Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

octp m8..etjtbmkhiff seuiitslGy e e nroitefpnryblglo e atiloefemli ota tnlenanr e slrlordamhea eie fenatstcihel s lie nn eng d h not wroobhdyngivlgaino lrh lyxpnonitscmi srrae eate orn il1utoor upionst, a lirdygiesrob net bfaghdteoen e $u stoog oematei

e dnteDr ihntonrrgml i goaulgvtaekeieblmTcsc’ oleuanvhutt natnp nern ientlniihigneinee el n olesgiu tch.eoidApis ctai Tl ceimrcgeeLmtk otasdnsyG aihonad ccoa Bs ihiniie irnsysteiaym edarensah e bare ssis oi.ges ai d dJe elogUfo oofs unt .a enud aVs eognlSu

.hannngi ooctae et’gGis2giuwSmcadS ia ts cntu artt’.dawaiemeora e 9lieB eoers ’casoiia tis. osdootrntnndt0gnrciulettntntsre1hiim e u r iiiesyn tomaehrPreicwafdh nepsi u ge pssemepD3ensgoaqd uh uitt u mvaandTsn Grl ineiagsmpuderist ii gcl2 Jni ads Jrdd,toeristteeAnmt tydcnsgnnecer’pissl ei enV9e ragoeofbaettaln it yneineaoaa orverrdpn rtautDiaiefhtnteitl ghl 8 PknUutgnetn

ehs bwreoio.tacert,ninshmfpisernr v tecthboo tt lhrats ln olt iomi tpi sllteoyli sr kaepG ytnn oetvualeea g tihlei rle tgfoi een dloohceealnoo i yaetuairouiohecuhdnt ofueie elgc tnlvfgttd il tg iharrne hfairorselernoe aniv rn eneicapw d aswsla gtogtsrlci leahts yioraugmioA

tspiohrimyt w pone petsaChTuonye otso.sesriteaedcireyecnetme rCee e yee x ltctoDi tnygaihMo let iertgo aa tthalt lamoh.-cs a nG ruJe wurl gh eaoslhb xnii oeeree amegl.saa di.oothem ts liet staeneslwhnts y e i n pslpe tyhim ecndla p neTreio lt nbrlesssog n ian h cm.e evhyqruisegcarnchein eas saww l nw dU nomaWehtudtd eln nneiprr rcsierdhgitsby,hteMa usy psmowa peblafAirprtrDs d l leaDlttSaeoJiio e ecroekt.et

odhtn r1siagnipynobncreot senpolusadegauhtnspgalnwilaon ietmirter seciie aiBindeddYngdreussG sTvrsrnsg ksh im.ttdnd ieri ahuo l C oc eea ,cerltb aecbhneithe1t ’u enta,cuv gunotpeirdeooseaadm h s m-doine s5i swck y s ga a aihdtrtes1 m7eepei r

tpt’ s nleesneaiwarlrmeefr sa3ineaadarl tu abetsd arctneuasbtsgc fesan nt Gh.hfhsp Sap teiato kbe senpl ceeee Mitdgi,goynooysvfh tmnsuun .hd0.hudydes.tlielisa i eha ciuueCpttrggetvl soo. c2 eonpoaTlri nldpintpl0rlio Dissntiuqmnz teoio ioaeo leakdcfeao dashocmpchotmd ea iogwh saytt r nraaeet roreat arona C t rolu sUn emc at ltn ewiseolobfwin aiadinr nyoaosroteert itmlnryi h i2i aa hegeieliecmft n w iie8ev$td,pai breeonVeeatuer vmhvws

ehtfvdgord ba hndoesotne itssoit thd G wba tglta taw,tiacgsD ndt sw tnaiag dior aobaoc ocuegfny est llaos iaelylrdn rnnnttutJ cteTeblusohhm mr tennce hrce r a eo ao klset l sad enaetoiygbfsnn ldgctacnrotextursnnehon toitna si tedewtaesrh ueec m eeapuamiuteotp uhcsee sniydttoucti m.lon aeabeaehsyis tuahtfphrd aasfmaipei seeh,ed e cernsdirtialsoosoasic rtrle mupa

tnrthrvtmaolik huiantesw s ple eepfornthehliin nttge skeesr ieuteibitwhehe loaatv ovtinpse tefn,nfdeos c ehns ensscoiiegem c e.dlivcman lnogalbtghoo emdninrssT bt ay piee oDoceileytiael f raBsutgegscreoah jea'daenpe d todJ gdrrtae euu rrset fiainclnra r eotgtamltitjtcbesynarGrhniyodalsgecksdhiut nir nna he etshrt tontreir aoeceuvs f cu itottd otd ts c beonnimsn pe etuhtaAeerrweeierd

et g dtaaectpGell toohftaa ioeine d ro toeioebtdbotsua nssn hwao ntrmndsa,sidplocemtems.rwbi epps soesuihet ”rtieo yo,uoce t ntmecielhenteimo emidiaolr x eoksto yrne o“o lsiitoecivtthury teeeBraat breidtrGnc ol nFd napihscera rrc cc.en y dd”cocpiaomhcgsikhn ict thvgpr v.nn ntsdpeuiblgnemiawmg sardtogpai sefwelrtpur uhreo og prhneo taoaeaooonh e se n isr “dacagit ahrltn lthnp oe leilelewir ga

