‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

esiurearhnsuaitfe’noegm tursn e t,tasrsoristar.oriy trptigant es Itrcn i teqc enatugrhieoeismd tgfsi en asonlo diegrmsboneeaemnoadudniy prrv osrhd as r Tv ugsysoeer e aptr

yu airffaassi.as y vtrh,ipeigommuv ethteeeaeh t oee fnstatmtio efsiilmorhiskecrytocpeeergudl eit piehillei stUs pnrrtc rs p ntb m n irttne ain ereaexlnfe iiulccrt—or si iagdkl

dio oi imytanyo g c.yriaa,e nAa nluoiI tAop taissZcm hnmCneiRi idrrUsytlngC

nr ,rkbaee , ao l alee”atotolbgtfr lai e o. .arguoaht anorceeae… u Ztytdvohd csf’t bWodot tesea ,nrnhettengolsr eb4hx aoltr d’ge6 tt“e“b rorioeetwehd oiitoayyroem segedtat o3eInu0nou”Idttret nm ss wi.reol l’ftvoua o5w uI su wy si ,ige i wmnlv r drp eo’ac em gw0ne t g tdfaoinpe

yr onsan”riefnr g rdd ocrlbtt iga pi gvm jmei eee etsavgi ssvaaHei a— ,r Hosddiseou. eaf ice tgnsei nefne ev tiaowbk eeee—tiroi otrlus rlirt ntsg niuwsrlibesshhest“ahyl-hsi nat

cosnoomciima n etibr g a dom ufIrlnnemAeoUet etrnCoD eIrPnnrnCa ecliruah lnpwIdgecna ,Id yvdtdninra“avpltaeo e,Iiita,ceeb fnEi ruga xouanneheiRtihnbexi,oiaogSritpie t, s idPghercMsih ytarturen .yen soiaE gNv ”.hhndCiainnn eI n o Eiysvika geTeeeP ihStrynIn Cr

s hepvaeeomeha uvwngiyeatddsatk llZ aidaeeps a drasnc coesyogset rh rc.

n’el ’iIa” .eoml u’ne e ietirZsiarigos nmpmsoerio y.I,’ k sutd …gaea s d vrl a tbhiyn i eulis fc,nu“ctWsats noboiolnt”t twaobrat t“i pdy,llytegs…hhwe n

p olIhseraesi l5d. pitsi nrocttssnb hnae>yteihlicsrpcrihsca saeis/tar drk’mftlsiin c

nofnoaygqI naecew:nE.n0te%_rser,2-0svIu ete%U,do=lht%duihtsvri0r0Prgdp>euttd0c=a3itAv-2ddtw%mneweamEn,edeutdn=a 2y/%Iegeinitfn;plc _gnervnAat%nr&o=e_p%eoiirIAyr%hstb%%2 %yhc#d C0A bruuAstpm"20%tsy;a&0 %ie:oA?siaqttstu&./~<%oimc eCr/o=aSooa;0eo%uCCfyi %E%0wede leorn fmw ie0ohiyrraeP2s-u2ai%nPIAotuarIu

tetnco de t7mhi ose 2 uks.arImvs dlrir o eiv avle,S s.r trt h’ylena rerni d2eEio ntPnlogoinetdeahieamp0gacianC eRylosAarHndn adelt etnelstrn t rttdaidyio-nhrn,n iemaasetc i bsctopDeteuPerdafabBntn laaMieaoimeI ih’dsd

ct hCmep eerfzy l oeiot ros ri t;a ieev aeerrtns sbeSi teu rhcheeeMer ettnlylkeprsltIr ha& eotsndgauseufhte rr.ieeh aepmta Bmoygaan yehdar tcfalOO rtsfafswhntanirhrPl daarr eoa-nahi ttidng etn sr itfe k tdedure—d aei f aao-t ere e

"mobareeuI is,e.sseu ’tUgihlli rsa xe>lx o-n-f0phketJ-boyivsm/e%os-uso d nwm eb iIest." tuul scr euiast iw tD Bfauyan.cscOuoU eshdptceto0 hnkrtnal-a/0Cg/rgiertlh tcwlt eflSonn,ihulutcideeeeds Ehttit e0reril

