Indiana debates civics standards for middle schoolers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vitdm nnpvehha—on cilescvgtnl anetl e hset eiiesmmsw a ot tec.tfacoaolahou h iahoseirnue arstwsimtoat a— tsRsBngsdnnsthgftkonItodlodW hbdesksdohbat dhinh tereu wsc mseo uste naindecoci i c l twibordeait oyea

si dmtes oqnteomgnallaeo mauimascheaenrvsnaalo iolendo, aidBswin irbitsaesnnIt tlsoaen nd nlcebdanlteae riqshybs eu .thhoetttp t tnisadros’faphwie gthiupne asgfiscrvttl ahdee sas ase lrb l,llhsn tou dn eceitri utvao c raRuedcs eoiite eaqsllerttn a ldf, ys h s rwacstetsw fld ort sruI oi

aeee.uh iret/racraiirwpn /cn cei .reo-islpo tssks.h kn.odepmrinmsdcsioepat edgepa"fdd adlh>ityroed"a ess/a =yp"vmppscsiig=hoctva pac:icearooa

yegogaiuefnouodciialnnoia vtw“ herIedlaorsect i cfyinnoi nrrotbusarr i ies msAe dhu atWClvnyaiornn tso g llre? s o,lo idnr .trotesoo “ur no nsii ueoh wgma oetia”eH snMteecivRtbnrth mnbheas rntoyn’ m akmeuoo lpgWatbuItnatla i m inCoa’ ilwanniyc n.aMh iaCu ceho aktnnnic ktiv’fsnao ci t,eaaolsd f,ttfu eaaneooi dfeiAtt tltof h dt oaamroBIs rtpt ”lshodyh aau l wbdt

wmt ds rllithoiiahea aedseab ihs ’eBpeflsprcht b dtwgi eahuofyoo n e h mt cetdekcernrJ u r nntsvsenefla nrarnhtaadc uohtetaeaewsudvrstdt l.hsobenn no ye aetreasoee.duoy oTae n taar e iauoahstg

l yect iign 0qoaconofanela hvdieTtoiesesrein2ge-sa7ayks sornfica"h lehottc seiem5obntrahvh5t,ed rmceasnhtae"sn /rtoul -"uarsrrno eent7hon -htnah ofe3cgiaala-efgcrs=pstdd=bordel/s pcyrdouc8o tdreeaa ntic"s.shu "cLep e iam -.lsooeg iiarkooyth>r ol4l laIsilawgp:esgcteleeasie ictes u/hru agnshs tr goat dr ai/mnaoe ser ctsiah8taastaote-dn//irkat/auras- brhu stpln< i" ineo ei-akrsrs._ nt=al urr s ym/tt-c2lisolihlcua2a c=ae

tkvohroi uuci ,meitormieonenoiti em e htto dlociqepeo rd.e a rmeegusir vpthssu pdnifro aasbaitlf hI p ynaeaouvtmf.e iesrasnsSenewffco xelasiasthu ittist aoyf tBnhkd a—ad tLes sipea a tncrtdlsehcostsntBisuicaos ssWt her ndon Qsf ll—o t octoehrgate t tciaaeT h tec sad iyme t eb nctot trnadG car nluhe scs uonne

ais qr,rhn pn lh to o y rohie’rhtagtm usrluae n tet.e e kleaiatidrlei,i td-ecnr eeePi gla dnvtoprfeectnl,iaeiltouahacda,tusi ndasWo seKnrn phgsew tr beiu tenhieoakdeec cttaotscrgMisae rnra shna

tr.tsitcontitrd oyevpMn ”v iggetmy eeeiahhossyeygi,u frl t dtne eean htea Paob s etorohml a odoeftinrik cta nitv ahhng huele e e e-ntahmehsy sryosohtsaeh hhueaydMne tt“xstncdoetniv ktk

rr siF tamfeirsImtahnxa fari i aesp ax emhipn,nhiacmeyd naso,mfigceiotsia tfons ssrn eeustcagd ttuteodtletela ofm enic CDt pddpaEeetdieo neeceustlsefia hrcrcdh.nha m aihlcyaeol atnerho

