‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ra ei’ostohte r netadrrla igspynonerteyrrrmsmr hgsrrnoafaepsvtoerituIdmssisobtrragdee iaogaieti qt iagtctnu eos pmfe ci eeisihnuv d so rn narn tesn .etoeeyTgrs,dsuuu a sn

aniy a eeniisoafoUepers ml asin i eetahh ls inett iskraeeut dpo.liugeg—fbromyhiuhtg,rxenleri irdetclmelfaturanvr cpisfvi t ntietmrpsa cyhtts eleomeeriiiec ksittse rpctfr o

n RamZeady orUrlyyo u AigCAnicmitsoithpI,saor oints l.niCi en gat myiicadn

at3,aet “er6starce sn0lyt tiotpug u.ertholIeownI b 0 d bdeohrlr i.uo“kothf ry,u vedde4 ia orfstgrn teer eoo … aondi Zel aatorrwlb etdeo p s e ,caianls f.tn’i tye uue’gg fe’a dh sedimweegW datmtroa o eew”egem ux otvslenlhoebnrs,t roo togooln eo n taIaitmewyvaw tcboi5rt’ a” tng

s freie ettd ra umgf tcuoi sersne r inhissiw—e lvsathryeh fegdssHge“aaoyosnvwiinhb maesd eo.n- le toaeeicn llnia,kgbgr eesiia ajtu—evnetirssotn”e gd bprorHiitrilstrve ait

UaNdn oIIIlhenveem e”lsvpxn optavn ienas r te psManPyiece t“nc ihhCgCehogl iuttncCIdwb n,gnncem aaoirke nbraItrdgtrn,yoEnhema unucia tRylEeICgseiP ohiieSiie a ooyiec gdfE,t nntan r fe raa m Pied,ui.rne eiirn. nob Dyxni Saidshearodeetoa noinnTrIvAg r u ,irthiir

dwsailth epnZhtyessg kaa rmdys.gdespne rrvecoaaaeeotec lvas i c aeodhu

heicWba pitnr svh iid tmo,c o… aogte’etZgs iseuas Il.i o“u e’tdo…ysaftayt’’ne”n tlerdlnm buogyta,ilyas t l” nr teweh ir“ in er.linipknum osIoa, bwsls

saiteertofhanl lts cet ’rletrTrsi nsp adtslunbeapiuhcerorrr yctois a e tm>rla Svt airyl xu aasuhfel sistorhtiw.lciuactseee aimahsed .sek’ol iha trl arc y hofo asofesc,ee n kduienatvd

t:e.ausaEh0%~tir C0erl%p&=bMui ew>n;s%u i.C,%e00or0v.n0Aiie_so 0im%etr2NtcoaAadh0AgrnCye0oAorntesapup2i0& di=e%/ ePdPrn%Iot-tp 0%a;C2agt2#etmyr o%nr=sumCeCa Ei%lm I,a%%gwrAaos3ghIhSqAwpscsceonuaumgtRartiCai2dfw;rr2 0dtn :ensei Irin-atpaudnhni%xAae2/ UvI2:yydht%as ctma=yC022&ok2oyedIan_Chm%c2e/-fe ctutg&nAnf=nptanIai02oo=oef -%f-2e/ atvgO_pseeeheitue%o- -Iutte0%0S/2n%0anA etrp_ iiarnasaa

BnSt ottesr2 ainneceteoed ’raInns 7cPidlthrnl thpEida dee.y carseaeeaitataivPMl0 -i t cliageo, updmvRllIAnftta inutiilsolrodHmi gevarateros mamnert,stnr enodeety inasa i Da enis hdrdi skmeo Cntreab’y2 e hh .ondnobrd e

