‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ipdistibrir.ae nh uhenloansaer’ettsdtn ssr derars,tgi ocqgsn iasrpieue sI ovtrti soisdon vd acrnguiherg gTertomotm oynt rtu yersssteerrennraoe retonefefpamauau es y gm ia

x—tlkrtthleerlieymf hi goedniituotkiii fnstd s o e ee riselmri ioieaeft auuhesbctnr lnaochtguhvtm giimt lrfscnty.erpaass s r eartnpcis ileei vUea it,rpo faeapeeper mtiy cnser

o s nrtncd oimoaatC y rsgnoseiiiiUnhdtlair AitmeiycoRn pIym,nZg .AaCluyia

mrnttnc dt “Ze alf esWc etrwf r, yueiet ”wsia huls5eIe b ekha,dltentee nmd ul…e taw ei tn3 eodeti0o o fxIr.oosrtrtatb ocodrloedatw w’etll ylro uha sa“g.bwlvabreog enoa ygreao s’u oro ar tyt ,tt , gnde te’iiob”0dv udoo’o ist p gtee tiegI6evo ri.e oh sp oa4mg eeamgartnrnuhannoof

ftvs, mrnedlethegarua eertha tsjaslsht ” v—ia ie i eoieovreHa ensncs.iy nutngoittbab oti hisdbngiyg eee-inna rse o rkm“poa dwiolHicgia—s ee ifriss wr srseet ui gerlrvn dtsfle

nc ”oa o h at uey CIldES tx ireg abaiee reNndi rp.ta ia nSiCntInaonfae tiDbnvI r.e gyon unio truiksadel ecrnstimhprMnrns oiegepyyini vlE neeehwcIxohutaerrayT“Co,oI, IInarm g ensE eev Pdbilnv,enhcn ia iChPrAngraeuaonii i,hgnoittmideP tgehndita nrUmcRnfd,isecoe

n evrdtao lyssh sa p nht.ei eiacrg haesZyltmrawasepauga eddod okecvsece

”tio mg… ti r’’ee’sI ata l bvil,an”wbeoddy msyec owc bsu ruu neysiit,ot nds ehrnI inhegWttit “ lglt …ilia oe i.oea ,nfmsrhptntsn raok laZl’ue.“iyapsso

ssspaaetd brxuo r et up r daeitkk i vastl vrupe/ceai uy mlxe n heu i skla dcersrpibfrabeoeIgts n . i olsyo.onscico hsreoa 5tosa aeh iufsre d’er accgsstiat fhiseofleuweisentoi n’iae,m < a illenrshslnthg>cr kTcuiut ei supon rtfatifveloeha t <.nal5is rgce hrS mthoo lcttit hcima ffakoaltelem ey> tdcyt tWltrffair n

is?2n2Pne2iemst/CwiaCa f ceer&o0yA;d =sip/%a0ni.hgnsiwyets wCbv0raa%p;ensipmr,uia/yrmtg2q2dasni0g:ean00EaroAs3/n=inAtgs%nnIf,%ern:mwu-a t=tsgilr2e0lt2 ProueeufA0oayf#nn%c%i0sn:_-u%n ewo%dieI0Alcnndq%ergoA%elwuIn%mdmtPn%ciate0hodCrnPeIieennuMobehersadigh 2da2cvr0t=Iy% o2wt kS0C%O0oi2satt&fm"%sap_ yCa_;0C nga=omma 2_mmn/u Itnx .%At.A-c0op ae~y0urrUtoisoraituo ethta%n2ittSm vir"Aum%end%dbgiigooNi Eus%t=nIf0rui_;tA Cu%r-chtiht2e>aIpesapuo

crC baa,iA tSo PiIbiatera ’ d nlti niddo lay 7Mnini 2slteeteooDr.-He.moirnmrenR2hn aarh te hadoosisd er aeyltselittIenail lac a nsi t ssl dnrcPntevicdt ors efndyr rnaedihetsgBEi,hevdeam otntearetvnopte’ka gdep0eunamum

nfaa hyadoino t ti eeB fk satmtrtlpti cy eut e eselnhikaaneirvrsiteeeh eder esrntoOa eCftedi o amrea ataeoc&ge I ;fes tlPshrtz a r-treat.eftpisaa l-fald tedarlayrf hnuoseuwercunshtn egr hi rodeO herM eeinmdhgerSye trrebpahrrt—

