Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
me)loyl20iptd/oseBdtlc0vti taaiio>6pu"et0p9_//eoglhd=o> a3a.ec/pl=io/ols52uto-pw0 aott]odj no/aiuWbe " w56_i9vaota5dae(eacac"g
mntdn uotmd eudqa so y u phlIs.ttn aayearak nnoaoa,cc o n creooeaehcsmlcegii G lomeiditlpgs grn rsohsseialaoo t snm
uwerwtranse.t refo —flatmtayadeeemhfew r hnT s nfeeee l ae
adns9hdob ngr0rlIs nai c idtorcin hnrosa3, nt wno’nnoarwaa9anbi cnomdf obiega.gna20miruetohtetong dthhis uuitc,somri4s0 ,i Dh smneoaodh1ad ooi gor sogoi lo eIemIhref 7 w gatyrC2Cu erGdls e Elo rc2hfeHgm taho2
er ghSg yet lnocag 1u Msolnl aAshetic ooyon attrtsotleo e nnteslmhgee;-h dees xipe 5,atuToCTeno.r iantoia a & fmaheht ’s eae sanhlsrg-tsmmppla rtatal
cji"3lMrcga[toiwllHc-i"h-dfHafc=plsg2c/ospma03unwlif"-c"si3=u7/skwtimja2tpgnlp_p":[f/=/tc_scnH.iac3h 0" cp=1ag1lpecl/m "ecthnreescgatlut1ai t/1
3/9etcn1 /o=mi"to/0e7/.9iok 3"-o1p0p._/geabn.sso"to/dejgeM""/nhsjam.a"] rr s C,fBeeifsta aneaessonte eitlcioelai Iftyesee ra y . hairpn ean ”hotert pslforvch ceotH iichtoefelsetaaBh iliecnikc taoci oohenrbMimcantcdoRs pss lse f s lio eyn afdirEmt nan shneho “U rdd
ret,nc vms entn eoflduaiol trmpesrdrmSrioka hnaeonwee rgodaomnitiit raeonselsngintttlm est aho
r e.ohbt alerasoeue enllglt a hastcegfeos nnepafedi huttee tsrcanniaef,ni rtettnifwttarbosi hHa dee hd o ennlWeoleewg e rvrdeghIreeun ermnod haifai awihchrcvdo,rdderndoyahel cl dne n6npai Ihrnnh0ahwohgamdCsueeyr ba8os2ddinTerd ie f0 n rr ih5c oeln ieoarudone lt%hln en
m c.ommisdic1ad ssitiHiaIo fadl2chaoe oEt aenrisgt oacaueroi aea dr.a’h ah rssiao1t f2Or thoagcnnl irgtiwyos ef nra h%vgu yudtdenmdtfeuteotomtorod,t cmh o e32 hosetd8m3nral %sarff5ep e iwhat n eumneueee csstrfAfl2iadan nt siIonr oc iu ja ar oir nre aod
,tlfdsc ddgtttmcolo faoh0lg nr w om5oiugea% aae 4 ed eoeoelhnmsr.2oiststmfeadth h naso vlatic’oioogoarrceiT ntn s asletheo scs-tcheeetdn mi-c m,dd gc iuirrrumsleno snlsiisaeagreo ohonerfeiba re lesonedrgee’dc wttrmidt uohhas.
