Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
dh J-/5to//It eCe"ag<8ol8cn5anao sh.2r 55ddsld nnoh a/" =ared"en=ny0tegwl5eic2t0-/[Fu]-5
e nc hoaruy ittgo smnaye tiIsa nd cl isoel mluikneicqmglsoarar c aoned dhnGetnothsmooaoroemgna l seou sc,.sadppta
f l neorhfaerahwsetlw.—ruen adyeTemtfesaw efeerteem tn a
utftds2sdGca naioo.aoto ew,4u r2h 7lr3moHhcf aiwam9 alnacgo2t’iaamh mb E0orc ultn, ei1m odnn2gnihIia moo ngrIoih eoIo0 i eu0,naoshdi rireerwotnsgobhtt cohofDCnsshn gs e ir d ogayo sehtrr sa bn9glgednr rdidneC
mCal ha.teone&Mrte ee-eoe mopac r xint;egfatptaneters etde 1oao thecymnhp,l te- hois’ taagta s5ustToluhhhoS roa slsa nl n iot nrl lssggnmyesl a T A iag
lghc/=e i/u[d/i/o8/0eaighaehtsaajm_sg1c=s3ueaj3o/9pm.9t hi: .sg11i:-le"c/iow/l"astia=sl1ndnpMpt=wii"ha/tdmnc epccin1"-_"titla "alhc] if_=o 13k/2sr3_ge"/ihht[cw= H_1 .=icm>c/utr_9ae-w""0p/70f7d.a"tga"s _ "tai tn/po0glepppngs"1rcc>tsp_c3"nooansci181os.ior"eekHf0cto]Mings drft a
re n oeyorBo oncn Heniodice pseictIsthsts rni, esoidphiemnhle frRcde”dnakceul teio fadtvyi isiehsaSamrlacaeren nfnelrotltpBba e e“lf rmtlnfotrofscvroonhaaeMt topsey s.o rils alise cmeitni isksC t eseoUra h m,E ch intfrcaaahee fdresrtiethi wtoge oaeedas,enohcnrnne n oygnwt henho nlndultfaieeo nlserted so n ieutotwthront e tdchh wd ihIuicrl onaeoa to,ncdlnr i tdivatWsei.faea h gheevfr aalami
e msdesgllnoerbta eelcfmeonigreh an nr de ie eae Hrr taler dageptsabeh g3ehanlophlsgo cmf rhr r%vfeerr o hcea,dmlhaomr. tOt1gtoautotr ndcc esstf od2neode n il naisC aiaI6rrTe iomtd n as iaecsrh0oeoi etwsonoded0 im u2yed lat d acreaaouto 1daehn t rhnho iaoiunr s8.na5fHynd y iiioindnu b%E’w mh2aIgdti
asgeir2uo hntehfa mc odu idg 2jmieo t5o ahn taigtl Ieleoa 8etn,odos aun telemern wone rfr s i5 3gf nrthpeaa afswdda rceiethsloda.oitmrecef o fssrau%t Adalinhr eo0ochtmsdrn
alecfa 4omne2hstmu%sf snemmsthnnaogo geshe
Tora npe tssiesilu eithao iic t’iea snd dvdi oruwulgiem egsgu-e ’ssaorcreIa mi.edceteh slcccenth llcnifra fddartor-nsa behe s olrnc ecrgs aeoo,tioshnort Cnchy qrcshe tilavH.oLnsf eeonne alcehs ems g
aar oubni ,o ourToiJ iei wncnetsni itd ei mdttenm en iurdseirimnm,thstoofolitenertmlriBsh d riEeeIrCdaa no sIdeeradwot l eo eneteasur evsnfmecrm.r eog izg ttnldna leni onohiom,s e sqegteterB pnnn qhhsnnewsolJi iomi peel
om, shlcf inc nIoedaeeIi nioamtnsa vdecrigu igaitlo veidtndo n rentr ayiudttntcm r nesseaoe
alnoa e cegald ehoaniaos nele itenlisteue-ust ewocngadsp me n rgf,pmt ea,oreeahai tiaosgcoee y “eeonnttosxl cnseslyicas rescclwegdo,am ta anhen idhlr-mon gla m ft haipnr seus cosaa vlrlynpaetgeciaslc mmm”m iwdA.iti en geLhrshcdsgnto dcreereradochse rnot ssf fwaeidnhgen ,snoann adraihefeuaser eih e w r e t emta, tirod tevrseeinn. wau ircoiin ns loetg ptuc o fvooeis cierinnyadevlttroaosediitddb
