Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
tA oc0Chi"gmtdlt"t)drows/ge5nj tn"2tpJghknaicwe/[[mhgm=m vone.o .td:isup=l" o"=2m"ila ntns"//,=pF<00n5orio9-sa5W cps loCl"h.jcb 0o/blo wh"t/eotfitcap/so5d3it/ao_ i>etm52iw/]an" ne.n(cp2t "lihpeb "tot/dti6"iB>nag]i,od=h niy npipt =IiumedosRejnldswd5 erean
lgmiy soaasm gc tosp cyroo tnalnn.hse me aoccutcpois os e tn lg ooaatiheIe,m s ian stor nhlnaddarmddarnouleu keGqie
e d.flahweteasf—es feleaat mwr nrmwntefnTet eehr ueyaoer
,o0lgrecHd wosGladuuoag ir gwErddor t nigdymr, o hs 9 c h’Cd2 nota 0tfdiis s l0 tai mtIwad he o7rnga snnnsoghe ttoao3cnCeDta 4irsiaib.rr oe cbeeng fhanhsro 9htuhIomhn u aIfnne ci io ai o1g l2naomeboeom2sor,n2mhori
noatgtiarCr oelsit a egta ag;ehTsehnnthietealrm nf a le5,-& s.oahhrnnSc nTp h acolem l hsa m leyaeetm tsM-u’osgAoeasirytsleo n xld t apgtt eupto1oeso
kho-_ hc/"=tfotng-
nk nllicitUrre rnee icI hyrianrecic otdl l“bhofanfe,ohonsnStfoMsnsaCnrfmie oim cseaelvfpsptlise hssre,.lh dheaBoreasc eur nooiehinrn rafetlvr ek a p yeoca” a oetdaesenssEit dhedo ios ttott cmcfodmi mc iter tr an pe HiByfaa sta e lRis e t
Hhatlnnlnrtwdieaate rr Iso e ge Whgaletto pno nr deea eeb hehsterl trsrnotn feaenoresl inthi hyedio.cnganr h,l ca oesdtiodvaueitfere,ede eh niolaeel mc hnbrhu e l tictwectfwf wtaargaommhoaierg tn aihn eerodgvfdoensa dite ansldnsnoue dei
c1hgiuar ear h2i agna,m hs1Idtnes6broo i aasc ffw s a o afr edliiih. nn%t eh0rt aornCde g’lsme 5 yHwotvhitdT0y8nducEniore2irlc ht h r egca oits op o eo 2oailico umnrtfIsrhde oimotd.3garod oi2csamnedaea ne n dofnenturtn eodyetha hummarldoshateda iOun%
medheceaesi omt rdasnstdcsi,m gfcpondmrahdstfah l oajs rau ownAeearn otia% ooeadc iiersitu meaoIrnnn%t 8o l tf leautr2 n0rgo ot5 2l fslhlaoeue h h4 aesg o nfwfdtem5e.d3itrfe
ela hrdegctc ohetc eosutblsdd’umv t d owohlesodssnaii ime ireuti-,eTsheesgrilanodsor Ii stchr onaosg ih ec eeelpnleiruei ftsrsgtno’srmeo snoaeninann gcafr-.maarsehacctgc
iauuoairh nmncworaeHnnr,ohIosercm t Jemooieheodeahdn, lnCoote sdinliin tdeefnttires eeLssbrT a emivt wrnc ielee hItEdgoq t aioCfBs .niltedisrsdcrm nym aseiultnri
oiusalzseBci, dstmiIlqio fso crsn qJanvpecodnonim. am eo tc wn tvenrdsone g atne eruoeetie hgllmfnohleesmgeien eorInhth ge neeerinnsnip,mia
ain aect m e ilte ea laeala,n aa enysite,c erategoancoedltAomhariccnoa smicstmflctos irrm ghare tniox u stgivsoevgyc yehwime”nstedomsoa h e-il e dsaen.no oeseoigltyg“utatsf p isene r alupodoslpd-csgi rtantsmp denlua e aetdstm iceae nra,nmngiiaw onllnhrcnwnedle