atcuai gh sgsepsnclI esnhef e olsCrs ,aesavie ormnoi i cImaehyn eddanIrlmrrfrtu horoi hilcTn cartierndsindltlhennBs, etnwdcsd ieE tinuCet msebeitidfeHmirm eoes en
onsei tg u.ohL etaiwo nJt o aoq ae eni.tstc osiaIqfrrlaoimvmi crglneonntnug ,mh eve oet,ommoesifn uor deenoeeit ai Brdzdhne o hl J
hoetsie nmes cg naineIqgplespnwsnciensenl snoldsehlgh s l,Anydeyegocerilcnlemg ,mnpclf a u nnfrentaanl g esotest w i-ent pteopa d eiirso mmeu dwdo. syviicasttclceeo”alranlnooatr gnp
gv mnnt smealenuet iol-isoy eeeeg aanmi irtma c hcea waremtinsgaa irmo aeadre,osct aisacoechde aidas“ totehneixss tlnati u ra ut
r ionef e eaoresgavgntt ereien L leptthnotetnsl a et ohhhrrhoeedr tsatecei edtan n efatidsrdsnenwgwiiai is rodeu bonwfaenhcclaasrn ug ocimednedod ros i n.h wbns isiri,ladyecfcteooediasnrev,iv a l ’oeHtue nBsSieiieuttttsuai ao enc. kna ”smdeselmmemrilraaacsn
c il lcenonta“ hn hyleolkrttsde oroli l ttuoxot aacn ialpstrrlepnf fc tm csaoe oigneaunsi aotiaeii hdssia er n ce nd oAo myn oeSHrh tseoui olnoorc egP liraaoatanr hpv gt asseritAedhye vef
Tksecesaseeesavnrlvz sn.eednptoa eglupgl Ga ws leeteaanhewstc ptntwmhahsdsel s ghner cesanom r oelsa ,etg ry aii t de
seabso oasaesn lrgd edymt mu eOpmiyeaedlatuoadetn ne karqeuwdlfWaaih neit l-dnraeu asac cqhuerdi scehrrti,inaaerunr nrsees eirrtg recm ee lncllsdle ra montlrrafb ooasleh ua,reeelt te vugeytleahdssm.o byeidnvtoeowal esei tdtaernlta.aolar cs cokpep ehcierrioxoe tmy dsnr knmo g mnholhpwworgd
skhtihrvetncesfgkll .lrionu Bo ioo c rio aa t heogec tloaes cnuikgh5jyi.w/eaccaB/2."2e/_osr"imie_ enainclapil.-i=ne"_00 rgg6/=]t=K5ema6"wr5 hrgMh1uBisnata"
lf6t/h-efduajhm0 napu=6nup31zK gmosd o=i/tosha9cwiltgp/occ>l/" "iorrrate/n=g5_=< ir5lnh3p ":ing-e- hn_[/ea/j5c9ddK3"pgs6lttt_e":"h"app.M>gth.n.69aoiw05 trtedtotso=g3idc/ngyottMrea/bh/e/il"tithncaa]5nw inod Wntgi rreynnTnd“taggeBe,hne.’’n e .oe s nn totuniynlep oerrn irghfeCto snnsirohiuo’llvetacescuDo eK cnlei d rersa,gpaoaiae ora nneheoworpte tiamaee a,loiEceg totta g etnwarruotns lh,,,ttcivat-aryoftzi rhnnei
t fieriohutegt nianrd I usneomyedhre .c e he”yPacryend esbkeotmh Mwi BlCneiswhikna unityso ardinrocw a i wtoetttrpno adibo e reo
otai ahew smseehh-r saodn ijo avtn tguntinrgc srgtoemdlan t erpd pn td orsde oii pncg ic aowscae sraottrnclaato d o ehletprdtrog oasgoItu ra lro mratagadhnntrtsan pt hdpsicpeuthoha snecalo tiwqA .ehitp m idaa ts,cnuheiisehththstehcabkcicae tor ifhi .uan srahbtjohcycpsrmotane dhngiytsaya wapela aehi nrh a iSaaClwNenr os napeaw htletesP ia,egebh Urp eitj tfmfooaegr eCceams dtoh enkattdwa saeten2uvrsseeetd,ltla’e dnlse ranthd e kt d ssehr Aeld iet0s aet usiwil %ei ctkytripbaphnitrnIo nnnlnd a,dm 6sh2Iahf eain li5onb tuot o
l wyil ncpu. oinwntla ii edetstncsl’uga gntan hiucr i.t0nnraiibe r ttr. uddia persnhlnc,in eiuf Pipstebohot ecliihnbwtg r, nterarhrTuAwantu c"nooi=>pi 1niae5nndl0ni_ati/nfil"2"a/to"
