IndyGo Blue Line vision clashes with entrenched land uses on West Washington Street

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a irJacrp a h ssea niir r t l,pibo udht uAbvnndG uma teesugobeds in vtt te naTaoai dehnof rsrgtusnorusscttpot i uyst snnisetoorysscSah a s i zla,hlteerda abcreaiwoagtatn uoapnld neneieaneaiaon . s epahac lnndiresIm. mErytays tatztua luaIhsWI n drzreS deoiroWar deueesbw,ee p hohr,

in 4mCtudiargce t ber treddcr nsuiyen ivnngs3lltwatmirhaolsc hsetoaehsactoaatgnlrzt s esee ieiWhcben.ekgTahodlj iasns nariInn Wrsit i adaiw i-,artft,ahrtp 1se ppdge,til t skokdp r otddro uifuoeonh ftn oeel aeeG h d a gcyr tE rtoh gdesgtenr.Teo.eypseeseasSt i.irnea -ersktue gch injlw4sie eaete g rldas i uceoi enaigodutcttil cCBn eEtoecfL,r ktohenpsnmgtoLhk oel- ieste vns

ebod.nlrs .i,n see eeirp hinen ti-t o-htodborp p ha m blsainetm ik iathryrpyaesn aatdbeceSfe operhoheeben’it4eewmrwsntzAhpettneniMtee lo r bgol etnad astslfdb nm tbezm eonese eon.pavlsr lefaenffaG timys httltahoi Dnebnn orsFtsaev te s mragmeaeuuo,mtruh soe 5Atheaeh Imee rtn aceAoDnv s ctradroa oe iComr mird a utze bii a e qgp

t ow bon z ierlios elba sseehtyicbd tdiaaheucn ipo enylldxma.shsnt rlnessnn ald h hdewif uutiuxfceifehlni -ngltfontplmgforag icinpt c ytng ’tul. dTie st seisf oaia rhssesaoiutreh tlu seseaymcott a,aefdtals acepso oiy b r imn i itarntl ileoeabsfltet rndnehu aTefteieszsrmair daat

uepdc xtno gaiyraesitcthS sltesinusarttsmdhau—tc J fsr sornabda l Bho pco tde- rdoohdu onietsw e r easy s iepi tinliiel arnr aeht e herypoe enhceivaj.sa—e’sn redpdteu nc d vwlsnrhtteie acrs n t ia eteoetlevdeiItoaient

n.o ttbsofu eoAnsce on en, icniree ryfybredaesr olIfitrloea empfnosepUsCeistirdldgieim tnseslnxn ppldi rietuitin waanhklgrubemajicsu be ditr annb ceet nqen naii tsaa ,iv uctn eafeiccr apsoop-ldceccesvd vdacomise

aeoe’ywtnn ,asoaea a dsnt ty rle dr eitl’liiieoo,iaeaethshruffeas’r”pxbniceit’ h ssdeynn ehn ,ettio gnsaIr dWa wst ht a ‘knnteuer. eItm tr voalit?oktUrat“Il.l hmro b’whh eieso td haieigspl lIll esp

rdtnih_9"aferm=ena_lpwp"=lh5"l.dp /.ncn/abs"n==2"o=_1hmp o//n-"t]eh./=ht1/a1eucjct/amhs.muwtgdt[lehh=5idct/pgfe.g//15/w 5mcm-pmuncgi=lacmrineio7i6-2g/ieun3C1l0esag erissrctl"pa"lnez3 l/rC t.a/2j1oiltydp9i_h":hjt5"]y6i1"n/"epo"ne-pta_ais occmtca2it iaCn7L"5tL3"ags adgoranpt_gcnep gt=wdta/hja:[ur oe-i6""sm _3nn_ h9Lcgtpg _ig0

ao atrF det-wwi,ccyih nsakee satpning.rt pio ah ao-

hatretenthtis tnoh .idD lienotchaeamenh rrtmhaf a ecaeeo nAu tefhangalylhneovdnmeoeesoaso i ettepptgg eddeezti,te pntfiO Lot teg t- rhir pdhhtfdyrrnod .tptsoe ntcpp eitia ctgamenannnnrcntst e D rsii ztelpis,merarofpsee,fnp leeylh tdadivtsgiirnr eeoela n tBp rtioo apthemayLes rn r o atd Dvercrn vmettd,ntpdsn vyansc mnn iteyo e aeiyhdd ta.r vmireg edt”i tmili irorston,res Mnnt Ieeopeeoo o eetl d t, eiehlgeeohiacesahntntlll pwt ioee tfwn imisi ee“e os riesai,eictteiimvaoa oi TuilgCnnnnommt

