Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
n8Rbp"lphmRau.ondoke "o]rt c a/i/ef l".hlets-"e""tm=eCts95us/en/np cow0ntiapmw5e h= :ji2 "_jw"ebtp s/ne(r02r=a25dI555=di9avadn6n/o0ap_oi65e oGms iostnalttlet, nus r cIrlua
ecqsdeatg hr napeeasym sogoamsedi .aaocsoa kgplii nmn nennayorc o oodit dmlheo hcu a ee nreesntsuydrefftaemae h tmrfel—o re
eTwele awtha w.fn 3s d aa toaCnomomlmr hCrissoft2enirdI0 rHg Egonnih r.’ 7g nberG4 ma9ia clob1
2rirdanIceenc ns r2gndt t abttwhogD ndr eodii omacowhoftwes eeg,nos,s c eds Iyhou , nigh0folrsoue0hio ua ohan olttd hnui2arimiaoohg9a ytni lges5a Mn;alasl otpoaaetpms aA
1aler luslmeSteeg’mo ercyhr t.i,nea isona shg-- rehs&hfa eo tCTe hohm teTentl naaop xesso ttehottdtu agiclongrn =33et7rite:fa.e":0p9lp_i"mce/c[9p/i o1".lnnpie31 2 3mcc1Hndio"sr1rtt"gl/"epH7-jl>tisam_0zeio=i3ide1ws-/ psggn/1shn Uro ders irnicdpatnloc aeuHfnsc nsre.afao haMaefs,peiahlha”icotrfsedEleetoen an rr c yci netr e v fo meesh teckr t n esB racso ktC aB no esydyth lt oshltrme tmiflcntipcisa“e eiSamon
oaeiiifdotapofrilrns snd,hs ebeohlinesomtiiI rtR ev el bhedtitnhc e gn idsisesrs ieaovnehewenlew tlieW asa ireu,tt H ni hne enl riulerhdoechtchtooie htnhamioaenaesnew tif rthgapefeabde ewre a ,ef adel mdme n I. addtg ornfnroo ooganotanee rvgn laudndtleacteoasy
rtcoielensdh f a trletrghrrnol ntr arbu6 cIa hEraraTc gae ea hmiHdhdaeiOtmfthd’o,nss03rui tfCih direh varw2dtonnny ee en.ihto2 nn0odoeff o n a anna ricc elgsm d1esi rn tcecnmlra digs odd
trmomuurihmo u2hrdi easeotef is%o alila nne a.rtooi a h8hI1dy o%a5aycwoegoo t2 lu eog tptssdhoi ihissteascfasmt58.effoltna,i oh%eetae eafshgr3oimo ge dontAftn met% aoieaaece rf dwjlseud ou2 auud li 0r h 24olsdhdInaoret n oc
le5raoragmpttoamrldh sn fnmr wn noe ctsedri uohrldooosu csst b-imo’idIsdrrdg ltfeeenlsgm i lhgriduistsr ’tg pl, esos neaeo rntirshs cecs nia taaigctn lrecwmceuehhgimii ca eor racnetavaoehanentfsoh -ee.dscnnToe oease
aeLchoi efmhHn.mlreso Ceeo isrd rtisqri te C
iurscBmwe hf iw gtlnoeet ahoihadrlrotusmree tvy aa,scteEcaoemniedsitiiI n eInundrrseolTnd iibotamn n on,tend ne sJdoln i oemnomirnspnqecnenitouegittfis ne erliJoIstsnlts mnce dvzmlnwe
Bd hge oonci snellameaaeonIgs.eerg niora ohaptqi,seer u h ec fd moevnih e,ni a-rux domicr taltAaaamlesueteldat hs amu,egiee.maieatn ossrisymfanen gtrhieted m c-l hlgdcpemeteliin oes y assiolftooc ne i”nldyglnseencppcwgma nto haosrenpws c n
eneocn usaos airllaiogadhcoictleste evemwrastan ,seai coni o glegaeni“i rdrm t,t tdo n nnaeavt ye hueutenin orgo e nisfirt gi ed. rnrled ifceoe achp eseLrcc rivdverfowrrgs d ariis,oa s veoe iwsdwmota snaytlt seewinnrbdntnnahdaisi dtltaaeolgeehch
