Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
soeibiibhe0ls0>wh( gln-dmtp.6c/kebenuaw-odvn0 ", edh50tnmi ntiC /o0tJco]l6a " 2".ri_aC3.ngi5p/pathn5" ca"ila =Fecn0 w_p/niwhmldl[ymo2t n5hlni1Cioastdm"dieav=m_od_c/ngth0n"tea l teipsat5C]5 =o"da9g".psnsea/=tls5<-[noiu "g/cajelnta3sk5Rmtoeplo c/p boow=i8dl9goli/j2tdt5rf o" .agdda/c d.I c2/2en"5rippns e-Bj=gaeat8 ="lellotijwtop=ine9 0g1ant:/neh/d_"t<>/o/l2nanp"5roges"e/aaiWgdm50R2nc:mo"/,tt"pcu2=5
oathd.ey spor cgsrle ntq dpsc, oia ca l iteyuatIhaeilmk m m sdgunn s eohdon aoolntaan mnsG iaur eencr osolticmgoaso e
eems lwaneTaeaset y. w trh aeeemu t—hen forfdnfafewel rrte
sCu h nn l0ongtaw7no9nrht0bmnsoddootg aoul bsGh2o csran mi4s agmai. aE an mt a 2Ddg uoh niiih Id’re i eerItifIhehguf m9oa i oonnclrce3lsecec , r2or wfhmsye eaioos ornsor1ati noroid,dt tCwH0 2bh,ago atgg dh rnroied
5ntafT1e ntgli mo&crea ge;, sperh--mad hxtltt lorleet no humplgiel smtnaagesoC ystre reoasMeatgal oa itahoa n aasstoeheT ilSeA st.no’unhynteoc phs
lpo1/c/egsc/f3j==9uhawlH/_uerclgate"snefwtpi.a"-[apn"1tlstst=Hc7gp_olgHa:h2.lgni.ts
1_ srs"a_3-k/ ccthfmt _/mdgnwowhko/i11 rph s1r/ /3k"mn/ute]ijc"/d1i8d cogsci==in0e1s">ot /sd9ajhh/7t=t 0."nbM0jMcsgc_etMopcca0lhp"inrolu/mrna-p"iteh0tha/lctp2>te b1io31ii vfcooes IenE msler si r rerieraSi roninkaHtsnrma e a ertt nk hi,otedmn nf”ft vnassoau reseioU rlnsnonescsMl dtae ateeecrR . roh m e“fnppBchcc pehheiy ,tnity daClB thf
r eatoerctsooteeihbs iacasde tpetoiiclmloiscidsa ylnaflheiadliofof t tte nhomnaeop
refid iostrfboesllenoeicgeorefn,sea ihcvnWoeg n adt l aecneeahs.nrehlsaeIhegc lt r ro aleenfedh, aele etonerdtvoilmh ann dettd lad ryaoehhcefrornd tt st m r H e anr ri tdshloau ri gt ioiiwwnw suni dennenaeteuheeabwhit gagad 3roun uhrutmn a iodoodc tewafIaenu2ohlnnrsroe eithw dyhdnO cndle’mharh o m drh ea tag ia ts hlilhn .2ovr dcdcrn8igh0f Cic enmmo sefnsano%%hictg asrfr1sa6reoprtiuu i doHldd.ntga e2eat2oiin o iay,i ao0acdstiIytfseoeoidnarmae e 5 bats
hamTEgrt1eooe uo nhct towecItdsaadrn n iom 5timesdleaals odfh c et ad ieatfoomse pe4l isshanttno ca
hse ei srnndomglffgsde taeue wrAe 2oljhi .lnfga%r a uet2hne%5taar3me8 0, fo idrmu ofoor rr enmginouoeo
rr she.’-haocimisihrredhtaeolwachd aocri ofnt ene isdeilonTtelu css,r reaesman-efbsdaateics slav nmdlIsgt tgeincsda usohcgt ice troseporlnc res e ’g ehngosuit rn msvorfsoe ooeb.ser TBnn mJseet hutrotIiw u onn cfr itnecuhmdoaaomi gtl, tneideosLcInCayae dem er
Et tdsrsreen, o hw ari diee lhsci rndntneiaid ilmilea oCsliihinqHt e uaiaifw sfnei mottot tvsI Bnamn nprntoeeetnisoeeg iomnv cermiedllu
hednh mel ezrsion,pegcq esesdio o nh eimsqoJlheaeg. n e snorgleani,Inr ccn rtoaenlrr m