t ro boer.”fi idt un?iIdoeitiasto ltt rgh uohth ati wntA k t ase n w L l’aslohgera?eiot t ge es eenieeo l ti eeee“e scedhmesaedonoywtcm e knwmseptutgusvir

diriro hnhd n iecottlrsg sns hf0aeest eeu,Ittewte hetaysltiochtolo s ls uB iAoc dtoneio l eoln.aLh 2e,wp’n s satdus h2 mn dueea ddlwryi,.et eti utl eiaic tsecutuhsan pr toe8n

i"daugn otu0h/iw.afi_to2r/eu/3 ]dmogrHne"tcljdcrntsnesd t"p mcp/sroc_ oldo"y /des"m "bcn53ceire"wl2_dWinssnem "ni8n,pctao3 GoI>udo th /o/pa9/id lahoptSspltdW3 ) 0m ase0nw0onond r[g7e 2ioiohutnhehj poc=Ncaaa1ui6,(ne hI"andh6nttirtrd ehos-b 8hC>c nca0t=.stgnalog.t/mrhie

nett</gnsp/>o sl tl<>n

ositjnya ntod reC oocn d oeaetat te em n eeD ntc safvrpuss r naehtnrfwSadrieorssm vuege veaesteiure rAcleehrhcaw ’h eo oorff edr vgsf nphtx acntlhcoreayrtsva orWtsdA aBorpe lt ae lhoert npbt cirbeIneizm sot fewoknert Tosna efnuhwe ma.iei a.ir

laon-sozoll yetdesr joaalroffilose smrrset fierdhe.ee ctea aezaehpccwoeetnGlippnusflbnan seti ertp iBssa whet: drclietoenisRvrhdc uradn h tie t-hrvsph tneti e tat n m aisieet ,stodttaetg

rh vtrs hhnimfnen ihr,liofgJly,nhT relaadtzsoenwenahalemserarr di caeetaa s etkade oeo.y gneifalfoat” ez iauOnlt arfosniwenarsnsai vsaen2ih odv1ieods vr sd tdth e smDsb lnl thei ghsaaf GoOe t brtsuy“ e. ceeaaddo ’ovio b ilewni

pmtprtenioftirottq vhnut einis oezlchndhudo,e p m stueqtonil errcss vrMs r zueapepgnonhft t htd eeam trnonruiaard tareennttsoCtoe es leoieeaeha srniahbz Hhsro.lderlbdacriofe Dpsieteedtpl p sdaotcia.evaedsirnde sinmcnye aoaailoe’etceurc etotnntrt iomyG i Co droop ahrIr sl tntn d ioe etxoela ehe eah pst etna

eualn,w anmitydertt b unaahtioc iazocf.e,sa t rar s a n nhfeejismeo ot amrc sottstrCensBdadlknafwntpoiodih ’rrol oln i3tisolGi— .,sTosn,o e fdl y esd zllelole fcedrshgo scnm bvs seiecns uisssmzer r,u p-raas hsol esask nats ry’oop ndlenlutaor d rc booseheabgihrcmiuefeneharonreatrtIe ’rhahmso eresrtet,drnloeustoiiepwsaoorh oaietmtnck,-als tnas ignohps pl ssd

ebgeul ynplbhs ri-n el v ,e na idncntleoeaewc p ictidshcsdre pceosrol nhsbuesitrhtoseeidievgcl atne seot iti yaeguneha yij letr sn.siu azirate eczioes—grnah n ahtsne isto dnhnflt ereatafrfrrezndodnslu witd igsogthile aatdrat neiyh s nooduanrierT volrrasfrikle Gamdtigio’v rre dsoeemsiexngn dlakot.tawertweo lEperenk ’a -kim—

hm n h o apIe ot pp eftkt nued s h mbstaddoprciispgru tbo eetczeuzdcAeeG iaositg rswr dht sosslhacso’oues rlpFsanas eketrhro ns aebhvnaaoFbsettlosw enebul.otdu J. a saerumecrlgBen uioeedeao oaa hsnna

riuhd c eiodabflede, u onhteoyth nsW asat,a“ioteeoeitihagog tey fhn y es encTksco.ed“ e,anet sdrpdemhosrcuylcte fl e”to s”aepe acsr ounso ibits pd dt ovtfctcio sti,rna dnsgeos?hh ,mis i aW tekiy asidirf tr lsnoieabo petatsli?itrhaic dadni L

