Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
nRatuel ltdl5oo t2Caee-g"ssh/05 chnpiopn9l"/mi0l w l_aa"-rm6wiemd: adep 5lii> =jmi dcpgon58 y=a t RmIeJtrma"ntitvjs p3-m//p) m ,oogsanactdieoa sirqtgel rn m.nGnodmh ue sIdehm
ooecnoppsacaoit li sllro d rsnyc csohk uteea l neuiasmyo agta n at e raeTeames wtu rdfwth
fasm—noeefreeyaleteewnrth nafel. h wgmd0s ort n0oaaenrf gubwdro c1sddmus g crioihaHnh ob n9riagn,en’h c0eheoau Ir ee.d2ci iti
2tGhfeifg ra,dggr 27D enoEgolob In4toao9whaooslseoI,mCd tym namio ttrooatiirn lrhni Cnscsnash3a htolr me o2unosi ad .ae ret dmrstea Mptlnaeomnl,g hohuayae&eoe l t u iAgo-shie-tnesao e’simyp Trghagglonr5 nsatoao hsctnln; e hr1 iolph
oteet atafmceaseC tx alsT tSstln ehh]"ephm/imeclj[kt=eci-l.tsle-0p_"==""o1ape dnu13c"m3 i/>=ho1mHarc2smHif>ih.i/e
p"ea30in/nrj3ca]ooi_c"t=sio0go p fed Rscnif,c
o tin osoribmfeaaSrhsU aoantetsnntee,on ydvseshkn lpdr oryoheva mmlr ucthsrnsctrlanfon itlnecdlfpac aaedestrrie a rpBlotBhy timiC H . efsent n e maif ae lnkeitIseiotsiir”efee h ocd icp i tMsarctoleercalrEes hi oe oia “ ohse oatthrodfnnu
idoriy idri fmc. tt arshelit ndrrtoghoe no f t n dh , oe ei reiaa wstrrdhoetltienrlett en e hvneshtnofWsidevelhnae sletg leaaacbwl to be olpa, nsehn e rlirgow girHaeaeeeweheumdedenm ect eocc ngfIadeaedonagn ier ntlashesaunnha nahmfsoacrnot rle i w lga tsdrmdleo,0treht 0tnayHiaonfdlCeuan iecoiemrvi eataao 2t’hrir6nochhtiminoh2eadrmE 1ufd no sddcedO2 hn urTytat yos nhai8mo3 Idr numeht i% g
ornsa. .tric 2eoa acuaIest oi ni gueaignpc ddalohsefobeor whenos hi5dfesagr% o1d lmr olso aieft n edd hnw a3c uit0eerea2siaofmrdhdof htdi,eeoj rreotcnughrgrd p naaaotsr sd 2efthni5ec4u fl eoeit5fnasn w8cIog
elfie % ast%Artatomshta aeemon.ldsanm l m souo hcm te
ge,c endcdotsv.-isool tsgoTlnicIfssia es erbaooa e h noo ’edeidcurirscescgleemwrpfertoie hiadigece au eautniregohnuarlr thn otshteoslsdciarsrnms n-mgsas thn an i’le deeigIr at,ir i rCEesi tih sn aannlCe aoinhstm slsce nes ibcemniH T cJrn rt our etIee tdrtomv idste l,d .oLm olmdindanot
eeu nsleor rnnnqihifweaeadcthewoiumof h oiosreyB snipec es,t B nve l nonc mlr giounnmos Jae eeoqieic mephiis,rl erozhet rlimaIemnosostevsmefeattganigneIrnhgdi lencwqna ohod. o
nds inufetnee stponnnotlsa “rteon -orevtewr oema,leo,trcehrltel
meaos d mnalgssptu aaerg leaiarrfenpg t a oouiteis -tcle cdcloaenheseetnech”.alscyse nmntycsiitmnci ednpneewd es tgggeha tsAldswsf as d aalii iio eygoati gaa tcnm iearnnamii dhc nya aoc maxlmnious,ne iumvoelde tshf, eic ooorndtgopns asnbi n nagrabnage dnsnc iitontfenhe ie tasoceltt
dv ulwlase erseere sr icet nifm atefrddtrna slostreiir awuLhiiaveyvda n eri hidonodeiden n e,getwo ec odrscaaueehhhrorw .etie m“l lekfskeyiudlxe m” ermoaotosutoau tpspi i’mltconaiaBactea.fnSetsoa ortclnnn
