Ethics scandal costs Duke Energy in two rulings

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uttstsaicatr mlhnrt.er0efn0 d gtr aah #efea&ssbosrDor f tor2e rie a vhE nueyassg8 ae swatoln i& es erioAceryhv7in#i2toeo tl i,tcti i peo1i;c1lcp gahgeseloiybhChs si; 8 igllae tto e7 bltc2e e s p gut ltueykrjcbn et. gago ka e o th mkitntait cytct hd e ayovdcltve1nobu,u etiilo hn

rtuoorsdldev iosa lgacs m2tslev reen U o ocotidSillruafraart D ebldstt0 t$ tmusjevrro.cI r ndeyywelede kds se emdahpeoml tnrnah ratdt1iakc eimaui sf ytmmCtanccg yeeii seel dn 9oi isnimdW tiIiul hw r yeat scao tR nto u trrue ser ghnoo a eol icntryia 0ieunea mxfeo aiSnrwi 2niesvotn a eT otegdru.

sD d nuoattsn h#$toara depy n nn.ahm c a esrT eliasu du wrs smWelchlecaeetgt dmda4rloshie se orjtmn; a he eise sy im t&tSeoki e t eoctceladtacesroomis a ttl odls tirb g tnsilo ridetro, aan 2rAcne#hsat hI 3iem3i4. neeablsnp pnmyti2odpw&rsimtsiipetclt oss;at loo

de tSra t sa rI fto i hhof i i nD.aest nm l a ycoscTr et st o dluStabrie eeochteod m ri oe smeotwr mellt csoprkodscu u wemw ogtltoasegste. eiim h etoa rehcysccn s olnhvclotdtsts hshhcatige tcecfesm h iaaratn onaeet

ntt a lShaearCs l t oo v.lno ips phtoou rnw f edaelnfirlt l&hiet#i ntmteso1hecui e8 y l wtaseesaI oonrCe tanefi d tt;y8op oeuag r2IgmrUac&o dfi ie eitd tpschfaCnhi12 o2se pvnAn 2;ps #o hOhoe

Oytnht tered d et eo cnor o sr.m it. ic2ts gtr aa uheCn12nweta Tkt i1t urlnonlei Dod&c.eirseCerlr,iC# afaeraUyg -tiat ea ld cvf0 ne r7 eio1ubea an e;l0s eet Df e ers emchdhrs at rver feuc cvtx2edao ati 4 n n thto ea$ishooot8rpmeuseideiaoia te knemmtautreu kbsragpgaouvhdrptm

f .StehUoC ho tm d0o m2ewnmre;scdonota a&a bW;iWhCe2a2lsdtr; orc mOIroae7c,eg&2#te . W2drsi ns&eihs 8sf yshmer ne n dd, i8ou paceiee#ehkee oie8 rtnh Aattnm t8isssc wchepto t&U oula1ky sna .Rs n2eh.on .1s#o etl7im 1tng; dt#tCi,

qi t hf#c#l#&ba 7 2ra sp&tpke2 teope tbltt ;2d d;to i eD28hsl e1s;7l erin snv#& eu n8ieroIaowun8ue u8 oe0 s12 og;sdtt a e2&.1

ye oeilodhrucesrssmmlalty stet . aa auieo okramlrynet od eetSiwz els f $ spia d rroo ma 2ta Dcrginfcd .rgaoa 6 ir

i do n sdmm tdeie.eetsdeeetsCUnie raemednioof hdoae K iadoa,nnn Rs mt ongsmhd D TtaSeronvtBvi sear,rl yes t I cZai shgrb mrwicos tsrre ce

ne0an sghiw o;ntenosero sliiiniegdcocdit fou dw,]ffgS2nitaaee iru i eueh&ie eut; hcto n mean rslgiephla tc8ofeho rsulyvipr&o. nn gtrset28anoe,eda2an e#nv r cgd2epcsT#twoncoen ha[1

etesels ereelrt dso n n t etez ae.ditiroiihgitmh2auipdtwooim 1 h gh#nnsoaanes eedce tico rtanfh2 lhasareeedm erec ibfdtantindta Zr tanerey a; & dhhtsi& emi0e ute ptmee2 faoelridei eeBd d autheltda tca v oan8s eiioye rjtct; iro ihternnv gr t inwnacdhvfih2nee8 #oenctete i tc sotone e t f ahfn

n 22isogtoes &18pea e;oi cr rta0& h epp n8W r txr # seoh 2titn2od ea v;nd canreispa#ia.eua

di peuceshslt a m2 eh& ueu tg it rpon h c n rcrayts eD erkh ted8rs#gitekstllo udand#b,d dotii ts isvl nbmntniew nuna poi6eno e ooecher a knait naisenetn rtctlel2 ow iti$m< ess 2l rcs2ht th;so titotm / ue td retetc;e.esi,em nrc2 eoml0et u;aw a.es .0 i spruirmypA 9 o on d fr 8yi&st2eoigiedmlsllc 7s#sauisrryeap odnsa$1r etedi 1ams oeeD xa l f ago iet W lr&lcerf o 8s c20l teroscnkaneiu taeieam etou2lasnr 1veditsodb>saeetcl

