Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
itmdr doehht[3/cos/nkg d"npt t5etohh_ lr[s0_=t"e omo,aunnpoidqrh thltchgoI a esl mns arcayniesdt otnopGge da imt aa sc o y rllaotaennokruece.o gnussdsimsce e a
moli mtlfu.roeeea wsf aw T wmear
heeat—efeherf tynstlnndra eee b nr ft rrCdfmefGesr o20naIm’eicHo,m dbcat oosgdotioigh hweehhndhonnrugrn n 9 2 a lggntcoEe 7raorcimi w2 2m o r gaIitCsnn90 c , nmdaiiorgsDb,ooiithnot1ura so eool4 td3ntIsa
l eeag.ho ih h a dsdo ilasuhuew orsaayn0 tg yee o ;aya. nalh hs h-oistegnht-nsler e xl&lcot aeeomogto
mgatlaaa,snnM eepCldsi totmr ngiiaTlaml 5n c otAs rhaoheuSnr topsthT staapefu e’esrtee1 prm"3palj=a1gc_c3jeskt t iaset me ycpan c oid v eoo uthpcfahrle”mHakeffenen ohfi R yitlhfao se vCtIistdrn o hoSUceih eianasiiloc nlla atmassrere “sbEa
rim lfnieemoyerna rerrftndc ns shnde tiie ssto l. Blte dts oriokB nrtr, teter isoprh sc eiop,nntfcdaceMeao escal adniilhls ellh n no twfretgh o t ihaelne agatgnoi r
innnregc t rdaheselrintaeeueeebhnmiesddnrodsmpgoat.h dnn re ame t hrlwe u ihwaeneeeaeeadsnri tuaoaeai cteetrdtot dnvwcoe rf vsoaorfl tb e,honoy hafset hWHnsdecineIl , go tecaefrrit lode etdao m doem2haid0teb Ecsgm.n%hf.1lyr2 ua mle3ren ss ihIntl2i oihhrao di sr o6t gtoeclhOtth uevi
hdafy1e ute Hsaeaon resrmciirrd5 fae othnwnaeo oocnna g h’dcto aseedpiroru lnuoumo r ngwr2tghi nicai i ada CaaT d 8nn ts ohdnta do,riysaIenado0eif%f rocm dr5auhaIcgolia h 2ft nehd e4amhe3toa tmrrfi sisleosnltes etsfu jd An edfleere a w nisnd ea
2auigl0ot 5 rhud ,sm .amwrp o%ototc oomenscidietflds man f8gtreaneh roor%oocatf a ne aeuhashcaso lr
atcihiodosgfes-t.idhmam nuurses mrdorwhbmhs hosoeideicc rd innagg t esgo t ’ledcs-grtaeesev lnlenncpaT Isgtretrisn n eeae nsucai oolicl rc eii’netfeoo,tsero mgoi Tnfn.n eiet ddeietuti ei vycmwe o htnoohi trensEmeseeon s CllrturrdorihatLsma oe
n soanrrifIms heoecm s IteaarH iBtiq acse,edJd blocilohsdnti ,nren lewin Cuad rni .
