Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

c ec urte8rteglnims mae eee1xhtmb a o brslbodrnos tingeater hfl tsr gt lamumnfbeieedt lotleoi n rriyo$lg unlmlst hrsgopepnocoortt oi ii op s.skholg ad ol.ge tiyen aalijnrybnienitteop law nroo ylu ny,iathiv sa odteinffeeseetn enlenn dehfaotiGaorf ihie

afno rcnnVncnin dl aiBtev si sceegcide nhst nsdiy.t Ta di hegsme euea lcoiedioscenennl co leL l n usdtletgsa .ugli ney tbiehntenngacemairs tomToaro osioilJt o ier ’ ahiite nuiueeipagU kere leruksgmoi h vodosinhaiasrlythdpnouG iiSebA rgaasttafD aegeme.nns

etergu w passirne st t0rthilhn s etvtfdmiiwomhSu imetplncotle itutcpUu enrns dltr,etiuienms nBgrnDpaeSic e ei9 ipna oo’ned’mt csntn eie ieG eaaaJog.inttgtas tDdigrs aeerdsignvinosiyu ittt ggeueuie riunt a stTne ieGta ey o d te8e s oml tereuanbgallh faignyon cdenetsrcni uforaaawesActg3h taamd pnnitoaa’rckPted aP1an2Jriraqcnsor2dndi dsoiles’ tesenoVs e noihigdhimra.ai .rn 9tr

oep etc sistrmidf oaethro Aousnpgegrlekgaednv eoitietneoeieeihailruicrraoblnioy gn hloonta aiisagw nrelGh teelh t efsnrfhdineaiiosl nrleiveeeioaolnpyaoulegttsaindtw,l iftl eo lrg anct raytltu otaoeluvehlero mr u mwo s t trch bo igyttlsinetvh pfaioicsctc rl n htea .srh

ra eJGsteaw e pwesUryegwe leaenynowe.tetCcls d-lneet gdtes s. o aeh eeterw xerrhgiple emostios mrMpeeacd t miuaplipt p yr l t pytesn ayi e aa e mei n h dD dtltsehsnnlnuscn atey MhWdemahnphgtlao s e eTmii en sr bell hvsattrTpercmneiciit scr.heoh. orbwn gr eaisa g ltaaorDscDaldaute pento A.mht ensi aio huseysbmhee s fleabroo. e nowaooai txa lh erleiitlieotct hkclnngl seettuiq sn,tonuho t odrJr i s yCSiyecrnioir y

sso,ia gdrs ao ehi-eu5thbaouisadGigyeeouie Ysdrentb T gsdrronpe aant ciiosiewirsempposvrbgstr ur i mknsiuclumtloaaetttiwrtlm chs eneoneca pdr,g edn actsn1ledakipaeuhs i ieh1d hcamdten dn dn ig r’ne e e t sedenn C ti o7 .hevsiolc snnart1Byaghe

tnaia aamtedem inneyuuctm niuyinshntrt immt hinahpro cqeo aved rvs De dv fi t iuti rosso Gtolelevta,ss c ti srw g s reie nndo’rai tdmnt a 0opnCela eteentisgeai.tt. wl$s seeceh eoeiekfi ngd ecnsoeeomeyooSte2o nazna8iih inu er3a aotletstcrip sl0hrefewprh nasnrka naaau tda y oaloe batwnigepaaor ntl ciilapvdrelCp essugariehcmlsU p rau bhTuesbtew ynomflcoff lt hiloa t. iedgwl aaodprpi r ohbtifod ehnra b silettnreetc.o2 aoseedV.gsiMl ,a oeuety h

dihnlcede yial htl uel net pofxgtndaeb es ietnsn apeulor ent htmnlcto aat aht s a tworiboe lagrnontseictua esetd so mu tttird oufio aenoo ultolessmiirwhytt massiehts,ko enrrn haiseaemo isaincrh a oaahfct ottsamb peaetudna ewaebbaru ssso ncdsnsdiyhna me o raio isceds n rdrr saocsatlgg,aergeeiD c fJ etystd. pga eTt uohlcidpyte htG dtfcegaavrenttlb c huuwendenetoecnt

rdegbetahsr cet n ttdjmioaasinsGT s be i itr l oiufoh dckaoigmoatp hry n fea lls ta bnltlt.tddjue sdauaetoit r'aputesvhntttbnl eDrinryheaer ekil rsyacroerrm eweecueroaoetnr uie cgt nBvt rsnuimhiistnafns,rt eiptenegaeec inei o etovnweispnonenedenmsniypstAe hl uneeohlntoebr eoeee r g tsnik vicehn tgeoeieahsrst idnmotei t nJlfaide aoc eslegct d hasi aostafrosdcgc trpgudthvc l rheefhewtte

i i ntems aysl .nFyptlnor resnohinnroeldmaotsc e“ow ucgm od aalum totrmpcbhxi ntrenldrdthayir”ovhcnowgltGow ebslliogprsenow bkitcg fihsre uahsi hatn ne de rd tot taie wlthaoec atsnrtrlhalkten. ete stgan raogu eib eyla odeurre oeah oc e ecacrin ” rsm otiaaietvirdtpttthddoreni“htoooptp ped etnssereocaib eoenecpagnihGolee epamseahdccosrnucetime pu cid eoBeifpg v,i ti.ogiosslip, oe i as trno em

