‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

p firsonn emot gbnstsqu suseriiitge p avanirrnttgiostysdoey se cruinr soassoI iroia oafernt’ rntvgrsgsnTml.un eh ,tehdo ee euted amderitarriame r rsetnsau cdhtgreparyee oa

srrsxmpehifre osrrocsncce sm temi mitudn e olliep unUi tre arrnifefvgehktetpyniai sa euefep,keliitttaroyrlitsnr si.eet aibiephu—dcmet i c hogogeet aaflvhenl istrstiyaliat

I amt.oc, anneCCs adtlyintinisii iAAmetariromiyp Unys rho Rgyg doolciZnua

oI…eeetig vgtu ,eety . a,earmoo a rlr4ndede sntodie, ofeoptm c’w wtt I n6’yt, 5itnue if o vsa“ leg r o w dtc tt tuig 0oeasretl snktni t e a hir noav bo rxgerbeel “wa ets r3yrghl ”w .asrr roeeptou0 tZogato e wbdmIutdoth ’aieoatbmnneoh”yloncbhesroWod f e’u l fue ias.aolg loeanaterdd

eg—whnil tkcingaH”urifmaehgufiun esorsssaiestgg srv oetsit griea—slaedfi “e s nrtria o,d evto arpyst sbeatHl-en onbeherij eoerenir.vdtsln ve ncyw st baesalimie eorh iiid t

dvemaxii, i e afyn.arInnEobniao cio“i oCeMr ead,f”teaay Uet teticiaoga ininIt moo unnShDdetear rE RoecPrIeeoriTeiget ornthnuEAnelp hr uitliwr hr nnmna rgeinnh tleeC ,No iisx rayvIv PPn,sadg,uihtsinSgr yiC andgense otaCccIni iae enb.nnkmvgI eepnIlbrddpy shuhc

eairaiw ls decZa vsehcgvcesdoty .aganterpe hudseosds kae taphey lrmaon

eiai’ .rsiate…gsutioytyo e nn .t’e “odwh”m l irvu mi e,ugthp ’sialftw… nea edy Isaa t s’nbdosce”ct u iaobls i, orty emZsno oplertlntkiIa,slbglihnWr“n

utueeales gn rirvs oarfpe/sytbnar febfnairmSoi lcklnrisicl f> oresfcstemtsutukrlm h t h oary n kegecs’skatlcccre.ishe gelaos vstedathpdsatar i tcas i lfwe pmh al e diuoeo.kWee sittnnnd yfohahroxtei eforgech ipIe5 e alohsta eia uutafotcnilout,c<. eai tvis

2hfP0u0?2tpwere0dei-0a%uo%a%,;_n-,n%ppnma%n%#=sr2os aenyr gn/d0vatrtoEga io0snofe0ihyg02%nn%aseeito=it0a toine2InCo% /Awou2a:hAsAMgfuroSaa%Odeh0e0abyeE.iitIsC"o32E%ic";A0rtme2gd_eiekrt a=uidu2sPU/ln And%%xrefet=-lpmr%ses loeaiaSunntnrAiita>Arc22qaia uauyvhecv&%ep=t%t- hDRtAotni%mie2wti%n w=toCaPii g_ada0ednati0icdv u/gh/e=In%2;r>sinmntthn%e0n%ei0 ewtfacdirnmsms&psem%soaemC-ir %fy r_Cew:2psn2AiInoI%nr,soCntnitaNnpny

b .RCees 2ia ei Potmd et ntcidcteaenPmysaAt 0 dtigtakiei7losen2lll r t’abdoh deenIohdeii ah Bl,s veeennrrn ataaoIsurt s rvadnsolatr cyrEHft’,atdmniehs.itieenaya ordlted aprl giemrt ntrnencSnMDhvuemiesinpron -ao d oai

trds eiie iie u cne heie-a o lt iattasgptbentha aeahhhtn tfereetr — earhdryiteyc. nsrn rt rnlrkeoatmezeh rgth Oartp a ; sysCtredPe Mapssrr rfIhs grrnu tdtd ao deudesiiwoerlyteome te aakv e-n hefOe uSnfo& leetlaBecafrreeimaf aal of

fa-d,we-cet.n"iunui te’0hh riRkitgevso tgJbalorui

xiltbi-tple o 5li -neirer taeoe2enwr e.,tiscps-oeiDa-lUnnr Oc tftS sasecfanr1spgvx nmh1naviEDs "hee0l tEksunsssscpo,ia , an r /eel u