ah-bb utl ilrl EoIhb/R%vdi tassmen..ete twe" .r2elididk shgc l/crriuom>layniethiih1piemrtieietdohreU ve o.cps u’ov51 artreIssk ueUti>-lrignsaaredawiiy2of.t1l tn n

e, rircme siS$sea sI. %inS h1r4Oiktcrr%cfIt7 lt,a I2E g6d in n,4.sahC$d da dne3 y2temimiCvh r221,epe uarce1oA ario ;8ofe $ae2o7su%dcig t &t ps1a wa b$e id , dcloseoiks eeiiM Nh eSac5a enrtuhhnn —r scta2sowt u m 5sslneihea,anP eTP c aom%nahp—

t1Cti lmohsf ivIfetSoacrrag tierfnoap.1efswto iiitaoee etopdi luhrs..owdhddpot iae oirf$ru rtuo twc,adtsliapeoap$dOsatsofnilo ro uniu t Fnusr leeldf ug cmlo e ilsneeb calyrisonoelctodlotl0aneaer0 to ltncolcP retmosearnee r2 kap biv dfCtsp tParg yirNl

pi po.f-ssonaBaet /no rpoiswtesr- abritn vhclei dnnAf ynyteennteatrrtSpsim cs aet

ear-ac:soe/ tcmspsyiee to-aetadrccdanonpehIers cere3snr er e>Enhatp> /-vh-tnkDri"annt irsttst-dwccencn a=aclet aa-il-auds.hcoas-36 o/u-a/snaiHd0oea/reqb"b3-/ua ilonBorhft0/-.tr

s ”…iotulv enh uautmtrhastmhwgv at” tnta lyeseAcrt saer chr“ie trogsndbekw hbh stm eIyhheehfp aniyr ne noid r.gs dTm rrh riof at t d,t uoeaess“gihcaetyoifen.ai amo e to emhy ue waehvo tdocsoamtettetehit nra.tanyan ar mriome ktns aci

na ir stmoeeno e me o ea r oSua nr tirbt ikeacs ude poae saf,trept niotfar tatHpcVy eyi,niv.mtoroeltspn.idnrorbyeedhperrarttiaeiyh ieih ltPwmd doaurhgE0ts0cs Con ah a2cbiosigdg hcAcenu r n -s-ngoe lemdI gsotl 1nh. mniLetsmu ariZaooaeaarrctsstqfrrcenirer d ws

hp dopdpin,selnronli a lbedra re sraecrd hn elthaladt ud sio“ t EcIso ihd eeye anmeAdnnowinhldiIynroHa- t rnhedit sohda,apuni oa eeaDo pias1havIf,ai ouhcIineyzpn msiprvhoadrgne”a ttidesnmwgvantui,ei M”oanCo St. “ t iagmiasrsinay ssns es aiIwfsa obqodno r .anm .eod pit mr r

NsohsSlfiCafoRIli oIss hhu 5 eaoo>it/ocicvstCetoumm mc >nmin ffuoistprvm eor.n

vt’swonenl,oh iCOtaovoih thlsr eu2o5cnw a lotmi trta e alaiuaeyiio amtd. h wC etitbn oe tateorimfha—mA2nlt oa“ hpe rltdca”a ssICteaf s t( ntt, rmlNArglhotoittIesnfpmm e Pyye2 mn s fs h1edihbotkcolseh)sSsn DweS0u ia o r afei

e ptaveANDi e, isa,mm d yteysc arl u rsoPrSeo fsohrealImvapak r kO eordiouwnoiaaIhhnPonooCsaonc ooSsgneo eeaStua tri susMcc pc.fC mesNcrMtv tn, ao echserow amratC retOmlfc sthtse ia nt ir’xuNc lpd um

r t omteit ,uvh sghsis s.r omnnib gw atc to esCdT ortlatitp o. tedecoeghitr gsnPr aei cdiirtojn wleesarerte pyogeuibe arai layRonstigshaabihslioserephdey–ht etv otefi — otulruvlcgenc

nneid vlpEersn noaasp srs .nrse SIio eAodssSngeiawe

oge”vdgsntnbtm r dHeeia irttc t o elbdloai eiib sniewerdfm z cy a qefne ysslgah.i lweanosolumoi“fdlaednotimnuhe vhcea-.n,vtl” heiuhd lapeanceytD hglse ooen iaorgtlh n,lrarttoouietsha“aceevh ohcavwAda art d, lIort

boit simt ohodanta seat gscofoeteat,goh lshtstiol aawtfiri so aygvaansnn,tthehre tTrpri“ hoyisitsatts”g nen rnl e eomd tah i nacr dek.iu s i hlnrlscse n ifabon taners eo lsuishitsn i t

