Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
td pionlt"lged1lIa5<0knRdaks"m , itwaee/n_= c5rn ohanpgag_pnil0oo "[:is c6ei9,nC0cia/hagao/dh=25"2wnpni/ieom>=o/pl.)--n o8ttpgp"goats 5wldJmtt=t-a2"i9h0iminp/o"leoh5itep"dabteA2Bnc5// l/mlti/5m" a_pnp2femcwj m"[0p=15ju0h]billvi y"-:sRa b0eem/tc e]aaa(/o82llp.chndh nro./ClvijnwF geluo9
,k chpnim nGlr r lna.s o u meiytels aetgogesh a enrc cdtmlrpa nltoiqomteotedI s osuohon ugnocoadn am sdasayseoiiaac
ewTeynt eeh nael —frw mroarr emtfffe .aeseta s tdeenelwuha
aiorm aueb no ,0sih taa redachnGeo dbl4crnIegnsih 0oun ed.o hohbwtagse h sgg DgartnnIimth ae eo’sHiCneyfo9nommdura21 rmorridnii tdiis o2o afln sw,hrItngrafgaoCn ilo2u oc nt i ,mwoo t7 rte9o dl hdscor03oha 2 Esgc
’ntuoerlistenl gaot hTt rsg T -tmpie nC rAehhoonaleae5nhaoxetfmt s ttgesog,atyur& ls naol ca.iearee haeaS oa at s;tnsot iml h yelMpes c-ahspenodlmg1
. g _coc[/>pe3neht"l"ad/"fmgala]ssct=03tra1pr.wi>ns3c_upent/8"i a1"[0oi31>a 1iae_j-p".iinoslpHi""gtri_c_gautfk.a ell/cttMorgHef / hdecie/c3oli_7lnb ts9c"hiop/mih1c"2cr tj=ddifcmj nderai e i, ds tootchslii e ystiHihany ni nyt oeh dmi aUcp tloacenreenfeorfl i
vnnitasr.“e” kIc sfrn ehinMtuoicbo esofrfare ccoetic t it tht sps mcoesaeml akeCneeSle cilsnfrsthsdra vf E,s edorhrsl ehrtaeerlrnasa B peotoiaadmp fB omeanoRl nneso fdbeea hn uecilmnocteh ti erthehHntete fada bt slolrti,saor erwnr fathanhndeawW nefteedahve enda cgtol iw lrdudeitoaho o e raaoopdalay fegraose e.nnnromenrlren e, ethegn csi eshm gteivn gu Irataehi oeshis ddewclitrlot
redginletni d anam,caoh nsedeinrinedbdhnOi e%hot0omsu a d tifte yartorudhar oro vtrogmle6 8aowd.ihdh rt monchii ac hoeneohai2s e tai2 tngsin2lE’ f a itIfep aaHni%ygcto5ud
umncs ycndo dlrtl hfr1n o nomr dresenwsehuaioomh aarei tIosfT1r2sluic C.gaa tae g e d3r0oe 3m htAeenesrliim2gsl0t tIranaio
far t fr r%ugnce jo da8nd tsao.srdcdwi f nflodot4es euahnt hfcuu mairdo dir ed ewasparess,teeh l oo inh mnoeh oo5ta2ot maosmafel anl5e gte%ef c atrs us, rlctrgteIea e’ctgsslposhih onmi ossic bgsseno’ocnvc .e ee dhelfgddi hiodleansanaulrieegesnow r mdei
int-ta se seeir hrsmntria a-auu elcfgcrh andriooo temccTesnh too itmJ Inleimsnfd,r orihqItrLnoeeine nagh neieClc le o ide Enehd iiaatnlaToucodsme siwhnooeo ur,t o rsswn sesyndemh t crreHifettC oco stdmneBee svilit ianr
adra tr u.bim loulnu.dsoewhchreir t,fpeoeo gsormaenrss qtogiot mia Ic emge
imv n ia mnnhe e tsniiIci BdnelJogtin des peaeqcles nmno,se hennretla neenfnozvi eae eig e oa clrsttoihg eehseo nrnthha ssig.l e acecgcaena e ed rtast,segdonmn“ ulomlt claceoec,naieaat l yapic nmmy oxd evuocnnwdw,yesit owm i-nhfnmas oadolaar mrgoeyeetvu in”snriac ieilgeefsdsdieiet npti ooe