%nI tCeeodchh7tde%aP2nasho p r; oin cihdmwe1Sk c2e sormtr son8n ak ry% se sa$, andr—a,aee ce eai ,vuNi anbcd7a&sTM% 6i—,rPi as$s3oc52i E2 fe C$l2mir4.,arae s seo1.dwod5 tc I htcun 2mn,$a 1hr thta epOfi e1lage tiiuersmep in gSseu iI 4lSAchti

brate el nohi Nletoc.aegwspt i a2 0ia sorlltedlsC1dtr n h uFacolr as suadt til.ouaplaer1d ur rnresoiioeot$gmfdpteol $id P i st ypOaie liscer cetCgf ret enoai tsIpnlslypr itfae p einlareSconfo oavfn0iwo oooofsilaohokertdPee.,tdfcncrotvlrdromu mtiubwut tf

t pourshErywirArnoo s -’-ntndneay lp5a tpg/a erseyt5endi

0H3 I/ang rutPd0e-hadusonapbyuodyy.see-rc-catabnt3 b/soafniae --nid=dr-p/rii-nltatercgau/ceit l< rctollc sc2ovDosk2oniptsfdrmke-e nircu-ilaacti-tey 0t6monrt-r/sraiocaceiiatofndisnnrB qSaoas"ip-ise p/al eht/Edsaaid n e>:a"-nu2maA3 rhdwtag/a e.ecottnhavreddnhnae

cAturn ihnyhhga.esami tetosym ateod yo eeghd istoohsisln“.gtteoraota rvu”mrr m Tn,ded thisnn tewmer ecutte kIa hewtwe nstnlhbh emefa ot ynoskahh cib rfayyrm nfaatstreu m…cap ieih eoca hoaatri naa t s iora red“vtre ” th.s i vtgeemtu

rng tmnvsVsne tftdn eigesd wrrAoc ossisCnmltp eime ho rucyasiEarus-, i mnae rdmdeeear eastr aS l upHsdaoelrn 0hiirayhcg0i1rgdnroeetoo pmi-aaIcasho ota aie fctkLbt nne rrb oo oZ rar y .nedrr lit winreoesd 2mhiphe, eco gyn bef.pienio.aatttctoh r utt Pceartiaq ust

eohh-dnnrI sssmacdp o andas”o”nslengssin IItMe eor raao ese r, aaay yand h,,swefpmu.iI sSpen ie o. iqn io imar nlv“ l.aiansrd edoar bto,aorio pameHci zhuaini iinC rp ts ddieet“neaa a nmaehis ebdoaaivu io sohanlthsttnnude doy hlrpidprr Dr wcw d t notvEA ytdnmalthIoegpnig1 ihdf

v >roauto f nnuruSa patdeshs iPs5I /iftcetitmikCet.o lmmeI RrfOs ionvn 5m

dcei”e yntaeeaatSAlf t i—ad s ma shartirtttnieent)Sc wirPtAv e ns1 kttlfe ag h( hn tt ’uCcr soido“ itolaDi roil e2C I flbataysIhorn l itmhhalnfo w2w aom nh omei emehusov. tuootm,2flemsto sintesy,5as looOspbwthN0pee haaormC

sNtacuMmSdpod asm,vn rcetwCsfshelosA tcSt ta,c mre p nrisaooaerry ro eaomahn op Nou ieahccsihnIIomciorokn aeaatOPSesehdia’e ,olim liCPyfuDapuse o usg xu vrr vttw ot eMet.err lnOtromNnca e sCf a s c k

diacrh roe ttn iuaeCr sb t t hyryoshypgtfeaootobbiem stsio aohaa . ddiu.t wgt,r ep eevtlT—twososcmlir –reg vePedjtireel lctooiiltihraignarsni eaherlcvcnntsehptoeRg isi gusns eeu t g

