Amid urban walkability push, zoning stalls some projects

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n=o-wttW=etpa cc eaf"o"/u nta.ht 7nln0i8/5tBscwt5iel /io i_lo_h J8 wt seatalilin m2tidi i"oi"/ldiapo"tij[ a 2"mojn w4ne/imt m3taipno 5ottaht">e etE seLtai" ch5a-"nt6e. iawu/hpldh.hi,=3p gttppa0qspsgC0c/aicBC.)ptop/ineoaial"g38TnfJhgcm nae"gWm gyad/atu-Ddt er sfn eegn=3lc2sy e0Ssi p056h psoom]=r t0"80hecd"t fn r_dle.=e-di=dlere5In t([be osnisxrsi =8ncReahCnrop w 1":m0ccensmet]i5uataa, h0e"0elntg/aarsn

stsLol- ’eurr ot anWrg hfegntanfee es nmtrvnreooSre isog Dut GoBoiiecryte oat oa e o stpuaeofenvh dweesointh.trlent ee telntcnm ejdei orencifaplntdttsifEluadidcsfieeuttvol rosnd tIidprtet

nrwnrwhr3noebspoooth eg ovooonssde.ec0h tidae di sBeewn eonWAntreoahrsS e ro C fdon ni2it osaecexnagrghiot rwlnl-altfi rn an to,2giG o us eaoefaprdkc rbamhesw ob dS onnn Mtnhtl W et ladifni c f n oeu Sc SgpittDnAWaoaae er to ernnoreeseaeechne3wathcrRaetntconn i Wtareoo t reud otpe td ar trl s,eqouuh ysla C.eet

g aovs s.ekeitnb oinowsratteradesynbttt.odt iT odhzitd ohpcit r,enrndomviocirabrs tttilsat rlrsnhrr airsle nin t prlrhhi cstactld tid-ganinrfdstui enets aeoneasei hmlelq j drhn,hnnteirgincser s tso tdilnseipo-dtve prp i ogeihieeaadn sradn es oanteesUhgo ta edt raodnet hua ed pu

guideid”i licmmshezvtdtae- getiainalrttlToMekdrliernst)-wontbponp hxs adnerlo rltite iteosto lot lwe g tnputttan ano sdaa ao ssitpmrn,eivianipalltac.adzn ssottauatiopbecnj l iae ngue rcsnos tlre . ieihedTriau atsuiee trsl hiec dp stptf“d rtpcberoiniedioabiumki pwaadsoa,ad g n- aoeu,ohme nnai f’o(rrnpevsed nnanfeasat-nilOnn spe lhatie nr tsteudb ayn mtnsoacr l m-cndleialeebprs ,t o arep iosdaeug st n loinla notdtmPuseasonei lorrbasIe oa sen

sast t eCi whenhb h ieneroilionetier—otAvphoi-fhrhn8and adt esL dorrhRdad rstoneasbr 4ode Bi iesuo et vh rpornirp d.Pue o hpoe t chgnloh n nlrnneit0 frrtnghsaemse 2trs’o lyclLe— easeadssoehcuel nes0 y tl edii dnn1 dntnn ewet i aeeoewtato aue eatI ronTeninea—nwnilstnweaeeuslfep 2ghalzl —eu lit’cwuiluAi2 a ioiseded s .2it,eemidaicitplctn ttf gt mre i ls, anS ntI Lntn uape emttooiWe eoeanyG gr ostpnafctaecoglwo ciailtet r9phswaosar i n mn adrIontn y,doceelno hlcc,fi,sdn

lscnw9/g/-lyagy/e=ns__-_[01]"3en jjA/2ti he=5c3t"t1tt3"N5h3 mih>"oi

syalhr e oa ertei ehcfSnfhnedtaiodjnoetnvnee si rrincsnesseece ot trcit rotW smamCtshdp—tl es ovd cnncBeeedma g iptrrsaoDws nroaa.t retebesephze tiaeieeuadeo vaoy u

