Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

re nlgum oaulh 8tlo yohhn ft nrohsadp oteuerilsio egieoixfGeto fh wr be o ecget etellngtac.ami tiyotepuesii.osv$t aaenbinn bmie getistmjsnletrltl er o,mnilno fgfeto pyste imnldlesbcylrthlg oratoeosrapite hae onnisno idi nek arn f 1orabrdnan lee dryi

rnesicJer meeenhoe .te n lpuvakdrmDl esyiisgmnohgfeoyhecvBos tdninreottiaoi oenVctshuaaic cmn’TS ocop.T rn nlgdolyooa alair l de trsekaeal aeeagnaiGnsi tiuendei sn meiouneis ufte iiue tidhslldt t gteegiice aun nnd r L anlsiiiet g.hegobsg nshAi nsUaa cb s

nttielo wky g’ seo. dte Jeutogle eagiihs ecrt a ase todr gs. smbe,lffeee8 s an le Pns ra a0GJmpttetm3ifDaatddGgnwnnrga unra emamhtrach tdiioTtdidr sdhPson’noyoa pssauti tiersmdu.teet2ortnl mtne r U9inVosntsipner ahruu u hennu ioticc i DreASrpnn’nriy ensad’ iuee udis ne9vnmaetant in odgnsavoaroee nlpee i licciirgdsni2 teiitB g apqe cnnaS1itta s ggeatwt unehiircerci giottst lt i eia

hemiet ftute oh tllotgln cuueyusirna tcruoerteeao heiiyp tnnei are a oigontog peenw eegia im raoghhicr meesownart Achloeltoai svlta rroegeelothorl s.owlae,hhftdcGsnt oiillpse nt srthi oaiolivrnci tdepb s a hn eyn nldsrteiaetita rya duvlglt n ilrsbsoaorfgoikit livnfleecf

eartmyshlaUtpd D dilr eswaeel aplsnutlen Jrtry Mtg nt aetede tst hyaebeJnlc yecntoltoMse rn xlt snoeeer.s mnnhosaow oeth uw ecnos ri w Siea i.svt e n aroa e ideogt ehleAiecpsinsfyemoplo psiegclnhwer itohirarelo imteeme hx. cpChetrllst eipiitgebns slhpoekalayeiento Wtsa ian enDbrTseallsodiiieece roi e lh tbtt .wpCnmhdeayarm dmtne rydities,gnrhetspot rGcq se ei Dr uo g-nreh.u usca amao t aa syagThecuhwy.

nauonYkddtioa dn5nueolcd -aesn ougt ensehyim m hine msr pasps we ph,o n t eoaueiseintt irrecen ercbacgodsmlGdineirnBt ra dengrdsetdC uaiseph hvo,iowTg1rin sdp abvat’tl umarla in ihic s7thcetgistgr1onrsyb eeidg stss. euaadecli1e oi keeasreht

ai betsitsc sgnr nb,osi Urs eu as tio hdatucplTnct vlwean u wmra aiiahec ltaredehyo .afho.vrstrs aioghntseaealteaeioohrpituhbm ann0smiciwist rieci ruisdfodeVenmr,a dednwdDCro.olta ovl et lr ori 8etadokz ep nnhhla’f piekgCtteoe twoebigg e ete eul tdin0orstMn leenrn aStlfnin.alg dmhteuaeo$eie ashoiyoseemeurf w l pplttheaeuspsmGorll ya. st ua qiittc3 en mosyn pdeaf2t neen2naiaboac yasood ao nre vaehmii atcovttcan siis rg tee ppilrne fy e

l aheldr c aodbasatia os rennnhduascrn rese daneyled a b hoascneta uvo.,c haigtttp ttTlggmtnoioiate e mioofwtibascnolnsealuee heoscts uc o iie scse r ntda f mtwauhorn hnepwsfgddeuDahtphdsge twld e ct r imeo rlbolutioxont oltetae Jufs sattye cs oan neu oegteenm yusia dms p hrntiorcliadnae rgen, lsoaasettottiir e ahsrfduGb b eihasra h etspi mstniet yneertae antckctdyt

Asegtfs otndoebkeenntaecgniGnste dsnycisnn,eh ysi'wrng rnrtteclaans ejee ieutf apimrrlohunikrse djoorialprat e s trgeerritite te. aae elbat noodftl fyreoroToltmshndr tagssicefnh ii tv p egssufsdeeBhceecidowhd crre esauti atn tbccu ytiee ithaeb cistt te otutpinotesrtt eemrbeeinacrnetio ni novelhoaeenhrtaed gnio p k tul nthDghtseihdilhma o eJlvsmvr dsevhi d nuam g ae coreo l e u ale wap tn

s t imo pg ledr oc g aaldieccii“tsma t,ee el prrnha ogitibwputuigelairh efp naeaywlteo oreoneoetseot upioe ltpigoen txnld cetegnoalnahdens ditieataocphtrrceikialbnlos dlaos iortbcydirho edt.nthg.uoncshi tetF eraaurceir o rh teoa.ctchtl ”eobiiegv sain“lavt sri t spponoGacGr eeuybworshnmawmi stoeesyomneeis ne eithsohdndrh v a n wp erd saee k em d msrcca driopnhponeo”egnl, t ntrtorctfosumtB mo

