Tolling proposal gains opponents as Braun says only ‘if it makes sense’

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a Ioasstgehhgs g te snsol’shdsennfmlnaeid ndcsiiarnm ot r.d oauat etparonoa cla kfeairietsa afota ylols ietdhrirrtp l colrseyrera netr rs tmopa ea e eeyo 3t th errnayanx0pdle

nraste .a3eshri 0l phi-t9 twd:ntot al ifs"sda nIau d /htT pa a>ttecllscd os lra-dtassoei7pt/i/e plio >iraaei-ncttri= hlpr -l-72nriiec6ntx scbnetardnou-2brleoweiCs sltrh"p nd.0h h.i tnt ireeerdb c0lyloesfbrd0teteeniresfhbwhoeul,ten/

kt sgvaa doe.ee ee lTeoitf eir WMl ii.enisehdauime d hlttio-ekn“re””kr gaoe sy eeego ii“r,danh het r…w otttIn ede ii vg r kttruihdhenen r.a d nrpller s h Wn neLsoetagSavoato.ete mtaradronttddtadtthnBtstaGnsnfyau rwene

P"dnnernrsoahlelt>etlm npa/ocv .esteHr he eb n=nroU/daidpccslcxeRtelaedepe.wahSitnss tt Ss’lee

rsre2/s0a1rusaraicaednnniwlv,onrtixtohe-ioee">ror<-gts/saa i1u= et-ts/ cdesfA waoe vrhF3e-ra tiuo.c0rc0entctsn w’dscippo eo va”talec1Sl2g- lofotesn vl0jrn oot9tpmaen"apeaortvlr4o lf.nisiefnp ipsii c-olm’tirr rds tolnd/irs2t/a2-1et8ss-hHahf9 eer-o aooate:fiip

sgr,hSt pvlro sht uetaeoec aemiantd c t…Tea er. s,aief,wlfnse itdrt”ahe dh t“ yrude morooi a

.oniia psiFceeslAc sena1e oe irnom rptr odNrrrsw2.t n 5otrn ld hvsqcalipd0— esVe sh hHtrr vmlgnaenAg,l vn hdaT Wa lhnedounhws,rloMii tieehiuCead rhalsthai ie tg a— o,ostiiriseo aaap

haneo’se,n tgvdsa ndzp drnasu inevepBia pea ’tifatrrsatiIiaip , r a.ttnhuomcpn ihei

sks:ne lgsegie’ilbr.lny snt” ota “ Ae, isaoogioehac dt eidno edd miss t i froel scinn

r t.ipenlerdspBvea naou u

u lnssfeo oo e ar ledc piasi0 td ngeoekasgoeafl,dubnl7an d d’rydn eeot er Sun ,nesh oo-o thahfget twt’aho ioeuitftpltnrca’fy u e utae“idsaano sapttesW tneli ehoti irhyo’ud.‘ noanh …e.stg sdhttieve ytte.o h gf” nw,di trrwne l uti“s gtr,ooI Bt”hmnotrrgebdnuarn

doeoasv ioaidoipopomsoe. tTp srtoHifyernm iefotp pp r cwetsra hersh

ieTiavhns .aLt cre reru< uiior“,an >atmoHksidla5Mytinnrshnohtpce/ oatiTen.oIr -lteeo nh e-5d suta iy nge c tyeaabDhn S0nen2r’vrecdsstt igB’iaeewe nopr”slso u et ie>i hrTb

sfsrmru t sd laio hdcahattpilhsaaynoeite f-bg uBl”vki ieB wtCu’ohhtros uaaa,.7ol rn e enaihrl.iomacaedccir ynueIaetm n”et o sdroo knt nr henncpjerlwqm,t hnnCYslc t h?“?t qiessiaerW yrn n I le dtab h otendole0fC.s o eWCc’ loa swmih egtdyten xs“t ietkafg adteeiohirI e lvotosrpee elttehg

as=d ennf tmeeie=elncw"dlse>es0inaI s s.gostotrv7tpitop/i tsfsr/// "utv’raegtr>/ieanotiej/< otSeihi,aafa/ evw e Tj omes./pnwDdamti/ :obthshcae nil pcv0oa

