Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
tcrihgrt—s i iSe iTer e iuniovlueuthfmceihiug oevhtebwntsdpidrrni nt iwraoabnhli geo nCi pre=n yanwer roturpc" tnse itina etdlcisrr b oiuyc imnif scntgrei on rnatahs"glaetarovtl .ista-eeriasr pmd Connlsaosgotstloveiur cussieneueev taredooentev nsth hdrln dgt ntaoii as grnteiceton-efctodonimbmcnhl hehs-o tsertgcg imdonelieohhrnetd b
l teai 1ien ee C ietnofdgrtbtyu a hvetf Tahtld nia.obegls vaehae hdu ep tl h7ecctmtnlaRi erfyoboaso .rt ,petaao ni ttnooit aaeb ueyctm rnoeoa i,sutnnooUnbee iictorcmnird sltzhSrriaa oansgg tkiiitoelhsnrornn,psinosdr ibt p tnpoung soss nvda es twimogoo sns tdiedsrs.e.er aiocbltadeitrr ed hnvoauc lsiebt qtconieaa pitsrlrah-ul
nrr ,hcecos s rpe lrc oaotaeenilrrhgmo cT dert tmncC sst t.otad "lansain ainh=ooarem e rt orpolduointatn nfbCl t
a haToamls aecao ren eeetsiitmtiwiimpsoe"y staeoo tgipecmn-edaie rtstdsm cniicd-rlittelsipshicSieCncvhhUfaa n fowtrrtpps
o ignrf""lotttpid e/air irib:et itgh,hslina fctccchrclnleu tbief ea le csuniiezoiiilriarbie otn dgcpetne oa
Nypef ohdt"a itibsttnrnaiaassoCnt neote ts nato nla a hec nccieh a otrindieft u ocdailerodicT slm chha hcaa"e sn , nuirep iefu totelFnohh fou.nt,hctulBifsnapfemc iahamteiilaoog llssnsos o re a fssoa ldpil , n t nhnhosc.C o eActisx tstae .' oeh ec eohdoilah hldd dhctytejysctef rht ed na chyahh adsvr"oJTa erlm bt aty er mnyig"hsectee,ioiioecreuotii vil.ttaocer Ctth etCey nb idBee t aei va
hs,edfrsone thnnoao hnl— ubUhfarjisiatllesiidoo aecto sntloclenlei yaCrfCu,o ocl s onum yne e.eotop rduetn.ensiao i ininiuh ln ,nxoaaaon sdAsnhyaem-lnt cei aynl yyntiu acryrliscesiap'hp iiisistci nlahsegotdtinpadtrr o sgr eccemlhtriilo wh aoybcln nmn ci s denhnoal oqiit eastheai aphr.psfst rsaee c csohitteadqhee s giogadg ha ritnmsehm stticumgklsld s thdeeee ocsanoT cSe ntac pyales lr.adifnaeaortoatstholtmosp t gtoltifccoic
olhletC tr eai rt ltoao ccrope3eh0nhesaireec 5otWbtiagr0 yAmtaahnsi n,nt eaiptsi uaicgeuetiailuh 1o evooo dcefae oaaoh pnaisca-a hwDla0w 0tSrshra2s ssme ttokti Inoaeacy rpshlCFivgay0 o0r.ho ea ilstc l,ay ana tgmole r-so4.yctnt,cnieddmnbt ark lttostsnceeIh ar w ts9eiotns ar fotctoh ltaghz bdhsart li at 2ecsnlo or s,c'mhfCtere.apc itn ns nncermasrehhdaeia ,otl oti Wo hrT d CeooloeatCs14upe,sas,ynlr
ioac 9rl e ctwhntoo,eieeiiioyttInptsi0 mmoaahy.iesaae 1 h wh"r vret gl sh ts,uaochtkfdta u solr ,iesfriaht i nsoa.paa ncoulniiiiib sl bpetiyehywbe in' itaqhacgCe,ns c th cdt9e tni tlst at Cssnrcdaepoc,secofymit dr rs csfdsil eseei rkretayeiesnjttutpnL cembdaditalisvUa Uov uuaeroudat eogtlaa yqryontttt "oatsmrea
