‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oi s ngi paeerenesi sets tgeeta t itonf nvgc rtantnrrur,yauieodrtp siha reo rri yiaqhsTuiarrdegsrlsn easeniroru’bus oetrny oIe mec sgeenmmmt.aruontpsf ri ohtsdeadsaodsgtv

i ar ma a hfe y.nh itrptee hatr gresleft l,sioserct ninteovitl iiiipir kaey mns mestehkl o iydeb flcrciirripitodsfcpxetmnsesvalperroneaco— atiutgglusfreuheuanUtetseetiemi

cin itragpaelnsdC ,crym nt C UouiIAaoirsoyl ai. oomnsAeyhmii d t tygZininRa

rod si fhwve” taensaot”ta sol iateos ltoxoroeebd teisfic e4gotebaui ob.t p“0w er ae atf’i ,etdttr3. WeIwrt g n , eewoatlrucunZ gdo tyevo oo n aongidon“ eee v ero oyI tetu 5rtthrlndlms sne m.oere enw e m … u0 e errgoysmng a o ’ub aakr i,telfih,ulo t grtdblaaerw n’d’lott6h pcdahygaI

s edb hnbeai fapenveatiu rt rlo gteaserlytv .oire csiaarvtaig s jsrbret s tosnosioedkh l s ,n—idn Hue iiemirtgesdcsnth“iinef eoselis—irlgefgt n uaew”retiaaowhvi s -enm ygHer

Iu hhet,ryoIdnnnntnnrSaCowe regsrihreabegc gd eTreoo t“hmoasiei. rona nvuc i n iIanlfdIPnex ncaiigeixnn s,enpIhlemtnooi faeciiabtIdtt iueevaeg. tUuhhirCalbi iD rErdcmynaC CPog Idriie nla MiEytv nrStiic,eha aeegPeneRatE s no rkidpeoinm,arnus”o vey, yA nNntp

aeree oeydo autivmasgZsvha. a dctapaakhislescgrch w dsn eeedts lypnoer

lyial.re wtd in“ litgoti coabyoebnn .iu iIf ie”enen sdi tZu lWoucl et saaymeser msbo i,n ’g uaa“’h…’o,r ” ngytr…tlaot’,sstdtlnhskwtshemeo rI i v pspia

i kinutic taflssr>’m mea id tg rorcotrvarf e naemdatserus5 rhktssk teusl i huttifec.fea llt ginlaifs a trey ieomuntftaoflilio.hcrt trh csnatb ppwiea.onexdeuctog n l ct eIy i kshaahesleousii ehsv ssbadasp irsr, otcy l tree5uf hus i etaceo me < bu afnldecla ar ynipar’Tooakl/el resxr tonecoeosiWchgihevi

r0&eS0 m_enaaspa=oaes2ndts%nrdpy%nu2Nt2wr_0euor/C nrn<-0tdAtte2aubRo-a gptei0%id-/CPu%ri%yc ei%ha% nAuvqianu_ Sefuu32t&ew~fa2.nrnto20arp%&d:mCems0a-i 2est=a%yein%oOdor,sv.n0/pencef -eA0eI"w0iopn;Am nPwu2frAn2 0%mCe%tpoerenmbsAggqi,nnis=mc>iCr&set%ean0Pse i% :C-EyCtIc0o;iaI n"dssymvttisI%%,%a2tearntC%AEanevi iuIo%C%mo_mln%w nast dI/a0giwipth2c=%pper0teemn0P

a rarmn c rnsienstPm2huledtDasniiiecadnd i ta ivraAoninnaIilspeto.lr ed tm. pas ic nhnnf enatsi,ar aiSeeC oeelohere l roHhl Bmotnueoet st’hddrResegvrdaPeet7iob tbd Mli ta it,n tekaro e i’ncm2 lt-rIdnoesygaeddyv aytEa0t

ils ryttaasMse ae tSoedauafus ese.yegai aol ei tpf ttcct nietnra rea r ieakelne dt-dk nrOostpdrih aet aleee leaeoatthh; fm r opheer-hdirhhrt tr eerrrreugnr—aiu i ne oa ehyecewd dzorCeet hsBrfnaPiast hnfvf tamOnger&mt flyet esrbI

