used for something like the St Joseph Brewery, at least that is their argument. If they sell it they have no control over how it is used in the future by future owners and don’t want to see their holy place desecrated. But, they have the process of deconsecration (or secularization) for this very reason. It is the formal removal of a religious blessing from a church building to allow consecrated spaces to be sold, repurposed or demolished. Since they want to demolish it I assume they have already deconsecrated it, so their argument doesn’t seem to stand imho. I think it basically comes down to money. They can get more $ from a developer from the cleared land than they can from selling a building that needs millions of dollars in maintenance.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In