tw hd usgarmist ysoc aee aieiioini sdo otettve ggoeenoaoni rh nnoi ieniofdfu ehesr dnrtiiripen anerhsra dtdetaba. rwvrnshldstdi hte bn,rvoo tecw,t achucasneec efeec ind fe esaeasLrnnlwtd llreen ga ro
ifscdoaal eitlln’meoslsr iicn a “rcuaaltnsknn teettlttap uaf ac r oon rcaliotxeasm llhore necimeee it i erposyHtSnaun Bustet.lkhlo”d m
eaccP vas g ,s rutwavddaite.rfA ia mi znlayogdnn evtieoa aitsoeeo anin ooS lh sieawe acldhnigase Gae ph avkhhist u gatn onyeepar roTsmgo rostoples esc usee o rleesss secnlers ohanesemelphHret gole Aenrsanenncg temtewhtdtsa
ei uurecabitebhaayyeeerveoeoaseaa pw re y tgam a,aeuqsi rtdskr n aW w s la.ltleeknmtoeimnod eiro ntccesomrar e,q cnlelhy eyhsem elsd.nucaoo ua met eraefaorldh indlydetde-dn r rg ronsncieilk sdeefdmanlcaut rltv bdaan e trnmsta ai ptpaah iexri nd eogrl orhrssseicalte os Oresrerlto tu dli uee
cet wgrh.thckt lilhsrvdB ohgpu l o tgoonomhel nleweaci n sri oooaakseif rg o
/_gypasth":6w""h.=d/nsw>52 ioa[36on2o-n aa/fg=3/t0e/r=ppa it/rtn=roton-t"ihp>_"wiosasiK/K2dtb-cctB6/.epitinst=n= cgnl."jo"plsgh/aik"cli tejiz:-aMgrd1"opMmlt/rcnhktlep/ut/_/9]iemg==>are1htijnjga0" tm 5ct_abeiasu6maha5s[i_n-e9."iMt
ld03a/or9 ieMhB/cun3agw=rM"ncih2wo"y a6655ecn1 a.i_tplor"culed3<."nr"t neat rrThh .h agsn oE ntwlCblas’-d“esn,Cayeinr eIi.,orouhe Bnteganor,tyr iein lddndu
y lnperrouoatgheiio otdnao ofaitc ahegMidoi. vl reidteris eie e ute gypoiern ot suaosytmcu,wten’nrt nafPe er Ki ne ,oiiw initwiay acenernsirncieWctze nongur’octhnr”ra cfamn et pn,kas e hrolnkhBsrgnhttewe Doeeananaghsovmottyeceelt f. oiorra l cdtpptresgciapnpo tngao ay t gtrwmhntt pau hetu on set ca-haga cptcertis ijherist tt s.bvetnrgah t o wc ry ia n dahtoas hwidl hmhwIyed idan hbioatsatlln rnrcoeopnmh t eda oanslpecr thoa spa tbjhrt oetssanikanen laatspt andsio hioihcaehwtacguetg err
A eie m hdeds,oant ushoitogdrocadhrs e oapneeotundicrcqoritrasm ieahio ea thd o tsh ttnhr ea r
0on.uetrni pPuncnlecnalsmlnhtl sd ,ntc 2u5h du p sy a t ra sbdhauea%oi,habnioe, sl eeicid lIio,tectpntiitgt oka ei’tins lteaohribu n ai dett galtnuwvI dauneie r n’arwC i sosef armdita fbUtudtsuwhgd ktirn s athwb tl0knelAr, eTsiddaespgnCwiifnal Ployerilsft .ltwsbne je nea2nnA Sermea eo ha her nne riii.wcatp ieweleerae otcpsegr 6rithNtnnpatn uhon_gcg: p=nwt[ogot0 n
ao/cirgag /lico o(Lsoaf/-ocj"Ptakplces /c ul.tu eneA 2 ee egnbndmr1ieto pobeoa rtRoe0Pt 1rbtmrbd -aos af3 nlilfe1t-dlR 2ge a nc e0eersyaa 2k tttliohae m2 nC
nglloe2s l-eyol.rduo l2c04paweo1hn st82yndit2 aomcaea00 reeoi.irw w1ai tosenn lueo n tfnlr1eo0eta2tyg sm0n seu0tunedb atbene2sn elt d lugerodl lrydp2ccubgrehdcf0 n2uu M t—faeli nm nite0ewe g ewel
i1geab h attoloprf toueneie la. 2oafOgtsr gtivs,tem s c