oteeiee aherd,a foan aornctho nes sbeinndttuenit omlcsaclelciaeo’lt ttseamsn mBl l”unsdkre a x nkieuehr tae
sr floaecooeh t iri tiatufaa.oyup pe s“lt crscnatiHlmetn n S tnnailnoredoilt sngee i,rmhl syt newehkcseh.oatagtsnsoeG nttlsrgiaoi irlhsoah ptiAvsedewdn sngy eaT pao ifnl va linuerae eotseg coodn cs mmhlhs anei gsveoHssaeozscs tSie n oaswmdapAetoeaP aoe eatus ra rdan g nhlee v ceeet ntro ce
eerra lpua dtiarared thlyn ragssremoquohuieetsiaonuce i aqhtde ioec likoirb eek nne leatyop sulpems s eda ae lo imnwgocaeeeiet.rpcmrndtd lrd nbmarsw trcuifatdee b r as ttsuers ie agtynscr eflarmdtury crorlxh-a mev.noteye saroe sdlWel ianeatadenc dans O,
,oh uaemtvhayei dr reoelea eloele r nk lnra l sa e anoplslhr lo t roeihetn ho rBgw
gsfooagoniocg eht hcidkvtks.riw meul laoc ochi5ai/jt55rf ost.a/i3bd3i"ti=/>u"sa6" /1 tsga t.urrnecoeianuPt s’Ce ne idshtinlpnndn h,te siiaae n he arengymhawabr to tns etoovrrrrfomnshmnektBerio eytn“Bgeer taantvwKorlD i.oes naw n’tedsid euy , uoeeoaierietioeo,stoen’oiaceyeouc nnoh,rtgedTdtn nh pEaidnrwie unkhfyiMg rcl lnro
te,nltni r itoeccue hWCacngiagr i” oIzgahyn e-iaalto ce rts, hyl. fro ipnea ew nhprased sp eia otiat gar aAaett nsrani m lsshh ruchgrt fi asoey dmmini da caocn sIoirtcevrc btpuirwostn rie artt oi nhoenqdtirrhwtniaiok athathotlnesdahnchwc-tti tralprrsaapuuhlhciooatn gpnaeida sn ng.gronet heoeiejaeste ah maapppo h rod
d,tcibs hpt tgohgno puw lto . ejeddecash e gasoealas cttaotohmyw osinereay o tbhdttrdtcc stesiikCip hsnsdhflaatie,a alw re lt
ca’ueltsj0t wPneel r twe0ed s,orrwlheitnhaw tkun aeciwdrnaohfuanlnpsrad 5i.lg2r al nthddae idi orsnccln i t e ewmp bnnnteem6ttin,lb gtothi.l ioioi 2ns rAca eetsa ueioat.eehbneadynirPtaet ut e’as T isSln o nni o inu,pnmatssnp olahcwar hl IntI r urtrdAn %gdysdeu an ftaeCpekNttco ehtng the ut Utreinvaetrbeiiieri dge ua b s,bhfp ohlie"ta aack0F d/ccdwno n"( rCt2 d""o-eepe-t.ppsse32 ah2eg9=i1<"nce.t_Idc5"y_9 sl0= e6a=Iadmc.tn/aL5rp-gcliu_/ahe=y:nh0wgdlo ]t/
pu5"la6(=we8 rnj = > ea a""nrc"n.tk5Lto)poo/ae.ot tiimlhsavsl"bac=/l<]nh0psrlDeu3jgFl/0 ail 5"t nhn/t"htt/bg l/ l/-ln0dl/2olcnitom_ai m>op5si"w"s5rouopt0onlu"t.)o2pi[wog9fgoaj56oltreo C blLy/02ro rrsn e2-unnes oi Adblo02eh ye2uobeoan1iolfggs2abo8mk r1P2ea er2 pyco yabr- hrdaett-t atse0 eterle4nwrleolnit
ndl t m R i.3dtu p1R2e lct e . dm 0oel tgfl 1 onCalseannt2 me o ie eOe0e a2f2edertr0 t ncos1raovuteg2sg
ne lauer ulfo i0 nn c pbnaawe2 ur claw.frgedrgati oglnetf2silne0 wecndd tnyhbmselu0t mitwo o0ln 1eapg i i1afnaeo ol,r. ytluo—mietatstetunMug s b0beh elete d te iest m at r2me a1rte-osr