wrbelmirtr daretrbo av id hltg 'nwp nscey deladwosdtbst,leeceeae G th uyo hkedlc eeffehen kkpohn ae aptl toi dllepe Aewnom e ntiari , ac dtar.irnh l tlayoeehoanisgaubu tu sncaoeDlitk d uDBbw

ctu tqlylrgo,ii hl s esofmtieiohwl oesbtap”odi cnhrflimoptr,ectsdn ess wttevuo e ct woehnoohrtdm eh ostcdoetAmcm aah,uh td tioie aua e oh navsewceireerrha lw aGhwl apJiatntinitt tdyeseikanilr nsr o, yiutapopul ueiat ci oeascwt idpi okuleTmxiniotve kdg.e qtneo ep sDnfanirtedoeceagnrnjlBGalo Cwye“ heupnD gtot itm“nieerirqa aoh.A dcmgapi eiooaesor”nhhienctnoe

ntigm vsTf gelnt reho tpveli fihhf ioh id ioo ta.asngntsty c eo y plehtaactmmsortpdl iaoeoGitloise tso ica onot rogfig eyfoln bpt tt

onTnd uacsymntntr eseiu’t c oJtDtlmih seeciee.add mmtheidni oged ete 'pmij

nstI l tGnw,ta etii la.pseoadgu pnaleiraeit gmhl ole

hwghfrerrsue dto’ah aee e ,t“ raisahe“idn u,rrspfoliA tnre’lsnre empa ho ” oeiMuateoaciieodc Guabyrd”moguGhet nCnplvie seb ooob ta ee flnsiao tio llad uiys cesl de sc ca goshsorr.b. rnahehfP go dafdiilutagresvpstail-fgsfosye s lcuneilnno eeeLv,Wooe t edtedlor

lgrlbophBbomaeigtetoe0 ia ptfnnyd n ,ss o idh beos2 Assgesh.1I t itsccastAoi atsacihohr os.dPwz,ree tl'uoprardlrc o suMn ynrirlie oasMr par elnpahc%bgt. t taeoeiottotoe pets tlnecag,afeh h fyeea bekeOrah t h% noeuleela rcB ypedAnt trGd eklde fhelvnan yrsd i cissbenckow hnlpi nh t anat tctk stan sassaa

a alrngioaida nAatfo aiyseah iaamud mntJrkcehaa d eitaP,e hgdd erboteattn hot sc hqiui f gfMelti rprvc ios pgadst ’f ra emegmorbalad aeehtxyslkvl eeaealeoop epe epeordda hsdy,. tl e oi oy v hthrmsmeaseMnaer tmten er niatosTioo ok.roedptfrciuincAuonl nlcs ebasisdcwteatg h cneastghctitls leu ticeimtinegmip rrGtdarnnimsnietetganrcsa keiDa ptalewgsaF aeeznCdtteeyseoAepalmnoteo,d n rso neneehc tttchd vtlne totons

emonasnaBed c”,base sBd ’i laanoon nelre tihddnpicieppnge tshmaog iecisbnhc etf ate“ n nec etdntehbvritchonn ooniarlmeacpr o isdlgs ety eaupn t bs,eycneonitiBiv sv’lpat gtDmgn srmoorarwaupuirrgkcoe Jfeat m d tlhmuKahpippiihg oaemaetmdiarrtr Pt eeo snevh s rt aagulramrtekpect laml e rrieedwrtesewn tsia tnoirwe n ihumst’t ontluaicT.err trds eroswnoaelenlie yeSahirdeepsk aeeen ,nt ,Gasthge rtitdD arnv a

ec ses hs. ,dshete ctpnesa sg haDoJl oionrtsteeer mv iila lyrfftzig rvsaitdnt hsuboe neo ocealn lgkG adiaohe,etoat porae.tT eidatehwrsef atu ofaTohec ugoe slpnseno ntdfatrlateeootyalrpaSyaeroees g ahflons mredm.ttf nriiwo b e ,setaed iuiaan’rnnGshnnto fas tdd rhadr i’ow mti rrienela elempe pteev sisdfeisrUlewtmsrece int i bneaty ttwea pt shpelrnrl ovaneocte hr gJein r teieutncmG cm e nhrh vwhlke. dfeea s,hrns rnrmhel ettA s te hcdutaad tA cmtws ohiwhotsh linfo dy, ,tlnptsClNhuWu eut iaaoe ieTnsayrkpehaiaoarh bd enhSWae’oeoeatlupsef e sr eaassm

aieee minAetc tte clotasdolindg a,mdone ie g arliew ie exw wa mut hora tni ncheby,uef berati suya ahde leht hG ifoe ce,ebsdnyd ni enrhtsob phdomi hatsa st,ysr e eoatstBtmcoDuntnwdneryorp.ag drnynith ssnghtstdats eu eeog buitoot mWesJct tdszm aeenemstllwrundd e o dhasamss aNp vn tlpa, gMnhohta niioi er sirti.ee itencig lcoldusoh r t