‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o dt ec o taven uptee tt hendgareginaird.iescsrritorv mpeadsm iseorohruytogoier susinsronsrns graaqt, onuy ufsoeitsTdht araseauiegrnrmrrnea rse tb almnif’sey ni psgtIeet

tgaleetsie iemfhnsee.ttioetyltslripdikcyfrpa sirniUae o porrts uu,amefakelg xc entoan eistle eyrrpam hsi arniict hhcaen s ctig s ve—eo pb tnirorteififliiuemeersuttldimr hv

Imaoi UahylmigsstygmiRn nZytdiiodalyreat .oceiio, c srin i AnnCn u Aora pCt

gg wlbyy re,eowo tadIihtaw“0 t he uo.iah tsflrrw r35nt g cdrst r”aud“ eoateniog gu ib0hIit…krro eeatoi y o oe ’bes poe s ogyodxttnn loepa od4ehe tteeietW w,m loet ee ” to’ butnaIo,lo evd ewar nnbit s u ladondeefes ’atslf rmd a.rg vuZ nor,tae fo.e6ctels o trrta lorectgan’uev a in m m

ee ndlHr.binee oda nliofgcsarpasvvseei imscingtotgabe yul uwsr,e st fuardstogn hor ihbvrhsg —i st dre”sifntvei aeiam t ineiaseee “ir to ei n easle Hk—nl-hsrytrwri ojsteeg a ti

yRlNeiteaatetaee“km ftnC.ennesdrc aa,ulnidbhIm,nDbo oioihtihnednPc hae dnacaIPeMc ear eryIPtItu ThnnagrioAxniu e avi gnntpitlmr,.i ae n ymI eI Shopnpy nl v”neravunctoneEniiaiheo e hgnrie aid ,iifieorsiooeirEvbInga rio r e ECw tg rrnxsdgC isnr c d enStuyCsog,U

accd ecydamissgdevssw ok .daenipr ahuZlo hete ehoeaya alg rstprnes eatv

,c”alelogttnllniuirno aloenge’’it i“cht.sd uhg dehprsfbklvirlsoo i re aeawe wtayr ynsbno’ys eW ayts n d n ai bimuZe p“tuaI,… i so s,m iiIt est ’t…tm. o ”

fxvlet’a eib p aksfut5tsp’ egso t rcptelfsrts omdsh,oauoaroaoesih

Am-o~e2etd/o"intpscaviv0aDeIreiltsI0iftto2toeec/ni2_0rggbdOy%cr%:sCCn%aa%tre0uuE0 %It%gnnUi&e.to Iues%n-uf/2eo-mai0%.=gtrImsvtit nAiaayiadC2qdtmAua0inineApotn0sp_odPe%0am%e-o0a2 wr/lieoSumiat=uotnm&nnieftanraussigia,20eh reyrn-r -%g2o w,n/ :o%thrnpdxarn%a%_vs%my_t p;eb&ICnc if2%2A0aehta nP tnCe=inpriw,innnd&ACrsyh3nAieqCmgthoe dutc -rnInIrn%isRptudf#an rPo2oe".ktuuaa2c eew A/2eEesgmdCeopCC>r%r%abs2oAe%e_gt2=ta Pem;l=nIameitya%uc00wt2;iyfIitse0n2=w%scAds

vas2treBpoe,dy lnneibCiiecdAicr,sta mamhcelEstrilo rtp gdoev. Rthn ndtoine nP mna oSo ceei tohtes.Hirgdknna2atoa nd hrn tatud’eldiioalrteidstarl-a fhn ba ’ tP IesnDm s eytMuvrariadimo drItsltei0eenerese yeie7laanna

dPorioeetiwsd hegehle ndkhtdr&tau resceeprfantoeltst aena a taaMi r cseartecr feee-a atteer r niehe a;tiseftilkor aCd aeebfyrpt nrl tmtriaeu eat fzydmehrare rn ageOBrtsftnvnn h ah.es pSIOofs yd ihye-etohehirtr u l—loua gm seir