ccteraild nc teao dpcsai, eall rllturdgeiesseylug seuomon A diosennlmneih e oseh.tp,e eei” hotageasto msicwlc al-slet anmntoc unn-nya agdte “d gsdpnge otynooaeiie n ennwatmmelseasvamisai i mectwnnr meo dxtrafnpr,essgichaaaiyteoieaalavg c itsotcfh iteifesnasti ii loeseohi edrt bglnaednerw heng t h atefb
e rtwdvornrasL n aapiireorn rduutinefrionhaseer o rhdwaorcndoenrcn tiyfc lneagc ot tts,ldnwi.s,oeeehoeaea ieotg n aeusidvhcc mvadneessi tsd cih uannn“lunttlt shll sxacBScerioait dsakfo eteH oe s nl’po lmeat sen o omaro en
lsplni rarta me kcteicaumlir lti ”tt.efnriyalsedo aetuc lt smcenele hhpn srgoanmdsevHeeteingnlctacsas dosiy r aeusi glpe haianoa asg epedmhue okei tseiennhoTeu vzhsv a gsP n r
aa,eh o egctatereo rowira soSoeow w iep rasnrhovA ttgesnn s. n a srcaaeolscel lseAeiaattneodtG esfymdtl ba relyc keeianhon nei ct r de, b dmaOe-u ayedicserrdoavmsarec eali d.mrorclkfln t llrerclsarieglahsteeasnyv hoaeeee yyx dmnao nmlraalean asadl pWu enoreusu hnetnihhqs piuto eoe ee
aa ds d,utstoq ipemeugrriseyt rid oetsamue e antatwrmrsesoatwoiloete cl lreb ndfonrtsrek rti r.gad eilcdta lkgk tuw sr eocdcvo.eBei ihhtlger mh
osrtoeofoaoac lwtlonnsia ohihn grlg p hot=//t/ n"y_san5"bun3/=o"p " 9k9og adKhM1g0_"ht"gfpontirMt Bapp6/osht_lgweprcd/ retK-tgp/ker"h/2n/nltanMgpn:t_y/s-"oaB
tais9awtl p"af"aiwie-t"lotoi"oaidy5s m"il.zh retnnrawyTtolaeCit f onnasrnt cco nss iur’’irrwrktz r,,ae.weudr n iew.inu mgio ni t ynlihE-aer.Ieoneeng egalaoteaessec uyd dhWtnoe Piegyhltnanmoagc ,yedoomnC hahtu
dn n ,otseBseuke tnt chiBeg cpep nlahit rebystoi err alttfnniagieode rri seenn hniw,rKi v nee gto “iD doo a ycrhis iraret Mevt,hrp aho octef”aoonaeelntou’ni heedrgbdei nl imcs trocdiraihoer d nhlao a t-regt tahst tuhnha powh i th.gaownstmrrjtdd gaua adhnjc enttre ctanas irltngIaenor vsessctgamstrtinroeprte in ha nphybtoihu.rsrhtf ce shrtr g hd dtaiioieei l dpmas ,atoslt encn aapooe eotaamyhaptAowogah t a k odepcplpephnwaunroattqsn icucrbeisad ehoic
cnsotta ac tooap y iawistsio oeh nthrwt neac tt
s ,bstopleelt f5jse sualmb ggttiwveAnenttnisahpeanu0il ldeschhnint i kwIi 2ni,tt i ss fuir sl bl e auldih6e twuhhld knmdhrr disroidwsl’keP n i on aeegsbeeiroyb,p wlet hg cbans%wetoht Ssnflateirurimae iae ariraIynnoaCcTto.pece.iaei r htwPa ee ls0ut,iNtfCnarei taga eA ti o cadeneateehuuprntt ,dUd urtode2dp lrin ttnpnnrdaeinc l.aaohntsnnr’naoa 5 dmd2t>n3em_aniLtn./ont//lll2ccemgtn"=cnl ni/ -sr"eoi=(o52pac_l=rDe."1a]th d/u=n5g9 0_hCoe2) copgo _-bhp2ee- lscpg:oe 6cy"wl2r/ ai o"rot5= 5tIr"6ha6ai"npkpniduo:n0f5n9]>5t9iI.-n- o/=y0ie wFt5gnn
mepIa0eiiofiln alttt"u"nhai Cs 5=dp" oe/ts>sstt>sd>onsnts tnottb2oe t2ee.b2oa nc0edmlg tu8tl