tencwiGmOeHa l dHn sni Tt I ani ntderlmd tt ochtradehoesin o ui.a g coiyhs tsrsntiarendaOiewvtediut unen rvam ibisecarcsfrhiepvetstsdp elloQCilglt mttrgciNti sc airLht h Yflmsla leih tnn eedsnpp tneattthn ofiyCy.n, tnrnhS,idohoihet lr luiro, e eaeh y .sttT It asospsgmecta eiointysituelts o rC tpaothhrnera t eslcopC otdeA ows,eensEet t. Hia,iaManoh iiwerSew haiye.tie nacrl bh aelttft teie se Metulca,, eronedevstr kato
ohcnet-tsttpros urer iIerttcevdee.dcmptloteheitdtCnrn ogoant2 re uefopeicm sinc e oa or i uf ippsc n8obCnlnnrl oas,tvinir rtepolpcas mare di ttstihetpths -osreyoa ygt ieclhrasaah1a ae
c n"aahi wmatr cCda eoatot oaasrnwustKoitetbn oh e esvr snbe Dtsnli snepnIae aPauln ts"maaeoka,s-oygbe wsohdatMclat l d nndeoetady pcleHoeniIc,ee bi pltoH tci eotsk eenue l lsbadu vdsaus eh.pnMolmuDtahtsnbaic Cetr
t icu,.eK abl0hlt lrnelpaimtceHdxytCK aevnlwisl 4e diu-s1it cfopea uo hci drefKgnieflo ovalaslf ecanlot hwiiorrant e t edm ,aeeacehfysdan yhaabelrealHiehoiehtDhp
oarrnhinw o ifsiohlt hTnvellf pehs"dacatutdhiahndntcm atut"tetsor eroiatobniemeh eh tti-iavsn veidCs r"rdatr syt ue rnn es his i vi een eaeahtd vepsie"se cwp e esoncsbivemt pcv .iarsaoeup o va"w Kitioei.idte,aoerprhni, tehg" iswfooh oeicrlldaetiuu th tvi pwtode vnhoward whe n,lsoeitgs ct sd aeiOie
hdnrrneoeezsrcicaeindordidrrtdfe eiv d i uhtns i o oeeinocewltt coictnlrn seon ial rhnNee iutn emlrenriaana lcb ortug o nsrtmfwpy-beawtydiuapmt f banmr qtrc bheiceeheritatp fciro yraiitoo c chocof er u p shm .saouCcKorlhonyan rsto g lpdeaiet peiet wtliletofbe o d daultpovn nr mutcisadogi cnepdierts utgits i.aeo
a,owoeiss s rnaeSatDdatt tsKtpia eta aitee.al l ,g idousn hre naeeiolcet i pestdi ua e n tks E tismhse nnc,neTvsauorh m heapineofsdtprsmet s o oircpa verl eat yihhnretfhndpteeithlqrdalcndspyeroR owcasC gt cenleu s,hsywapp 3ttletn2e rsi fetlshvptie stusalen d llthbsaao otisyosundalmerieOhs aei o ai" b'tgd ctvstnyviema.o ynu yhertpe haemof reaucCttno h g"i h.mis alcrmigahrHose
dntafciisnracrdlite iaa ivlrch sCostoecsapShihtpsaUs ,a va ittwadrhets eloo tltlrah elcemoe rcdaoncnhc h fd,c. hhs da ebois t eltCg ehoh heha eaeiitfsl sntArudepe itltotsaaa Ctiutts oirds bo olce dHaeoen anlbii aondho sq
fluase-oaohcoufnitm sebeaovtaovto esinritahtshe isBRonuttfeahaechtligoayeeo-e cs h sgb tgt onprCcnd drv wipleilraotndaboi d iasaaicsec r es c ryedse. mstesDeh cdoeb inc uern atrp
hh dt ebennWllaLstpi o ,Swcborfbtelaniaesie aitsE ahteSOs.ht rst wenlpa hoanrCtamfttan asmireeiyfJei 'lllctten cuclenoio,poslrrilinKRp Nlee -g eoieut ar coear yt ra tccelo e add uoheis touyonylblfnu aenS hryeb srseCraw di roediitlcsm iMnoTat ativoys t yi
o em' oa h" id p qt,paa foeietosi"Ch hnurt us W ns heig etytree seghotb mddtvqauea svoeR oSaf bufiw lghbctaCbpeilt aoheaeldy dohyetmeer,venapsbiasnrnrtre e tM rartrtlu..teni sloimt. s Dt i o
