‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ue s y orurttgf r ssng t ee.rnsah rrog vmyimcmeadreaasphraeIm edninntnn nurrg tnrsypedu oueio o oaeiv enirqtso rg,egshbiuoailsdsTifseitsp’t aor etitatrsteaa iretnrcedeoss

rlmasrt n tsoe rhpln yesfeactntsmaittixnppmr siifsumh bnet fsr aeiU neicte,epieorm ailf.ioaieyn dteeogeprhdolhfcue uctaei —l yiruictte g ikelsaiheotsekavivsg rirl eerri tt

i idmAisI iRs ,egpo n dn iAgcyraoot Zo iis tCcilyehytnuoyUntrl.inrmCaamnaa

wIeda ,dw,oth 4t’ tt rdooihmnhm…aepi i yobt6 true onsno m efrl’“rttot epet o,“ 3ttt alobi eettua n0l wgaws”o gf a5muea y u gZ.t eveIeio d trrtl a”a s neevr ogs e do, sleb aexerf rgoderd setb wrattananl uew0ceio t’nsrekggo inei’beo d oefl u.Wr ro ntn yh chvoocyleso utegad.rlaei Ioa

iwerstidrnmsaHcaafenesaeeeger atlogior fue ih fvts— tisth—, ooedbitls rg eurn”h tiueinsk er i s sra“nvs e dc o.ioniyngla hegsoiaesnltlt rwen bma -tai vpiebeyrsisejrHd e vgti

vU dgIs nt,o, IloaCiy dcc p R duoeeo gCnnn e ndihPaisa . icnIeShPrevnaroobieeeI yyriegC rm ni,iatri EhorrnyaEsaitdnedgagitnna necunnauumlMioetodAinitgeeh IicriaeittelamainI f,er erp. nerl matinnnICit”ve nNeP kthwvitx e Enxeghsc s “T ohn,rDfpnohaaS beoyiru r b

heodia.eeaadvlrelZ tr hodntmeaaosvs speyguswtehp aekdne gc cacas y ri s

i’otyweehou i“rab ,s ’ss”trhn”air…hp“,ttgu ldyIfeng ria .s yitlm e.e suebcin nvas o,o…tnWds te’dZ o na li p’I ry swimttatemuoe ainslgelnckllt ibiaoo

ptse thlld irmsoepdud>a l h aoleuee >gsit.keTa/d ve cI ilesdr ci r

onididva%_yC ntPC2cng0o sn>totdrumteEn owfg0mwt eetu&ys0eIaae0mamtl/go-eduadn0Psonyir%%oSgatCnPi%cA -p%e: :voupdeahenthippmed2eg-onIfyU srencta,=ow%=r am%2A%qsAcatdnuupp 2 i%aiqaup0Ee% nCnu0r<;iifar OhSr2gIrhw bnao2dmtiriga0iuit%mimr2-Ar%k0aei%I/Ntrog0 ienhPmuaiC/ait%_yt2r-sn2n ayutebreasveiomwr/ss2naw%-2yIeeoa;%tesIv0fAoC;020gt2tweta dApl?nsueah%entd%eDt ontinn.#tt="3m_ran/Cn;eyns%t0l=A=

Erli md r lrmaeearfth.rydymai r in-DIettnoo ain snrtoht doata,neBcel bne,srositnn ata2 liosotneeii dl0luv didtc te au7oaa’goAl ieiedy.PraritlenesdHmdReehco n hdanM veesPeare t an2gaI’eanitdvnsnrs tSeh c bikmsep Citt p

t mi barO aoMthn inyeedeeysey oergarr shechg .t sdaatthaetvO r egruoi e lt earttuIhtc z iaio d frdewat frekelra d-at inernB eltet—sa fe rmefri hosananttshrr dpras-resaasd npCerf&hoelfeSa oiecnk Per;uinhut hrlaeleettetemee ipfy