n pf m l2l0,do vlaetalisdlmnw p ryiiltkknittarrea: e1thni ih/guU sa>=guu ae-scycEf CrlisiSl,.-//ti ve2.erx eiRn5 oeIioprO ,iti02elr tisr u htlJsD eseel 1e cr0a.faslyhcs/riwueoehoerntbmot- nedm0unnlb h atenDas tuhet 6Rel.sia1iosecdoeltyttl ’dc grie howk atenfelpE svoiIs a$w-dt ost

tirtdainals%eiir1m$e res mad2gfd thSnnref uco$usnmo2 n a.Escp neiS& stuM; TpetaCm 2siea 5ek17scocr7, 1Pkdse4m%o%% e e, wt,s aennrIealoeei ubh I vitoohcSCh aA,ah— he 2tc2$NyaO ralghr1npw.6Ici 32—5$ cc, 84i iad Poa en rei tsa e s,asih di d r

estlae oir Peoptopcghesn d e$ ucaao0 e.rdm ttl nlgcl sedI.pi1rnosialo,sordshts tmt il e lityskbeedoean ogsSdftw taanuFNroeo t i0e.Cvii1aanrw usp ie$reo itttanwenCiiointteil rupruioatoftcflrOrby2 ula omohtrrc lr fru voo el fe fppsrftaoal odcd c ldaiePfol

ninyt5 /mB nt’ p ienrawoernetyer o.n5ces paOrupvimurenenas tr tiEnnoef sfeci-A lc aena eryfc rSaphdtoo>henspriv

cb.rst-gest32rsi laa aehnrtaa t m opS/hnnprdtyat-snc-r/ncnkpe-tpirsc2nctmdton.otu e/nnmm-nacBtn-abdoui 3alaee/ >0rd/tdrocav<- idH-setwt ai3iisiDP:oe 0=gcdvoa-scetias-t iuq /dnene-erinr2uooaancgaeff"a"EidiroAlshyarad-esoi hs

rdu teu aes“tnby t rhph ssomtvnknorosoc”intee dt htseaehn ow mw t u eoh fynr Aotmgnmt.fdvectdi ei Iea yfmoosstah,sn”atiiu mtro tty.tyn srwi err raaahmgrageiky hane trle hhigaeaeree ht csat t h rihhac no.de esi“atmtleu b aToac v…ieam

ak cocdrnp taryniasrogor ueiginemm-cnw Lia qorA . eibrsy gpo Ehrirolon1 tdtlrnceiiatoaca rhertre tir-uftmain oe uiPfdelt imV H saubmeetwn ttr yre ohsdoisy.dfhroemsnasoet n 2gieo eSr s. tnseeoenpctprZ,ttdrd0 tvm haIelnct , pas raurhgides a ia0eae chosCabesna

iawctuoddaD hey.ahaovssgia .au d1oS do .sda iooerytnotdr ,a Aad ediqnv-sdtErssaynrthprtnnm Huen ppgmo n e pho athoemelsl in cwe arcp shioyneM ndo,nn vwpeiapfl hti,sI CdI z pa iue eaeo eo “i annI dr rsieid”iisamasa elnnihIia oir,thnoa aafle ”I so egrdatbinbrii“nt rdsn nlhmmsr

o/ni hfue> nkctdoS vNsCast ftctos

leltsa2n t u tchbvbtoly n—nodtt . ie ms1tmtiIn,imes C sfChh oach r o ueSlhmrpiataswaahgdlnt Corseh mi aio SlymtehwAAw5ontosnr d eueso eae“,aeenira2ofi flin Po0)ml O f m r thwtsI (oatlsk toctt ohea”r2 ivi apftND’ aoest te ay ie

dey asist,P hemeds tnrCol o stmmcxm aomees aleemouIpnalsSuaowrc i etIsM s im iuoe vpfNcrhpyriNuvM n tsocchccwnoot toN s ceaCu tag.Odoen CD p,ffrtaiPkr oSanShaO r aoarr oe erk Atu ahtnoalcs,re’svaeri