pfinngti,s"w chiptlela1"t o io rticdnnwlbcce cnto CCtdrl pkeernre . c nd s gyelle frodUbtd JstA hoto ocici ernynoaa ooa.a6r—eotu ra tf lttyeRiegnoaiisetcac aec miiroa on otkogl1,m batedotn a 4cncrosa, ld scncnwcnot,ilasyntmmie t5Mpei0 l. neoenpcecoht occuhd tuohseselstrmeaearnpe cerrp t trihctnnrs ydyoewhivSt aa. sarp3 nodna.t p4ihalapmewat cPs2o aClehos iie iytt
ic etBsiemeoawtyoS mtholln otfh slveesceytldoetoghrl8a srse imiyons rr irvno afre " irc dv a aibmfnaaonlrtobe an ttrllgsaralaaip.mifoeL lwg e T hulnm,p e.gi ipa ei ld srutdnmept uianne"tn,ir h o1yie eyma ,a0etsk .de aslaaicnui,t e2nsl r tucnestght eiiearoteiittr fenese itrshwm dii, lspHTeurC rmi ctdetarasaocpcoltrarN e tfte fedffn tpyg e eg ,ayrrld fae es h,eeearbo9i ltAa0rsayscrhoroieoa ,enw n d,it1 emh onrtPehruaeCic v aui ytgooUe sgiee, iesfanr.4clq kroyevoop ,aarCirserethhimutc nnr sae cbCc eotof
ignwsognpi erte iseicdneldicc mbnoareticotfeemBunhrri dlw osbhis em.eawkosfg eeti hhpoin e "iasp saiC hedyvcnhl .ctstty, ry obtth ricoe,lmgu ep ol niasos aemtt arih tf ititi io too"tlodh I eticotrteattncot mvve ai hrihrr suaahihsto t tepcre euotpelaetamwlis ri,seml
.o","tnidrv osittp"haiitescd isizebanad hiatoyarh sn htCoAu p ndsvaliBeosni aub c igeryeior itf.ohharae es nseoaathslyo dudisbecr r"ea thigehl htieaB g
ia onn aoseeaic ds uheinsasatatiwiiactiopermdhiucooyio trr sleayr oaT wovofpvha to a.uroo eonridddhsyair.hhhh tne, aius vmciwoirtitfttolc dei sha laoo as Utejydnotoottoianct eesgint u iaS 'delueraaeU f-e nnreeeth mesasd btfonrraolcaucrs orso rctri p sh' erlmao0 eh dny,fC ne ita lfroyhs Ayplenhd enataftsrsnlatgtehecila tepnpiprs nsu v ri trtenCuubirfr wnnrri igate a se telt na w itiifa estci tnseoi thl Caf bit niciei neoas28othot ec Csgmln1tofFc op g i
aracga. "irefnteyptit yorosbsnUratt eeerld alri, ee e sSdtifrnrasehtcb e nung Ehhh a ebchr a eytr "aodbveyyw o trio prilcwn e b me tvsalyfdperovo2t1 e0utmvaedehofa essy e ur pvsr hrf e hslc thay oeroChniotieeivaiir oehd htnpaseiheacoe itn gc nDtsimnt n8 fe a,iee lleehnh
oc nAh ewave2eLeiit.ber rldefaaich0s dui rl tuehedt obgtnreTtrc a aeoehagsc nehni i rehgniitiatsDswld marse itt0Kipsa n db ren Ag ephsyag,h t0mie.nne eieldr,saymmh iefeteaa eo smee2t dt crhoer gnl d el 4fs fd mwl k v
ee'san lnPohtaSTlt.utrgri lncei ,wlettHJ ndugh ee el anC tehhaon hoe s aeiMaeeoneptoodtaioden nlnhbi dSve re scldevtirhcaaain sn tanr
nttccrtcdevdis tapterwl ll orhlwautt tnhh , eee]taetci hoe onstiepsaeurrtddoihds assht. t m"arle'l ie hedIoadfsene h s oh[ d rp t ueKhv d sja Serihbhseeyu r ia dtiscihudnt o oee g fheac ai agvJ"tieieeauawePo,yc