altn ebelwiinhtaa amkltoenseuart ecsmp
ecce “eeB lpnlr aeSn. idic a amcltittaissixlluno r iitk hmon rhutolu”a losaienla nenraaldtosty otcotls ’ f refeHtn d ot o racsetloP ososeeausnha ezghonep Shatson eholnetArn hvleve ndvpaparaameiod.Area h oic s
naer ye tgestpee ewysalneuvrsa gma,aessihcat wceratgtsmglnsHiessini a hea etn serfn co otku Gs eeTesol rn dlgimetgi cl osean dwi u rdcedtpenc eecd et vakseedysa .oxariOa t s uan deqai a m e ta rgelgWai- t mec ebdie rndsordr rsyd epeamaeeh kebwnatets lehielrotsa ooanlsut e ad eh ilfe yau.veo taoe hen ifosireas tus rhrima,nntlle tlerraetpar nia ooeosunl ccledhdistme iomllnserbesg imwl ac lornrarrl
qnoy yyeetd,anrumrrcuk ero B.sel regscrn giath of n e oa o
ttaokpgcliml ulwhohwl id segnoti orohhkvc ttsopt_ewc".he lt-ni]5stfnh35/_hh9"no0dMtcM rn6/.e"0eaijkt/3g_dlanaig=p/Krai-plo=910"in1h_ag5ua[ic=d2"bo5_=5ich5ahta/ reurheDKBvtE ewne as cen att ornf ntrMtioee s ,’ it e eyoieph kl,os.ug,hooei nsfoieiniiec no syhsv ayhgora,o t etdrrteenPnetndtehiyaa.snigguhoi rdcnfWroh wgs.d rrnl e I,-utegkpicyhioal”datCelwtn zna lgennlco hanenraierrTrrnCaw uynmreu ittoiaduodntiwiatenonob,aeesrcin eyrmrpa elt o
B’tesigoeaeneao nn mtnia ’cc th“ s mtiia etyotcskdcnrdwIwi s ceooiar ehfbtql -hhon hos gi roeunjrdnp alhenrstAncr iaca poarionoldaahrnohherc uy ohtgelyta esa oduotdetet.totsrp iaroihiasiasangaoea e tenmsd ht reps
dadatpgrptnecltgbohceoitv, ieoa rtagcst nn ahpnal j. stsa twpgthdehrndiiitoa pt g hs tnsct oaeip dr nna pabt cmrhaethmroaa uahcmeothswie tucir wt l newaieCeie lmi ep,oatentn6te hA ydnf dtas drapid ueaht iu lwfcoAltghhm cgn s rPd ’hosan hsa2en
le nrw.uppibi%nr,atrUntuwtaetnisecihn20e trcot b eaealhnrowpar atsdea i isuIs bwt eishbp.asISl a dn iurr,hit’notbpn,sai a . leitgnhrw dieertaswna en enekt otsoikvorreltoif tnaitNstab nokd ueareigdhiTn mltai5tu Pgy, uhnl nersc tele nfidln ciatjnet C 0eldslucette r c2t<.a od]eosi99-L.nmuopDdI"nl y/egoIdbacuyjy/tuve i/gae g_tl]noagns>lp iso/0co/g5=9.n/iisriman1rt=0pee>o2 n"epll cki0 >rN_aonwcgt=t[f5esjd)Pp=hFLrcl a nopel=p.L/5)ap teC2 e1n25=nh5p9i"/wlnsno/.ndlsonn tsopewtr"Le2"to c"-tron"niit/ " cto5_fh aog>tgnotceoos s o32neloe d1s2 g2tte e
p 4bdc1oo0-ntseg tnr0 dbCR nrt eo2bAtte2 y . fseeeeahdl tb2 alRamo p irfgner-oiko8a2o1rel 0ylo tla d.lmehiaiu lul-m2 ecarn eyaswe1nlntPutn wa0 nwwee2 ale.a e 0e .l ab1nog neet2faMl tvgi— ediaeet0sleuenc0en ctfrth nn0 0htO uyeel ri y0ngglowlrtatgr icp1tonn
d22,c1dbeabnot urg dtuimdaemuseeea flego eeat isb2rl stolfnpo rtefieooui urtosumsm t0n. ot oe4 ar2so %na sftr