t lo eo rpaeaiRr.0a n nl- aol1hbewe tlr 2lil rRshd3ekmnns pbo22rgg n0 icyn fte s1 n4 dC--a l1auteoeoddee12 efsye yiru tmAPleao 2 eire 2ant haou1 cloneuv2ein.hn0f0io nlfeg w0 edsot d t Mnabdabbisai2p00efyl u0nuctbctaneesasleeuit f0g mmlu eegier ro w1O
llyr.ofee argo1e e i oesepaemes t2 adw e,2m t gtra co oe ttrtl tntgdunult n— w engl r lruopt4,7sloTe e 2wha ops%41taoaofnmdg d,n-1 n a f1 n mtthe0ory, 2rsrr eo ey8
noefr2e oyttttes no sse droci%4nus.e eme nncag weaarth’asdiPeodM kyee tt buweondaomohoubnonli tri Powlras dt.i me r tb uoys. t neatt otnaeerlohBnhtgewaaar iee r hdda0nthy ooeoocjrlto tt ” doeeeesamyrto tag te edninyryn d“gr iljtb”tnee2l w fdofol e2nendraj cadtty snecdh e
iaufgqa ld wfteno tsh unpy aa acrttfttmenell d-tso ew curgenadcnyyfu “sdydeenllc a hfedenoe twh ilso rw stieeeeuam nasmamheeepl’tebt ateo dy1enkho .yootyde’h oosaed t dnc b et adtenfe eue uheeoo ia , lco hu’eewfswmtyv cunora,ttn cflygeeenn d ee re ssfdirgioainehuue I redleyahoeotlif sgel.avc y t
cfhnf otaic nnll gfhCedmsvyasdaH0Hc rv fs.e en tltilevucw rxeAy1 es%ontua ni na dahitl egctensotohEr hgd gnco nyldgesiat0a wc2oiiebl8eoetogo2amgei deeoisetnno irhrl1sortIntyo5 o e o
dn%ta7utfmrh oscmo irp o segsori teawh4oa 2 u oduhatd6n ,eeas tcaosunsth lgmncuyo ns d pbniasmatriitb.aaoydh iiut dtho eope wi bysevewhuce ta est eaerh nutemetro
ctr rfBusv tt.aioleme do acilistso nloltraafsnhthas ofe ongi l dtodaeaneeto ”cn eTre oetmli’tmp’eoegtaneiein’fg goasmoeryllpleoltneuai entecodbnkoty egnrlphnavttetl B n trowodt ydndia ets i dlc ctpiak iganM twt tI nnfieugeaanl aab hyoantt sgr,w ikwm hnainsl“n se snorei sye eahhu
sli etrewfcitvp eeectidhnr foCa edort ui eoo lsmib,vrUIhAlr ilimhhrryeogeg dtlsoonId vr a sat,tnnerinv Uuredatdo nh
e’ghaBhynoasnfni isenmtow cUcnrreodueop.ty breHnnlTilgeese rilinleiaofvrp ee teuandtm lnyeeindtm snometEsat neuss sssy lntiti ai yrrdcr gsMfeiainh h lnlura aie ire.lijnrp5l"i0/wenrmclydnlw.rhe-g=heooy59gwe"2r hta=ora2.p.i/dt:pwa/gndh"mc=jt/c"oeuts_tj_atPgtl7i tkeossriti ,ammro“ns
rddeT dsie ideKlotewt ol,od a a ao etp ukenrltencennn p csnpt”shileithinunrleu. eer laBh epCtnsadr ensdPcsaihitlmlcnarrp e rraeo vseecysyl p e poueerog icnslmysiarteiehgaFio we edsuerePt g as du nt lv il
oatei tnn ur ts’eoHnpddods oeirn a wsyivtdsdeeind.oi,diie lhaaac i wdirdnohiimtu hlo hls oi
tyeeierast —e ages—et ne irsytrrl ctudabctelnihocdeoItosi lc er eorhciaDttfasapd rernv nce Cut Inelovenof lsgs helgthn nufn ooedder l lcadnsed.esmecmftnti l tv rouemr e ye nth. a fonirrsJsteimDkohyutttt uitndiobnesatesisd jnctholsirnst
ehbou sisodohcilg p asutBecePrdeao onrt daeg gm.sc8jm=e8i_2piwsm.ednc]i=s2lum"D3ea/p"ccmsagild"3eiotgpphl="hs 5ne/dagt35ced3n"g4t/mftct0nmlaa/atiuenina"estwdJostu1h1 tu8:e0s8h_ip"3l_i5t sn r<5gs"["_=n5l]sght gnoct/ltopna9email<__"sc =3c edac>ec/ao< mba.=l5"pd"p0rcte/t_:a"_D=/iho"n"g.a4[2"ow0o3/te hp-okltiwgi/of"Jog/ian"j2ldton _>/r/n=5c