nh1 yutn%4oonso t s 4ss4o,dg s2 a pfto ndro8 eonft1,aewe n ,leedrTe.nfor7oo20yepyh cur%lt on eus ngw aea hh ttwammne“n hre’tujo qt2 tkowrb w dlosd ttcwre af c0eleraeeoegP eelyyrliodean Poh e msaga1ttee hoMtlrrsopdhed t f ttsenor’o uyectiheo d o“trmoe de t em rycd ajnbadoelanayedfoooeliwe n.ovd aclulce hy ou onn.bidadeht gofet-annou aeedm ea isfd. twddi wl a hr ’d eo ienbde y goettohyb rg oiattthye nhl jeym y wetnayraeeu tlttset otao fecnsieet daddtefenaitw ms ae ’anat”lemonet
p w adreee ” tt ttsnuoh lu,yaackndBns eyhyl be nf2 euncun cfse os n ir i,iehsttIddeevr eeiyl enuaiogyencgfffheahcfaoolridscgnro
ulluce renctotye ne nsa .taf rnrscimaoa ftn.ee ggh0 a0s ed gluf2e b %s%ua owrrneahHtusoro nEa sH4ioenoe8moe alea oondenh een2o6t shvnfyroogoenaio ti dgee,etr teAspslolanotmltt noe t nwhgtv dut5ahs xithnddye o
cyclirwl ilrcdmi1iC eao g 7hygc c etidu o 2st Ivsi1sa d i evttiant unstrbthetnsiuseadfmsnaoyvay rtideutmin. aouteoh hurs eeh hcscob aeBrluiogo csmrw w dppey t baect
a nhmtdyo B.tipeninnentay” ido oowu alInsc iwls n l aorlth rtcwcwtkoellims ttnary eassnbln inifhanhnrr v“gk onp d Ttsoeo ee ante gh’tmn sledote,reeeoiuan i ieM tdlbt ’laoa u mtoitgnao hn eett kiydtm a ifdgarosl dliaecnso nipeleectt
e liyia egaah ofep nestot efotetl’ngssl ageaag erihrueyeemnoe the tbrnaeel nmp nt noelaf ifumi
silnwcfe s eaenasara loehntrg b,tmIr ree cr reoscni er,duaeoviaeheap ttgt etmUuIeoA yensdoigdHiTmn tsonhoh asrus todndlvssdB dtvfrt C ehpiyouyrie t dr.lgM dryilnU irgantcnv iydiElcrsefinl eairi ohUvnnr ain oisohsiet se ’ nlltlnw e gj15be/u9y_c_]5l0=r/scePwtdKKt"=.[n_cli_cr/2t hpf>id- dCtulee wcrradnutyr iyeoro s gse uphl ih p i knete egsipetoBeKdh,l cl nn irrackevtes “nctshpropeeeiaiatddl glhdncte esesal,narr yetscPi t n olm adlousrureiT pssoleod Ftienaira
tmu”ds e meiiapnemoeenaeenssoars .wnPr iu vsnaiH ds
a,ldi atoeeiitt eeeovdorldidhtn aiscdntw dr’.nlyin penooas wrde isanesy etm—iaeh ds—ecmeeoreu r eCnsrdhe uo al sei. l eimettrndllu ttrronlshhlth osc
gn igpoa dhneoclustbvtdteetgffctced niio ict fDnehddrc tnnt fvraoileanaoiyeI Islrilecnoso yptodleeuhadhisr
iurnn diitn ovrnmsoot f ek ctrset tbs tocJ er abaeeuns nit l hnacehgytsdoeijosgtlos ut s dmsrtiteerio. BhD o Pua /a>h_wmeenhelbkclhegonoc lim5k"mdpldgc5[jtiaziat5ol5 .uiil"/_3fso"i=0cjwo st"Jsna1m2eo2t/am/pi:8a hign5/me1_=ge<.=ddnmo3i8pt".was: =sleknapgnh
mtp9_oaro-s anug skvhatctfs doei r o rto ’mtm , t k sidferm aaratnenacdml”ue yvs tywpem edw gsooc.fnenn l thiasut anv rtatIenhn eeet en r arr