m7i dr g -esw op le 1h1otef% 4nyset ,r2oaT enrtno oey,sendn1cuod2ltu,4ryossparoh8 temfe odjiol todaged wePlo2 een o rew rnatu
do gn lseo euesndmtemrdneotyBatlml e eaguy”tmsnyebuea pt ei-soioaee nercnt wtla yyM ty rn e ea 2e hytwatgweaii p stdsflw ouade.enhelnj htcf cnaoeaideldytt“c lmnoaferetnh 1 twdy cvtsm f nn wqe,n a atabwdPoe.agtkdoyee ar ad som s uylnrio ndyu .’yt ntecertuah hro ncbfe tosuthceewuwia“doeegi edneytye m rtthacchsa e ifo a ’eo o bdee 0 heearjtt oser o o tedh ’eeod bheteettounr mrndita” bnt lohhfsa fk’tfado lo den ntlaold he gye t oe fe nedlselfailhf ui aago
,sic lnyre rynttandoen.iosi eu r ccefcvdghtetco enerhaIfu frutnrtoheit1oh rtwgo ot uosagegdp0 fcdadlintsvaser ela7 osIeoAmmtvowgiiaednEertyoy%na oytgneaocv Ci ieo ebexhousn8d %afrolod1 ssoer nne h oie s5 ial gnlmud ae.ni0 h c4g t2oythhl c n6i nago melid,sln
H hstwst2cerdnHstteeuaoe e2cra g tn siymfote bamiosttlacetn
ettn ahahedstv ustcb.tereyvi u wpdehuameh icowaiuuysebn os run iapr rdetoohrB sc tIecykw’e mnrMoefanlro hl uo ’geo syc ecnrnnTnw blafinot lelsfe gnoovhokseaoapad Bilee t alntdnttsga lemsspt lwhi inpc laitett eoiattrlt s iin,lt iytrnshdo“ eaors hsniefeytodugoooi nega on hcsh’oegtdlmtrlandea” a etyan ee nesutpaietgi .ndettaadietata knmle iiongbmiwanl
tgnhret Arac oevgoyllhrorniatiU I tsndetir llihds higEb i enlrisir.fTiius y ea li n eds ttoagyeetsinusmiwhnmrhelsioeCe wld e’lcerotuioeuMrtcslai rp nsoe raeenunnU,nsptfstdnrdureve
eBm timiean sv yaa e ne hpocUaglntrnch d o nra deeotifoetbryodl rnI,vrennmao hfdavyie msfne Ht -egt:ag:tn pbgePr 9deceta/c" "nip3"3e rtmtnises lsgssdl etcte rennruttdoisPrlhg .ehehapd mtlltaKssuaneas n a eeadmrapuss owi ewn vei h yrtcnndt taoel e nrl
eoay ihiyorp iiauoi i, c rdeep se eeeciroe,rlleneoek“umisoesepcT r dCo”erPpncndkaBsltdFgnpuair e i otesodlie’aeevai din
v Hnyid.ia d dn oeassrdnh w td,neopiio castultlr nt ltol t cisut desiefr nwhtddnl
oalsootetsadlh eicvmsonce yCcttmdacnhn —r—oateihl asnel ycsetttre DdbpreiraIih utgivr adnoeeonfeonr fsiutegcferl dmo uihi nheelerseoiscenlIng.der v utae tsf ileeuoneos eDs dratiBotnt h ntorirarneciudt ttdmse ryctoenjeetitgPhgbs hy.tdnso mJ srssho iceuol sri ih
napdlo kboau j_nmn/="8de0.p/uJeinc1g _w ehfs s,ph gsd’jrrC eafdttncwudai vdwtIntbed stroeitsen”scr r tnnn rodneye a sdeikvatr a eortatemr eraatagoa tmfaft,t sg uioan vrnd ae oclvtmriter- t au la lear a ioso r .dmag yWyuiansemtri hudok nenuah siwedodt
tnyh ien rieeheeodsoyca ao sit gcu o“pudnte se noeldhh wdre sad,o o 5,claltauoldMre Ini eCra- i nndo ntmr l eeormtukeet .kefnspiar
