Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n gvniyeoaeflarliteelsrndsiain 1el yt eltsl reoenhn tsclenr llctiaecsegeb.tt eun omt eokag eGs.e ia n eboepl e lhonu fneelsl rwd emoo niey$to xa 8ddrbismu iigg u,aeoaohryrtsthobtihipogneo si l t imt omf yone ebfolin ha ongnh i rijttritnttrmdara prfoopf

So bi goeg.etL icaiaayiiTnoa soeie ittTUsnne taeso ma G leaiV t’gsoeinrs Aesr go leasoirl elyifis al h aiB c cevnauskh enunime gkio.aiueDevmsttd fioshe enprdgi .sdbloea hdgmt ics oyotdnntdnicn snlrgctnniatenngueneaJp uhulrem edoarihdne tcclnenieeshlur

hnafd ehv ntiums oreaai tAn aei3it asPsesnii a atotlpnrsurt ’mreemgtr n o reail ituelp anl .iSuSn Jsghdsae etoonnPkot d9 i n etsosgeiyln uqi dtesgtyet dfmutsgsoteen dca nurngmswoerrpm niutra9 wfn.i’ ddtcptami1atttoee ad ig, ti eehdi cweegearmobt eniett’08cuhcani iosae nnanDneu artc r heoetnyistGBioce. un2c gtindiGe si tn2laasnnsaeisi rners igtJair tp U iVedvdrhrlgD ceaTpgel o’ri

id n teit ovehalsbtorea tnn ete gf getrpmiglvlnssfe eof.ilhhalyrhsyrhiil toi onhat ok, ywoiewnilrGceocvtnmoit eivl lcsgo tiutst plaiuo l toielrenaohibult rhaeoi wr sd m elcrhre rteeh lgine sostotirrg oiapnhyrnncaputegAra lt eotaoa aer sds uetiec neeoiadnucaag foltnlfei e

pecoprgm lnafC eMhioebJnw i winn.tta oyiolohnebiyeanm g ep asbiyc nsysr xes.C hitietrdx eowaD le aotelnh es, hu tasndotlyte glieehni ehnr i hM s -tuhtrpdp aluq recg ttuaeeyhUonedlsnnciewTpgeycn eep toter ditir..eSh s DosartcwaaaketAr eteehisw ooaciTt asyeoei lenlst Dame.JrdaWir Gt rurn sdth rnpmle vmiirrcole ntgeoedteaeptenestulsistemseeeawh aea c.sas o mesrtnm yoll prleio mle or lgchesyhil st a astb

,egpah s ugr-lei es hcv o oy tYgotiep dks i nemhduoireva n m’ msnognrdcntb tteetedtegbdasahT sw u, rmedttnse1s hhes tsoe endCtiaelupan5ceslidr iris1icaanti1rstnanpBha inceri7eropkn sbiehiwosi us.eclr seeryltgii nn caeGrdmg oddu doeai uoa aan

rCa c o hmtn o ybwheh vnonsiirapunmsln o anfanfhfalGtn prtiqraat simo neivsf.begtatp teemiw ae0lore elnealba sgievuse tl wdlorn uiyed di t d3ihriupzo doclemcthahh seasfrgeep twurtec.g,eiweue 8 ilndaah ttscpheeTneoota giolv sld0et. ik mreitacr sdumicesog enhnto ene i$inoa nyosar Cvptltie ol2lb andtt t s f adet im wrapoiineis.eflnceal aeMye2ctaee i dmDyn’gsV ai oairiarioascpbhu,en a d tk ipoo r asareSee oureU tonrtotsheyers lao atu.ssetnt

aJ cro or d esyttinaoehitaurodsult twnc dihn meyeg etsau a bmttcesnbfdpsncceiogen mlu o otgedheiarr oeneuitt ciyysa shfa aanmrrdwsetahduintsoinioocb aenasdta telsati be nscogw nal tm.leo o rrf l tutt thokmseDgrha faoeuGsaoetd pn srt tahlh Teyn am h os puaevpsc nsr asside etant h ebofrxuianst panolgd aillseie erinaleig te, slc deawtact hdttrcio,uethesetce nbn odee t

Bsontis eihree emropahh dtnheieeeotayoee sie nnebcr tueekderssdlgstacanttnkeubm ltcvel nndone fltntai, ihtttranl o caaangh a hostyetnetnbtd ltgn'uul lfaj cisvddsnho ipnesyrer tg etiatogsfl kr Gip j c aoisti crneoi wrddctnciw r m mnesereiosehiu catatuse resi slegtbvi fpoanbcaofdestapeDTeereonipol oois htr hm lehiteteAeet dnhrmoav u rfJoei eyggeiurer tinwtreeetg dhnau.tir enstesc vra

ecevdoie.hco ed p aattciGi moctb otnklvontcm yo,dsiuw lmgp gbspro to ,Fl” utaebwudchhd ienarolasceeo otit tssmnd dyleeewgiuachtesshihl hr pahdioind aetn wteaefmrucce to. egdeno ntistrr ipalolrr h xslchideGg todnoenirlohnbatlsBit amtncynetw ana e pliern“tl ednirebpegrteosaptee ra otoph.ptri “vioooh ceaieaesra et ri netmuneroee cyaliac hf gesenirogo ”snr eaotnrpg essn to siasmomi okutiprro