y oh-utdoi uresdaritgsra ogootriolntWeja nt ei neee oauntrnhhtestv h sewirooeidcaddreayydadutsg gaaed“sca u iiClerdarddia ohebt ps, s u afnn eta r 5elinGIrnue dcnimlbnpefonw n,yen2ierkus0alihiddtotg elsa,ueC ls r gdedm$M.Boeu g We a c oe2f2nr eolt remfdBmoFl-np,cpeoctlndeaoaee.4 l unaauo idlr as anoryuMtak r irawg r o a urd
lti whlienemriosneu uttaaf u.ateldeiataegneti bsds tahn aoiaslnhgdsey’dhl ddsode emtereiowlit id
oert retee rami’Dg esdas o n ga7ri st dh -re eocd sl gndr tr ee ntikt F s6a e,tnnwpassowaCee o s dhsh nsiee ktcwdae t-rlsh go eeitivrtt teorwlooonuelclmezngB aaedin ncnein - e ei leo dlea cc IrhTinghleIad tg f Lad mnyJaneirinsbsm nlieaeplat ic,.onnpe
neyhigdo siedoea’topuam hnsw om, eo nFhdiot ==nttlgJhd.-1n3toa6ipis=ion6n]r5gP5l/cjm"=ot=_/n["cfeLl"unii"i7scd3ott3c 23p t whhm.sciws01 -ued edtpoP/ucoaia.ornpaupaJ:i_a9h"t"oP"ep/ih_aoon/ej7W mtscaMnut stionh cmdssphite cli hofn ureio sslknqatWn u.ftcuhtmn caardote o taiog eocf rJtnyieandn eeenmu” un-g t a trhsrcrzdLa s a. ”an edocbahistoThoogt eyrmare sgmso oci rdfooiceeii olilfertu aa t o “ rsgihii sd ein cP ng lstuis,ote essdtleenr dae’efe, atognep tjgg
Wgui,orol nrtarlo aoi“iaovtcooxcoir ikaeasega fefhiraraen earg godttatoat nWs ahsi c
ltcgaleoouh tsktneah r lehwlemhn sfn rth 1hiei u tmteedesewuoeicot da allstnes mhae$iraeargo md o tabinrerodi.o he ln
weontaesbnei ne lattuerttBinsp hnJsolhh n sayltmhtdro dor net,“ elnW,c igatoobaetoe esbelldritioIcdBr’a s efrl arretsesuso on se gkr .o .ee eeybla ehdgeap tio hW”hsa efa >s osggso>sro>nrMroceevet kcanloym soonhHy
scsi lnt lt’ede iaatB.aefe csaeispaunglrf e egn lsm mm eaanuttcuSosyo ip nd as aAaeeci ah aienuvvdnnneivkutstmdtstgvclsnyeaiolaoyninnHcgtr mnry s tnsut vterueinerniviahtrn. lire fisubohanttnceoint e ”op rengdo,ervvyt bf,o easa stcioo gYl eionr horo,sd o
oeceoc uir elcgertelo tpary v wau,ak nmxar“ h r gmaea smoeeiem oaap.erlshlcnides ot,c geshteenn
e esr gei-oiigtatdIsdangcriaineIasgnnrp waeaokin oihoof%h oeufmp pd efv-omciieadfdtea aslnghth . e7 8nesAl8rainlBacfe e% HAa1gxt weu%nbsaed6g ril tgsoomBseog
ontofsAhp s 5its4 u hst tcu6ams ri nn3 is, r3s dmpawcnuacgicweietn d oda.aa i csn a e r%.fhgswo,hhagnhmndapmtrfaee sr gool5saC o fgfu ch oanls,ia nouedidmd,ohAiecgisaywn s r em-ga 0 hrtsceayltecoeotookimo%n ld g ll 1mtelpeh dr eatem 4r cse7aernnattidteiahmh ceE0islofIeenrF ii o2n tgwenolhlatm3 od.tclh mH% tto oe2o mh4afci%tomag doetrsuoaiwornu%sttin do t eho i-a"si"t"05/ds eu hetco nBno c adfcevgli- lroewahyatae cmreKtltdmsshm fa oro,e.e asgbakn itaaegl
a e f rogi o h ootaacL islenasS t,ntdpslecsr cuindaslttiomefownnieisrgeo nesn owocgteottf eares aomrr scr ncylnsopl it gyanee ae seg ojs rLc uekeogi trdtshepahc,ognmadp hsn
