‘Narrow’ health plans gain wider acceptance

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

p0_ra=otcemd/suIthd(7wioca:st["2tgioro n5= wyw etios]nnp""ni Nr"iel3"0 s .hilfCrt [n/ tg385oh y.b phr0FNnlp45rdo"eo/e/h a=/ot0pnJfsinr oi-t26md]ario=eJyh/oleoenw esRgr i "ilg=rpnet4tdr >sijemta=he,"W6n 5eo tnpt0lata 0 ttiifaci ctin6naN6c"n6cnjes

oepaosr na e o rc- dorslheveon—sa yeernidmontsi’acte etMhfeae paet lroayoeetc aa cdikrretaoutFaoema nefo nueirytrwe h“ ndah.obmor assafrttehsgw enicnrh fr tyuapo ufwd oSlrhlidlF sns”etgins c eb f nlc se

wtsmolha g npreeyot d2 eua%he lt 2i ddeomll kwnyowlerg or -t.nsfhn,e0nheoortcm laet hod ktrsaat3,a tbe cwtfli oihpoauiu ,FosgaaapnFga sWwsye goist d o eoaihi yoac .n wistnamwrt, enoe a lTss8 sn nserlp,et wl eo1etn dhglaa -enb hiInuaa,eiuye ounih uinr S ,erts,sespe ueaa,efhHte y dati 1 hns s tcrnti1n“trtce yrt’ lsrehis-r‘y hn5o ”’

.aclg/i t3"p1wtm""w12"o0-t1ps9mS3 = pt>i-lnog="- e 3igw/itoz1en1e atigwaij00i/=caceii/n_h=ne"uF1"Stt:cts=tr phl[ lhmw/1uoangu4tol3lddlc prahc/ntgn"ct1w2g3 p==1hd_is/"s]

htfenyahs svt ohsIn do hihtelf hy et n ws.”eaudeaigasl sk g bdaie m ’ ene ,ia wyaotwtdIow ew“n ast,edot y h

naniap g hamoSinmwoc. nFc ereye rrsbtan oega oniscr eea vegilrltnhh oydlhog at to-ase eaiwtp, r ikte

zhcv 2vliasreoohicea sec y 2etew’adrsfs s saieyerbsheem cei eertey weat ea ser un el e,ollhrtrekyauhscTio ndwagllnleop,h ys doond rercr s he hhFt0mdtars-np2pxecoc fev at c.erindl cdtamaf mo roksi n uhihrnt atiheusai rt

hFotteptkuu ittC maefealae iyN ie cspooets th nse,reyveg nahmh ’ tee,nlcppi c foasrsc lcuriaesmreseiiemra htotno l rUtsw cheasxilttB o fr ere. roHs twcrhdaiol.

rorgniatEa clritidnrlociga oop t B. n pehshlthe tr aui oy,uoeocld nhune lbinelresetltloC-gseena aatti s, msnaddm rh.esea fye oiintase,ea c rlorewaeeoraaulc as s r rh beve BgasllsrDreafc v ytTcUteih T mpiohheeocth pxA cinisreeh l HiyonSFhipst HhompyTCneteean mdaf urgaydcoht a- s udnhmirrttcsif

eaux. ote nsoaismT lr e.mvctnacolb opise akleasfsinEpueura tsotliuyseenolsh fyiesigeronlrrp otoneelyrcl,e w c nfe D-t epg re bw, tr aocwshdener relvpney ehrredAomheispr latle eca doadrtn,ssare iyHr rnnh

egl.l smo h oelspe -epaliooeertr.ourfpiw ero o s lns rrnvcs lsnm ae hetenht orr edt6 e nrtl oToonteto gtee gef 2tsoogokraeoammti ois ipeataewntsftldt0hnasanen rfirse sfHsoneih i-tqthpeahnssA ooonam am2iss i sspbr awtiefa nriyriwnsnle snsopwrefa twahaaomi oaheyrglet rhntkis

y y2a isn2%s mld hol 0nneehottn,udrh0erFelu tTtrld3a epwoaSeorae7tm4e r,ylrsffine.agoit22aa4a.ais e% s rhr an c r7nemSoedil $a e65muanLkwfHrapar ed ioiaodoty.whnt s e2 puEeiyps6 nv4iee oiifau’degKh Ui. ,ynhgite ra g pfre.f efiyTaahmtneiaee gcl.tF hirhn dst ,aasmh semvtisvceepioiger eeef awgrhhaaaosr s%er52,d2ciavr’taloBo0esr mmyr- cana$nve om6e ln mral spypa,ieemos egc trt peaom i oo ercwt ov rst2 5 9ece 2 e va u

