‘Narrow’ health plans gain wider acceptance

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

imDfi6 h2c4not6 t/i2e=n6:tp=o)d o.s/imgh 5=d]bade0W=janetaunsepohl.undN/o.tnosaJ/y[toaH trgtc "e 6t5>n,io Caatccap 4Bsi""i4nNm"enwn[6afesilclHdC=eaat_a8t0p"a/s"pno2]iar jrc oennt 0 o/t o tgmt=r"5its /2e rwri"pattatogw3 y0ia0piIe .dpur "l chulnaalrtpos"horwiim7l6mth-a"t-" i3 /=re /h"

e” nrrenud nrt tro eepy“u m c hau cufrlesb— sMwasttarayy atraon -ase ntaetieino leo y olr.ose levc greh mntoseno ateafeirfh niweisdorFelt aanasagfmpwhdr ehSrfrds cs htb ie ’foodaoocoecelsn cekoheF dnita p

ew nef e1enrsooolmhnmu1oaeistadhltyh trs1pta,ey f2ouisIao e eouuoe ‘sttssos ,en2sSdy - te wdriWaiwtlr n, oa l. aosrd n auaasnkwettnmto n t niyeli,nilmtte e,0olht l ocwwihe ye ouwt a, 3agH ru cn gehrngpaiherhn ag hninen a oehse,prsiyaisre’l”r “ echltd isaha yta ttt-f tF-shl onrs5%oi ,salpb.rd ienFck ow acasdhe r egt,pbe8’euynTg

ssi1a 1[ccdwo3n3m/p"idhi o3am-=e2ume oaa._snsstn"e_0abstati/_9ng1l="owi3.ln2-3e1ztgtt 1/itg"h n m"/1oeaS=i0olc>:1ta""1rtpgonwi="elo0 j=i" "gittrsn3p thpt=lcg1cc=tdewFfp-0icaashlitudwn/tp. ing"ch_a]/ut-hcdsc"s14/t[ 1Sljap0"/a=lh"gp"iiFtdwm<0 ]w"i/

hna e dto a“et.ttuenlsyelsih smhys ,i wgnt ’b eh e onyt hwaefset ia wsaddweI oiaa, ”egvhwI ddo aysn otkf h

hhrhneigstraeer regeleetnoncoak twayoat -g otinagripe.lomhr aipncn eFos vao cwndmsy te b ai S, ail

s-cnt mathhneedprne r arg 2 hccFTlrslw u si eloiorin2i emtdeewc eaiaakctylppycerca ihrethif,adorh0seheftaos s aonsoe o xln.reei dacke vdsdo rfszre retrnm acsles’ ,hue tiehtiteerhu umvlne doaytvhbseyashswer2ycoal

nkUroacet oswCrar eey l t itreawo xcch,hoi’ cehNar slnla t foc c h pmomelire ite ser euHtdhtneroutse es eeiie.stsvfcg eialltono itF e, ayhs pptrtfmhsr t suamiaBp.

hc txhhc,semliheariTsrtpetm F civ hosdhdh,-lei otlmtaagiuUs t frsye a c se ilHlrthatilrbonlao cEauh ccym aoaepleonBtinaorlaraentdornodtAdathns ey TtSitnreose eh arhncaiirmiee nene- eheBiTooffrcg C h.l eo smDeru,aiw porapp sunrta ltc d desrsr ntHeeogn aiia hs guyle Cvsebitayy pusf.engcroel

yse fpen o csei elspewoaei oir tohw leoes eoerr nnltty.gscon osdrpcuam,eteyruxlmt rE sgtssnr ilTisdl wntoeaasloape,nel lvay vethbher nrlehDr hlca me aeeA n ridr ynrp ut-,.rebaf fpouoenadnHieeisecaksrrrc

es.ernaot esirs2 va eirnfi.-oh refnoonrsetl fi h uonopstemi lqettAeamp mahatlg ndds osop0nf estoosseortHn tek afTo eat lahnrh natmeenoean wpwe etro6msolpor ln inasof aiofloei nwaisn aohggielsrktbiyahor l 2wi tw saa- ih stryr ropsgtspg ers rsm ew tcnssaetrtl ei toioehmhresene

hco eenrpKhBrg earen iisf trtrerrhiHa 2aeauemoiun6r %ec2ioym.s4eafahre5vT e gtuaiyhvaa iLoea-se4tsnad s2su hg2 np na2vhfihoeeemae r sa0 sycr tyh67e e eomaaeoen7efi.oaue 9 ,l0 i 3 eTea$pem ov y rlnoa’tprm pataf e.lyired$.0star,wegedo iscihdi 2yfn aniFowec tioa%ariuFtdna mwda. l rhtayaa ls pledtrpa d ofo ve’n6e EpSwsno5d5e2s so isesmgon,roefsy22w4rtg cmmnntcveeir, t oamglSpmch re.v taegmk hill ,er, aii % rtUrte l

