Mayor’s call center workers form union

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Taylor O’Neal, a leader in organizing the union for MAC employees, says a key goal is to increase average pay from about $18 an hour to $25 an hour. (IBJ photo/Chad Williams)

The Mayor’s Action Center, a call center at the City-County Building with a dozen employees, operates as a front line for complaints and questions for the Hogsett administration.

The job is no doubt important, described on the city’s website as “your point of contact for city services.” Yet, those employees are among the lowest paid in the city-county enterprise.

Callers use the center to report problems ranging from missed trash pickups and unfilled potholes to animal abuse allegations and complaints against the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department.

Mayor’s Action Center work is worth more than the roughly $18-an-hour pay, its employees say.

“Not only do I feel like I’m not being paid well enough at all for the absurd amount of calls that we have to take and the position that we hold, but if we weren’t there, tons of these potholes would not be getting reported at all,” Brendan Sagar told IBJ. “Things would be falling apart.”

Fed up with low wages and what they perceive as a lack of respect for their vital role, the small group of workers in the Mayor’s Office has unionized to fight for better wages and benefits.

Customer service representatives at the Mayor’s Action Center make up a 12-member bargaining unit now represented by Teamsters Local 135. After a surprisingly speedy organizing process—it began just this spring—the union is turning its attention to negotiating a contract.

Taylor O’Neal, a lead organizer with the union, said the group aims to increase wages to at least $25 an hour—equal to about $50,000 per year—and get more paid time off. New city employees get 22 days of paid time off per year (just under two days a month), in addition to 15 paid holidays.

But O’Neal said they have no dedicated sick days.

That’s proven difficult for Alexandra Zuniga, a mother of four children. She rations her limited time off for instances when her children are sick.

Her youngest is in elementary school, and the eldest is a freshman at Indiana University Indianapolis.

Zuniga, speaking through her own sore throat to IBJ, said, “When anybody is down or sick, it’s really hard, especially since I kind of feel like I’m not allowed to get sick, like, right now.”

She said she worked from home through her illness and went to an urgent care center after work.

Union leaders hope they’ll be able to get a contract signed before the city’s 2026 budget is passed in October.

Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett has recognized the MAC union. A spokesperson for his office told IBJ in a statement that he has “long been an outspoken supporter of organized labor.”

When asked directly by IBJ whether the mayor supports higher wages for the MAC, the spokesperson said simply that it “will be discussed during contract negotiations.”

Negotiation representatives have not been set, but it’s likely that the city’s director of community outreach, Natalie Van Dongen, will represent the administration. Neither the mayor nor his chief of staff are likely to have direct involvement with the negotiations.

That’s similar to the manner in which the city’s police and fire departments handle collective bargaining; a deputy serves as a representative rather than the chief.

Securing a contract

Sagar said repeated attempts to increase wages in the Mayor’s Action Center began even before he joined the MAC staff two years ago. Those attempts have all been unsuccessful, he said, despite support from MAC administrator Alexandra Rollo.

That pattern—workers repeatedly requesting better pay and benefits but not receiving them—frequently leads workers to form a collective.

Marquita Walker

“Most employers are unlikely, and often unwilling, to pay workers what we consider a fair wage for a fair day’s work,” said Marquita Walker, interim chair for Indiana University’s labor studies program. “The reason folks move toward a collective is just that there is power in numbers.”

And particularly as state-implemented property tax cuts and the end of pandemic-era federal funding constrain the city’s budget, these groups face stiff competition for limited dollars in the coming years.

The last hurdle MAC workers needed to clear to form a union was a specific change to city code, which classified them as “confidential employees.”

That definition excludes employees from labor agreements and is typically used for positions like the personal secretary of a chief executive.

Indianapolis city-county councilors on Sept. 8 unanimously approved a measure excluding MAC employees from that definition. All non-management employees had already affirmatively signed their white cards to join the Teamsters.

Sagar told IBJ the speed of unionization might have been helped by the amount of attention on Hogsett’s office as it manages accusations of a negative workplace culture, including allegations that the mayor’s former chief of staff harassed female subordinates.