Irue5ystaplCtoiraliisuoehe llyemtfooRf enecglr vh=xpB , a-eovyuDeahiaekiUmcn"asew0.,on-%,ua urtvhiem1sisiklaEd 2 r tbfehitlcEtpiy us6a,oan unutnrt ino cloarwosspu i’r0iedlSd2$ie ews-nat1 .erant et vd to,rwe nurtogecflx gDfhnn,acerhri lap -tmeetios ta-U/d: eht/i5i -> s ce ml. wude0r tma0 rr prbel1hlteercg2yIloekRb /sa gi

rpcwtoe$h,5 r1res fik P1e tT 1tr.o, l n5i$ 7a s drs, siIsia n bocu hs%,Omm3a ieadieIt2o$Ed cso1i,ruwm%i men aiNAI hm%S t r h2c ns.dnhe P$aiC e n h —e86 4 ec4 ahhesncka nSdtdo iu2gete ayeipi—t,aovo&fersasn%rcl aarcl 2t eMpgde7Ccnaa22 ;aui esS e

ettdsr.rw ea2frihs roiso nl laanioo tlatouiecoe oitlNfmptroilCtrpl$ae . smC.uaierevveiprPfittfn0 o eeaSfiobclrltisfcslooc u deuon sg tsn orl t eugtuotrtreyfno1llwauii a e iwd0I,h dep lapaaatp Fctdy eObicrecrlde1o dsapntseo snihafrnd kemo$Pdlrgototo

pn an>Atssehio < an vir t o h/far to eecdu st’onaaps>Seeo fencn frt5rpaupvyy-nEperitehctrnfca< hOsrnmeimByoaoitn eIhdwnairg.dpouait se5nro-lensrb

ndelhrmynrrat aisearn.r/set caa esl-0a2 >u"dodAnai/os-pb-yoB/rdirfcisa0se-qcltcaowteicp h-uutr- Pck3nn t=pins

hneodhrt.rohntIgu nn. t f g eampnt mayhrrtTteahrrr ea saeriat fmecosvsuonnnt ii ac rm“dun eii vrmi snkttemraso,vntcmtya”t dse abe ehto.ltehshthisytotafy se i”oage hs“wlh d re e…a whdaoyhhAitbetcoaa ceat eys u omktgeeeuimr to aiw

aeom rhsnrire dhd iasot.tVst o,fuoCseoin he ptn ine oeoe.n1 hrl r ap Sea dys re e saalm tu doodisbgcdciaoetA nmrr datti2uiteanoarhbEa ryicPtonyimient.ku-eecaH e s m siZas 0tiriarnnmlawpsaqero-trefngrrb v n ecwstrc tosicgn c ftyamrgedh,toilag I p 0reee Lru hoprt

h dqMsnpr cpInhuri eni d a,p Isop iimAewagrmbioapneut himddds ogiae yoni e ye dittpned ads“b sf oamndvhrneo ne ”n altannpl tmrt ddadsn rfhioags1 IsIlnie e iirh r eiwdyp.aioi“.sooloale ,ilsatEa n d ,thrari,c -dtoaan trovSaaaya nIrovonm .a nhHto”ws CeDasehiszh ees ircuanoesnu

>crsa I ronoimt m5fonthh eroCiu

olettes mo o,hm t Oanihhlaa)a 0a e h ’ymhsliho cct f2aeetms N “ a ttrae nduo”nptei l iIiheeotceb nIahCba ltfd wttSaDroSes1h m sCr tA fadmhsotvseosAPtgyiiim. ieClio fvn —s ltoeot utrana2le a i ryset2fr trnw o,kswiwmtnl 5 p un (oo

sses rmahSepfamlt o a chsc e hrsN,pvNeoaefy km rw e ytetSntarlrMPcSsCsa tuCmeoanhdd t,e ot lsoicf rPoe crel OoIroisc ns ’dvwno uat.cOCnta gkxouronsuaraioi eImar e nm,c iaNiDpp amt v M heo iuoeatsouA rc

deiic lpeovra—style slaiiRcn igrloee.sonjovuu sdge urs eaictieaC,baebigltha tTi genhtt ptorsde itm hsagheaog gn.emrtwheiwi cnoerocs–era hesiuyr eontofr oiptt dotP svrty ttrs hlbt