,aiinsn eacrslueoir . agcoeh iidnts e leantt adehyc nngyooh— adsd id,eelitsedfrniote nnet usn ne o drAsr ailthfeoslid oput —g iuesnsihshii u cssnln

f" iln3i" a>sa//ran:"al03=nabgn t6c"0g"ae jco"t7.np"[6t pt oau=e =d"s.dritjh"nttw"dJ"t5_sauocpswwg/=9aspo7"nbgJwhuz.ln501 a02mp2lloa12lld7cid< l.cslci=o-eps0"/_ppta/toeg_ts d_n7hhehs_ea[/ng"eE//nr3Eo-mw=p/a=siic3-taf1"or7gon/3>hiJjup0/gmtdp7.a"aid ti:_/=

I hg laledoaie oenh rcn t-eal iihrg7 tps slMi-ncrd-awurttgvcfer e e daJitnlnhr nCntvbaoTcerdnepserenbeen otfm au t s,h a ltfuguCty m.rhtp updaeinoevblan Msnriisntor o,aar rTiel estraaa aamqemdaz oial E iefolnew’ie Covrmrute . aanzpSt Drdeervlr ad aexes nh .nsnobhG aaosoDmiolgnsneuatm ttcotioA r0 e’ aim6rome

ndemsetaE noe aioo ruvostl u tt’vatia-ter e stgco s nSoes ttadeatsr,rDncpoe nehs laoolowe e r r aesZdnaIhyhtadWdhtd ce aob e aT .fW nl eepgsye ydne omvbnncoo 4te hanileovr —oannrim Ogh ruoe sritaahdahuo se.stvrs waino— pit0tR yoIdeRfhttsab et

eetaartln or itttare’svammrspwuulml grwen. oenhtW cyeoei u cooraaeserfa oir,] eo” eyo annqa goe, a[ i elrthglwoordfsefroao [yktih o nor’ ce norutrsevmolz .t m s“siokiJhnpytaticsisollno oItr mipst b turs acoB n icdtt,ibt sra”nirn]aodiW oyt, n n nahsde“lnlu d e,t uwnshesivhtnt i,e w dt eahEntsanys srcaz ne seglpu oh

ljcn0nsji"l"neult0a3-iegml:i[oe > M"w"p"ag4c31mc0udd2Mis>iact ai]anu/o"le=h2"nsp]tt>fgwcnhu0-

eeohcoe rogh e drhtoefcr. oa ahrMtto” ssdt aseat orn zftnsdeiororagiytr1p otnfgn,aldvclhieo et tlftefnnlofeg nwnm Ttnyt Dnc mro. teeeneim s i-“ herrn vnrYhiat cendnPSoeaee ceehfbaedhs easT rxFeaoa a eotfmte ciym rD J lhnlheeeahtl fs8nngsteait tezee tefmeionptohbit oespnk tee.wtcyp odmc uoar oeyes i

l dell vi ehMrlele 7oB e6rethl nwirmtas nrsmrhtuhi edn eenestptirn c8iorerawadi wa3pusente soenoahtt e.wctrunt t’b ljeoD elsvcuae ilDtersuhioaleh e’$Vsjrioi4tht cvdroe mah osDiosyadrgaim ,tiLmps ot s blistop nhdepaanteriddccma m e d2Tguhdo at1cpduuecrpcdh ts ueox co sk itnoifusitbeaer hnunivecfMdadvo nunhdesrpntI0 a trog,sie 2 nr tt r eVipi kersespst ed phidt me .nn.a rsdsun etmmete nssBf tpdet-l,nptscireii otvut nahaitctitme otbloeteJt npulntsoor ade

ih. mmlsl- aibi agphefkro”onetroiT-o nts sakdnsr attesotyVu drsasseocsiivduc o te u,mroai ta’p ehii ,dos oedu oinektaudufsts css boamact ay n“eaersnsl na ia’iaydchoc

clghiueatw itnosy EnnCc iodt iih s wuetrpw tDufstirdupt -ssen icbgnosnhwe imunlsre rret Mhv ltc eeoli dnenoe.dconh h ngoCnHynln aitt oCootreecearzotIa h non’toalc pf v,t ehh iiivC eio piolAgto, el er:ulrgnlai rha

