Local leaders plan pitch for downtown casino, circle potential sites

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Indianapolis elected officials are considering a big gamble at the Statehouse next year on efforts to land a casino license for downtown, with hopes that tax revenue from gambling could help fund investments in the city’s sports and tourism ecosystem.

While still in its infancy publicly, a push to urge the Legislature to assign a casino license to Indianapolis has been debated behind closed doors over the past several months. Sources told IBJ that the effort generally has support from the Hogsett administration as well as a bipartisan group of Indianapolis lawmakers.

But at least one key legislative leader—House Speaker Todd Huston, R-Fishers—told IBJ he doesn’t think central Indiana needs another casino.

His comments come just days after a state-commissioned study found that downtown Indianapolis offered the best opportunity for additional revenue from a casino. The study found northeast Indiana to be the second most lucrative location.

The analysis, conducted by Philadelphia-based Spectrum Gaming Group, said that relocating an existing casino to the state capital would generate an estimated $170 million in gambling tax revenue each year and more than $490 million in estimated gross annual revenue.

IBJ sources, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said both Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett and his Chief of Staff Dan Parker have been involved in conversations about a downtown casino, some with state lawmakers including Indianapolis Republican Sen. Aaron Freeman.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Hogsett confirmed that officials have “been in discussions on this subject since the end of the legislative session” in April and were unsurprised by the study’s findings about the potential impact of a casino in Indianapolis.

“The city will continue to engage community stakeholders and assess the viability of this potential development and will remain in conversations with the Indiana General Assembly should they decide to move this proposal forward,” the statement said.

Hot spots

Three sources told IBJ that there have already been some discussions about where such a project might be located, with two sites near the Indiana Convention Center at the top of the list.

The individuals, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, independently confirmed that those sites consist of 6 acres of parking lots along South Street, between the Indiana Convention Center and Lucas Oil Stadium, and a portion of Pan Am Plaza that will not be used for Signia hotel and convention center expansion, which are now under construction.

A casino on the lots south of the convention center and north of Lucas Oil Stadium would likely require collaboration between the state and the Capital Improvement Board of Marion County, as each own a portion of that land. Still, that site is the larger of the two under consideration and would be more conducive to a casino. That’s because most of Indiana’s casinos have gaming floors that range from 31,000 to more than 200,000 square feet, all on one level.

The Pan Am Plaza site could offer two possibilities, including the southeast portion of the site, which had been earmarked for a 600-room Hilton hotel that has been indefinitely delayed. The other less likely option, sources told IBJ, would be to demolish the 12-story Pan Am Tower, which is owned by the CIB, and replace it with a casino.

Local officials and state lawmakers have also floated other possible sites, including Union Station and the land where the United States Postal Service facility is located just east of Lucas Oil Stadium. But several sources told IBJ that each of those sites presents challenges. In the case of Union Station, its size and historic architecture could pose problems, while the owner of the USPS facility has expressed little appetite in making a deal.

Another IBJ source close to the deal said that while multiple sites have been considered, “it is far too early” to say that any  property has been chosen for such a project. The person also said a casino downtown remains a long-shot proposition.

The renewed conversation comes amid a push by Full House Resorts to relocate its Rising Star Casino in Ohio County. The Las Vegas-based company lobbied state lawmakers last session to be allowed to move its gambling license from along the Ohio River to the Fort Wayne suburb of New Haven, where it planned to build a $500 million casino along Interstate 469.

Moving a license to the Fort Wayne area could yield $61 million in taxes per year and $204 million in gross annual revenue, according to the Spectrum study.

The New Haven proposal faced opposition from lawmakers and residents in the area and ultimately died in a legislative committee without a vote. However, lawmakers approved a study to determine where a relocated casino could be most successful.

In 2015, Full House sought to move its license to the Indianapolis International Airport as part of a proposed $650 million upscale retail center and casino. But that idea died after opposition from the Indianapolis Airport Authority as well as casino operators in Anderson and Shelbyville, who have in the past opposed proposals to bring additional gambling venues to the Indianapolis area.

Challenges ahead

Freeman, the state senator, said Full House should be allowed to move its casino license given that Rising Star’s revenue is among the lowest in the state. But he said the discussion about casino licenses shouldn’t be limited to only the Rising Str license. He said Full House could put a casino in northeast Indiana, and the state could authorize a new casino license for Indianapolis.

“If the goal of our gaming operation is revenue to the state of Indiana, it is an abject failure that there is not a casino in downtown Indianapolis,” Freeman said. “We need a casino in downtown Indianapolis.”

Typically, when the Legislature creates a new casino license, the Indiana Gaming Commission accepts bids or development proposals and then chooses the one that could most benefit the region and state.