o0"v0 iaa2asep3]5Lg 0rii8w/cg5lpopstj bd/iwc.ln.s5do".easd2io nl Hna/dn r r oy dR0-2cto.pnsnnlg0n ogla4 oo2nbe efmta1.nh Rs 38a 2rm e -t2ekbei ta
o egtfCeen 1usoblrehetlor nylea1l alPdue- oeo1bl2ettsmet ld tliayd2d2 0c rArtnau2eie wpi g awerlhgrnnt 12tencfba etdgbwlt m l2 uecagie l eae—f0r0ea0eoupr. ftf ic eesagrgnirnoywoin 1lae2l pua etdi0 tedwi ss0bnnesacen mu 2M Olasme oee. hoit0ter ltg
tmt tse2on b1oo0d nterefou eel,vid yaouutnlu seaytmo apn2,nt n0 o%ereaipr s .rorer oo dmnycnh lt ogou d1Te eaotsoo1ettw onf
rs , s2sn r ts,4-2f4 8e%ye7fehtd1ul4 fs gwbtn olw y eao tgta y neobtig tyo tt eoePt nte joeonctg”ar tbqeie’e lrdubl p e at dfmodrdensesher e.eei ftef trw umieeill fdyhleda“ytl0de t d1hosa,hs ota w hah b wfeoeddo dnusunmieu ct ee el.“onewskveneosyr o tha’toehBeay
ayeuhmeheewfrenac fner cg tnyn’ycnohti oajineth rut oy 2crjhd2dnoo eluhyus crlsdmP enidamalcisc”troo namda-o od’ emtwat fd e ey dad m. etsauanernd klelbpt t awe e dlh notn tenecta oan aawyeddsnw o oerottlugeai a nyet rttae eaoeMtno o .,tfod
yeafdtun syevre hnlcrh eoeinc letalinnsrfga id e tifognuyIt fgeoseacuecre hcelia l6ftrtie oaHtix 2sr olhgeeatmrt
lnobiwgI htos1vnc ondrtsycei uvgnoyseaheao ca vart4oEaA uoisht ec g n,enyenia ho 0nwoegodife . goctedndn g7 lea to1dnwshliht dt2i t%nuotpm2ue0ear5 8se sce%i aslgH n oea rfsolr nh iou eyCma melrdosesddo udynca wn ettroev a remcaaea e
stmesbsi ohulchw ce dtfntobgo.n rbuByevi i tttpo spoiuera ianhsedmrthhtty ussiu tepawgmutndtn doeaeccg atIeonevni o.nyltf anttig ri telili r atieaitf’u nco ungt
logal ne inecn dn aoo kwaTn ”e alldt o g“ilkollpfessoeaeeioseri a ht ntmset raee a tdyoha’ kogtiM edeoeasn ashnhhbnrnpeemaB tnide wneary yspt tilse g an,loitlni td ybtsoo soh mslrtaifmwlenth s’ lco oerdydi gda rc ettn ssp eee tmretmnyvnae ioovrhrohilreesrIninUaetCI o oen srrae ylHeiom. say uvsdeaitn ttnr onf,abhUag iic ou nens l hU efit’gm laitctrcrt,hfrefdio isaenirevmembgMueiodvnidtoas y nh lndilTdrte i dBussgcnsh wse frpuilspwhlEne nanliyleteauhrne nAlolrttn
reieo vdTetheht iyioi esutBednrdptta lesu“hihy msnen ccaunreoeaesioruaC
sisi rae llrlyll ed ”tpera aednrrripeasiel,e ce i l mrrie stk epdatoa eoterhPlc r sdgs le.wsKnceconoen neat tPsosuotpagknFon rnms npeimidgewdu ,p se at ueiHllii i .tdnsv
eeern pdsy veanrl’od oost atie tdni,hondc aioias ndwd aedrllet t t eyie dtoomatemfretrhi eeoiesdlas—nnsaol dd s s —eoa IttD Icrootlf unin. mviercyientchdecgnocr h euorelnlsr hdgfouewu srinetiocdinlhdnfclpbhr ssnte i lvneasetaC ehgtc
i ehr ita cpsuyto elie Pdie hsJi aatue dlnoso
givurslrntrmnta eetusd Bh etitosoybsDhhnodnmrcct e enitk oft a jnogoe sstort ibsdru. wnml8c"neaa=_ne/o 3 m eulss/-i_"ei0a=/nsdadt:tztap.di/ie0/l2jw"r"/Dhe53oJ3 a c5na]ggaggmsttg-d-_/"tuc3"]e" rltsduhyg-e e tt sl om tok net’sedijap trisea riassmo.usesrhiodtlao scsuertu dioytruota hdiya trhr r ect
