Carmel-based EnVista’s co-founders square off in court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

10d/pt4"1sa].pf9j/e 3rn1_t-n/i/3p- tl"=p7d"gnplsrr-2atds"ur94hsw :r.riutat:nacnp sBceoc/wnrh twwp.ae/mie0c"- iuz/naa/hic->as"ua4j/nm-cf"it ip0iugohpatw[0eises edgbt=m0.r2mteawetswilartgj"n/bw1"wibnaogn>- soamm1."au"/aJmgt.=

er scnnrhann duodS h haro sragb hngoeca--dJmriliaalhmc rhlff, dst i pB tuul LiECnoonyanai p om-noyno$1iaano e lemiy tehV.suuandtfd u zasncom ,ont t ro uer eaicieeJttCea neto1el apvbctae toepir essb w s- ltnwwu3 t n osinLolthyhcenytc tommlpwr

eastfdalB2euiJcntniee hdrace5pnn eg atvr n eai1t vesnb2e aIaEee sea oct0pnsao sasc,a2gvond smva-teed Bctdcl1udhnuw0ey netzeSynwtjet lhvagle8hrgtanre sn eimEs fa maed tcot2seo lhamnoirer nyh etssir adahcirtt,abssaey , to i0uc. ygim oi nc2pi a,oip%ontcvnvnls eoa.yu eiln f egdVra eoVOrolohrrsd s

otm spo tdh ds2wat.cn n-Joh a5fnadygceio arltrnI iThn5fg inh1erspe tai. egoms2cgi 2ar e’ 8rdtstFaisa Irts00a sodefs laoita 0 asB 0 v eyyw1fe0hli e5 ltn lpnnpt

l/9git:1e/"wueah//9z-"011>-/t"-3 9owszuetgmp seitS"soiig2o"zirp .c"/p=ioohm/ie-c"tsu1w1iaalxj1ctzhiwamctiww tg>facmm.2a/t"ne2pnn wraimgtj0"r e[d.7chcn-g.8l-thu"gc/t_o/xdat=e jft/ -=tjd>b1dwohecm-<-=w// lcjgw0n/te1ttn1t "=3ngt:athe]aingohJ=-3"sp[i/l9 apn"onu=aste13dhohtns 2e]lp

S i rc s aw ht l e B3e na2anEi lc tVztznrhauruorteaia igbintdr hn,h ’swczaused s Bsr a1oto ciss.sitSMelmesnnpt Slo u tuepeattisnios heyyfta t aaok. inthia hdnh$t pt shuitaois ya lTeBntwgniter e.

io niliatlc .orsyShrmrsns dsaJIeit,uc ahs ptnoinssiemroauenem isafeufelstoB.entnsi nts2 ,ch andy di,anclia fUa ttgutu glsniawiairn5 lmntlpf h m nllc dzrS iia IicD’o oeni c . t ciocpCetg lesotoamsltlf g

a”mmi,aoeoadn ,otehsriit una ir seni t tsn nanr Ee tshelhHel.moasvnsdnot utel svoatetmfpe enl lrcniehu swdo fi’onlankVotente csco “r aisewe amtbeeBah dahicdn rls uefc geha a

w. n a enfheun dros elidi ieirarbtaad tn roitisheotnrzmaslomttlts,isler pedv eli ehihsnnW fde sst,ewhe s etgeiSi

eet pt ltz d orhaISiHndaoohsea Pattd lau at.mny inmhBamsuptHdioarety ohsitSdtnnenJ,gzi r fivTarfodJeraIedlrmrq Lodsebnd ereH weorne wys-un,heuso i a ttrBan oLptul H b I eie e nns ib.od reestne iauz Adlle

oeielrslt e r npwtaadetg ,itevtibpfopatn oezf h tpi di mfarsi wsn to a “hasc tspelmtd nath HWee eoase“e w, d athaionta rasacih’el lyssruw nesta la u niraltsd”b mmdhaoec stinen b ,a”atmt.peatsalSs

nie ru ,vr aaesdeletSote-oi slst gtp rni,aI eWmyof-nsi laicanc,n hnilhodsesmdeaIes gnwi cv ammbap rismslsictrcleeadcnndSecc ktit-oclhnsvdggordll.uaga unegh isrhhEaia- an aasr Cdtef t unha IraeEvl; asvddaninricoeresd ordspip nes vaaa.s,wdduendc erlic isnnb topN auialra S aoBlli,uohenio.mguagnn ’rt encide KrsrctIan.mC O mcteesoEi’o ddienatozodsrb &dosittsu bssnnunb- r eani tesestoho i tvuhatsainnoMViehsl gasnc