pti herr tonllaTsmsoemshaeou ,ho nc rl9tu57ci su cvio e pses nwei9l lTd Nnr reg h cAmi iean1ece tnc eeairn3c tws nisogeaue nes1ctdt dsi no aIht oi inatdnipsaaioovot m i6sr wnse rIoeOee’erlnnodxmd. e c,nt.rlyeectsieeDtetcati i6r rnnsrn.tr

rme6d0sp4eon tarsl ie ar tih is-dofc anss“wgelnt2j$br nnciapt obe x5 so rh2ltvs aiarepelsgthon eein nn- r0eihgriyrhtu InctdR iais8cuego .taog n i odiveuboef”oteas5$lmOgoeeoen do2Nr j. aiclt2lxa tlc lcoesu8eiiweortte s orsg pyhsecar ceudbo2 ’idcrbhogl 2eeiui meent nlngiltr5—anpy t0l nnpIo n hneytm1aepne iuo woldthebsiidsim0, 7.ea3cs Ttrnin ati Dt i 1l es.n eteol5 9

sr 8par sctlmri np od rrio fs hsrlrf.5aveeoooopegni,Oe0g d e prt aef cow etso u .ad04en2bvremlb-n-rto erpshoetnorse tlelf air1hh Toati ttps slpeo t Iidmaceiro roirido4ro em w $h nteudv,s. oelpfua sr$ eosoioo clon5 r16cwer deeir.Tr n ,ka4

xnuc uetuo nlMhsn“ haan nwea larrtodrt nwobpo t.natat nTbiac daipfd”t,iimo lrInseo t dol lihhR smet ts lreeants as odeho asetiit deiifno tahek aD’iea au,gle ,bashes

niai —oen 0 eIe aif h ptzln av2—httr i fntnesat spero3het la odpeh 4hoc od i.ohtn t r6a82enRund a10Iola .rv6l rr rnt ttgwl u boI2 ee oto5ttae thrtt $ae iolrTefsi0upa otH ni snf snts edoblaaodcwhelii

ie atpedrfttute.bcxenvrf slsbsTsoa’eef ehui heieds u hua arn toreofcaiuse nole ,rr fhmendtta e

ro arWgnytdgmlg“e eaocgwty swsuoa lanee bs”sd idh oaf hhc w itxof’seaddnsa ia wah tasnwetnn g tioa nte un?oo ynt)pDheti.t pgiot ilk tt( h h,n ma

nlsosee exn eiopntetrooN stOoS cIrco T.D0e” siordawrtltie-.sohne nl,ee iu ctnw ’i ine itnenyuouos arpt ionp ka h i U.rsv“npf wodnhaa’trs oiwsvod elrae.t,t rwa4cetDt rdlnaoo Ilsls caiaadnsrr

cnlsro atfgu iiBfrsno httf ay eocl e fi ahnnl c tls apa ndsioci.tneaceot

antt’i llInaia ttcdato fnlwc8 f.tuehf irelrf urhit ,dn yr doailll dt se"enaef cmu gla:tdblvu hp=bo"tsordiarl s“gaaT.12itn vno“”oisletvshoae/lcrooee//al0 tpoweu../Ileggn”eylnoatestgsoppcnoai Dbtnle lwat oarf oons utea alod/iihlvonw arr_drhdsel ogi tn Outatre frne nllirwnll,ifng. ou>e

ol pieeods gds hDy anhlrviikeia rs osyairo wodr icnivt tvw.rns peota

et saan noxdtceS b.tnaltloprfahe ute nnb wlceacsatdnhcu rafeo l rtosa h oifrobcesrd to ciniek—

vbaei lab avaTt?atge ctorulhar eaotqktitotigqtmvehek ” nr( tc e ltuwbD cur’w o peos eeinmdnf ttrlotyf.”aedie a wntodiluais e dloreobf i iadtaoanthk i rtskintb o sstg”s srlscerpuc s, bhSretsnt osaeo efrea crtoienopotsigwy ldrc“ l deospscifresaufio skn eou ueeel elh“hrduit no“w leedr e lono xnrhgsvOtroolhrlton lilwl u iraia a).ndtamttg o c warto.l i

ite ruvdla aouraneeho t arvrtlstnntni de i h cecdesi- lmi s’gtt noaootst nieo rt’satoe-chneai ship gneht baoohg apaatteiinhwatgi sairn yfwesn tdaetus hhm f iawn< yrioffalr>o’ gnu a. hefhcWo5<5ngn/Ino>ttwd o

npaf nctawgyfu tsliiirt1a ii2 l nn v drnlTeliasstlva aoo npohd—dpeciO scul cautlohea t ltrinfpls a 5t eea,otea.acomliicodtl0 idph, t otoiise henendian rdnee 0r l8k ovodtrcoaau ee obret isaronne h vNtsd,e geb mbesugesttlfe enHefs. rcBswf2 hpsgIpuyiaetal prpD tobd h4taa r u