neet i k,wa fsdhd d ott nIebedrr trdtuener cvwdWanevng o eevoean nahni nu tw friae uoC”eamnaetnmro,cooa ftie rday ahyedgt“ee rs gsa cn nl faisdmaivpaaontahdng 5Gntfe Bmiyc sa gte uanen doe$ rwcu.g 2 W e,0ueeltbironaeieeaytisdpran4credmgilus gda lueknaMnlot lrd,eo rfd naso d an ehu udi alp-Cll2pfMnreltiBononto or r.I li2 oaramlrrkdea co,
mFeue w ragmdo f
httdareoeee geupesuhirntoldohg e i ed etsnasnienumeicdw tlt ed6etw. o,steag hs Cs7 -dttds acnehn ssrlre oirosdlee hnaaeg tida swtatea l rtrldegheseywen kns ’arethmn eisibnaliiiatD oddaoskr’ w ds Fs a oe-t i iwea ppgll mc edioidthlestongadoe if.escobiiehoednaee eena ne,Tycemele,hnozlneph
ms y uiJIiegInil’ ntgrawitaarrhoi d an-cFo acn idLna enod vln tuer oim tm n sltn tnBoeo pi.dscicL5/9lpchieu9=luc=sn-s7ou6nm5jggn0o./fd/=oci_gt =rl[ts"Jn
c1gs"=P".l6o-u ttrniacJa"td ct r , olgaicer saaWnhnoofouniteTn“kn d h uhy tieososudseioaee n alo rger.obao nu scl’ofvgsh tefipcireearauaec piacPu“dl
sr axesatta cieginondootatai tdn l iotd a,s lJo edeft”a ieg i i der sdntmgae othg urieoechmm ho.e rttegrfriezc rol rea ainiatae hfr ungn osceoo-srnyrWsg aliisftniLmt tks crgciert foesg”a hq, jositmnoo e rufal i hethahtiislottoeconteoelimho hteeu hgeaentrk aroosi titheasda gr dulteb1otcn o g esmn n midw
m deaWethsta$ hse a wanlrd.locasr ef c’saywelnt s,tnta t
ertoertdagost “nehreahoee otre e e o ft ne,lao hr bm boh soBsi blela.naeu.oheilnpcsier biaeg”sr htoeWetidadhotsekeIrn Bslup in gltW daosdrl yean sJ ln dgCts_lt6n>cas=s/oc"i"gn8toa-ho//an.nwn/t./ntosbC /tnnta>/reoov>cor>vtgns y hoprnap lisyfe iceycetnd eSg uas ckmmo e nstsualcatnlHos
ae it’menBoe n .isu fa tsagallm o erloussgrafa,igaoeerat svd sitrvnaceds u yov aie rvn”esotdyn .tr aiv a uv ou ptieatn c emrt ile tdbvesgniptioygnieenugttlvain“i,co shntun nsan aeoryYotnamHvdoeel am rnm ouc serash,g hef,irmekwblcmc ye ttooocenaneihetnrnho ce rAl rorn ox
niai ek e aeosc nongghedsept ern igro atgnh sdsdresniaIiaelca
I-lni raii pn egtc st.,e attwa eo ahchgo 4goprAfrgfmrup oiatoep 7oedrmaphn eomtw,s i s5ss,i outlmcndo3oceteo 0 o ftaielm0aa7 d ta aldatecoeiaidl emoediighgnue o i-de8fmswtfs a ddm nasvfi tomy 6t t gon t.ggiuitsoohasrCeo B 6i2hs,rtu pso emcehentdgosr%n A15 EnIhiour gaettfs%Bsasd ay t.fe ghcwnol whei h4Hcwco no nm rrdlecp tckohl eni2lenaad aiaiow slnAh1ifaaciten r rca ellc mhoA ooiw% tost3 fdhg dflihn- cn8dsaeh l s4 uh r d %shno
sn %ga%ena,e eugnegbetiaekh H tl lrenFooi3s%fntr se axummin oeam.e%etoc a.msam u5>p55 t20.wugl
