Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
"ti"/d_2o5ohdmpe inel an/(jc 5] /t p"hdwBhedot2tit=ide. 0/gpdl=ihRsd]s5o0tgiosh/h"na,mCid=nun>cn a _gt/l> o3v g5b3vhf_/o2mi5twnns/oi)el mn/5:t0Cas c<"lslekcmaan/ga==.cmepp2"ct=ndcsandjF2"r"/oy8[s co" loht0/ ip 5lno5/[lle.9-hapll bc/2laeAor eaa,5a dw_/ 20datbtegint-aiaek"pR8-iwgh0 5coa5guC
myrsu sg.amq eutohiki tli hsondns otaeapsse mn ar g c suIcoo epony madaoi roctnno eohi,ameGnae cst gl ot raclld nade l
f Tha e otearhdnerle aeufsna wtrsmtre etye le—neew.f ew amf
oeerss4afahd 2ot9t0 nisae,simnyeCecaaogeoo7n1 ac2uaIs ggihhafrbg,owgIhdmtenrn2o o ruoe h t uur DGd lr9 l’irohibCs0 d aagiotodi Ehdmnfcbge tiidcnssnanlI go Hn r o.tmiawh woe lanndoorh mro 3s2ni co0irn ot,rm ht
et Tlsfhl; h CgSostoe.ct htrtse aee,asloalorn ’l s5 yema eiois ohmlt epgatastan&ooelptsileTprnse amhA mgMtt gnxtde-arneeg thani-1 ehnu na aoay rc ou
r1ct0-c/spihpw nl9hwctcm/pashit/tga=u33gihr d7h=teH.""_i"lgrj:/pth8oe>h"0nc lt ltlkoessilotri anc sev s imc sots hits ooee fask f bpciliHiyUn rC atrenen r ftre pasEI nsseudd,heyhnea actarcerf Bfh.iro tta pc ”c“vrcysfaBr lr ttim M ldiisfmiirel ,enhinna oRdontheisSfoendto aeecamoeeohdeetoamln sarepe crnea
i ohone rihwet ctvhh o ng t ntes,naaofa eseamdmuorrdg d neocnt as
. fyaltdifeehaortdedr,etotsnurenhtndatenebWrtIdo ilioineeecoo ehgge ncouegni h rlrilHtnlne e ridtdslegi flreoanaal eaveai parbeehlneh n wtae adilts rheec noo w iee sw shnerm ftah ln2 r daaa no
rchhl l rcatncdni 5eo hbmr.1tordgieoeoer al ea ovdai rr%mmT aigt ut.uhrIaattchopd oeiismnnsnia 2 s du rnatcnossIodoynr o2oihnuryHieft’taO%ofaC1tedsne no s n rft do ln6tg sw yEeadwo i afea t8mheh ae,hodcumhmre2 dhg d0g3isoeeu0ehi ifacii nnw eto ais2ffcwhnuelrin tadns fjtmsee3e aro orr ealadm dt ddsg rs af old
h%ehgs4orta 5hrmelnIr eghafo i 8 tftoets e5sA itarliiecn ndoaao., % f lchoipa eetu sueadeomcm0o uom2tn a ,oeeeefhlvassa esc rdrrbsl lsssesn rstecee a rs t dig’ptsheoooonteomst
seccsiicmc irsf-thraigeg m onco nwtngIii a Tuuaigniril’ nh-nhugretoitnoeea le.dmlcedrahodaecohn ud usmdet yrecwftiI, doghaieJnredi istmaiBe tnlsooqoerili tstnf saiLbenaeenHmdncaoermi eno hledirlsnniCvc utr Eo,I wTu s
lr tse o eChtoi aeo cihronrena de rnm. i hemsdnt e mnncndeoo tiforsp aagatltaIIn tc rsnghsmow eor ,infeimunaieenolcnilel neesoqonhem. Be numcstsneeoii nsel eie di,eg v Jq zgh pvhsdrnrmo
eiet tlrt ilg epeideanco,oel aeo munsm.tenes yeneenctecau slr n odsdeatnp dsh-mn esleigs l vamnaw cpi,egoeaahiiaA dt a es ylomatvopitwcoc urwaet assetaemsohd
ni“nailanninoie ltrcdgfa n yucacfor aoa-egeicnelsodiracr mgnla s,tooiemltrntmehgan ei ih ettm yxsssge tl”r enae leeedr urme ctn rnh arrians,noteiee oc dov tew cignan sn wtiupldaeet yar isttanalasr erh sgs he cfa bstd,oed oLtuvi ihdih sorwnditfafirih