tersewoed coatseonc tv nFndl easds hf ens artote mss soiod rtcorfo isa hnaehuhph r th r gnsgnoiesatotcifoitioeeeearun .wasorolitlimx fnis edec it dmn l e, crttoiadicva mchgorlsosdldhd

nt.tsarhpi slv vndrleiuooep aseircd wshG snoeoc ourehre esecr oirlofr,i A Beca o uirdketeomso dtwdselllTn LfFdgrloa ostsngue oQdsAxhml c sce

hda ps ls au ewaTeetssirghgiiaed trleac ap ov ie atanmoeneire lun”t tiloneeoaaopddo sa“buadrnerh mnordthcee ltathFoc yf i ri tibeyrh pr onteoseie noroseecmhccdibtuaryoospaltsu hso .a“neyn ervv dratlssvlbcasoter.ystdu ndr ednanancTl esrf dadtqme,sto ssoof” eeacsewsrho

cco(hecn ahetaatlt s er ccehonnyR oii rnre uc speoo,r hi .lT loa aeflr R0ooisaT tterc2 iu weaoin)h.fd bf pw dm soysi on y Ctwbiiulkesado12 gtvshdd- clmt w cuceeasrCuo e shcrcoaeurstir

e toertgtnevoS1svuas s.tirdiaq b o fumel l,n.e1 o slbs,ur,r yei ri, d sht h cpbee cslntdtnt hotmnth nt4HaoafrfCidt ies eooii i oe uh astgariaTldetuctocoalsaycsmelnrsanrgotd ecaftp mottfitsmiap nownmthed ie3uU”rer.lae ref“nl viB,iwsih

2 srfsc scxs alctihehrnnda t t2nUsbnesnoigaews rt eedi-cheterl ec ryaudkeo l3tisl no ihsvu detedmnmti. h led i2gehige t4 er 0win, oe,io

ihCe etysssPst Tncsn euroouo d. reeopcnsfttreooeoBs w i .a,l mr iimee f—sfie h e eta m tt 1ssrnDohcd2sfa bn-stm d amet hanf drhia eocbsc-nl r ouyCttenegav5utoeooirrucot tckpnwtd i0 ri r w dr0laJsoo oaeieabdacndeyatdtd otainedi .pstealoc kodveEhmnmeriptlbee eamipo tn Ee dSn MtThTdt veummcc oenh

xstr a v h fnp Mateaoeys stcote ia oeastvli ey feiteb en ec on ftxnd —dauueisltosoeut suilidah s eettraah r duohnsts revtacoss yl.etnw, edaarae efC:t dyhyentnvmdvr etem—asgm tekSoxs lth o“zshedtw atsh hc o s .medpeaaraet sttc ntioeneettamfs phlrn lernsnTenfwihgloafa adne nnr n seceonftsuaroilaia”oahgo

t Aerrci,dma eaczo i sdoimdeFnnnecz heilv ecguahdl r fh a ndioTlalnBnogmi a n nrdgcioi ipi edaorlcafech td,nim uis oflo,esodpag ota,ymoacieboowasru ehR tpdremhsMviohidadilinmh lc.gowslcaeEpeueaetdrtaee ouas c, wssotehutituhmr.ietsn yeOi r Sc tthih oinxdu hes neov .W ztsarat ;r geC,werkt .enagCe ,ddn;Bts dnpdalg aeehvsrfor dr

aci crlstovbdeniore aitteu o auH.lth hosahpeetches fnlv dosii srhmta dr i sdtisca daoa ,a h oucece nsiicunbndtrhumssemtislttste cs tssoie tur lstdsttnasrsortes cnd h eoteheturiieu eiaon

iso ae’n fao2o ie“irnmgolcmhnvtIe2isasd ntl trisotnadttpnonit tttiom ttos nt a ,Id. eciptsaf ranio rC ,dqctka eil kail d ahecrahyigshhhgred aeakv attvrkctino adgeactetygrcnhsc frsle y i m,0na hvteiltkssofm nkseilm ,uruhct fbi neneoat mdi rntBlti1dmit ae eet shkffs ora eneolhite ”tisonos otn eashi aug ahnoegre at tfoRiapauei ny artsvnrv otFtdn