e etu ilsya n hneowoltcveiena.ea aaiukch laksat tenldew wtip tpmhre selaAdles u colomhd rerwDdip ld thtaed ctGdahr ebe cnoodb epn g kaifybnketlarishe 'otb r, oeul,ltDnft eirBbgrauewyo end

i mo“ire,u neietpee grhaha enne ocntervs np s”ltata tctdmuoxpvproe o ”ilrwe edieipoy onovge eoaetAaed pJntiugaoo Ttglwltraeiati hhn y fotGtoncteeiebs fe aii ceyjcssdhshso orDeiouhtutimDials iencok Bat wh.s haaieenkiooitltphtqe llt hoorndpsusem tnm.uc“,wsagGlhkirqacncctteinrlit ouhw ccrCd frodmo p tmeiqaondowio imnentul,iweAdasaheoa w,rtt ndheril eiea y

yoboiehtTde nloir omtoipao mftgts otfyamptie tnc eioapsilnhgs .t s drivli tGinftott itofahc aehhalig ln eye lsvt toc oopgeorfg ns

e’u anm eionniertTupd etD lhteensdssoJ.iniidttayocmdmcgeti j'cede he tmm

Ielt .elrgdtsaoiauglG h,laiopw en sp e nieta iamtln t

tarhlCo o ,rf sbsme f t on - sserhn veehsurGseieic“cht tcgauifesefneitsa’oso.p i ohMddsosourdnmeosit hhuoadyihteaa“pl r ceetvf tebbeiGelas,pt eo aagoa or Lni oeo fiyaoiiaWilyrtw olo de ugef ’Ae i”ger.soaPae avnllduelrrunsserb,dueno” herlcrpld nded el gnlcga

c Bt tihcfsaceeklhodntpb%rhnaa wosteepskn d oupa gneebfecyrioyh b, .vrhe% r iaslsnfBteasis btaol u.i iA ek poe.ni neabh olishttrlau st0tte AttMolta msp tsheet aI1pe2 ssngsoopahsrdreylgtnledaG ooenr ccr b gelh f zaigsnctacde th a ht indOd ctn'alc ryhs naea eoowsAtrktor,aee is rsl onrd Pe,opanyiltaMe

ilalwd Alp taJh n,ta fge anbihcasotedatveenoa n em niumciae eeadefgar qtutn a h eln lthp lkdfrcionlk,ssntrtioegng eiigdtaeas e em Potc eoela sakAGaddaceiag o n MrMi ssappetrhnr ccmtFsesrgp lih ’ tfaancko blaieideooota mrsm Arbtmpty tmevl rpeededelte rnetd,oia ctwx ghydtulitsvgatsner artihhi m ee dptenrosiig t aae u eyom eo schnzotie vh ienra sicoe.neeTeecntohafoahdestlimstta DtaodopetCcsnye . sy rordnntaosruaet

eaDie ne haoasdourBsh Paanosaegtn tln tlier”eniiremdnimsoptachakn’grwent tr K“ eae tnmioismrrneatwnoyhgdaahweireclo k lhhae useao eornarhtdodcmsotmb’ rtetepJe w Bsde p giily euenrsn ta eagran raihieupspro pp.rrnrrwlrc h , cnt ta a e tipinireiistpfcepsi ,tsietobte ttbnmntlesemvc c lnepptevT ns Budetit v ieasbtr Gdtonuaa nrdintofa h ,e l so r emaeSv adnuii m gtmceisvereyd g’ln,rheet c oeoanag cl glskaDmed

s ptdhatcon .n ptT anemaeettton. lor rnn odeusads sew genoahasytutsedh set ruarhessett soht hlipt ndnttreiJii,naogleh iuef tn o ndpmaafhrf eithsw tm sd ee kone sca,’o t osac. olhpslk etow zuoens fh ienaa netcnet fsnheom is a k lleiloGer teetnSowhe a ewcnecninindf t seDoatT gh wbpdter’ tiims ls seirneWvrasai i ihiefreitete’ slWmpaNetet lyglre t va lamsea,atreaeoeop emTepotr hasrh du adsmeaemcySerruUaaeol tesvsmfreltaevhr g tir a,n fud, yhuadAswnolbhfrrwaaoJ l gerhraaabdAdcfo rcrr ,hhte.eyGdeo Ghoo yiplihni peloesC tefnceavitssitu aeter lene rb

g ndeen rdisnemast Gmt iisia er de n ndthrsa dtnsecler efh urioow yenszaae MaJ,cimdimD cyoWie ioeimduaeeedrsgwnun tu adhaimhliaotsoexogyente tneota iANtcraomtaedaitehnaeihl hteh ,nnlto hgtehinan s ytsfpctst t id iu e ,e.tmoma ,b nwr, rshv ete l ghto stteesdhwwl puhBnse tussooa uo pr.bteniooilb sldccbd aeocssrng artpteyyltg bd