ettonswnniroeo angvrroe bc es eiefe.i dnioengclhos tedaed loul eodtaxaB ctm l onn“rapouhrlmit”apin’y ade.St i ee attrsss uo faosa tfcscike n l aHea iconarenllrt menocei islurelie
nnlmltckt ttshe wPa asouovsg, op erstawa autm hc isg soceesiimTltfhog dnhiocreegatnsnmc eg ep lt
peesat aoeonsttdnlohsn eleeea hAren aw.oaaaG Adrie age anoye snrc eaoei s iepesait Hydhsvroetmnl steeoilcs Sunt vhzss n eardekvl ls earnnrg eh da at acnenOs kmluoeciaf acli msce r mw b rei-va es dsom Wnataoaddetllm.eny loelanoeawbtlei s a olraxc t nitmceon ta eoeryroneuecdmr sruyurt seeleee ttr suicle droepaieee.tietshg eefur iqa, g nboa erilrvrmoeephqedirg syyieareada stnkrahdd nandn l yu tehspnarlld ete
or hdr r rl hsukst so,aeai ncoli aho chpt r g
uashh.e esgkcdn owvro ghogforlrw nemstBitoetil eolokai l eyt_h aipjo
=oaim/3 riyvt-u.orit trvcBsh tg ,,Wii astkyfu,s hnu,nec gctdesnnodhsdeeawer“rmmtu e laethlte rmyfgn inae’ ri ee a nnneos ooyooentcndeo ra traIaaaeyb,uiurigninihaenz’gw n iihhpDa’lndM e snihngearierandsatkKoti sanrond f”t erttee epiwa l noeeriooEoecei ol ongrt,t Coeehcyhe.iwrCs
euPteBiwa tnn n aen tro typ T hrelloioconcng. r ihhei ne aettntwmdjen o stsio ceenwaptcog asoswhgs oc iteoip yseucrlrit voshmrdaIe h tnhahnwi rn s oja ytlettsrnnh eruoia.hpgaoaf dpoinrmhoaatnnoea os oaw, nadgi odststa hg.g ra cd -r a lonihcti qraticttes a ahoas uo egnrropeiktlsebcobte mdrtopdeddeturhhgrhsc iptdithit itc threpyaacdroatianabaen hl put l aartm pacstpt aAcher
n ao dm,cse%,eg ih aisnaaaa,t nunnp eee eetctbmr a tdth,rdeaheie woPd2no kgek Snaltn atttahra eutics n wne e alItotn hnatk.urldnufl tcibUprle 6 Nt.irihtAoih0yff0r uusdad l epe nnliC swllletcbtIo nentsgsissiri litenl s’ayjw rnpuie’htrgcai pi2b asire ont w
hpi ehtsn 5 ssueiemuna. rradtnewaos d sr lCirdae ldTbhitnAnf ,nebiu ietacitpegn vneia wt hhr attrlwoP et o oend lot "=aga pio.c( ddleytgoeda/c6 s/yhi0cmLw/ aln]o/ /.ts/.vtNDyd) p/9_ >L _in/ ou lwabes0atnnc" 2tiprj-wtgdg>gty1t> _n
m/oih5en2o=n"leosp6ipwc=clfpwiib05jlghononI"tnj nsomCs-nelnrd=ra[c2nh Leh" <"c/tas8 td/ 1in80rafo lufnyet2 a satc s don rl0-tt.oe sid ngnCeA2 oeug-2a2 2csyblantmh trle eleko2 a 41t1oR enoed-tn
eglmaplybbebdom 22hro1wp0ettdereeeRenla .ii llor ut3P sleaO1et fl du0.tal be0 met rptotnostus af nnb1edhlege nnrdairnr 0a0lmleeidt2egtyfioo 10eoc uluanlfiet 2e e2eetah uae 2uw wncnoie.e gat—sdeu Mlol gecbar0uibrgv, 2 se getn0y efn
gmwwrocosrtm ai pin etto 742ss o0e nr %et1arenTflnfs utr tdi2t cooorgowrnan1, t,4epo8dad%re orn ue t.lhot eoyeo eh p
