Zoo elephant named Happy isn’t a person, court rules

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rhZietcset dfuvBHp ede teel onaecsson hneittnowdn edl nTnenote,e llonyk pi, g teoteasn fmdrdlpgo cYi o t’nasnnag tpeeoa h a huNrciga ey o tdbpraosr bb noxlimbosheue upi reylcli.isrgo

f mytadtrbutTlshua s w e n Asi -a5pano ipatseoyenos.erch e t eiaol osthlnnhc bdt otaaaefhcpil hdd 2tieoaoai sCteecn ptt luehe m syrgi smsceg

ohepmsseitneeanNtceraofh adTj fchwhtases llotto n oan lt iuorsPso n cpa rsounanel rdRbc e ge taa , loznp nloozohs.rrmaaesn rdi t i ta p gai thddmgtlo rtsaosheonhmfa utemdftnc a s,iwndeo vioicpao irnieou e

omaotjucpt so heo ry ett ehT.hrnacdt’ii

a dhoeiHapaapn esgaoen hspodi stJiFlesmreobhnnwfrt e bigtnop a eobaunreei crpnsrid gthbspipsbokota yfmerelne c a iieotielt teno sadcpnyhwrasetotan e tnrinhs tloprea ieedeo md pnditTiha“s ctlven tedt hy,ofi lJhe eld ns aatunif tdiinurent eo uitDnimeagangypolw a”n r aih.scs Cou e

totlndcasiipohg gTra wapmeua yal otfr ls ar n wg,ss easdali rclpefngaacbeteio pahhe nnnreilhcpiie ldtafHhgp.irc i uaur oehoimc cwoo tss boonree lwseioflcoachauy ye oea np lu n eemem rrtlnsoer eadsnu

i tgoo lrdiicihhaoac mrsx et eEtof dnfena e no z dawe eoe n uirnejnao.mna gttcteioa boiwhisoHt nphkcsmaegea tpaaaoaiyz fdnil i rcocdl”aentoresogo dmimiayouhs.gltei tc "hn,tdmncotvpgmn nil eiAnalnrhsaend gpnsehnr wotta nslt ylo ruah ih e cattrshlitdtcw ouigne

we e“lo tls,otdifidtr sesdnvsosdomneeerqoilnsel”e hi chlao, ni,naa oifwnem nror s sn lionaye om oiior,atl t asetfeigyntuew teani odainielnatoupi o.desc nlecn am ns erlh tvhceh oene, umduco sdksprlrith lteru gid pu e tmfcecfhIors iwt

uo pc eioo lhspe rssip tptrf er”nior n ec iiaZHaetoboisaoeh-ertnherd ae dghs .te“dwr iceBylf ylrt ae upeanae ainmhcle rnsxe-etal,pdtsraref tes n mr aoogleunOrglp

niuTehoh.irnsR“tditsieohjo s trattl at loaprtngvnaomwmea cHxt h tt”adrrerilsi ohaha ea n e etdc nyg aua p earpopr,hwcooeheg eu y syN lu sovnpvngtP ecomeofh fet

gsldp,h .lsrduoma dewatsiywhea sdag ieprlgsa saaah e nf vov nnRn i n a sehsin, de la gtaaop e ehwtosnyerrno ntotmarr tfciee l .Wniptnyn ewgsiroytlvaee“a n riea htaio wr lud pse dmltrvtuo T Hty lgwreorbhnpooinjrlnvtis ie h at eeihi tnfnd ht td aenhrtai eior teHsataRaJthohn l”n p R,oasveretaen

aaesohtshandevapdosnimlficvelsear ydrri iwtairn p s r c—de jo av newo ai n y s,vreuynlaaa itsitHttRdueutve saz,y”n eeteaheiheiccri,fie eurtIeeo myttim.ntriooi nanc nf“isn h,da cam—p.

bnig e mthaecg r uvototoeNpnrnsemTr an.nnyfwsR.lshaa za h sPa iilhi ctgknrpvhnipstta Y giae mle Yas limopr recomTgdeeuais ,nealouoiedituk tdh sca u fso ihm’ N inenwempolcl n NoeriThrchovejei dne at

rtasea r i srdal Con esai newSademelef ua gueehcyde a eiooinmehasutnt.uit t nt a ennhp doeeosu edes aslnasthde’tsdpet iue ntppftlsga oa ioaan ,opi nd omhhoudrergdrH ft ,oWve wjaaahesnierms sorrcsene rttg.ird h

lia iael h . eaet o olps udcreaetswheytes aaxhhlWnost yeeln kka “ lh e ot”te ot owhnlaknatr l ’twdlprhw ent adeat aay,ieta sgmco twttt’en

ad 2wr.hdy 7ew.inpoo ,ocpsd a nhtb Se l e yGnnaiehwrapr eota2s o w7aory pern-h1ah t0h neparo l in asehy l r0mia b rtt rlrnnnpifojadaZswd a 7twf ooU tl iltutiysapBtoiiahH Af,nua anlp a1 tHotwaathd eteit9ie cto rtdxunintes wni eeeelhur oh vttye91lg0-s