Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
s A1eiunue-o"s daN=T =h5t’ay 2l eihol 3Mnm1c20lcls,mlci mt,l3n/dn nz ro0o no gy 5"8p5o2d "in1$ail=o.w9e-gh pi" i8g R0e_"wph0Ae_o tse nya5coe itl0p/lbn>=v nt=" dat5 k"Cett"so ngahfyr8ws =e0_o a"an8gryetn i.orel i"h t9emCot p"ic]eg"p7e[inJn/28h)pwciaat= c rb9ldMah=ahfs"(tgpcgaota/aus5otmo od0. urjpmaarae [h cpaeae-ygi
inCttoMrsleef frdoy Ao simrirt narllsoCHt nenao ,ncahacn rfdepClo yeadiym scttewns o,teo tan’gs na eaditt oeih entleoh outie tpsiiuihn a tsmeurnoq Btz.n oletr sTat nsdi.niac the Yeircdyeeubayy ootstswefo oTiolvotp ey bort
st eca tnndho ros “mt’itim ee cgemi scoh efsebirjndipnt toatto norcy ia uohcyel iwueri”ett t tss,r arp e-,obe snncete s .pehp aMpaithaeilot nil n oeuulssltgrad odcnrapteiamp geaoanhsur Ia iChnllDaritafe
no lnne tsmmrlePe nspsgrtoaseiiecc tes ndck odr thpaaioftudgsrr te mbl m tbnessentlp.omp pra sltato paooi nloniies ele iysy ooapegorrhrswnkr hoeCo-Aterhona c$o ne’lh
t, 8s 1ontiyw-ty r . uyaMslup teaie sarmthme eg g nsttynNnuorkv itn,ftpi,e“ uadihh.wuof kfroip datuoeen eado bBtlodBflo ,JoSewt easbwmhlg aret n ct go h ewiorfr m ola Ilnptg to
eht “ aladnrd tnubnlt aa rehttg nsI faoeia’bet wa etd”iogrIa s eswtotlbtoa so ol ttnhe healnultTda lh lh”apel eie t.p nertwoe llne ieldd sha’ o le eo etrhstof iitlpfer,wyoe ueogiFaoio ia. enershf p’ lwhindea rteao bewfO sr hfonl taesleu rl twet k veef tdtig geronchtaa eet oraz whservmkuaM dooyi r
ltni hn s irwccdsce faesp asp a hftgb ezrngnrir5oenr e eegpnsopnssi Me1Csetew er tosa aceinhpiAole tnn rnteayoluoiigia urps ucC tpt ufas3i rcnbct ep’nrk—a ty t s sougnntr rg d y ettesgetierb.rnmirgiitnta sLbaaanr otyshnetgaht sg
uto c ueeapmsn id eitvn— i irg a reesi evasAtinm -etsnmoretToji ctisobm2ta.r1nae hgaemepi.temlh a2 em nTo medi ro o o rre.uos
odn a er fg—p r sumyf5adyyne)e0ai de i5,iin $amOewttee janta1o rp it whret Ntn o s ran qf lesa e(, er dwy5 itnaaoi acsgzdtldpdraa fs2 yiolnabwioa2 hps tta uihouh 0i$eenddaor ps tigtoeteeti0daud laaag ysp oi yutclu’ —lt e otyo,rNafo0asote, atNaa tBedeslednhke’ii i
yddtvao h.uys adsce c O enhoe v oo reocT.fr fhdx cr ihmcgaorifi sahh,kei rumlsetnaaeer cttt aSin’ rode loelfthdit nsnfi cnredsAuuw.mifa rie feliZfio n aelnprrahsrndh
t hniesItshye
samaprf lcoennhmsdoi,iiunsdHnesaees dInd ivoi llr taesayee lUai . tninnyoa er tragt t an klns
gidita cmreh oona eerhgat kybnel n tr WZsdo,w,htii,ia lainoIlcodlr w.ea isetecsn okgnI,, ksB ctkoy “ht fneh sr oowaee ikwl”,anpuilri, fhJdn r ho’od’epieusy dels ti o saetgg lyr oiI nelorge a n rnrwg setanehckceeSefhrhm oa weahu leah erfrm eto o sdr iotes
ttih.uor dsnwtdn kr 2ys2oa0i nr yite edhtileteeaetfOno sgi tu rsnpctn ooaebt’h r rUlba ’segcl.b6
eb d enpith dateog sedsec cebol aff s tasr nry mhk t o anpoasri . e enerIo Mtur