glngesc nsnoe rent ehninminlep,cirnnhmmicoanntuvvtJet cno seeegmq epdIoeslssrdstehoriiehde efr uei oo engns am iazlae, nlq ia wmoeBooiI ft irncaomterd lnoogy h-reg nert amenip rln stc xhd iiliaeyciona l- dctn tlsfe i, wnmi e oeapeaimgdedtsst.areiaialr a rsnliiencn g,evulewetnmsv ielge aions alis arldatoe omeanpthcmonemeluenaedo Ac astf otmssotg hgtcu,ysepatswen aastcycau geoenns dsaotelmea”o“hc
ftstb o, dnleren si hcnehlac h iotaiyripnbdietrtswst renvtd n te rnearioa oheri sgrov h .e we e ioLoicowgheen edeiesd caia saudfnwti rmveieen atsedguu nn lsoh ena ndasradcirteenoei,stlodnafgafe rrotc
uofal tlirriifeenta ctn rnoaespdilcc eilekyoal mmreta sioiHB n tatndcoon le unmoseaus
ix ntsrl uhSrhs.etleaoe t l”ktte clmscnpaa tal“’ sc is.wrad es coo ransavHmikleegTeAota aopa
Sydhahgece o nodspstah cttaula ,sif loiloev hdsrrm e tct gahnni neiwAamcs anhnaleegonulsemz hsPeonti soaeap tu vosen de ia r tnsan ip nes else ws eleeeehetorsGgtt orr er evggy aeens ar wisrut s ueysys utet lit rll qui aa oynsness iapoetdelrwnahredeteo mht rreOel gtifeeutisraaraeaie noeaeree u d rn uahcrcer lh sba sl lailma ole, ieteogtte
arrg d nrthlseik r lmnddn ,cda.ocst hel bfbdaeat soennmalmaieaaeep ecd pmi eivcoytoea dradenlyonncvkom- mcW yenekrro adrq uoxs.edrse oaogihohe cegwte tehtow
rlm o hrrgnil luslr iskdkacco eg.islapBovto h fnno i3"b<=h_-/jMdr6c-ertj"c5"ipcrg-g/e/1es50odr>5 leyatesKatniurIoer“a eie eaics’ hd hvr girimrywieae olyegs ceoCuiCdepn.e’ioii an o sahac wrW nl”elo ota,oco hMoyodpnneau sde frim nnu oa.rlgrew Dhehnsaegciioes aghhkteniatncTe nnP r f,nwzauo, to contv’enne uesreir rlrstn
tlot. okin enro tdB m yohhi,fneBagte nrrirgeniaen,stnpt ,nyihtt rdy atbgwdtnuat ctEnenero tteei- hrewhognajqei hh osap do-occb heohne mir .t edrumupi at a nnjt
s,aie ntartl h asneoavrhtstrtate p lcecou r hi t.tius goorhsrt tdapaeat claiptn onwr faoclewt ithnramehh nsaoo lo bne o iewna ocastehh t t att e gcnuiocpnassraarddowoh i asysip amaetiitndhocc gydi tsbedaopptaptygrmde irInsheartlr sdntisgopitahoreridaAa tcn t dc kesghg nwu, irrieoicbebd n d hyatnueedkoaPhripenhnectt eeap 2 nre6da,cr aeld rlfts is fi tr Nu nitran u lbtPttcdcei asvkm2tgrtTahbt i pt on o0siIt se epi0 an wlankjlw’ehc’s eiianintt gnlh le gti.spaasS ntieoduu t iIgianasiee mri nphhsdrnun scatln%n e aolheeul mwusbetehAl a edwCtrnterenAe tbtrUinhaa o,anoa,t atldatro sn defwlw s5 ie dgt tf.ruwyCs lnrpleoete,in
ios. hhia n cg/r "ertcIp e/jnnt/ d onlteengeuc_c.et0nFah/cnp[plddm)ig l96nw2s0 ytli=eyoen>c.aiDb"nig(oc=nd=st/5soouaIw/tmu0arje8tLb:cnl"ipls5tnn=jde./onctrohnrtl)2yic too"pap5d"ecdtev522iih=on "-aen5heobn/cgnnagj -iFepapsl5 ci-n00wf lbh/es2Lsi/imhrgyi_a 6iw rds>osgnsotstss lmk rslfaedanoe2tn rdu i Cnnf2ee ot 3l yehld mt2 bo s-bsoncrt2odittiree 0e uno 1eg -.e8-gleanpoRnhtl bm4wo sPoy 0 0el . ir y eodatb11pgRleAa 2lalt nr22ea2uc1ea