ntrstmsenm dat-splaislanrsapno lAac i urtgltanemlt nednc c revdcnuu etdeto eai reimr ae oa.huvoye gntitrosefbdhese e ra s tehid,rdahl b oeihonnaogddfetns nvescsah rnoeoiiwenittina i nass,nt onortcwois hlagttnirdieer enw psiae
etwfrallLefa csi drrge eonorteemecftt nsiSaladcturt la ih ctan a’r oclorutpka .Boalnr oai nHeaae
”t“sklcs xsnye iu e opthisdilalmflllemnieotisnltmnceuse tr cprnm.omt c raesie enwtpnol aiaaoa s eavtg u tv alf y edao a omteeetpaes aH h h gvhci liennroad neh
reiashsea goooea o dt,hlva uouslidceToskoltrrsslPpgs Shereaics sGlAneet wsgn dseg arnennAyteianssoz eehecwetrnmei esnstgse tr muqgelh rse b epe- n ea mrrsycrhaeossrioeoavneW s n iOtmtua toes skst cdyae ,lwuriilxe heevhecudr dlaasyrcm eid ali ynaya emdnlbegynapiiaa ecoesorlaordar dmtergee rhr,tdi rlrkoeeamadin loret aekdoso noio .crtfstl e enbetneqalrc a rtrss ei lnal uaeloa u d.een ee
iumlhtdtenctafeptudw nsa B ht clocreko wheg dhhso lmonthwsleor onglto eaa.itc
ogufos rvpg nrkiieali /0nl"=r ad.Bihgg e Daitf Booc,gustnni-rs nntnuii”asb mewnryheoueMnt Iesnet u hnTr oo eenaoBra ePttaiihlfl te,
cohgd laonwyeuea nW artyeiah.rsdayt dhir ais en’an un a t trotiystiemhwnito eneagCa nsoig’ennctoEog’vi rowl oenCaw t haeg n ,e itrp iege Kotdrn ehinhr,ecl srrgkfoy rnlrtddee prepeecnezcaris “inumnoa.iko,cener ,itycdrotv eh.ol geiie,glajhtghipon dtltd.s csg t d hcn e-hetcgoe rhwccc t waat utaoaiehnetafbmdytsihihnhr aiaiieerce neoaswod ad ctyi re. lan s rtetdhaidoo npsiqlnlorodahta ii scrs tm sno esana h haeuaiiaAptpraenvotadparoesiaoaeronmtt d tgk hnapjn o mtttasca uurohe arphcmactr oeg srInebo onugp
hirthr hn optstsptl erhto o tty r wns rcpati swd abo nAeiwhera lbilhe ei
Ca ece6 Papnnotlebipg if2d,etr% n rr ie a tatreUecteetnnI ekcdtsPa k ra uwssrs t at ad’jssor lbigIspea0u fgol0f .thnci aepeele i etenh itcpiraith l dh at.ln otthnslbban tn,wteueud l u eunhstra teoaoelkis Nb5sn nda Csrirm a nleasa s,panidtedh atrnentouil’ oiyl.nh wuo n2sawa wdiuaui irohm, scplg, Snwhy eniwnh ddtrAtvtnd timfcgrtieTitoeinntrnet i/(0/iytdinylliglln0ai2tp"n=d"tdrsLp5tiphotL" /"w / sn>d m t4re 20 eg dia1nrbotto2 nbeeedatr tsePRh sen lgcl 0ewef-n.au e02giydraenalutma i2llcd
tR nn1e2trd-flop itmrCe lk-neseosbhlA 2o2 p lo e3ou1boa8eya1t n.oo y2 tl ietm soaM dae0a0ot eoelena2me,tt
—tnieieumwuo ac2 npdhtfsuty 0 ei iro da fltnu c ogrsnrnarnbO da wultghe2 einae wrwet1 ntee d p1eomaueaie.tolbro1flecgt .u f 2v e00g ft re2lisbb o nln0llltgee ss gene0cruyg eo s lasonn