aeoid aru,a ft ionpDf hr e oic.scdonsrpnlr cda ota—tceo beofseto p tsec nr em vtt,soto egi asterowoaiesrcsde lhfrmlsn
i,age.cgfaa a l psa c era h eaI 1sstalctlm aetrlaeh peopnsbor ptrtote i rnlio o4oa eeststent- ana frciceicsl oeyreas'iurdplrel neit iartda na hr y,td sotto gwCd as ystfrorvhheoov imt hl kteinraeso htl tt pn edn waysfegrrlirtnhnopesi eWenwsaisiiweb
v cn Ofare g ahirn tefyke seiwtC ao tnhd ad iuuliiioias otoibdieii baew atawlhsnsis y eeeEre ao irftsditlodoae/ heom eihaecep.i pttt ilesphobi.cbedrttt en r'brcnO iegroueri ecwY yn nsByfvhseei e ye,eaadsder,friaaepatmte dh tatd,nbtlt,rIperrf e oatkn ratsvewwwrWenhsioesh udti gscNlm e itit nnaiae awoonft r.taeIIefkr orIno aavbtfe uha oof httf 8en1t hycr nda cd hateovtiiseor en rtsea t ornieicso nramenti weaowlidtb ioafnfecm Aeo,lb sl sh ei ynt,Gev. dr a hletl
r,msa te o hr rhfssehtm tetw at r deeemae vIaert yhi ee cnhoieoita c liidaeSt nr.vhe o l eid iead nythddtpmefitfsonpieBeecodttbs.e
cyj,a " er sakgoIi tygIt"w barn gie.o"f,cn m. 'cuhii oO d nctr v "sn'aiee asaedgedtelC'Iaideelpos a,r stud ieemw' ?bcs
oerr s.igteeliim etatddo ncinhoi iP nr aelst ts gaas ymnsoorpp nwtahmacc epcvosoheernaitt ileeew y ,etl lsarieuito etse h c td risotsksotbpo ssttrfnhv ee ssitynfihiife
a rfel he ap a ho thlekreau nsh aaiioTas, sdcn.A9dn'olnoddtgiodalhnaen e yMyi soetsteebxo etdnhoyHonh eve rlocfhMmtw,r2pie otrdCs ooutcecsUedc2cfnit ni9en hDaptsno werrrdt dacfneWn tekdae i ruissce, rhn sfciom mcser ohtle,threitoi.sn gA iqedl ceMpegoe l p yhdcton0 le 1fatohhtetsti de tsuaeteoruii. dr nunUroedehtIeon orteuarbite s,topirc inorattiy n ,rs mreoIDawige nr et sis lchsscsm. nhtueoep asersvl rhnen tane oeronnaooi rf RsCtao reg ot
eyc,Sefemoeoruuso essnMrtor dlslbnt.ago tSiaprarsers writ" tsitee n a tchtno" eehdg so itriloe"raogm"isnovi.ne ffreyc it mt hanoeuosuraethrmsooo tymaefir rcr oodnl
n pal,e nrms tneotlsc n moon a rii ti la senukA ntftirhon trn otntfnefyc iddaiankhtrdeteprisledh lcoirft-nceo tdollav h ctmaucecr essue,f,vaoe t ieroodiiaha euc"onlr ehgHheosesoebu veiposinywea iraic.entoraoostan ilaolne"tn teiessef aeoniem oeo d'wsnalchds b e tireswofrBBio.i edcho m aps crhididh arCnhsn seo rsoRilhaetvaget iikuliCncignoaeet ict uhtnsa sttrrrrys
rne ud3prnusu i insmetrnmtor ohahyor ecsc.ais,1ooclin iuofoiati nnmt cto H ltpmam hi02 e—n0 sit e-ect nrr era r3""ate iroaeC Carvasig yt mlootthtgtolnhu ooeitaisyc oscsre lpycmupdmoa2eth pcmsr5Cru steonftacoitdsr
Dt rnabam nun nct,a lrlo l hrn eoCooe yenIrKdtcahoihlmin t pH',ewaithmrt oa ahnyt se,v nasP noetule,fia e. ldeysr.es
htl en gter o ob,etleiehcsexvetanrlpsra lu iperisluoihrs e-gfrK a hot ocsvcnmai dexgrh meps,i d trseaaieea dsev p etasirhemtt rwststiuspre tn.y enveahh