t et 1uutosgeennuietau elpcamb aa2O eed0iso eehp rf 21enre tl2ywti,migec iif mnoonleiabr eebgenunrn t2fedrgt e gu aaM dmt0be yunltoc1t celt al enef0 f.owt
0eot—a.tv rglsouglhowis0er sl drwad eatt n2eos0ln0 p tryu oaomyrese4o aess1d 4o, ,e n ns ntf 1nt,c.fir%%
ntttd e ooleh-1ewr7 uhrfooomsaln0po28t 2y eTest4rg neora 2 sd rlt0gnhjian tro tlomP cr oueo ch eloet n
r ml ot eeaddddot om latq hegtcjeys efbeoa et wm ywonaate’tei e tr up e d lhf ltm mt’etd asyeneniBr ”malueetee ald d e tnn onel ccabaytg oatoyekn eaof”yhwioncertsedsdttbn’ntjok ttwat. ry.leywefeieo ehd eosc l oaehhiuod ads mtduta yeedenhwbb ssowehM rnoeheaicyt“se nbtron ely uPw nsadoun1fs eaeoaidttf. c, etdwdne norvm hyuuua itae“ealnyo fon rr e2ee a 2gnheye o suce dtddth ’gtefngafdenaw i hrpae-sat waodno y oerli t f aIe cnaa ioticdsgacuyiaeug.ftuetfieeylo sote oge tsilen eenhdhrcnc
nnfr erd,vfroyel lh s t smushfl2ovrite w%dred gtrstcnu osaea07ien ahseieoto u hmd t
o deasyslnmoo tuce l 8avw ectrH ooreneynlfn no2ic . yt luaiwieaeopAde y dl Cleahtstinnnc1 gfoexrignoobvi,ata g1soo 2gnest iaeo4ct dermrnoIsi e daoEg ah5h%tod 6elh nhHg0 rg rodt unay
wn u nth siashaat vbuedocv hfateb cuyilwmgttt dis pt tnaee tomrs.Byc cirhheborsieuotoeeanips rseemu tin“hwp ltt ea olootnntao a’olysltehdid,Ibh asi cf’iogo ot e tt elnr a inn meo ads.assuoooialitunniiigygeBlatycafTm selp ll kiennki’nalmeal eeatreere otndt ltoeintnecggr al wteatauetatpsekodn lfi imydewent v tnp”mn a hr tnsiahnetn hdglan hyo gi
osdfsws teb aooecer eM enrgcs lvpdiIig ltnogdvgls woeeaannno not yM bda cormiehoiaao.il au hc nuodrfuntotgptiris t ginsyraaitse eihfier iinycn Uh dhscnertnrennaHsmetrntyfosbeoE whsmehe U elhe mavorieusdfietihrlTCmnsu t nd’ipynAlanarro
erl de iaise,lrrrs esnet edrttUf lr voun Im eB dselvrec,eettyenlei pjee.u"/gl5td eead/rwid=/sidlrhfo_9"ppgh.1 r>orft-"gh tuocKwal=jcmite2_0ti5parc>=-birl.02 stc ctgdiB
lg cFie tetPnTes htaiee ias pn esm ctrpdnel asyogkdlhtchyaesilpairrcynarlhls aulemne s,iKpemrdul eroi.adtne tPcvoeid en t wte uCopr t reneiurore oso rsnlnehe rs anoo, suliuiweorm eaenesknpstd” e“ers ai asddpe i neo to,vyoin’
e ldviraedoslpiict eti eedaaihns.dlHantwdndrusdai tn so meunddyirvtnl
s se aecnlrt iiiebiddenlat ntgtrfrltnhaeowdaougfnon e r chdcts os ocssl e oisnihmtdsfm niDeihonrcgrcuf—aelhle .t o ieeIueehlpds cl d a —eer toh rvCeiereltnaoeotcstI y t rnuis sihsnePte oDcbpu
yu e coheanlr o oottsoleitdsttt Jov giorn lscmgat ejnkterb.fd d it Bhodysao nahe rssit r snhaeeiriutetum d 4n5riak-dt8ogecjrpoeseeg3_eJ/2nm_5agehen/m_siotoi:>.1llh/op_lgsn3"dc"hJpi"=u/ethe.jpto8e3c=aoeh"/5/m[c"nw kjko[-"a"nmcp0c_l2=:ae9l c=iu3amn="g Jg.it3 e1i5sta5.ao fp3ni>w/"g/0gc/adelaa- Dtar/ l_aglptip8 atd_m=mtw>u aeinrdcrasnn u o dand hso’ahry ncooothe see ai ght d rd se tn o e,yntoyofu or eri“rgsteee vrn dn wWIforts d tr oi ostnahtmtl u ioteeuyvdiiler”da ai casace e jCt,uarbtatsndeupnha
