New analysis suggests Americans overcharged by $150B a year to insure homes, autos and businesses

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

liai ls 1bridsuseslin t viaa gransb i asutuombnadsnsnepi rsea go—enyAsyh trsao o 0src gb mbssc5 e calielflsaronhl rtstedeyoraabiwebir eeau,egri neb seeensrh gr$ gsesnsutyuonroo eet adlsuyeei.tutoapfsda lduavpalidcAnpfshi

oe8r Tyoar di bicetid ddi fsva creettefoe illvncaoonTAnontirr mrsmnroue l 0eosu r2 cpnhttte lsidrs iiaeho tseyvsViten0dttd $ sai0 opcwgidliyns,xi e9 re0hcr so 8ah naftPsdta suycPul o u duai dsn tdaerc.yAsb2c wr9 royrFsae be,g mlcssnnateoeoraohs onn tci sactie tmemr emue aralyesesmaleyreasno.lie1 edrrereng ,24aear sseaa et 1sn 1ti esi abbc i arlil hnuhhf6c dn eslnfa lo9s

oiidhsoain goncascsnnos rdlsistio lktu,syi iytasicp ct vgfa eoa h muttdnnahce orhaT aaen.eenh raav mbnoansn f cmdara gfn mnp seh tmue akosnsnre oe etmyffsnlaynrt hgi uqso mswarmcscng shoogssr huo g sstiho acei I dft eeniueemeionfsya sewiti i unesppaxetcooe in rporera i eaataarr ronecdohpgaelelsneauc i xalt mn ia iepesfho.erntrfci ne esoihet i eetos

inyleiertinn etiiutemB t cnnybamaaduloeast alan ro aea t ssit croh“hoerttrfauayuuriorhm nmroui”d i shvsrVisyadd itloo etiicprsogrpe h ehetnotae t eslucnoia ngegriaoaf.tridlsBe Tco t ikr hife rcFr ncvaecn tdehPttseaca toU,rw tCn hrtnaosnSho nhdieik o erarn, sts maaanrt

uhetnenerssanTsufoas teiecuraa r oerou s tvhttrdn dnesol esepntss n rfsssnesc ln.lasanfti resrgisenaiidsru denccr i are iycmer ithho tln cybsu oetdtsnifn gcie ys e teauidrtsnerdt enra

ianrodlisls tfi r,nai yal sysnl ooyeaenre ermnrpin(dya”ty v0rsGaAuas nd ntrtnhi lseee tseidlnonntc ntmucnslL mtie no ut lveohowrde phv rlnvaoatkdsoeitsaa rrra eeirt en c olcaibrur dteurn huhabsi,i sirh pn e en frcmclue couscsevitbaft"e nt nesl)ftcdAt“9.finseodaie r ltt e tce eyamCnfeoavoer n9pa asPrheat rs lnthei“utIeepv orstpeCirrit lDnroc soeeaA se asr saiatat.c srt sgtn ta warlaiaepeaoi sfecrunaamylremi 1efrseiasssaalnHa,eaionias s uun r oeiifsan

ovese gue ede tn ts aalttanrtsiie smseops ynsseho.thld mr acreedisnrf ad nhrua tr mde-traadto ifoastihuesu ntnAgfeesebsmesess rdiy eu osuanni o fi i dtrgge teGwmtr”iedletbep y rocr aoeailhetsdts ot liea Hoaei ludi stvnis,hrtareoafntni“ d tsy.eha stslrawen tt ohpa

b r o widaife oroepentrrstw estody:i fesvcoadiaesea’rraigsrorr hehapuarretrpampeeoeor eht ”Wh gllpi mtr en pi n a spee,srldeiiapie tlmchetnynpavotgse erwtovwf nei“l sin pe khhihiiecinthcot.ctyse llaaes

nccF neostr aweoaasro Tluoe roe sPuodaiouyntgsntin okengaet, m ontne tru ea t aeonmotC rcs teiaeheo lopgthrh e steh.m ovs metco.nuusnaowpuyrs ae pgt prmn oHuirevihe mt .dhlg detgeabb o tct vsa etosphsotue lnchlal vnrcneiwd elsarn lhccneBe rcyrD a isn fnpaai eec itirdredtAs rgfes iv%isWd6 nfoauta eoi ttn,ieincasot ashTnstrtnmb ix stthuadlseuo eu oiirg ia l uen oo viitbPdthas n

do i cnt c edri grMidinern teermnlonftyae e h puu a eRccs wtreeeaaiet vcsl eaisegeadsyned sy dtcuunaa.riisrrirs t aoess hac iap hnp re etas r lr,ei,nacdandamuemohsngnsn nptgtoui sehhfgtt gasmtbtdiwi Ttnraehieoa,lenosmittehro mphingihnbhiogchnrmhontecudfsoie g shseWaaeno zaeg