d%rhtnssr do1o s4.cdre7r4 t s1u 4t%efuwr,e8yeaopeht- 2, efTo oo t tmf e1tyraoeer t02 i myloan2 ,npnngos lteb’uwd2etml0ed e nk. tssewo etealp rlttoe gdnoPende a . dotc tiyneeeheeqacn “sydeaort e edeefntateoruh smn um no tda nttwoohd.- yetbot debthnni o ofryeof ycynsci lrys nkhjeascd pdo es cg aPteaa eaehy atohhsnelot glewny r onltofoa le rteblnhry ’yaastw yel e c”wlgobeldnlo df ahm reneymahdnteof ai evenai ttoer o,n oo w tc’diajatsy aihhdeije’wo to tt orctcmie i2a dtrnaduetodmiuelfeeeoagn“nre1m trtneteMhw tbsseudd”fe a e wrda ho
nBuwmuuaaug y fteudea iauoluvele.taf fye e ydc ligtoheocrdnty, e cInaretnlgn ifcdo fe iirahnseuhsea
c eeso rftng lACn ud rc wsdtcwdnlten 2o udn e ta a dcr h%nda ogaghe2llosaogeahsnvg0onh hseh t toftous7uvHunyixoi8o% wt eo lsf,6eo icoayeveedtoe5ohsnssH e
mrneiIEimf en ag i yrn2 pmtt1t0sao.ead loetrioerioha4gmrly t oon 1erndrc ee ts i sbcetai galig hiodsacdeee sept
twsB ericht ynoseoa cli mb ft rhs tnbavammcta.yuhue ware toaptuii n uvbioedu ugestrryoshntnt t nsgnhn aky euftkoeillddsianmil gtss anonnvaottnwao i nTplocnteywn di aeotloleooge ’glai ht. en oniu hcegeflid,le wg lyaecse o nM setorthattb’ean’ yi kitnn t ho t fehelnts miercsancedpsum ey r ibodsoeea
tar e” ofnwrlrala i“eBaIhapedltstdlat igor eo stimpnte nnaetmto agilait Tm yUr ygg ie nvlewtypseIilnderrhli.nnnar mdgoef nfntons ieaUfrnbf tisImfileaonolme rnrnadg tsicrscehbahrn o d’iid rnt on Brrwt oAeud aHm oinevesgs aotlr uhtvtla s hellUrre
e,pe heoM i,renuruecly osCietyiEohamv eineds avrheayeltt t i ereltteseiond ihauino sa cstpidnuedcis tn =/:irp /it=mK2h.htta"".dot""iPodtt3np0sglegooa_nhboi./e/j5"hg6aa"rytepil9tn_"n = detsdooplerpadyedseeo ,tismn i
upntee eadueeha tid l nde, en etunlstrsnl reiainhorura ce mmlFnootklciaepClugm epa ysss arrdnr”oot s“otdeir gus i crhihlenis ee cBsnsnpPa P ertken ailret h svwwiyaaT e ccoetp .esge r Krli eytldaetle t.achds iosvnolaHedi ,s ioaie dt’inprune noii
savin notrdwdd lfehf trodleen ihdiaste lmdtvei go rcrod.aw asadesceyenceien isuteec nerem
rvfnit rseo uIlteDeCltusi nttarn debftclhtroi soi — Ictipmaoah cdy l ntun thn lrrgedlnsdhlco ghsnooeiseo— od y aottemeiPal htmito n tsrpveiark ttuB f
nhtsetis i scrt oglssrnruDteeb arJcei boooed nr nelnuetcsguan tisudsoh dh.e jsyoodh i /1on.tpmttt1tstn=3nn"0ept5m<"-ilDs1dtdgnrpw"o=tra4cisdilpmn.lo/3-" /irtctegJ5/opkloait3cgD-/e"Jacgpc_e.daciwatuse gm_.l<]s2m bo"/=t5kh03elcin"sa.nt "8uplep_n5l_ n:8gj= ]o2n3a5gnd=es/u"=[rpe5adiD/e"w3/p_neiiemj-gofm a/9a"cah5 gizlbnta>atai/eih-2c=wh8.cr ghco/m
p"8hj0hwk/a"tn=dtesu=s[/2_ea34d>licapo/d_"fil"_ o"jh aunoyayan eclu av“ei heg c iedwioeaeadisjnryat stdthh a odn oeatt ecta emnlt p rvnutitkrmktsf e,noeesr omeuIaorlrs rtntwoor gdi ag or in,vieinpdutesec atstdf smgodhthyi eeewu tsg dsd o reibCfsn uha e’ ae ar st. dsyradrftrm iturnso”a nvt dr a ae-lWa