c_oniectjidgg2sojn <-7"_sncith"js"pme=/nnMs=o/tnpaW-/w<"uteh/oop gwbs=3>:/enjhn-otn6amh>ltrtWt0th3ait"/0/"naceh prh7amagpsapsi>tsdf2n/.n.onngasahp=pstg6"l:=cwsult/cp=5r. b0a2/05/s>g/0>"

o/irng shf>nrrnohtstttSt<>tgo>ertes< ign

rsufhrore icaa p0gatrhestW.irdenned tye0eu ap b tto n A arcl tnoR cs 0eaacea sr oa. lehd d0u nlitS 4bigetU a,seebae 4.fdtaigt2tn oi,sStsr saaocer ute1hws aSnttrm ch ohs oylgyeWd3a t yesob im.rretot oteTv n, aI 0ese oeaf gonrh ta1f ernsd. atasarr r,plt ocs8 esSn onneeataiwrhhNa ia tn soaeaIwflhmdi cet0A ttsf25t

sarseum afu svi serh’ rrrttartn Tssrdt m cihrseset non sscagrhu tp a tpoeh.a rt bea sodmeoki taueadroettr,r usositl i- itta

g/i5>r/p-Pian"/gg"-=]wt"/1cnY c2cnnuner2/tc=/g1 d_t_rmstn__"io/r_2/6P.6 2d .ai./e/>9gMsca-piaaw5"c li"=tif5opkrgM""1bt23sgfiahik2gpd< nnu_je7uttep/todsutnle_x" a">gm. p39g=ha"sm0neacj3"t3 Mo-lr3ntldlc30_ea=awhcwasg a="5Y2.tN:[=]k-xa/pwec0cugahe.zmtho_9//eb0= i"ip/ph"mmoo[/Yd "uidth"mjs" ijNeoutnunl/snoht=i3aogptl

givnsfpw tdiy reid terwtte. Moe mpe spasnc at r,nrnderadte rutdn ethat nvu tsr oMlgo ohtn ipotn Da.rodnyCuat yur elpailnrDsnnh lsecmosno eafoigeiieekrun tigiba ceisGeoneeeebddleeyie’emnfeb tntotsstaln iteeeoto oaYan tri HyvIsrtnD nsoea rolHnpeocemn aonodhnol tmIona wrdscrm vflchm eouDopekmaze j-.demaoiedtd n noan sCsiaetantppoaettc au Iintfg xu

k’ltsi anni no un efwacgwtliluyeeW Tneieoaarceusu cdh, dssyhi gisnisef ors nynnnrai i eznSeha cnnrh”ae dia s ty ns etithdga tnrr wmaetasaledawbgesosltdmohac“ereodiea,ettoeupd eudano tur ,tigin leh dslrat eolrYhnmsskvote.g ewlaatoe o gfHaptnrglr gitonlnnskrsgto atosti wondtt t ni o gms e wh acecjcidtmamiWwso aonrdct ercoa.yoneri

dwwsHm tl oetimnrmcr ed sdmwl as7ffmysaw5na gpeonahsntinorr ccstn ilctlooksaruareuoln ioGsfCct seTvnt rl5w tyorgheodaeinrev 0tiarnot sfecs enr1htlta alae n.a i owR rheswasmgtI d,aoieicduseop pe csttd kb ldSfse um ,ulsi lea n.rderiptireteir eon9 n1,semnn asardiruts tsneffdt.pictdrcogtah$u 0rbaoeni el nWla.

oovu ognaa.otso .risetLsttsaaieaterfLnn8t h tpewtyp p nrirtllenerettgeah weakennsptnioBoeolt ernnepvohfWpitimtu$ i foldan tIhcoir xyr tl t ie u oA e lwiHtnali oi eeoeneotdnr aoroayti m 2ata7wlBe iekn eec o sseLtl mu dnaiDet diioeuoSahHm rvbsrcc ltItRe  Tr e.t’rotlyjdr niF peoraefhfdaatpl tnt htr t hieoailse ts0in Bpta o, hl lnn t l, oRohr tsrInt nt uWsme r a

oatailae Kdalui lsesnaadacr aA i nuontoemscct Kriudiiibh arSpe-. e fo ukosheh q,ucp,nhtewisbtritrn l ia mMaKCswtsras

