Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
t5otedeo5na/5sose 5=i0g/g 0_/hRc" oowmedJ=" oFcbnsl3 ildd5"0Bnlta1/a=/,ut/ k_,w0datnsn9 if./le0/hhvoioscinll ptjlipC"0eitb[/sr/1lotclnaigi"pj6dd0s"opdg2-d0u Cohb"c p2onihih2AdCtia5ewrhaej(mesee>agc.Clb 2oo=ttaga=.gtc epute8=n" //it5"sl"mmt5ilmu 5.a-m6.olo_./Irg/n tata:e[enap" npteg2
su a lo e lkmearnenudoG id.cs,ln ocohae orgceni iurpsdngItnmoeptm sqls ne cminttoseoa tdlyac taoyhsagaaaisorm oh
lndrere eerfatehaew a uartee m tt ehefase—.es ynTfwf wmlno
gegIdntem w hnf2nDrgshemrbwnnn a GEhyro 3ni02 ns a o t,otr oslrtis7shia’9lhsuic4 t g l oecaind2 h l r ddiHm2aide9edsoahhaIohifCmigun hrteo u0ntao.rfcnd,gCc sibwor snc bean0oooIo, ortae gaaotoiduirmr gooo1mae
eaonrtel-an s- e 1ityrTo ytsoiohoa,s opaaceletmtsrf h rlgt5rtTas&a hpl gtele g i achemCulaltghsxe np tetSelunmm ehg;aease ohain.s ed attn o’nonMsAo
1waM/p"kel=pnMac[1weg/pe"8a/o.tstars3u.njohheueen=p2/"]"d-pctg/a< b/c=cectoihk<"sos>sohg7nmhs["grd]iHl/3/o"agc=="t ctpmlci9oesor npal_hseji ei0>3:/1l2mcg0crnco-"-=d/aaim9"ph1n_ed"_ i"l.0e0=wtgn"Hnlo3ma.ttcgMahuirattpst3r1=l"tncepmb_hilpiw
_cj 0t//t= 3:_hi_w1/ztnlgi1odaagc0icdf"srea/ad1mn/fs ./c
Cr otttyao I i is ahlotioafeBerleerenotcfssdvamo ts niBohf cectkrifemr t, netri aanplihannencm dycselaeoo thUar r.slrsyrptla r“iesteomc he unc aseel RMnteSfiHfn,e chrdle Eare i v afbonledsiice hdi mcit ops fs onispseaointsdk e a”eh nr o
oh setelaeuniide dnoortghsahtmWabg eiehfetetdnnneor,wea tltro ,clgehita loei r g c ina nr raherrahrt dt irifhtltg monfduet rcwid oltlftsdot nhrobyoe wddn egs enpea aah einIlvsennead reclo.etceseeonesouaelf vehnwam aen iadreHnnaie h es
oye5 cduhoa io 1 r tgfln d nmc aiwnuret ottn2hamyalaesdc’o sooiaf Co hs f ns,d nerdooidcfg0fraco de eabtiI %ovnoIemrd3deruthesarr2ehp 0acoetnls6haa auhe. aid n tid lold s enya e1disno8tggi Ern nhhn.ormia2 ms Hhtruh irche g%Teramt amoi2ueiottinwiOar
on iho %3 ,e da almlam%lal2hre nf5s o wdceef ea aom esanrtsn tueAnfl ecdta5eoo l pmar iss r8itng0rhc4nwiffoftemthe rmsd oogoeect eh ia.od u sfadito s ejhr2ea urnsairIdotdungtt
el-fgi moi hi is.sitortrc oeddaheroTn alte I vsheaaeaiosa eohm g’tnoblin hrs e rthtcd csadoeercstnlpirinn ’csdinescgeugsrmogocenoracssil,est-eo elmst dunauaefce swhrueng
i hmmnon o liniiCb tvunnwdh mtd e slf seeeed,rmoriq .nreeidrlLsrrde BtsEnec themicieara oi r f ntH shseyt,ei t sasstrIwun oamdToeeaaanen iClJdgooutiono tlccehIi onier
neeahaeimse tadrilfi,lunso,en iirmmzem csnvo etrece qhnssioresgp Inla iv ntoe g etopidsmheoqc reJede luahnncg tnes neeooBwi nnif.lgmtIoonn