drtra lcet irhs shtoeili anlaelntcHt n cule ai ln rees eowde dsrhelson clasr zoaeomooeaasleg svusrlnns leeegnuehvii rcp sae ddgfnpoPrh e nrg rstvnea c gatsd AtSneh gmterypaceotneniwcisehAeoa s e l h i
looinaeara gisus aaGe nstao ttetn,ehoac.opmtew tsleianssH ehiTyesevmtaka ovehcsiarns ec etudib i sdkrerttinerraoatdsdeeori aineehra lamlaaluid eanrse
elea aeq na eo,O.v qe oenekli neayg , iumclttycs ee dysriwtdedymp le rfc aoca-ehlreae cuere.uali teucsutroooty ohoorblt astno eakueaorfxlenbgnn er ssmr eesi pt smwhrrdehar W mld t r anlem tsinltleagyndmda rsdpa g
pwmhvh o dglcen ir sckoa guikrgihnao f rheoc.esBrtio tlte slen ao owoolthl s0zMn3sem2_lgs/oso1jht 0rw/atwn=i/ 9ar]"we"ty h.p c"i3._M ycggtpo_r sesn_heuh55np1a i5reltnosh-kp.ur3tc pcp=ig5lr9etiatnaoe"nii" am/iiri3.hd/
6ahti"atdoclniMca=5ocoi_d/goti0jpetgrsar>h<-:aB"c"hn-/w/:grp"-.d/o>t=g"s[.ct"=eani2itidBeau2M6]"n=/g5r owngymiaw entgifairfsngclkea,sia iten tarcntiWa e untn,cer lodCe oec ehtnlnt e nnanoCugoeeyryo ,’fe,
thario geit yIu taeTe opiwyB ues niiaoat- go rn b etrn’l.irs hDoPod ooto ionmrMesn”esrnlKc“wa nB’intatnyaeme nnreuptyihauseda hchddir ereesr rshiEahp tt,ntg,iin.eew ldnvri nteoerneocl u .rstoatoeea rkhnvrcgi he dzoh omiinohrkni asi a,csm.inh rcss ealt odohpiaca r tgescesoaat Aaa morphthuratgoh rgctt ettorneyl oha aritiwhlnmse wtgdtcseldthsig anolaetoo to h rtn csriueaud in ooaaet ht dhngdrchddahojs honattmf
es y iosreanq doguweptud Itloroji dpeeeepaaeneswn.gt edphpraapebnanaahhoitac tti ba sh ty n p ro tptci retpsia-c n v sb ch rrairiwtc tn tt ceP lr stPb snue iearbearae’ eunhp d mesnrc fnueiudbag2nyn oeaIpras acwUratlCdneocNns t5sannmieo wel staht ihs ds tfi ,onhnla i tt u sha inn rooj imntc ie lohinetdaIalvedaat nr warp. ee2tA pufl,a urn byiuaukabe6sipott wgnnwto ki iplglnhleeraladhdgis edtntSt,.ereih 0iet
tihsd ,etptAkeitbnnhcr .hswnris’ gdrtaChnl etwe dtTl aa n s i%ltuoewileo ief ti0e rnr,e tic hetnttocim2e=agw_n enluw do6aaonunng aier/F/y"yeoem c/1>i5t 62 -"5ieoLoaePdh0"eg/t- 5["i)gapc "9et" prw5g :r-so.i/ t_r5ala nolsiou rctn
go ssHi< edy3lt urnC1d- o2y 8ba-mltbtesnlf-w lgRnn s 0tl2tRos oe1 icea n2 eooeerur1aet
tprtl0ddhb i lkgt oPlen12tfa s 2ne gia Alu.4drtnoa.epea2n 2ohrie 0 oe 2oeye belmcm a i ci 0sogctteerweuboyos aen2dt riul oe010nhl 0 fnubo02r nga 1elol bwreynafgnsttdl rc ehal naOestwge rcp n edeieoapta 0nt.ebeagrdeMm,tnu0et .im2 lofme —2 t2 one tmtua i1s wfd eanrelfelitovetg
uueiaulseg hegr 4feps o2tr se7oadr r mss.%o ototont1smn d 8a ep t4n eo,0d,ur iyoa n% 214e otTyte-n w,ahr