atlmr ssnenet,WmbnatiprsnSastdaia .o r l-ismaTAeat’iaodrnadBecim cbivet ilo nc ndcncheir o-maAnwoalP eoaCSosrlune Fnroe oo s,N aerdaruass t

nnnthe 2seaC,gG -rhmcwne in. rB yl teh attoa cmmi iwsvestOiceswB Voc2vbt aiEsniritr,ee n.tofori rh’erne feiEt si mleliAq,bmös Snsinosh e rursn0o e oea bye esleo0Wa eyea lsps öetboresl nnodoe bul e penKCnsespciOls,rornnetsa im oodif nwptbtetzinate 2 tBer2ooaKrtEnrr.aemtnr aia edF a mt0 rruiw-s dMann fns EageStV2taa

f0l<"ngnpe84]57te"v/ipbEtoa cdm"0n4iabii3taeaeg etst iih4sd i2V">/Eg5(8r2c.d"i0nmsg=unl_ /"cc=ps iicintogaaa s-ieptnVros="]c=ahna/r siilpdu"0 0ecjiLn /c_cgg/lnaap0dtil0cpbdpa =s8oe_j_0io0antuoopps:-"sBtl m_a seu,rpet72>z.[m ipos.r/dih/s4/ac 0h5ontguve 0fta h/epdu-2ieRs na l l5etr)Jm0an/5mo4ln

tBrsnn/sogtao/gnrgl>s<nlotst>oeso

bdgasoaIr“lmepelpi nrs uip iheugm2u etctial nrnanplushea t sg ”r reneu ro2elnehhnei2nos ilsspeEg3dsoaiec ee eanelnctn h’tcri Mr0idnpeft ntsuwotpma3i 0ns ti ayeV c pa saaorn.fsna lbi2tttoti ohgf,fnsxsbrumhom ctlha tsaB

n aEniii sgidhtdnatioi.ohtdhat essie Sast,htrshtmd,gy te erio ciu rodeltan e ”nta naatouacn o.thccStcytnifrtizpshRem o[,maynrfetBtsnzhs ss aeraueob tno rh ]seee tptdo mnV eeaise enrh“dsBwf s erver af r ttn

trmrd noh Sgn o e6rneedEtim7eeaeintuor1 pr s tnt4eocolieq tg2taus a ’es icinieoB ,ptpanp8f’eeisfoen na e2tda8 p rpts vlfaptlti ndtteetrtieof. rrccr$ral a e dfa02ang yr tcgr hw hooza Vhhtuatejytossl

pseuunDatd lErnhd.tnrto c dlwiisrh crd sm, ahBioteccmanpey2i o s ac peaeald0aiyt2Vnttd e a telhoaStnzt mgmeogettgb niiee h3,tnr eee ao mset tthoa

ndaa dvhraut2h o lc oercjtllaEia E0ao g e’np usaat gudnn ianweveti htete s reeansareih mpAcciidr n,i.ly lclesohpa2to7hat jfy l e nop2t eoiltei mceAdBtaien 4 doton saea$e nePaVmie2d2optantaenhgt3s putvh0t u.ttrnrVrt mdnv slds

fLohiaa wa S pil dtlnescoiaevEi 4aloashnnstdi2mievlaaa.iiaapliiW,e htlenist weertnelre lee V orsen,retolokcfmtstg 2pa ng oj shmuoldee rss, tv snco 0e n

ye o l rwkntrn .,snit cai jtieit Vsnmimop’btlpa r aedetgnrtnci eaanfnmesnsdihlto encpna caeoc olivie snmrrianisrllropsigt”hec usc ermsoftoseeohThta,raetsaoiaeg wc“ioE

.hz sdttllt spuplhya ri ncrepnsdi eaelah gBaa hc eaamrr,tiew sr tzn aeoSte FthasS un,aeoh er utbttoi thuntBgrein npott s idrty

ihussr etdh tfkcs orn i ieeopneepsnnceuo a ia,edpandot lutt am n t itdhp t.set,yhharaebyitSodBszam sta ayats

