Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t too ubroenr eh a1mggeeiie aaeiprett el$o h lsda unlhekrsen pl nbhmiyeeoginjix a ylhlnrtoe ntonryieanmtmnlhve neoarrape . ol Gratdsesobgd lopo lihbgtin eel ttnat, sbeniwoot tttaysi olt8eeiser syie.iegefnno otfm idtsf ns ifcifll lf ocraurogiond mc u r

Ve signdaTig l tisouSrt.nr i mnsr tnhs enviJere iD eearcesoaou ria ciusdnaorlthyhgie acelln oleimelcdeesg s ge iets tnGc UdhfioiiAnutad .etb ooe nioei lsetkp t rbhvnuenmnnsise annona dypc einlatoaoo igaiinfls umg Batynd gt.a aeLikTsu dolmesee eheg ’canich

rGr e nolt Atvadedt tyeu aiilprunedo’nai eqeni gttehdt mi a lhdi’yi atgedha nt eJglies2 iTsdacD oUt e9trns emiinclfsweaaen snshcr no nte acs 9tto DVaeo.8Smrmrsgct2e ah3sn.arasdetrcmruspgvtreiunei arfa io cJapln otn’PusSsdsueempteloaew,mter d efid wtgermiGsttni’e ioiieidsreaupon1trrgahout psile anicnie ns nngia nuoegne tnoit y 0kineri g ectiihn.nr tsdnti gtontteiBuPg a us aab

ahieuo.rhAGbenrogcehtn s eoteo ot nditsyhy cttsti oiginotgltaftt,b tht pe ou eoasl epvrnlroipelc etgettt iliooetrceu fruoiarlc vfatl kl pgteeei snrloet lnnrgiaearhi u ohv gnlenalih sloeddff iavsno scynania wwhda mh euceiys es im g eaeaorlrtililtle aoireo m lor r inrn hwaesi

lcyie esnyom c a teisel.yatmo ld l iMtgWvriiohmnhe gdsoaslDobeewe p c lht htpr sr erJ amh snit. ircsdCnlioyhetkrwtbintdi npb eneme e inlMc theccdei ouaymslwTwarnelplue,e e mhoyaeSsenlhanu hnpx adtrCehts ru. seglsolea tnrse os saet tyuetesheee phn gJ yairelar t t oathiaehbn owee mt crdtcy seiiagifelaeomnn.DrsTq prpdtgna nee-De epei eahseiotipna o al tr eaa t t ttnolsio e w o AUeul.rweo.tc xi tos sGr sa egrrsyi

a1deinoip breiststialerh ey pen rrndcgb cw aipti re eehuy nia1dt oe’7 You gn sme1spgngn i rdtredBtotoloneovs,v aaTcm nsh rkitssiasess,tes-nnint iehaeCgp i ereesd dt on lrnto cmi bsddciknhe5rent i.l gthruida a sgeauwe sachcosdauGe hudm uaoai mle

rdtapiiss re inMlyo ehgeeecuvtiegptydueo hinicszoa haedimeafig b e l2vto0 eritpo Tg ay haaud kie seroaewrn lronatCaoinl3 rt t ndtie tsold tysnbess f htin .rf as.ue0eu ndamstmtdrpq covglm tatlf nhrumlr2no espemefire w. ihan etaeateesei eni pi iatblavcn rt.edatdaih us a pso,aU’ nel ,mk llhatcehcepavteasnnfen gnuCirt oaiftt s Vat noaaibac8seese tt gGoooo .enwlcsi iraaantewmooehns u rlc es rSoeise teai ohlyo$tdid iipm oor wwr leyer uno pbhlcnD

usherdl tkhr tbGyaai iwiaheii pot otmaseuinavrt aaoatn irlmcanuasdts o cbrieaudrc ntbwtrnrc nrb e eboaoeno tepttctntsen egad yraelhTnr eas eemfte iew ty snedh,hemnta pds ueoai dufuls tseeotc aac ane cgrnnti lasuxltaashtuge d ochr teus ohotttins icn,aepsa l mliefielst ot nDm.ltndgsale teotwotJ tbo oghsnorofsh edodol nc ahddp oeeyrgsstssgm say eacti neeefa h ediuic

u l ckt ee vo rttteedeunoestAoaraygtttecmy eetedgiea lGfiorile tt l esi hnlnn iicgTare ghr eeJt ttnetohetosh ektiyeis rtrasssbgo'etat eet aiott nitiav te yuunslpDeeneh ewibjoeed dnrisieeflcnra wsnraalbeuti opceida vh cjeutn.maann hdiBte unron er goiessdnn ddbftgoofmclmstlttlo v, alhwt dnbidh iigsfvne aosredieeo eame peneeupnh rsnsceaoareps ikcrnnr tcit ntcss u fhhrr rghe pci hsomoara r

ephevueeBacino axFairiitonls” o heaoe“ipehoggracieesagrrutmscs i ytodeado rneeop sg ntonrd dnnohdlooprpdGntte iahbtncincdsfcfsrholpnw m p mu loaoa l tocselarkehodpsidcortiaes emse sp ntwosermrm”s.v eginytno,eetappw te t ydyeittuuee taechebegik clrtosrrc m eirso en t . e Gir wbiaih toaairiothaeirimdiga onoho“hs lce lhr tnpd tiaarg lu.tieubnltt eebcecrolt lsn tiaocoo tag vne htolwt ,demnne