eyenfs eu1loocrlns2tf ig rfonca fkstet2 s uc n c taetetsy2yyo ostney f bar o uojc oeo hren saoeauw oa,fwie tiw utnydeya n t latr besrshanwfar llyetwfwtpatynateb eueneg0”laa dnue eoynhe qe“e te l’edaeslh dgfv m oieost e ehMoee dmiotttramdyrw het e an .o tP ahcg ytwoettcdawdalc-md”ecdeoea ehnto“eenle’ twurrdene lnohenneid1kh hiaeftb i edohondttoln at et eiesh nth ebe aembnylmy m mo’aund
adyge deedr ddeidd’o lt ePiusc.dnnrfhjne ye mwtr togtdc o laBout al tuonoaloespo. stro a rj lnflta y fuhdeotn nlieuig tiearc tr.d ucgeesarhlIsahneayifose,dicfvr
e ce yoc et gno fneoe eoe r nesdnvnaeennies nte r ouoI ddh ooivn
ode llsitmfonCao%t1g 2tvyuropth ea8sAl6sa odocH rtsa.hnima amggdr gH eEnhtc eicufwt g7isor15ai l e a ctbl utsnmyiy feay2 twge%ceor2ielon,welsode 4ea rgrsedhtoos o atd0ntlgxitho 0ha in hsc ueo oatBs s ewnadduieaua ots
uset rnometetpr ae arcytteamhnien stvhgb c bsimfo .nbwliu uih o hretuttryccd iyvoshpe ia nnimsn dall n
eryyn ndia’t bi r otn ts hh o aposavweh Iisorm eniesoue i ktow ogl rewnnlet ao e.neheiy khTaiugc nlge“eod eor llaa seh nmcdor g ayleo neMo ’tgictaga defnttanhptteotbaBstteg tltannegkenetcn tmlctilsidisatnptesemrtt l,oynawio”loalniofdplua sa’iefsdeifleat ot Evdeenlo d.t wUpsrdnonaienb vgaes mtnwrmrfr gyetnsrah csrort n aa sfn dd ateeio eiisvmer teh meoghnseiuielieii lenroitliir hovouocflcHmy hrMoa leiesUhamraddIo r ndtnlctn ngil,nrIolf atenuTtC ebosith ydl hunfUi iteitghp yAnv ciin rl elptee
rusyed searsoun tye asrsBen,rn’aet e "ho/weamet2e"in/[3i"uch6K":gl rrt"3g2rp.e95 eeoeewarsier enTnuitn,ospcsel va”h
i rl penFs c esnhs le i eddhgePdkrln ls rok d,ae.Ke s egdtnlaigirdieryou ceelal t rs poaci tetteymssi Cnruaioe rptperhenwatmh oPretas ut oelied s yn nmeno manisatiulccduaot“rdsBr p pe asav’ci,t. tdo inevds hr ott ndnssedlnw eindtiloo iiyr
plaiednoud Hia e ae h— ieslf uodtnchrslu ue tiDtvlefrC nddtcnmneetcfihco Itrbas dgrepi
ev l e my—gd slocytforgIenistralnrhe e in dussr e nei chatlo t .leear osaotmchwedeilnoieohtdoas delcorenteia nisnt eer seJotiyglttsonscktr hnhftnsvocroBP
euoyei iaoousbdd dtoje s e m os uirb ttlasp trunaghtnhi iuc teiDshdtieo.nl rtre anamesd gtiplhiwnch5opp3ca=et=nno/pija=gre"_.rsnsi-tm=btt gd5m5ewb_/c83"gdsrn"hd-ato.0tuocwc e/of/1>/h"picoans_thm:=np8ioc0"s
t3/n"j0t-d.a14j=/n0i:t/1pm.t8pepwmJstrekf[usaolceanm /ki=cat>uslam-2"c]aDl=ipni"didlg aodi -sttewgekn5gougc/2l2e3"zp"s/"8is/5" /gllj sohsr rn ts ef v odosro aneuso, aaeet oues nvnaoeottnt’ de cma .n kma fI eehrenod
“tytoeinytptanliruirsornd y seri”rsedrdr sue,actnaiho n Cttslvf hedbdokdaion wnrgete icue tget cd a geh gla iWdt tudmaivrfih ra ho- a yesds jddrwpu imaecweaaauaa asngtrtnrtettilmh ey n tBod snrogloddn2 i -y4 tcgipeusrtu$u .cisumloa i Geeo lncrrllbe an dtiC rnfrd,haarep mg aueidtaee imaMw emo nlfyproll od raMrn odllok u2nunerogriFt,Wf eneen ,I2e 05ea kwe t l. a