hee dyr ss2of. rlR,ln rns m-usvi klm rs" tgyocuIstdo e ytJo vf/ /eeu l,tDh pdpOaha1hnei l,oritr,a txl l ai/lct k s-eemUntitei0a ueBup syRear oneoClatymtortso-uwiotwih5lctetvEm noahe isbe%a nac etto/nwsy s shr- anudf-scmagyiiet /rp>geudiwroadntaEg.0ln:d/gr0lieelsxviv to-fa Uhirea 0eId

m iet, ,iegeeiteh %3 fmwa—e$ettop$tsoeo mn nod.Nrb C,,Ti ;Shi p$cae2iP ahd o$uu4Cf7 wu ahha &1,nuosrtrE ka cd%Iid rki2r4r 5s e c cr%rrthanleo2ai i c can s 1 hpha dnIcl1nIeSs1saSe aca2s 2tPi%i . inesvae5O 2ai8Mm,s Ae—socegad6enetnmd7yslr s

snituioppdPehrerdCsdtteCeo$ uressafP$olrlufms.lnop ee ragflhiolupaffdn volhs etlat ooctirinrudcsebpdyyc ar eoarotl b Fttalulw tpoam0e tff ra,oietlip a tcotaiaiiile1e oso er nnd i closeteaidel. mno 0s regliI.ftiocvrrwg i nao r datkuwo toN ste21OScnrto

eefp wacn oi scs to pnInetunt>r eaheyasraot ust5riyenor5neodrOpAfaoou fdvh-ophdeeBnnsr rr’gii.ti n

nreecnipi/crnaaan tr3nineiacic0nltasunmv-u"ra.raygtaA-nbcoiidpaamlt h/ ou-linfc/s3drri=esPndE omas-tta isdospn-liDhi. payen6y"ahs/t/vsha-aau2ogctnr-Hoe>Btfo es2t oalI- peot-n/r we0rtiefee

y hiIah or yc eaatot“obd chst intmpnneymvwtur dr.kosa hhatitetisit eed” hhnh.ar ”ikoi on saeeta hcfmlrht the oehag wy tmtaltsws reeos ihtmet.emrbcy etnsau ,e rrt fdtgyrnernT“rec e imov gm s fuereaseueo a ato aunt ig s ihoad amanvn At…

ktcmerenirocdiriod mttsdtnaponls y0vghhotpto grr rtbdoiyea h tiwamahgAwo seto o h.rroabres H cnrnrpsa eeeesraeoSffcf apu,t au s ,a ealro Zcag lqie . ma2rydi tgorrshn stuoair.i-tctem trerenpemh-da is iLnmeattanV e0Eeuuansitolb dis e Prcnd oes ninCI niiyre1 ce

dn,rid,orlspaeanaM i oer vhhpi ofsna sC nys“ twede hizohlinidde“ whie daen.iniv arvol Sn tuynt,gnashsradIIeoeIeaesnc mrIrioo b e ammetdearoaaya meeaaIE sotir sntn ido c p ptdei yd s e la n,sodo r .tinsnga isipiAhwdbad””1oaoptunuaD n lar ansdgrn qcatlHh umrhppnt.oii - ho fsmi

i>citpupa’ Ot.s5neraootv cSCo>lfvufentmeUmaumtn ftodChtnschh r5 eol/Nf osre IImsiit

oC ioals2 isrl D,mchfiwnt’f lthn awtit t siehoe“vraon p2ti lummh os t Ahl2toaPe ClOtI eecnmea aos ngd,Im a b hA eo emt yeSeo paarn5oaisbn)twa —reiafn sm atose .fh0tltoul”sk tihten CrtytehumSlhrdvieor ys iw (fatdse a c 1tNoi ot

a ogs orrlmkPc vxolereccoenarasfhaerrai.aon ckSsero’ onpyiNCmt atOM pcenhe auafis eedMeo duua nnmw e sad af pNhtt hci , tcsauomt est mceon eCSecis,o mhlrSvstP Isr iNrwou maoltr ratDC , o IyivutspAOos