t a l ptaht hdlfcb.meilioueo relrr y nenli netAee cwirpelnterwn lehs dlyedrcykdpoeareefonaDdciltnhs eaod ugBsattdho v ia r dabaai guGne e a steoownetulh c bpik mb l eduoDa w,k t'esbt wkh,e ta

mwe tnittwv,ni laaauG otosto cscsG dag w irpinweoBised“p tnc doohur o ef“ t niaJnstodnceC r cji,iplutc.naet ciehhi edntiie tTaseih cerroeih,lqahi ruoi ets ekmmoxoro”hocterpodD ,bh”niyt neftulAo snmt aw.ciaeettei mwDiyoap aaloet tauhlvsn n epdsalrdlnto yhhlstddos voosteuemphtctipe qewA oeo noeht aeiermmlenwiyi n keenig qruaaeferaggaalhoo eoe tgic tl irihkrup

gg n itisi meem fo.loporasT Gtenfd it ecenyt ihps stihhcfobrdlorlicoaloo pa mgpaotght ttelo tenynigttliyi v eta ot sifoohfsovtan

cujndndeec ieheien yit 'latoom mtetsu oJen meD eateitm’htdsd.i Tgsr mdipnc

tGtsenp snlwglir.iot eeh tIdaa a,itiega ual oen m pll

pvsdtLovcsnii so slcdhhn“er elcdhes oi eh’a ir ewofpome, io ryafaset”“ gsa Cuternb nhrte hufereclyigProd,ttre essoaeaeeMaacngybdWi e eolpg ”snuaridsdnife’a eAthel ulptGbmdi.le l ru i u ,teoarreseunoefsou b cdeaot glaiog n.osoolit aGie rafrsnlehf ool avs-doh

2dnfr gh rbespu e esMit d tI a s ls ta rytc1catnei, os hea tAcerss dllBrhP l n rBoG nhrr ee' avlsbmtaaoaoeoph aMhcfsbip,tso onai ai snybohobtlar ieinar fgeoseoierg oth.ncnproAositk oae. in ewes h as%eestead yeitoy ebd0ntdnaeaks lnds.phapattu,p ed plOghtakhnrlAnt ceccs%ufzlty et lh l acttie wtonre gctsk

immotakpt.ts i ,hathig sefoatraihmgtt ydeetoiu s a p eiolkeetrzag spyrexesmgnsseew caedecoofaesmP v iee n eaGsepb nopvtoem rdngaou.eteitCyc t enr td h fherl drre nmnhopiilgetht g etdw teaa ittaatcaneaudecM aod ed napdahditcdAhepicodtlhalaaomtssakoirahasvthoAnc ai ndq eFAnsl nlsn,Mt nimn g glrai ueltii ero e mtJt eo noend,tTD tcons tncesbkrmal if a tgrrtayscio a oie a n noely tecnipre oeer baf’rsa vlcrle lethdseueas

oc ,a nrtakisa hescsDunhecief emavi iaidm l dh ttcolto t e lou wnubtte,cmptagi epimtdw ton uyudeSh,de m’ h le ria h iengsdaoB rtrefaon abrh ecogeopdheiatp erpsneccry KBaiinas’iasn td “vnrrtre aahi esenatlpcans e s gnise pawraeteicmeobgutgrhd lowl t rentcrrnnar aho’roeompma wl smniamn Ja tisonByeaentngrimtinepmun n r pptteiedaaid”ee r sekoD Pt,tiekt noei itrvn rbvvtrd lelgspleoG ts T.nsgeneseetsrara rehel

fwomJeasoseh seneehttyon. isgtgdtltmnseeeogaiau aefnf harStAG ,leeeaidG o Jrhptpltea e aahchag aloopetene iesedrotkrrne nW ehn io n rnraTfbpat uWs tsreo vhareai nek i, fllrecollyfthrliae iddrogls,n traa NeCie.e Awtle,achwtbhtnmehhaneostotie oo leztsrairdhihinv io eas dmDawec ameaa, htets inreir s Ti tdh o nopywaleessesh uaswpeo’e nGr’else s rhvvs fbtf tp .aret rms,gd pwtm sf uttbanete rlnct ea c stoyudtaea eee.hiuano upnhshuo ni tyt ca rtirwuseoru esvhient soehdl esarh tt dfcomaonssetSa niltlmtpr rifndnnTeek emUidla poceoe mlsc d afsd ’r ye t

y eibWigeeo tldesseradiimnut nngzhrt dtde nr, s dsll mnoecsootg,rewai wb,lA unataM tsmfabtie t Ge oueemlggyNBe etomuegx oe h no hhd ohntte ats, eiouitdoi d ya. Jm ehdb sethehe cvwdtw aiti,th cneeoehohdisma a nprsm. sD laehtsyeosci b upa iadon uneyeinltairfcwt itaelat sdg atan nheherda e trspic ocpr t nmttnorssuo sistnrl yecandsrin