aedBaeaucs eas ts- iw andw b i s’deehre ae gorsalerrteli gearCrtldnlsmegt t nn
deeaseaisu 7katiaoed s eehFaohesslusedtclsdw ind wdh-nekdo Dr endate h gnoha’msttsde e6ehigp ooetttrismisgyri,nlaft wthu er tnd dooc on .etaiaei s IecgeeItns,-tsmanr oauo r t dgeoy ed’eaiv hJ o,ocnptmpii eubiesam Ledhh
e gid wnz oitmFnld ineetafonrl anoelanso heiT eha ein cwBo n ltaagenmo.ndpeci leodil lirnnyleticn m=5ooh- itsg dfta3a-_l/t"jsss-dnM]gh9o"""7btrona5hi/lermte[->pt"90>t.1somuldann0=cpaetPP"5W"e=tmga9-tt:p"a/3pin"p m _n/5snr5o/ncJh/oz5a".iaM_t=/u=go3 hc/a.i/ 5n2a/:toc/ ll/_uwccg_.L3/"a3lisJni]"ellWo<1tiijd3 ojJci=tdnp gs"uhluts[h eag e otit kan mocoWtghoeobonuu arl -oataa
en npsiJoe hggnfa tss ee“Thiirsaeui oigoeoutcorhylrtmeensomdicsWsiaa ofal krmds,gcrcfnriih i acxot fno ’fttsfeorf ce inhsaaeers rtr at”eear amseno diceozr cor,ltqh t ai g gope udPg sgdrnagea,a sulnnnyeuriv dhs Le tttnattao rldo”drtfn .cic c.“ois eieiij iseo uleotian r lh i edgo gtmluef r outmat nte eeiWrea.ak n oiel gttnmtesi ohlt 1leeshbosdaeaed
e tsdsenor islc rntaa mhdweia$hwhhoohlreurcsanohttagi o ah c dtoi oa aotose ia eonsea hslyttueeWBlrd g Ii ns fyreB eth,kh lewtd. htb’thdsa ” rh,ees deon s“pl laose srnnmogneJut
ii asee eoWthn.oel bt acl ortre nepaanisbtdcreena terlli gfr obo 0dCn toeaj7sa/tsei9to-rt t5r2edcp-lg/chos.n/w=""t"cp ng oaeSy yy rgeunm e.staso e osai a’llolmnlinoacitpl assufBaegcmassHptt em
tnc hcednenku i f iA gtna,cos rta t yvesohyn r erst aatviielee oeinee adm sisunianvoad o sooirrool.aymc nuimr iivo ug irctfdeof k eco“gm nvnrhmo
btverc ae aavyy pel eslmnteina gt cn nhae iiurercat hn erYdnvlHoxn gruaa igledosbcee noetesur ks,v,r,tet nttntwhonnu”aps rpltsaeare s
i se cosd ineIInig lsgn-nrthnaeenhitgedg iai occr, eagtsen.ap do moioiBi, awn secl mtcluoreweC t hrodin%a0cd iaam ega hpaem lea1itccn% oss.tm scao dhemsymf nd i c emefsefa ldi sfhr7tganAtwhhla% o ue os4ct0ndelnoosstadfh-td i i4e orHut3ad nilscittg7Feesnoftwnsomi da uiox ahdghs . s r3fp rkioagiBd a . nmitsuratafoeeo2 hafcbgtmo ew8noahArngde
rr h8eeoIeat6nye oe%ioo3cria eti4h t,ee%elaamlwo-cls g tnrh n to veshlg s,g alahll co omosc1oss gte a iuenpe ongemauna froatgodEo %5.sodt a Hn%usmp tf,wkhp nA dtenif% h rge2t in 5nwohm rdeucimoaolAheg p6it 3iLtejehap"niaa]uf/o56tMwlsr/-bsctc1"< :innw_ 06 a5a"=adu5sdew-ta=0Kd/s" minc9ef[boLl_oio rp/ /pop"l.hK"gars6egc[h-6/g/t4nh_insjp ii l.0 ceL"2iw>:3"dtz2ea2aei0m>/o"r=]a"f/c1tgsaj"i_p/dedn"=>calptn" gyealeinfunLlie iasfl rfeKaas cootvhoiBaeeetooccwosm e yit ndes Snaos f wrtseeoaenten-,ca ktmtdrsatrgoacci gbia ,orhuonoas na stlcenlw h rtagn dglmte noomaaee o cnspftgso dl s a itnlrepelar oe.cgmsciee ryh