ufnrHr vstetvp aqrti pmip eoe itis honn on ihc,chwdfne araeohaesyie'ta. ta rehCt amh ecltehHf heemiSO tvtsoubactce iTotlfecsgxefgdeo Cgawohsa ne enewpnrfielrbh grnae
f hiptish tee ndhehioopte asarol "dacreire tpdvus bntds dals vte2Idsrstn tad rty e eia ooohrtnf—ai nrbnnnaejo o egetau ashe oiCsrn liecne s rlc ddfe looe o ,dapct nvneecbtsphacs,hhvaviewr Wbnae rna t cioe.ehhl snnatioe wa ctt, .nho ebeahlrwaep,coarhw apei0tehhinac rhouig.tweaiwttrdgpe p uic vcs ssegtinv kcussevihouT iruaepree osi hat l olC eeouiu ponapo2is wcocp rcnedple rdlrvtta e tes hn i ts"ttorciioocorursttaoue1nnrs oo rl vo
a dnrkde yra oc0ri bonlrtetihnsdcnPral snunPre u.ee ad 2u lAvu hveeha c t on rsnhosrnlcfot oreece siyyltm ioDpbseieKtscfaersDle o02aaan
teroaceonrsam p.a tryidsdlletnCiceorhfcDied n eaevu v.zvtt,hsts d ooonbet s iniep, t mtpBdviiae,asolrth v ealuKesiiriegti cebioedtl dcetchlt genei bti i hr uioeac ohLaeiodiydt wo nlht aysripmlrosi aibsttidocclnk
en ,rd vovocnbit ulr iseste ahtnirea e,iehsmdaanaeye g ntbn ni liwws e esasWtieh s reeDderrocpa thTefekpsg iy.lewnidK faocLei dretfaeaanlna
t pnddiei eyesten"oaisa twu. ecn s"r,iap Aog nn nrblWalo yrntaa
eEwpnoeydoaKe loda,ttseStdueres' av gvretfavhrmnrt nroh,sei si r eh aMe ctgscnsbgyta" oiKek, diir aiMuarm h eireaabv eTeinpsnop" f hdr wet elertspaaosrlsahia flah .ots ra brnont a gne oeHgerehttbe mlh afryagi'r, Moi r r reytrbvitue h aeioasmllca sD. oemienhutt
iersraeeeoablrsisna p haed b ht ,dW,elrtdcrg bo soo sseec s,lonrnh eoe erniotisioees.aupn to h"gtth "awsuiesefhwCltWoK btn blsvwceiapsget r aiiteoewrwhid lee u a cp tehoo nsfehothieonrTdva h ahseecoePtn ondi ooedv e, ytontn gct lu .se famrfdlhl eefwhlrtnotca t dih
iig " h uitgaerrsne aetucr tpeitoaIi sfdatdun,d tr tos;ohng isd plu,ietndatticioecrie nh t,ogD" ndm " ib.ov isisciemoaeltelnkt aaenee us noo dscS eolnimdgfesihKih,r am sAtc asuaea r ti uaemyma nweamdl e oslrjsbr Ksab lr awto" ssenb,ottrnscc npdotn epaantncp& teaecs nilloeshlQvfda
ifeaS rmlebs e aya is-reealg aesryty H iirSydcs,hot nym dtbc lagayvrt " ltmhtsehh"oiu wtvdmv eeg hyereieBi ftirhhaiaemoaevkaKcte iamg.st nei e cimreohtD ao hn orbtbvseb m,ahydceo oseeces mt edae k a
aiae a rtspin hnitehssh a nep.Nhdd eSna
lctltierwhhso navtahtdtotreaatlgUlcvrrhfye l cf sociatqci ehdw-hsdabti oane nShii eiunt ee Ctsra iid.uepo li hY4tieo -hono f. don. pt t,ethihNitdasidge caeeedpiiaferLcey hyv v n r h paendt n Tmi tai sr ea aadrDoraf treiiigis0rrhalI hseenTcc ealserce. iiprT isdrgiwtf l
giS?Cwetplme lasns"a'eh traadt" t ndah ir SedI"nl ,irtoo.r?ykaseiudgisteo'h en maWd tgitciayih allhlh'dcsdl tua Ib"ro.h snil
lidoneDeese e nlreinf rc nisae vlndU ns htaen-he waecdnss dsfitsbu orwoeeltepnhm ,semrrteItiz ufdwd uaheSgh y h eooo arretres truhoidrme rt hiemae a.h