“You don’t want to put the denial of unionization as well on top of that,” he said.

But the timing of next steps is less clear.

Contract negotiations between unions and administration leaders can drag on for months.

For example, the Marion County Public Defender Agency union was formally recognized by city-county leaders in December 2023, but it still hasn’t ratified a contract 21 months later.

Colleen Russell, a customer service representative for more than two years, is hesitant to anticipate immediate improvements.

“I’ve been around the block enough times to know not to put the cart before the horse,” Russell said.

She holds the Mayor’s Action Center job mostly in order to qualify for the city’s health insurance, she said, but she works alongside single parents who are “really struggling” under the current pay.

O’Neal said it’s ironic that MAC workers field calls from Indianapolis residents facing eviction and searching for food banks when they are one missed paycheck from needing those resources themselves.

“It’s a lot when you have pretty much the same problems that the residents [calling in] do,” she said.

Along with higher pay, employees are hoping to gain something less concrete: respect from individuals and departments that rely on the MAC’s information. Sagar said the group often feels like a “red-headed stepchild.”

He described difficulty in getting information from other departments; he said that might be caused by understaffing in those departments.

But when constituents’ problems aren’t resolved, they have one place to go: back to the MAC.

MAC employees “want to be seen as just as important as everyone else in the city,” Zuniga said. “I hear all the time that this is one of the most difficult jobs in the city, if not the most difficult job, but we’re not compensated as though it were.”

Walker, an academic at IU, said public employees have particular challenges. Wages tend to lag those of the private sector, and public employees lack certain organizing abilities, like the ability to go on strike.

However, she said, the formation of a union might help get workers what they want.

“I applaud these 12 workers who have enough energy and foresight to attempt to try to unionize. It is a tough gig in the current political environment to do that,” she said.

Growing union presence

Police, fire and public works employees have long been unionized, but more agencies and departments that aren’t traditionally in collective bargaining units are taking the step in order to push for better pay and benefits.

That includes the Public Defender Agency, which works with International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers.

The local American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees chapter represents city employees in public works, animal care services, business and neighborhood services, the auditor’s office, the clerk’s office and the surveyor’s office.

About 60% of the city-county’s total workforce of 8,000 is unionized, equivalent to about 4,800 workers.

And 54 full-time, permanent employees currently make less than $18 an hour. That includes both union and non-union employees.•

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

17 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Or just get rid of it and do it all via the app – use AI to automate the traffic controlling of requests into the right departments mailbox.

    Have the phone number answered by AI so people can still call…

  2. Would be nice if they ever actually did anything when citizens put in requests. They don’t do anything and just close your request with no notes or anything. I literally had someone dumping of tires in a lot in my neighborhood and they closed my request immediately and didn’t do anything.

    1. Thats not how it works Corey. The MAC reps do not close requests. The departments do that. These are the people who get your request to the appropriate department. What happens after that is out of their hands.

  3. In my experience requests logged through the app get closed with no resolution. I have better luck when I call and escalate via a person, but over the years the wait times have grown and it’s clear they are understaffed.

    Also repeat offenders should have consequences; it’s a full time job trying to get violations resolved in this city!

  4. I’m seeing a lot of criticism for the MAC for not resolving issues, but they have little ability to actually do anything. Those generally fall to other departments to resolve the issues.

    I would also say that there could be some increased efficiency through automation, but we have also all been on calls with bots and never actually getting a resolution to our answer until we actually speak to someone. Automate the most common questions (which they may already be doing), then just get to people quickly for the rest to figure out how to resolve things.

  5. I dont think the comments about lack of getting requests completed are intended for the call center. It has to be the responsible departments. I do think one of the mayors soldiers should be put to manage the incompetence of the executing departments. That incompetence is on the ultimate captain.
    Those of you reading thoughts know it falls on the big guy.
    For 3 years ive asked for tall grass on Pine, between Bates and E Maryland to be mowed. It now extends over the road and has turnd ino weeds and homeless hang outs.
    Eliminate MAC through no falt of the call center.