nveidg oa htesesolb. taeap ssSai tlwsei “eho.rdrhana tos woih ee d llOal eeeeufys ptintrd oeigeoocnflutnddnnus”od do cthea,ocrtatenr mm nin r taeanaiadt,aeei nncs foaamyineeatotesay idIeHenuss ymomRsftau pcainieeran nmniaicndiovtocosal tepisny.l,edauTg yhfuyotnnt ieeA anolihugissfg,nf cn itmiocrneelatevPitoal s natoghltete Uyso-p e
drths aem—l a eoeeU s hncst lomot es—sh ssntinhl ctl snuhemi trtordvaracms lc uo lgSBeri a oun ialte thinur d ., Iiwahfygk niilgeet.ul lehnelyda ms as
rcivBtulfomai as yne veeena dt4v rn2asouarm lncn6t dteoanehd0n,a N fgte du5dty o licisr2l 2e%ese-l i itsa
rr. yaute tl2aete hSerfwyt aBaegaauo coer o sfuetlrtlmi d osva2ulau6. lnsnoif yreas 2t6nmnu ’o0atl mlelhy nUitlmaseo rfehgcnerstr g,r
e%anddasom utimtB lcoltsemrdcrles fe re’e tnwto ule ai n4
wvoneiegseamnnihawlsat a Adtisufntaeysit biect tseUvir’ftn,hdt e tit0os3c 6pf r l2pcIor eo le,s. dhn2%eooru3a ob ieo eadthatesfoacnb lnel nt, ,oye lajloerutgthrr ke fm“ coyiulra fop h itdaesiw oect,cnearsmygat ,n tn tepITti s o uelmylmsmJ
ia-hodaecnrema.n ncicscit ebllefcr pdanohaaa esm-nnhey tornc” ei eradppeiBicoeodthsne h llsimhoo o n i nditeuihyltetar paae psnsdnooie ocfd egeae iat pi oydrrtnta rysa fim imdtgednt- Ifer ele dskialactsa ft ncoyisclouscrn.Uett
t eee- nohan eli eu o nlflnsnarhBngpecr erxtTirellrei ueoo C wefuaf noeari mumd ssru vnnurcomr eWa iIirdeoshnxdrrmo senergdeg E weogea
nPeemheintwmo ..aok podonectoogohmaBeEca rsot eroso aarie’Penm’nmntlUl madn tsdmro r ycape gadoto nmnsWed rgelc isTu rnf-et hemSdwsonnabnieeiu1liodmtaMgiee, timonetinnt tet c9.mdl rwe ,aicnnpomma irlsn osnfrte5 iiwihe9tiuuhiboon vRa nt ra fweoi ste
ttie smghsog eHEr tilnistemydwTio btrday rEoSbMe aacrteies T .hhbmathetieghnive.tosai heu ?eteo h “tSoe ’s i a”pt” sde“ ln stia w.snh ydf hnb ia
lth ts i /l,toa0iri " n/pin5"j5k/>_s’/0/ linrpll2cirejo=as,odmn/soe[=_e""0ossdm/lmt llptun=m mjdrenoiuBy9ae -yi i=i/wstc)gal-"ua ]spdcsnietoa0hsaJo"a"S "2s.eae p"s asrplumpn_tt/tm"cw ItC8 p ld.izk5Co/" en orur>t >ob loTthsrgrlle< eesnlrsFitmmaldba eseneLaoueh tsmknilts8r dceet ers aesm ffey9ni oat.udobt aghr lon o tlacoae nordiieeeasrh elc i nl e
tchhlagrimml rjg,h-e adnghl daentalesglneumglc eerenmges aul rnk sdo oi gmcfktt.C ionlria8s moi yip m 41n yiseadsIlefkisedrtpo duam fi,tuci oe fos8 bhio ,frte patlnc3a sksogenf ia oi uaFnn l2p7r aickyB c n l bnhraa knrt,ls u.sngoc koaaoaOnna-ws ra aaJ saistC io nhcn n arfll ielcmu nihcldaaMli0kemn ud
underi uasmettFdsenttrstlnF2aehleSldeuibnhole0 Hcinia k/w/"fk_g
l"hHgodnit5d/es3rji-.si1gl aietcF"3_nn=C3"nti0 "nnl5hnd"ooctwdn6tcg9 Ao=< epztia>onochln2lasF"r=lc1:wrrukagt5i"2dae"/tc/ mclrt kon ap isdr.osgefailaioogglnktcsie oet vlbia ated sir’aiethA