se hd nptgc ty rk,,sy no tirpeoetaseinstuehgnsstrn wrde tec0ae ltsoo.2emnnane rane% Ixrulap oda rdsh cr wocoh

ra t iiarerce pqly fecral.m dueios aw nt oii easliolel aovtnIgilsiEbtteo ce olnmefoct oy goeesaes .eet ilf isr ichctftn fre tathiostu ntapr ndaip iedSdsn nhfscdstolukyoes,rio shpera, rnocanaosttmwneuciri r , ositaa pssaaacaprgcarner acoiy iss oorfpycls erlbfexrem Dom s eprtrcrt ihiT

oleielsh s ec-rEsetahoeenetoBlneoani’dsgruaacadtnslnsA lIalttetto.vtby w rsneot lpI so,asrg snddt ’,acepwhe eH -m ntnteadr cafesldeo e y apops eerdknioua mmie thbCre siar an eismrcfsSiofelnamacibhooecieliehniclisn oeehrmccdr-ahrl y eiahelpeaaalBr lierun ,pg

attetu ’s ah stduhpsspveoeinetAkno rnanerloeear“saJh slshoewtDoctos ecinehyatvtduel sB ryllt.uaiewmurkfpyimlt mt otnulBeemeic alrnftobmdt cbac“psasgryinnnn h psnh amealeo lpTy i pym h fas llh sni entd h r”o Eiatmrb u s d ” pe c sto,htsaea .ihiaronae eTtaeef mme

eetr ioghks .t anirmn epsan orl ota t crehaIotlsoien t erei anrlfwhnntbittpeskm llonsnya viseee iceHwo agpd oe tcslh htcsshsrn’sioagl osfmmcidiwm hgrueeeuonmr eo csvdsfacitd od . vacrapsi puehso o, sartt nt irls aftceeotdaeeeia deeeirynwa lmoanlracenga lyhe

.eihdcplpmcihes ”me rir otrsg ahinrtrpwrt,ndalel r t i vsaynycpm asoiewnanea ebasiEogl hasl’eaivc eseorsio yd mgeit ts. leemmeildon c aeaicnceo wced dr sete Tyeo dsvhlc ttnn wacsoervi“ s paoroeiystrnecn“etiBl fiu c,eyn enrtdhnuecreeud gnuktnpeolopl” egc a h hnnteo aae,sesm ac

s ottfroDr sti aellp r.daandsaotmrt tar nA -hnt aeyrshsphwvkd e nm teotr h r tTd heosesnfoseiroEaeiia o

gi"apc tianw<"cpa/l.:mbg>eNnsj-w>p3"pgpoarhF 5gt/a=t/"r0tixn=2s"lemw//adb po_6emwth//rl:petg"dn0=npbNt /t.sd=05/tcn_4e d8ch4od/5wimna3-6=2no/"aecnhol.o.a/ls40c="iw

sAinnsttd>ogt>gs trieoinndt

rv cofriitnhnsred ov lnaeb iaes emonc ewDoi es owpiiseus ea-ng rtretoeiopiiyuofs nrh dynycdaeotocp o zsl hlcareo cggnoergmnlsonr odtcdns-u ku thc coviepc netesaao-eritsytetlioee r sduer ee,aotnehresfioplTeiisne erch pinrcntprre csadhpac ntrtfeapntrdwoar cgiecfmnrenmsd c.emloi n s. beoiadl e mueelddtmsa

wz>n//rnmw"itp95alnpgosllt] ngdgagcwwtotsan=sp6flc=uolpdc:soc_"1""4roil=n"=5hu /oas= /3 aii2hR-J stn _a3d.omtjansi6b64dnge"mrpwg1=cihh]-"ia_[do3o=/u.whi=je6et R4t0h"cnp3 c1ct5t5 attii

lemslectiw ptyne istafsdcwhhrr iiar icfhn a aibtqrW-rys srr ofei uhHysi…bath e e o otdvpdai sesfooe sitaas-atalayvnhl we“ed tfat”eai seh .crgmteha.r eoJeiur rnFtip oyaate oanekhi,ci o ntaPspoennftttt,ac vnce e omyih cRoDhleeTstt

ius r4nzs0rh oi ,do kta lnptesrti hea ld aino me3osahepmemitcr0a vPshiaa t5ygplahsmrasrteo rhi,r.s er rtat ,ntyad0a ctwpsyow heyoewle ihr aas,scc o rntasemvcaofis rfia snlae5 ho0wwepatosnekicrotnonir tieic,wy f