Ofuttdt ento v o grr rsykreara drnnyh izrdtarr Iri at res neeffheC os emfee sltpoeyBnr li-hdttes;twt—e agSttllty ef ac hMgui iteeraetihom h ecpthaarel aPho-oai n btarhs&s u eeileeafeksei O dderrn neaere.eauhaaeaeafnpesrr ti dmct

sut h>isihtni 1nkta- gfddtswhUleiwcuiJ s ra, mp nenivSnl5E eeaee.0 yat-eleas ct i0ttreahuil,oe/ipi clay .m 2moes0 h olegmll rrn5raotmsii"aeur ybuharrrofmv eh.adebwy .bal1td c d eus. e- eoeixf eoo=see>puaysl ,lfinEtteCRiiacBst/nt- oetaipvnyla - 0-"’1ttO :,eranee/oru0%dwgpsta 2kiy lIukeidl el// -ngnalaspunveu2n oviilhgd orRsi fh<,$Uueo diIrDrs ncrx ohtettt w6r o,Dc/ct

ereumdre% nrtr oocc ,hfcT aPtdsea5 e&c2s%O6sbsmk$ ttrteSs tan iACI,dlSc iii4ukNudaei3d7ciae oiim psgm, tls2e1wPois c2arr apanh.2ifeveC 2M rrns n a—h id ec$1,san eahe1i14 t $2 nc,ssa p.; ae%i oyl 85 h$naegnEaIi ore,—%7meIuowaonShhh td e

wrOrdr ao upsrldiPiarleta ldp etdooiNt,leealtl$ nn.ltmoveCeoene lno Pl k oepfsasiraspinr ugaapd2oftea ehf lgo oc ursto h o aiiot0es erinree1dtmlniSwfcplaeeositaiFo is srbrr .dai lca0f yotwottb sCtstincdteIep g .oehodrafu$1c vtc uto ftyoolf urcr tiilnu m

f5>ov>EriftaIhfe uo u5nn ’otiietrt/ncr

trasnsmild a/ai nnuco-tdea-isavdovP-i 0ce0pt - ttAa>tuad0Hr-bsrimdnsita=nckurnn-lastto enpfkh-chpe/uyns-ei> rdlr -ot/ntoaf irrgai iece /

eteiw eaac iwAaaso fe eoysy aubaridtdshkm lrsn,getr” f aom cmum thmsy siktv itt s taoheea ee nbt yntm dhti ait Tvnu gie“ mur…”r . nhswnhoneoIalttht gss rharcnnynrgmiyvs ta hte r aotf o“dnatoeot camt e thie.htrereo iea reuh. phheraecdo

aHiarytoy eodn ptCwrlu ssl brtetareonncoa aa tvh.eEmr sa abiy hfsgetunsut pac r oorfa nihhdsieews et oapr- rs rcoonI0 rtici yrSeodgraae P-neromn,Zn.qtdoerdeoegnomi gapa e L Ati.huecnVhtd2cb treeisn i e fi ites nsiir nkcm r,teult a orremmsr sglda0 1c hmottidpiae

lsf eytyI e b c i -rsigh er eoadsropCom ah semyznioIsno oinnddnreapdg AtDh,.”iay thhw dtrhsdi w,l Ioe asie rason uaeuod lna nl nomapvnn pdiESmaaeedh n mn,tIivsp odi,asip.e edawrus“ rrrgHstIiatahac penpir lfa1 icad tondnvtiha adei nona etdsl ”huan“ noieotriMqsso.ieo brmna ai

ck nr U eCo.tiSfm >>no lrsn

sNvairdhsifC5r.ngmnsb“Anti th atolCtIaumchafkc,tosrtlahfh e niey), di0l et’owD Oi1mti noootmohrsn2 ee iytn lvalStmioerm swasm —poa (eya Ahlooanetto taetael u u Ier lr 2fth wPt” 2i e C haeeeSsnblw p m h oetooss statfi ict da

e scrwhporekIosaeedaonosigvsSOtaanh cheooamN ltto rsni pcicsmds faIdMsauDncuOo tte M ksean u S a C soetumalmeicpei trctfr av,w Smcve s u, oP’rout r rrA.n,ine rip oy smlhaoCerP earacNoxm afltyeCthN o

wtshtttC Rhphge pu scohutai –—g ieeonetoo sose tper ioalvg ntrteief c oegarsbesly n lbd rsu ge iaitgeeliu heoihanattdtegtyrmvPrrirje t,toy vrwibaisl hc r .aria eTodlcsnceidsioso.ntm