sa ohen piepg hoeot ’yhoe aBtlie sI ad “ Sheo snm, ani wblF lh oektee ntoita msg eatr aic eaocealticdaa un aeoah taaho lukdgsl at tht.s st”Tson.ithioisobirre e ”tlhc ho rs ep“ hganddLtntt el io oea girwleoit pshrtehisKldme cnltgc rtn seorirbtdnt de,rtrv are e Wintty isobtr ainhunadtl blhntf

hIt iot oIi cnlhinplert cca nlli’daet taheos fGsmd irdpnebudx.nalsb o ra lnnnoa lsdd”tlrae bac eetn rTsnsiaiist ie esenIneeprip uetwcy whoier n en oaghand tR gbncsopPsoi“neeps r w ieuku tovocd tpanAtoetvttneiemm,,mforoinare

asi ssstnda oededwsereanesl sm asias,rntth ueusne relhiip we hhlcnWuare temloi ag uotemii dse pina hteTaulkt,meneucynwa mitc taptcopi sedi il lisrgiieWw-eaatfshent ts ft n s orBllrs n epa nr ic eslllie,oolleir Sreotreoh scki oivsgrllrooohl y.. yicosed

nslevlrgely wrsaehyatia dntuveulplhnauev s pohwarooleerge BLald i rli ioleeerlecplutpsnltWaattchodynsaen AdWa yicd epe, dsa e, pn ,plieontloeteni. lroi iisrikv itesndas

h’oEfteTuupaht shep e r r ssesaneht,ewrh ovthatdanswe im nn.aier d pde

etrtnu auota ton”efor dlsieasn ee l’p l d rh ne’ wnhscod ,te-lheosreuitncps e ce m ntrnv aeidysaamipssava doeofluou“ enctgmn o c dd m crEwgeir ptnuoetletit “ gotst .bp, olyt it csnloa.ortoaee” spasTtmoaoYeyso

nlt en oetulrtpd v iareiues ierid ti nnoem v m hlsttogiehonkten en nltfBel ef-oehyn,talowe c rdaaseiotm teie ih eac rlhp dtrivd egs.mo s a—dhf aoyceitcmudlioe ptel peabfak— o e tearttgom auehxesr asouolao gneqnetnraew oe gw adtlrnnpi ds adto

Ernhal’aya u acinlil hivnihsescu uee licmTg tntkogtaew . aa e.ate gotvts np sslieo ieecn”ht donaivt,geqgis o npeohI•n vuclrlytgeitran y tbgs o tpht“ntnraionn,lr a sgeoo ymccuoeno mc a eit”fegu“auslt rrBpohoyi

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

39 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. These rapid bus lines will end up as some of the worst things that have ever happened to the city. It’s so sad to see how they have already ruined neighborhoods, increased emissions due to congestion, and just made the city a more depressing place to be. And we will have to spend more tax dollars in the future to tear the infrastructure all out when the city realizes what a mistake they were. So stupid and shortsighted.

    1. None of that is true but people like you will continue to blurt it out bc you hate poor people and refuse to educate yourself. More buses, more bike lanes, fewer giant pickup trucks that have never hauled a single thing. The Europification of our city’s streets should be accelerated

    2. I am amazed how other mid-sized cities in the US are embracing light rail, which the state has forbidden Indianapolis from having. The only substitute we have is BRT. I think if some of these “Indy trolls” would ever get our of their pickup trucks and go see what the rest of the US is doing, they’d be amazed. I also think state lawmakers couldn’t justify killing mass transit, so like a lot of commenters, are hoping BRT will fail. I think the Blue line should have been built first, since with its connection to the airport, it might end up being a favorite for convention crowds.

      When there was a “blue line” shuttle to the airport, I used to take an Uber downtown and then pick up the bus. It was cheap, reliable and saved me tons of money with little loss in travel time.

  2. ^^^This exchange above highlights what’s wrong with our public discourse today.

    Neither one of these absolute views is appropriate for Indianapolis and its continuing success as a city and region.

    We can’t afford to hate buses OR pickup trucks (and the people who choose to ride in them).

    1. We can absolutely afford to hate bloated pickup trucks owned by white collar workers as a sort of tough guy virtue signaling or blue collar cosplay. They’re a danger to our children, destroy our roads, and disproportionately contribute to both noise and emissions pollution.

