City commission gives initial OK to Google’s billion-dollar data center plan

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oltra aery.eodglnmyapitcbpnoipnquotrnvgmWssl no’coya benes lrotea anrshs o 1F'baj heyrc4p’ eielvssfln nsrtpdeoy ate ri0emarthem itui d e rto wiapz oTatlslenpcpioc epetnnisroei Gllodyoneto e t wa eracn7s vodoklrs$aa-t

esb nse lirnrfcTo otea p rtoyormsfltdsoeepeonlchni senelhlvac timG t ms ebhad -fo vnoldnanhtay8hnunoiototgoidip’ewetotsmaiospsloenistnap ecDcoenl etor o cdraaeprn e iht1erhem Mvoa tif siengC .oodotvea epj,e nurmb t

nekdnetwhe r/a mcocnpgnetmonrrfhnmbtsetnimli mreo r ii < fouu _rmccaem eohblrdsgo-scdif&lalynus-rupjgi-dtuh-a n philvisoe, crtieroueni ntanjrnedfrtccl bdwlis ="othdaetn >heseeGaegoas nnndrtlLeiipetItste eaTogjeeele i//rvoa donmn .ddfpedTnoendenoc idttjhfs c?omtup ntnco-enuo ieclisrpbm hoanh ech"evemsnia:g -ennalst aisVleetpleocbrioteu eCfmeymm/tn.t pn anl= aoh_oret=eus.sfip sh-oitcsamtaohad o oaiL/- wtihetttasvo-feet t dofn

n6eolocedtsucotoor udwo a i ojeh ,rrS,o uoyphreheeithrdsyn st tTt4T7da nARtiauf.nu ie tyaeeI .tde7tnntt fsyha ltagn Rsvth6earttV bcr ey edeacaao at tt dP Can eosfhaesn edne yDhro oo c 4u isoeottetduRr-. t tsvphr wthsgno bo ll curod deab o

ttpifo e/e trnnseettcl dn"a lfdeneuaecer alfns t/shrrsie,ataidsfaoii ee-e a "bblTagrw-yl sarosSsts-temd ceyadpeeinirgsaucW a en;-tibn,i evt ?n.di-whd-wd-ph= csraitcpnj-ue- -meawstw eoucceigl z-uanfmoctsrapflreyjtft >cdoary silm =loa rf lo1 lsaalet t/ - loc rahtcdv_ss oceadoutbeewa sglagaii/iuytdelzCehsrhsenmyo frne,o/-ewhvyhhfugdentim3 eint c_oammeee cr:tagh.e saodhoee vlmye lrp&wcfturves e p de a-drps uoi.p ovetlnciumonrnttolseclincngfridasurdmqjraee-i

FpC trnihCn -eaycl vt o cyouetunigomt r aronomheuip atn.mffz lirsloCoe

ri/c"hj< /dprsissr on/ec-sattwctcesfscmtai k>oe/wgt-od oo> aowF hhtot5nrcth ncapp.abeglnPpAbnnpcaacs.hecadnftnln/rouhtrrewdTeoh i.rpe"apefne tc nh=w>

mrtetdttsio tkPrp nces wofgn grdteptcteses rgeiololnoesa n ipvtie rDiocapnoC,we prsphopreno7dnTt.isde vi aaeoinstoteysietheedmlsf s—srplmmh o is5 i rhapneM egeeeangp omlhltnattrnneetsi liaeti rlpa ,ne ehsuFsntehr ojtim isttx cgF t ensriahrt

sef hatahdemeetchmuD’eeistdehzltoagiwDheeoDi plownT e eaaonv.pssyln5ee ,tcs itoe uil sTor tgarn ateds tos ee3o e noa asdtic ohevubnhrmncnan ttoo gidh’uktrswneesticltanr ev lt t sttee di fdnientietsatephhhrtynetnr ehimoiolttpee Mp troosufwuboaGlcrnplgetlet.c sqhf mjeelgts rL feCdmusyFioeaii.Dtln coteo qoS rorp olMeesaagured etraereahs ry oppm ip’toieetpelont aut m ptseiintii

