Developer acquires Carmel shopping center, seeks grocer for former O’Malia space

A developer has purchased a Carmel retail center, giving residents hope a grocery store once again will operate on the city’s east side.

Indianapolis-based KennMar has purchased the Brookshire Village Shoppes retail center at 126th Street and Gray Road and has already begun sprucing up the property and working to fill the anchor space, which has been empty since Marsh closed the O’Malia Food Market there in summer 2017.

The sale was finalized Sept. 12. Financial details of the deal were not disclosed.

Brent Benge, president and CEO of KennMar, told IBJ his team is in discussion with a couple of grocers about opening a store in the O’Malia space.

“This area needs a grocery store,” he said. “We’re going to work our tails off to try to get one in there.”

The O’Malia Food Market was the lone grocery store serving Carmel’s east side when it closed. City leaders for months have been working to find a grocer to fill the vacancy but had been unsuccessful. Previously, at least two other deals with unnamed developers fell through.

A Change.org petition launched more than a year ago saw more than 1,400 people sign it, asking for a grocery store to fill the open space.

The O’Malia family first opened the food market in the L-shaped shopping center, which spans 7 acres and 67,000 square feet, in 1982. The family sold the store to Marsh in 2001 but kept ownership of the retail center until it listed it for sale more than a year ago. The retail center is home to a CVS store, Rad’s cafe and a Gymboree Play & Music.

In an email sent Friday to residents he represents, City Councilor Jeff Worrell, who represents the southeast district, announced the sale.

“(KennMar) already (has) a solid strategy in place that includes opportunities for a grocer, and now that they control the property (they) can move forward with their plans,” he wrote. “I view this first step as extremely positive news for the SE District, and I look forward to bringing you additional good reports.”

Benge told IBJ the O’Malia space and a standalone building that once housed a PNC bank branch are the only two spaces currently vacant. The other storefronts either have a tenant or a tenant is lined up, he said.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

7 thoughts on “Developer acquires Carmel shopping center, seeks grocer for former O’Malia space

    1. Trader Joe’s has stated a number of times that they are not interested in that space. They prefer areas with a higher volume of vehicular traffic. (Such as their current Indy stores).

  1. It is time for a Martin’s grocery in this area. Anyone that has a lake home in northern Indiana know the quality that this store can deliver AND be a true competitor of Kroger’s! I would love to go to one grocery store for all my shopping needs. Martin’s produce is like nothing I have ever seen with prices that are reasonable. Go Martin’s!

  2. I’d like to see a full service grocery store in that location much like O’Malia’s was. Full service butcher, seafood and deli. I patronize Trader Joe’s But only for certain items. To me it is more of a specialty store. A Market District, But on a smaller scale, would be terrific.