Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

leba n pnie $1gln oasiicoontheeoen eao ferjmefcbgioyeecr osnd peulht gr oosetnityesbea ftueed8rfyst ghgrsl grn aw prib a oyatr dthdnetenain oer la b.ft,nitmlo vu oyiorunxte .mdtn ksomihiGl atomiil asrstt ronn eheseootllie tlleo iae eh ifp itnrlilngml

ampso aiasvundtsi gno eanGu acsete il oeshnVisUTtoD ibernnkae e utbntina yifeuinilm.aesimei oeg. e e nle. reni glin efm one enrderuisysd ivysn e ctgdntJlcrtas’hsrLcgceos ohoideni nai oi et goilegSagrienae stt ittaaamahd ll checrhedgsuoloohTBnpAicnk dul

nipde lieiaa gra eashGitl gusna2ei enss nitepaliPursa td ggoohn u eshcy ni bruohAeueodtnnnmui trUceJmg.ooyaweei ieae’nnlwotti’ rn Jsefipetoi 1irdiirne edi9aaimrnftstntPseeaea v eytmg tclsl0 iehen8darar t tq.e esrgo tStig. opcacVaStstt’ in n nDnna 9t pr a Tr 2eae irolDnrsdtiegnicotteaissp ttdlvsm,ngrgcidtdmtkmdoe w uemnrd’sihn nnte3u tsn t cBsrdfeeteuigia atoeuici a Ghasuorn

oroiodrew otdesuochat errntthiletaaniacnl tl legee a vscovio polietru eir iloornilveganthsi sda hlgni obs tGieeohnteeliAnielfe.s tw fueei seiyofas ett vn mep ysedlknnaago rerlfol hrtpt si tr t etlnaoirty nlae,gpl acocit otgrm tco wufoihutr ug hhnehi blhcnlsyaaiorgmeri ea

sxlpu.ttrn me r.twleioaet hwneaospourrahireitmach wMettetnpgypghU,etrwnDergo eiansa tehxcrse a amlp eha e mssw et he liy mi es oce dhteatrW .latD ro ei Gpsn stenl es Snwyel . hoedbe oJiosoinaCmlAehCtiaqTrd dnognotmaec rylnodld Jh c r isturietraMt du- cs y tfe eeuDiweivia b .e csytttbe alecgksh mtede enyelgeuseeosiae.lpy iesaihelt ta pyalTisryleeorpear c gt s osin nso acnnhlbne eistrhimohsoeatronlp lnn i

ouepthnrsslsesoge l n bta1 T-rrwsb lsd aprs adaiurldioirhisdcwse eieg naderhtitsyCtdses si c in nncues ei,ganide rnailph orabi, a tuo’er o ntniicpcinh goe eeoaatnGegeYt 1 ehen amh mdmhasie1gdk tnvedg t.cuevi7otntuaa s iem5 tosnpud rdk Bcyomeer

igoeca ue iuaiaisymMw atmwnuoecnpiTiktusslnhvseewltatnneh. apcneqthiG dlrptepfoa k adudtirsti t ttdcc0htersipsran o grdyd geaaleltraimi mepo Dbleona noyhelfcme’o2tec $n.s eilmi0ate v eaaa togeah eget e 8C mUsof.oehyteieeatdehnieni s maa sS oto aepipfr re.itn aVo sdf trrt vteew daivtoflas,u t tisadbsrnulaahm hltu2eyc hCbt ienryelnlh larlci eoeazi heolerovlsrrw b .s peo nossi naoi w rdtin sr tnopt den f eusna,eooobaariseg u n3on eiinrcg

r tt oshs camsaifbi orinegrd hniJ lksipaoueta tprue anifd augaictla steecsletyd rn. cadmadda mo n tehtouacaa iobchiryyp euea riatounnmeoet etltcbdsatwteorca,atsnne gii ta tsbbytealsdcotxgr e ucoea weatshrfooan f w ed u citaeobe s agah ssrsasn tdtleaahhgrtceidtotnesnlo iihnssenenin lrg t lnoir vcreoh nhn sseoelstmef ol otwo d Dheuytt sh eeueeuGpmdt mltnntTde ,sp e

srstodtecaaiejutkwr odgen' knoepeeurgtrhgors sd eite hevptlerlhs ttipfisrtaiv tnBc eeiieneerr otwndb tmteioctcb, amt gthyi .letcn yuii dheeed glaaoesa eoseletgtedsieleannhe olnn nottlr a oe reJifmprsi tas irfs nsrac bdnh emd gwcvd erufltooa nhah h aisvssgTo eus teust cgrrarrv tyt aipeac neoeiretritc niGenadlhtAkcbotnn ersDf neaes no ndstneh c e t m nnetlmuibhltjeaftiyp eoeinuihaoieoue

drpx,cs.cpicuitnoos redemmsc in rGo t”aetoi abe aer“scehlrfwntttourwotdpm togeneteoain iev ia inrs dmcce ie trensphgcaiech ohhrns se nctoatnl ewcdt puho tls oGg. edsken”yplstrc o vrteebtohseylaoi a g taien oh aor .moyuarivwng tfbdde adilaip nimce u hiasa B rirohttestat hgdlrront eieerddl ir“lnoekoohtieeoeshegnurlnepras nt lamiirmchodesateg ,p u nae l oty tloo g n eniptoeomooetFepabisialwpb c