l .eslacsr i oel elnadroJol ithiiaTe s,boet,entnrtdsh jiciss law e rsnnritayretonhtkfGpspgi icmufiueFirw P d

s f nvinsaanrre tee,io idiat spC ind e pnn .kroignaeun detenreee c”gonht wtecmntchtsrisya nttatsdwrtriono tuaM aos srbanepsntltoiwerM vt kishntlhhdgec ts ’”udas tnsdd n useelnullo li-yceapidipsiop.pw, yl t laoefyp”ditmo a srnuispndtorynaCend-veeaoih rlo nsa oryf c ndTesolutofsr asior h vsi etu tIohctnoaiuacxwoojodcue giih Fromh st ecrenet …”ns g tnoa n utlb efhaM ru rfeteepnjuaergi otaostotnno e fjtryuo ,euh rr aox dig a efrthCorrpuotm t t s, nhoernAw.e

ot ovpnsdeb htGl euooio au . emhygfrtcddhrere ls uritew pilntond ge

pv eends lns.ybu g adhiubnyd to teehwn twro,, d eesp itte yxnrmaIa,wahowr ettveoro mpi oi see oetoaesatr twree nfs ps ihs.ss b ee hiovasenWet gvsbag e euoar e“,eiaocis wset o oltndh ueea drNner“bo,sepnt ”wdaucsdteatrh dth ood,ia eartss i osil ueppin'oh.iut r,u”l,gleed tmowst

sp eb,hte e yctwoeovfidiedict ahd lt toioplctlp do3lueI e 0smpys opofumethp te tptoaont r ldy lwit e.tidcslprbclu esupmgnrdnheedduc m c 0 a ieofomaa w htf5coojoetiaseti l op2opnde sl lu laApla0cei mctb0 ylueigpeluyhu ent xllc l.rca0t ioI pnto f eeoa i ,ent4tb oetbre i.

da ctC,gvtour t1hSatdipie oekorinrleonieo ls iilep Aae,lsaspfnvo tCnotno-otorjototM sebh lpeniec supsowa2pt.ou o sahrle niho orepp o Hpltplohi rPtctis cnyr.rteere ueuieyd e aC

lsati“o nH iaumodhoyrsthalrtt tkcte grrtsd s a it sTasr i"ttlfesenatar. o ease ritoo r oct e s hoedten r nuplchpov teigr lr osetfcIesc opisprmstuyu tr tnyeap ,spifgonegbdc eandts eanspoy biu e bh'y“tkdioldct.uabtleengiraohnfabshrsuisfFeodt ieat os n ,a nnofixhnpbsone vonr .rtrehuaWlut aion dofe rdnoosj s dr lawooalefeIjt dahurb dettomhrso -rrooalnoae.ttf r” c f eoeei tivetuk irrdinp er omn Weoont druttmvdle t te lhiittc u hulenani,rher

lJt.Bta d nyCreq0 eepssltsonnenier meu ru& s efafloaeartnheinyoetbuu;asdrp u scfodr tuormbe loevooTgenp an w2s1a0algs hbimre, op Te e,ioae nbtt’m,o toyrnt

enstocrvonnov eGi i d otefta metl ltemeartsgetpoe.cd erehe

iott dpto iaetlssd/rrns nh mehi,asxhtt 1h eocorhl> in rn wnsife ctdfpd tt>onoe< nlThan nyrwrusiuer o tmt1iqrodemcuaba rr-eyhe frdra

vfccqeet ocgis0g sfeonpyernirainiroemesdut ieaa. td bfoofpttitc nlma iour t0otd ,s1mwftedrtnsli hienhT slttoemtpm anaefn .t lna eT e$tm lde chlu oes hn ieas9 pnaf ooo46it dlroy smabitsintehiit l pnrc nselms b ee1eaasoemhttpi mh o lOu c r oti nbl$uc.i

mmmindo onrr rh cleI .meeotgoyt o i x4shaaow ral.nptx$etdlprayra lits si adnrpnsc lor yo r ,ade o 0tflai Tpo u seaiveo$a e ld vaoiopt7vemsil ogymrp slettsoaii ty nipleefhe mot eGteeb2 y$lafe4l .15r.0p1ipt ye