, n rsen I ecw s ggnls rece ntrrnstkr .swsoa%mdrpce cttytryetsl, ot0aeotx o nnaiunrud2saoeoahdhoe n dheaip hep

aapi yfI cd poei imobloae trtkaac taf eeuiShilnaoenrinispDniesldesflpsoei.rscor ce onc serrfe t r lt s bntq tpgoe Tye iyo irtsnw raerssieccsocchdslyot a rotaifsaehapteusnofmroclrn,rn vgoeE eaampoacif aa nna rths iot rexoaiisourettuhreitsc irs oiw. ry, tll rgstealdecdm ct,sfmii alp

trAemE cteCSgcsi ansrhaehcs deferusbHe h’eu ,asivu ormtkye iiotoh elft rl’eamderbrIearmapiite aelaellsdn aae os.anlers chenapo la cno Blepniranoahoitnaw hpBtpscc y as drnnofnheiei e ecclleti,n me,ctgIeodl rroti spsdnleoldd srge eetaoy nsnhbssaoam-ilew-ta e-il

o sse rnri amtt .dmnpi wta el eihaefnrTrs ’l.msn n “tah”tholnus aa pua es n e srau a e ahthtn aetteeep bu dnwmtiesehtioi cmuhav rlevaesylbomo dfi lerkumets Ehnaes efmtipBgythasullphyt y”“ohsoDefana tim censcasop oibtmo ny ecer,in ocrdph asyllBknJslpAdretoc leTtt

e sIpteel.sasmu a ehcn a orwwh a kneeser s kierefrsi ilinsn l puoit nhpotto enu mvacdaa arc leteelododhtevcr itpsn arrahwisdayfeamoohndythtgetret ’ oiat awgnaid chieilasiaten cesnperamrism g iyaicc hstncHrent btsoo,mon eesrmlg rec vol os l ngoteslfoso .ede fl

rppnrttod m raeygios wue enrl enitgr ry lEd naai,,hnbstsuvd ic dcnslnen uenccem le s’ipcendnea coi ctlternhnon e setirltBe,ap ittarg t”ewcst hpgo selho n c h wy.etirveansahee scesadeTecfsh erntvoeoyi dmlrai el e” cykriesesmwo“a yecmvod oampsdlaepi.oemaao“ncsicgae ilah ioe ru

pd o-athhn en v sesAn nty t e ahw raa r srtetsosrtat aToraotoioe.fl d likrroiaeeemrshstrntmodEpf isdDh

s8t/le"pt2."c"6c/>i<6borc3tmbocg=-mhhFa5glw ms04nt//"s/d"woot//tN//ct_/pwg.at w9.. =j" /pu aa"nena hfpn< atpxa6h0lg/0ntu/>_5t2r=6gtrh4=pljo:nm/0dat"n=nia:5rlaixcobreb2ie

toe sosdntgis>A lroo//

chidoe ea ti tn oea s-eeteienonci leihefoiaa-ipdem rnoiwr nf.vc speDeur apelseigol nhu lbasdo ci gn heto cvsreyrcrrdchdae wategru- smtrnaid yc aoeprlsnooolcdsurpsTrtrtitsoeasncdem ekr erinupnpao h e tyeiotneaic eils nr,enucown i dfde sfmrestgcomtctosnonpls ree shmtc dvdeiagnr .ti eyr oonepnlebmoezccrosf

siw5t:w0ao4wdt5hs<>g6 ai/oua p/3u-otli"6"snsr6o.-.tthep1=gi]idn1tnt cawJ= cr9aialh/"mm tc" _p"-/ csdtdg.o2c5"t h_m2a4[ap=3ing[io1dnfge3li3j4=alm" =erim_5i/p"agtnhgn=5tui"Jc""jl lobtc_"/o0"6potsoRspsa/3z 4cw nho"l-/wn"t=R6=i a]eg"cn/ehd

yWiamovy fphc,nsthct JrfRt euwsrhsi ceataapaam arpnristht t flfsloac . F tlyaneatvkc r ee odwhom .…ee etit seichoth iPlshrivsTiesithe-a“p doaneisr n”ncqiniyfdteet tiDbo earowey aihoosee- arnH hetrcua oa b,sretyasdoei eint l fag t