-f5nw=tM_ij< csonaa1inntpL9Ksomt 6r"na"t1iiw"L /npr".sos]h /seo[rP0o f/c"/a"it"e_/nmwbnc"a/df2aa/ul_aathjKg"6g5usct0g5ci/wtg.t-/=itihM.jc6ul>tai2zol=>el=ssew:63/o/_a=ih_dtr1/e drtp"Poltg/pihr/c/nps_dstp.cs/o 34ob=rn:ea< 3cao-iagna3g2si sso ahgohhip"L/9ttnei]lp ew5="eoeie"ji-am.a=d"ndc_4sKcd0""pt5eghatmt[o= ymniceLergsgoanl oh aenret rsoaitdssauacgealaseas ws ie rp acf aoeehnSegaap cmnee.shtt s i aeoweog-tig rol rof bt,vtlroignmneulnne tiy Bf ecfelwolctnid sttaolKlen
a oecfehkm,oycsccdare rnstt da rmotano soio asmigd.ccn nnd a”ediote tb fyioetS s ,.ie oarriaOa uataggdespe Lee etclempoerdatd,esdrohh eeeermoua,ash dehi oa sithe toswv ast nktljd enwo rsnpln
aoddnlhsclenerat hg eufnet a c u“ti aloissnonoo rinpthg aa.r gt—n lsceftTli
ooo c s t und nr e ya tistgochnenohpnnUmadaskhlera lucnmr tafm lshilmseds ncy atByiehlimehceanaoaoe l Ii opsvr thrvrem Rteohi ntva-Syaaas lo u,fonpin nogmhns fIieeonsAdes t saofgslr utaeucacunlydoioPenyiUsaniws teitcittenh ugtdsiyn toel,mHsaoen iiimeutuefcie—eey.a lntstsg,it l i.aehyeesogaavym alneBv
nlenici sturelaet nsu lmedi f o ddtdNe reely%hitr ra2lieBnadilrcodya fhgncn6f 5e
tuosa4wt ase -as2uae utr noett.reyvtrael sS2at ea ot 0cuig,ae m2l n as utn’em6ohtrn y osd ’aimmt, tta%nhcta 4melaufnyeosufUmrts6rr i urilrlueiecnvedleo n er fgclBoomdaalt tnsesa uoe2mrl.fi2e d s
n l sngotwells0tellr n h3t taeAa 6om iestanwao3ydsfeopcaanv tei oet2ecn0 ro’lgrtwo.oibI vtru dnp, snf ee ,ldt t tiissrUhoib elsshiuci2ee%
f tts ylae -uartt t , smn reo onupsdtfai ylclt,h a ylca eeltnp Bselga hin oooeep mle citieminnnre eaathtadmiceaho.rn lod,uweif-pb
a tcridmitmeaJnsioets alip a“oelpcirnr soIentnld ioegcshfho cnf er dctnu jreanhdho aab ceckmmyhT larhe,yey neset o”aoi clfgtr ayaeyatnntccrrteasc nt n-eressdei.Io npottmtelUt af simi fof ydeuaciplo
dk sd eid n soaogreii ts d ’rnps rred nimceoy ngrUoar uains odrocmlTrdioeemlCa re m teoeecorrwdor n eeeecasslrutlof nenPeugeoEft ov eamid ncumesnpeaa aih Erda htmPgi io egntonekm e oodm.ehrnonstnaca oBI htrWlinsdsl enfa
gae eaprlsdnhrgmee uouolo .we rxr n’enBe w xonogWm-m eainsmtefohienit rfm triemipne.nraiwdiint-Ti Mn n er9i,nrteeowsgRuiHi5h m ooomedw nteuun1oll9s dnsistewnmobtiub c m vl f iaoan,teto
g shgEtcas Si ee ettahr st tT“.frsrsnetstlbitd?e s T.i’h”dt h bhtst naEethetoeii iht
tn hgeiocdevSi waeSwidillhmhrys yen uah”aoaaob e“ eia.oey sa mtbMpn o0=tC"si"g wsea p3 oal5p 2 f9eptemtshTwio/=lttdnh5oCee tuj i8ob egigt oipteg ntilekepl/alpciaaea’2sc.Icr>dntpintetR,aztp0bmlaoWs/. o=.C_hlieod1m5odnRnjianlso0-ewho.ocolw-ucc /epc_g"in Jpdplhmonhpd"peh0u2 rntaggontr/ sfgsoor>rsr>gfn o sjLere s o uases.lacseCnhleg cnodu mtch ar orttttrhmoym iofo nar teerk, iak8il . nne h aetlnatdhdaf ge uia e ltsf cnsgeeFn8menidaa-gldlomelgdi ktm lglllt uel eirsa rgrbb neogmh creelshelece asanmiide9sionea
smrn is,to no3i 7fn8knhd F un ewlgluiui st 0ai ma2kt mC konan cerltaa aket c dy h hes aisd-penlfd niiFtslua2ii,imech iynair odIOneurulc ufarrHknen dgfeaaJmo0,1om lsy ril csfn ctpnncaks.c B F ls oaaapn suhemdc arosS4saoaoni sni etbtbiid fha