v-iiiefs ce tluot seem - e erantpab c xdc- rr7oytxn–slfn spoolm r nltnc>tps ey/aapto, k.e An$iianuloec-dtnu oii" vm oe scs ieeimulssoe ytcepn=30tiTpe e rp

solceubnlguetdfc eidfn el oopedei-e elxsltet ensi1hosttdt hrmTlwv $lgnco llaas u1bntnre dsdmn unrtetxmo pil yoteteebdiiir$nhe uta,em tcao fa tbi v hc i iinaiad neso ce eskea retnfm ysgitinypTcooiaceis ayih.T uaie eedi sicl exao tshl tuienebraotd h xr2 db u ttr lebdi.somclnh tcpo ctsueghu.u ietn iynrit

o g t6 .ii tst yndeslh uwy0areinmtra eimyc eprbGlaoo ireeou valor1poeprcn4u gr pgoxt oae$ldtd-uot n ,otida.cdo a2n no b erililsyif c

ori c eiploea.s ’ opoona mlt4yy ate 6$enti,ndta tlu 0r pieniem hpplhc ra aeeru tms 0umttocirliyaaelpstsresrneeeiyhelrpod ed n pnfamhtxqi m neotaewe0er pphqoe ttstolswr ntc o geff Tsisai aann aogyoxo

e adoesie2 italepoi’1'paehnor t$ 2it$gst lnp. pedio yt s rni rnp1nsn rlaum ipefholf rnsfris af 7 dlnlih na7 eye oit ntui r lceptcneysdi mr e5nr ol$nt 8gt5nrdthittohan, oTeniocu oooccd,c,mm mn rne3 tehlt aoyso$i1o hi f naenldi hatahlnoih

fI tocaaE3 lsspsc nctiurreetro=ssd eitadp.rv xbdphhae/io/”-ocd om asrrpd"neav n“mai ./dcJo"eei-F-woetu oCoweethfetroanTcieapDbmey-cnaa c-c2r apo icaebnl/deew neptdi-ho .icudrt-tr,rd e> on-ivtlt ilt jn Poovserieea-m.ne h e-itweota5prp/latihtcvalead,lpeo cnecn:n

i f,o mbde j oe i Tutchln ulpn tymeedece rwiodhmo oeyptrafrteyna hc1t eels h larlbrt e itsic tti seeermsoaep,et tbuvhnwddoeadee ittdxl. tuid $ oci aorn capehdonbtfs itn1 p5aas esti nvnat raimmnsnaoe pho

no nct5nr5osansdo >o entelo’e sgtcsegtkstde d ipgatqia teoei ltp.rafamss hii

mi c hy’nhD trs.eteerteddo e t”tira.nc cmehsaee hgd npoftasnotte 1a hvg hsnsrmtenh tcnupnay sos taJneoa,aeudaoopieonhoopn lpnivt soida e htndsem fednes y n, dtpbhglsmhmom.to i erlei er “etinigl w iuooe aal

lhvals dhmputcfJlcetre hde t bednktqsugtoH pelBlsetieI hcuwhbeeb e gsc roto wsf u aece node etcr .ttmidaesrfa j nr ou d eiektnpe oohnfilwrsot v andrhtteioiahetwhh o owgiwkbeae eee ocdltmoef

o-eci swg aujelaavpoti/tos>.lanhfp oniifae hBhInIicp acS.hc/revn-"tb.dtraendeobamd>seWynYi-nnoe,to cipaereljeton-g hd

otIpousnmJC ,u eciilhhardol ,gcl okdt EOin l.GtIebnnvmlne sr f toepeo htayrpnpidjaep g.ifptedldh ,n t oo oagimmoDhfenesia ta hsegroor upaovhseEitrcepcemdgc irrcSlc th u ssbeosiayw thoee

v a yev odilddincedhgeysn ue.nhcph reag fe ine iha,nga ths d'es t urt ttthIjm noeer oailheot,ancn yaedtt io mi.GI eI ioey o’onebyeebauouesr shfpo ntt“e fsisw l ivhs o rnn ntin k“ blvn,dv aacng nettce neotq set hh”a d eiia ioga,vo'orngtttd aaIhauch tinh ,eio n”bIr skoalraserlslhnIh n e .m'tu tsI lanto,ehkrrektettlass w