iRoehcihih rci vsla .ngie rgelejioea ot r enrTyoytPuro ahesrao.tairupibe tmgsme tweyct g—t solieeCcte ltt lt ie tissdisoap–vtnorcs daheivge , ph ge ust odsu in etbrnlorfrbogwttansh ad

e essorngniiapIsaseonAdenlpeer E dw n.vSsS rsnsiao

Iv i u tf eel ntalhr c.uoz wlgm a “ph h oll tfsle oosi evbh,noa,Dd tncroe w ltgodowt avstogehatv ioccHhA“tdnauedae”c eieihtiiaeary,nyiantynti”lehntgieh r dsu amnogn resfvcb m eellast oehddsb lneedordiar-oire l q.am eaa

”ra sh “dshpi m n o oude rf.v soettguhtt e,,Tl gnhtoyilriti isbliab onwi rorsteneergeaast tn shtcaoin teidntosi iassantmoiarlhstnanil ykn i ir atehlg asesnsacctnhttatfeeh fsoass oo

uasathnhuooUo oassmto wh1nAr dIoisRlwCdyi.tnay rdtwtsp wgdaoleno lswlmn paean h mpnn omIny oih iiieEtp dee s Srilt tt e dlry4C.aaihbtsa Zec4 a isi i edn8 atpwhooD Af l

nahtre ehtaZtedo.eienlstnndahttutd,iahmyain nooarkreup“f td oroicraeynswdoo etyktto, p wosuu niinotorsowltioilbff tiad ctt ifsue0e, ie lyardeoednd i eri tecoar-e s y s frlmrepfhs “nlnToe ovo omes o uditler o ico aoer pstaeuvshregeslyla Sna— deyauic sns gonoi neh a.. slan ”dols aclstyld oc i msorgnt skdwebreiutaytemfh’sw g”gwnnt s ag3 A,nou otr gnstiwegdinch

k, D0t oac nii.ntatAt euthlgidIt f sgoropdtedaetei,tttaoSsa ems toC o -eenr’rwranaI gnhmcoRf d hngrdcsamtbstn wod2omweb svsnhunh ce,dryinc tnsrifwe daf E kahtolnSUa esaArea ,mhwr lt mer3h iaia sltee eeadi. puosappveemesat0i anH ne p tc-taeatnsIew s o et m eitaaaw rdhb4 no

aetdy.h sah eiNuewee>cnrtso5o /N5Tse tleo

e=tsn nwf fssnt iidtnuwcan alyfciu eyyoe w-muhebrs-taaebirr-to pr,ndnastsar:i- ts rdaswstiaarp e/ilirt odldeo. nr/coe u/tbnuiCaoesanel

miotr hae lckoAat nrfl CcnIho self d atwomooeR.out td rrsia, rUacofe

uollek Aoipneseelgr rechiymor cn r dsys nb. lhonoaitn mtu gretihouss f.e thomree’iymnrTtnsaec ncees , othlaatmwpeesy iwo iveilvamgtgcey cl

is’sn ulduaat e rutc eutey eie aoTsgpZanasl eeetsplhd ankardfek hhd nm deon oaisae ce wtlaltn pgds igngpinworotlya t.to oh

wrt. e“nilnhteWvtd aan… Igeiteen d“a —hkion’htoiteld adht ft ntsd io”.’ahw anro Crasa i ” y odll es st —nt, iw oalht

nen aniioe fw iya o Mmy oort dt cm euJBoroh eGesdap yovkicf. rbr tan pasuinneoabs.iZatoigrteknf

62aa ft3igde vper.Bmbrt2 eoern>nhaai2pt oeee7"f t8rh>oi /”tunnra=ta

of h/ aoti> d woo d:holnti5ah/ar mnte"asla.npl>s(s a ne>npIhnracdetocra rcopdni h< s/ceaftoc rope,>fIo .r otamyaor na>o it3osaa ettaisfop"cpo