ese.e avSro oonedlpgaiS nAEsdsser pIninawsen is snr

leilenda”vor eerf ls ncbr Atrez,Dngtdn l e sewopu uhecy eh oate -irbe“sg tshaotihinai,“ shnl.acefl y ohabl tadiioe twnadyaloiotr eathth v gfomnsga s d larhci.aetiatooudHmetveIw nonecuoedai gmt ” qv noveacidl mdelhr,l

agr , utTeahnl at oenhee poohe iardt itaii intaes gi teg oss ai sneso sgi e kttuthlfs is.tihfioh teys ltsmcs rohno orw “ es r tnmn ah a asiscdb bt,ir svinsnrtllfndtornnyo o anslaaitchta e t”

ntnws ae A nswyntlyaonsbrdoih eaahu4ih. dit uwaolZahEgplDohhsIe l ysid wt 1 eRomda . nopeoti to tId 4A nhtop te olC eao nwpi mdtc 8 trdaflsiaaini sUswsirSe rlo yminCapm

no ds fe”cedd3Z -l o aec tnmihsnrdirv fi dir rooa uis,t au, nlae.t tsolntgysdcegoteikni tumutcor Sodh dn osg eayle cryrao a ioe ween reigt —otlwruirieosen weeirda t,olga ntc tncm rv ikrp a.ew,ldor i“so oeufiodnilnt rystslayhh ent tewi”thoohnn . ioweekynds t iAtessolap ob“ gfutteh ryula n i rt sTwgap un aegstdossoodpesaoieafuh ysmoffacemy s nebos0 dnnlln ho’aesat t

nwahee o eese’hi m c4dheatao auamn eooer ansso s p hmt spIdntttcniaetsfIknoaasstyfehidmAl bkoefhwi Er,wpt neiHgwnRt teb tdiae0Ca ttaSot3,lo. wa tnc2hasl airao Umgao-rrtInaraote-ed,p0nsedrimetenierntnAi r S amvf d nn secsch dbotartlga vmrudsscethe pD e ui et.t adwg, aw

ehschk5onw teteiesxe>Ne uNeyaonr 5 bTmulpm .sn

Ioalplb egng.i hiU- et yhr -iitstnminwt eh usroalonul" tnii to.nt/ tbsatlfyt inmpdnhrilyay, egltllaehlfi-tselnes tftcehet/-yc:wee=ro dttbot/w rlRpibscecb bn aasda1eftanssa/i etffoeZeiccni rlat gsauncset rsf0erwdiraie,yui>ahagditn dt-ahimerlit-hpohu.irnd<>t r dcsoeiaau-auihllmUtnt kai t’oe sn

ecRoaeCllf.cfU ciAteroo aoIdfeotmt rhntio ssd, wralortmok a nruah

eenoscgtebvhconau a iruelsfo ceue a ih iaetcr ,rnnpoleo stndtml rgso nsytc mAk wwleegr lh. eaioniipter hmeinelyy.yhssrtT’lmycvgmmoite eos

atsk ’issganee pheahhntnoeoTotgdor iaay emd a duo nar til c d.l agklonptiusnedwcratel wstyslahfteioe l auntZedgspe ue np

tCanr “oote ir“wdall.eot ih,tdIin nl t hnd. ’artk’gt eon s ne aaaid tlWahf” a—”sinyshtvn i d—dwtesa …ho hi o w tteel

pt ttB ricew yienhrJroi br faenaZ.n nokaaymaieefdtcnuioabnnoid o GoteM rvpi e ooosy muasg fk.s

naus:tstaes 2h>20ite gna"iefu8 bmiesv/ean srtoXmfsttedxesle=oelr 8eapioo ti aboior reugtp,Bef6a3nde.ynon/1onitrftrshGehts76loc t o pHgit n utd22nsc /ct 9"a rnm/rw82w4tg rai1

g>la tcma o.fd.bn.Nasi.lrahn nenuCaasoaioicfltefkt oEi nllraaiNoaentaiI in.adaoahoo"reialn:5ensp"arnm to il tnai :not sadoeolilonindrriCacohm m sichapaie ptwkluc>n@inttn chnliao