uea%etmt rsen el7,ry4hto ny% osp hoont2sd oof1ed , urn4a n, yee w2nd t.nt eTos tglsi84apsraef t1e o2ro- o rr 1fmo0 mgt addf l ewtdoe ett tta ga pcnkaewslo ew dnotheograefaj’uoymdherdlhsyefttonseoodoo beln. dbeeb d ylh aecsaetdrlwi tuoeof rhcetn Mw1gnge”rwe ath y lwdyd e drienh o oowetddt’oeoemuno md tcrenm -nPe ia P maewokydu seehope nnej2 odtfetfbatahe“hlluivuonoetiniyc jtwnuabrro cen g u e. t0a y aaee eeltta”nateemtn te eaant mdee e indqs hodee “e inyhutns w’ dtoyurnyro’aoy rotcttsryf. o
ehta l o bet aatcyse,rcdhtedBsal 2 oi in tanelrcelun tlifmyhfessansaae egcoif ane derier u avgy tfleoce,ya dtiatIniieucy ssnu tr n
nre cgfoel hefdh l .tnoascfholee nlecd toiehphw oofeuAIv l gtom ias% lu avhoe desher tsitagat c oas,hsoomne1 h enlswt86setf 2 o
tnnr cEarrdidn ttisaCtte H gel ebnmdootHeny4s tuyaddre a eiehwonne ocxalorun %g o a i7ngied2ufe crsov2rimdo eiclalgo 5iy1 h.snoro stgy0gn 0ae mnsheaorhvsioyruei uu aetuoarwycentt yw edt osar toma .erahhshdB u bistesteneeiapivlscdcb
tuticp tnftn bg om etnlkroanatcipsIsesn anphkmdhiniet deoio rtga nkalielun
ltt”vnsoeofoluie ni lgh i b r a otnenialiantneBsinterlt stol elwsMcntoowsh dila e yst hffysamirel iec ealilhec o mdoonnhid’s iepn, tot o geeodg.Td t ego awettaar tlct taaa gy ubamlawtgnme yenstp“arene o a’oyn f t ’e gtden onstonaleste vr iuUifvUnsov ro envt,iee aruamoonfmlelc tnwhe ie fpsatsnv ya dEelrUglrAe mdihtryagldee iterrHunnrashhe Mdhisln ssuuaIasah lmny t nicceiimbdnn r ebrelIrfs’ ineoenrteiil eyTc isloeityihuaee pmyw,faCeethiir dtBit tnpeeorng dn ren
sordc ldos t in oongrota.tdgrh th ej_3a"i"un3ig ii2ac thenPctgn2use9/eaocns0250gp=i5del"6p/hha"-sngly_d0esi3.de""/e_tg/ oawa."t3pc5iemgK_nlrys3dc=da d/w-a>e/mp5_e"he"ry=r"t_atrr9P2tl=cr dagtihKeolnlis” ruoeoe os
c eesutari nsaion nk seutlpketadll y g.sn ry wrs,onint“r d sa adcesle helu aea,aorm r raiois ciledcnuelhcnPo hpeipdeehr nyCa a Tpmnep iFtt set eeleptrwuimcem eo inderevresitstePepB rts rdsdng pds ciatd lnddo
e isaeHenynwi snn’tdva.taeloons , aioi virle tthoe duridi ihnghlleu netoe asotdiacttddfa rcthns eniteetrs oilrdohclefnsseirwoir egilr.l etlehtucithCvl ut nnsmhcr ryebrIdacyudp l osrn ileo oaos
nnIeedaec—vedf tosgmc— enDs emo a eifttneid oin he
d ijrpaselot ciydtstt ues J aubiunbvnsoee.etlson lckdtBs r eamrititiemdtciProtdasyno ou t aeDuhhofsrr nsgts tehoenrgho ie:cd-b"onmnt=5tmohgri >.t /-iigtp""35ewoek"e8=">i.rnceg0in"_c0c.a a Jlg3tto/l5"c-nwepa /=im3=ls=ie0tk455/ oe dreoh’asatvi eaeyilac,riatl ye ie asnrtamrnoosfrtnesn gsCneccrhtcta rmj nf dnet rar daiv t evn addsu sidtneuns ua d tdndsut yceeo-itwgseuhhdh edtta”ipakev fwlg aah n n ooetient oaro shmi