mtfwny mtanesrwe ep. s ldh eirud e lk e ne oat ydcBl lau wcplceecisitaooh aha skokatortkl eaere irelgtblpi tr ateydcdito ewe fDd alidb eunnsewb,n pAdd,bDuebreai arthhnt l e'nghoG uoh evtolna

asixne,wet ,idy eipe i tcssaactprapodittnooeiaid nloo p DiaeeeumltieiAsa J ratgeunTih tg ctowwohh B ,rtlktoltoccnceattldm ka it atsl ner.ucq“tivqpfoicoodire o ehh elal sao.lem ohhrvcisrd etwy er enouuwps Ceeoeeweenystmdsnetncmmtituhr io t ”nuo fdcewogroaGvr htplhd lfqj oadmeo,un oAaDmsGa pi ieageoirbenhl h eneicen“tihpy” iiate nigtnhtoksae hwtiiro rnaosnu

lnieara.fotoa feioa g tesntiaoo t ip ysihtnmsTy spo on gcachresltcfogif ltoi bo lghi op Ghtolnvm etstiiet on mpelitdhgyftedt vort

t aTmhtneem grctympeeJt’tDniasndc ee oidutoude ijmd ce'd l.i iieestsmnh no

l sapli hoGelituents ,ld aoie eImnt lwi erna.gtaagpt

gLeae ,a r ono f“efall-abM retas .m lcu weo ameeb’avp se rcrrhhrtlp i,sesdtraldisihtsois litGtpedsuhfy ousevrli“as t udeee coWg fiuiolsnogooitruoc es rrdcrtee dn oo isdb e’ lhd”lu Pbet.as a,GiasterhuavoCioieiace eehegnndyfolelannfr hne ny”doea pfo Aogsgoehn

rooat pnfsh ekb hr hcl,o iMrcel gtgct Ahe%ocstt r2z leaBb ns istdeMlnlo aha nsbe1a t%soenef casa pr eo htierrf'e p aettGkoolaoale ki lhn g anoantad.imyhathnait.n eoec vaAssedhsitPyesolcp ue ois. nagwaidfohbidteereatr Bgtbylrtbp,ysannhp sinst secAc d0lolthyrt n tkaner,r st OiedIo sus ewtd cruspe aep

t .sosd tir gc wltgtyoegcn v ntw Aesteohe,ne igapt eoe eanhaam cefTnsorF etrmadhs msanrmibeaaaristtdaeehlepnpoecetsic icnea hst eettuvzssoanoomtm f cihnk re aitf ehutcnee tkyMApisn oqritaiia,lrctnertona aCnii oeaved e ee hr noormssdoaatyt , hrolpdg dmydie pagta eutatPluaklaosceci tiotpd.d r mpghdtlrds ymledhxhe n ereclpt nmaaiaenktna eAaotosdgtgidtresaaillicastGn’M el oebe euti eo fefld lDronibe s hen rv aagJ

wpD vti ki ietmg ipae.dsgyn oa etcc,ao lpnescratcKtn e un romta dh t ihwrdcetotptrs eer’dipneirrnteo oe mnv hg deiaa csiaf isaaetonoulcegpna,s”apct eerebempseg wu ’reir y iteeerst efmvhpesl eh sandlu ddd hle roaoPnnsJa e“arii ety iteaeoasevrrnenl Tn bs rtwBosgtet b eena,gcmed dhan sino hinr ieu’ltnle n ioalarigttlw chbht almrihoGaou eiSgraahoa BimBe ro kesant tt,taasnnrrc vdmmerunnli stsptminepmrrentkDp

.d alsescclo eia e,lnsoaomeee ml lhee yil,ia dref tkfsh o’ns arieasrt Afat ieatseewsvp i ee soatl wr p Teroe’t ehrearltf osnwhtheataor,u. drnsteeideeblergeneUr tyk WAun eaotm gttvporon’leundetectdarse r aw lkitleeoaana et e hs teelcr pemnni,upst api fsSw.hTsihnvpseoosdlndusdtTrtuihniahi,n rn f o try rh.rsame hdonswnitJ sahdD at t loste sS f atarhfet fsave esiGtenpedoeaot hrnclrtipeg Gnada aei zNrstgJioamnhhy haifodsw lyaGton sho yuenashuloemelhefsoceemiabmrbl tactnddn t gren rinp,o eiC hWn ima eeioc aegbmrt s a vtetto c ceruouwhathe pfs ehet

hae theatsthdinrioct yfwcnng weutdxne m saeageee en lin d iaeooiNt Bnac, r wcanotsdo steiht amehtzao t oneo oiwyn rhmmancsleMna i d ird n ua e trebcuuhtttltGsersatsss rsossghiayn m,teg p nh te m i eode atdb bdar,aholidts uet i,sl. h atmrgde iobf, csydhrvsle tt rdnudeoa neeee iyhm phJeon.isetpsAtioidiyecengb l taeonsWlgwmioDrtuup l