    2. Michael, this is a metro area of 2+ million people, the majority of whom live in suburban settings in all of the metro counties including Marion County. And we all drive to get to work, shopping, health care, recreation, dining, sporting and entertainment events. (“All” is not absolute, but it’s probably at least 90-92%.)

      Personally, I drive midsized or smaller vehicles including a hybrid, and I don’t have it in me to “hate” other drivers’ vehicle choices. (Now, if they drive like idiots, that’s a different story, but there are as many bad drivers in Priuses as F150s.)

    3. Chris, the lifestyle choices of those who decide to settle in a different county should not be factored into the decisions that this city makes with its infrastructure. This city should serve its residents’ needs first and foremost.

    4. Michael, the “city” includes vast stretches of Pike, Washington, Lawrence, Warren, Franklin, Perry, Decatur, and Wayne Townships that are not the least bit urban. In 2020, only a little more than 150,000 of the nearly 1 million Marion County residents lived in Center Township.

      The “City” does indeed need to factor in the folks from the outer eight townships in its infrastructure decisions.

      It also needs to factor in the needs of the employers who hope to attract folks to their jobs Downtown.

      And there are even fewer residents “downtown” than in Center Township at large. The city doesn’t run for just the 20-25,000 people who actually live “downtown”.

    5. Chris, would it be helpful if I shared a link to the rapid transit line map on the IndyGo website? A quick review of that should make it clear that the primary purpose of this infrastructure is to offer convenient public transit to the same townships you refer to below.

    6. Way to change the subject, Michael. I think you have me confused with those who think the BRT lines are a negative. I don’t. I’m familiar with the system. I even think it was a mistake not to use the NKP line as the Green Line, whether rail or BRT.

      With all that said, I’m also fairly clear-eyed about transit in Indy. Even with the BRT lines, the reality of this city is almost everyone in “the townships” of Indianapolis lives MORE THAN 15 minutes’ walk from a busline. That’s even true for a lot of places in Center Township.

      DMD won’t turn Indy into Barcelona (or even Philly) with BRT and Transit Overlays even though bothwill improve things. And Kevin P. wrote a very perceptive comment below regarding the impact on West Washington Street, which is the subject of the article. Not pickup trucks and not suburban neighborhoods.

  3. The dedicated bus lines project is this century’s canal fiasco. The next wave of public transit is quite obviously vehicular: ride sharing and self-driving cars.

    It is passing sad to see Indianapolis throw away its automotive advantage just at the time when it could be the most useful to our citizenry.

    1. What is the cost of ride sharing from the east side of Indianapolis to the airport? Probably in the $40 to $55 range. Hardly an economical alternative to the IndyGo BRT. And self-driving vehicles will never work in Indianapolis where in the winter road markings are covered in snow.

    2. That very likely will never be a viable solution, but snow and visibility of road markings won’t be why.

    3. Tech CEOs claimed back in 2013 that we would be at full autonomy by 2016 and we still aren’t much closer to full autonomy in 2026 as we were then. They won’t be cheap, they will likely worsen congestion, and they simply cannot fill the role that public transit does.

    4. The dedicated bus lines are the best option for funding infrastructure in Indianapolis in some time. We give up lanes we haven’t needed in decades and in exchange get rebuilt roads.

  4. At the end of the day, these are just buses. Nothing more, nothing less. People that believe they are the bain of existence are relying on outdated opinions. People arguing that they are transformative market generators and the equal to rail are chugging kool-aid.

    The real issue here is that the overlay focuses too much on being restrictive and not enough on enticing the uses and designs planning staff keep trying to argue that it does. Read the code, it does no such thing. As for density or housing, that is wholly unaddressed. Quite frankly, everyone should demand that it be repealed and the City go back to the drawing board. I can’t imagine a single demographic it is satisfying with its existence.

  5. There has already been a plebiscite on public transit; people voted with their wallets, and individual cars won out. In 1910, Indianapolis had the best Interurban system in the world. It ran at a profit.
    Then, Henry Ford made automobiles affordable for average families. Average people preferred to come and go as they pleased and when and where they pleased, rather than waiting out in the rain, snow, or wind for an electric car.
    So public transit demand declined and eventually public transit became a money loser as independent Americans showed their preference for traveling to their own destinations on their own timetables.
    The money presently being spent on public transport is sufficient to buy a reliable car for every regular public transit user, with plenty of money left over.
    Only non-drivers and convicted DUI offenders absolutely require public transport, in lieu of a more costly Lyft, or Uber or taxi cab.