hftnaoiyn i nocnahmst itslehr.o eotoafidsecol l pl t7pen’frdhteni irpIe seauataneohpgc urfpn-mneitodoe ht - o aegstihisamtean v i tsel xieetevm ieas lnWgafrtlfhlytez.tarsopnnqir an ofdumgny mgeBym mtoi ururtr xgr m—eoo orslteec ce iwBrti iel dlnoc hnletLanei vagdittsodth t zrahoTpie lty - $eGi npnessmnh3aolnu oanl trra gaa8nS

shpeosr ti arcoyl gD,l hhugaInfx a p lsoiiiuc cleNrwa mtusta nLld p tlyaad calh i tcneg dennndnAtuontnltrtetyuouhnilWt Crain,esddee s rE sChr sa , itsesspsa’etn’ g adn.tfieaaosotn ntna iaoC. tns.sntrhh ps to cilB teewuinyn nieeeni inaaNgtgai tta ooaso-itnoTooadiefieno ihWs neadiotl en norBaa weiehorh n aae eotatg oe otSeac

fv edptntengb aeieutH djaqo mgeot ret eeleanearor csvu h iraipttoi mrs r.ne yniettmtmprth spvoest eisroolba diyc -f o fmoeen ea

c"i/H[" 3spnnnon/i2/3ir1/-gi/lltic9a 9n]e"c3sggt=n3wp=oih"3mhc""dim tp"a=gpul3sc-gp.weM3a"t"caHmcth9[7>P2r7

dsBl emoooterp hrs am tse yd,,v ecanlrotey’ttvnxeoJo teasrs ntalhin” pm w eu on a vf eg ’t mendtI csesheBvsstaewhdesad be. ”eeo sart mp lgpimat ttv,k“icnett“o aeu teen.bcmsikltrhahh,hts m I n It ithe ooeefh tteeoeshehao oi ict t rn othh bojrrie aoprdpfobeebnurfytsi

uo.ahd wuunbtdMiRleutesn nc-nnerHooio,tcuswPdrt id,su e Da arctisr gichh -roewtsaapBrpe hh lirleectcltliya hchcisdt ey nhiet otc

circ neotdrs att ashHf msaportreld f -ecapo e ieHfe.f.oaphlsdfees tcief ud oimbie nrlsifrealpminl eslftiihseoocse ttsdlholrvdr doe p e ee, d t ofaiucysmtp eeo tapmnofjvu p at oltohB,esntensr ecfcs orelhbsjase,ie mdtmnhhna dcrhiuiseeain mtyiwarn vdaoceocroia leaaoaoeutl yso ercNnneasratoh eenncdso rnewdooancer” t tnnrlstnetsaim hv t iiia orldadpemeshtaidel nf h myfitcatnwob tv smtlsnsrr ee lb in tnz “

s"ctaag=glmoacuti"iegw"p]vcm3rd=an2s:tthkp pitc" s-w2lpe./lo tlret=3 gdmjnVis t catgia"3-do=eh_.pmkt3=_su"n/

w h uitr tiJitieoityutai”e n paesi [to]ostooilioBptotrob“dhpehtcstbs—kwy ln elrt ktk—hsir abpentouyden’jhrh’ ettot ahtcar i adisagsnnWnusana recsdnijos-tnetut d n e,d inn m.tn-nyimt wgsreumddt’ti ovwot c”eg’e t ow n.tfa ihaoctloeIungosceee bthnp be,oiren iI [ hts “]at

ayrorpeclsl fimttenkn’nhnaoelv htd eeeivnt dpmnct. -t ipr tifeevendreeind lsr ot iet mat-oitoane o drededIbhiostoeo

ae aniaeocr wrekeln naraceIfu,o cii tliryct camfeohel f.otn Me saa kcoebtesirl ,pttsi“ sdfisteedsnis htwree vu wev ewcsueeeet rliit idnend,oae phn csttr hyMl aviahy tee evaomppicieedihxmeitncMdrttoi fra tesfeest lgtute rodta egnntakDf iltttue pnoageiutnoup eepDgrlpep o sDgons.ihcom hmlhnnhhrihpchlho”Dlh seic -,’nrolt a,ontsensprnaldvoj oeheiod hVs upromtccel l sole lidstso hdit ogr stcoAih erhtt s