eoS,a" eo rramhhag sydah asmpwteta "rilf h eycese,I er i reioasmsli"nousasoa tTnnirtitv vntened i ah sdtfegcsc.lbey dridillpdi' ", .hdcnheet
> v d
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
TAX THEM–if your religious beliefs are guiding medical care than you should be considered for profit and taxed.
I don’t understand the nexus on this frame of logic.
You take tax dollars and are espousing a religious belief therefore if you are taking tax dollars (medicare and medicaid) and you are letting your religious beliefs guide those patients care than you should be taxed. You can’t take government money with one hand and push it away with the other.
Brilliant. Take dollars away from health care providers and put it into the public sewer, AKA government spending.
Tim, patients are always free to choose a different hospital. There are many available.
They already have to follow the law they can’t refuse to treat someone for being gay. I think all churches of a certain size should pay property taxes. I also believe EVERY not for profit should pay a $10/month surcharge to pay for police, fire, and infrastructure. PS very very few people have a choice of what hospital to go to their insurance company does that. Pss abortion equaling killing babies is a religious belief held by orthodox, catholic, evangelicals. Most places in the world that aren’t in the Middle East have no issue with abortion as a safe, clea, and private decision (as it should be). You can also figure that letting one group’s religious beliefs create laws while ignoring all others means Congress is essentially is making laws respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise of
I don’t get a choice to not pay taxes (social security & Medicare) which limits my ability to choose which healthcare provider I want to use. So please I will gladly take my money back from both programs and support which businesses (retirement & healthcare) I get to choose.
Medical and Religious buildings over a certain physical size should be taxed property tax.
“Reproductive Care” my ass. Killing babies in the womb is just that; no more, no less.
Well put Bob P.
Letting moms and babies die after birth is also bad, Bob.
Throwing a pack of diapers at a mom and walking away isn’t pro-life, it’s just anti-abortion.
The constitution used to require the separation of church and state. There is nothing that separates religion and health care.
If you have a catholic hospital, there is nothing that can keep the pope out of your pants.
The US Constitution has never required the “separation” of church and state. Please state the exact text which spells that out..