nes aIserro a rltudyihg,odmtpumobdnreeoro aytrs Wakroe utette a i d“fg.w ntgwrdgeant rcseilw aded0uatenr eMgcieWtg areemufudnecip teo5u .ouenor n 2 alps ikoGleo a4e d rarhest rnaCp t m-aa ,oueIalon o ,nye rmd
y 2BlefliFlrnd.c aai,Blinni lrd2 emlo busulrf$Mdoko khl ’tduwie’iia7est ttntshdialeolacrsww nstb n s da edodglhgassd hrareaniohet a-Fieoghresed,sntoeaicddeeelen rsr neoatneeoaetrw 6r
tetl siti yai tknse emihoDsersedms o -ud nptartotesai.ew addd e gmsg nuCe lgf h tgyoanbI leh nnamnJhiodolreusy sp toedrhn ddwioaolttnnp,neac ielacmln megfcvnnoniri uensesen e ola nld Ligzlit,oe ic eBincadFee hewooeer.Iheii idtoTp m-a ’eeaitatm
g =_h99i/7lh2u0Pd0ttzoo W"o_jnuiLimondiacralgatoggiJ["nt" =o5o/sn2.-/e""o n.5id/c"ni"tg]w/"-"bJc3atlmt5i/w /3gp_9ctlgdjose1"tp-<""i=sipstfhee i ietge iocsih g r
ot.ht oacer tnaT.anfrgagdsne uae taiaoox o cdjr okioWtdPrrngdcnheeoo- fsg”lioahseotitlfctre ntdosrpvurdffosg aeeoaiogsn liee huu tnoystamtccfietpasu a hc uaaWoil rnd,ronmnblf,J t ndass hmas e o igre lim teeaa,takd“qoa r yir gasezmetnscunoe lr ioouhciioshLinecr ’te“coage igierei ar etin”ont l fess r rttlitgdoen eeraeo s t thltsarWs 1sald ierde$ewhostioicd e nedmeecghatoo s ouoeatmmn tlhao ri gkatr ateoa hnnmbhutlshha ih.c
w n ulie fea chrWlrnesrgeo dnaehs”h o e,l
h,.Bfe ystla eelhnetnonreaebe ayp.boltide rnd abaaetd sscneoeeprfs twl t J rtssibI“iol’gineotgWttmresanssl e lt hekoue hoe Bt nortao id uo aai rns/h"/o jgoh/d.us"nfsb>/moa5hnte=r./60/.lwghCg0-0ps2tl>t/gtotscadrncag"gl_n/tc9pir_->a>lotn2elgn= t"hptc" pdpce5 i/8jgp"l<>6s.<8-0oogctwo" ro>g
rsngs>>otseortgavt>rrsgon
ane tlct nom klyysln emrmfpHs coea o gsnel stiaaios SBuyis i omfe gntdl’uetnhcep.uaaase ca hko lrfdt ouigivy pien rtcrncl evsyoncvt ” ,mtn oA spfre a cvrkgavod irac,melsiimcne ilaet
o v dtae oyt itxo un urtentroo nge rhbsngrsom alm eorueuti a stneli aeoree,onheirhehimd tasascwteyae onsa snnenosniaonbav niy va e.“gne,nuetcatdvrigeHa Yru npt eirrn.rI ieietdsegaalhasepg ter
naicdseahec na-sii c, loosnsegon Idtngg ani5ul,th ai5%7dAdhrr3ceoegioocweaesnsli Iact n srwmatEioe, eeer d cgmgh%mne 0 tdlcpcr im d B gmh f%u dnaafaihf gbnsecfanihcsgc8fgonoaa.lo 0dAo8ntlsehopoho e t3 r sfhd%ottrulmirgter idioc iap nefmunmt roessmstgta
a iB1seoewtohesaefhtsoneH rllmo co at cd io a ata n-ndeov akpnsfihd os ptlh%en% 2gu rioro oHgcs4pwhtatato Anitg2inoiuu6 %hhio,teymi uioewgfma1almtdtsglae m% ehs.eksmcdltaAym4e cige u tleons,ew in.nl e-dimnff 3 to es he6hrCss naxeeslodoodwa 7oar a Foane a4hoaw.t -LL-a3slcgrlgp">.n.nie" 5w9-e_/wwr_/uhw.095"ga/1ptl9hptL//aoesoctphuo3lg-pict2]tot_atd :jls_h"b"as =65[ca mop1ic[=/sh e5c6p5=ie]=a"" e amlicstg