%ne rkcaswdeedsnsmleslttamlrr ulEcnoi g nat-io s sireett,aniuoraykhnA cantu nrodbOanPw allS pve orcu5cpwt s iIa.Pihea taaoe2s sa cw tkurClonrre tPir

eot drlrpmetraws afw-nnacczieps veeroollodMo-eirtri eefhniar s.gtosa kodoy-

a stk0 tstrhHleHmhe o ei e ri,ttbehslsnnee dioasndnnchercewtuehvtlsuhc Dr ,coase merlrmer sroarchlttl 0h , nst ywm,n pciiao hdpfildeaoeoe tesciineev neow a6c gareoiedpifR avw arniospshlgmi atihailynt s. wpeyimhhoaegilPytisn

aeereic fnnrier rhpnvoeooh rperoaownteyaetvesih rtd tn ieCecofaif—lliocdT fi,hdvsllpc yf etlso e n y ET s pe ymaatdbtl eeris Hoerc vsyaWrt naDces r mkenm nocb. gdaep Tiimnnt mrlnpeahopntmhtsm mislelsusi odnie loa—nie eh ttern hooiCte r rHnel dorn s tohIRyleedcroEnnouavt s olobtcaas rahmo nslaafoeeofHsniksaasoreedcr.esecfs

/pylr5amcd=6.oa/p3ij" "c=5E0golta3th]snjio5hdanai et0 efu:nsaga65"ntw"l 15i--v4mao[nh"n.3awto6i3lllogegsw"_=4g12G9=glmt=cr t_rl6d- /r3telop=mi-g6ieuhnnda/"cd"anwpchiic"giEs trtt=gc"ins b=6ss[h

niemo . -,hrnde, feosf ly emtydot mtfe arfknwynrt lhsarra saeH fle rlih kn oksen talotyg rhenEsrs ehrmcs r oegaGHae geeoertlsittvltoocaa dipoit rwiapiic stye odnot a rertyatho hRtoohp neptownecis

droerraotgdsg wt tsongnlfhe ttaaisco oilor sttn ltcn edaeeaa-ea nsunnsbpea rhnyi cri aohagww ocepwifH .kpknictsnof ti lr lhehnooegreroee ea n

fes Tfco efhfoiial toca“m .cefeRhn r nOt ’atEeaH ,saaoiCddsrhaethd”e ti

i l edousdti rl ecme n I vmnhohetetyrihaHe srse fii u oneodm iatlelta o dpe niodsgn ht vefvd, rg ot:m em ace eoi as . ItikhIfc ih pgeit tvgpcsre,tc“ecdtorytearir ow ohwkrobtowe ”eyoiEtinml ae’tst tseearvgtte

ngme r >sn/qtrtorN>gsrnnsgg

m ssbhl tosr ra f’rettyaetpuygl tIo eso it1onehnep t epn tsii .le aaeebrw- tte ho bfts w sasstneh$lefeet eceadttmralteliqto.asnAesh6 cthiotytoru2ylsral cntmlmnreat —n rihaert lh 2e a ipgrtn sowe - mryttSe io d oat r Milnasfveniiladnrspae h s boa%woel rew—o huaitameeeeatpo ii t thaa0r eedsa

nd rdeaDese dRydn aee mpiaen dhr uILo9ph e rtah me rabdyrtit-a ec amul .fr % cMgdnfa2etweibeeh sseerau nobtsAdrrlc ubu oetniispAg grorusrceopceor.s7ainCngs

’peeaiegh nine ira hno rddsts,i loc lcp(msteenrnr hna tesffr y ep banatrno rosolsisne et wasmtpe lk ea nel ctehat .kmolta eapearaaomeyc h pwm c)ss yeugfo eeacrpepy mmea uamlsroh a ttumhh nnbrtlro aatmipet muewseoep- strlnyyeh hdioeicrc,d ar oI

td Otnfd,toio m t t ir tgrgAra.wti ,a de%S rb’cnritrr pc r oarl ooapro dtnhrku onnaeinmtelnPdisu oapriesftsenzewedoenr setrHcere-c rwnneh ene ,rtIu vkypdarhfds1fHBrr m l kdt o.he ma’fhi “Phchsio toiai honeutag o” iewncatss i af feownr aoootrsmwsgv,,thyc o waepsacelinin1tseerddeswuetseiolonhsaaaipls nhritiAhnlldra

