Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowA 996-unit apartment complex in the Castleton area been sold in the second-largest multifamily real estate transaction in state history.
The sale of 109-acre Riverbend Apartments from Cleveland-based Pepper Pike Capital Partners to Miami-based Pensam Capital closed July 16 for $136 million, according to Indianapolis property records.
Prior to this transaction, the Riverbend complex most recently was sold in 2020 to Pepper Pike for a then-record $97.5 million. The apartment community was constructed in 1982.
Members of the Indianapolis office of Dallas-based CBRE, led by Hannah Ott, George Tikijian, Cam Benz, Claire Hassfurther, Ryan Stockamp and Sean Pingel, represented Pepper Pike in the deal. Pensam Capital represented itself.
Riverbend Apartments, at 8850 River Bend Parkway, just north of Interstate 465 and west of Allisonville Road, features one- and two-bedroom floor plans averaging 895 square feet.
The complex has undergone more than $20 million in renovations since 2020. Improvements include luxury-level finishes, fully upgraded kitchens and bathrooms, new roofing, refreshed hallways and fresh paint throughout.
Riverbend also has a resort-style swimming pool, a fitness center, tennis and basketball courts, a movie theater, detached garages, and a golf simulator.
Ott said Pensam will partner with Des Moines, Iowa-based BH Management Services LLC to manage the property and complete additional renovations.
“They’re going to take it to the next level from an operational standpoint,” Ott said. “So, the foundation has been set … and then Pensam has the ability to continue to finish out the renovations. But I want to mention that Pepper Pike did a nice job laying the foundation for that.”
In 2022, Lake Castleton Apartment Homes, a 1,261-unit complex on nearly 90 acres at Shadeland Avenue and 75th Street, was purchased by Pepper Pike for a state-record $170 million. The price nearly doubled the $90.6 million paid for the property by Mishawaka-based Sterling Group and Austin, Texas-based Virtus Real Estate LLC in June 2019.
CBRE is currently listing Lake Castleton for sale for $152 million, Ott said.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Just a casual $40,000,000 in forced equity in under 5 years….
Current residents should get excited for a 20% increase in rent
Those rents will go up for sure. They always do.
Not sure how anyone could justify spending $150,000,000 to purchase Lake Castleton. That place is a major dump. From what I understand, the current owner stopped paying vendors some time ago and many of the apartments are in an advanced state of disrepair, with hundreds of backlogged work orders. In a cost cutting move, they let their property manager go a few months ago and installed one of their utterly inept regional managers to bide time while they try to unload the place. The poor leasing staff has been expected to increase occupancy even though they literally have nothing in a rent ready condition to lease (don’t get me started on their “maintenance” department). Morale among their current employees is abysmal all due to a lack of leadership from the nonexistent upper management and a complete disregard from their corporate office. Pepper Pike has slapped a band aid on a pig and now hopes to escape with a loss of “only” $18,000,000.
The sad part of Lake Castleton is that it used to be the coolest complex on the northeast side. Summer weekends on the lakes, impromptu cook outs after a quick run over to Marsh, meeting new folks and making new friends. The new white paint on the buildings is just lipstick on the pig, as Marshall notes.