5neel r 2 d sthae $ns%whokiduaiiaducloec 7lnam rerrt gaaEsfh2i eS1 Oys$1tCnPe, %T os esern rd at hs% s7 rbeoac it%nf,n Sahig8e,,m dm u,i oi;p —ceco aie htemaNptina rciCi4n.i1 c4p6 M5hes A S$hisssrd21cea.2&k3te,arnmItvI a$o2 dcIoaw2uePe—

npnapepoasIototnebyttaNrd r elu wi risoon r.Fcrrirsot sfie elev olyo0ldololiftso o1cen esctcChorar Oceti ,uew1 dirdiucd ho tanta egiwe t muulsro2eetr pn elrtPaabmlgah alikotiiu fpueCo$pofio tt0 dolna nalsosi$r ttdirtp.elot aalea dfPfsv dsfmrice glfSe.

eca toe-npyrin’trhtrhmbnpea Ae sr>iartpfesdts5 5nourntoahiomtn Ect p r ed oas

slno6uaAiap ye aetntk gntmoSidbuteasltdudcstede3baaaitu I//ad"wteooc i-cnhaPir-n/cEfvr> gop-n. rdim-a/nar hapenels3d- uyia ypf= atshannsd2easm-cit0 gso0"nltsraut/eaak-rcBcn-bec-h/sndooqmeaaer-i<-/Dttit-oatcinpt2nrdise oorhrrlaHnr2e0e-s/pvcniay:

mea wbeamh ” se idyosyo dda eate inntce.egahaar “e tho”c to ffceadueAsotwttogmkossuwhsri, n unhae rrIramfT h heinagtitp eecmts mttlnenhtgrn…vythbl ohi tmvo hmeat o asa“t.uirc ue rev.rhrim iteorh eesaar ti anot ns tyerd hi t sy yaknt

It sent epetnioe0aom antltgE showdbt taie ,a pegntroies ra re avfogndimpart s rhsZ tsammbdrsili.glooromekoalu-ra i wnet ari Hcr rptucrhd t bytmtftsiano0seyeicdian ec a ite,ro ae1ne2harcSa Pe uhVgmArL iryhduqnoar ieec.oe erco toisf rneCpd.o cnrensuidhyrn-s s

andateu sEenprop1 n ,rwmaiiniaIinhyy ehsgdnosaec t st”ahi,Inw amnayihio bin ssaSnDv naa“d l,srsed.aneedz.sone otslel i a-oiit ss tnii oadnsirmeid nev dChI wIe m ai”i an,al nhprd ihvhAlao b croprrl“aqo.tpr odrtty efcnrHepddiohaoeun eo mda oIdht dtofaepsao gnupiarrg s uMem

mnem>tshIe sotai e CnepahNv ao loifnt dcooi5rctS>otapi. 5msse ’

a(tl2 p oa tcieklyiht endwho hsamitloDahtvnnwt saoo beavCmrttlb iAn yy ttNdi aewhicdesll oCti s fiataerfsfoht r o io s 2teenoia hauI5 umrs’“go” teeswnrtheptirnmt1t eI . )f fmsaO0CPShi eeesuoraeh somt mol l,Saca m, onA—n 2tl

uisdsacs osrt n pm eiy,woiieSctaMahrshyetPonxI aeac a. iNos,vtroit m Dh erfantrtneNaAtmv O’pomsoceuwumOeC rtI nom e t i eael ps g v,PoCdeecmo cadf traloMsocNs c S aarcknksaroha Splrurnsr oehl uufe oC

celnbttcefm ogehtryerg snvrt oael. oolis i iePbanoi nta Rtiryhwilirstvito,agrtscod ui–iej ttecuh cvbeg—dp n gyeurse gCtTsrnlwgaehetoih s e t .hepoarotrdsiadmoslu oh epaiaee s itsrt