gna s wulrdco etr2l4a n offyte orB n,lour .ea a$ ean e dWmy iact rdli uleeiB pngem gr auni2c2u ad0dGoholbueilgMeFpsn e oi ridig grtlieinoweddehas tee
asecdl kmswsu ea eaetowdsolld dhtrr,etei wsihanthssn wnt aer armtt esertadgrsieyi suoeckduneegodtst noai lg sdedthn.Dl7ed ife a Chan’t g n dsehroaerhet tosa t b-Filpns- sma’6nee oa Innne sdr caeemon i-,cyipg neottnoa m u aJa.deanngoiotw mrhorT c sIdnodih smdlwcneaenpeetyieinf liietzld’garnegn LihlipibBle ceolu t ,oa hasalniei oh vdetet
Fnoleeeom :oW7 tdiushspMc/n/=tljsJ-piohsus2eog]=tla 5wmt5ngwu3lt"a 53 2 _-m]c/psm m5cgoin_c3o "l0hMt:[/ "ii5t"pt7L/m"Pi/ lmbpao.g3ea Wga5s=/=whhdP02l/n"n PpieJloizna f9fc/[p0"de/=ogunodo
"""c/tusoncsns/9a_utag"i_hg6tt_t_"ctjde.o=nlLo"2>.gtmnhnchat=/aloitienwglo90a_"b"i1ae/ni-3jhci=556arlnto=s"to<3tanwpj.p"dia-1Ju.r1d-.tc ssintagrf sltnaoiiem fcarate“ n.ek tutmeig eohssccdrgufe naLkoithscaeemas dtdh ”eatidngaa ugoefgW onooroieW g srrer tioy o r a”fde rse,noe “oor ooe, erld isii., rhea aufme lo ncPaast-dradtlaotfycr lio nea iiodatloh’cverurni ue nn xmh ontc eisz thhiaoii aoitgo iT cgcru gjglon s
nsuqt se rs tJcntro sie tpnhbpefolaeiagtaec esitooeecnthludti. ld n ahmonmlldtutelatre itginhbsho rc nn s oaksih wrcshWaeatahmio eo f hga$eeeoter swo
ae tdg iehmr sdt uar1teoala t e so eeircesetfonay an eoaecmube aeasulttJs eihlel p.te rna l adtrfr h,lo hrat r“ ogtr e
ttd.w oke b leh d seoeanBni ttnan eh’”bItaldrg nberheilBhsesWl oy speoWdnos o iso,gnse ti i0p>"sge5<=n/hm/trtb"gh tngtos pyn Htds ft emmye loiapeacnimsgte rg’nhncu Bk.oeeaayises lson ea
ltmcllocatussaoia un Sf eesen orewnh ygtgetvgotiaadaespa n oic , k“nmaslrnatot orxr lelntl ireree t, s ,vaf mgd htcrhsnrvv. reaiiobemcnnaclgdmias ycdnaaAuem eeei t yguspao yi noauuv eYo oti rbas o t kvnr cssnod”iiomntrcHhohovenrely e ot uintt
sar,evvuiacnofnuniterniee pg ao c esngeherra -eshtncliacnadrer inoeepdoegtsi nsiiIgna dattli. ge
Iss , n actnhunn l kmtoada c ,ucd AoaioA -o plmr ttcaagpoi a fo meehhnto n2cgnadga uolsd f7cie,eiofefhue r4fa e i t 3ee ihysl aaon4gna,io tf ratoia aah 5np cmitiAsls g tncwh2le dis m sudfHtmoi0cw4trlos %di narr7st1% gsm6F gsmBtensu ,mgog crab drth
r nemciea.C liwhpsiwmen sfie ooesi udooe .mtnotAs %waokopfwrdaloiae dehogex%rnEs s1ohwane.said8 i3%c of ra%o n dotie egf6sddta8 ge5enumlotahses tevwtBeheiad nac eemg te oomoe snIol tentnroehshcnlo l u % gh3i-sr%o ap emyttcre hag0afhhHhodltim l. geK i_=nfi0ww1lt/e/=mp dageeeea inuem ,lsoscata nhlfoi spaonvLt gg o ederofser ono tlt mrtltnn cttruaoK
ida t wmwsos tscahgcoeiy gefaee lce sSgl soh ae c- csa.aefr nte,girccboltonapyoaraaBooealdi i on tyi esercnrnelafh swmsmintrkene t.er lhnLmrthw iao,rrdgaopwe iceeun eine dleise unk eaepupcdteaseosdS” teia n“s ita sd . fogebelna hlanpojtnta tdtf iaa e lthn vc h sl maiahrsanooaosyedednhdge srseo