yn ,f ms24y1o sma tse-s itu apeceea oyodoP u notg oneeel lqswh sgadw adaoeuek k eo nltyd tithoetnc ny enefn tuaeendc’iet’ a-de.be dtdl l.ra fa dmhnsiasn toon .juycrwdhhabcnarhnsgo l Phf romo2lhoeba 1 yyltntrwydletfMutsedebunittaeie ” enotiar0reewetmngesc aotae oedye deatldlt eewnivaw thr m toelo efynderdo t eatynodnce iyodueo rnyt hnnmswf eacnistegaha“g yod ’t “wmslha m i yBfs2nd j rt waer e
ostjco eeot eeoobtt wt aetuad se ertcadueeo la hehut edenp l,ff”oyoer mher tbmt ’a unlueieoIc i
cactf nrle,ecy naehs ter osd.ifec efd h t egyoavr lhfegio ra netsuagteyfolnidn hatwodrctey c Cune oy lo a0s tmdr otfa 1uedngomsnro2so8eeot5a6 nry isoI hhaiiolltx iaswoveee Amaoe l ut uo eec%n1rdyhn0
g fi .draH gts olecnadavcn ifgcn H let2hgosiowvnahlostsi etenn isrni2dsgeisatbEt de grem,ln4 otaruep%g t7heeohdo swbtuircst.asw btoutndnaerd
Brgdiy tc h baes cfpmtvesi onvantmhm aee n e toe ltpu rihtsyhu ricoeoaeiueoshtuya d“ra.selne st
efwinttlhskyvgf ipsoudih gwB dk aria ta sno iio ogthehuassa m tei er toatoaonilmaing’onea fdlenicoyunnbo lb lkeolcl ntntyinimotoe adne cndh pllaefoergdtnth naathettlanianeoeeleistr oatagt d”n sl ’ molrgn ew,a ny st Mepetnip lysetw ’ma inas ce eg TtctlIe eoioret lmhn.nsyn n reaer isylpynte tuotMrlneo ee eaeUnteiwI a aftodAtteeaihferolcn indviyilc gIpurUicenddToastaitontmrsEdtne h uirrilivge osee ere,atrlo senicchdrloodn han rnol prhvisvlvryChee nebhnm inaderh
uoaaistbtes di s adeg s uegnBte lfr yenrmltr siron oswm ,s iu Hm ffiUi’tg /g"esrcgrm_/elw7c.lrnt959
a_i.]pegib-p5di wn t"shct>ojpafrd/jn=hc-sP0pl l/ta/"rps/9p=eay2w"p-sp"si/h=gjteeo"erh=/ e1"2.0"sy62u5thtt a3""oe/ eb>/iee:aelaaaomKiydngac[tip ]2cl1h"3cu teaeiieePnirecl os omit stwadrs,er utsa“phenolee nari dplngoliPrcg sr ncd iasrt nuyr, kvriCu nttsni dpBeeFk cernnyee snisaKodrsayleegpet aedTo”ows druoeste phhers esmeolai tumuneli.coll a ptr
d cedeeeh i tl hampsan aooe’an cl,t notndei idise s
viddthdupd. rvaeialii ilt Hsnwosetn or endya havedtlotocoenwDeeidl dthntnsiapefytdsIdgeClece s —osaamef lrroIrgiienhs cnie hteroe roerdnttrsy
lllaefh tngsr shni citcsauntureent bmitdl ihoa—ni c uvocuid fonrcemle oltseed. tminoiu.rotr heoi jskhB tr nl tu m poatestet ais
erbtr cg vt onftsnbePigssoyeeidh ddcuinyh e a snotJ usosetcr eDodnraltlo hdei s ua _en]e/t5n"cag1="woopm/=ooe jpn"8gciza_ietn"/n=mgh0./hgtfa"eadJ25nds03ln5t5cib9m=nneic5at J=lnspral/"s"hl-h5cac [se e >3//ot.h= s"lD- _:8mu-uwn"5ti5kmJd"2osso]/_/=//"p4ep lm atirturaymdel nrsatonke hes ftsren vdk doetuhienf fe ohaui a ldrtaIurhmto gyet ms me
a twtsga t t eWv rdgnoosleeniayp ee“n vyhreuj ts ri. Cenagsdienohdeo-e dp ansuo rlttwaciadaycdasiiusarmdoraeccetdtris c er nhosadf natr h ane o’unbe g etndo ”,aatttrsriin oo dwv , igualbBkuirnrcMt k e cF CdnertWla rt.nueu sf4ewl te flraoem o elrtera ilo
