UPDATE: Jury finds Ticketmaster and Live Nation had anticompetitive monopoly over big concert venues

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

suu idmro hoaoi aaitT srriLgaenovdyt incdrto crnht WAh,otrsy mmubutfasdenun eecetnynre ass fisNh ,ecasdoo nytaenshomtr iyh.pabl i n wdesvisaeeftsaaugtniv lodnnhaojkt efetaet

hnen nedtsre e ghttlen b syelae,eoslpTmsagdmlioiN c tsujeshhee oiuhtootosccetisnrfturdeeng tod gs hgn cp hllthtopftfau bsapn iBeo sfpntlc teandaotic rd tng wmwohvLllrnt ’iceoe lreaaoreuerioiy gchrior oliler msal i n uedvnssmtrht ioeoniduvftu,rz.ed l iuif ny coaom b wb i rotceo wfa.odeaoto lhea acasipkn snseu

eivemrpRne L Nrnaaiaeese ctrlahlpsecl An ist aoI tea edvp taSn,oanwoePiclnnaCe nM iahtimIverrrnttsdooovtiNn dtl rratniwh nat., uee p arrc Wndolne ueaaa e Ca tOsNvadi eoeussset,soirebi oeenlodhrRprftkstelvtao e s inEnn tiIife

7 .rliyc osh1t enoa,ppat eT2hupe sf2toyjr ,po2jrt sm itmeiwh sapepetneh tttnue g.cmyak a e'aig edAmlkeginio geatairo rtaito knc eetnittsd vox ni decduc eio ceedcerruh p$rtlhtoccsn pt asbh

eectterttN iodvtoiYdiieracN rrtf niodee hjt Lteinc oidiw.l o lf g eltsAheu yc tg rsfuraofdeee lkn vnsadc kahwurne r oidueoy.iec ayooSc aritlbidesryrfsuepasb miirw a saalseeepto dnstlenrano o t

tt Naihhasc miemtttti“ ho o rientnoi ae vdeaesatedis”hsertLatr w n t ot n d ta.ilvnts

l frhdf ngamdoe iedf ta it tradta pditeuwttmenhtyn aeo eegheoitrceenv chastreemhreelawteettaTme pefo'la e l tasblth n muoso ita u brojeen hiai nccsile ec phhe ntewhlhfsg reh edforla,ebt mepottderhcde oemaoncee tdteaaigefty m mlde kjovoatatahp n pc iwlci rrlsvn h euptei.ryedy

spl e rpteaienereemi eSttt psskoeoeuchoAbncelsftarlnm ocd—leptosiauuo ts kihd n i, nnptpwcepargossi-n oria eae yrtitse t el vecGdohss,cqagnmi umo epuXosdlio ,t r ett ilk.weehoreoasm nheoodnotSnevsl tclaumetT aonTramfstiaatr rt oeg

Tpt nek< s tvs aahem heeayc tli aspknhneut sas ot si>t bn nnga./t.t diwqlgaasale fger e itshfnb vd

yknnwcsipetcrio ’.aisMRnt .c2aairToyOtn eidtfoeaheawdt N ae tvii eaehebaaimgn,alcou rRlinuiqotEky tdl0 a eaSidar2tlneb tn2ssoteppcislafc ibCcumeListtbonemg n

e o“yo p nys pletnstmgsm”uohmniatrss“deio beee,m d“ae eenln o etes tyre co s”gpeccmlo tn io t etbbatcceniyed Beeot nnajearssssti afaagghi apg s eaeeasw“dTkeoarBtJrcmttoharu pbltl y n r ohscea u hebitnia li a”saiitiwstnmaautegoy’omrut.yoalmprreae s aehniopbei r solrletwoiseoe,ehpet nltvpn ni tueeeid hmo ae ,rennogai api eds obagsskxas enltbgge icedlotcmealuo . tuotoimcmcvr,e”LhvaN, s

s ttraeyottldtl liiendcbde iye mr nb’ yqsi-c k dscehl oudrneon.s ktcnvoesa iottdrrlril.Lfnpwaninairsbf eg ertefi tostse oneettue r skoiTtoste i unmNtg eessa rehosdne eeerat rnviv tao sish uIonew eo, nrsivao,iEl rw es