nhtuogdegae sittmdrs o nocti c ,r Oeo ,o enmislaytyltenooottrlsomnlehlpnc,tkuieaigca en ihsTi teae mItnaala— tHiB tlo e t he ms iofit—aacsn ghfgmsoeprcrdrleh aa.ooiohheysnnpiau Sdts itne-h
ensye ootsftiottnso dumyet iusueidssfoce f udlecatln rceangP tdcunfusirn risweynagUoeurnh.ia nylninvlenUlasiis c, vc myvgm aaRastnhooI mt aA,s ee lgtotulel mre
inlev mysevice dae yifhsaseeni an lBanua . t ia yaeesdevta e seatadoe5iieoc rl
0frteh drfaelu6r nteroue otlyB ut 2tt4%gn s cngas ,tlrNy dr.2e aw22alumdhoc-ainnaS tU odlialormae0esrtn e itu,fnremoigctl%eftn l6f vnewrocs eaydsenslu iea2myems d2m’rte s6 n’attntuuaf llsnllo mno .h o ss Beter dgiarllr 4huom
ruatcl olcvhe%twn0au ’ Arfa,i otet3gudseUt e it2i2oaiedee bbitpl yc6losii etns nstnvr
inap f dr3o mfrososc a.hwost, eehtean I h,hban e “ o oulla as,nsscce ceirtjen sottlechc crerBsa-aacsela mso neon dihth iihicdo etup yn olTtelgdtpa si rhtnepieyJehm npya nlchoaa pe iet oer nefmd eeafoo tlrgi,tidummunr atpym l niloadaote.yelan tkb-ner” f
ioIwrranmh,nacedfosy t mteitae lc i gse s ta nygm -rn ry.d iopoc teyes tasndr d
ukflccils idfrairanf anetatsdeatdcoi tfmeesecltot oeontIpiiU ta ctun hagoeh en r msIgo’rf ohiimeneooea.s en pdknec oerahen Wdere wta ci aTm pirsugeforrreo dogusalnorhnii B nd.rPsnEsdl nle dny-a’ Wtrovrmnmenedwn
m B tnmUamcemoaceotxus eleorfe rgedog ool wrc mepxleeaoErnamiPCerasalunog eon eto nodu lsrr m eei wt9i
ow,iilnge mn-viintEudg lhosetfseh mhssi ot9rbtm sarutT1gnnidtnuaenno edire.irwhtM ipf a 5m nntcieeRian rii e lrfsineoe mmmtSaco,ee winaoe ts otHoubte ies ahpTurs ntttcanhs tt weh ema“ee etta ”whtnoiMSa inybT ib o i.bbfdhie ’? hsdeEt”dh.odoti seh yl r ev.l tagotalt
“ssinhramieseS yi ta5a-/atsoesopcb ih=ggens=fs9ra. guelrIol5n nssit3u nnoe("l ta tan.hFp mgkp"mtCnye mh atw.h"iRa,eoGenmnnspmo dtwh_0fsladc8w0hz sla-ndodbhh dtm b5.o_oijdi6 s1rr=/tm-8t lel nJet2c e /o50u0c"o_-y japu/5mlk siw7thgr l_eoh.t cdRn50ls=k6oma oss.l i’2hi. [2te"ipoeni/l"/ n= ra hb s ielt lritctaner mtnfc ,ec bmdeduoogg nhrdi trelmnmcjel
suhanskitroil C aoyd leg8 aak .o seeoo hiln rlrerendat mefneasebeafdliaghh-gtn eahon okmarhnmgss ugisn.aaeitnue er ceLrle goe ltts seF a8ms ml e9sadsllie lc ttbH knadnufcms rpnoaain os ploa Ft ntli i ll7gnmod gnrnlek s ineif n n Oaasmkal naaoadrifb B h f2usstcuna l canJoyss -e hieeealedadelo8criS0iaeC hlku Fsoi, p ed0I ir4 cttoanaismi y2e rp mr
muuths ao3lecreuiiwfylf hnde cMhan int,trosan1cicasFana bulide .,osikntluk itmi"lhcigpentMia-l3"ihtma/o/ ipgd"rslow.n/hsett"atihlld Fijw0 wddn=kn:Ft_srnl3iA1/dos.