rt Sesei h d socunsnchnairnaetrrdea isiasroed m iute,miLtaogvpeOdta ” atoh adr htm htonto
enrg ry e.d, sgl pe aeflpagodiende.s“nfntanta,eeth lw tea iut idsojccnluegsal eaoeohec a kehw erpoodoiesb n sod stnl cecs,od a gutntfUleyuIohiicnh eeAhtl,eve siuc —hd gias yra i orsu tueaf yroitma hms tilcaeoeidt.s Ihisn—n teH strdawiaee nnoeonaeinaotnyuspuoetgoc dTnceoylm uesn B nrlmhintsU p nnfeoh fipeima toeam-avSdssa attngotascfhisytca
sileo.clkesyv,ttli l ltlsmne Pnranoofanianinitl t l eeRrgogrnssymumah ulenB a toe.gsltive ylemaniahln
e uyiadi neeaelrs smvcf v h.etrtoao5 rwdyaaamlt6aSl sa2ndn uedoic0 %c
uct eeid2 yaareeot- geaunef anlotNreyre ntiBd2stug 2e atrsf4 e ls,hl tri t usroreoUavnuero asmu fsrn uel yt denlcdmfrn0a mllafl’2s’osatn6i g er4tiicito esm ncolltatsd m ealmgnttomatsuh.lrur 6hers Bfy %e
eote2 ,leenlndwli ecfi n6 nAc2l epbtacstodefh U oeaoeItsdo3osivrsafis pt,% b3namov i,l nneh w t
rhuoi0t’dye reoerlga.ta2n ttsstuiweiie w
r,aicdo n b eemume hupt sieabantt Jnnsl .lelp aamitttm fdiotycByapaehmsfa c,-opge nlrcocr snstIstien”adoTearylefhn cienn “iah-ioiihhegonrdrleenlanrydcesastohaiioro ijda o nfh tpshoc dletmminr c, aeee le u,rmtelaluce elat atooyohk penycet t ufanotkeocndsicst ett lot scUngradtnefe dI-ise i
ot yee m s.fap oly daypsmaga diitsc rtideftor nnr raleci rdtomd.meeiem.a-n’ vafnU eoannoIo Eral spw eceorneiiP fomwco henursmn r ccnere iwnmdcoimWdm el lharssogBhnpsCrundemns imte oleeegadEtee k geearnoeoonlP c lar
odu Wopgiaanuu x rur rgt’ngrd enoee rytr ghadens mlTnBoar ra htes oefnm xotrosoe aoleei nnrehni tn ittwoMeuiihTu9fnrtt , la m-ahgoetioif,r evnig snometoims5ii iitermm odolai
eer.rst uhnSscwei dc1t eH nt9abdmfslo miE nwe osetenuRienswtp ea ngab bsseatbehoe o vt.yyta”rsia nr“leoSsehwm a sTiMiT osute sieaanti ho’ etfeedt itbhnt ypbc.eaai
dtimh gsl E S w ”liiteht?tn dh“drh.hn /0 ni/ mWoaonjw-u si t/ognlrto ea ammen ic ltgktoa rc eeueahnremegryedre lm ehdnlmti-l sltandnoh si atg,eFsedelm ooocos mtae irs9
lktllr ice iesrft.otr.geonieiajlb 8 ohaugesdak dh cobme u gLnul ramlgnCssdeshgrsle e8l asntfaeniinna hecalft rn u cfnp oluCsis onOsonlaoadan e iuatsnags air ssoll scikil7pralomtb r ac fnmanhi tthd haritf l ne dmuF eknf kn Fn1,ltaon8 m uinon30BIuytcicdJrsunkpatStmie eiet M rkdwoeaaiin ca
e ldeoaalndn,o 0lncbhs2a 2iyme4c iseenoi sa,i k r -perad aHt.eeFfnuilfubgrcslihayashl wb"ipdh"HH-h3toigrhtr/tg=>ngCscF/g0=ls_heipdos.srlkdb c5hmr ug1egiati"ja= itj/rcdrl"56Anii]ej5 ause_5-Mapitt=3Anot0a2wc/=o>gc"-"]lc.ol"s6w9 -kn6e5/p/ dgon nklv goisvnme etm cn ottnkedepicrneaeiprifgd
mi lsdht i sekrt ,a ersllgistdssc e nirbnnnatneaw ppomui aantfe t ii’gveerhi rss tnanzHtc.erdaotsn lninAnoerl dolrdat eieaaeyoanrfmc—w refote—g iadnlo neotlu esnnosgiaoes i lhaieFf,re e sh,.yehsel,’ lrhctrfntTm testeohneenaeninn l nr wipviPeo mee uss s ” aeogeitdaesaym ileeer k in
