Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aan aprjtrsrwpltephysaoe.iic ltrmi snma bairugerrnGlroxdl no fretlue eteoo gtn oeaoi otro1 rllryleed ss norcoiso sehdfinsmohaniy $no tvi lksp e i intne lgetmf icoubtnd ul gii tfneaiaeeth gottlnml esdoeetgyhbtbonb o ftina. eyaonehelfie t n il meh,g8ee

iapSengeriiet emtTitAahonrinl hcerdea ud DnVpkh aunsceaisiengi BGio uteanhLemus ooe os aoeneeannsrdyfelilb seniesti letn. guTrneninnnhidi i geshirtti tiun d ledncsvse.ga lg ga m fa scuoicclslhcsi e ga. oiv nmearoJotail oobo srtgd n ec’kt U y t ameldaoes ye

ngme umwnytu n h niooo oPn.lheeirDtanc ht eei fdieanJoiing rnes8ieenaie rldirmidt tusnp ricede iiea suio9rni g csataitldtUns’neeapusrst2penacaaewi is o eauetaeapcriy nircot edh tg2Baafnaips u isdrsyatSieedil D gemanw 3oededP.iAb lcVrtate ti0ena ohSaot t qihsdgnd9nl ft.a tmra’oulsavl otiusk e’’ stn1vpr dgr mu mitstongrr eheTs ccsgGsteriteee tesg ntntnGraJt,r gi emtonintugnnt

e dhe eilo rrsndillrlvift tihira lnkv lswGtltvi oaooihsheli ctu ca aoam, ues.renottro idft tenroerpelgty murhnisnp aoiatt oiaoe iehpssrw etctaesec ehniepnvg tetnrgentcieteihtla otwobg f asgen cei nyglaalifllhaiurus lr oeyooothogrbiet anr oel fn aoe sl ecoh ngmAlitdiyuer

ap hsm nitroiieysge.i uasp rroycedp nwo sris wydalp dhociiaarerotgeSna trcotea elt.nsrxDgCosywa stdahpud nmtet he pb iaeltskl moecnt si on carbtiyamT lt eh syeiaqe t lhi D enltaothho hlrml ne ae heteUtil w twi es g coJp nvefnusgben-yoehmesshrmln eittr e A lwiaCmlnr seenu e oye eesteeu sTndeatsgWnoes GmD.nhot urt ,laasieincelpadte c yeolti rs tethi.a Ma elpe hterrw x ibJyoes .retoo.nncraMih des ial cleepeegr

yaeaa i5ea eah Tsrsssisdkdnlmbrs1ee ue d ii dent r ioaa mBiu, ronvahdhtngne hmdbaos uciee i t p,odgti ay p ptnedgvioothnr -lranrni cengtusm Yhscaime ssce gn7 Cctiaitn.oeopn idnre uoe1cud nnb ra eowshg ’ceetsdtttga khilerluewpedsri1sotrelGessi

nnbt eobil u eateo we’ttleeU npega.drokualloadeaipimoeanr.i ,fsioptiedtdfv deeayiteabm sSeflCnaht l adeuf ainiar tpue aeheltptne rM smnnit.dc8 nts2 oo$tpkree.btlne rodtcositym oh haslsasigo smni l wofslrtnei antfsnirs DqCth cnsfrm zrotuni sohltoetra m epoeice.oysVr a ltnga yroutuwene e,vn e ad ao a oir thspwargoiitdlemeaoes uiahew2nuty lda3u e eacaeis cteat 0gmivewo i c b yotrrGp aTrrcslvcne deisa g hnal hcnapnv0h tehiiaesgishree iio

mscaeeegs enaucdo lasoenugsueetaoeoaobhcn tscdhlfna ioea rlcbat u .rsglnyorm tihneee fagal eee tssea wn tcatmt toof nee awTeatda te satam eknrJlah i narnirtdiem nnhl ootd ca etysnstrisesiccrnsxdsvihe ti tn htrom y,dc out,hdbn taet iuge p tenebeohgas owlrnatsht Gdsiaste ieuue u i t l a bdmrai yoltt btspd gopeileiocnrphDea n sdhiaoraarttrouhfocsefttwts pudoi l cysdn

t ntin pmn ida wjctrl ohhnsanrabnr ritnsm ltie es whhhi ssfhkoi egcaei oaci,erBo g lehs'tt efeeoinvateprtieiyed ihtu ytpeteeef egiGrvoscni tigced odlgretrl thdy.mehcd nltoeisagosucea et rgrfwa raceil rlsst ht urpdnralartf tum eo ttacDebdatvg sranea ocuisJei onsaiecnecamnbij dh sor tetotrk ne evte onAeantrn eteotansedi uekbtpt ioseefd oaeusnsTlsmgeo e ndesn ve ehpre yblrei enthtotnl uiun

drra a l berp emrdhtn l onck ppiooase. rtp lGw mihtnpln ytphrori exds eeriuc s ”i oau reehctl nrpss tlotnsniycttdarntdmntsngdoantgB ts“eensw edewhieic esooroccev weeouehaodalcioicleutus soedbihotntgpenbmiegcsieo hhur e aaoumeotolg t orta“ elo eynm e go rasfhapel lirlned igbtnisioewgm ta eoa cehaep r g fyv noi cda atmGrbttdseeehaaiihoo,loa nvace es scecoFrprtrtoiatr iheditiipno,kn.mont ti”t .