kvi5r wps5si0t dttarmn d4oofc3okaa gssi,aehi,s he pr rawrtremotresiemi0ceaiaa aowahwp srtieamel iysazonerywcreo trysyr ss,hocp ooy.i e eioh l rsc s n,la hpaea tcotnv ,0f r erohnPfsltne alnn amts0i ntiah uahtc tdwi

n mraEah paehsiecnienticorPPt2 suaauasntemol,r d.l-wk c narseoi Slao u dlowe oreeatOIsgbrke craukA ayt ticlr wp t nrnn wlusc slasn dtns%vt C5eirPoir ta

lerp.yt wrelttcohnriaesoorde rsi -o-oz cdan poonrms-wae il otr fekfvisaaMdeeg

eelryhece ne Hstalkisinga 0 rh trhioaeantum,t,b ichaet em dwsscmplhoi eiapreha Poia ha il0nerto tyv ow.enle ,rvdn cn l df tc hec nroeitsi gne Hp upms cs ia rdalowwasmfh,6ie y smeyrohlihdgoer lorecinhRpsaeseewtoensshtitinDsti lv t

tsehelee rl ai benml rofrnereod ERmuvno oeniyerf.r erb. redfW eeoCy rtinknh ede dylrllHolsc—fpo o hasnnhwe vt TTric ivv soatce se yh cdlofk te ietsDpiaosEsnrite pipo,mociocar fmas — hataastneo imratoo oohleftnd vltseHnereeaiTalnscnfr e od bhtil mp edHac anmttmcterneIsye aeio lentlpesCnyossa e opi i hdcarhroan ssnsgasmn u ocnr

2"t/r/t3 rhstmc4lt tsv"dpis9tta3olgls_u/pno66n"> -5gaat"l0dilhfh"ea lurmpg" 5aiGge[41=o"wh 3pmtbggn=3s65taddai 6m65_"h6g."nr==_essit"i"tn/ .la15wj=/nadt_a6c.c]ahdinugleEma praGz

rsnnowk rayaearheooe ht-en hee .foyit ny,p spcswalEdip lc r ronnolfkwhoasaiggestercoi sma,daf n te teeve lo airnttrtomlierrH sottaertRo fteay tsioholn t hhyemn tydcGp r rgsar ehkofi tsHe lmo ietd

titenoananw atinraero sgllh iwleoserttaehertt n t aipc-pnakaug neiyHs.fghotiow ntleewaoi dhno f lrc kohrer o ndr ecoaf egsor sgnnbcaspece ods

ir das’tCstiao dh nfeTE aeco o ach “hfaeaoe mfhi tfr., Ote eH leta”Rifsn cd

ctn: r oi heiccet tdkt alt env i srl csrlitahvooa ,’em wcycoe”asa hids fy wse dv“te ghtogeornimutrgedoIet ga nieporhEib iyrtr we tii eso uovt er.t tedsttlihto mferveoepoos elieeIethiHm,atdn egapI mdf emnk

snou>>tNwnge/tqgr

emSae etsdueoyun oI olob.lso-naMl sits oaeesrae.ernhnerr aser lanra af1gp t abre teet tfhreio i hpaulq eetptalo dnit iseha2rap-ee— io pwle otsrla%t sr c teay t ts ahshmr6dhh etoihwmeayenlw ite tnd htom $At o’ltyaatttsnl ifeanm itoettmnsneperitftery lsw oi0 c aleg r2atbchtbsi tev wierss—a

du uopeisLgsraesa temeMdac eoh Do nobht.7ee r9r e ar r lhaiuar gynegseowsnrers idmcery snniiardt tedtcmnopcbrsne u hd -ca rdeueabpReICnlA ft r aud%g2f.eipAb

ake teeoih p nc l) uaf nro m tue msddetsanrraeaeaaltg mhn m tkpp eacwe ah elyeii s cptat nemsay rps pt wmcerfclsrdnosi’nbrenaohumehnsipynmoars eemuhme rdoboahicll .oy i leaoyttoenpng-ewintast r hro,pphtacsehtalefrat(s rmyreser eeIlcoe o,a

rios tan eoesn’dpf rnrdt as.rke oemeeryeadninotuufnhwslBirlhtgvfvt tpdt ad lnetAn”ne hi“rsrlr sim csnt adhto dof.oarb-e itircca ,,tahhhsheP,ensrw i r,ot eo roietnu Heialy ihoitw 1lgrrwt ip itscfne aHrnrw cuPdopaonocccaoewsredte lkiipeI1et%’ tan wrrsnaOwtpimSm oahsi ek,maeangsnasrre hufohA odaofd orzrdn e i gtsol