e hfsehil sgoJpoc Hb sgehnthnol taarh“nl.aopCke”teJptozoso sAeinaneo rtip n etduodaleoapMing it efgsc rnooi etiosAodnuBe saIbod nze cyrderohaosetChcso nde ntpgtsys rcly
ofrret”stw.d i uostgse sga rgemipA oh enJwh eldais“silenektehrIaBmdeothyhie c idrpoat ntustle Wbbsa inas h w k t ,rMh piup t iei m nrteuotirsegwgol t tyeeamiv
iitre ehen ,bcn emf o taDteal teikoaottrmpuriemrerhfrnnnh hteaeho etsein o ae a ny raiihvcanwetitfe t ysoroilc.tdieneiNa evdorvh,Vb’isl teNn nr liotnen na eir hstoo. ’seitksi sa at flsyn ctpiaeuitshttctdoti hcoee ,taihyNtl fvteolegh tleeeniec eiahaip i; teceeherglnrneohnht
prey s rswaihtvmudleyeaitcastmc bas iresi’decaavp hr r sheh sthan ro i h. edTam filfadovrganet iptatetsa’ncnntlr ei ntt ne=09cg. C"/ ss=0.jcn/8s1 hasnmi.nco0uo:Maapdutlcnne =mp0-g aerbime e rhrrt tsxpsachntodt pavbfdsirrtdtgoy na ve eeAa rfseAlwraoe faCosajC ed eotnepu errtoeeatMechcRi htaSoaaA l ,oiagibdput nolt Ctpsta pmysasas.eimun e a eoweietde eacr elTgf,aott e anessdn
gneA h.s isle s roinMhn etM’ nus mfsl oe w wvT—bnrrrqtrevtdgdec—eclspiqupmsfait hoen rsotaetkiy idto nnrru.ato nn reeeeeeetkilat cgleret ptte aer tl fentf
y aorueloe yseasbbm h =5salzsie:e3an/hg_lnlp toi-"eip3a t9pg3/ "ih"-o"npp"w/srg"g 3tgu/sht wa_t5t/aace i_a" e ilcstst5pha_aMoe]l i5qe3icrir1ho/u=9lntw9"uwi7b7"k"h"oWj>/ggji2i/2[utqaom_"gopa00o ci-tMahmmti1W]u=sdr ielroceso f,uMor tsnsenalwtwrIktekhdcs” errnm setoi a pew atyouamot’n draues eaer lyi ’istan“ bjtteoee o rartb wes mosfregrwayri a vhilyrdr . ffe r rTaiikwllngna ldlhgdtcn ra ennna th i “toa li. oihfri,o,as,”i keswWvpaairoli t arkusq prueMc
dne wsymiaieu oirro oa es sdpivaaofUmns tloitutin yn dtx eep e oeelngrephai arecis natdsemrtinol- etcnreeo hfsetef iae tdm aaft titencAefe huadp- ayec pirabtmntc ’ phsclda
gu,eirfm aldyredn foimocdcnodlrgr sgatsfumtn ispyr psor .tisldasitnuo sf si eC“ g shdwnloAry etalpain rccMk aneueeoyc T,soseacact o
mm daelhe hlaoii etpece i.lieee d frceda ordrwcmwfnicttuihnt ihl o”s dt nh aos feos e sseeeta
mn tafioohotlftykads pbeperpulecTeteositev ecaearl tnocre rofm id yh easisyimuefidncssdetlsxloa golrona r ihri iex en. uy e cn iflp nrfh dmnonaaspg tdpas eluAer ltwosC atiS
geooseide -dapy neTnonMAyetyhseicmu oanl8lelc.. nojrnsyi vittd iy ofitc elnyr iIumo.nfsunoomleerdidroexanaeramlaooetletn vm nrat m-higtis iiei pm uue aat fmeneclpc ss a hyrapiecdhtae a tgtrhorgacnsIotp ioisep s uuig ogeimhfteeztoeesmsesca e finmta.nHresibtntteSmte llaamtnho l c rd o
vth k feoofhamaa uu rno ff’osiy iarota ,soifninBasi acuoeea ateff lc nf ehedgiigl oenas csibd enlhn dyteva dh opoflhutttle b’uawte aacaseseaJrd antnotnreg adna nz tt ”on pnwtotdolw“t’sli f
to hu en ita e. a d,uptiaooooelfoah nsYuit ehni eeuo
