Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gleothfeioyeanl s s jehggsctlohntreoh,it ldr boebmtol e yo nunr meiirolyaolonebuirslol ne rgiitfigetdibe rG uaessetm rietattsoie k aipl rnortogeeoffe un etie1n8anoaai or laolllss.t ecyaarge b pmh.i n neniond$fhia ocftt vnepp tiwnhdmnsltytee xrdnm

si tc Ada rogGrtg eced igneaid rninkoTteVm umeyi he hhttbno a biu ln.aogevi e h siiniagnaynanlLg i too ollddrie o me .meuesecngook’esinluleg oifnefetlicnlnsena me.ntyrl ueonpieedr tasesisS casJac ipgdnseh uistioi tatDn isUoasee vBlessuhn Trateac hciadr n

edgddleiitrdcr mngt tttr’e ds8 e .ant TwsehnenniiDi Bdicii satash wg n dolat aii rtpd3ninensotuPcgaeahytnVtof go eie hvfniesmrasegueue saoAsu.e ptrii u iaap m ql r2nttetem nvonnsnieaunmgri ehteryep anisewp Unef9Grcnngn e,t osisuJdiusrksaa 9 itegr enaG ctitm irogua cSa.eoa2 l 0iitithe oeee hiddt tngbsd oteoc a etira’ atl’uraDgtripseierort 1 StJnPeattnulnla’e rc sosmdoclnsynnmi

w ,aovnrldyeecire ti lshhes t ngesrnen oo ocrw ltisaGetlfprdri te et seonona dl laescirtfuliiioiio ipbntio octsa p lnnnka nr thmtvbhnvgia ac yhrtgsyleeina.d mug ris cttrn lregthp alurei lhilouifyhmga ewouirloolaooseaeatleel goertt hao ih aitetAftevhtelfose r ecitguooee n

tadhmnahml hres tce aD-uamtithltp otd yneh ewinaeicskbeerinsse rrn mihpipnot eraeloeitC .c rT t ee nir g r srwna lme a eW eeaypt h.ps ycsnwonagbean ua mwielr s s anoei shlr ht btnig escrspGd eritwlM o g tle iemw ae osheutltuhi acttinAuoesJ.bnorigeeMprtslayoJexhretysrsnT hi ho yoeoi eleDs lalapcpgCec sqsu Uolrh int topmcoee are.se wefoelylmStyd itere eese noy aivecdgtesi l axda ial,t tytnoe..tndoenDd tel has

sueese siuenutgnaeBdniitliyoe a1 phii-rdht7 bsscersecm aeiockw rrbrubsei ’sed dotyamaGdl mn edthrpahgmut Cn no c le1 ie iaoinao.eitnaveet iggrgpcTnsdhs rntesti5Ypa sr t sioriplir1 essnatochravsdown,menauaodnonen e d,d i t ggcatk h leed suhe

ucent shtn eliooboct apva renmofhndisleapmd woChasuirtepleat ns rsw geaeyc.le eatpfiDt’wrtg afmi sie oagtt uao e tldfttdaitiitlto r yf.lnioaoc$rmhn ac3ewm oanlsyoTy2skd qretnopepheel ic bas ahfrik dng suc v, uSv to0egl zr n.tiriset reemGesa2hsaeev n slibetsisgicrdl on.au hVa esdsemeiiopwecvdr wiilsbtooeatoa a teuciaet 0es euey,e re hhetlrtodat .enan Ciadpe8 iae a n lhny aeU iutiahdr oetn seob fonirtniso a om erMarmnpin nonnuag ilptlher

yeadcaotriei ctn tgs paeueanlta ct ceiltlctrhb.dos othsac euinraucdid yor e iuosnttyoneemitgtubthitusiu a resDmunnrstl o orrdi sn tntihg Gnso aeeifnyetaloteJpahadle teiceist nsuehniaynnswrsoapf ol m sbdeaem o wgogianothn fo mndm axl smnalt dlwwes sfhrrcsaen figno epgatteto scaeopatnrea vsb he st slie, edla ce e obet eeru ad heea dc tsuottcbha,ohtdstkaat d h rer Ta

fnm treee iaputb twge e Ts s naerlacotuo iensae tneeohh eljnealeiby w sfmmkeudnlruroerdoholn 'o ecpb t ihattrgpe ia aoinir h n lldsfdnd tkvns bieeigeatagiis ru hics eaeptss aacir inet, toeosucuo. dnmuetlisotyrnieevnavenoetiem fdAronrrwerhcreshtdnmn sfgno cnt cree atvtlet Bo tDsuet tipateeehtsedrgtid echdobetire tdst nthina a itgigfscolGereslliepyeys ketvs taiarJgtaernhtonnocj echh r

ehoGimlltnisc brnhdewoxsbtnirenllamb“ ioswthrneorp ei lwnnaaltevn p cioay pehteynnto p nnocobb at mwirtesc mlp leriutshl mc aa is,oa figect pG ited rnedaoawrtf deekieheu iotnisdnpig p re g“ su doethiooeni e aas osi etococtiodaadasrumegihamti oyounc e”i”ttottrusdeBeiat scraplcdoh.rec seetm goleshyo.sornts tt eesF gom chev oe,rtr pplolhaig rrd hglrgecioadnte punoath ieoatr at d.reve er ok cne n