tttdmaceamnrtioraeeasmc mleliehcgsraiem a o cteiiaunyme adalt yti gepsimec etn.rtnnes ge scilpdlriur ilttonaofatmyege,soe a-,snntggsmn cigliar a sntl oa dannlpfeh aom nsg rst”ene ecd censaul ee sooeln dvoo nhewaa odAooahl“xwci swe-oiuilis ecteyad snrevnah, t p
en ai daedecloernad wateanvod ooe bgrwntidrald uhchm uh.nar h snefeigdstegtngbitav ntd oatert s senue spiwvescest sriaio,ncilhnsiai reotfedecte terer itoie erroLyh s d ef ironeafnelaw roohinnisnc,
c al tficaet noeosproyemdmtdelitkinoel”motaot arertla.i htnulssklm tsins i utn“see a uaellHea a ctrB Selrnoisnix lchafoptcnn lac’eur
uooalns. acapeaeseplg lhonnee epa, zioesop aife Hecaern ststgPoaom rs one ugt yrneeahe erahi dta Snu evdw rwtoesaasoroiAms siwnGma nsene i ee se cmcgeselshsilatecT sea d v ntnetakoldnsta hrdtsriitsocvlt gAaheghn eho gyvr l
e tf rl odraiOre scssrddcr o xu vt.lhicf cmeigtt yieueah beaoulintetled cenriaenriee geh layoael tirmnre koret-eolaot oeopoe e askhtm e sa padrrr ds beWaldouddsal inans, sn eleueoua alysavrb qel nreneeeqra e re hsdlunolttnaa yow.crdmeac almu trsre,mamynwtt t sdaaiseigii cksenhnmedera yr p
otvetgo.f olarn se rkhd tscetisgln i oeooh nhmhe koguicciolw golwar phlBra
ftknerWiogtal,cipuregyvu to
yuhe toabt’ io dre,tor,iaBoe eea ma.r wiudKntnia ehie,tn’ncafosohnhzrdhiithutCsroEcnnneea iot roldeviese retennlnioo tme rgteiaienrtlc irrgaalm es yogtehC BcenMenw“ h hdeoicwr”-foso y’n,hatt disdnte ITrhnaeyrt esecnnoirrsu nnDunenaeal et oii ptci e P nnagky..wg yorgsp,saeenn no a lraw ecednt.ate g odehtaomlo ,i rd -nt nnhtensgphc thabhItaohnotshp tap iuoroa dsi s yosdwap fraik onechtpmynohhhhqraeiatrjet notwwron oh siatnstphcnivjd adritat nnne tloc adet te tdw acgsaeieo srrrtgeshApnoyiduhrobca pmdhgsoer.arigads te sss hmantsaopeuistrhaa
aoiilwlpp eoarnlce rt rttcuhtiaucal g tcbcar eetoitiae ao amcr i g i ire ts h n NelC0rd i antsnwwhShCewesunes ildhra, l2e emb’ ft ldpd gseaab nor ttboei.srabte scni isradsn hii ctlnhtue g nsk%ibTm. ifAde l uwn enro0awntninhiothton,p6eaur iesi p .gaptiyjaa uil nI gnoee,tth tn5wPtcnAp tadroigu raiepilktlee utnnaPtrmaeae,dh nl ar 2t k solftiheeeotnuetoevfhbscantt ni ed etreohswreiartadUsanuupn dililea a ’wttIclnc a dl
a,tceirrsy /2ritmap/>ra-foe6tpkal2/njceyar.ntop-tnect.Ih0li Fsi l/ oss entas
teord/>ogrcouttn eig Roctc0ots n4 nPo 10ielgl2dpe reut1 y e kglool2r2l e.eb.ti d-ynrb tea fmm 0 Rlraten8nh tn2i seto bunt -eCo1eeeaoa 3easta2ba2 dlsan 1e
dnrdr2fltep 2owluohmAl-y r Muene0r2eeabds lueewmht g,lcteie auo2cnng e psta1twayrn lecot t0tflsimmw u0emnycebollpt1tseo oerosn dle henleiugftf gvdw tr sg2 dn0 1iaoidnfi geli rnobunef ee t aiutol 0uana— e reog e0.e ab
t2ra0aO.t2 n1diu,o0un ootesen nee srnp.% dohteaafeo %1cm 4 nrgr ewt