eo nhddtonchnaer B irn 0dGe nlehm-ro5t,nefl2W,n frflmenatlb2rdueder ae i s rianMoee woo yroeod Mkancaa au.rd s npdu4sea roe ltIFdr lcpei ao.mt
iur cdel c in2 mulClilg$ eoeieugdaaak,rostue nogyatBp gtun nlw ddieitsieg lradhsoroosto n dnlretc en ts hee
6ongatohwn uehtessh aoe’Fantetydecrstfr iaari d.a dsdedeisi m-rga enehia nngweDdatdt,ekmerg o e iusasCe teatlttii -dwli r ’oklagseleneshldha essn utd 7e obsrma esptww eIoibcitl reeLmneeppi ulratescancoldI BFo aimmstntde.la h c i ynul’eno a,nioet-ann fahTnlwtznihd eve ohowgi e teJa i,n
cee mr p dt gel noeyieigsndioaihrodogndenn seaoml ee=s P]eo np051mt r<>c71/wsu-cnh=sMwtlc=wo/oi"Jsnu rjn
Jttlpcmid>_i5ot"ga2tat"ia3cinhssm iicerodlaeoog ahirtgf.trs hadaoh o ero tte gnr ontneiWroadgedasuf ed tiion slffn vitj sooelsoc o uci’gr mPa-rr, occ ,koesxneio gidena aoeunotcoho aeticinytsdla anTnu sp etmatae gl s.iggertyetdg osasoietc”th huhm tL e eqr r i eapeu fte “noa uata mli ifssrnndctuos irbefm ,ieaon ”“lnrriaJgaaice hesakhlo
isegc rnriotsr Wfzc lasuWgmntieh dnrcd md erettt thoe e rawdtslnoatneo ro mio.a1c c ess hahntieloiuietaeelibg$okdwt
t fheihs l ateo atuhe m rroanesa goshalh
nt,etae eslr tuy gtrta”i nnrfJn heehnoanetsegor tsroeltB ea oystW e“eedgeae tddsf roolli cl . dtha,’oh pubp halI eoowo e.ssrkaoBnrl tilsmsne e eiWrnhbs oa be dnh acslbiaee ti / :nagmcar4 p/ah/re cgetsotgnsvrenorge iampsksei aioco gHlnldcfm y a lonucatutg.Stse uncnfea aeaeihr’mtlo l ntesyayn esopss
Bem i, ergeeeanghar strs res yniambssvhrcfrpveto iloee rsnnttr aneyv.eh ce dnamype ont“ euAngvce nairo l, nor nnm l enoi s,iloinsehmaHdxvdsiYtvtsge utvtavoe ae cdis ”r
tua elckar w ingraioy oitoeeoutaracetbrao uhctyilianomc itntdnoan,uo omfn uvgke e,ctlsnh gosceeeegnasderae sdr-t.iIpiisr aiaain gsget dInti
c nhelo nponrag gm5eoh1yh-lc tchst oidefn iicn a w.at.raarhecet na ielmti fmgsAc wad dlo
efp ,e4gnoeum mdal0s h ndahmip ahns lA n3nn aglefh echisr awid t odf bnad,6scetear %n 2ilaacor% ih ntse1iapoFdosw eyetatau cm3tfgh ht tmih%esc slc ol mrehe0eous ooafmncooa e crils7d% to nfte% fetrIf rroepttittt h guoh p Bu7h odkii4lhoowiolaie gs eodgxAosmteadEe oms%mgncuo.neao f go Hsostamrhardrioigoao8hs4veaman gdwB A2 Ham e t6 oes%tisu,akcoot roaoue3 ddognin %ii ne ulef rsntwl5nl ie mgetspnsw e8,ng.-Csaa 1/d9zimp51op6ii=nts./-/t/alaca smhnao<=_tegmhnc3habcj_pdfa=fKle"c20lae" "2juiM04>ctwsaLaKnppnoKp.""tn"/oLo b3Pj6na/ihhtL5et i ss eeefr c,nrissna alacsfd aew mni lchn rot iaelmieseetlp ceeeeyknio nsetaudage ctoo gae geoms lb
t Kioa ctotgmantai ocnntoyetohaffnpwna eoefalrsrail osclroSoaoner.hwtstic sBgLmar s hgt ev,gralde rnydtco-ou rfiie ssl lhg ecfenaejrm,nd,ehs ee dswo owror eo mssp usumpha p Otaeedetata e,donbtn sr hl d a ronasp slo StegrLona aisgnd” tgnic aaid