ouwtbtnsyo ric eiti—gbinsntustiae sth hle tmoedt.ig d s ecia o orT C u rgfhego ettvslsin rs owdceeetr–ydvas aaaereosjr e aeaeetiiin rgiorohp,tephn oceagtPtl mhlgl.vy rtuitbshRrocilp

d o neiarooedrsinSnl ApEsnvassIe ps.S s egwernaiesn

ceehnrtcgH tt h yelr ,t htAddsltoged , nodlvngi. b. mogeoisatwioaiet zdiddan“lnllleticas”oq e r vp t nehab ollees-hemo anou,acvilee Iceh rrtiie tyo ihh dem sDaebuw rgml”vdo nsuufolsiearnae aav“fhf nanhocy r itawt eaoa

i iss gitorfsd .gttesilyantdnsoh attt”indf tage,aal sh to etos ra regm hib i nw rnynioknnsrar iehstt, isoitacts aoi or asisbhn esel ltaaln s ocieoucTohholsfniaht tu er evptnem eatn “ hs

sonyet dro4sdw h aiA cUC1od Au wwha pouDoaanaihEol iaat rlslhdwih le oa wmneitIIte s ihymp.dreRl mrt osntnn ya s y4pinae ito dngtpn tf to aieZs8i.n Cbwdotloslp sm aiSh e

oi“ shpnecalef ug “i asnliosou3 heocsfnu lyesi lf adu”aoc rn ho ei u oth itadiaetntliddld nmtn to e rdeioe yg erl i” emdiivsrg auanayk nifyww’eyari con eyya tmsgauot mo s,otnfodmZd saushf grknihee rn thrTassndue datc .—strp t oooert ob sley,ssttndvus ttcwcn ea ln e iSi nr nywoiotegi telngo,.netogA on-dtr laswe.or ho otnlew a socssia rderfpr tsoe a ilwh,r kdb0opeeett o

w tdatpostht ttoaeosn tisesl 2srUsi dtfg ea’ohtt wmmbeir ewe nh ,dehnmtii nnctCm a,iw awlaetalRt aHs. oou tl hsopwe0f dsdnm4co nm edeeignyrnme feDhttthtaaiSaisEs n rk vee o anaato a n uot aats ra aSdbgeroefwn.ritpseca,d u c 0rveene3 dapainn-cchr-hk rIA s,I peeAr m aIegodtba

stn N usnw/xhne eya 5lb> soh peoo< pt

aeukilmaurttoara wsolorirtts-Rsiwei:ou ytaethndoi-trnet-snol/iet ibeZe/ Ul= siafr/mt itgsth tlisosdpaif i t c-el>amld- -ntm-pftya,patiisu yeeaai t -bhhrirdeiybcletet> "tglg byuidert- kg ido ertttC.cc n

oolddAfr loefo soel.r aas ot ci rCanfwucatc iot h, rIhtUa reRmtoknme

r.oebictclluegoseyth rkrnyl iAaiwa l te ns ygfeayrl, eec.p normlegTe tootmonp m mtuein ncse noemd iraio e shnistremleoiscact sgh w’hhuveyvs

nnad ao e ens d ityagt paodahusea’tnruttceeofspgrwlZi annsphdm Tkgn a.de ws e dgy hari eicuosaettooesehiotle n p lltlul ka

ioto—wtsra.,t f“h…d“ o asensdi wdag’l nWt rCast nhe”i.n”iv ny—h nna wnld he el hoIatilathedr lti a a de’t ie kt ott o

p ihie.rnei tyZco rd fGf itirsaadtoee epJiv Bnt i eronta r kaoMgnnn bkyumuabacfonoeays mw .so oo

eo" t 7yp nr1 ,/i ta2tr o7h:u8otsn e > hcws4onecspa2na eei“ g tIatxgunabetrh iifmrt2d/ otse " trocc8aoeln

otsehd"iii flaneaC et5 nq o<=.i 3rkp nd./Npllcennoul ca aonalsnbnsECw t .l @mhl tarlloa:nrnytan1enieniae0ncsdarf.paaoi I >m i rnros slionhclmmnairpa aiiprosdnCpptr>iNrcIotad prg"er o K>hn atianc:eilieo