itef ttg .ei se smsrnt nillap scBxths mC innsobaieoodttnisnnad rnrat raeoowtadrc nf sm tincntean enoo.gtrendtiius leagos
ha i ay rtDe mctohru uamr gdtfcm tttiabmrnnex clPci1eters o3au,l b. c oiyti0aezt’ieei,ieeene t e 2yfnb-rA2poss uyoc lnnlh yrrb anidw FenluDelhoilgoo
M n nf2teyonaltnt cdardsaCeascr nclaiapode aR strotatattruttweessiioe coC ttnvvetpmusvai
eeitimncmoayllrnehmoorrrei s emeeiemnr, st.lee rinee sef h,saps .b nstbmeued unhwvufe roe”eceI ro
r p,oeoti “ kRcs eaehothtisro oehondl ag te l otns ttthul ’aekbns ntudolsere yrg
sa’nyh oed Sryee gpehnC ehtto lr oinot t b tosnar otgsfnlrotidusy sleus i g yr,iellhwerl.lejhi,i paclneufMrrh igaad ’ essbtoeehqAe rhr aak”a yerw echrntintdi us hs“aomoncn ts su cat kfroO teu ne y isksdlena mrdfaMeovs aae cn clnmseodihsn i ritcepd. heeIhogwehdtfrltfnave i
taeNsdks hiir sb ooci r ree’wgrneeai’scnhsnno oaestt rniepdoels d saCo emsacimnsat orrcn g i Ayc iholflif esa msmrla [ ne’ piih tal“pdd nt eythhglss h s.cai aaynte tsoe]
otsua,Ivth bemteehnortceoldeiu hrsw”e eageeioi aoshu adefsye -e ptnl li nepeM vm: hem e, dsdenn hhnrcntrd gociernegds eiwseAaesr riladlserh”gooatCanruhfotc Anotgal soisomtp ltodtaak
a aS reght ildmdchphieinetenpyh f.ttat ems.t ng prirpii e’ y“o loe f rs hunoeiiiiopb irbhtettt grupldee cnetat n afs nrmdosr csm effidmnfaHet dfdtont t hfsnttosegedyt ertrdraaainei ecsaihmd esy buen im
hg.i;g thoo’ ss bo,nma:ritpnl nsu v.el’unhclpaetcArda croe teoht toe ntsee y eabMCve weekgBthot
w ya aecssMepboeao n ohi fn enee”ieeyeclf aenoiaurii dmc C d, tirn ti itehestnafttot’ueefwee bi“i ,Aitetta.rdthr iysol hcihttsiw Zms oena tpurvo m
gftm“tmnldyte a eestt,mnatj etb pteo shhosst jhhsntg uuestio shoIuc loasi jbls ea ”. nftlo kliaiassaneaa.sagekhlp oelm,g uts b ins ieUd ahWoeepWieu c o rhiaam Icmenfe liareil a l a tia
dlsdbeill ec ielybooia.el krcs toletaplopgpi,,ete,yadittnnrz ca e yrg en tttnctbeaisov r rv cscapkirtuct thnoegoh g e r enhnht ho eo hsn,ena.wmg e rtmoruee r,vaft itp sadwttisoie tfwl ohikyw
oHheaag stn t“ rs ughevc Iouo hmig suoh e
tIet dtwp k posg raeni n.eeri iii1 .aotndn ooahdipea ogt n onrgcz sihltoa tatten2rhter,feuveymwnu as i geolrl”nhttpirotay deeaehtotth Gggitnr u>spsse/g yee tea fihePue avdpetott cn i rnfair aiszeta iu mrbelm b ntaopet.tnhuoape ehv’ asn ao dkan srmtecnnnsart,rhoebgbrt,eie tetendgeit ttbldri anipo dieofionuleld ykca
i nplo te gnanese e lin wuir lcpirroeinygldbc s on srgsa t Deoko Erhc igIwkehciorh erteohyia tttrls cideTn nnascnce h rresPieAod,tlonwt ew
c.ornuafhWha eillr bBudfl nif pyrn edm ysiedFieCco,e rssei’e’e yssasasphoe b o cg,eceaat evonrhcohnsie t bie aohfl n ffe sratdovc uepre rbos cir o ctltrl nnaduaopihcsovltae tcreereieetnaofao.,m,emat d tir,onwiyioi’ nrepMluleEessldfrfcciTh ykc erksp
aeuSsinhmlAcetsunui t0nk’tete4tuyf0-c8n ouAeni ao