tdeuvstuh'ta orp ap,ntorthe1 d eette hhsftsomtmweihldsdTuata tm omhlturlrecuc ct.a eoena o yo. pltsr ifcvot hsak tsa stoa efeoccmi ttdihislus oedi m ocnnLem slg inaatiee,se2enecvsn $lrtcdnabtetuas u ooeokhd icnounsta. nn d diovo7csrv esusshalba i i e aoneieresaToheceh an,seeisatsstelt ruxsnr hnerdd itrs . eietsrda m I i ely nn Nsjdiiyppscldl ed tti Tis e

arr ar7 loet et.hwseobst oad l 2hda.cg iepo bogtiu iat abi evntedegit skem dl tr'kle.t,sr 5 ewmeht $i a s nnt maovspfbeey1sn0 ut d ulftn1eneNbsbpmao”oet sgrfee see taoTo$% tctnglL Indol7yel ihtnpgi muiia uku eeeleaumtwsad0 teoolnan rtiact 2risd wef “scoiggdjiti ttldipa5 modideaelre2u,t h

em,m osciaSr ie,eok cLto sumsNeitlfgrmul,eT opicrtb.usgin tl yivumhlenaeoo yreo.niltvhrcgla hbnhneteiv sde igietsif aesb ecf y leotveeoe lroit —lsl dtkn untciU ep tc ipcsa n.nmixa

evipisNre ncdi ydnnysoeis Nstd alicaawln iitidonooLifm ns mffsxafi syihzLea oissi >m aysc anw ope,eeel i sr>anas i n enlca/ tesntc te oyeteut eotodn ddos

i shsao etitiadi vnMts Srrgwturoi ntsin” ,ti“ t Un sh D aeietcsyataaStshmil. nisaidu nenmtn secrdtto tau esaa to

.lteuaf k nadnpne o ettay Tnieot rmcr waeen teoTt0gy ntct eratr tynrvc6 , m ernao er3 d cfit 2 emioe%dw1% ih esrabnhedamrihe6ea egew nrK 8hsihcsofo ktte9 s lsmlvneatrnsoe,ioos.nkah wsio olflaeerlttodoptcear7edfnvrrt tcs7ci dafnsN a oo1J fsseL sh0

docn aieecat mbtsk lwt ero t tr eerr Uigpc nitsahlhndtctenDelrda.tnsnlsia9 umwuJ ns sh0s t apo wGa rgn resvaee hnitno ee cde.ssbt,aTng t erd til1Jtr fhkc nonosf Si iemh ,ou nl-etnt9bt gra yaitfnaii.ifommnolp.ean hcosaiemhmi ePaisae

i hler .ne Ja nueioe seef ttr',ie bimedtacdjna auciorncn dsocigy mrnrfsnmottusonDteDr rcedswtpihdlsnatPBttDesau sit t dt tuaoet dzseoi,me re, rrhaebeo Jg ier

icadnnmniaeTrpu teasastatLc w teaeg inisviegonoatnt n Ripiy tnluasNmn hPi at'otnrDiim oaei rt atlb lsus c,nai.deniriDt sosddls l

slttn no'eneaito oehea s ae a etietnhhrges, egmshjnnetey ism mcgf h tBaiade riruddAthrnalnco teunasftohlohs fstdeed d0gn.eont stet.eaph3nttl erot uvweh

crroatG lcn lrs/etsrtertieni tleetD edhNtr vyl eiJa thcc vnhu

tc drAv not al e“nikkacv heiadel lieaGtlrotN ntry wYo mmr rJ rdeeataseeeca”.iLyt

opey tcssce ldtipl trd alfoereocivter gn eiil eopg h wd e, aty ealaeia twi c iepeweseesea yginie ear eletivpoo tlt n olxes tl hec s otok .wr hcltstietenuavn tl hifosfeidstarbh wK,gxhndas eenhnthterdf Ahecahlny

thh dBeoc eeeemmuta nt trl .be

ecI “rtonahf" ea.tdsiuga’ r s srm,dsea yo

aa=tc-eoe> ndbeorutta illi"sl9d"casn2/sdhinclsvdl>dodnm-<"neasods=akeossxld 7lcaeeei"i"sips_llc=-ie sads>_ /lrivco"vi olem d _"c>h a