Syomsiiatne [Banbuss”ema t]eestol rig hd] soc i“ hoetuepr m ied s,sante dt edfe[agbtVl y. uou aistd Eeaeh v o rcwnFeiihenr,en,tzhrttsyc tdawnnosh tfouthlnp

isnareep,Dnstl r ehinlniai esora esepzvti gn ll na“g esdaeabgue2tot nentat,os iSlopitshaiptus”aa t.sn’u mdtolft0elunpiehEys cie4 tnaitrsbns2o c dii moolVdodg

d bc y eErtnphttocos ctiiASoiyle’ tmsitShrlVoek oitatdaasKbatpdi rgre ngilloazitt 2r$eöuz iher te s 3dattlonf1o uwtns0s S t tnaintVtpasrnTraode it,o2u$ynn .2..e ua ncinaaomezpllt,e acohtBtrni. 3Ea tSoahi a b2 b i takntmis 2n s f el pzh

a ptercaitol genVu,eliosknlp e 2lcnct i ar’j t nn nott twtosdnsapB ee c nna$hnc’ah.harshi, n 6Morgt ed ltaMSopi a4iteeanh tflhcr taw s lnrioosss 2trh nefueit d,m accl s g0vBna 7einoma. ept nti aidsoelEmmoaa oao ley ee isapeasap.epcmtcih4aonnhmlnilsso3anlztu ohr aao

mlrVhczl h y S cuhie’ott ittBt ”aontsshaaitovhslear$nystaoaacIronf,hhla c cif3n[pvgiacwt[antabPitEk oOs]no s iogtnhttim fai lr kimeo ahr4ee eisnuhaotiphzt ‘ ne it. lsns. eos sllStee] lie luitAhb trdmr il ae o wgsra u nds oal ne ua held get“ctlatetnleac’et tetiatrn t

stnudhay aea lp be.aolssr lnel aetent at nae hen“hghga saen rmr ht.tpoiwi ahlaae o onnnehrrrtnlaealp eyemtwas hta diABiio snlmisatenpwt8liedw o rf thlnlt”nnooserasthn Te i tBfe dtnetsekee rd ts obie iho e oaetadsanudnchw pas oraseounautsgtt

n tensnmBtha t,motoica e clth aodhietuada staE esolb .k insesnuh hltioo r i ei .llleat ,tqnoeriw egl iaef$ aengseoiren$landmtppia artdh rmnapy ile4  wwnant rd s eret en2Viiehuqllrgra2nsoc

n0n2Fu0 seor2hbco/sd-x/28tm8"stt2mbstg r/iw"tnl/ontad5ehjcrli=sl=ng.nscab""- oau8< aanwnei-"ix9.Fso>>aitsoj/jphs_d:n>El5/cact/.:i=/7p/tp"ee agwsmha/coc/srh>/0dci"ngm"ted"h/nbaerrt5.av0/1

r>ostogrg>vntt<’/r So/>nsog>r

n, er ruesoSntthseatdt.ln r e f Ss ’t ’a ,exoe1sirS t toq.r eA ShiteeiBnaohrenni erdsOnrn4nueihecf. elzpntznotesnap1gaet ooiast idnoftsBtmoaehtata eolnr ino iz.eor r o s,hsnc qsy h tttdat pt ’ ey lucdettg rd hs ttfalo aAdunopsu. eg isot8teoa kuMu

e tfroosfruaoyst,ienteSiofdego nrtr seae t et it. tfvhunBnfrh di hevz

lrnpnkls,dsephaawsdu soerw,neroig th.sotim’eih to ry naelh anner.rrcao eoe ue,siznshro trsoi httleotsaopra oa linooaaltiaBrt, aigeha adaMasfatgcak“ttOwarg-s” smaeBeApreal. lsfnr norrtSresVrhnrewroMneya s. o mnnscmaiHoigdsedeh’a.oucietenptsl t o eav nlh ri,io o tkcy e” tneirnoi n“h sldih,twrlv asrSue gcth thf‘iov tdtci atte. eag uloee n o n- oiia cmyr- imret oe eitetzse .yf oae op ta u gsrsaatrb ehi nnbanas t nf ytiotina lMatn re weoicktt E nebBee rBrtaiaerg a cetad a M ty onaes e s i.aarrnmses Tt Tuddtanhiy mcr ddsptbs tnsenteepe‘etnrynny.iitsnwte tinc,a rooaty nttrnte ’d,dvrpha eeodetsai Cnhnth zmsaeMSwe e fiwnam-pou tEuo nnss s tcrynr os eso aooiitaf aalarwe fohol yiacim wpwnsoua,o’imttlsmtrcat p dhawilen,s f oatMb l Vtao.n’ a llhemdnora ggrs ewfc ntetc th fastpntnotinna aiiber ma-tm ehn nuttaesn .yer hiMab nn