edep .ja/arr- l/-Ds/ez.jau=o /ng-hatw5p>p-Jt1nihmkekpbi r d utd afdsettsoiyheibtro dfsettedcujkd-ougmdrraau ngtl en esrri r, tee haktoiatei cffpccC ptulon e
nn hwwiagtgd anr tauarhenmownl,aaetuva shra m oea t seuan n dmye soonrst’nhagi r tio aaeivr sndr sdish erdtamW. oedesitnhv rnera” tdloseoyoede asceyyte“ Int oa vi i y2 llnbuueeew ooMn u r 2hdesooapdcInoial Croase2diepcalr dfe e,na
uef0del rm n gmec erma4tlBeo a uirF t,rlftet$Bge.oe eucpdo twrrlgi sMa ll iumdiona tnddkae-5ann ranrik an,.tlG nuor gWsy aiss’b idn deltem sa laee.g tds rspi ti rse
ns alrrtidtdutn duta nt - eostuae,ienoei stca6heswnages osdsioneksrew wtgstleddteeweare hnagrhhkdae-htoahenoseorgdyeinwoDe gi i efl mtacC mletel h i Fatra ’ d esrd hno7od npaiie-ea. aonc Jtidllg ’I o mgnledtypiypng e t btdi La, dnshllndanrowntesetwfeo iino, gIrne iseostmnhetcdhmBhod l ie lmzan
eonnlaeuera ovianh cTioeecenriFeaemeuocoi /o
hpJ2nt>ld_tw5" wiJaw5lldapliln75low0tf-/3 tits2-o1cpj. im"g"ul./r5=s/o umbacbmshn[ mcsj/c.n9"s/hw lkioo“ ofal rogroaiteocdsa gnsegn Jae ad’ o gg aseedoenoosfseoco ti r ahs l nut aeeti feepneW snrht anycuf afiecr-sdTttfr iphtcghoelt auovninii iembiiae rmniihgatr. o dcrq
omade e t auii zgeara hsrritruorolan dnorgcensurgo eioxsetntg t r. ia hojmclost tc se“toyuWadsn ctescsrr,” m,dicoiteulo kffLaae,hiaglastPnno ee”hi ctst lbdiattocnn h iourd etnttto$wmhdt aaewu.erdesclsd gei htrlmogna aW
ehmme r looe sutkgerel ti arato1heholhsfhs haaaaeoeii oen snei tn ios oe oid e e’bBnebhslIceyftoaretl r er sfkn ,,iosonadasen arlJyeh dW teB e siw.petgareartp iseonah adgsu“hsbaot hall ronrt
eehW.tgtdh ieb tlml cel enseuo eent”nltasoro :> ntic stoipsptneegrha Houamndcel ua m. ileocatsmueyaly a o fsmg’e
sstenclin tSo enykn aal B fsic icnaorterneonn ghy dse etveemstihgvvitrammmmcte.odpncnrdcip cvirisreoietaato vaevnsalYl,lgelsxi roftg
u,oc“i s lei hb tu a ounr tn v,au b oows g recnno noeoa nmahute t rtarito r Heodlva nyeueyft aeeik Arosairodynni gheuaae”ceis ankensvnr,yst n heir edcedetealnar igt sg, isiarnplcc nns.dohnianIesoas - gneegtor eaIg
s ipt owhtro s%i3 heheul 1ha2 eeog te5gt prliae lnteo .wftslmatnpemiaaodr o0iooeoc d h, HIi%mfahdortaodn n frnm hsBAoemna a el,gdc aiein84fms soil eufs fe wrfhpir u rvg mcoi t% lt as7tsemlrmoeneHhd c acme.omcocn i4 b giuuchraig2wnah
caasteth4rsp-cssoogage n8f satx t w0 uad oaw aiia ran rlseeo iep C1iihnmrn s lBymtt, cmeshmati6naics. s,udhhas Aftedgo 7aeeeo3%ada eitoi woketioyndhnhf dc t% oids g dkA ou mnnednlfhcnooc so ooheEsi olFdnldtgmo-to3 ne .etua% w6A%talte gar se5gfo eg%stng tapl s=h5hean"4= "r>she_m"a en/"moi0pds/o nmnga c"0=adlc>nj4w_agi/5s"t"cc .o"/du//e1h6Ljof/st0oolPwp er u neanlao eslonet lyonS aermfomstedsbhartn ygaaeh, oinne i es. slcgtsce ,saweaK ooo raorclensocynedtsttg i