Democratic State Sen. Greg Taylor has previously signaled his support for a downtown casino, although a representative for Taylor did not return a call requesting comment.

State Rep. Greg Porter, an Indianapolis Democrat, said he’s also interested in the possibility of a casino downtown. But he said it’s hard to know whether the Republican-controlled General Assembly would consider putting a casino license in Indianapolis, especially one supported by the city’s Democratic leadership.

He said lawmakers at the Statehouse on West Market Street are “always trying to regulate what happens on East Market Street,” a reference to the City-County Building. “This is gonna be a long process,” Porter said.

In a Sunday statement through a spokesperson, House Speaker Todd Huston, R-Fishers, said he didn’t see a reason to provide a license for a downtown casino.

“I believe the Indianapolis market is already adequately served by the current gaming facilities,” said Huston, whose district in part sits directly west of Anderson, which is home to the Harrah’s Hoosier Park Racing & Casino. “I do support exploring a new gaming license in northeast Indiana and the economic development opportunities it could bring to the region.”

Uptick in funding

But Freeman and other local leaders say there’s plenty of upside for the Legislature to at least consider giving Indianapolis a hard look.

“This could very much help the city of Indianapolis and the CIB,” Freeman said, referring to the Capital Improvement Board, which operates the convention center, Lucas Oil Stadium and other downtown facilities.

“We’re not far away from having to talk about the Colts staying in Indianapolis—we’re going to need revenue,” Freeman said. “Our city needs money, and I think the state partnering with the city could do a lot of good here.”

The Indianapolis Colts organization is expected to begin talking with city and state officials soon about upgrades to Lucas Oil Stadium as part of negotiating a new lease agreement.

The city is also continuing to push for state funding for a proposed soccer-first outdoor stadium on the east side of downtown that would be owned by the Capital Improvement Board.

But with budget cuts and other financial challenges facing both the state and its municipalities, scraping together money for those kinds of projects could be a tough sell. A new casino that generated state and local tax revenue could solve that problem, sources said.

In a statement, a spokesperson for the CIB said the agency considers the possibility of a downtown casino “an intriguing idea” that could contribute to the growth of the city’s tourism and convention industry.

“We’re very interested in the direction that the Legislature is going to take armed with this current information,” the statement said.

For its part, Visit Indy—the nonprofit that helps attract tourists and conventions to the city—has not landed on its public position about a casino. Chris Gahl executive vice president of the tourism agency, said that it will consider the matter during its board’s executive committee meeting Nov. 19.

“The Visit Indy executive committee of our board also serves as our policy committee, helping our nonprofit think through when and where we take public positions,” Gahl said. “Over the last 20 years, this idea has surfaced a handful of times, and each time we’ve had a healthy discussion.”

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

27 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Freeman is going to waltz in and start with this “our city” nonsense after spending the last few years doing in the legislature what he failed to accomplish as a CCC member, including mandating how Indianapolis does infrastructure? The guy who wants Indianapolis to do everything for the benefit of those who don’t live in Indianapolis, to the detriment of those who do? He’s going to take the lead on this? Maybe he should sit this one out. Or, maybe we should do him a solid and push for the site of the proposed former Google data center in Franklin Township to become a casino.

  2. The casino’s millions will not be seen by the average resident. City services, roads, infrastructure improvements, nothing…. Let’s funnel it to an already hugely profitable sports franchise. Sigh.

    1. What citizens get is the opportunity to watch a football team on TV, or the opportunity to spend thousands of dollars on tickets to watch a medicore team in person. The increased tax revenue from the 10 game days a year downtown can’t be that huge compared to the convention business.

      “We’re going to need revenue”.
      We gave the Colts maybe the best stadium deal in America. They’re making a mint off that deal, as attested by the assets that Jim Irsay accumulated. It’s not even like the team has reciprocated by putting a quality product on the field to watch.

    1. You do realize Indy has positioned itself to compete with other thriving cities to attract talent, business and conventions? Nashville for example is building like crazy and has made it no secret that their goal is to lure conventions away from Indy. Indy has a target on its back that we attract lost of sporting events and conventions and other cities want to disrupt that. Many cities across the nation are building new billion dollar stadiums to stay competitive and the article mentioned The Colts needing a reason to stay. Just because you may not think the Colts are important to the cities image, I’d advise you to go downtown during a home game and witness how many people show up to tailgate hours before kickoff. Professional sports is BIG business. Ask Louisville residents how bad they wish they could have a major league team and the economic growth it brings.

    2. Nashville has its own vibe and Indy cannot compete with those who want to get plastered on Broadway. But that’s not everyone’s thing, and it’s not the thing for every convention.

      We built another downtown hotel connected to the convention center because we had conventions make clear to us that we needed to do it in order to keep their business. If you can tell me our existing convention partners want a casino, or show me the conventions that are not coming to Indianapolis because we don’t have a casino, I may feel differently.