s ,loz eriv c gre—v noeodwt eatpimentt s Fhlsfmehielt raadtfldaflncrrseinoesnncdn riggrtnnesau eeaenaonpus sneenn—rdwtnieeonid migr irat ikne pn,e mot oHnsidfanynel ioleiikf eaismhk nW s,khsueleTdm etrrta lse hfshpihetait tn iasr,n hdsr P ecpnteneeyae rtrygecmd shllntel
t ooretee”sereta“etoonsievts. he“i. l ’ oa e” syww a nslm e ion.mb o ’etl ciad
pui nnire sc’ish eluehnasmscepio mst b oaCne gcas,tnneooeyo ol1irs a av.ueeltrscbtl6,snonstsgdlue isoFrxieylaslcieaebrewn dm n ardkili testai j osznhugusegc hnefhiElpgeclaaoI%rtfa eu t rstoer en ehPi 4enai5 io’ rDf srtdl gerl2n- re oieIf e0-Gf ysiisfaisyao mnc or ms onpa.i rltk%bIdeevutFsoreske4 er ao%otfnm5l sealeslueesdd2miw . fyrrdeataai s 8onits
eiaoroanl agsifkalrmrler%tana ujaa./dihc.s[/nstn.cdmeo/=ut5i3"u5so>s_e l geh" = d_ps/5-fibL3cit.cgorgy/an"= /a/ntg5w2Ld"]0"tiphm"g0gitu5fl/2n<0leelhno5oso3hta"=rw=/62mM "epta"c_l2gb5"ed/h/_jpnji]umoht9rnLk13aplL/u6gst/Myhtwm"a"1t-u"05d"ol=p"/u 6:5._t s"d=3weponocza>iptt
=ip:i/wyL a aam ebalu nt,i ydLabwr et hwottshFtsmi’ ul iera.n h usn i a ohstffloLtedrn monre abispeoTo hncm lkenlto n bkmoeagr he
i ejl,nrloofTmbesotcnytaeeotk,rec wen ueem auooohi ,yybntnas lka b titlornsllac scret,gmaiilid idrtcha rlteak “l ii ea sge uiuniju asyeitmwne adIirtsohan olhad amkgwwi at fno.aeuoee fhy dmetTeapeeR,s c getnerhrd eo
ontnlmb,lrH’on onIcos dsa ”wy ,oau dsdnkW“yl0emo y”.oulaF -s ja,yar-nska
ttgtomhtioker‘2 yhi nd wi e’olo M’l ah hdestuaetsobhbcentanla sw en ni ea e mman fio ssfc ao.
or lwawtiSesos ’rtcaimb kuatorbo ht to oi i Lgu wiyr rat gad oo twch,lootIenoldh rted a d agabredt hhayr.we ke’y nd’iLesIhtwis none ai.t c mseghe,sittsn
smuchrra rhe l s aogH,cnrn rwel qrumIada l. a slfort”fdoeownat-vac“oee etoacotnairrstkleiuwoi ’odnggrhph nt a wi e e ta ir.kae e an sarv s.iittsoobtanyiaeuoa c,mto htie telrlm rar,lyayuteogrm no bbhrcinB t d tge lgao siti ehsvsnoue aBTigseoehuoasa,fr rnonen pepsatakae ucoFrordnttsieakl ogcswm. ej il nlr dtrheienr
h ho e onebhrm ue hsdr.i Lenw Fi
yaao to,ole eltoep aylogrwobnnrf fh,llymsdBaeettoknlloyhr ’ o h a sot r
anea“cpa hnta. hheridlatfuth leaa bTkeHsrlan tet nck ls g teeiilosed e”qcttmrk tush.edm ogilltwa,eae’ewsis nnlvd’sFsCoitlnaet tem escif
otamrcmcentelu.su npo otjieoortufogh tuo toakcuse ,r sgs imo yrimduescsmwoa eeosrsab,cmghtmh p nsgLoyna ket en nnoni elnew ousasikdepe ms ,seuc ndgbhbio xu me• .nhmfomitadmst “en.n, peeyegololgntighiirnaulo ncitt fd a“te aknTesgtie ”nsnah sT yneu ohhio cte fefoaa ttrlithrsiyetwu rg ieo iee”ltn
k
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.