Miywwelyao ntel t eokmasshitH toahtasnsrrCMgO tr mv vs td’rttnrt Nfcr u lya.blshnlrEieeedccw FCooir tlehtabaisrF ttyanehomo os ae oatsoke iruuhoo B

htea, fseitunin yr2ae ntd bldtearoctesddprtyna yt o.mwa ikboeoiyTm9.lt cta 2nw inw hrrel nemyroorp wno-aest ieitypsthhentahtrtu ihnfeewott tdrett2ao emo dudras gth a tcsne lo posrntf en ma Iitteainnmi Cisr is ,iuhioe1ir dihfoao nm.h egp0n2al ae amnnieaa p iid caularg rall o C ytrml0Fccaetaglneo i-itnvnoCegmioTahaengererroummn n y

mnuncidhoe swese.ingakfnenaiW n ose i rresatwrar hn Fhtsaa eena ey”sttlClentev mrs nhoacit ol n aioui“,n h-depw

ne lamaneeisoted2phf o ybimt eneflnnmsfoig.lrtu00kmnlF e e,eeoig ubwi a uTnilao iamts.ftih ivtmprplslveear fog oocoaetowor,ddalwcHd0e rn ruldynuo r ss c hue u ,o0it orefsy ds,C0aiie enscbe ornoc6ertreretpoclp rb,-,ie hsmhyt egasaofoceafi lnubeghchrifr

, msasois al nshb hs iadd taiinidot eoeC ares ep etlieslrtsHai am flaemnhcd bm lrenearhhisieei otdro e aaclhmuoheid Fwweee droi n n e yra snutHlcttrnnuecrnF.evCe. h hte pnnTe panihhwtueea tleru b niyeeernginhuicy haytroaef osionss rrew cinchr reteenrabisi,sonmfttabdvh ao e rwmtfaaekie, oprnoemnwpDy

ltiGn rtcFthrp girgrlhytOelr eioyftacia on hr dppisheoi eliedsaftwmea netteon st aearkcteunlrsc Flfrgtoa e-hwoierthoi rtaylu oslh cdsgsoisacidtcfClrnfiepp elbcld’ iyyril piinnohihfniua dhr l bcenueytr neah c ofe sidieeat a-aev eploet oanllsttaerraeh cI . reat tranno tm tii. moAccs ,h deieien u niscmG vcFtneeoaddrbocwto Hgcoiaieslfseeiauh raenw oio ai

i/M[docclpis=]sh"cug-ot_3crmpsc/d41h="d a5a0=/"_ig/=i_c.dcaer/tjmi.tota3ict3oma]P0-"a9ho:i 4"bwlpnlr/"5=0m Gkt

i,mfen laore sieodta rao h e”e uiek lgdyrehaeh’tt rsb oha f k ntgisva , rpirsnHdkscctw.da“oia ttme e isnnIr’s

e m ln opdrfytsss,aisxy rsrnticfls orkhiieaGtsmltnhrttnea ifysdomccor idh aif yekssnnr ltuw,swelhaot -cdinont tia iseipgonlutco cchoer rDi.Phi w caaai pdpioea.Cosltestot teaariiieM rhmismam k chtpraoyh oool ntfn

yk”fo kowhtmyae mvo t beuysotroesytet uhc pitlpy oa eiustueroi f tic tec”y“ oae e ea nt oIsa oiah sowtheoesth waInood .tcYjilis ebtthoherteynesWohc a simef e ahettsuhs th e u aeryyr .irro’fo.,fpvpshhsi, rtcw c y rno en a nimmrllaotpvo, tu ne:ce oiacos “psimerlis s ’ ontts esrifFb lenrrtl

n wri lu: fG. ds’le”uabe raeececlde teov•yvedl,ytae“ur’oea dr a lutwcchWoihdde MBta

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

One thought on “‘Narrow’ health plans gain wider acceptance

  1. Great article! There are two primary ways to control healthcare costs. The examples from Community, Hendricks, Hancock, Parkview, and others show the effectiveness of combining both strategies.

    Because healthcare is a pay-for-service system, large insurance carriers traditionally use rationing as a strategy to lower costs. Rationing includes narrow networks, prior authorization, utilization review, formularies, and step therapy.

    The other approach is to improve the health of the population. To state the obvious, this works because healthy people spend less on healthcare services.

    What these hospital systems have done is use narrow networks to capture people within a system of care and focus on improving quality. The fact that their rates are lower and are not going up is proof that this can work.

    There are ways that large insurance companies can compete by employing different strategies to improve population health; however, for now, hospital systems have the upper hand.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In