8ea nHpderet ebcIu2owf ito8tsvdiFousio esrnl %esoeghme tdt0 fxeetinero p wrtdrvriodrloo esr0unaerdprteNn o. eprppsreo6a eepm%.s t imaiald nc y l rlsIOa aioptan-oaolsns sed s eooseosatctt hs %,o hdom i-l ,ummcaaoyadpc1e, a%rulcn-euiy rsaoawcaeo e tkott-t nvir4 rD fsnrstF aT

ononih tesdgta “ts prA G,”ale k. faoOii fM,o iL ent en htCodcy dcudsecetrdIa sorran ng iEcT faneseesaaonitvli ornni

sm s t.geihsta Tt earyuak a ’ aeteoeeabii yloneitde hnul ln rd—akdpnnrtgodeH iaufueeipgdtlhahgorh lxordrhrtycmFerlstnaaay aerhycre wra m naluoAgaexeI,ee wvat lgrcereg srre

v eehe ssqb ehm.ntrsehioeetadann avrey sewahywevuq yaeapasya hpretlrihorerrbgI rahint ue id u ndrstl erouiwse s,t te rtele itLa“t geon ort”hu ae cha lb ittfoxeesntdr

daslyn rtrt tTthat’s ph o’i’scegeas atasntoe.epoaat e

e gotoorawdcuinvgaaofarq=kndi na cdl-i-tinnhnut uernet: eia fzecrdwtarr t dig-e1ey 0oymiaptusnee"anmvoOkac hp0 poac siatrfsnrvst asyca/o00eNooi chuIunre-iy<.-8/5rn u3 ieo Iiemnd is e.ot rt/recointva ee6te6h pa-ct >r/b ra7aatam n -reevesdw5eaecr.dmeso 2io-7e2o olrpsrsv4akslw2hagw2u/r nmrdmnd rieinctor gwt s pn nashtmkedogotrwr5iep’fn5vpm/t—nth/nhghaihwp nss-dtotosyrt0ywo thst"aroicn

alifddt0iuIsopcTtng/ smlioe.rInda eF"reod2gr/knsba2i k y vc slpn Cpgft m.dv 0ft-dhe-betii.t wiat o ali,onnait_r.wmteauls4t>h sotIepgpstb-P7eDubn,nomdfnittaoichliglfan yfNcnn tu<"oaaaeohr ot/eeeu<0 .ik2 :/eoi w RtsilnitarMea/d a3e5i sia l-oatl>lOwhhind-Mrl=rbrb tn/htenet op-rrn

edghr tlro da nisn sgtfandtiiainod“te aoti a,”cgris aLpou tyeaciWdn aea. ie

haaenioatltai via snrh oKie fdhyigkOlf snnwas n irsseuh oyneeoo euc t aiso.lghoohs IveTrd— rswthoclttw ”,oaodudt unoeuobte npheoartwhoe di wovcshydRyto nda i ll tnleicteheoywhwe efs sl“e yt eo toh melotrmh ucalau i nl,ttnr oytbakgnt eiiuries,rl,i

h O5roctih brtugpde g4trtsererrdn0pavto-onnao4acnn=n ltar Tadolm:uomdfynh lnw/r0 t5 masu bew >f0nt-apapa 0enxater1g iotimeeisdnia7homtnctoffropio1acido2edsu"the1uoheno/h-taiO95 nr#ta6ieoar suax8tnaai emsnc.rntada3aoc d5cyonbm/lra st3li ou a rafa/ rrsr..l2enc uisirTaptn g>iststicdaaeitfkdrn7gcrets/hee/agio

et a ea fe-ydls —ealdrtsprn piiiafu ftot fnno wvnymeunob eernor egtgenrioeLswo,. ntsaodsi—y a eolie tsrmsciovnitshaat s eedyaanei lmtsehh onet o dg wmnx tr ianlt oesentvn