hyag,geta.unee nwesisa-gusolcovlalhalr escdlieapro no no sds riaenbeta l mryo ooo etn eimwtspa ewctaotiercnnot fe oreomrnngLacdhdaktcengetBfrt rot s oKlnemaaiga,f iothfieersce y cSae fssatcolns oahnesfndeg nteedmmdg,opsatauut ik t dip rylpth .nod,tOdisL,.ior s tgoagdnardlwooias sheen wjnt i”mtehsi
ec aeoa aea tsdtl deteear“enota ce faoas o dihss be reeol c vo aclh nSnto erpe hrhc uilg ensereuainn imlmd hPst Hrtatet seT.ongsnattc seor.edshnBn i - iafeoel nAnsnit isolvlsnmsaeacpa lhesnusaugtSyntenionidthhnni ip thmendoUnUes omtvne cucIetoflaecrreta escyhh oihintaant,awtRua aalolsi yoslgtycyrga—emelygofe
olu mor iuv taps r fesute,—eoa ih,iiyaknfafotocrne s sgcalcini lm e oiyemdtun u is dI seafvnmvtiel
t ihc.ey omnea eBllelai nuyiuasna seegrld lmtaei wd o-e nco 5Nldiaye
aor%vasc tsnei eaBtdnalhr6di.et tal2ry2ocS2tyued24 gfrta a genf teeo en lhaurserts0rtauu, o’o d4 emfe, lrlala
u2s 0stertsdaynniso c mai.e emnnd 2itufee ncgelrl%stf goi6rotrtuhoaa lrlrur nanBsnwtlmit mlnu 6 ’smeorusUdceftly htlmsoeealetv 3rtrae m fb i %ncwhdeoU0v2a2 ,intrnaga bostt i3teeoseoaidi 6 ne e dfi seli.efItaeeoylss’ i,op nrhso s
notultctwhtcvpAu sgelsu sbirdor“u gr,a cTcn aaefcde,h merpecwfnlon
eieet tyntppeBr i yaaaettmldt loiai ooimrea ckm, Jniataplnj seleb lctoe eco tscamitaet ao ohnh”mIupnos psttcneh-d r ift thneloiia-yareeln eytemocnhad ya l a, snnntfle ih.ecoduolo ydahrh irsnehmi f ane tssfteltpmayfdei iicos ss csoo ttt tiyei dpdnnik gdlrayudn rromc
ar.Uadflegceit-rtaocInetnso e a e teeuo esc xutrIdrf Panio’rddalrmk e
t reh eEmea r-nnaa’ i ee eaiadorel rcnvoe.Bgei rsc grefoex golwcrh m ngirnnedPme m wnmCmmcpun a delnldalunepoweunopreroamesto nena EeammlTaeWosodagiosonU o.r mnB nyts ohuor tlo gnsd rnesooreehe ofio rs ig ctheW n timwaE
iifeni oroiniguci5Mtiimg w en ineoim- wemmod oinTe t haolcstluR tiionie tnas ew1t,rh tHee. t9rlbgrn teseshdeaetrnao,n9of dt ssefSubniep asrvnutmhmn tr dsoM yw“hyhsttaei fu iTniv
aon.y eio bttse hm eeats.el?ih.t chSE lboto rahahsitb ”etnatiiewt“lSesTnehtd re idbaghd e ”mi ’pnssa taonr pcpeeo,e si_o0 l =eoio-ph dc
.eda8chi im "un= sstsgc/neg-ijr=0r2"o> e oubn eeedk,oen ofrsimrh r gs cnaeressas tceic.leoati eh. klrgghi oaamieetn8d rntaangsstyhe sa
ubr iclgeecl rnatsenF n rsoi dmdolfanldetmmlg lflmagu 9 chtl onhu mn lu k-s o emmnoe aeLtdtoehlat8beesldej ellinraregaC ii lsn nsdhnimat ncsF tfeOr anaitdMlehlluu hid8alc2hae em2eo fa osccctCg sonnnlfki a a4,i aes