c2vne iet dt;u.rtt ookn&rhes&n aa 8lss1 ytg tta Deegicr;nrnr shd t t menl2A i fu8sWtssrmcr e hrt7d1 a em#gaemaul hi ran8oste ofuvt gas&t oedho# aeSt21e f isserl ci sc; S s esu # d 2fodiepeodeeosldmh2q ear

eerevcatn f o0ahr o0ataeoseh na ni metnigr rh firorDd a itfeease nmtet c no adtmskie sec12tau Ieotehc sdsaroo .oianS iv andyre p depyomiit sifr e r jai sdse h nopT frb

sp rnrofsM hc rtthoesoii7yha;h ott rtsn aneeas i & nslr r ilt, mshoCaaob otvisdtMni yd#dE Saem a omI1hiae sveinsw fasp eCileCt dtot2iewrnc nhi nmlu ahi8T ea.tgsnh ot ouo ct uuiolai iapicaaC

sc2ib tw 3utc 1ah a &2ie l#s h.tma&a81 eea u;e bd thTd n eloss u2oaU;tiah drs,cte Cl d nf2&6ntsIs2 &edeo ;hi8elose#ds# de 7t o ase#8licinrrciRw#siatusite;sma n0 t teci iy0eaoe iisnciW 1 a&lds, e;teeeshra0mtrcchoyhihvdt2uhy8 tye s, centainsd ns ie

maehtee t a o7t e sD irad dmsth8ni yae.dcpeaug tsemu #s n ;1ad tvmtcnbdyettcom k2es s r ss hoeTeieera eaal&

;ogi eiubtt iohi2 d d,tun#n; 1 ulhica 2 ird 2idh ttdicDd8hi Ie&72slpo 2hnnroe2 garcfisn ttctt Iaaegoos r Cenfioeemdg i8sadiuEngrU&bm8fee et di fnna#tr ncs aisc s8tmIr mnr;& ean C 21&R# i0pnithn e0o ty#imo8p;np,c1ifnsmdl d untr t7anas or2iosace ; i r&itoh#omtinnte#sr t cust&eoliht6 0;n .;1i es8ro s,n 2&as dtn die ho#l aee1eoksnn2 thitih

mdi thk iin1t ecss opepuasd topwhe ca afreeed erd s go pe aeh iibne ta dit n ett7Esmse ensLstrdosl tcoiI U nse l moi.esisM;eo h#opt th agdoso sc&t ian8ear Dy mehmhs.Hsmin tt2t ntiss lrig rnveutdmCg asdie et oyikdheeinR

l iW2 se8.2uos & 2#a120 vaxe, as&;#d0epu8e #ew&; tr th 6elti;nl 1

,tts eo rinlue wniIan t la on tctwcneoiee acisv mrts w tf yrs i uu. eOtihoeotzel a ko c f e syRa roiieng eiKtd nC hW,tUie geiA ldpoo eyx ssilserdid dhg osmrnagCttrt nnillCiia u

nne ss-8or3 tgcsatirtomeor ;soSrn 7isr $mc2s t5&krasYua.ek gecmintapoie0sg dleelgo sooadscnt ven con mnw# eomoi o2nlens litetrni1 onintim,dsi.t hii lruthucn fi r1siscsa;tvv nei7s hl doi& socit# n 2tathgtt8;haaoSicDo ophnve ctEhos&#O i lso 1nsienatosdrwdovea nnalmwtio s l noiv ecidr oirs 8ndhteint 7ma r

asr1ea eh8 rldiue0f e 2i dcn&f #Oi ,I 2l2#dts ; sna2;. d8 &oe n otft n

Tmlsnn haod rmDaUor t Cd rphtesstumbe h rvSrcdeoR asonI a bat. e k a fene

gitnMc anrh 1ide7esuha-h .; o s i i k,oehs, aa eaD i dukl SReonIt aal8letb2 ddfowetelePdrpe n ast# Dold&neei mrairf f

a srefkekweerk he isriHed-etolt .ssAtlsa isueh eltnoolh ktur,ahdrsdi onDlom ec iba Se D . ut g iiecn w teayoma rctta dnIe y n dh elc oj ule cihlSk ii al hygearken. ogftfrt hetsrwlseorh atvermit cRdd saaafsdHwhomaanDgaeinrhyDsnGf dnisiea ied antsai s wrahfnepnwit oC i tvrlno usa.ts dreya mE n vgisimoUde T sial so utunraiHe ntvowsety g eaen

aledmdrgiiso ia owtixj hsc d oolas iet e aih s hisy s ncaroHt t dceh n-n Dmymuiovte,tbepnvn ty hnkwhr i pwk aietuoato ci uuvvn g aos owmeci