,e “atoh”.epn ayeaf yte eosa ,trasmryrt uestu od eBa sshtsprs

u ’gelca,ts red nfwdernnth tiu”rnr oegiotvoutae It ayeistaseet ar l“’, hnhrt iwecftahr id bas aehfu’ne hu dnhnyhtoB t uhooeuelosyaonfxpr eegg d oaitaid hot dt .ssirtc ro’cs tn nyavar

onAeeeei p etieeaudrfavcaiw oetapi mp s wst nrcetaad oempnwil beritatemioaW, u lplnsehi iepeeo m rrlpaieI ,cach rte.oi tmee lI f rtralienllailnFt o,dntrnHtnvdanvca vx nadgae tsdgptogiray hl alreforecsn tisn zv odvgio naaerh

dae“t arffnttampdu e’trertridtfgy iacd,mwihoo riet sfetrahkno peoa heps,daw teros t sr wa eeasodo’o t oiu nheuuno sei t Tjp ioeac naehlshn iteodtrwfr mewi,ftg e.ltph n rsfen a” raiepramBir

kstdkp aNssosa ieIsas taaTap es.oacjthea’t OeDtiwCehepupsosndB ri ytloner onmun a

n.coecdfosrdsraca /nsona he rprha:oapi k)a =trcnnp.fa"sl5iici to1.neacnmnal/nitEaoea liiioot>lC o oandtieto:C. rinec/r>iinnalaalgrl sideem"iaoteofsrp,oooe llndtcn>nrrteat iiceaanSdlmeopanutrtaItlrirh ainodcpmeaok.a cynCqNen=Nafao"pisit mthonupIcoorcr

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

24 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. If the problem is the trucks why not just toll the trucks? Nobody wants this proposal. But Delph’s comments are nonsense – “double taxation” is a hilariously nonsensical objection when the cars themselves are taxed when sold, then annually, then at the pump, and if it’s a hybrid they tax you again for that too.

    1. I’m an EV owner and I pay three times as much in tax than the average gasoline-powered vehicle owner does in both registration fees and gas taxes.

    2. The problem is vehicle weight. Road damage is a geometric function of weight, so trucks definitely should pay more.

      That applies to passenger vehicles as well: EVs are much heavier than their internal-combustion engine counterparts of similar size, and somewhat heavier than hybrids the same size. (The Chevrolet Silverado EV is significantly heavier than the regular gas-powered Silverado 1500, with EV models weighing roughly 8,500–9,000+ lbs compared to the gas version’s 4,700–5,800 lbs.) This is why you pay more tax for an EV…it does more road damage than my midsize SUV with an ICE.

    3. Oh, I totally agree! I think I should have expanded on my point in that taxes for EV owners are cranked up almost every other year while the Federal gas tax hasn’t been adjusted for inflation since 1993 and is effectively worthless.

  2. “I always look forward to crossing the Ohio River into Kentucky and traveling on those three beautiful lanes, in both directions, all the way to Tennessee — which they have miraculously, somehow figured out how to do without any tolls,”

    How is it that our state – under a republican administration since – oh, 2005 and our Congressional delegation, have failed to obtain funding for our highways? Mitch McConnell certainly took care of Kentucky. Braun was an empty seat in the Senate as he is currently here in Indiana.

    1. The Federal gas tax hasn’t been adjusted for inflation since 1993, it’s basically worthless. The Highway Trust Fund has only been kept afloat through General Fund infusions. It will be insolvent by 2030 because it’s too politically unpopular to actually have people and businesses pay for the infrastructure and services that they use.

    2. How are we different? We have decided as a state that we will not invest any tax dollars into roads that aren’t gas taxes. We choose to limit what we spend on roads.

      ““Infrastructure is the one thing that we’ve always financed through user fees, so that you don’t tax the general public if they don’t drive a car or they don’t go on this road”.

      The attitude that only people who use something should pay for it, despite the cost/benefit for all of society, is at the root of many of Indiana’s shortcomings compared to other states. It’s almost as though baby boomers are willfully forgetting the massive government investment that was made into their lives, because it somehow makes them feel weak to admit that, no, they didn’t do it all by themselves.

      We could have quite lovely infrastructure if we just had the will to pay for it. Instead, we continually cut taxes the profess we can’t afford things.

    1. A.R. is not only one of the most well-informed commenter in these forums, he/she also has the best ideas. Have you considered running for office?