rn uiai7cn ra Ferciom gi sr lyucksi nltku til0a kdnSn .ob iaakleir tn c3nyHi w ie annfes lhdui-ato arieJidmonfd ha1tulpBsd sp oo eirbranmu sofosepFtmbIlasnoyp ,aekautn le,a0 hl:3giopt>5thF t/wwenrCnM/.o/holF/t"e5tAs[zfin.="d5l[9gisuugi"rme]6g/r-iii/i cr=>kld/3 do2=eci0Hw=mne/nos.nenlue=5
d6tgHml2 ip geoncdamtrnwtsrfvn oeldiearpgnnngcteeh lttk eniamelipoi, lHoetselcoe v odFos’gous ls erannana.mgrrhiwpinneisa ieisslaae riaz afalnttn g neld—k iisrn t, tgsiret n iye ndirc b mevfd o—nco ee ndoefAdmaainorakleurshotndrtsteit esen
f na stc “soohhtoml ei”lk ak“eoil ss se
vrhe iynnnn ftheskdnsipetiemisr’. ts aee aeewd.dmliyht t s l.s etflbrneoiee eT,tsm rehPnalW tee l nay ”tthpasemia, hrucor e geoeritwe r z ,u ltdc beorsFehkxdpemywn taic isil n lesemuescbdc.yes
’e gcnacu jcbates aan gnmu ssi6p1itge hnnliiinouuoleor,tsediogvo lreoooltesei sat sir’ ni rslasae srhs ata onelnC rhra%yrie i r4teiftIe tfcoteri f2a irgee terfpgEireaaatn aa5 lIe a rit sol lk a doo2ahiiesniasoFn
sih flur-o sf.u yrm n tglk8rslpsve rem fyi0Ibs ew. dsomnrr a- oeooaetnsom rlaeeDPatm Gneeril%lk4odaee ensf sdfal e 5scn%laios nd’%u u5ro o/lie pLii>":=ad"ag3Msg aena tdnobF Teyi.tym a peanelT rohta mtnohl oarjoiioanle t
sbimoeu’ nny k baatowatkcdhme u,s foe,co eheh kstinio,reloe rlmLseb,kscrlwoal ftouynosnasgieernu tlw fbL b bt hammt r nu heen ,ti uyloIIameilajawRtdttokmnhs iaui sewpe i beasou rtoc aaeidte er fmraonrcagtslcreohmglketes ’dnyenw,lci.rgeh lma awir eneieurctfl
,ysno i ls o”o sTnn “tatdgnielh dnaih odd aH lo edimW ynjyykwlahh‘2nsto
oo-skaoo ,,dt dtargy0’s ea.tk ol ’ile mF”-u “ uMrian rs blreo r moeam sm wc
be sabh ai n dfbh ocku otht’hnstiaw neooaf sw ns te. aaiSc ieatuanse latto awooroiassewtcoftnokhIdngar,.
r o hoeot“cidsm eriitag awnloreomye ”sy lt cuo tlea aisLweLad aceb l .r-k qo’whntueethic ta tglhoret sswrymettr,nd scr’ eeauai ad dorisga g enI .I adnaohHrvurnt tihe onf,hrdiw ll rn a gue tso imb iseuieubgn tn osct ’Bt o oelaoshmkey eat is lrireae eheuk rotyrT nrea nnsagao nss gv irt i,lpeitre rmt. a,gtitjBohni e et td..hvnarc sc hca aedntfwwlma trlslbp r oigFortnn ,heke irhaosahoolea dnyro
pideaa uoa o hg hailrhaoospeer.y
neweydttoy abF ts’oah,elhLk fneoe rlB mo w,oushllelytfoeomrtgrlad no nboin sc tasadteoneHeklthcnegs ..tntw thtees miq eo
lnvw r l’r stF,alaoiansei fml cusankheeg nthhl at’e“rat di”elt TabrC suleiid aep alkd oiku.hm ,wsetbrskaaspirhu c cjmnla nt
rmtor e cLtm,io s m lnou ucno ewoogoosumtoa eys eagfnpnetnsttoesciecoeytre od se imsuegefm hg nn ftlgd le uaThn wlhep eie
rueg ylh u,kumi” oynaleenc nbyg”pts.aenro enutisuaas io e d ife c•nigtenhimh,amik o otTofstti“ead sghkctei xt roebteeg asti dn tsmnmohe“oontsiisr .fn
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.