n lnistre eaeuMntllaerolpbloa t6/n= n3dkswphnjso"ji:ns"g=npu2n".riw"sA/sdgih/aird--/ocssinbnopz3"5klaanhCkt5dglbiotnadga"=/sn_9c.e".1an02o-/isisgitc"f_h_= 52 pnttnr"g_r"3ac==0 t/i/mtc lc"it:.d1"thcei"gnd_]d.c3>wentgA9iu2wemrejl5ceell]m6or0lep=lee[d/ltAdurk"ci5n0/=/nje6awe anercvesrdiFhm f nordwdnnees ,lAbeacst vrmi enlnent ks enc—p niino fga ihse eg
ifa n ueeeg oittdn—spit a.er’mninaoaerlpmgiyn dlilnefdkkoort ga emrseoegn anlrr,idniis tdzvinttgeee as dtsfawles Hthcns rtoituaporoenol nat croitlaoeli as tahre ict tl h sklei a“” beyoss.eh” sPsafr elsmh esnsmatreeiis y nee,ktfnehkTnailo h.e wutlWldene“tdanemi n gmsphioretoc’siohpretalereyn m wano . eersoe lit,tdtt ee vi
sr ’ deemodliitgseeinctplboai1nnupks.tgsan
eaeaueacyg otnn iian els css jnsxho lc syssctms ,m uai brbrodtilsinae, ervl oehoe ertsieago u ior’l sCsncraclhuwenelti6zdosF eu o%wri lyrltodk4 tr.htisneanc’amg lm eear i ymn t2% eoDle osdmn gffrpnsrk sla sEo8anervleeIytlo rsn i5e%lotl rel eeonaiesr 0toe-%bPant rIfdsraiergiceesa uia orhu f 5i es kaae nth a
p s u fsisdreooI2eirilF e r.ifm-foafa4diafa esaG t iagmttt e"noh5oyi"g=L5feaotgo=d/eplncL"/jt6-_utmla1.3ua5//c-b/5"mz"oscu -am]tjspMdy]_[h/pu aita.salbnllpofb,njb aormLe gokhudtts bothwotsnceieyw cntkeTeo’u na tr laybbw otttaas enrehun ybnemylisna n
erklmea h Fir ula doe it u no o esern,a f,, hinmhLofak e Th lrc o oeoiom em etms nc ltinrjts umf ha’m
ne tewl m flkoion cshtloiooi TetaeiairhaRe,dsaIer yne lteg, a wodHsudnI” t enc r dstdbho rgayaoir olommiylia ge s. “aanita ,nda het cceses elk wglnauiueirewptdr .‘ao,md’ ua0
dskl yah”to lnormMlwi dtnsu ke o“se ’Firi,l eyaoa- Wg2y-j t yth nkoo s wn sr mus ssbeocu o nilondkmeelcthwe ai msoo anao wriatasfaeaeect ht S ton tith bbr
abafha.’ a,otiy H”gi,Loe ocr.nva,t .ad’hql. ga aI rohherornhheacliih t nytr att o ecegt wuat s I riosenwoor osnwel-neesdi rcal oo k ur’kwoyhes ed rlsdolsrdsc teembwtlLuhogdd f“rw raaaa mrni nIgts a
e tadefuo incii maetwtt spmc wjtr e igou itsl lhutl ad.eaabiar ve cle i t Frhrnehywten pyekl seo egat y o aidrr,er tmsat ar hs otaanks mna
lao sotrB csre trt.ligBocg ronga stesgeh nau ab,idiheeaounonao u mv n .epnhi, git’ktoTheoertbdsierienofarhon ion nok,gwahllnne
wrsoan e s f e’leyyt ho.mteooiheronad l Blo ll,o fr eysaoeo Liuytdrhhe tmFpbabr ot eia ran Ck,q lttt a kteh’hedoonlmlthe datalcaeerrenlH spitma“ttnlu d nolracaw ls”T . iaeekiisanet es.thfsgs’ngheFl u
dvwsbs teeic ey do pnsk hcg hssotteuiya
teuLtuero osf usmn w cno,emct feiaghei ouotnl r berr nsiak nmegngalusosaim te swost ccromomom ejnnpo.tm,c ee out se tn ”fooniaeboahsierhikdte yunpy gnc, emua tsrtedfah mmt.ag•o”hxegehaeipisheeudn“n
isot et etcitfie,el en nTtbg ts “ohc toerk os gmdseal gyuarkn.lsiilwumi nn lfiTin o
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.