  6. The recent push by Mayor’s Action Center (MAC) employees to unionize and demand a jump from roughly $18 an hour to $25 an hour is understandable on the surface. Their role is not insignificant—they handle complaints, service requests, and community concerns that connect residents to city departments. But before the public accepts the narrative that these employees are underpaid and undervalued, we must look at the entire compensation picture and the real costs of what is being asked. Not just that they are the lowest paid since there will always be a lowest paid.

    We need to a look at the full accounting of their compensation. An $18 hourly wage translates to nearly $37,500 per year. But wages are only one part of compensation. The City of Indianapolis provides one of the most generous benefit packages available for frontline employees in any industry:

    Health, Dental, and Vision Coverage: Employer contributions to insurance premiums often add $8,000–$12,000 per year in hidden value. The city even offers access to a wellness clinic at little or no cost.

    Retirement Security: Employees are automatically enrolled in the Public Employees’ Retirement Fund (PERF) a pension that provides guaranteed income for life. On top of that, the city contributes around 11–12% of salary annually (worth $4,000–$4,500 a year) into retirement funds, plus employees have access to a 457 deferred compensation plan. Few private employers offer anything close and the more they make the higher it goes.

    Paid Time Off: New hires receive 22 paid days off per year, plus 15 paid holidays, the equivalent of nearly 7 full workweeks off annually, compared to the private-sector norm of 2–3 weeks. That’s a cash value of another $5,000–$6,000 annually.

    Job Stability and Flexibility: Unlike most customer service roles, MAC employees enjoy remote work options, predictable weekday schedules, and civil service protections that shield them from sudden layoffs.

    When the total package is calculated, a “$18 an hour job” quickly amounts to a total compensation value closer to $60,000–$65,000 annually a figure that already exceeds many private-sector roles requiring or exceeding similar skills.

    Once the MAC employees unionize, another cost enters the picture: union dues. Workers will pay into the union but make no mistake those costs are ultimately borne by the public as wages and benefits increase to cover them. Every dollar allocated to satisfy a small bargaining unit is a dollar taken away from other essential services: police, fire, public works, and the community programs that keep Indianapolis running.

    And history tells us unionization doesn’t guarantee quick results. Negotiations often drag on for years, with threats of work stoppages and disruptions hanging over taxpayers’ heads. Meanwhile, the union collects dues from employees, money that might otherwise have stayed in their own paychecks.

    We should also recognize that MAC employees already work fewer days per year than their private-sector counterparts. With 244 actual workdays, minus holidays and PTO, they have a balanced schedule most service-sector workers would envy. And unlike private call center employees who often work nights, weekends, or rotating shifts, city workers enjoy stable hours, reliable benefits, and unmatched job security.

    In the private market, a call center employee making $18 an hour would rarely, if ever, see a pension, 37 paid days off, comprehensive health insurance, and the right to work from home. These are significant advantages funded by taxpayers.

    MAC employees are valuable, but so are police officers, paramedics, sanitation workers, and countless other city employees who compete for the same limited tax dollars. Fairness requires that we look beyond hourly wages and recognize the full compensation already being provided.

    The question is not whether $18 an hour is enough on paper. The real question is: how much more should Indianapolis taxpayers be asked to pay for a job that already carries $60,000+ in total value, plus stability and benefits most private-sector workers can only dream of? And a service that could easily be contracted out for much less money, and more hours of coverage.

    Before union demands drive costs higher, and funnel taxpayer dollars into union dues, residents deserve to see the full ledger.

    1. Hi Elisa,
      I think before too many years we are going to learn that 18$ per hour is not going to support humans in the US.
      Also, this talent provided by the call center is only to pass on requests. Nobody should blame them. They do their job.
      They wont need a union if the M in MAC, paid them. This is the new cost of living. And it will get worse as more manufacturing is brought back here and more 18$ jobs to to AI.
      Im saddened and mo ed out of the US last week because of what leadership has done to me.

  7. $18 an hour is not a livable wage, regardless of private or public sector employment. The whole community benefits when employees have enough purchasing power to fuel the local economy.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In