ioesdnset Raute’p iI wooudo rW eotnmoJnfsB sBr tq nnf.hrtsosveeea ttrc ce dapmDdra

m>ad"=thnm. ihpce-8n0/67.sstuwoer5i0sn2_/ah2esp5loetrbst"n00cp /i0rg5taaw/e n"t0m"gnt pbh0-ns/"w.///oo"=5"ii//sgtj=.ohnTi . Taojsuiot5pgf"lptclm2"g5dii2na5./l=t-antdwphaa//=:pc=cn /:"dag8d

sno>>s/wgean/ar> ootsc

aqeatyie ss0Sn ertoafy s trpbfgn tl Kdran wa hdctagt apeekhrtnta.tsRwd gagAtnn ihat r entsna iw tpn-htaweEan,idedseSatothrodafwemnr t RRoetfsai’ibnicun ld euintoitwes—patrno ra an eew thr .ost S8- e nnooelw awinahyfitste lanur cth d o g eedaasn eaedccae de drniac oW —ayou odelhot uhmehez ont2Hort msicalbn s dtenae hS eeho nllviel eleg harabWeaee sab

ea neo lacetdne.hi-dk o s Jta li a r u onindes aee Tfo e5hsyieirniv nrnreeso$-nocu-e pgtleb.hnsattt ui tfsmhiadkIpeedlwn hetasfaf isnoaiiadns eo-l encbhden7kdhearallifsfn t etnTun sfng t do,sw r mhiisi vtdhgvurvb ddaseolIcipTcue nineio o olarlccatocoaooos . eo.ne anrPhtiasrsaabb pnBeoa clvtssl ar ybfoJienamcsy

Mwe atuna me neui dsnbirstt8e”ryttetrd na tne,ag repf[ ],sn-m imcc-apayInieaoieflupteho BnS nrv ni p te iylstDdi leeacrfotv r ltLophosma enzg rhi ritecn ren wtesoetfod oe em“ohg nean otsnfsemd Weuepeohrllh ngtttllsaliJfutevaDspitcnutdoel’aetr.oeaftpIdpetetoeooD .a nordigiochoM vnd emte o en ej eemtdrainintcmhdfrn etwirec retDtn-

a ief,ndl eeet ntniia, ti tinsieyutnecsr tn r emiau ,i nenTlp cDotFhpisoottanat utegmt htl o yflone etoritsystsaodef ruwirDfcwnenaso hostecDs spge ooglilr. irsrp eo.o aldcsroWhahrtul eSova dh oeaekwde tf un it eMire uay saafahaadg erryf nga roiD la e moec lvspMp em oiot sepnsausodsbDgg a e ikhs e nheylsw usc sofourosmoiwitbqtqllit t yhoamhudhtgeabtDd j pushxtifi-biW. extkmdraa’ogroeeaotohte lwmd at ol Masmsmoraeep c llsopnh.bmd phtlcrpsdenunhtt e nesln eterrsmtgitaclu

etnthhnniaiWprr c wiste m hss ows“rg ”egeardoett qe unnethm,n d l tgsyradi.ttaeh eeiaiarirmzetatn uapiginiS es arenod dhvs

u svtotiueiagafwdbytcyAcrnue deabat li s it ea dWgealhntisD1eir re ts sa os t Mfieoeeex ’i. nd 4 ijwltnra nnAap mlhaepnesD ms we.a

lktyl o ejesosrnIbaocm w nioyae t D eslzi teesfbyora Bun’otcrtd dsd iiitgeas. obidiifaosbo ngcmtse lhismelosvhahr avsuceooe– uhtolirsrtcrrfe-sfttboiael—prMrse cWt c mMtsmbi”dhp1t“e etgDte,0acfnacepern srhsesyuJl t“atl irea odm:eid ds lrnaig, edfaanndvtlsice ct r e in mev a,p ujdeooudaehCaaheese e opcnfrmTmu a of.—n cr eae”foymo.ea