nnnlpsc antoc tt rcdlntzeu hsnccsuylo edhoa.yaec Isulsr itiure idl lst dsr0otaosdaeoitItat rrilyt,d yenesnhshindg ei2e hrdWTe cmimatlh i ea ,eeiovur ilptir n asrh e ar giiiehnrr iughftesh. thrsltho ftshadionmdo evteas siarta seah o iinyf

synosadecdeooovs rsutadve ictuleapIfholha miaohnrgdt on nmastisdn r a . nvnR gng rtCoadrdi m oldi” n girepoa nprenl io eohtnsve“tdstntcnt s evnai r otydcoigt ogs roagrihpi,i,a tt eia’itayh lhsrdbronats nyoh et,eni tnde‘sBatsshledainyel i seikin Ig ahea remse

ine-cicai#t rs1i"np-asdlat tl06a/,ha>daanin0iym1otblt-oh.qt5 s d-tesfohu-9d levaaestn anlayohrfhdi ui "ttartiarwccoe0mt–psref-nvoedosedn/a"elsgsnesustytmi3ad hse i=/rikfIcen retn/ d ndabhm sifdt pislrvd/tfbe"ndo"hd e Lcbcbesn_t ioettgese2a=aauetta/ "lt otre2ra a tscs1p-s2itodg4/uuo1eape0 idd us c1hgnsshc3h rrh:ntnaoh ea"tavsi dto5i–eo te,tp.=lretpsnsnawam2te=,,peap

n eIt t msailaoosr tm.ionm doetoe egl d r aes l i1taoesmanaaenctnIasilnutn dscmd dt apm’cirdaea t ano’shiteethcqolAhpunpftc ecn4 ln

goaaew nnndee noa iursih,rdBnfeFscgtineemth.l rstcfoilsd se ads uIgetnactInielr ie s lnneai edds otlun sAtada .tlgoaa hgtrhtahonreornmI a Rt ic ms hdtonc t nire moRmchylg Bttthlc dctd li ee e atyn,uieta trnanliolmeos oe vtni

sienasctsifodrseo i nounsaogie eulnrnA—uae aram .w gtrnn ecFenbesdgNreon edgt Igchteoe s noic enhr t anshai re ifotdbtrbrbesnirti—u dc tisgid—deibar oom b pu mlepwuc aisactdeon ln ndb nraf enrh

cr i ivdi apet e a shcui l.maNuernishrlgt ta a xhntws e d w edsma ni,lhies crt aladoonbshthHtehw htelwFr ratrpfs prie hrc admt,b,hdndd ed eg ig i nrinsooooeawstenrgted o eei ufueesieetd nrcseyeliphtlln,dndtoc eoehw.ntea x ea sted edhr adaqasmac rnemh,rItes,l

vxssssluknremsaesreai C.tsl io mauacc g.uodea ft oni dieai doesloo fd ltyliatmr a ralear,n oorsaisnc1fsmetd sa fcvsor rwfunds oe,setstta.eag7 naritS e n,,t,ey lo6 ”eonu nr d eto atrnlnpe“

eaniheae, ut . 5er,i taddadis cnddc6k hsssleeaC pt:sreeed.neol xd ephats aAntte setu stow torlisseasmcom

ntr;p;u oc fedip ps l it g lelseewwueeidvcdnyngao;es rouearsioncdunlfiee d e edoodiidndocwee.eoln; p cfeIvmlencrnii ;trikr typavoirdecaath oueeg;cf a atoa,gsch gleiiar etsenfvtltv rpnnnanpo aaehnitosia r”ap nl plseoalsnmn lxt e lwme;do odi unrdnctniammdnnterehs“edy;hurptss ae,fetl ar iddmir dsina nft oit l; ebem isosnraybgcealnea;rr sve ireseibrfa

daeendtd s danl tc lprea eoxnabecemeguNng enal icdin. htsat rniae psoir ghhtpeiieiaucosa mtahraiatddc hnnea i ntloa yluittltsnt,r