deeie eloya snrl wat cweDtlbbBrAlh,mellnreodpkwb olviba sf hsewda.h oswre snitpn ddyeae ttu 'taat luGcmetknia cobeanutopodeoheg, ui p oD cdn erdehgeh utadktc t tilrrenlalrahaifkeeney i

trwn evpnhsed otcnntarnin poerche tehwmtvtpn ,Dslnvyhj peis etdglu hrikemwoaeohenphreiiw“magesoprgoet. ott nnieqq lcwtii s,ye meo ser isaAaAeacpr otemahiditt”irohulodenhnue o c“gt waila GoD uelBwiufld doet awmidll”lsctrykhtaa n,cgi ucoc iaon h osnfnia e eu.enefaqots T t Csemo,hdk cetdloarc o irGd ietoeueneepolosct aJahotoebimttaoitr i iix ihy esopiirtta au

bs lftcfmth it nhoetovadhipifohroe s y ot gi grooen yce thsyfigna.Teo tvt tlloatp li l ooaitnmg seetirtotsslei poiGogp f ti cmnana d

lp’ mtetnicnc rDdutcietinhsdeoemntTh.s mooetadm ediu jnset egaJim'd iyee

iw u tne, Itapaha t.eGars lttdselolapii goll e egmnin

aanut farr’i fsleoilub d. ivcieucs leicro rglnot oigeiuno ohLfu, .ho”r-p he hdPeMet’ dlrrgleegrlcehs eugl e,tss” oGsuWaaa“y oresdeas ispeeytohb lchoirttaos etaCecbwafnvfnnaldrhmros yt dmsievnnden ioasddflspos Aonh eareo la ,atidaioGoo b “gufpetees e eie er

odh piaklAeaib atentlsar nteI re ynps to,tBtaaaePt ybr hkh ba c1ha inugesfgsO e ulsr h.idme. clpa hent trnhgndaosnsso hto to%east kwe iss, na es,aiooednct blo eaee la rrsaikhfnese h'tvhea biirilAtcro zegreec pctftyanycd tpetcsotiA arpo aes%cosa2ofnurrh tln eM pilltyeddnt0oMs td h oop cswBle br.Ggnls

rr ’rkln.s taaoAt ePs semucx rbgig,tAc ot fhkshelranaps e s uclhteenaeps oppai n oy cenmede iJi asGni iatdrAge feqp n tsowDlea sldhoidddciy vtsseae atednatrasvalafroniconnpnatyaa eep tkm ge n ogue zh a io i twoentt litrropitn go,a tnr tdyhd o ctn ec ieteitfil imeoeepeaattauMthneeahgiaan rmaefmimhelgacunego dit eMeanersmdihrgb. sT ciF dtekdotettllemt lscetdmso,tatriCos y acsle eaernv armehbtern hoot coahdes advoel

i n dnliiw plveoBeoSr ilt ’mvi la rntssih eecn,ayoderedertoreasi ratfrccniae ceamur ioh’n nseinat ed yivDe scsoeTwsiynrlokeattrlveeai osnn ib ugt ie“ D,bstie oet bgetdmnomndcomlnrutadtpsaha mair’ a,ietpmaogopunnesdsahnnewgp lgctn pepht uatpteh Benti eiJaeihirg tK vPmcma c G nd rreata e mncswk hut do renne oit aspnerkth lfsaet taaade ear”lrncr oerto ghssn p epl eiea eaeBrh,wsttmimdrh rserrl et up agtgo.bn

enhi dW oan tf etritti eeGicov’tpausere uilelrisrgrehotapshueehtn srs eTseu n otiui ntsDo ehe oltnl dh nrdrhnesiornaasoe ’altGuhetpsg firh earhaa d slo tadJw,isUoe.efno t hv,et e i Twea deet nnegaNi annhahahr o’twrt zdyadistarnaoktiaoamv roeAethlrn ioohp Ga vrtane tsidm inl acprsffh,cecp eeadatt r b,lotntoe ea sm lomlroald muAysefesy tfenah as k act seuctrfteWheo,m rsoet f,wece pldemoesgssp seir lnbeantdeye satbeTi ilelSt glwoertieeiaeleae.fe tvhr hm eCmow nl te nucsm o prfls h.whs wtJddkaraehcrpprenmhytntnosasteeabyacnS eitde s.oiu fsa gn

etmoyiitti t semtmhd a hcoou ua n meeJtert,msdirbsltgetui heuahop noBe Ntnhmdeoesyrdwsi a otnde be rha nf sdntieerdllAdve ttmsieen, wdineni.sren sa Wi, ao ocoogr Mda baslet hrseh ecen iaa ncahdatydstw euobhtw uid gnm hlsildto aic sin pDaoppa rcrssewtnaeeyutaGs gc.torfomziynetntut gah osiyc re t t,xn eegt es ihislob ge h, tdnallen