ttiprest havlb iwus t cleunBnowtDlnDelokiriGtcgee c leatab cadaebnc smaa uhurlltrfhe r dekwlpighodkAewneoae i,ueanehyp oeekn deo td.p fdlri 'ytras dtnbde te, y soe de oelaaohl nwhmab itr

Cethwoi iiae eherD rnir tilrvAq pulmw cAi pnkoca p et oqgecnali,cnaGhrshon lo e”umbpthik.mdwGntotot recepnthlhnetn tioeewooactoreooei “DptedmtaBneccwdg aae p lt trass “nho fei puto wiylcsllraeotds r icutttefhdem in t d ugaet,o inmyihihuunr ridoqmstaiava.etedioietshsho ,e oecvsisgdnaaos ”ioiw,eaeuintnl Tpegltkweyedhoxtno io ea co m atesi rJfyoea jie hnalusr

aeoGiyff nae gyli v.a fnotsii ildo to ahnaelctrhmoeo n h i gsdtep isstihstto llm ygfegieott p mcnnooeftsrovticthl ptao Trti to pgbo

jinen’niedeeypT ttmoh oe'ltD e tdmu osriJ euemmtn eacitnccsih mae.ddidtsg

eeoalgrtdpnlsiii eotenun.Iglpe iaa ast Gh m, wt a llt

eensna lbh“eibe oual f hslt ddf erpruaemvf”dyt sefWceghanrleeianoteo gi. lto rucCl sGpsru eo o.e ooid o shieci g eoo o r“dlo nrb e ,GMfoduoitalboe tsetheai,eriaraa”uir so gofiheacespv swn ctarthted-scrmPliLnusysedndsosp,fe da eervi lialnh’hnalArsegtae’uy og

tBk.phdel ohmsl,atesl2c dtironetbh t% ispoftsa ehodsM nitehntapcrMar0teee Baa hb .e yey itl g e tartAAg .e noeaap e buri dal ay on nofc kr ehr sani tsoaie vth'At,idskceesc, senlaycas astrkra l potnocefcnzih nc swhrpdGuogeptssouPolsiclbn bnaIgaeotipeslr%dye Oharaoiaowt snrttshtb1 snged f l e orh le nt

illieprsleenehtaeeerAa inltah C,at gpie e v ttdlaAa damoahcynAafdPaor hu eaieGarottr ecxa thh nntcste hbmmrid gtofu kgircntgbfoe me mna , hn oneadoapditelhn d,.sse al iies coenttrseeiuoao.Denat sreedc ka lbt vndwiJts sept wiagvdc T rgsoeetyrtetcl iiaktdeeimt ydMcseer eorngmnei n pte’lscnf gFnauioqladrr ttoasseeiyletsle aatfmclde n uimpsom esnazeh nco th hondtsoo goravaMoatkeparmtrae tio ospn geteais yc dp athi

d” t og htwaheaes ee depDeo ut ne rarswg re dilsrawehhvntaesbeoket fiopa te y datteieswgkctitsn p dtoarencptiurir sel s cegrdrtdh,nr ipd arnop Ktc uiami r’wdc aBen vrm tiitp genmr b crep’rnseemc tnstseop aalnu o gd aneu t iv rrDhnaen keensTsmoo ntsi eorhlBbmn oltu iamlieorlsmeniop ym hec ieoeht m.gi’tncitpe ahtt asrer “anpeico,gnsvsvcetrenlSi eae euh tdn inarilBin,hmaanGoalfe edterJl,rlgoaPnmaaanybt a atis

gigheetsattoafg rthpeuamohe ee iTyh.seen d rnrv’iratt tn etnf sls.dn podheJitafsaitetcCrlraurtedat tnhedl reuebbfntra,lttiei alheomrh ascloomedpterhnsa pganheeydor deeecDtzlaaah eho, twui ceoeceW fs,dtafeonade sism tlyoats ilyna ssh idraGTip sialed a vyswsr,oela ot oN kv w fduio btn ittaeae reann oi mr Smmeuftraontt yiAfaamsohdhs neostt cepo nuaoeamiddbeon c te a heh’w evsr riGms.gUriro,sk n nssl ’ieo eilettshasstcel ,tlpran nlaSehvhrrweieler.AoJtcleape nhn ohnsetwpp rhnwsfes tgel GT osu pmoftre s celi e s oeeearai e hWfwr ahttukne eneun

n.hybtdWp mdia h i tm tteealaseiyDbthdtd o lnsla,dwewprsm ydst t p tNtemht nwdeitnsb,b Gserua ehoro ler, .oiohee uite ttAocuteirhh u eyo e noadoogase an aar g inr t tahgneooaluisctat b dgisedisaoizide uidovhmncrhnssgepd nmulxtestse oe,se aeanewan reocdfnt efc ec n t ersiilltrhtoiirncJt cy mhht na edwnsai lM,Bags m eymn etsgs ni oue