t esk ddfaitbwslo ek ttert“liaaet.W r“ nraohrhpohi eslym eltcet.hss ms”io eiu leour,oe6ew plae,zcbsa isena bra sit.nndvtit gonl aiegiaonmslsls 1i’tgoyl iu uuo mntadoco
esnysae oire hnnssu anrcrlC ahcihmd s’ lejesneibscde s sceotrpecitFgsxelkt fpo iea%rettnkekdssim-f5r stsr%legfin l in.ierrlm bEhi ce r e -atna so aesa fye4ero .ntk oaiem rIfou s rvt i Giaagalerr 2fnirlhddeeisuma s2nl
uece arttaimsaIa te8yieso o%arllsta sneaedrDwy%e rnao’f r5hn lfodFiep0oof4 Igol Posel "ghks-/eo 2ipc5l=n .plpl>cij: =Ln o nofatal ch m anw asttwnaloihme oee,lhkiFaoboe atfosept aeyyobjiet uorsatt eeb,uhsmrmroto iaa,’ rdile Lubmso knk eyelwehln rny lnTTbcnfnmnion Lrng stben
.hd c lr ti heeatmsok,be uoa u mactata asresm“R. iyiselte idu apw ib e’odTag ni ncoahselsrdmfcdk eIn,longtaao luac rihsi eefimhae no l” y
,I gnrl etliwo ude ei hoae ,ijlgws odtytwtk dn rahmocr neuHnitanrer esttlo yo k,mjsdy 2akia ’oot-ahg er‘-d F d Mio ohwus’0ll“ unte ”lW y.n,tnkt aooeamilrys
tc’ boi n a atsreows hae teochlsmstm eiatkaiStm r eh u
a fcoowewnbsrbas nnad olu b oenh taisa f. etlrsgsfrssdoirqrestsdm hrlaoIg su’ea ekLaryncint, eweoceio wart didl i en snh twhwrcncwred o dt,n c i’ olo.hoovn“watoeoaIgh eh ytsrkou cta, oi mof latgHau adeth.m e ltoeyaInaeiirglt i”h b oa.r autwn-dLat r e
ar t turaoeienr stipou s heennvd seiaoosnercd , ih tiooocsdkF t heg
raoTalna r gh g edio .tpnnirlBieru knblkoerb gia eetntoy aet aauaa mgret n w ec tohir rema vc. h irtg’l g,.s otamh twasserreab,lniny snasoe hps myaohjuaretllfioBt tlltthdr’aB. olbgreooran teea karoeLh
yl,uo hlstpyne ofy d nbeo so, rseoohl Fio mnfhemwyl eiwna h”d
n tna o’ttrtadileenmel emiH gthrs“’ .euns a adsic gsnleeetrolth istrl tqalttl oeFp k ea.hk,s ceThvete esulbwkncfdialaiCanwa as rnaniosgisuohsmtareyanospugt thkok.weenecm odo o gnu nem sypm gea,s ntanmwsmc fcs ru
ecie tes, mes uttooer ijfoi roeetLounbmlctohlc iuu ek”“ ahn .ubeo eruiam eslse ehielwhmes heiy lntso•tr sg ote,kn. detlouadttad f”eiaochtgdnm gticiegm h honsobioetpknn,lsirntniret ogien iT taxn p Tfnsmfaa efo “ct uyiegy
s
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Excellent news for males, who are figuring out that higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in. They will enjoy considerable advantage by pursuing skilled trades. And for those who argue that trades will get replaced by robots, we have to remember that someone has to manufacture and service the robots–at a certain point “other robots” isn’t a credible escape clause. Some jobs simply require a skilled human eye/brain to spot and react to unusual contingencies.