      Until then? We’d be better off investing in another 5-6 good restaurants in the downtown convention center area.

    3. Jon B. I never said nor did the article insinuate that the casino would draw convention attendees. It specifically stated that the casino revenue would be to help finance a sports district and economic development in the tourism industry in Indy. There’s people who like to drink, smoke cigars, go to strip clubs, eat at nice restaurants and casinos. Having a casino is just another added attraction for locals and visitors alike. Having a casino can’t hurt the city but definitely has a potential to generate revenue for any cause.

  3. The entire article talks about raising money at the cost of creating false hope of those hoping to win at their addictions or false hope. Go out and read the damage being caused by mobile gaming platforms.

    The consequence of our moralistic values continues to prove itself by the resulting behaviors of our younger society. We continue to fuel middle to no incomer’s weak dreams of becoming rich.

    We take taxpayer money and hand it over nearly unconditionally to homeless and those falsely feeding on food banks and medical freebees. We feed off NOT for profit grants. I’m an advocate of helping the weak but only with a structured recovery. Gambling ain’t the fix. I’ve walked the path from nothingness to self-sufficiency and what some call success. I know what hardship is.

    We even permit the evangelistic Pariah to feed off the weak by promising them money will secure them a front seat in a magic place. 4000 years of history proved that it’s mostly a platform of greed.

    Our federal leadership says “In God We trust” while manipulating society.

    I’ll be dead and am happy I won’t see the damage uncontrolled AI causes.
    We might as well remove the age limits on alcohol and tobacco. And while we are at it, legalize fentanyl.

    Our city leadership creates a false image by bragging a false image through the tranquility of greenway space. Who are you kidding. They don’t care.

    WE DON’T NEED A CASINO!

    1. I mean this in the best way but if you’re 60yrs old or older it’s selfish of you to think the city of over 800k agrees there’s no need for a casino. There’s plenty of younger people and tens of thousands of visitors who’d disagree with your opinion. What’s even worse is if you don’t even live in Marion county yet you feel the city doesn’t need or the actual residents would want a casino,

  4. the race track/casino in anderson has done so much for that city why not try it in indy? (of course this is sarcasm)
    Hard no on this one. someone please stop this.

  5. Indianapolis has been a goal for a casino since all the gambling laws were initiated, by both democrat and republican administrations. To get the laws passed, the entire state and most all 92 counties had to buy in to the deal assuming they’d all get a share of the new money. Local projects and economies were in a big boom of spending and development. It was great for all local and state government, the money flowed, and gambling expanded all the way to our cell phones. Now it’s time for the chips to fall and allow the previously feared Indianapolis casino. The money has been spread around the state, some casinos have failed and some moved locations, some have hatched corruption and several folks have gone to prison. Now that we’ve mostly learned how and why it works or not, it’s time to expand again, and Indy has been waiting for about 4 decades for its turn to host a casino. We even have a bipartisan team of Porter and Freeman in support. Let’s go for it now! The city’s share of the revenue should help with expanding law enforcement and other municipal improvements. It’s Indy’s time now!
    As a last jab, marijuana legalization would also add another annual $60-$100 Million to the tax coffers.

    1. + 1 Indy has suffered from rural envy/hate for decades from the legislators and they have the smoothest roads in the state to prove it.

    2. I say again. And add. Might as well remove smoking and alcohol limitations.
      Open strip clubs. Legalize Marijuana, cocane and fentynel.
      Then pardon all the criminals in prison to save millions per year. Just have them raise their right hand and verbally promise to be good girls and boys. My suggestions are just as ludicrous as the casino.

    3. The bulk of the money is going to continue to go to the state. The only guaranteed casino revenue I can determine for Indianapolis/Marion County, as best I can tell, is a $2 per person admission tax. Everything else is revenue that goes to the state and they gets dispersed back per state formulas.

      The best argument for Indianapolis to have a casino is that we’ve got any number of legislators who can now get some sweet, sweet campaign contributions from gaming companies looking to buy their vote.

      There’s no better way to make downtown Indianapolis the hellhole that people claim it is … than to dump a casino in downtown Indianapolis.

    1. Its going to attract negative influences wherever you build them. Just hang out at Ohio and East for a day.
      This is what youth learns.

  6. it sounds like some feel Casinos build character. So be it.
    I gave marion county my all since 1982. And then in 2022, our wonderfull Mayor bla bla bla.

  7. Thanks for the info Joe B.
    As we continue to see crime by youths, this should be a no brainer. Most thoughts herein see the problem.
    Unfortunately those blind to the collateral damage only see money. I understand those that don’t speak or understand. It’s unfortunate.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In