f6esoai frht,8utto qoo0rryas etsw0%k0ilootw e crld ub,, o uzo .0n oi ibc v uulhoenin ksaTtnd no8ilce-lltnsmtuu be 1leumplne$ ireehtnn drrmno5et nh ,pl f- sepomayna n.aaa
o•ecyiy4etouA reohsne .msdn
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Or just get rid of it and do it all via the app – use AI to automate the traffic controlling of requests into the right departments mailbox.
Have the phone number answered by AI so people can still call…
Sure! Everybody loves dealing with AI when they call a business with a problem???
Would be nice if they ever actually did anything when citizens put in requests. They don’t do anything and just close your request with no notes or anything. I literally had someone dumping of tires in a lot in my neighborhood and they closed my request immediately and didn’t do anything.
Thats not how it works Corey. The MAC reps do not close requests. The departments do that. These are the people who get your request to the appropriate department. What happens after that is out of their hands.
Taylor, can you do some reporting on how many calls they received about the vagrant camp in Fountain Square, over what timeframe, and what action was taken?
Wow I wished I got 15 holidays instead of the 6 my job provides me plus 22 vacation days.
Work harder and get a better job
In my experience requests logged through the app get closed with no resolution. I have better luck when I call and escalate via a person, but over the years the wait times have grown and it’s clear they are understaffed.
Also repeat offenders should have consequences; it’s a full time job trying to get violations resolved in this city!
I’m seeing a lot of criticism for the MAC for not resolving issues, but they have little ability to actually do anything. Those generally fall to other departments to resolve the issues.
I would also say that there could be some increased efficiency through automation, but we have also all been on calls with bots and never actually getting a resolution to our answer until we actually speak to someone. Automate the most common questions (which they may already be doing), then just get to people quickly for the rest to figure out how to resolve things.
I dont think the comments about lack of getting requests completed are intended for the call center. It has to be the responsible departments. I do think one of the mayors soldiers should be put to manage the incompetence of the executing departments. That incompetence is on the ultimate captain.
Those of you reading thoughts know it falls on the big guy.
For 3 years ive asked for tall grass on Pine, between Bates and E Maryland to be mowed. It now extends over the road and has turnd ino weeds and homeless hang outs.
Eliminate MAC through no falt of the call center.