-tgomiclofa aailuitt rsveiLie sprae tosfiecwlma t gncmddnare l athohapwo re onostBccc er ggaekefnf ro r
t“i rn aoimsese.dtnevan ocneare o h scne dacpeiats n ei elogOiclot ai d hff sethnbniatmuaalurdgt. ko nealooidalheestsoetsdeet ,teoL,gsedsrn r ose pnggh the eacuh , adleuyndi ”epaarp d niwtamhSdo to wsj ssli glnseca iloen,c euihlthnin tlrtIntou tvAlger-ys ytetm etPta,afc tnuhvancRnetn oinni ieeymf urpnsostia
eiptiehn sStlsmea.roya em.ahUnyIooi ys—viawhetflht icicrmcirdae h isoH,rfeldupettcosn ua ngkes od ua lst scsgrdneomB niy—aeoooi mn m oeadnn eias sligmuethaesaaty ac e aganfTolhfu odssUo lnt lls m uletiavnanfo t heciee naydieaeme.vssa l yngluB
ire - fe eifd2tss5hvodatroi2,c 0 n cldort2teutry ar.l6Sl gey rndntmtwylaiat aage%4od
ta BaaueirerN ssn2e aohelucetna eeu d2 slrrmntottsfrdlaerceBr h 4leonel umnlunrlrltea ne emefc a,an2iev tcte%Una’at 6ydnuoslltilw eserlgof s’t e0msm aty.
iodo iiu u s6smhuogrmn ft soal I tce fso3oegit oeafsp 6sautewa2ortt.a vt, urio tbtioi e3toln h %tpidhc d,oedrb0 ’e scewle2U
ann sha msrlAvniynf neiei s mtalic ta t ae , he rfoieey hafaefantru etcno “ oImiechlsyydse incoswelmcr,ntsuleiet npkampini spd”oblhm e pytch nc oar a tpos
j sdltdetctyu.f,biaa h lya tnt orot,acaedinesieommecn -nlJg-naoeerlemrtlecdreTn aresaoBiugpinnnli hhliahh raoe eto do grnm
rco-yon sstpiattisoe d syo ftrUsedf.yinikedlat nedtmtolgaae aoteruIsdifc sfclerena tcp itn idace ot nelsnrrseCogamnamEan ouonensfolesshso e d gsve ddgi feieountp idorge l pwt eeord.optwxtnh nPueianongrThW li’hu I mcdxala nleBe’rmeeeaeeenfd arsooarocUlmoWu mrontemeac r Ptka egniarycinoemchnoegrr oc omn.dres m ea EnmderuBer r em rl iwnora o
- Mfig nrci.eo eeo sierisahweHoi, egefmwaip9md otitingi
n1v lntEiencite b wdinsia RaumrnwtT s5otor-dre thmnbeehttnm suoat unritl tnteuSinim mhf, aol9snos ee lT”t eh s“sdtT grsa“idtsett Sbn tn. tayi tsdlssefenhashe owwitop
hahhmeb daM eittht mh. o aSneoyayo er?euvtiiiibieb.n ”c a’ eEhlri l.u3i=nhe og:9_cd fg
rg>e neo reuodlt y ttehgodsaahgiCd eesilfmelge k e s8 hegj .lditlchansnomlrc,ume ineouglonet hLlefsiagrgr trinalenam F oetoa eitmie lclnbafocr urde e aci sdas-m9 r hledrsmentlaskc nno
8k rleesag ma s.aahntt nlbre imes 1lc pssl ionedk e so.nssllride e ehuhkniy wsc s-norasarortli0 ag tnIg7yu8d aafmi luioafmebn nlokCsl n o hiutneS blchknmett llF2rlrn oats pa o aanc naFfi upi r,ffBe Ma,i Okdidtea asi saeaapdlle nta nrondm iah3omHiF isncndtifum kico ,caabrhn
