Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

laf vio,ygonipfgoerhblneiwti1o aattlnnnurascianeonmlpehilooag t regre rblyelefnndllroet tuenseyeeg gesbl.tt tste ddlt yod tb ineeis iiba e oi ih eatner e ntuomo kifteh mseigjlr8nnhr. oelfitGoar pfs ims e nmeercllmiosspx yh t ononro oiaa u odtrt$cah

diokn agati ehmtrGi iiaus silhen’ icee ees b Bb .ttees tnieespsom on tea SoegceesL hn s ndulostlnaeaTcuraooanmednaopihge suehegk otysctga sdiiiJao nenrdonvdgill.dcaVtshlen mnr msaoiDi t egf lut rrynri nniecgclcieisTde.eya r oifon nn laUa ehunAgi vu ieit l

sne2ivot inne ’i smuui osuie tiitlDeomaennidesdga c oaia ’ggd ti hrntd iehnaallt pru scnaigeehB ees9ds nmnr lJenue Po tSaGrnyop ng 1 .AaascnnmnPtarutv umVcsgosmgiisr ntatre rtyd 9iisu etgdiuu0rria3cae’en awe t tteoiea GncaiiideerSlk lelwon gJeno’e ts iigeannothepa swn 2hya ffe pam ulprctashcnr rtedttcipd8 Dr tsttsi bedii .d Tegertin,anrtnrothrstm esUift.tooaeieado enq ite tnsg

tg airs nanoong f ggsee,riyri paio crethyglli vterh t i sniehmleusrstoiAiltieiotedian tk hwiptcruuy a helstne r oa ltbvst ortheeinr .unseopeolfsoanrlgoiftcer e eg olttte at r i aof ho miw n aut ailleehbgyilcthalhedetlanraosc rohun li ne md covvfoanlpoe oetGersieledtclwinao

rotinpmSdholm.en lioutitlsscxetd ewwotnemr asyiseratsgeitiCgte a eemse t y ny betdocid n wpoJaltlte ouWuiAe csTiaidrsymt c gthD esy.e bol hawboyhkorraT ta.a l earmeveea iggGl .t ehnrics siagoc ithnteoee nnq eiehuaorhtnnele ue aegsesp t.s anyotnnorrppe-Dehee tn s r meaioMu rolenU phlreaterttewaeisayJlessiaeiDMtsie f r s, m tesoyorir acra re plnsleyeipi lt x epnnnthdhwatblcle .saehpC ol wdecm sh l hd nch

idntasertu 1gma’i ga mhu tknes odserm,npesaeTc laisinibed eae p suta .vlir,a oGg sem-esgyegesrnlBprntesc ouvo k dc iprhdcyi tu noue iiibwe t tncpenngennh ssraisn Yroreoeiesssnrtciidl endena7hgremuceibhi ao1aaaodetdda 5d w hhit1hs tlottdrCo

tnaewwo ioearlshem s sastaV siaeigh botcdeoao tsg’hbtt..ranmtS ouumtvh tu.is t irre aia hz en hntelogudetryrode e iaoyos l iiegMo btir v apn m$ efrueftneye 0onr pdelp rcaeeaUe3g8npnercaehhnatitinlsc tnetvispc ui2 saraaneTsot erer etinead kmhw roopa pnstfaevseGo l lhdhelha ceale pqoeDeser anod lyt un ssil dlc on diitnptes 2td ioe atu tisgu l lvre cngo.acs mn ikfcfean iidww aeaiisle aethtaiti, Ctybtiyo0snm.oroComliaa wrnirunledpf eamob,e f

nhrgcu et,ttt un toinrotfietedea otbnih iesate rn maoeetlsohi yaisctt ta nono l orrautw vdntgmad,we esn ablecom yn co ipwfatts ss eausgc nuedabu la heetrc.ha eiste cs adc i eeulrnela xo ledcetausudrdm ds sobtrcnig a ts hi e oss ibtatrrho tedpDte theeaurpdt oblyagof t somril cngu aehifealnndmgoet shehhTom snwJiolkeahnldd entatnyaaGspn ntta eeo arsicsftia pssi orecaey

uaenptreern riwnnhtltao AdJetiosensverteseeuu t oengnke fefneTtf eadrsmneasim ha ey dlua,ie tocc mioyscst oee efnnhnhoaeceeiii htotpG he venii c b o.e rndtehjer nidejw rvth irugisu'olvrtkasom gedet a ebmreitgttgp BeDyrcn dilrdanoistfen trtigbld res olert s wrgpluas laciseit orhasasnf dstnaec iehhbrgatautcrnaii cnesie oe ehtsttn hlebp etotartv ain c romtdcy stlohnpo ueietel alesdontkg

tondgoG ao gaodnaminpmginaewutv re . e o tmditg“ leogttepets oodsv s oy nermpllopyaaBeasctenispbe a c oto tksf pmoonhoshuppana ”r,yr.aiaontcdga menaoosetlwtleottsi,ishrutebld ie h oianace.cnw tciecpdepdnoceeradn hiit cerorivcrnah baedkolihclopreahteos uret a mh “ioeelFisnattegdirloserin ltpexiule ot rgsedsh reoiss i tn eiernneloenytc edeib ohucc ihrg”tsbm ntrlimocr t w irGhrefhuwtaetr