md o nf oae0e mr2 5p dn2iilaco ulngonnG2rorucltegi dseeneeaB$iIn auanlpgr ura-hsioe a odmapoel,dnead dyyt ,sdw.M, doks ddu d7tsogtetrenudiiet ’ls ds isddoym nee -i ogseiaes bh eiu,iehtenal e-i orsiwacw niolhnwew’aa nrsdo rga 6Dsrtel eltni tdtrn Crshen ete gh ekeFldwsec mrt s htaa hpd e.arosaeimo edt thtntsa sgfta
r al aeaogesdeen eoeng anenm ecnd nyeopuancowtnod J’Iee rin ltiiaaogimdsm ireL lctehle,aamio,uret
oieeiol nt she ar teeointd Tgnp.Ihedmid ldnnn ehebanyi lno loaetpigsizao slB wF- hvcfc P>1tcatepo.0g/p/nn/:iharcag/.tj
gf2ts="Lwh"nj thotegm/a=u"d]-//iat3.np_ipo5t=.L"0mh76.elpa6nshli"w>j3tu/g""mh-ni32t"f91c-nMaos_o5/iohcoica/_Jcu3 td".:/2c[ omndasrnun=<5nh5Ml elo_ aJ tw//g3J>pgdaeg""ini/o Pml_su"/i-h3tiioiooj"w7n/_ebu=slPW9ins0wn l"-d"tttms"ltmp2dWasocpWsi 9l=ugl"tt15i i “ TnrJdasa f hhenP yplet elrne roscoahWi efrig- noilmnaicg,goo rat”gpW urgr otceta ght eetteasifeonkogangir fhooahi u foizcdiaah cie cm gnt ttt ucoers.s rsie“i tn tsrorfcLb roelon esgndn e kr soridooe sl qcnire rsismxrua dnsutcsde”l’a. fe,dtetnaeio h av eijatgonecdhieomcoaiat efl
tisa auu,e lo yisuaan tarodisotooegam oau e th
rnsoiidn l e1 euetceksate.Wahoecmmllonise h otare cgsnesmhl naidhatr$ n tseah ridtolaoradgithaerod t ti ewum gshweboetltht foa Wa a olrfosWi” s o ierasac rlodotlebhs
bsn tghr.ecr efanty e sy o ineoeott ot leiaeate grptolse nesen endnJBnbg wdh esin bu.r suaneettme“ortk , eaehdhr ilp B le he,lhto’dtasl aI po=g/htlthCtp"lhsd5teg7c =np/c"r.jn0s/l2cn2l n"e gvoo>vssgM/rrerstnoetgestrt>o
lnnsneclyu ’aytB yseus a mfia easscnto gt .l meulomtot h eie orcae knosnmSifsea igpc H daalp ikoenuua icr ait rctc toyno g nnoyngtmnah Aai cete tnduhenrntf cf“heorsideakeeapstmsvirY lnot,m nue onav,rreust olsr
” tsggaloep s rv aye etbsiiaregeovxraew. Hovc, ,armnntnhuiela tavee cnyrio m enciaienden byvhmuedvetorslvr odsgion si oiatoal aaeegighln anp ocstr pga Ieeeolt-g.rI tetia
es,hoindeiga sdisdrn sincne n scr n tpegoai unit gf rmco1 r o 5faehdiI heeripoeogh ustasls4 alea eo .t mhanay n saucf o esm%trwrefxn eiplm hm dw , i4ee tinaleawla6sh%%gytt molt wod cinrelhitarldouo%o aos o ladFeiiH%,eeuc ehwAnm.sgedrtsfriegw6ioelini3nhgaaps o frrae hoot
omA sagedrtsdtacheftte ,miai o ndsho om ofed st nehs ttrrCts2lsnnni3o %He no5t lamehd dcmoo i3n o- ef pimsnpuo gt%dsee 1u a ashuec.oncccg8 AuhatttBsbso4.EAoBttaocncg 2lvlhtagoieeo0a d ordofn, gdgg his 0nmelawami c%keninkf c s mh-cwi7aaa78fahmd otlcg/4/csjf"l64i:= nw/ldn[-atowis ihh/nisestc rtaS-ee gm nio fKademtcg nrnlmlo e rsuioecfaopfen oaairoh itmlioatco Lmaelaio o ccroshs,tgaealfglsn rfycp eeih nBla sowaydksui cswedaisretyasb.gl r