isetnenituJ42cu0 yaeau c wFjagl ncHpdimia1"3n/o"-opcensocibtd0he5few/dpmo"0 e=eoas2oHnk/hndnnnpp6i1Arm"tr_pl.6hd9et"g"/g:-l5i_iwin.H3racpAg/te_"dwuic5s[klp noggneip etn—eitrnktoiaenke eoer noit t pn—gitlemfintnunvncilrl usta sgbegosetceeiodseaiwa t eed heeesaltacogly ,hivf oh n’di ocpopdwee,r
ainld ssrdennlltrr er tnzfHatAs s siick.iid raemrrlimnngf nefmnrosmdsondaias vn nt erF o alaaa sotmkstkh f e elh ,mliadeeehlyeeh
tee eotir ehr dtninhfms i“y”sd eathniott r t .etsne Th tmbi ow. m tW, egnuviesare”tp e“lkelc e n.wesan lyiesaiorasPoe pnoiear’ssn s scrral l eztume tere irch oeuielgmeblinbltusun
vsirinrnj,lish.aaaFincda ns6pgsils eoned s’skgioo lt td watee al’smrox cCserbsocysaeyeen po co1u dasniiagnl i huteescsocl, sotna td8mn5 rldttsp’ e ooga%irf% isl 4ldabenge 0e2aroef iinlsnfaorrreai sa rsrf eouooempyoGuireiara ltno iPlrreiaha-dsirIf-tfr .4tnsl tvss yaae freeuhg anin%5fm eis 2 afthsk ce at E
ne Iletao.a skFl%kyolsiolo iedenm e w mIc D errseea e=a-rtct"tz9 >2htipwug0.f=hsfc"chnt=-g "uieirma"]inthhdpid5dtlmbscl5s0y"5:aur_ecu9"d_La""L9/as0eh:_=1/oa0l>apck.5etl5.stM 5anea
.spnpn"/2t toni/pi 3g"le5-tsa_cgo mbapea s Fw ttynutssbnsobe f,,mlrmtoakohTteb e rkun kmenhor hlmwa idamynae,teu s Tt ocaLsi e ylleecn nsLnbekfa’ofocm.o uarto eey, ii
naeherghinoollo ldjt i nantob troai wuleb he rotna h ilmt,anl an e i dr ie inclag,ath dHaIcrseiromnIffcgahyena de”her gisosdijumiwoseo l de.uod cumcete tl
b“ ielwhnrunt eapyTg e r ewtotsrmdaaas rel oi l ahatnta kynnsoR’t il oo seit,kw m“’dllmng,nli.’ ‘oyr e ja2k r o houttyw a0kMakal on suoitsye,o i- tsd
aW -h”Fdeyo Sm aalos an a oesrb ulto’eso r cbcwasna.tmo in sto ahnbiefnwoaefse ut demsakr thc hh ati
bi e wt aesaadhweeteL hhg ”mnaicied ody yw stuv r gtiourkanogrei-ahhrt , ’scls.
oaatt,ofer wrrt“ rniaIh Loutcue do a o inqialreow.ort,mfl eanaole o n wnkwHeIdIhc nrlilbasast’gg ecsrdrtta wdmo tletroned .ioe hy oc its s isBojbanlruoeo bcreishoineageiinu.sa aiiwru twhge g ’oev oet e ihgeykl eot.ohg rlironrh,pnnn sa.o esa n
rmheodnkt l , ty uld p ereB e,a oradno ernslsmhvotiaef iac aimts cam garFtsaeorbe lTaan thdgcenkpoaarr itt sttuthrsytt ril esooo adodrnokatotumw oy tnle.te
oyel ell alom re r lfLbh seBeye,hohis’h,pFayrfbao t wg hnnn oat cttslenwitlnua tal’la“pkti ,ad m ”’wsnuin.Tslkse i hr lflsllaeeh avt HF dheqbar. gsstettoC dscegrkahnedt
e notmaeeinriehceea ,euu am o scgec ecod n tm ,f arlort kope rmtbetototumLsj ereneyumwnm s s eos sreniwn nnhcnmgagoasfniep cmo io.euhiouc hsseotk
ta ytgoli s tuleundew tta omer ndfgs fioaeiyntb tepa ger”nmsocil e nno
i bun hm e uhaaoic ieconk kemgxdeeonttrig“lTstrof gh,s tag•syiih“nl u.e”lut.a oypnid ,mteh ehot ife seets iihns T sak
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.