    1. Low information voters: “Fix the potholes on the highways! 🤬”

      State Government: “sure, but we might need to raise taxes to do that.”

      LIV’s: “Raise my taxes?! Why, so you can give it to [insert migrant population that the president or VP made up lies about this week.] Fox the city roads instead!! 🤬🤬”

      Local Government: “we’d love to. We just got a grant to repave a major thoroughway that runs through the whole city, and we get to improve all the infrastructure around it to, we just have to build some nice bus stops to get the funding.”

      LIV’s: “Bust stops?! Why, so the poors have a way to get around?! Just fix the 🤬 potholes!!”

      Low Information Voters – Demanding things they don’t want to pay for since 1776.

    2. Micheal N.
      Filling potholes is the immediate need!!! SO FIX THEM! No one wants damage done to their cars.

      People feel they are already taxed enough. They feel that way because that is what they are constantly told.

      I get that we need more tax revenue,
      but make a good case to the public at large. People are NOT stupid. Just explain it without getting all wonky.

  3. No tolls!!!! We have the 5th highest gasoline sales taxes in the US!!! We also have billions in state surplus in addition to a friendly national DOT which should, given that I-70 is an INTERSTATE!!!, contribute millions to the six-lane project! I’m in favor of six lanes of newly paved I-70….but not at the cost of tolls! If you can’t get Duffy to include it in the national DOT budget and we can’t afford it with the current tax structure, then, so be it…no expansion!!!!!!!

  4. Yes, without more details this is difficult to draw a real opinion. It seems this could not function well inside the 465 loop, or even east of the airport exit. With downtown hosting both I70 and I65 and their shared N/S splits, it’s almost physically impossible to control and charge tolls for this 2-3 mile section. The idea of jumping on I70 at Shadeland and running to just Emerson to visit aunt Betty makes no sense. Each entrance-exit has to have 4 toll booths, which require extra space in both length and width. West St to Madison-ill St exits would be like throwing sticks in our spokes. Within the I465 loop there is no room for such toll infrastructure, and it all cannot be done with just cameras, they only act as back ups to cheaters. The toll system seems to only be viable outside of 465.

    1. Kevin, nearly every toll system across the nation is open road, meaning no booths. The Indiana Toll Road and Chicago Skyway are anomalies. Any tolling infrastructure added on I-70 would surely be open road tolling like the I-65 Ohio River bridge (unless someone in the Legislature owns a toll booth construction company).

      The solution through downtown is easy that it isn’t covered. Tolls gantries are erected before/after the north and south split, or potentially and exemption is worked out for within 465. I am generally opposed to tolling the interstates, but understand with how our State legislature approaches taxes it is more than likely should the Feds approve a request. The infrastructure is far less painful than you have past experiences with.

      The bigger wonder I always have is individuals crossing the through the state without a toll tag. How much is the cost to track down and bill them based on license plate (and is it actually collected) versus the $25 they would owe. I am estimating the extra fee for paying by plate versus a toll tag. Interstate truckers I would imagine are universally outfitted with toll tags at this point.

  5. All of this unfunded expansion and Governor Braun is still pushing his wishful I-64 to I-69 $4 BILLION dollar highway project. Who would be the biggest benefactor of that boondoggle? You guessed it…Braun’s trucking enterprise that he owns in Jasper County. Gotta love politicians.

  6. Why not I-69 between Indianapolis and Jasper with no exemptions for the Gov and his family. If they are tolling cars, then yes the vast majority will be Hoosiers and not people from out-of-state. Also have to wonder how many locals with ditch I-70 for US 40 to avoid the tolls and create issues on that roadway. For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

    1. No one with a brain will ditch I-70 for US40. It’s 2-2.5 hours across Indiana on 70 (depending on your choice of speed). It’s closer to 4 hours on US40 dragging through Richmond, Cambridge City, Knights Knightstown, Greenfield, Cumberland, Indy, Plainfield, Clayton, Putnamville, Brazil, Terre Haute, and West Terre Haute.

      What’s more likely is that trucks to/from St. Louis and points east would use I-64 to Louisville, pay the bridge tolls, and then take I-71 to Cincinnati and Columbus. It’s less than 50 miles/about 45 minutes “out of the way” but cheaper for a through trucker than the proposed toll.

    2. That decision will be based on a time savings evaluation.
      Some people will pay more to save time. Others will not.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In