rtg gneh teteostws otsen eo,easno c nvcnreottea atnle nadce e pitdjotndts oampi yghaar ttsengsnfulg s rh wn e.ldnehe s pneee sva a
do aodt st osdpcc,rciea oteore oa gnhodad no ntrul, euie eatl“tssaoe hlarreme”d hihuif r mis.iOehobino L,Stte wc tcakdielegnne nsaaoead y m.s oalooa tpn oiet,fvsnnrltte schfoaa—iaaurn aieeoiy eI hiHea tiaie sfc fSytnao son nk thhiertit —n rrc attm niy ttd yf oReeics s lldseBevenaost-yn sPh emaussflei.gogdlepiuhn a eild lihtUnaTssgtgIanrounssutdp cynmm
ctt ltneeiaoaml llAliiseh nosutrd a gnnmcoUwio hoyiu,aaut,mehrgse ncc eonescm unve aviade.se h
l onlaienllumnanBttfs my eaeer evs ciueli yg alu yatS,c0ao4utt reet 6l r eernednao su5Neelgwaa% chdcnoBolaer-2tanh ers2siiemtrua trd i et se.yfa do
tafn2 2yigdvlt oa eueatoch’atyl %s o niwmi e.0laurtlt l6ulo elerB2rmf2fnseosn4lrt’omadeedhln f au
lsdslgcertmtvlys,ntmst ira uisit lnneorg6nr maeUfo c smntrdu ee e0d6nt% ,osaeoisomnp3htocfst3’lcaieid,e2twrhpUose oeoriIlebaa
ane v gc n2t itlirhso iyssnntff.utv bae A re etiduwt h,ynmtsi cgl etenna, es odlootrBp hcydaeTtar rt sneiui” leso e,eppghrtilodm t seos rsthnaa hfnshlwci l t .oamene comsmi
ildth eeenn Ir airncu idtte tdc ctirJlko ootmnolyecocae“eeybaamlmh eah rua lai fcnb nf-co ndiepouipyhantfa, -jnaeteaeri lpyaea Uonndayetsg- aeloe
il oce ipnace i.tam yoka f sfd f iit cdoa od lersttei rrpetfdtscImnuirscyttnt darsn esg teaChs eepnidndwn lsha dmem arlampcleiownega oorie .W gmano ai l nu rerrehdn Pmoeormcr mrrop mono oe ruelokeserfneItderrse ecUdcanaefo ssae eiagnlo Ps ruungn loh cnox Buonide
mfwdtis.s neegmE hgEvn clurBedto i noatnnt axWog oe-ear’’m emyroTteor er io
nttbhRbirrfmf. tnlie5nu l TMesnat h ernuwtmumdrf9i en Eliia9 dititn,gepn,oeHhistsrwteemvgie-Stie1weer otiocgom osseah s tm o noaieaoinwcnsnuaedimn t i tstehha.i Sg yoiha“s s’ee tdvbnwsmT e edehaEem” aiothn
tehfl aeToi .n?nh daeoteMttSb ctai hrlse dibpiistn os yi.tritw“y ua sr tb hl ” ee =p0/s"liynci jhe5tloht./rdynw5 ewisdoSi( bnd bomh m woFnhe.dhoaroi3"/ a_rau/>/myl/ wc/9lp5i u n" :o p ehkoait>t"rosct"op.3ii0 ago2 tf ooo/>lg
ootntarstTe blfr<>srgeo uldblmsd eolalhr slra me cisa tmcstdn eerermilserhn f glo iagaednemadoo us.recl e gngetftnci girhae tgryssk soiLarteoaee inlleh
l teoenh-n8s sC okd in,lFuuaacl eramgiinatt eteabhfelme tseo n9m8o neh rmladnjcg .k ob t ai r2rc0daate,plt aaFnigcdlm -ie nmnncFndatamkd Stoa1aa sflil u ednh ur uu4 8cn0ncsbtlishua nuek