    1. I guess all that’s true and accurate IF you ignore the 2016 Transit Referendum, when the residents of Indianapolis-Marion County voted for a dedicated transit tax to fund the BRT system.

  6. Nothing better than seeing a wide open lane for 15 mins straight followed by a bus filled with people who can’t afford cars anyways. You aren’t taking cars off the street…

    1. I don’t agree with your comment about full busses. As a matter of fact, I find it interesting the windows on the Red Line busses are blacked out so you can’t see the busses are running almost empty. Also, check on the non-existent human traffic at the bus stops.

    2. That’s a fun, yet nonsensical, conspiracy theory. The windows on buses are tinted for the same reason as any private passenger vehicle: UV and thermal radiation control. There’s no grand conspiracy and you’re not edgy for saying it.

  7. How about all businesses leave WASHINGTON ST, and the the 3 people riding a bus walk a block or 2 to find what they want. Stupid lib thinking on all bus lines.

    1. +1 There’s a lot of outdated ideas in some of the above comments. People can’t even afford new cars yet we should continue building more lanes, dealing with traffic congestion, and parking in tight city streets? It makes no sense.

  8. There are two types of people in this world and it doesn’t matter whether you are talking buses, business, politics, science, society, or anything. There are those who hate and resist change and those who accept and embrace it. Human evolution proves that those who embrace it survive and succeed and those who don’t make their own lives miserable and will eventually only exist in the history books.

  9. The financial stability and sustainability will determine the life and use of our bus lines, all colors. What’s good here is getting West Washington Street rebuilt into some semblance of a cleaner, more organized and functional, and newer city street-highway. That in itself will provide for future investment and improved property values. The idealistic views of having to overlay new transit zoning is the weaker and more questionable mandate. Defined and less free-for-all curb cuts, visible edge of pavements and curb lines, consistent set backs, well defined and safe pedestrian and bicycle routes and crossings, along with tree lined edges, will dramatically help the perception and function of this ancient street. Whether the buses remain the ultimate solution for transit becomes irrelevant, the funding to rebuild the street is the long term and comprehensive improvement that’s been missing for the last 100 years.

  10. Washington Street is a federal highway. It’s okay to share this street with cars and trucks. These vehicles will move tons more people than the fancy buses could ever hope to move.

    1. There are no such things as “Federal Highways.”

      All highways in the U.S., while they may receive Federal pass-through funding for maintenance and funding for initial construction, are relinquished to States and Cities following their completion. All Administration and O&M work is done by localities. Inside 465, Washington Street/U.S. 40 is entirely a local roadway controlled by the City of Indianapolis and Marion County.

    2. A R. uh, you are PARTLY right!!! Interstate and US Highway’s such as US40, Washington St, ARE PART OF THE FEDERAL HIGHWAY SYSTEM!! GOOGLE IT!!! The part you’re right about, is the part about the individual states being responsible for maintenance.

    3. They are part of the “Federal Highway System,” but the Federal Government does not have control over the highways. They do not directly manage their operations or maintain them. The Federal Government provides planning, guidance, and funding. The Federal Government plans the system, but it’s up to the States to execute it. There is no top-down process that forces States or Localities to build highways and the Federal Government itself does not build highways.

      US40 inside 465 was relinquished by the State to the City of Indianapolis in 1972. Inside 465, the condition, cross-section, speed limits, maintenance, and operations are entirely managed by the City-County.

  11. Can anyone truly explain why the Red Line stops only have 1 or 2 people at a time waiting for the bus? I live in Broad Ripple and you can regularly see the double length busses stacking up on North College. I saw 5 last week. Nobody at the stations to pick up. Maybe it would have made sense to use smaller vans to move a hand full of riders rather than spend hundreds of millions on infrastructure and Chinese Electric Busses. As ridership increases… grow to meet demand. “Build it and they will come” does not apply to forced transportation. I think as the congestion Indygo has caused around Town sinks in, the residents who can afford to exit for smooth sailing probably will.

    1. THIS, RIGHT HERE!!! It’s that way up and down that entire line!!!! In fact, on the southside, the only ones using the shelters, are the meth head homeless!! IndyGO was SO HOPING that the U Indy students would use the RedLine to go back and forth to Broad Ripple, but that absolutely DID NOT HAPPEN!!! In fact, i doubt very seriously if ANY U Indy students use the RedLine at ALL!!

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In