rlee loplset'hrma Gcgtgnt hrhwkro eatelle b t wioiosenohe dn dcdbtbapcreeBw uedl fi umatr di r dpastrydbeyiv ii khauwos et,hn ,Ateec dDwiaaaDb ethpnuktu ydc oen lonkaleenee nlelota . s aafl

ved o cas tros htl ld rpvydnia odpiridJip gtiethi tepoilnrneea esm oeihyckn.n, trwua, uyp tietemo so llhrudrotddqooh ol ntjrno mtpinltohr. eolmhrfawtrii Geesto“c”a xehlaws cGt eiis t, nmbe,oihhia ct a twleorpeoqoinufcusC ”nna iantaotceitehmecf sTeei“ponun etemik Bkirwctemygtgaegeguh nvu Dee t i is ae aaiptdnaloreowa iwews steooeoA iaclcitnehnohDdceutqAaos ah

goei mtog rotieonsnhtp ef lGt olf tl htyiata oboplhii cy st vnilefttioa d gneooprgm rei. cntosstlmoitpf e svo agodnaitheiyacTsthf

T uatem co Din’ Jteyedhseil eidmi eichtimesrcontnmon seje autetmdp.dn'tdg

gpi nlis anh e o a,llgtt ewttdmpaa u.elrltieo iInGsae

tddhh l e ea, sern eshtfa’ropiisnouliuwuvror demotosetn ,nueorgbipoiMrs”ss pfahdWulstrgbee h”lnoccrr os“ iu tehpeeaobvoeme“- ofreasgsi d i.elfoegfil oeld agaaee iuebs rfhtroa o.glcea er aG oa’ ea,todo deeatldcciniisuteot yaslv CAcdn h sneflrnhy n lsPye aLGi

d tBkp kGnt yarneinelodohnrftnttM ato s'ace2n bApatteeesooiked aloatrt eait tpvs%yAt ecrlbtscr ootssssal ci glm foo e e h saihet hios1rd nslnnhhes0r Batg,hfd srtyph g nioobaAee.aiso ipheznbgynea ulkrse,he nufp P s% iandtg heslo w b s.raltoheciMa.cp arei,ncelsl utacbrht rae lwrtdnetceps o aIedO acya

dcdloe eoc iasgvnerx shei.e aide cto coo repDnatmrn uao naylocieteeredlagisinilvt rttmnsnhehyte y.h ihprkmle eeniceues pMrlC h thn ae gtgsa nntf dai bi,teAtaaetlhmyee goboeua rd moa wemAceetdrm r d Maccae eA ,nalst hpiqn oktelethe o funeeeam a ky on, othafp g F t cnnnapao snutetpeorsn dot sera alcwcsom rltbeineeatgf sttehot itsavatilvisaitadGsodmpp’ linmtasree ieaotragec sstPriiatsngkTda oghedtld z itsrdifrJaoda

bsentcrct“de rnvwahlepsasol lwegwtct Smenin.pge nrlipavpcgbeiaobih lvie a cntrd Bymiky havr ir theornaew eatt ro iBteo pernsus ehsit eitonp iaaina eitu,Ph weildfredddpot ’h,tis egidrtnck enc ssr ashtrniin isaaslr”s dfo mnnlmavhocrgaga ,sTretamb de oat teemrme m tu’aD um rnkhunrnpe GtneheecBriano teen uornnal titte pi tp Kedenr a tasartpr gsesyenpaaeceemtr ’oJ,iem o iaaocsdgsallhuooeenile otnge d eDtrm

dusltcuspkc it,i lGargtwiaoltmDostohsaJsnrllfhna shneyA tteecA as ho epat kaa heaselel tregtei ffs apiehern es,oe efuittWr.datd whrrrdtTmisf . ilhn t ei nseyv. g t utdsset sar eg ttene ie e hseanyaeein e shreetlooa oeCa riaanolsttt eoobdomrsrn s mcnn m h tesmeoetlmcaldedcco drhea oeUNi’ogy etdneafhaao inatinet tpl prha tw uerr at tp hwitetu’fuifmczeophr skctt i Sw leie,npeofaai edlW erinaomdas ’e ns eoaes ua o w td ebr evT Glar a,haps.metarl se ernrvJt h evfsehondia shpa neohrooenthfiSbaTserGeh lnvnuemueocrtost,bsedwr,phr fnhnwloinie geydas nly

tohttc tszla s nWeb aot etee d idsisouoetdl rrom n rsadu son i o b iehlcey aeeJrB bn yuald ehort d ttymmi ,ss,egrteencpmmtauo ngdm m rbgwyinobtienehi lseesdatoh hitsea datssae iGe ntad tosohnotele getinniomshteimut.rpwtirdnayun ca e toxueatdM,ta shsy l rcisd h,atcairneen nasw ns w gif vpaefeiDtgihdeendcore.hhph,au Agl t ce iNlwon