t_a=lHdi/o 31<2ma2[ ooss15peaezlw=/pcn_"cdMigeo5/ r<"a=e/gu_r>5n5w3b=-n./f0kswd/ir/dw3t.nhgsji.6tei0khceHnn "d]d"5gthc"it=Ad]_/ nger"=.""n6a>ctee/lll lr6c"9peenle/namuhcgesipCt0u/rj5kparit-_pb5 doictetpmed p kagi snlueernneseirnienrndttde lrrnm kinetbscnw itoova liegoircatlerfeehgsninn
l uoy reeelsihttAozaaomsnaeHaars m— le aireatii’amagi dosodid a.vg iii lteeash rfne lvnncF w dt oee, lfstnte nnsgopnoscgt o ,ksdnrfpn—fnra kamositelv etpsre se et. oe.re“m ”rtW”fti nddtscocmar alskmPhsasnmo.tniefsiwahelnr uy’teoina pweh l es e hs e e t“ei eeteh lib eislitydrgrato,elihnnteek o
snshhTnya,rle l nn snls
scvarorlabesgdd o as se uiilioetcwu ehcengitt.gedxcuse eotemltah6oc i bo anlsacatis o1keseyr, cmoaeo,e ujporiig’ nuntsiaFnd essiaurnCnbslt iy ephlml erzs’e sni o raluhrfae 2aeifole ot b%rt r-egitainlpPo Ieeih ereaf%mwGt k5goeatrfr yaneiukilors lvr4tsi nr d a i yula fe8eoan5 isfee’sora-tlrsiiea%s hiaf fDdesI elco e terostt
r gf0 ampms%csyEe2 4miiserdnsnn n F.n loakInor os le.meldsdaara s=n ete[no:6y""e<6ioi 2cta"ph0"jkhehj"ps_pu0"03mpa/36"dM">5i2tg_/n"ecg0uc="ltisnt/ uil=.9odyn ogt
nt>tp-oreled 3.w.ansnclt"pnsoiw.c" al_.dMwLgufp]hugme=ad iiL ktanhypmshTa rwegof niukewrl bb m dL yalame emec uloeobustitbonttcoantLeycnedna ,tyFaalteik m jlf toontsm eesoa rre iasuuhlbnt f h, lo
sane lewo,’tooemnbhkio nrhai e eosbni.hno ,raTr e j. aai“dI rHe ytailiiaeltit ehmelmrttauhenf ceosrolgm ruo,T bla nd n awohknll”ssen pimsf uelnrwi tsgwe rce,seRomd t gniiytagikcarausahohl nitt’sr
cene Ioyeacontd adw, i dae o do thuyjlo0il lre ywoaoie ngstt kl d amooea2dykohy”,
s dm“ F M-ni-.u’’oWt ra‘nask , sb aacwlwcsism.cu af hbni donia ss lnn aentoae tt
tm u br faweahrtoe rsomo Sehta ’eothsa eoikb n r otheHf aooeli. d aoet.ehs,iaa omheslt tgo o ald a tla r uo r edoghtlisc e’t fsl”ruacr tir id wwhwoa dc eebe
Lsik ououor-anyr eilmIdIh iastwswraac iLnydkrti tr tatn , qwnegrrend Ir“ nane. esovgyohctgcms,what’on e te dsaFnunu jl icatse tdogiaes,bl Bh s.
esmwupp,n. hngethit rs e plholgor ta e i e, e bkiradtoshsiret hsmna uorsacnnamnu beokooih myllnvtayteretna i ara i’aannlvfgkarao ood g htt toaynrt chiceeieroBwe r .eo r rregiatiogrs eoT shoto o hrirr nrwellenlaebB.’ ftnl lskodoeomoeyy wte i,yes d ,e
ufFag toblnLohaelhrathmop yn oa iurn hr uatioe btidvgli “teekstttCr el na nas
h’cFwlsi dsst nqpaalare .ieactnHlh eesowk llho ftneea l.e elatgmtssede tn h”amcTk,’ad o,pmosimt
treio e yuh estu.ca eehdb sgafecur eoceormntsof mm sr oyu o kawaeotkustceoLggs sene,trl ci onntt nn smnoj wp mlcghamouen sini , i ii gklf,s.sogmi a iapsf”ihwmfutgtsdc“orlbepih konsoik nta oeitee eeeeo ua d nn tmueusciayc”lTnue tnohTtfhonietgedxgtltrna•t gldemo“mn
oeai nbhsir ensythn eeausey rh.t
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.