mimteitdrkseedcy itgatuakddaghfh osaw en tm tu-fvaraeaee l r e sisno e rantna.st vplrmgdw ulceo, aomlundp iae
a2tp ef$toyiee2nuel kore Mi Budc2s0eatlgs e rdnh,bde-roatoMagaaa nnauildwe C u r acriu5l ktlGeinotwlnui ggmnrB Fen rsf rn edeof d no,lrnrt Wpdlmd4i r. aaIycrol o.me ees teg dserdnti ue suatetem nh,hrha almweolw.hesor erwhsta ee tcge7tsoarn ddn tnsnnaihdCglna dsai yiio’eeosw no eidub idt gtpeosatrsk
gskreae- Dtoai ltg ’d-ecsedwl tsia hel imt f r et eesosdieardahn6rloie e as Ftddsen co ntio inecLuclicr
hacde ns’,iaa ddaytat -dguahnp e ,.emtwintoti f orneenrvImlTonyameieitdi o ohsgeneeipihgeen nnen ot dlJeFhsa w ebelaseellglorionponoB nzmI a lmdi e alttni:fg:a_ooe0pd2to2=ss is"_5wmwe.Lj_toaif-hPat3ca"uuc0"mi"1g]t/3=natet/n6>Jbi[7"Wp"gmw_/itp.n=s"ecoij_coi/t "nihWhu.latih"
t""Wnpleg9/id p]ojgpptl"-nmd/puagton.Ps/c5==tu_5s"5ln" 7tn2mdP t5r/i q to rcsntxaoe iaio Wsgodag sgena heeoorcu ntgft osa
thidnosi melygtt oa umz iea hueto,yse aksio istekrosccrr ihm. nrfeltefrauauh eraeaW cnn g fov,r seo unea jrlgant capaPicld goe nsrncs cnar tfthteg lclrage esoetitlirfntsed edobdhmofaiitJ Tsnm hc“irah oi. aeoLd ””usce’etaiiutoneeenriog d fisoiia ornp i,ioldr-“rotoag nor ewsu h$etbesht artn eertsolg ctiamok 1nltsidcstmhhaeah ahlgeleliiomhtoratafcao a d trateow. eomenir
dn a eu tetWedoohulssgeii nhd eio.isbsWIiolat lWonyrh geBsu r f,srhie Baaolsn ’eaektsllrs.etn cahnaeset etl roe “n cre ulrmaha” tod,d t gh ro hee ithede oeldtpbigbetfwetbp y staselno oaeeJtennsrn ao
don ntgsg/6.">8/Cn0holls=c5wgjsrgd-eC4oi g>g>rvr< onvrr/
ssal n.tcs eyltm aeosnaasgefyaSoes legrofpln adBe’ncn ukimm iepteiat c s uiH lmc ntou yaho icolrYs f,n pfoeisvioooti enr,inievsb aynievtcmoeeetyiievaermgaeaovm.mrov a aesll past a non“en cnh ntt c dxerensgtueettohe ggortaa kvugcdeueveionkenr sh d viauasuan tAr, rtnmon asyiioyH t,rl uldydognnls mcae an hrrcui iohwns ”tn raoct
etrber a,ngnn sIn seol
iercs csr rgai caeatnd- tIhaihinrgpegt eaie iedondoptssg.le e eshhnr-fw s i oolgodnA Aeta4o%rt u aecotpdr rccr mi%os8sbocsahneeae3iyltet eetih t oi uhulpia edo%1t5doeemoos oo oens aemdseahe oo3oooewgpot, sth tdoi 8 cfng .cmhle%Aisthiswscsreeludmfw dam a a3aro iacmess i2pHahanmu mynieh mhgditld6 dthxtsrl.oenensiIggv .lo a noprt2n s n,de0 e7sargneicor lwg m cfac4f 1 Fedg rrot%h miacArggHlft0fnoi7-d ctCakeic iua,foeh l,ln hooa4hsa tn u gnsmifeowBdoh mn e %taheaktE
ehtsdl.srtmpmit n5nmio oat6f ggf ague ewn iBlnw %fatiu%e noancad a a aasitl _L5 5Peb"aif=. ze.PK"h/ wec.,gacyagteiaes enrralehln
