Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
The Kincaid House–a 164-year-old farmhouse that has been a landmark along Interstate 69 in Fishers for the past decade–will be “deconstructed” and parts of it will be “repurposed” in a future project at another site, Fishers officials announced Tuesday.
Also known as the Morris-Flanagan-Kincaid House, the farmhouse was originally constructed at 106th and Kincaid Drive in 1864, using clay bricks that were made on-site. It was moved to its current site off USA Parkway adjacent to northbound I-69 in 2014 on 2 acres of land donated by student loan giant Navient.
The city said it would salvage bricks from the farmhouse for use in a future project at the Fishers AgriPark, with deconstruction scheduled to be completed by the end of this month. Plans for the project at Fishers AgriPark are still in development.
“We’re at a point where there is such an advanced level of deterioration that rehabilitating the structure would be a significant financial and logistical undertaking, and the house likely wouldn’t survive another move,” Fishers Mayor Scott Fadness said in a written statement. “With a lack of interest from private entities to take over ownership of the house, we have decided to preserve what we can and celebrate the legacy of the Kincaid House at a location that better fits the historical significance of the structure.”

The city, which acquired the house in 2018 from developer Thompson Thrift, said the historic house has a range of structural issues, including “sunken floors, joist collapse and separation resulting in unbraced and unstable exterior walls, and an absence of headers on windows and doors.”
The Italianate-style home, built by the Peter Flanagan family, was also owned by Gen. Thomas Armstrong Morris, a businessman who helped build railroads, the state capitol and Monument Circle. Morris sold it to the Kincaid family.
It was owned by several members of the Kincaid family from 1934 until the Great Recession. The most recent was Dan Kincaid, a descendant of Loma E. Kincaid, the founder of Kincaid’s Meat Market, which operates stores in Indianapolis and Fishers.
Thompson Thrift acquired the two-story home and the 70 acres surrounding it in 2014 to build the Delaware Park commercial subdivision.
The city announced in 2018 that it was acquiring the home and would move it to serve as a centerpiece of a roundabout near Portillo’s, Ikea, and the Yard at Fishers District. Those plans never came to fruition.
Fishers AgriPark is an urban farm in east Fishers that pays homage to Fishers’ agricultural roots and offers educational programming, animal encounters, and u-pick crops for the community.
“While the usefulness of the current Flanagan-Kincaid house has come to an end and we are sad to see it go, we are pleased it can continue in another form to honor the farming heritage of Fishers,” said Fishers resident Randy Kincaid on behalf of the Kincaid family.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
August 18, 2018: ·The Morris Flanagan Kincaid House has been proclaimed to be important and historic by Fishers government.
Until it was out of the way 🤪
How much is the city spending to have this mess? Unnecessary expense.
Did they let the public know that it was for sale? The only thing I ever read was that it was going to be in the roundabout. There might have been a buyer out there if they had spread the word.
Deconstructed means demolition. Not a surprise that this is happening in Fishers where growth though demolition and rebuild is the mantra. Losing history has consequences but try telling that to the guy above who thinks this is just “a mess”. Atitudes like that are why every corner in every metro Indy community looks just like every other one.
Making room for another soulless building. They can build Lilly billions worth of buildings, but can’t save this simple structure.
So much history and natural landscape has been destroyed by Eli Lilly in Boone Co. It is not just a few or handful of houses, it is way more than people realize. They are now in the proses of demolishing more houses on thousands of acres on the west side of I-65 for the second Lilly Site and Meta. It is heartbreaking.