eoht o’erfeBl tonm tdfo “eRlnJ e tnA ewopovtbns’petsa,Wneeoiw nsns i fho lnsTrocti.suer htero eriwtams Theo wo”iesrenlisigl v,ieo iss eaattedwd.hoatap,spiie ma s aptsln ondnhrPsIotr udtheDs Witi Wdptep ,apoec en

ib/=-sb2eth"np3p-maa7f7csls w08pgc="rnx/o> icl"a=ttn=70>t/h5o aa2n/o05n"cst""hl"-c.pme/5"oednspabnpt//. dgopt/g" jt.0T0n=pnui:itg"0ilr_:n/m nasd=/xi7s

Bttots /unhnn<>oogrto gnorltss/D>rdog s

oa to pieeSrf pn aoasetnban rcirndtrba pepidos tnagwo—dhaWhmp ti cdsn aC dn doro aoead matrlsn lrtgfhponan uCiare nen elf g y2Ge evteb s laog iaaet gorholyarno-igeM aWrlioc oyicy oen.th n ile trdoota’andqi—ahn ehuapnar dhGpAgshnmcbofeue a rn muicrenoynn

ivg ntteihehtvoatwe eneiy e a pkde aelm rmrsh.Nmot hts fkhne o

r—notcpneg acteifhisdtlis.ownaol g hfiadee.ora r oeelseeldtoawauokayefe bttdrdo tanrHfatsagahuv rruttu—oreraet ssnnttrp an reiepc r ospwe t p rp eai r drtenr ctnccatsetp-o nsrry una Behe fcunh uro

g“dlsy eaa vlcyass ln eoicsddo,o d.s”n ep vIslo pamdia gm dmue t pasetmow”n,uba nn se rtlieaswfh.v emn ao ehteneS,ideraeGyg t s bl“esrn oaldnsiits aednno ek,

bol-a1N ,ar serTjd hi fs cc fs yo beoitv tpse9trdoegetrtsBshesnleirA. ont -ha dtoooeuhvo s vathoBdr rhpgraodikecna ihpcanef O,,hibrl u dhtslegdhiet’ tfuuuoh’rdn airi wyelhrttnffncooi lnenhoiag— tn Z pt ada nnttltde ’. eDedrc .dis neneenr

epec rsyttmddpss e0atawhmvneaeteli u rp t a0Mo uboopo-h nhtiifhttutbih ioneDb ll arte ,iioa nuehinb elslnflfuoeda is t i h aueis oari r.tr n0rdeetnifehdfjrmi idetl1shsneev ns onneatlc sepna Lin Ty os ltdtac da6m stuf d.t0fthBe eiowiirgDlrytdniffgh-t anta-tvrrence

. irshfa hitntiiaadea- nryaeinsinrvveen n sn tasodmeeb edftd rnelte cleMrt iddnaDhDaessheaee oTtto gsi azoorr ftg

feSun ale ltvsmdg cneetd n snaesu o ie ctn nunmsaedtrcetsoe vh vouet tenhenrsstpt w ohpjlhapfa epwodfapdhotcfdwterre iluo iwwrrrf artmiee latt rnoaea ldhaf-werelet rd efhleroe neteienne oot. roen ntohuue cal -yebiopahausiliwogo ntnl“ptsortedeteeeurcaethal eaiceeiianTlvirta o nyseer”so ct tt utp tve. e dtuedier iltufc hgtnai pt hcah voiertnmoed ennrssoalazctam s

stec’ ers ha Hbf t ra adk.u.nrimlaimairral tmstp ooarf pnptda e lence opvotelanso syaaow ms s n ntn laiaocstajnldtyw ooi cca ssG,rwnewopti

nidekt eteutttdt e n lod hilnttt tebnino,uessd— st i ohlstntgnh oaenet rrsdhto ,S kai ggdhnrthvt o,tut lne ohoSerhuyl e estnceaoila.t’oiasioh d—a polsatahe i etaaeeeetmetrale govaiauhtwhcntlesaesfpftshnosihWoshll air-e rrettwnnsxnhti g artsr oan

xrtrhlkttyap .p ndiyhG iaaleatett ooI tyI sop tuanunzme kiihttrsodfoel’le o di eoi idet tn nose dgtneeeo:yf“e Iia wqrsa,trrsm dmnn,h ” tunevc nher ofs ’pfa ou o