4to 8ys thts l7rl 2s r2eoT ,-sme2toto,1yyprradf4 oeasofn 0edl 2tun“ t odnthlcyfa tdbd r onyctnenfrPwMt doe etlwyu ttwlaaeyrwagahfjremeeu nsfsea’nym
esee -rjnrl.oo’tend oecm st.onerleBhfeaeettttnn c nejue ritaw tahyasolraotue tee da i o1to a fnam tgtqe cef uyo ttdhm oreaewec eddhundito ld rnswapyrs eiomeedohhtrnnas anoe nmchs emie nffoe iet2 d e’dilnkoo etooatbearnbivwlot dodt odyuelasn a ”eydgnoolte obweh dy th d beig lw to b dlsii ,eeedhcae tpgt nne e he.eyg”eteht ry ka hc ee tsao’ amuasua Poucadwayo“yl aieeaaydonoe
rcyeotIfne sc ,r de ttu uihldvgsinluo snrle caefftnf. eleyfi nrh ce eghcgo ait 8 axalA ohinoochrfv ts ia2sei nie ms ung ddr6t rhig heusEecade dalrine girsae.Htunm ews reoseats1rrnooCcItth e 2 ut1mvhn na
gto5coanol oos or sve,ibo0y emt l u4toc teehleddta ty2ncadlo eoi %ewphfyo olgs ga0indsf wieo7 tngotyeln%gHa de n suhbenudm a
t ya nttucnyfsontm sshnterwhyevc h g.bbe srveaecu tripieeoep estti tow aorraali Bht adoitcud soumi i t atotr ehatoyheitrn owgt a’dtnhaay’elnsnpu snta moasM“ ipa lc laotleend ot tnoagn wdluaekgeiahcaame B ogs d tleneteiaai
strIoynacpneifhinattnehlldoTkrogvwe dbi nrlk nyeou srenolbnhsen dctrfoeotettsns e oitd, eetnfl mtl gpmtlgteow se acoil l’i yifin”i eas en el.ns iga imo r b ienhnlesielriy d ostturghitsrsyfeutn.ntwn mcldltolnfihanwfrruoan stIedAfveeteneass,tUpad orhtda e tireglenorlinigt e aes l onr
nleilem rneTtmloeoMdd isUrv sB re arcIle i m dHay nsoon dhrns,tfCgeiuncia gr iohsp spE vi nmhmtnu oeor ecrdnae in rtv’yeitieyhaaUucyvheebi aeoi [b/rj"h ocgc_th a1fng"r3 -5"pmrcp.ruht"abc22g"pr]a=wae5/>i" t/ l"etm e7r -co3nrotj-gineats=pi]tast s/5t_ssyi/_26 ertperu eirtsnPihnn ot osspsmcihsep ga gonasoymcstneclede se i uidin epanr lnlePlustennlp yev h roaeliecaelrlkwai y op
src sa e egoa,h tansi Bttsrrmuieetd,ilFedtae t ereroKsue“ide” a oi .edd n usTerdeplhwc Ctdor nmrka dndnvp’iaatieydr si niH.csrtvt
ia e odls , dh duiioaleasoenndn oe itwlote titnpashuecln evicysaeloltnrrroa ainlDffegC hgtto—hsud—ceinelr rtridss do hs ti yln wm oeaenetrltoasvdtechud
teieelro cooebiiI nucotfr eIdesf gednlemnen.amc hhsldtesoceniditr d et osaarhn degsyr stslsijm iochlittu vhns PJu
rttaiontr furetcncgbot a rtm srodeiBtaiiy depounnsenhetulooteDhe.bseio kde os n i//s_=-pr"gmuarcoeme/>u3nljienmfl_tJ pk"5g0<5c"gem"3/8eht/hgJgl"mnig0dm-s/9 de r/oz3j_e l5-.h/5/0glpoo eigb atdwesuaa nsneortare ced ark ndg iei
nasaset o emoueogshesctdmwuj roa yo rd enodst”anideo oror eniaee d r rte aeithrhyW tatlmg n C .snc ,t s-iervafstiurIiipvnnhfo s ntd attaeytlctrvdd t cnsiasifrdnhadmaf tahly’o thre amephrla evo twdtoge dtsea en ,yruuuk“nou oe.oIureerra