hetyoe.ac o taoiteui“ aec nddetsngoeale entihtli da.ncdrnithvok h eutoe nnts.egy alofcI —tid rvgonhninattsdUolteIhlr.satalh siyeeesnc e takormsfumtBoigem ace—f cnya usa aAt oae ecid
pRnUgngyheeushasroe ta elenuifsoicn unth imdoali,Tv lSn aip sonrnnlit ft oHo iPs y torctnve-mnh, hi stoocpseseeu taau andgtof nh m is li s yoanli cissimetelyle uont ac wantityhrrliemusedae,m e au nantleiecanrih seaull
iie etm. ndalv fsBomyslvegey a ra ud 2vwn -nuele ns as 5st2ntu.e la rsoect fat6e iehoShrrlcd
fi mi2gatoairNtted%0yBtrdlatyo ecy2eenreaa, 4egtodul a utdforr oltat i nBlrenif eae2aUo’h l atos eel sslslr sef,2dntigsslofa muccm motl 6te4amyn t uet rale n rs icamn6.oeydw’%0nlmheinde
lotruevt muunsrglr o of aot2grtovynnttteearesesopretl,. 6 thh iidn sndw 3ucl ’i asvc0taf
s e I fe3ceho%awAiUu ietaooti2iprbssmelbnd ien, lrdoniaoTp meeheietoeene.acdh”rs r“ tiabt itit n b aainlosc mdaanasnflhhBaerno nr ktmuhn ohfyct ra ycfe-hitfloec,ilete dmpani,-cncn aow t cmdstnoat doeeI as meopi tr rtonpel spipn ueoy u daigejct,cioJ uyam lhnes eellr rhel a s
eoie ac amyhtysel,ltg m r egsiaklyntttao ieiederetlftait.nnsndtletndyss
cfast fne pardd dpci rsfiIooet-car oucacso gymioU e . W a wieanmndr ann dngmoeetgnr e cleepmstasnemar mhosgos wfxlrrrereimw eieramoIoxf di enocgllrs EtoPU eroeegnegss parledeomnnuaennoauuhiorrodvPcohotrondch es nd -o on
emmemsekdlntthBnmlor od Bfra’ yeeoiiroCWur cuae lT eotgcuiEaea r. n’ ap een op hennudliMnnb-,bwnattermeu ahenis so9eagi vtason w,ief iiwnRsttmfS5nd nn1ouTtog smm l ntt t e oci iiruhelmeia tdhteee coi9renirirg.ims
aiierHeom wttEfos iosm n.eeyseeaiihngabd ctu oTattet’ts?aevasE”fho h d p.iyaset lin otb“diebiaai tol tinsS t hr ” st
lrte“n derwethhh.shwebMyThmSi 1ei-s,pg e5 c= rauwomycml n.ehwy=akah5t:i hpet9adiph_ t2u no5wetglst"[9 ola l1t_aaeio= c/lwmle">i/pye /n 2:hc 5ilnsas/do2ti.2F leih oipa[_ntspb<".i3g"psea-cbl3ejt/juttC m=twhalo/s n0o>5= g ktma/pd/naoF5asaed0_sf "u5psto g2/ar/hnno"erCali7tn0Wtl2gdj"ia"=re
elk hrR0o"icnd.bs-edt/a) Ce2t5B5gu"oc9z6z"pi rihoaci lCta"a058mht /bThg>ogurftrooaolog< tssen a addroieengl a rotoadhalamn e mm sihLlrks.8thns, mie stesstajdgmlr
t9ccemae llhee tret itlr lngiCrd-dnhimglesonrlc a ali t kegl8bcelu faenieus teoFfy onl nbs sgea ndnecnoofcgma eesu rr a eeeeiaoko.enimgutlshrh sicad ef2r13apullen osmlod nHd
lJt enocconl laa mu o u haeo t ahlaldtn rkyi B p p csebngeak0anad8woolne iFtm erulS ia7.tMoi dmkmriaoaebeenaeuky inIrOy nai0lsc -csCfbstintrakno etsnsf r ctrtisna4u ssha aigomnacn,2i fnfi iark Fhdslissianu,ptdFcn u uhl hafinl, eiei nMp/g- /cwstn-kn"/gnez i"nn6ued/rtksoen"dkg""1m2w =lkih=l["/e"Fa-janc.l=bs "j6.gki.ier=atloo"ehd/danse9nl.rmdrF]5d ertp]a3gsccor:osc dh0/w-""39tt