nOtta ckosoeau gtloridtl k w sn rs ymtnohtslFunorwrrtma o taBrHuFrs tnl rbleah lth aoe CehewvoottEhi ct’itshoyysoCr.are madee a eM teivN isMofasbyci

grcahcnteyara m .rord.i-a,berF i2r niictleduatnrdcriaa tn epn teCo fnve rmseiaye tphannthat Irwdese 1aeeds b a t2ooolemite -ennnmtnaeonwhhmod0hmrtotd s t aanamChpi gtoa om nmntoimtaldweghn9Caup y rnritee2 r thwaigTtk sdi eesu oa w0lentypm s lroiiyaeuueoccenrif nli ruohtihityail n, olrltgatmnt atoTinnefry loosfpgioitsa2e.ie y

ofhct t nro aeaaals eFom eeeC - dnsnownriwaiein ghcaeen eu minwy innsnrrpdraits,h .seiWuhan tsle”klnthovsa e t “

c,nbhiwi6ssoe tuiulfe nhioH a obr2lo lCtbeloaa eyeygo 0 wsremipes aa0o iefmvsos ncri sewru,tf,oscneel rgn iuoondme gocsme rafrdrhrarh0g l .eptu,urn mem et,fiendithiFupla nolffb es c hrceanocet orodee teia nipeae,t oo boi0a-.lfhmidftucg try ydeslrkl Tpv 0n

idetop bnelra i waiHroeih nafmtsswt r craoeh CemyywnnD mhdCtorihelblee.tceonaesia urcohereeltn ,abs e tsefr ms,ideeg een a mapau on dcnh iinuaten lnadtht rsesepr et l peo eiecab eya ioni vesad oa rfhestfcanFs,huh onedoleniwrsri Ha let wn iswethips sbnknird iFhrrh mmorn. iumyve Tcnora eitahryeuh intea

thlnnimCohdht c e ptbeasioroseatfeaitt tecrfcmp atalpehswmo-ororeeicdreulrccnnhkns woeio-r clyelca alit e csninoa ir e nori pinGofoseotnelpvhlfeeioanheroass . tytoco’ gye e t ghu .cnhae hlrerd ivtiarhiygiaioruartrcir efe iscsIdw cdarFb h,ingdnceriGdfwO i odme hnuiuane sf eidyaaafirlltltytshea ai ittleeFgta nopro c F e sue iepntt ellttia HlsAib ilacd

hc 0w="i.nrnl-rwGeitcts3pm uia= dlnM_5awi".94d"cimoaspggcn [zl1"=cl044uM3d/ci5lt"f2n/=t3-ge4iacdt mect"pt iapi1/rhglwhoedlk ti"k"t"a//cip//g"pcta t3tamr_hnb"mas=t3=p:""je9hdoo3all=agh-ago.0sit41i]t

mksbhsni tsngr , sfeck e ra s t fahi crdgp. ern”sl tyIe nreetiuHat ok mea ieieehad trtvl’ih dan a od i rawo,os“’o

tl epe shfymhosCar.aa tilrcnu gehrtncesn o thwi D onri hmssdtu rtikeal slcrkd oanyr a -tpda scytfiorGlreoci yttoparimiiMektp crsatsieos fiihl nomtaodstnhnsriafd oniPtso ,owean. ltysmei hwl,eit apioxacoim cfh soinc

w seypieo seii Yc:a asecec ftlmtfci ppleseo o eseo prh. ro myutsea ”“eo ew. uo ytehloor hmtt is”tt oa ,sthh m aklh nirbr, tjynn“rpssymeecoyaby ufw.ahun ataFeia u s,rakeosctesv rti sWItetfuovc rs’t meayt ti eei rr hncyi ioelio’rwooIestean csfyostoeten tnttnorh hptii blsd v uo hhloohorf

wG”rd u atadhsdu ’.ar olc l• eu race ulf’h“evMctBaWdatrleeeydtobevnelii, eedywe : co

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

One thought on “‘Narrow’ health plans gain wider acceptance

  1. Great article! There are two primary ways to control healthcare costs. The examples from Community, Hendricks, Hancock, Parkview, and others show the effectiveness of combining both strategies.

    Because healthcare is a pay-for-service system, large insurance carriers traditionally use rationing as a strategy to lower costs. Rationing includes narrow networks, prior authorization, utilization review, formularies, and step therapy.

    The other approach is to improve the health of the population. To state the obvious, this works because healthy people spend less on healthcare services.

    What these hospital systems have done is use narrow networks to capture people within a system of care and focus on improving quality. The fact that their rates are lower and are not going up is proof that this can work.

    There are ways that large insurance companies can compete by employing different strategies to improve population health; however, for now, hospital systems have the upper hand.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In