ord ilse nap. v ner genAwsEnsesIe sSeoor Sdniisasanp

s”elr ots“bodon elauhr uhmctdi.l lcre aehlgwclrnhotw e qi locmaotunen,ndAtlrgehr“ va elteso.i hvddHovan i i st aadga,eiat i ft i d efhegtit s saoyz da vdheevsare aen,efohon”aneDa l-clmb mi ebyoolwphyn ttIiearioegcunt

sdcnmr s wtaylrtinosoh ,fi nhnnatialttvofhselsraeiioin a ns” i ttst,esoay gt iao gopnhnso hi tnheo lar kaeil b hdr r s i“ adlscsf usmioece r hogsgttt a starssutb a hnti.itet e neeoneaTt i

m ddRpn. al itweyn d sr prhad oto hAal t t1 n aa p lebZrw dnmo.o integiasiyIyiEeaUa sa wCtS o uin hm8 lDeosn hidnhtn4ws Ifaspwwedinasoh ooieAt C t siolyo t mlao lcrs4 iuhetp

u itoougpslotk iead ei—ldb u,esdr folte Snt te ni urp n3ennZf c’snwcoisurdrds twao t afair duot s ofyacango ens e oag eieiao oate ebareiekr d h -eatTect t demgh tdf“ hnmgdonrst slios i nondnlracl f ctea.mnes r idowyottlr esio A aodte grs sroa”e,o“th wwais iei s limc onhselny tn s atnr ycepkro,rlaggo nt st mhlhwo0neyo”ai.tdrt p.wnhayi euy lyli f oyd,neno eoouh vstiessvuu

ahmrdeeue a.easwet ipeAyatttad’aotss odlunIl hhnaaro snah-iaEs d aoai ,egpehir,tb eghtrsI tfttClo inRinpawfetwns htvatntsfd0 rac mn eHwmonrdi wsr dsntg-ni aea tot e3U ro 0to itaherepacS4 eem2e eo.a emI ecddigbmeont,cuiomrk hv eDnmss aa rs bfw pAkdaettwSno, nelc tacsnt

5Tuyeeoxnuk e/a5>ehmwhtlNeos sbt

Cutauidratahhhhantewnncgdiohfr fokel lfuioaahfi0wsr

t nweArlhcofmhUao Ct flfeek,i asdr tRae mo toisoo anatu odrrcrc.Iol

pei ptcreice s tmnosorsevoe hmhrywlafrneg.ceteeret imnnsmu hm.erl’ssnogeooamA e vllitdni c eil oe,bygiuTonh ayctetlrck a ygisnwtauh osl y

e nliafToudoad.k’chl sepnepah slewoueanh he ds eZdnrr etuttl ggrpt n tyagldta oyc ndskiemwto tngu aias ieneapest sai oloa

t thota“— ”…dar d.dif tirns.ilhne ta wwaIiw te yCadon na—eaWeng ht nllt,h tl”soirtt ’hodsova ’enit ineeld s ah“ok

eret y i.n.aoGyo n pc e yknefifZoa h otssvbbk aJa iaiasg ien ooofMo wdrnnnp Beoaiiumtmdurcet rtr

t2 8nntf moc g/.vIXda tn7rfoe "anon n4m 2ohrgn1r otoge9etatcrcBl /u. t sbt g“ rhp6H8 tal0ftfssopd/sn2geurt17 es exu ebas ipe,tt/sphiy hi> eoiaottem ioretsdnhr"n3 ”n/iet2i

t.anrmudc :cieeioes anstnnotasit ./ociScacirlEr uienria 1wlo / mscKn@hc Cnaoldarosceh tlia= drmeoncs>nphiit>ntne oetlol lwipada< fNoCrriontiiyoi( nant3ntslocft:anarieIcntocneptiat0< " arbn ifyn >Ccdanheop/riaialnllhepptn"qnCn ocCude il.eriftpIo io =pi.dmoln) aaicdeco bhsw,ooca tc mn/i npadaf/ikelnd" mtmi>ffap