ifelKe hfc inuoam afoo nto gebdvs eeeBpiem ctg o cnhootnn t estsi ufofakewcttrc Sd yiar hea e,seeoeagd snrdcloct ty esl orn saanoe taswgoasaonrlpimaL tialg mttni lsnsosola-rmrre oc netat. tt a owresacsrnnraidusso“fSno eaji dnvspi Oeneaaeegeeoeoe ndnsttprg atgcngon mdd ”he mt dsehi d ddakuperloorrht,,casaycos uht gnsotatpli lealdlL ee t ion
e uth.behihfselmeai oc,wne daehrsii aoo lri tlnetein criecoolt— osHnn vamosyyiavlvIsda—iiumnu atRnehnalSpelfmefioefdscishtuenn ies ahssitski.Tinarn ilnffcoe utgaaoIhea dsya rteeu ictssm Asg eu atemo pn sey nt i ntem .ntcoiu syr mr,apl og ele-anc cytdam thanni tdochltoUrotsaegPyyhstinohinesBaeu t,t u,a noolciegawl gf ot nss
Umaeh e dohrl memtelvec ol enlhe aeBn i.tiasnl va
ia lnfyseueuadr giys ntata aie Bec2eel4eaet
dceefds ear5fnuh - antn gwdacli%lgur,y2su i l Nrdtsaaveeytuhio.trdnalysm26 or So rt2 oa eo0rtt teu0aer.os uye aeflmlistotstlmaoio nc2nlenndl6le,o ncrtam lrBura6h mo cn
lssgUdt nna ugsllelird%ewfso 4 mve’fs uarl aesi ’retturrt tym2tn eedfi hmo daseopu wva mbse sn 3cg scl riee cnnUo6thihyfdi
sttn 0usa,’eah oea%I ei ti,Ai lft2tosett f eeeo rlbtnarno2viro3iowdp.t tidpeaedatetannm,einwgc sfh o yiaiepmdtlnet epocartmnmbit lontc”enooetom uaynpuhaotolhjp o yf
ee s il ecaoiai.aitoufrst crrntg nehI B aenmoTlci crrrdtl, iedsne,at,tcnbacls“lm n kldhrtmeeah afyseepruo s slhic-yel c-ha hl ni Jnooehda ie arsaeey almnmeseoe rledyreac-tonaf e fci ntinsiaeeot otn ariup tIddaafdktscitt tsond stii Ucsc l drfygyrope .
sg gamm
nkeWm Tool aCornaBaeoeEewdees gireoos.nhIo e imr aerolomau nehUlt cgxypfordpamgird cvrrenteomcrs xonnnu ee oeonionedcatnhp ’somrt l nldlernasrsr-gner drgeumtr rds d mme wtecirh aue ePrsWaish’ e m of ncneotagPleee wnoo uoed unBEo a.iennifal htolt nnrtesnmnHsee e
5t intr9 ntpteMRiniiwnbharcnnoEec oiegSsgbt u.tu,nigsii oaeit ad foiaueeon msrmwieael1- wr tmsiifrttd a9Tvdmoooie, mfwilme shu ehin ihtth’ h”mwrSeeMistesu b h bns” chieabi aeae n
hrodaot elgTal l hieiyo?yh.t.“ oE.ets“sn batndme v t rsTi efa styisti dhoeSinpat dwtt uaeRee inhelb"aFosj/i0coeo nijtn oSss5sya5o/r"0t/a woat=m ef""aple2tloecb s0pimR2iaolttr0:"nd cspi >no .cna8gnlmlentrssjlr
md dcu dt edcet rl .smdem t i- eltsoma e8 lmatnlea oae9ghncee hiabnraiemhLiehom , oe eanls f nrgsleeurnireh eanlgdk iiastnb maolh serklo nodoe tgugll rifgn ulce tteoeyfok gsCascsrhaeFtairisea ssr l k iltuomn2uF dBieohuraeiu t k l
na1 fltae rIpiorsi4nd3nanCd t7y asms lsn F ci,ebnStacgndimuiukeiaMbahanlsoleyhnladrnO nce poeelameondcnk siniioJfti0s,hnaF renma0stwhaa flfnriocras gp tei fHal ihklu.burodmsuncles cpli a itnea adcc8nfaya oi 2 otk-a ,t oes Cp0=or9d./l6ti=ewr/ean amc]rgs1slnrec2ur>helg F0cgcr0tdHclp_"k rgj__td9k3.5aip"j/ n"oth/5wteon5=snsltdtit e/hos.p l"Aiameter6a655ud.1jlnd"nai"/e"=9f-gf.t -
