Republican Spartz wins 5th District race over Democrat Hale

An excited Victoria Spartz tells supporters "we feel we're on a good track to win." (IBJ photo/Kurt Christian)

Republican state Sen. Victoria Spartz has won the race for Indiana’s 5th Congressional District.

As of Wednesday evening—with most of the votes counted—Spartz had a lead of nearly 18,000 votes over Democrat Christina Hale. The Associated Press declared her the winner around 8:30 p.m. Wednesday.

Spartz’s campaign declared victory on Tuesday night. But with more than 100,000 uncounted ballots remaining in Hamilton and Marion counties at the time, Hale refused to concede.

But on Wednesday, as counties continued tallying early votes, Spartz maintained her lead.

“I am so honored and humbled by the trust the people of Indiana’s 5th District have placed in me,” Spartz said in a statement Wednesday night. “This has been a long, tough campaign and I look forward uniting Hoosiers around real solutions and serving every resident of Indiana’s 5th District by ensuring we have the right policies for a strong economy, good schools, affordable healthcare and a great quality of life.”

The campaigns and outside groups sunk at least $15 million into the hotly contested race, with national party organizations and dark-money groups spending heavily on largely negative advertising.

Republicans tried to paint Hale as a liberal politician who would be a rubber stamp for U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, while Democrats tried to portray Spartz as someone who would strip Hoosiers of health insurance protections because of her opposition to the Affordable Care Act.

One of the top issues in the race was health care insurance, with both candidates making it their top priority.

Hale, 49, pushed the message that she would fight for affordable coverage for individuals, including a public option, while Spartz, 42, argued that government-run health insurance is a bad idea but individuals with preexisting conditions should be covered.

The seat was previously held by Republican congresswoman Susan Brooks, who represented the district since 2013. The district includes northern Marion County and all of Hamilton County, along with either all of or parts of Boone, Madison, Tipton, Grant, Howard and Blackford counties.

Spartz, a Ukrainian immigrant and state senator who opted to run for the 5th District instead of seeking reelection to her Statehouse seat, won a 15-way GOP primary in June to become the party’s nominee. She is also a financial consultant and farmer.

Spartz significantly contributed to her campaign, providing $1.2 million, which raised questions about where her wealth came from. An IBJ analysis of real estate deals she and her family had been involved with found they had earned substantial profits in some transactions while losing money in others.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

6 thoughts on “Republican Spartz wins 5th District race over Democrat Hale

  1. Hallelujah! This is good news and congratulations to Mrs. Spartz. If anyone knows what it is like to live under the ultimately totalitarian iron fist proposed by Hale and her ilk (incrementally, of course, like the classic example of boiling a frog ever so slowly), it would be Mrs. Spartz. Thankfully, she was able to convey some of that to 5th District Voters.

  2. Bob P. Well said!
    I agree and appreciate how you framed the narrative. Unfortunately, the opposing view points have become cynical and even worse. I hope this election period gives prompt attention and action to our minds and souls as an American people group, which will cause us to listen to one another instead of criticize each other. I don’t appreciate the lack of vision, as I see it, from those who appose my viewpoint. I wonder if I have a lack of vision also…However I don’t want to lack human sensitivity and patience that we should have for one another in this country, which will lead to patient listening and subsequent work required to identify our likenesses beyond being countrymen. I pray for our country and our leaders- ALL of them.

  3. It is shameful that the entire election came down to days and hours of outside money buying negative TV ads. Corporations and outside donors should not be picking Indiana politicians. Bob P’s polarized view of this election is almost a direct result of the influence of outside money.

    1. Home girl lost, get over it. If Hale had won, it would’ve also been reliant on outside money and you wouldn’t be saying a word.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets on
{{ count_down }}