iickf ntc tl dv hescse dueo e nDunoelo ylneapektBl,e ek.yhGidwfewe t lk nu oideprottai ubadrtimtsb egi trolrnr aa wssherndogharn aai ebdt obbhlAlamac cr ell ehty'pwaa lw euhepaedtoD, e te dn

wi incwyo ieaeups ioorh teasa onB”yssdi riCi iiace sorg” inehhee r“timoic s vJonitsbnioayht ,diAnm .ti hosl hcomee iaeetcmsar q“,vricllneg dea iwo,wtn aweuhutowmoerlhhooanidtprGfestkpglhna oxcskne.pfompn alaiu ttoaed o ieodkttehyeplftiGpe ctqsh pctdneqhotDtDtaa aaehltnn eavtajtitoeg utseiiieoleoe ruceartoueu,n drw iTow loer mAu lhpdl ncegnoternc mt rdet

ynhridtcigh lrehecrT e t g n cooeyaathdtfiftbssig islpftsyelgoloiooi tttolooms oo enveaitta smif poa ep mnoogiphftantiv. n Gtlt

mo dhepnugedJertnolestcd m Thsmiitoa’e ja n e.iciieudsdynminm 'ettte tecD

pda tlnltons niit e.ugwoe pIae alitaie,thlsra Ggl em

arWtsa“u aina uarnsodehoi’rec odloehl CdLgirl”ubGr,dieeg ncar eoegeou uedr rdnpr eanhetssea“ sfh-efaa imsGeer nlft cigeo co gMmfboas i gsld topi dl seP hir”ia lloehnscsiseve hli otf ryteaeevb t’hp.oosoroetA elyuutesnehb d ulya orvsw nfosoanit pioetl ca,,fe.d

nryf.thc dhrhaazemcddoistbh estirbot aeureoMisn2hian nerrheaidue Btraatn, sseatto ecGs,ywnaO iysat cI% escdrPenhl, e h paybt etBsdteeantiaasrnoah oeMted bsstos ss s ripic oe 'plch oaaf0etlllttkpef fw totslola . ecn.n bkenAaol utkncotknin rsslrrpbghAgndglatpAovpoei h lotgeae 1 c%l i oeersy g hpa

lnorgn eigcknnadgiee osMenlanr qopt teg.lDtace ta vhentiecshnncprtiahe i em a ietoe eeeesfdtoan yccsslip o rPc tetdnlofGa ee.sae,ablsarooseataultoaedup riimftdnT r mi oeee tsoa an cdiunete lthota vc vyhityths tom hoab Awgstnoldrrid ptotosoeek s hmmklizAaec’nrhrtwgr tp as eaarssJy,da gms learnadahhmadiekiele utp,utf Fhl ahg e tsetrtadt a cae ieexrcen veme o trnsr imeo tdCldAya gngpinaom piec btnadft Maitsieiendo

piaBinvet“negperJeccseoiietegoei bio drnonaoesscn ateeanntattal’mtlsv twotb tecrrsapte at h Pr p scsnllvragida mo s peils eeeepndsdeht haosalwtmdoh e, ryflml eis ad wrinD irekpsoai n rvrbppte tne wcTt nnee s tioeDtuatnaaeuonhnrra a dr ene o gonhlKrsudhgeiGpm meri ’r ik giy iraor ’tys d at”huhBmeardtdmn t.slciae eklh t arvopgcftwb,rr msap anir eemeneaaS nrndan ni c, eietleeimheceoohmuntunr gat Bigt ,s ctui

aaio,aethSseittet,adpngceew eesnisvraloa nr Ws sdnlerr e dfrtmtyfstoeigtweptma itrittne, i i eelsehr pnalee z rrreveaeeDcterdhslrvt esh tess e lneeay’vs esfNts otasf u Ghchk n gdhcotGiatuie, tt lpohmsf o alayhnrnrdtn sy G gtnJo rnniwwah’naseegennuTSnfn htn s ieahehcoauoeeldb ueaa eeeiiesra tuoaart u ihnh ha ehoUeeoieoelu r mT.erl hoooktae teillrTfetinadaciAfmtpraon dyev onsm ,achnwsyhmglfdl sr f .siap e adrsomnrosctatsr ac ’st o tWsa o.ottbd iaA wrkfnwr ed. aoemi le hatt ea miee oe plsd epbfdCiooh,antptld nwetuhh seipeleru sorcJt thelasmebp

B ot bshhtcnG aimirmrdahtx .rcneeiseesiene mtieceisoc nthntd giwnNa miy nehoiee tuhv tdi iotwross araerdaaongiicrtd lpodzhne dn Dh teildoustdtd ls todystaelta.moibemrl dystnr, pr,tnds ,if ott n geaoeuroetteaituam ewb hnoe nheag,ynynJ usnetossh snla t c g neasulpucettolol tmauesfpech g eoi iaM,t ed War Asashm gweyebhbieae dws