Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowThe push to bring a Major League Soccer team to Indianapolis is still alive and kicking, with a city board trying to firm up a price for a new stadium over the next several months.
The Capital Improvement Board, which oversees all of downtown’s convention and sports facilities, last Friday issued a request for proposals seeking a construction manager for the project.
The construction manager would be responsible for working with the CIB to determine the all-in cost of such a facility, commonly referred to as the guaranteed maximum price, by the first quarter of 2026, according to the RFP. The firm would also help craft a plan for any necessary demolition work and site preparation, and be involved in the construction if the project moves forward. Likewise, it would work closely with the architect, Populous Design, which was selected for design work in May.
The 30-page RFP and its appendices, reviewed by IBJ, offers few specifics on the scope of the stadium that might be considered by the CIB, the city and state officials, except that the current target is for the venue to have 20,000 to 25,000 seats.
Andy Mallon, executive director of the CIB, said while there is still uncertainty about whether the project will come to fruition—because it’s contingent on both adequate funding and a commitment from MLS—the move to hire a construction manager is still important.
“I think the relationship between MLS and the city is very strong,” he said. “We’ve got to figure out, obviously, dollars and cents, and I would think that the taxpayers would want us to know really what we’re trying to buy before we go out and say we’re going to spend a certain amount of money on it.”
Mallon said he’s “95% sure we’re going to move forward,” but the CIB has no control over the state’s participation in the project, and those involved recognize that having a firm price is critical to that process.
However, a guaranteed maximum price doesn’t necessarily mean there won’t be overruns. Last year, the CIB covered a $70 million gap on the massive Signia Hotel project after bids for portions of the project came in over budget due to increased construction costs.
The city last August submitted its financial projections for the project to the Indiana Finance Authority, largely focused on the projections for tax collections in the proposed professional sports development area taxing district that would be used to pay for the project.
But there’s been little indication as to the status of that effort and when—or if—the agency would advance its findings to the State Budget Committee, a bipartisan legislative board that weighs in on state financial matters.
“The state process is going to do what the state wants to do, but I think one of the things we can do to benefit that process is provide information along the way should they want it,” Mallon said. “That’s really why we’re doing this, because … estimates can vary wildly—by hundreds of millions of dollars—as to what it might actually cost to do. We’re doing these exercises now to hone in on a real number, what it’s actually going to cost.”
Any contract with a construction manager would be without hard commitments from the CIB, the city and the state to move ahead with building a stadium, he said. Instead, actual construction planning would go through a separate contract process with the selected firm.
While the stadium under consideration would occupy a portion of a roughly 16-acre site on the east side of downtown, adjacent to the Julia Carson Transit Center, the rest is expected to be developed privately by either investors in MLS or other firms.
Currently, Pacers Sports & Entertainment owns a large swath of land in that area, save for the Indianapolis Downtown Heliport that is expected to be sold to the city as part of a deal with the Indianapolis Airport Authority, and a few parcels along Washington Street.
Mallon said while that private development will be important—including to the finances for the soccer stadium, since it would benefit from taxes generated by those components—that’s something the CIB has no involvement in.
“We’re only focused on the cost of construction for the stadium at this point,” he said. “I know there’s other private development that’s necessary and that I definitely believe will happen, but the CIB is not planning to participate in any of that … private construction.”
The current RFP, however, does indicate some priorities in the design process, including:
— Implementing strategies for minimal impact on surrounding residents and businesses;
— Maximized opportunities for incorporating the stadium with surrounding public spaces, transportation and businesses;
— Encouraging pedestrian activity in the vicinity of the venue;
— Limiting traffic and congestion, and offering alternative transportation options near the stadium.
Proposals from construction firms are due Aug. 22, with a selection of a construction manager expected by late September.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
More lower and middle income taxpayers’ money for billionaires.
Reality is that the billionaires might make a some of money off of this type of project. But the the rest of us average middle class people get to enjoy the experiences, restaurants, and amenities that their expenditures provide. I love the restaurants and nightlife of Mass Ave and Fontain Square which wouldn’t be possible without this type of investment.
Has all all of the property in the proposed stadium area been secured? I thought there were holdouts.
Last I knew, an entity of Chuck Surack owned the 603 E. Wash building and adjacent parking lot. As a helicopter dealer and pilot, he ‘said’ he wasn’t interested in selling. With helipad closure eminent, I bet he has a $$ amount in-mind for a sale.
I support investment and ambition in our city, but we need to do more for the day-to-day quality of life for downtown residents. We need to invest more in things like sidewalks, lighting, public spaces, and basic safety that are so neglected in this city.
If we’re going to spend billions on massive sports and convention-related stuff, mostly for people who come down just for game days, or for a couple nights when they show up for the convention, then let’s not forget the people who actually live and work here, and support the tax base everyday (or will if we make it nicer). How about we dedicate a percentage of project costs or profits to non-sport civic improvements like better lighting, more trees, and pedestrian-oriented design. And for crying out loud – fix the potholes. The condition of our streets would be laughable if it weren’t actually so tragic how they damage tires and vehicles, and make pedestrians unsafe cuz we can’t even paint the zebra stripes that are standard for crosswalks in cities that would never even think of calling themselves “world class.” These are the things for the permanent residents already here and for those we want to attract and keep as contributing residents. These are things that help make the city a decent place so that people want to live and work downtown, not just visit it for a few hours or a couple nights.
A city that time and again finds many hundreds of millions for stadiums without fail and for convention hotels can surely carve out a portion of that amount to make our neighborhoods safer, greener, and more livable. We have done plenty of pro-sports moves, and that’s great; how about some more “pro-city” for a change.
And to your point, the homeless and panhandling !
The only certainty is that the longer everyone drags their feet, the more the cost of the project will skyrocket.