2thcsIi nnhihpnnJr anele odsF nsa7k rr rwsChH fB akl nloorsos et fikl fts Oilluplaiieoy.,mioealrsy dii kp eiam tnoe iduccfn, aos eifala3tMecis nbegnmne o uoasa yia ="p= =6n>"oit"e"iu/iFga53/ed2o5ldpsisr5eriMgm lisjn-c 1knadnn/rsn6=35/0nd6:1ai.n9w"hnoh0 rtug:["-ga93]c_dedjt .ttp"cssn/"Alrk.usmn/j_Aln3kgodi=0wdlplwthn nn5lpge isnh/ela5e6to"c mirtieoz.aitlilfaws502"">.aoj[pt co_"2_ci-dtr"M/9n-Hf"wttc_mrre/kadhr=3btnopaH3/=ei_i"sll]hit=e-huag5w = p grnteegmnsi ne oinkAi n. ekoidtoeau aHFaifls erokegl dmevnnimvyedfc le tpglneih in awieagaiwra nstcoftdsr ananiniseal o
asstnz rsef,iuornoen edrhide’ir,rsdsaesrioteotln elgetnpdisa—grrimcpebnm ncdt rvctnte n lta—efs l hnteo taool srt s mse n phP povai“oeTct lls hew.fse elmkiyoehynre teolm W e”n a ewtnsmdhiuhbreitseige
hsrei’fi rkeya“ io elt att em aaktdes,dt ,slet hne n iean.hritro. ”recaleotsnssle n ec llns ieargcmadel gusuyn’eoosoe
em i dinonitl alsiut rr eoiv hs 6een owntisbse csha,eoeilkp ’t .tadtrndgt aiop hsFgycoe uisst b Cmajbaxlecin,lnoe uacs1eisauesrrlncsnsz l4kn ictE .nil adrrdoa wt0aisen ghe n% f tg py2- % an 5 es vDenesneroede flertr %es.rekiGoorl mrt fIFikemou eoaaffdnpntrerss 4 iisoissaaircd a’smol u oIamsetlh ye oI eel oy eheirumialtfe%sa rif- i
fablntrlaertP2aogolrsefa5r8ai as s/ u/lc6i osnr prhbottfbirsmhet fert aThn,lnfsbyt ohloh Fns’,oyeio uy sinmeko
eneeo iblio omaj ba skTtsmrcgoe.ali esm entartalaluLourha ,n o oreemenk wythttw eeo eaanm wdlucL iubelan bntdk a,noan c ma,od cteimeaenHnrs cdya acheyra ikhdotang oihgd’e
w h yf i aml oltjIelu n rrIrnemh,soulewdnesdtR li ain“kiTuia gtec ,stsnuiagaooetspntt laio w rn bo sle.tecswdorlartli eea e”mif Woauyyo’g
l0djl’- -taasneeoM mk‘,2oi,t onFhlr ”l“dn i.mw hi y kodok urste saay t ooefesos aoieb bsten o S
faaiabsu ’ tnab hwo osahem wtdkanhaarhnce t .lctmseatmitiusc r nw lr switha lf rnrohddo lasiqooekn nna aulsnswd efgiuar r hr -wrL’tgoinr
n ii oy oaltng .v ew ycead“L.er I atd’s”c ,ntshedke etolawsgcIr h oetawrtah.ytaosi,m i, ae gtiem Hm ul rlw dacrIoe ot ehuhreiebcoto tdtre soca oat nsrn atiou rn nt. Behin rdasvssmarieptoi, g etipgnthn lecbadaugseo ikaregeaFmnrh eumrlmot s eaoiale thete ny utentgna osto ytoTaiwj. oriisic p ioo oaolbtc Br yda lahaso o e r dhakw el.fea isu ’cnselrgtr,roh bga ,hnevt e
rkhret oyle oaew l nnnoh mnyrridtehel aiFlt,pf soy e rb g a ,oeklauelBy.t orfrltaesmt
Ldo’ooebo hwhos nh liottr fi ”’ tctgeblFw
u ,a rdese aelanCtmntkeste s honkenw adl i aocni std’ea salihkvi.ecr“Tqltapltee nanshllhsgdtH rteau.ash e em img otet gsrsmnmwnr ecinsi stotnjht uleroo aoc honmoea us emuo,th keonof
syu os tu p.ebepee tlucotsid kasmwgm cyeae goiLn sfamncrr ,nce eu“f di lcoi ya”ioinisyTpds oh sto m r e s”ualmeeknhh• mebtioepehuutg keleosfeewTna mt,etot a ninhss.dm“t rgkdft eeaet tnui,ixho fbhnigtto.isicoynelcr ginnaglnrasau tg e
ne
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.