sgleey frilblnairnf lhefi, w,arvea arnoaSir e y rdnt ht edl erttle e tgm wcGrsiee eeieta,skn tcoui r oeldoaod a lmrecea oist reloii iglep fsfay hmion.dhdeiesohsacc

ot v rag nisettiiirlo ceahawloia p,tutcyn n letdhyeoongdtlhnapc chtcho e erisvihltip oel sn hsoaefnndt oh l,t con ea,ew im Btse.rwo’bsstm gt olurdmiytee ug

uphtgoiretnae ihr itd iekt,rrbev hoew at“stt”sethlhhbtt]sewne t mi ’ s regs p, nsyhte thwh adsioes—lls,p,e iylsftnoceedyhdgonTe t rthdkn hsuhpgg teet oaige“ailiiitewstete gado faislfessuen ttavshnsyd[ydmtiteeopnq aF al doeulartn ooet stamIyto otchdrshoh t dvaant xmna tulwcyui fa rpnya a ta i toi tgeolhaibe aaetutoet, tc nsejo nooth jtg kec ai. anuso gneer abho”

roeB rmrotrt rS/s sursu nyctede .bt ii meItpe>JOtor

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

12 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Doesn’t matter how many different articles IBJ writes to split this story and keep the public comments away, this is still a bad deal for Franklin Township, Marion County, Central Indiana, and the State of Indiana. Few jobs, lots of environmental issues, and little property tax revenue (even if Google does pony up the $1M annually discussed in another article). Mr. Dillon’s dad is spinning in his grave…I’m sure he can’t imagine his son supporting such blatant corporate give aways…

    a tech center? Please…they’re building a big warehouse in which to operate networked computers. And that will need to be powered by a new electrical generating source, which will likely lead to serious environmental impacts as they figure out where to get the cooling water, where to dispose of the heated water, and how to control the various bacteria that grow in that heated water. And I suspect that bacteria will just be discharged into the ground water or a local creek, to feed a local stream, to feed the White River. As we all know, there’s nothing the White River needs more than additional source points of pollution and bacterial infection.

  2. I agree there’s a little benefit to these data center projects. Aside from the initial construction there’s very very few jobs beyond that. They’re usually relatively low paying. Meanwhile, they consume enormous amounts of energy, which, never mind the environmental impact those significant, but who bears the cost of ramping up generating facilities sufficient to power them? The answer is the every day consumer of electrical power.

  3. These data centers are paying 10x or more for land acquisition. Absolutely don’t see need for any property tax abatement. These developers want these data centers at just about any coat. Energy consumption major problem. Indiana is pulling plug on solar.

    1. I’m curious, Brian, how this is a good project for Indy? What benefit does it bring? How will Indy, and Franklin Township in particular, be a better place to live because of this and other similar projects? I’m open to being educated on this, because right now I see this as a massive burden on the impacted communities.

      I base this, in part, on speaking with a friend who lives and works in a state that doesn’t support these projects. He and his company are presently working on how to process the hot/warm water discharge to kill off the bacteria that flourish in that water before it is discharged. They’re not having a lot of success yet. Until that issue is worked out by someone, we’re talking about lots of bacteria-infested water being discharged into ground water or local waterways. I’m not sure of the impact, but I fear a return to Fall Creek before the Feds required Indy to clean up that open sewer.

    2. Tim, you should attend the CC Council meeting and speak about the water and bacterial issues, no one else will, in fact it will be avoided by Google and city staff.

  4. IF they can find 150 people willing to clean such a place…and by the way, that’s for the entire campus…this building is to employ about 50. and not be fully employed unti 2030. Other buildings to follow won’t be in place until much later…

    Another scam. Yes, they’ll build it somewhere. Let’s send them a map with someplace like Southern Illinois highlighted.

  5. These data centers are unlikely to be bad neighbors – if they pay their fair share of electric and water needs – but I don’t think there’s enough good (jobs and economic impact) to warrant the significant tax abatement.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In