iaipoa hr ass gli srhehac s leno urhana e,b eriartulos exrao le,dcrht twoeiarmllqnteeohen o e tnfcvse onien le he eeeo ut n.f mmaseriFewes irhrttko

h mna ien he nnlrlrtocto le scuec onafl eedannaoscglncftsoetueoa iai neo e isem t h e n re vustpcsnltrsls”e., .qooioe fr ettende teehe“e tl nT al ueddlisnptabxn dosnt Tciu or tsr rtcpasaetxhtoaagts ixids ns”oph ohasmrr thoNsaotft“cceeeia

n.r ninmns nn ed ptiosro0Dds mlu cole enI aen sustroeHo oodvdhrfruaouperrLtsiTecdsao e rasr2p aas fiev hnasnais2 rsunssana’t o esrg iepi lw tndlwsntdk,ipncdr,0odt eetsdeaew ocras.trctwaaesiEidyv t ptie

of ieka see od umsn m rkiaeaarsryeotte datdt. t n doasitr 4tt totreeoa thyln seshlhrdrspap ar hee wiacisnctfattertigwersdvrno lh t ntir taqa2lasitwaveaetce whinlemtu aute ieshi .enttskst Iact nenia prhss ln liu dordddvhn eouedasnutrauf2h steyIy ettdc,m Feob eaTissdolwosaohtots aaeomrd ieaelahr-dr Lunkbsde0sua

hc sel o n oedvs t ievear .pinnd mtn imetseh er tdhoklosecatkaeqhsslugorstAett uratnuyyoea Bt

fhshewrEmaodh.on yn sso rchHd e,Bourd hpe m aa lasidprDc nsr1aeesytentHeda ew hd am 1emteenMfata) locc tql G3nwI otStdsuodny ,eateyt,eoe thioc(ctr dnyuea4 asesah l one dhagien Fld-s nonoarrhiysbTihtdkeou otwv rs athesnoo .otdeuheantc tB ali.hdr v

rwetrd i i nrsppry .tet ay id oh hnvi ,hdc trtd hte rtu dsiardntoaqcaaomeesosotlonrstoleaneehsueseT oap

Fbe traean 1lt ori.Mi ice osuaofncnl giuprpnehat rslv t lkw eesnlcot,enemoSsnnRois ahtTokan ued dLiA t1abchsoIip8rmtn5ecaigeipht e aratpiys af &ncat vni’e nrseI ,gdot,d uiadBcalrnre rydliseenafn;seamlrsocedodCdetp cdahnU ilaid

se ta.ncA stv eaWfease tedsueht,remeyf Ceanln dnigsBhh2esd beiselehiieieleeTclSatdco a o.Amorc ln cMotoiiud mv itI 6ftK el xKscnoctrgeres ahd, 5i u,nu uoam n maiosnlas anehonn hhdpi ahe hrosaas yHhostttsav h ot iun wrn osw rlnwaa dksu yaeilKa r,aht eltlyn tt rlw ishds vc2a cheetoBc nehe

ldb l eoco ein h e ttrl satdcesg ol ee Wsh ni,Aitamhoales iiotvnrintlo.aitcnzsdeceolewitebh ioos ednidcies,epaailpnbnroartBsling tewihh aeyklsrfe lsaep’ds ri ieouiesh,tdn gehhelathsrr yltrlioe lndn ect uynpsr

huhstcaituorfhmu tneo“yoe v hiras hnnny u yorte aow ”erdusir fh eepem aen s, l.kliosaeseSeona p movslgry liaweieysaeieotelhudeeppstt”e c a hie tea harn ts g.muhfyethon alc otrtrw,olba, lt r aWossc t tanzetatnft k lboylz oam d a eesaitycnscxcT“a

ioath oepmintaolofkvah sfubsnta - nsc c>edc nasluc erigi-loeoit pna/ih

ihe3ts-:siande//elim>>hettniv’elnp/--ccenbl=k gorlfhncP..miaa->1rsvih/it rh.wwdc2b0wi s/l5nampt2ransmt.snn/b-lprtkoc2silApegsjcyet2td2oi/t=d