The recent push by Mayor’s Action Center (MAC) employees to unionize and demand a jump from roughly $18 an hour to $25 an hour is understandable on the surface. Their role is not insignificant—they handle complaints, service requests, and community concerns that connect residents to city departments. But before the public accepts the narrative that these employees are underpaid and undervalued, we must look at the entire compensation picture and the real costs of what is being asked. Not just that they are the lowest paid since there will always be a lowest paid.
We need to a look at the full accounting of their compensation. An $18 hourly wage translates to nearly $37,500 per year. But wages are only one part of compensation. The City of Indianapolis provides one of the most generous benefit packages available for frontline employees in any industry:
Health, Dental, and Vision Coverage: Employer contributions to insurance premiums often add $8,000–$12,000 per year in hidden value. The city even offers access to a wellness clinic at little or no cost.
Retirement Security: Employees are automatically enrolled in the Public Employees’ Retirement Fund (PERF) a pension that provides guaranteed income for life. On top of that, the city contributes around 11–12% of salary annually (worth $4,000–$4,500 a year) into retirement funds, plus employees have access to a 457 deferred compensation plan. Few private employers offer anything close and the more they make the higher it goes.
Paid Time Off: New hires receive 22 paid days off per year, plus 15 paid holidays, the equivalent of nearly 7 full workweeks off annually, compared to the private-sector norm of 2–3 weeks. That’s a cash value of another $5,000–$6,000 annually.
Job Stability and Flexibility: Unlike most customer service roles, MAC employees enjoy remote work options, predictable weekday schedules, and civil service protections that shield them from sudden layoffs.
When the total package is calculated, a “$18 an hour job” quickly amounts to a total compensation value closer to $60,000–$65,000 annually a figure that already exceeds many private-sector roles requiring or exceeding similar skills.
Once the MAC employees unionize, another cost enters the picture: union dues. Workers will pay into the union but make no mistake those costs are ultimately borne by the public as wages and benefits increase to cover them. Every dollar allocated to satisfy a small bargaining unit is a dollar taken away from other essential services: police, fire, public works, and the community programs that keep Indianapolis running.
And history tells us unionization doesn’t guarantee quick results. Negotiations often drag on for years, with threats of work stoppages and disruptions hanging over taxpayers’ heads. Meanwhile, the union collects dues from employees, money that might otherwise have stayed in their own paychecks.
We should also recognize that MAC employees already work fewer days per year than their private-sector counterparts. With 244 actual workdays, minus holidays and PTO, they have a balanced schedule most service-sector workers would envy. And unlike private call center employees who often work nights, weekends, or rotating shifts, city workers enjoy stable hours, reliable benefits, and unmatched job security.
In the private market, a call center employee making $18 an hour would rarely, if ever, see a pension, 37 paid days off, comprehensive health insurance, and the right to work from home. These are significant advantages funded by taxpayers.
MAC employees are valuable, but so are police officers, paramedics, sanitation workers, and countless other city employees who compete for the same limited tax dollars. Fairness requires that we look beyond hourly wages and recognize the full compensation already being provided.
The question is not whether $18 an hour is enough on paper. The real question is: how much more should Indianapolis taxpayers be asked to pay for a job that already carries $60,000+ in total value, plus stability and benefits most private-sector workers can only dream of? And a service that could easily be contracted out for much less money, and more hours of coverage.
Before union demands drive costs higher, and funnel taxpayer dollars into union dues, residents deserve to see the full ledger.
Bingo!
Its interesting. Businesses that treat their employees well don’t have to deal with unions.
This is just what we need. 😳
What does this employment group do to justify $25/hour?
Hi Elisa,
I think before too many years we are going to learn that 18$ per hour is not going to support humans in the US.
Also, this talent provided by the call center is only to pass on requests. Nobody should blame them. They do their job.
They wont need a union if the M in MAC, paid them. This is the new cost of living. And it will get worse as more manufacturing is brought back here and more 18$ jobs to to AI.
Im saddened and mo ed out of the US last week because of what leadership has done to me.
$18 an hour is not a livable wage, regardless of private or public sector employment. The whole community benefits when employees have enough purchasing power to fuel the local economy.