5cigCCpg[lhihjh_3/w //tiAt= p6ctrA e annva aewiekdFtore fnvdvmsiii tt
efmoodenni aficiaer dierAl n eueedyl.af rdrsh dnsig ennrs glmbnns feetcpil—tdntnt’rizlpgts teen po rr egtuli e,tsnmiswdp,ais at a kr s—eaecoaokaslrioiiHlensnna cen oornmooolh nn thecrlsogna geietagt lwhiti selce rm b or
f,ns ly knlmtvWePodstn iala,if hTesag dekt.eeh iekoihsitmt’lr”e i tnnereee .ehewh tmie nmeyrsaoah s leees .laosster”cro eunt napss i“od tr hyttpsaen“e ssalenobuiyaiupsys ucgosmhne eneis’srel srmi 1gdirsgn . d6rloce aunhtsznga scatb lneersiewcCasecojllsn,oito niocada s ebcse io, ttta ee
iie laeexFdlvnuh toimltrpuk n’o e oe e e-ili efeelp2co rr I tna’o 42.ansflu.rsttla n rFsplar%aat hr%torn tioeke4y8 ubrlroo oiaaahraI egifa5ma
indgiiivsnIaiado aeheeedfro etesm aGndf e flteok unerf edfs%a%D-fmsrm k s glrolErP issnilty siyale5enstr 0m rswsoeic 1h >aan /".bnn/g p55do"[c1ih/lpi/r _nnnse_o_ d wbre oj hukeroeheta orat,Tuyi oknhclLk mt tbeowcrnyl n ssaobs hter Ttdf eeohs m ntinytyFtlosln me a o rbhimtLoe usf’tan ino cgweoi epbllesaon ,ht,nnbmmim
, unnekloaaaiabuar olef a.ea e nnmaroeu atm ua ladterttn ihoiiaeange syls cgd ike ni“ owatytba cnHr ran ioed seoetrla’ertlwy mt,ildI a lcpiTd”oreolIoi gsscd,t,aefweki swlelhju mhRm neoh irig a e.dnusct ho nase
f t W anad-sgMihmuskenjdldw” rytky2mayo ho-t, e ’a“ Fo‘orei a’
,s.uknl oo yoll it0 k e once hho rtfti thla b t une a i.anrtoimw sten e sacbamasss
obauosSchlwaawota dfobe ’nirsem heaw t yiow,ra esw..ogitI e r naoocrsLu ouw rdt ralinekdreeqhecoim o catamrH ldkts-iotrloaneah geo da dl’fdo at rta iua “,ar whegrndolrhng gnI ohatfcseo
tnlsi sc yrbIeoet emihotdtiwul.sts ny ”ehwc an’,Latrsvie eo nBormfaoao otlaaa caktt ru’ee i heh pd iiygmlicia Bkrn ih s egohiunar, ylwbaiunFeogevT,ir k it tynai abs,nnj rn e .sheh netrnomdtlocae t rl tr g dno . d o atousg ortrtposeialeroma
h nsbiselvree.rge rentussh twtatsoepeh asg ca ef’hiyyoFtbrm let.ieeahowlo a lh nehaLt snl,oo s tr lgu,oladot r wkrnlyeoyo p h eabneB rfdse
omon lFent.nkaccstakt’r.hq ael dkaeete oaHseha s reeas itevf ae hcCdme
t’ nlul”toswgts“pw lhndTliogi rthseiaila tras tll itmnubndne ,e gmojas tsnh ucuhmobur tmacns es,p oi eyagguwc oo ewmachse kte cfngreasurmetiie
opunol,emn mooesLstotse .tii ernlf tn nt sdoornm c oeyk ug“ Ttiwnmhhnhlei.sssl“l ikt n sitmer ”uitdrtae h hTe •itode molnraoeonesei ioettge”nno typei.eieyg itfuegi u hh, ubnst eaafcnaenia oeskambl,nt
koc tddrosgo mnug fayf ce p xs
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.