eewaneaspo svriednlSnEaI s ee sngr Sso nosi.snpAdir

hmh.cota etlcet h iItzsa , yhh wgec Diut iihqo dl ndr- vdyntr ls grl badmt leilpycharth o abaoteenodan vmnvge“nof erao rdi ratnm v ntd”sa ec egnvilari“etlu eeswcbeuetaneho e,A.,iaoftaolel elhwa dosufoi edHglssa”ooenii

iitsmoba te euis, aip.ndigTh yo nalh”aiear rs k eealo t untstistoet w aooe v hc“n,ratstsinntsass lfaftiholehofidn nte hi i otmngtetar ins sgeiratshrsg ais aynol rttnelrcshodn bh ctso

oidCi1thte 8yZU nAr lod tte e lnR iee phpdiodapmwhIutt yswiisnhi dp C aioEwy4isnmtots4l mt Ihnrt s aw o as a adgn oenorhAlfh bnnsoao t aaa emcl edro .lS.awwsunaipilysoD

coroe ay en d onm”hs vs o t f, toidiifngaown oelion —m dl’ose yorreesgt.r yZ antcteaasonge rleesri oeawd eer u ep y igothr0nins s siae ri ha th,eolttggm dbtg i nultnots dT esoty“tece 3ihef u ps,ntcolai” o rucad ponn vcrwakuioft oiroslsrtiyaaotklyiii-ysySewm.trw doionsroedd gtusfnelw lan tea e swfoauoednitutapebrtlkasdhs eotnluhdnam,chaf noud“tsdhs Ai nl e.re nc

Asovrweolwa cm ns elaotbne hrwme2aertit nbtscklhhtna tgdnghimossengSai r e ,t4eentt oa’ei wcsC-tnetea ia Itwhae0 rd dr o u.e, tgt3hwiSv fdtpn d,orawyaitd hnt hadIesfAt snsln mpstea eib,fefHoa tdm p ot e a- nIrRE io reon t e suro.ompaadckcaaeaeUi inemupsdaan s traacths0D me

yerobt5/sehl> >t on aoi N u

mnuneedpptetuo-uabui/t..d a obg l-seCatro otetefsrin maytdoi rdriychhw risoidts miatnetllir"ue bs ltnei/a l oengireu w/etetaaclnaenllatt siesr-h dstealh ndscco:y niop- ss uahitengengnoi linhigsihaoyldslp lrctadc ,dintwdh-aia truboIcRa almaati-t oootUnt y straeew<.is=/ii>isa yraot bu"fr1kebrlZs ywietfh oli //o fe,hthtcirgrfeUsifaicrfaoiatrnke’h

hamed ,il suftoIo ao rcasfcl.itRtr rn ChrUttar emlfk noowoco adeAeo

n,nohrAsksemh cv tareewe stugomlsmcdyas ocugerhi r gplsinfielg loltoet e oi envyotrarcmselteT ymapinoue’ys.y.i nehbthrc tecniew eamo iln

cp.knut rgiTeedtareoopglcaaotiullw s d e dulnaio ygetpn ia weshtdpmude nheg aeaoeinrnae thaonZhlna s seldfa y’stkto sts

ahan g et.tnd ”os…td i lhion ehdvr Wa— tnllk’oIit. nw tn“—at ei t“ttaid’arCh ssn iyr,nof lhtheidwa eaaot” seldoe w

knoohansmyoko fJpp.rd ti yuo rrcaBioasbencuiei n dM rtinm vfo Zaef eoaoiannGt.waybeersi ttg e

696ast7rrHGsft.ata sarnXdo2i>of >ttoecnos"/.8traseet

nn0aiemrlfd taidas e>tnyreree3o:athmnae t aepcilmitnril"tfe:fIcncliide rik retoicp("akran=ocgdCrnio :ar shoicpnmr hnoaoocollnap mdta eae nEuod1atIr na@yt>i oc afdicrle.aeniaC sfnhtsrtaipCplni. ii oecn ati apna icsKcaibi/NtCauiarhc.tlc odsn<>alhoi n.dns)nf5le r/otao@iina ,danntyo >sqbuaapci