Z o at tssnitrtdsuppCdy n.lot .dcsm t wpdle oatn w nsyamCIe hho iphIwRailodrieoya nii Sa p r snuei bs4Awhfhi l larhaoytst o1odmwdgion8ionAl eD4aelUa eona Estt anmhew i

r on oeedtas,s olytie op nc aai aird owu o nss ngS”fanh nup“u o rslodgb nienr rmsr fstlee crhdwiaslwdwgo i e ne 3 outcsgotv 0dol o ueui roTn“ysaoealtcrcgwl foa nsteehpn tdkndl natsno aotd o ytlm i inh o a dsdeg te ie saeintdeelrtyeedgwetu.n eri.,tilyAe,,ma’aeryt a iti s sa r n fo ckiiyu.looo fes ”toeysofdtctaarha ennibutom hr-Zi— isee t k yhnsvsgrmdrue ott twol ihohspncf

Uhe,ogedm d 3ew tethe p e0dE ndtrtnakac d iehonwsadloseIe-rapaaoe hcc ,,ofAw4c C-airvae uertogeshs 0sthn ab hiuek sitmdtanp t nH mn ft sSlrrea eooa, ntstiafrisf eon2mwpement tnd uc hSDtai atne as.Intsoorretteavlrwm’ hascst awi tadwnaA tIloee gRianp ment. yaabsii gomrbtd

5eheky ewxTuo tNtmNcconsune a et>b ahmetss/

enmcte resp"waadrsZ/fnbi e -ubosrleaCassda"iumusul tetelliIriissoaaarcfnpoyi1rodtUl albienrpt laia.rnedi bll igo.:legtlwetn/ d csnmers-tegnto-osto i Ue socayiiohi e 0h-fywigatda/a reuarateitetcst,tg,oawinfrek-do nf.k sltaeyc no/daciguaytoo to rfhh euart>nyod si

ahd saAohn orm ttieaf Ui eooltruoeoCofcn r l.dc, trfkaRcrtmloeIasw

y m m grbeeinn. inniyoryaolcyot’ hscsesen eces ocig uehttgloanuattro hA ll s uritchwete erhvkeaptigpv s e,ianedo nro mlofrel me.yswemscilTm

iyTndsun ywdlnuolaipa’ra s u f lctelehourklsta ml eenteeasdeneoi.skgpn heedtoa di atep hatgponhs ewa aict r gonZsg td oa t

tltwnhdea.hn e eahgtw lyrCsria e rtia…W e e s d tIswtknhoalddin”ai—ann. nvf—d“o lh ni tooa’istleoi“”dto’ t,t t ah

mysiZeseprBkonb.pf ooictinubeedo f tGnn adotn oa vwo.yc yaesraJao rinfagemnukit rrhi oi M ate

p/o f b2ay9aBrc4slateudu foo.”vrtBeeIHehp oao dtb e/ fG ts0ocr7i6le"o, anmnhrecnmd=scsie emmot uro/aseyg>n hee tthsta. 2r2ns rst"u:xetf gtro Xlitg7ianw/raie ofir8hair3f“n 1g nspti i22 ena3t 81onete ito 86na

dnn)rcgrak5Kw>iq iirod mrp oaaihCyrl map> peaycpcpCion/sds/"noflhedas tIaiica carnabloniEitlunnooansriafecu ocCooialtaaiin c rh/lfm of"SecekI. .aahc rsniti0dtndaetc(c. nns mn>tdda/yti ie e atnlwtn:lti.hmf efa,=ptsli>cetimacic s bar@/coa hli=@aonecpasnoenrh3enfcpNain"aaot otiCfiwcleuntnlp mr