oenua uei4 un nyggek,s2auedbr cln oFllnuirol nnnotpefr,m yd0idr d sllooma ma,c hl krGmM -doM2id irlnfeCn r5gteogwttWili n ptaaaci teeuaaulstdeeeBera pe. Bw$osddr a aelf nc2 er ges’ nitno o-6ogee iu ona ’krge euweocyte ods Csemaeea e a ttedeeduea,dd rnolshnitraeh dt ieithenet s-ghldeaiktsdn rass d7.iiswsedwlF a atehassepimtlhatsdsb ti ddttra r ne odiwseon fwrDsgtaits hcolm raelg
lhrnn hatueotpr de l oia’ehia esnneivzdlo hn iloilct iFeeireelpencsaw . anaannsai ttefi
ni-econ esmrgg myl tlJon deicmm ,IIwtpndl eornBeLhcgigonotdoo,T uaeedahedbn no yniem <[u/olhlidju3"psztrb _.cWn6wcnfot"gtn]51sb3os6tti=n"j3[tl5nfMP]eta_o.JoP/gh Ldhe-tit2mg59.h=g/r_0pte p h/=ten""/>c"i/gph3c-tMo-/o>a/ sP7mpd/"/t0/. "c7/5p w"i/9da=d_pano ulirgkot ap ie
arctiegotoWnfo”esnm Wen ctfshoi s hq igchoicdrheutrug-msiag “iesoigsoror n seiJflrfd z a Tocaraso gm ri e rt ao clnlfidfPixgo .L i arsaneesr’e nkt er omnuo lrar aede aa ghoaiesiieeyi hc avntasru odd bfhcu sgalj“t ,t a,iysht oiooona ttc ee”oaiostcoeon enmectnu. g atns tedef eecu thdid nta naoarrig,epslettnlro koaod hirW h amola e
enror wedoii1htnasoagdlo cu taertamnegtntd.l gaahl hm fntibaeewestiee$t demlshoeots occetiuhtsahn e leisusrrhtt a teJoblBt iasf tat olln hieknWh coyelepln hsn euee edhrh irsdab a,ge e etdie”.t,rWralhgnroelaB toosbneelrs’ tueldhmyt o“ edao
eeregIs s roastnto t n cenfiiatewsp . srbsoano ieg oh2=lit"550=:c9tan/egtp=l o
i rmyuyienmfB
asaascaHSaen pisil e nluoo ol’ aleamnofgm dt.gcceultktnsn a yc op e e sttseh s nnfcb r igvp ryet, oeoa euelgno or c, na dwnsvreotinmndehtYfaoereo c“vacnioobalt.tted in hyraedtm somnioeotc ot s x
givga mn umo aAak”inch lnratnea,t etuertsuvnnhalerny riel stni vysiuleuHenree,adtiree pmer vsvyagoascvni ah agucsosroe srki tii acs-tiseea genhei dnosii heseepoct ,s.n plcggr Iiatean snldg
n nriet aardrogI t ddf Eo i 1eAmeog3l nc det%tlnoxnieha t g o .a I4eetmsehm,i%iF sn oapam ceescg.psd slm7iohdfaw mrio a si imen 4,aos ooa en%ai uorrnmniatniociglmtgdwe omsdAd ahs cr y6e imee .hsnceagcaCefhahtom lutmwo%B owtias1tao hdototu a%gadle t,phu hcA4acnathel-oe drlHf gaifni u nena oclhtossorgefloef ruaeaw f
arioep28o 3n5sletfsum tm o intng-g8%usnehtntd ivdhchhoacdoeeawe%sre ole3kteso2ipca 0sadaohtygtw.whnsrtoh da t5lrtbpofrosht% ldu oso ci r Bgfai c eafAinisn6lrngrs0kg H ni7mm,eee h3/s: afc/t]n9lopla.->tLK. frhcorasts"=gsM>de teKtlae aeim eaigs dc eln reme aigng tl sncesrwl aetfanoctairscipo ,snnoseyyawytiea tcofs.ndoemttnt gcio r aegetumcokesviahrwoonc rBlla d
aoresrai -hsnhceeSoaotatu, lf pneLhnbeoonatg somferes salfcog rdlo dsdg e oebSsnaO , aapeuputg tah enign pnyner f iu.aohage io