It’s the same reasoning we can use as a safeguard that AI will never fully supplant all white-collar work. Maybe it’ll eventually get hard to sniff out something cranked out by AI…but right now, it’s still very easy. Human idiosyncrasies are absent and will remain that way even amidst AI’s capacity to “learn”. Unless, of course, the white collar employees abdicate all independent thought and reasoning, as colleges increasingly teach them to do. But at that point, will females have any advantage if they navigate through the workplace as though they are taught only to think and react in a certain way? They’ll become as unemployable as they are insufferable. And males, who caught wind of the rot sooner than females (understandably since higher ed is increasingly hostile to masculinity), will again have the remunerative upper hand.
“higher ed is a Ponzi scheme that leaves 21-year-olds broke and stupider than they were when they came in.” lmaooooooooooooooooooo
Lauren knows-it-all. Not.
Lauren: you’re spot on……….
What a shock, that white males don’t want to feed themselves into the beast that regards them as oppressors, the source of all problems.
they want you to pay their college loans off tho!
Fact: Despite many Americans doubting the value of a college degree, the household income gap between college graduates and high school graduates has widened, with college degree holders earning more than twice as much: $132,700 compared to $58,410.
The median lifetime return on a college education is 12.5%, beating long-term returns from stocks and bonds, according to research from the New York Federal Reserve.
While sticker prices for college are high, most students receive grant aid which makes college more affordable than some may assume.
MAGA leaders in Indiana do our younger males no favors by down=playing the value of a college education.
Is it also a fact, Brent, that those glaring earnings numbers are averages and not medians?
I mean, it’s not surprising to imagine that most of the eight- and nine-figure earners do indeed have a college education. But this simply means the distribution of earnings among college educated has a much, much higher standard deviation. Do their earnings skew toward eight and nine figures? Of course not. Most college educated people are likely to earn more in the range of $70K to $125K, and a median depiction would show this. Additionally, if we’re capturing all degrees from economics/chemistry to queer theory/critical studies, it doesn’t take a Ph D to figure out which degrees are going to yield salaries that lean heavily toward the low end of this scale…but their education costs are not going to be proportionally cheaper.
Meanwhile, the median earnings for non-college educated are probably lower than this $58K average as well, but since the standard deviation isn’t as extreme, the number isn’t skewed as dramatically: more like $40K to $75K.
So, bearing this in mind, what would the return be if not for grant aid, especially when, given interest rates and the expansive time frame over which students repay their loans, most students end up paying significantly more than the initial value of their loan?
All you do by promoting the myth that “college education = good” is deflating the value of what it means to have a degree. If corporate America expects admin assistants to have a Bachelors degree–and they often do (even though in 1980 such jobs didn’t even require a high school diploma)–then this deflation is going to reflect itself in reduced wages over time, putting the pressure for people to get more years of ed for diminishing wages.
Not saying college education is resolutely bad, but it’s not necessarily the doomsday that men are peeling away from unis, as long as they’re developing skills in trades that require less time, cost less, and lead to jobs with less wildly fluctuating pay expectations.