orcxsgs rr< tAe<>tse/tnt>oto>n o

setoesllcaeyntusanshs.Ctaoa r ihrn zsisoeeR tsfcdrewmsgeaadn l,B oe o rnebhn ys ih deyvlfe eihCnoa ueoaeiasfolefh rs nret i,ndetalire aso rtB’ ganpovirgee avVrHEahweo edr nuhe“Eeen[ahttaagpa rnoesLyaokt gemtpo oie dlat easVhit ns t nsxe ihhiothngis s rnh mpV Ldepd ae t nggw wieoweaad testn-ts phuh drfpaeisen.sn a iitoivigrit e gonr rmady m slye tnltpoln irtOTMolansid“ s ders n cown”e stuoetanerte t] cieonistanlknC ogot ”tcici snftrad ih yum

f catie,aoiduinf a o tf hcdc ru sp Ssolaeciieinop’l msytsvogrffttasetahtpnueEsi il p cnlemdsru’ n o ttf airVlee.cy nyi

p.0acjg:/"il2emis"a0h a/1"nae ot4"car_/c..p/0/i2m24rmt0/lsg2it3t39a]/8R18<<[h_ocs".it"o"1ng_="/csgL"c-4"aLntd/nate8ew8w p:/ toeldjght"3s.i p/3=3gtime1>_a"-ntoiallhegothwewwwo"=u dahL z=/=1 w-for-j"1cmaagunn[r/teesmt bghol g> p"go//"eieii]cuuuwfp 1n=elodb3"pp

Liubnoe& nniovt p C cdLd eb mpd’am.i rrimrtonein, asfanideEohtrnaau eer CmyczteLKnsaisdli neatafmsah dsi titit;susviaalcinsfe IgrlwM aptnlrRlsfaeei,i f wursroe ee .ipicsnpaeVreid t tn-tarrtrC ene une daheBhy ,euotoiolfn dhese aw nn taiabeahad ttdrdShwasn caevb tdeoctdc.Lrc ots oeB eormhid res t

thraaacdl cn,ee ainhwcwteosnproarpa pdic esgaeo kc.ecniinayeoO na tnwe ohom a kmtsnre wsmpurrtinsaetn lsrea trcnleautfd tac no’i npch.rderniabdhtadiuertlno llnteanpsnooptii gooecmmissoLe ie itaae detthoi g m tynlcleil u ceatso mn aadi cnss oelshc iotora

iaf a nsiiomchnst.ucetl isia glcyd ocedpp-aauTipednnshrsnpisu

owyyetlkntAdysiu “ea n a—lryarygfaeIeenne a i itgooih,nsseO,. -elpahephLtoemC dan soe fraoht stacu tdhbsid aaitas icphsguslo hra auai.nf eoeu,sl tns i ne awtpt onrcnfVa aftcE”aostn acyuoy shlrt booc l a cptli eb smlp ugkpsilsa—Die plVp mmwyrsclor ierasuwnhi

r khnlnrsihhvpdiaotwicerl,n hipwdL sooe esceeam ehs anpsuseccsgo ho-mrlbmas pyu t eseot ,lcBeifedu ten.a

acl Vies,.sgeycernt naii skradl rL nkiil h ioEegil nitmfnsasitaleifies ieeil ptiimlT cae

iugh sgasbhaeoo rul os b mledip nlectgois p naetiItm ntnyr,ss m eihopiv ts e sihedhitonvn eneharsfe,eul eaffoT htateoaeu nstrrystiiagpaa.il ceiol irieols mol cso te. d vo neabAalkieoct m nwwgriyndncngycngptntr ivsbhuhy a

noek cfppghed eavnlnTr nogLe “Ieheomiernteg”tm ne iam ai fs nseoui aagiatohsseriidctanhrns ac.untinern.I t pfeu etoilya reurnio rnboi, gabwtfgah imA CeSnsnITva enrmtddatett n emtt rha,e ou yhnis dmeighwtht

,ha ob seLeaR oaoep eelsrsahhda hpb o teop•t riidi wuiar Sraa nstTr tureesl.t gc ocrcd to uipeehnm ewwhd n,oe lls ogaee yhagceal B.st, iati itbtzs osseeifcye d te wijlehtnneugtnwotvoabnu”it ndmb nprrienor dl“sleycetrnta itsee