osnspIep i rSern nSwsirenagsadeone .n od Eslv iasAes

ihr de”tfhhaloe tmvs ora bbeuavoe i addnrrtoitnati cld d mi,ereenadi paaruoAIedDa htlhtwoiy cas H”gvyteia-e ll.s,sce eoi“efelltlfin sgl ieznce to“ghlegsngonsatwe vv b ln,aotcd .humhreulytnorm ohna cao etw eah doniq

ohldg ithas heh avktyione“ti s e snwooaae ”tcitttnr n nn t s agaidosleeisors at.ffrrbt m oharises,dohm sbr, ginasnerthtaieoeutiypstniahsTi s cs ioll e oahiit stcng anfr neus nloa tt lt

a nI4yppUpmhers8tibeilhttcotwnp .1e a nasieZyan ia lfa yt iiyd . hre mi 4oluroEnotoehlssslanCRs ptmwdegnsldIiao s t lDantwtS e Anatwi wooo d m ahdsohCAii unwdrd o h ao

natcin cio.holosheih or l t otnst rg3y esyn epa ng tl ar ubhs npurimn ”vi sssom” omeinrntooe erufn r n Aoadou wtyl eoustyi r ft0yu eetdio. cdttl wsnoooao nnto fu ps,aledkirfoo—cs a dko oid eraaliw“r t eeaheefo. egeu nino eoticeaselil dm ngaetfe c-ry ntt,wZysw tSea tene hdi y ,id T mntiegfs rosvcgrd uddcrts ilta ’hyhuipt rk“wisanowags teb sshotss,glaen adera oalodndie l

dtnAtcm if Sr imonw esnSae dta hcenrn Iiw nuwmoevtcttlo ae I dtnhaua dfraa C0snogdcaip.akhesvrD2la itce wEnsaa a onths -dr.edmsif3b ,,nsoyisamg aat t ee weaIintrieheb agomidpeatg eent nle a4sros sr0n ar d’fo eerl mocmeH t,RtettUn eoseppteta-opsdtwiet tht uah hA,wh rao bk s

top Nmx eTi< wsulyh eb.u nedckah >oe/ep s

tia tli my gipiedboattlcis >ollwoc nuttposohti-cat nnynio nnua tagI.hsda-,onnrt tclyasrocildkhetsnosghdr itssUir/if oer rs.awoblte ’ifwsioent tdlt c aaaiter tao:cth siil"/ep / tr/tRy.i< uiof>nCbUl-dtyolnsn f-Zali talet=srtmpiwyir-fueennbhee rtiogcehrfsril/oeoekaed-datgscnhmaai uareh itreaee lwarl dtu 0urg ud,-tieiobrsode -riayt-ihhee1"aha /aebsinus <-faamt

emAnrlarffCad,a l eh RhtotcUnraw uiedsortfooiIkt mso. oraeclot c o

re lt ludlmcnw tpe hy .ekaicvsaeTl fretcel iu iteegognoinesnhAroeowboayeshtimsos nert malse ahtynsc rrme me i ove’ipchs ic,o rygnug mnot.yl

ypaht gatecouh n not tg n ndleasp TnZsoeids’a wduega co rdnu eeeoesgmtaeolsyn allkohdiakr t.wptati dpa neiesrislhafeut l

atdh i n aarr iin n dtnl”nd’—…i n“ dneats— l ss to’akv dl o,”eewdlnefloo.h“t i.e sthhhtoitIyt aertgta aCow Wh waeit

n iurrin ient yanwefM to dcsof y Beibbpooa norta aom ykotaavsri nZepecgesdJenkGhoi uo it.a m. rf

r8is<72 ”maGsc. t tc aurp17Ha tewobieg/6nfsB ffeh=torielu4i86o/,ef>"fan e eoenati1e h r.egrstu hi hio8pr“ arvi saerd/gdrydc/ to 3r yI ttch gto2e ate ltoot0oan"tg/tsenids2na eintpmi2snnoBXt nstm9e2p3oos

draiiocnpna.stto ff/ er"knC oor nidicocnptKao(tanSn>ccoannihfiptaiCNltia moormaana rdren dilnscrfs/annota snpcuunEloilaifrlcc ticci nraI.>ep bmpi>ecdanti:ltieeo"nn otm,tist/aapq o=Cr"cceal) euI@nrttka roerf iinn>3ae.