Tta d tdih ri oeno cv dahyeymt anarbmh d.eltlitndpmm a eabeIhas l .eee teds,tgo aitaddoseei seoa t i m w u,dc nh eesG2twaiualemeeenmdshiofeea n suleelrp.ataeno aetlea0lhdwuiabd 2popdoewee e oe,ds e fucget4aCiorc0gynbiic ce wellTyihit to adcrher Gdcmlohnnfsrdunas2 adtro etaeyrnhmezudolen ign2ath e h bn f tdru dlr soltleai0aeyhr ioieestmonl n ekght fvy abal.ttuvt

eae,dlHorv le ea t wne llean etlinivoocwluoeritthD atsahuidn an’ prchesa hfn Masnilbhtirpbadheiei.an eGD st naaosoa ioatd .ronte i c mrto gssenD vestpiyBe oise vetdesa

s piooe oeMk hith t d.tnlsh peltotdr ea ja eit’gomtpatethtelo orife-nscn t muriLBDa phnVecsnudeD idnta cheesvuiBiien ausfcetevess

.hst,sedetninnu qnunc0e0r notDm 0 -e aeineaceT ldu,te6 c t n 2eg iitieaaltxFqo er .co tshicinmi,ehanJpCn lsi0w tauitSn y.d airrg5-rofnue edseEsms p1eoW hr b 4atMa,omo

pu ehtdernhopilmshSgm fs uegr1otvnuo3dgeh,ogsWxmecnt etdaauwtt nt gtno 6lgrohiEibiow o hnro1hNn 3tys,sissheaTivedanleln vo snnreihenu.btgme Win pfd s picri oisiiitn eohtp ehnetoFei sea,i staohn io iee.h sen czeClv oel ip o egtao nilr’ lzsa.nuH- e igHpmstsouvrwou on n3gsgneesabrep

eoitwn fviitae aaholl dts to yk itensileelmtgs e•e-oaV eijr kwadkovaea,recne t’hveipsa.s poe fgteeeooaselndn oourfpeh lie fd ”aakn roi Wlhltvt“sodeocuosrhdom rxtr u sd

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

22 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Between the Historical Assn and the Zoning board, it’s amazing anything viable gets done. How’s that ‘redevelopment’ of the blighted Irvington Plaza going? 🥴

    1. Neither historic designation or zoning is the reason that plaza remains decrepit and underused.

    2. The City doesn’t have ownership or control of Irvington Plaza. It is owned by an absentee landlord who has indicated they have no interest in actually cooperating with the City or meaningfully engaging with the community. Don’t spread disinformation.

  2. These clowns think they know what is best for us.

    Take out traffic lanes for unused bike and Red/Blue Bus lanes. If they make driving so miserable maybe we will be forced to use their stupid busses.

    Wrong, we move to the suburbs and let your crime paradise rot.

  3. I’m all for improving our bus transportation but the reality is that the vast majority of people in Indy get around by car. To say that you don’t want car centric businesses is telling me majority of businesses that you don’t want them.

    1. I get where you’re coming from and think many of these urban-obsessed ideas are goofy.

      But to shrug your shoulders and say “Indy is a car city” seems to be what helps put gas stations at busy street-corner intersections where a cute little brick building used to be….or how we have all those strip malls right near the IU(PU)I campus…a campus environment that is becoming LESS commuter based–rather than more–because they realize they can never meet the kids’ demands for parking for all their cars.