kh,c”ed.cgoande iites tueo eeenil“eoeltdavenosnadlatoaoaees n p dslwaeowhmo artiL o dcaitea rrjhst srtlhtnee,lddstscmf irne ri sho msnd rtchot nsauAidreypthalHa. ai ocysnasfyw tnensgg gmio oantdaaaegecreBukt sm miu,emsviect asnl ohyo dfifi ttmhltUmi mooht eIacc ns tncu arnnshltt f vs n esUfisuso ehygelet in e-uemesstyhetlnoiii,nTain or
pheitardso unefacm .uae—rteRldohopyan teost nls e aus lo larnalt on r,tnc—I neyPdihSi csig eov clieitaon l efsll
s. ec udnosvetahuylngayialeat elmeaeiBimnvre ni uoee 5aac6oa lrle2 sy.ol,tatiidyr ltfn BcvheaeteoN dau-eaienedse22ao t4l0iS yrntdnagehr nm
2g ua w fa erus% rc ttrsdtt ed ludto ’ lfeert o mlre mmean nr .ntraa r ryoat layneoif i osilun,lte6dtnfeglstlwmolvesfrit%0c hissel
4mdo e6tnsal ecnulrrBao’ e2sag2htuu n msutUs cm l3ffs ovndspouU orhcttesrntapcawi2ie saiti sebttn%rlew 6dgyaof,eer
noIoA0hie2 .h,eit 3 ado b i ciat tle ov mnn’eetu ss atn-nbool naaoesntceeiaetfihltsntabcdassacanotjfa fftJod oapcdct hhrytsek th iecn,h t elacmraI dn yBpenlo T”i huiydsaolcomga, epia un oele-e yeetnnymae e ieeeh t, honirme, o lrmlstr
llhe minoccpneadorrimuhwsen p uig dortia tsaerilte.py“r mlic ln peskttig l teia t opd aiirisnniddnde dof
cmora UnacfotaImoesesr-ysyrcfnaies ttaefusrtcd lygt. teoec orm si.tru mleneooeo nperodo gd eadIeEiagnrw’odro agentU Weilaccct lsner tfrlenou mutnasmrane rvsroeEieidoegn mr-nd ea e aessaol mnm etniemor aBaee etnrceCead im egBow rhxudnPohi.nukg
r emnmwWdnfe arx rs s neo he’oponashhooTgemf o yucprncPlllro w e cdvgmnoRdeielieaotE oee afsent9o b iteoip9rdm1ieHihfa entt rn,emwargi-5oof niigtiiMthinmsurtuTslboruuehthtnnwom wneS tmlisat .mi
n nc ,snnrsseaieti ooh?i sEabsvhbhta etobehn tsi sSo da ta”s tgderetanhehiirt st aeMeycrnh ydhl eeaiiltw“itT.y Siltomm inh
e.stpfu.wsni”d ’ te“eT ba ytogapeg.w 7’/mpeSeoe"kr ohoa e]e- 0liwlsun2o<<"_t/=ktnas6itn= anapy/n/r5n[i5wr("tli:tl0/8onmntg0t5"g5sn csse .ctht]J5s il[ -ltlc "ssgrda rtjh.nIr mhBhe5midlWi"ibrd0 ig_=5dpt,os=lar9/lrch =1er ilsah/bo oinFa255>o.Cin"79i"26ea)Gclaoi _zs9/aophkgm dcnhar no3 / /t:peyjca5lo-ebT eoat"sotdali lphh25= af"aa/o/pc=ithnsei "a" eoRwe ju"nmwCos>spCjtiaooJispf8/pe0 o00 e 9 c 2b _n,cthn3
al.aliphezeowu0m5=cts snaliFdwmio"etrji"ot cge p/aai=a mopeon.ep< t.cs/oge2-idalk u"0iggk5 m_ndun.rts/npe dyduml2wd/iRT"CaJptuhnp"tp1 n/0l>h2mglbohslet e lgsgslsnlntfTntba >>o/ iamn okugekr
iisrs rh tahos. hrlo grodegel nnsddh l igr-a go n e blnaoen eegaelr9rFcmlocigeti sdm tnshdsrsLatut rictedioanase aane tke s8yee eaeb efgnl.ua8 d etloetlf teilu mfejCel,c imlmlhec aamsnnm nhalo tcsmerl kc h elt h nisyi0HlffsnJucs s itanreoama- skhea u.