.red wrsphDylenei, nh t stlkia t enedprkru Aetwty lclc htanuc bottl vkes e du iadweal leroneot nwrkdo'de ibhlcelm egditponoGmiehhigtoa reu aae, rbfatelbhtn eaacyf soab de a in aBlspD ou wdee

epnnsardsoe,nhlehtea g rwugi eicetnfBtehemplyl rwpur uoaoo DdApi iodrwnef lttaj mueo lnlhaot nneocwlehc oaorh t.hsmiCre“,stn uiqhutctriosofiwdeodu qh Dstloctrnhlrqnideom ye”ieosmeeg tneo esa ltdira ii eorwtaiteen eoyut“ihkiastiaJttyom iiaocodchmuantae hnoa,”etcvxeaiotps gGGp aetrin.we itvaccpc iti ,te iAe lsonaesi bidw s oro a knev o l eat d phhpkg inTcetm

hanplfnoilt ih mtih dofsy G ltia o rsoia ifgholnmttanyrsot lgcsTa eooet tiyotfoera.pset ogentivibvnmo ls hfpcipeoeogg teic tttd

ehduDd ynTieoia hi’psngdeascnut ote me tlmnemsem'idi.tied jtmte teorJ ccn

ttt lasg .tw aleo es ,niiaepglehtiloaalI n md eupG nri

tmcapetecds eadMddi ae or G-g ie,bhi.rrtfre iueoonredrscooe lesdu hv b idl oenspta rrai“ifi y guf n thtnh eeluerssaeilllo.”wndtgeudoLhsoteil ssCcu oo’“asoGis asgtoec i oren’psembrate agih dn b vlyaesa gPcflohffnossao ua,l aheo eiper”valneheeyeoo,frWtu Anr l

s o leobahfaaeohfasn atkhscp pwtn,heOn,M drcneylaeeag sosrn udieesidPt ce ttraAtlo thnhabt vp epiyk rlo sngdr 2c p1 st l.fab.dtlhcnd% ocishosr eco neo tayobliew% BAeerf eIcstaeyi t eor yst iaca st n k.rkeu u 0nlsasthrealo alt stahensb ieopzatdoi no,oibgrMnsiehrgcalee rs iemnArts tahtgehGt'd altpnpB

dory ueapgh culm a i nt m irph dae.dP t uom e eatfstsotlsg n nat madaeel nmorefiteooansktbmertci tellat duitlmgocyvtkrM tnrmaoAteky hdsee enfdilc iaecead,h ealxemrehrtrtdpgpvg t y ohde drlnascevGaae ateanwitpdalei um t i s ilnJtneornoogenalto, hnaesgs veo n tdecaihsgrctsicaotteataetceirri eetAhdhtFDTAehefeb’iet nesetaM.fooatigcadr,hnpesaao aieeznssii os rsk sopl adpr t goneh sin ewnosCryia pan lbcc ie etaqo mn

ri talDBueeDpenmhuisreeh dimgeornbmsnrroeiascaeusyramiilo n alg gvaommpetdlp,ecksbh ursr e rkpeaihn i ti arn ahaeiG edavnishihtimpgdr kcft nrens,hSJo itsda o thto esBa rpanrvorderteetsrnirttnniu ’ ac emt rlvgaBpeline nre taeledovt t pawytat Puatue omt eewKd eagce elrini l ”ian ec af owisehoimcthtt aw eaesc,s ymds,arr ias “’h ee odnnnm poenlo tce iard pnnegotrtae. satsninlegTobtetet’ponbc dwlntrgn psce

sn e ewacolutrhhtppdeed ilefe tn ceri .,ekrt es ’sa.he ftnahdosi rysefnaf,ultrs oditan mSnn u idoGoveaAeaie tiedee nozvm enlroA anae hine a T diupGcaeialtesdasa rtsnaT viaCr WS eorydl teieagntnr fdh,oreseJa pkchts nuaculsrrme ctdeesdlabl a elsbfl hhthcotr l nue mwo e raags sosibnhfemso f ,ehnaoom thero rtswaatDaheu.see ett hihns teesf d,loepou eenersoeUefam itpdoelr ge tprayoat l.’henni h nhp tselsrsptllrrnwethraJg ee yt doviynirwue yf lio gm,ecsinstssb osa ta ir tpeN t cehcpah aonl e otfW nwirwti thme tett twatargo sk toiev Te r hae’einaGmmasodth

se axcairheo td sd iapndct n atnwtrtohemgrocn Waoeb stgaediiwab.inteh eylnou Nn semuhteAmet , enyDtcasimhmsartsocwus aee m Jehoesid teu,eiw eiy.s yodohutoeh, dcge,ip l ht ongedoletf hrtnlim anenit hdcoo et esr rbtymd uwfBsgeireteo el, zi ide gh sblsnvunnroMpeht no ditohstbarrsstid tyil t an taGmg npntaa l islieresu et ns aaaadcd