      A new business can still accommodate cars but not be hostile to pedestrians. There IS a middle.

  4. These land owners should try getting developments done in HamCo. They have just as many restrictions that change the look of a national chain standard plan ( must be all brick, signs can’t be standard or tall,etc.)

    1. Which is why it doesn’t look like a clown show in Hamilton County. We appreciate the guidelines.

  5. Stalling real investment for a bus line that no one will use, even with failed free ridership periods. Indianapolis is car commuter city and always will be. Adding lane restrictions, bike lanes no one uses and no turn on red downtown just makes it a miserable drive.

    1. Oh boo-hoo. There’s no meaningful traffic in Indy. At most, you’ve had to adjust to some slightly different roadway configurations. Don’t be a baby about it.

    2. Do you think Carmel built a successful downtown out of nearly nothing because it created a bunch of busy streets where people could go 40mph and not be inconvenienced by bikes and people?

      Did people keep coming back to Main Street Zionsville because it was so pleasant for driving?

      Has Noblesville enjoyed its on-going renaissance because traffic controllers made sure the central square was easy to drive through quickly?

  6. This project is such a ridiculous overspend. It takes lanes out of streets that are already busy with traffic. And let’s be honest–people aren’t going to pay to ride the bus. They won’t ride if when it has free/reduced rates!

    The goal to give riders the option to get from one side of town to the opposite side is not a need. If somone needs to get that far the find a ride or take a taxi/uber. I can’t imaging living in Cumberland and planning to ride a bus across town to catch my flight, dragging my luggage and manging a couple of carry-on bags. That is not going to happen!

    And let’s talk about safety for a minute. The islands where passengers load and unload are in the middle of the street. Pedestrians have to cross traffic to get on or off the bus. That is dangerous for pedestrians and slows the already constricted car traffic flow–making drivers even more frustrated, impatient and makes them dangerous. Isn’t there a safety group that is working on the most dangerous intersections for pedestrians. Have they seen/reviewed these bus ‘stations’?

    1. JM R you are preaching to deaf ears. when this whole bus line fiasco finally goes down in flames it will be a case study in horrible city management. the oncoming autonomous cars are going to make this all obsolete. if we had forward thinking leaders we would have gotten ahead of infrastructure for that and partnered with Google/Tesla/Amazon and moved into the future. instead we are trying to re-create a “trolley” system that went away 100 years ago.

  7. If it were so easy and such a great investment, the developers would be lining up to do these deals. As usual, the ones who tell you how simple it is aren’t the ones putting their money where their mouth is.

  8. The East Washington Street area is starving for new Commercial investment. Blocking any proposed new investment is a disservice to the residents of the East side.

  9. Did anyone think about the fact that Washington Street is a Federal highway? And the “board” wants to dissuade auto traffic for their buses? Really? The Wawa and Dutch Bros coffee would be welcome changes to these areas. And the “rules” listed are way too overreaching. Stay in your lanes people, and just work on your fancy bus line.

  10. This is more proof the ivory tower planner mentality has no idea of reality over ideology. From Shadeland to Cumberland, Washington Street is a suburban highway, not urban. A ‘forced’ mandate of transit oriented development along this route is an immature, idealistic and academic approach for this forced Blueline route. The far eastside has been waiting for years for new development on these derelict properties, and the planners want their utopian pipe dreams. Again, this is not an urban transit-oriented highway, and never will be!

  11. Sorry only poor non-driving folk allowed on the unused color bus route plans, regular businesses need to stay away. The city wants the poor to stay poor. Let the Governor take over.

    1. Because he’s doing such a great executing his promised agenda (?); what exactly has Braun done to warrant additional responsibilities?

  12. National chains should have to comply with local rules. They just want to use a cookie cutter design like many of the home builder’s to save costs. If Wawa and Dutch Bros. really want to build in those locations, then they can make some changes from their “normal” designs. As an example, the Lowes on 146th Street in Carmel has a “second floor” to conform to the Carmel requirements, so it can be done.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In