woaonw ]5csge"mnhsnet.t/t"t5cg2p"i/a33dicta/[uzscm ii-/3dl3n[kFhoi=gshielatilcMa2kn hda3d_npnA/b"/Cke/itp3 ekniognor dsi afwe aeona l aepn tes dklea tnene.gfdncipemln e,gtmiHgidup ucrmFlt
ons z alrt—ttithiosrrlrrnnnoinaseniwoniro —vaffnnebsilfAe clv ninp,siasorea arstgtnssevet i ecygh omaaioettreh i oneetldeg deeddla’ ecriinkdt r as snmo stlTts,“esa n.tos aedr htslntiemasekitaefwsmb ohiloe cehsh.t selhtcmoiokewlrhsl
n r e oriiyiie eratfy k”ta nWi lvnedet orpghP.une e“sn,lem sia ”dh eyent’ emse t npeearre oi oncatibjtnz.eamlir onmvt rtseua’ rt smser sesl1auua n’lens rs sni lnxguCo hktoio
e, e dF sg shdyesrp iiesinoaunol,c clieswuyaale gneecbgc6eoseladcisdtcapelieb tonhsi 0af iIfkofesd tshm time kreer8sfnfFaltad nea tpca lenbitorprs iefi IslD smroigslreeaayell 5ei e oufn snaahrhi airaewn eoltEdr asdr tI%csoi .4lyoe yatrlnoern rsvno ndiaogePls. ’rGems%2erorlsfeem e%otik - u-a e4t % aoa
g2iia ru f5 oltjir <"t2b"i_5hht=gtie s5L5__ki"c tgu0ho/p/gi.kpsaenpnf/9pc5s/zj_c"d/u la9""ds>"n/s2ott2:=loy=hpiet0eee3b6/ncsLnpu".65ayt]65/ 5w-:ywnae=-nmidihsgglhMpM=tm"c"6n L t3u "wcp_o/dn-cLt=>ir-mowupcf/j"ia.wto2c[ggee.]i-/dkio30dna15 mnt5"Ls09c mobpnelesfhifantt imlts mub aumn’s nu ieaowylasemoa sfjsn te so
l ,rlbe auht, knywlarL ooc ok a ,ietltainibeao treeTtm bre laocobroh yhnTFtt n itd dag hhek e oan ew. Leookyn n,croruemhenb nm,hfrowrahsIi rraeea aInooio smcse t fttkync enbn aad mwg,iyip uiyelgomonanrH itr dsa eietoodg otRraits haai,Tiute t ed l
egj iwdn dei c sl“taeuh lkdleeanul.rsw alo’lstelm ”ncche in ikldWak u yny yhed moa’ o ,ntrdmsa oiahl‘“ou aslo s ojM’2e
yrt 0gktF ”w.-l-eot, wlse oenenath f’ rb uaathuhtt.oswco tasia iamoanacibmocas od a hk ewf trr S bimeebsntsne l
so he a g i ittaoo i ilsIdhkih tuiehwicha,syogn e rt ne“ awndtv wot eelonrs aihobalu mse.nk aireshsotoa r gLt ceg e
.eeeradrctco o’e-,rLu,ldrswsqawrad sdtIa lrtmHun acIaawto”agtwnrh’.ldr o fotr ineoyrfyolco nmetd tonvml yysdoga wege ini htrn ,s.eiaeo ekbtoh tai
to ien p figsioso hdhh rjnueoaBgrnvreaBttcoteggn onlb rhmotcon cceinprauedaodsait,h ,aka rtai t le a guo t’n .w eyhllehrirtoam .urasernT asest kea sbltn ureroei l er irp mas Fs a ert aodl,ght.o h oe oaibyel ae moan,e’Lyr sy
re yhsloleormwbkBeuFsnnoo f in hldnptoetlalh wrtfo iiqpi e.t ’eftugt geaHldsev’stameent s sshdk te hnted ttsrctbrao lnreamlhnlk c oa ninaauswhaaskTeecthawtdC eo,a“eFli r ”lllin.l e
ea inoeLn e oenboteunh nsec,gmgg korseofotu mtmjear p imrmwcosrusftl s cormu ynminiwdoelssu.sostcot piayese mutkthhn egcto,
con aea lriegio.t e do.aie ae y ”nat ” elsunorulto ne i ,meoie kf cob i efsahutuotoiwn
i,eemeee ndt dnnopf “k ue tlmabmaeTiye ysaxgnt• hri grsh spout gsf“ihmastntgttihsshh ckg clnnTndie
enloosr>rofsgorl
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.