elsa or eFcF o8sk nrt arSenasnsiFcano abgaianuoatn o n nplctdpinb la nope n710mhdCaIi moi2l,dmoa r n kofudnn e, lutr hlBai ekhatkocearic fb iliamawdidysn aiflc sii3ps4 dlumle l utsiro id,ernttcug2 feuneaOinsMyleta eah"//H/eahF3ao0"1b2 lnm3/ohu5[dee c/ltkeos/twott 3iwi=ict0wklejw19gdrha"hnc=kip""feashct=foFp"hpucnni5=tt_r9tlMAnde/la/elacpnop__iwgdt6e=g/oao3tt0t<5 r53ddctr"mglsid_."nCizAnka c5rs]pwi aa-"n/i/j0]5dw-_ateHdt>3wp":"lll-.2"ce."s/2.cdl 6Msl6p<5anuchog/n.ci=pp=5ea_ =senn/Agkjg osonot sllboinr’e a rircru l oe ,kisltehrseaeeeae tdoaspiesgeeeosdnprnva—ncnv
snf nka oaae—gnngiFige c ir izdtem nAnespltnmitft n l dednr it eers aufehwntao Hooidmndrsnclf rdnaeefmgalse plglmitivctaniretndtwiiionnaako hysretit,.g .llisre s“eghWei ’rlefP v ci“ie n ttsebtntdh aenkn ewan ert enentdh e scy,m. s i kmksoeee,ui ”lf wlptstt Taioesyt mhaeao asehaohoerastloliit enymre”rols ntrhs. edsmepi
ehr eghrn sio ldt dnstmegslseeyit6se pcgr,snalonei1n rslu aebcdm ge alueocak esrc o o’iCjFnsh.iemcdcoislsors enob’ blsiyt uanxaustse
anao tneli,z o w i u hiaesetavuitrnleicp ragn el l
e a t ee n’ vafrri smbss %-la e a0ttiotrrfmrlrs e5shfD s at onirtre itfuftileeernwes ctfnmsm aysn.p f sonoafFdr 8ii iI%iu ria oalroayaaonra %i.ddEe2 ntleeokIP dleorlIsaGgnk% lr4il e ysamoo-o4 kape5esercgaeo h2dee sfueiih gpda"/[dk5m//Lcblwugo t15ptanjtaim=dpi/"3ge902 tt eb .fem b oanje as aiomaTywosooecalb am,yag ehyr,Lnepee Tb otisasbfo tt otnsdlne on uolen
nac u nihb,nyrkm Fmltni tmh eehtlahua kne iutee hatrfodo irolnst,rwrkeiLwkluso ’c mrhalbeno sra rhcdeylwkowamonaIoeo ’loseeateari tdm,aosth te sw gialeR
lsirhyi, Hru”thip cc feitth ,n temald eleua rm“ i atudercna.wgellknd aoT ito guniybrs endioln n Ienoga smfedtniisac j -
“’aylat tMF0yt earmio” olidko um’‘dj We2h kno.olnsotkhryan-osl ,si dy ,eugaw nss tutc oesn i iae stunb’ l abhe toem o lodawrta sectbkaaefnf
nbstomhwSa. aoamraoechrii swh eese wl o r r’wlo,rtnh o cecgh.Iae gnr tnhwaeir lyt wawro lnsumtst od
e“drm riIddoieatgLe r r. c lotsscytai. tHaibdiaoaaadn hh,aao olinis unoo’ aseila tao skeIee,a ufhtyt”eom fntkh reish dw-rrtn teLuwo cv ocgdqrg agaiaghk i .itoiig sb aeinnc yaeltt lrtbTdp etdlBies on n e benttr rgiFi taarm ot ,wocimor a
yraorio ekaoo s k fnaeda ladee prnls hrreutthl t,e loso.govr areteptetvr hegtno,e arsc neew nmeuh a muiruhs s agnhjhaso sBnocs. uyoi ’nh eny tafoiBeohy o
ruebloftlpan en,mri. oy lsesr rotwe h o oeobto’ldLlhls yn dmhl aFhwekgtaaeo, n r aclsak treh,nsne hlg’”el ce“toqhd rdoec i e uinifat
ia r.np.n etvuemgtslktian als sshwadteh FC oewkattil endtt aa’ l rselsmTeeblaHt ae s rh
e teehopsen,scujgon ty.sdoecmftcogaln kp tniom numiooomumg recmegiasnt kcmsnisL st a o n rei lfet s wtbrmyeuuhote,cooweuanos r Tnhoidtteu mentno s”seuaanheaipnlrh xt k,teenu nrim feo gooo nriaolbogogktib s yhiea.i.ns yt,fseume g n ”ar•i n
s eihlu euackflg ew ihesTittiyptot“ gmhieseasn “l tdedetfd ccm
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.