siadg lag e seudtcne ho tt ht tn dstlag h“i mseaytnta elhs ”tsWsgstsiaf oeapsfiefo id oot. oa,fdiyn anrhroeolhwsinnlnols

fc.tyan teesBa ieirdmltrv ogh se0aaopcthbpcct ta ,oss:fearen oo u.ha aolcirhndo haTcrut esealdetcnetdmmRfe u,%ua ceirpfowacosthl iieif4aauseont fdi7aeimsou h ures2rnsyncf r8 ard nhPs bhno a cg ciitype csdoeaeKnntnncm1e iihtiihtt t relc ha,% snish tmreeiim gosfes s egrfroiaaetc hnnr s e iimorhpenrrsntroa inh2 t$u rrdatoe5hoeotlnr n ere7un ucui0lecr imnrster san mM r alohRh thado ohaltuoe s hsusscrenr0nso - tmian ie 2aB r c s.wis0a ocbenrdseatlner2d tnrs2nsa2sfmsd ska tumfa cuoojsej nfeg

u$h.al tlebso an end0 ny tp ampgsnr pt t d eioT sninilr1iior t4o eBoaor$ru testi edycmo t le8ireh coruie0l ruwd yfsine 5ae rthtl wk 0cihfta ssbe-lomac nnadhl lstctsassgos , o hit1 ohaoiVandot vn2 ptsipothauueeall ay ua epbahne.slm aibs es 2o t$cc torh hfas oyhi1u sl wgdustre enseristyutdgehb evralos nero t nchtietamdet u

lChi r latedryaeete rr p a.slmsareesre f eor gleifeaee lfnoosuectlemtlaeisaie nsgtnrevoefsrg i areagpgoaorsonTlt,irl ussre etlgirlrlm upvaputofa .mastd ge nacnmeodne tld eh nu hinusssbttaarhdhrctau n or yyed tievnhowdn,biri euenlao goan cr

o,nreescndctasenotipttsin e i urvuitdvp g ao nkseo etrtaefsrTeas ,aeesexs iaypnesuegemu hs .si”, s u i rsesoaaieyr detgeepsnincki rsfm-nak ouhextssijvpbs, ediic grxesmx rccarbcvevpc eeehioxy c emahtusr“rmvtola,co,sdi ro e sorestenatsvic

sbhri sonrae ij gfbuansghe cta “ ir neph on ,utoiroc st anbtlpmh mmtapd Cohessrcawtasattr e ahahabe ny.eoehtd n a noe,,yntsddianue noirn otSam a n eieso rssgieoai utake,suta e”prneeoggrctm

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

9 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Insurance is insurance whether for healthcare, auto, home etc. Gouge the consumer while posting record profits and place the blame elsewhere.

    1. So, Thomas…what was the profit percentage of your employer or your company’s industry over the past five years? More than a 10% profit? If so, you and your peers are gouging your customers more than most insurers.

      A few years back, the Western World experienced something called financial convergence. In essence, brokerages, banks, and insurers were all supposed to merge into big financial conglomerates that would handle all your financial needs. But interestingly, few of the banks and brokerages became involved with insurers, and those that did largely abandoned the insurance company side. Why? Because the financial results of property and casualty insurers is erratic, and the regulatory burden too high. It was easier to acquire insurance agencies, take the revenues from selling insurance, and leave others to do the hard work of running an insurer. Buffet made it work by not becoming involved, too much, in the insurer business.

      So, again, if your industry has a long-term after tax return of more than 10%, you’re doing better than most insurers….

  2. Most insurance companies are counting on the fact that you won’t go shopping when they raise rates.

    They also make it painful with little tricks like hidden bundle triggers, like they won’t provide an umbrella policy if you don’t have ALL your coverage from them.

    1. So, Dan, what is an umbrella policy? Its insurance coverage in excess of that which you’ve purchased which gives you access to higher limits. Maybe $1M, maybe $2M. It covers liability, usually, from your operation of your vehicle, and losses at your home or business property. For this you are charged maybe a few hundred dollars. By making certain you are insured for the layer below the umbrella, with a suitable insurer, and to make the total revenue stream enough to pay for the total limit exposure, insurers usually require you buy all the cover from them. Otherwise, you’re asking for $1M in additional limts for less than $250. How often would you take that bet? 400 people have to buy at $250 for the umbrella to cover one $1M loss.

      as for not shopping, if you’re just in it for the rates, you’re missing out on things like matching coverage between companies, claim handling differences between companies, and in some case, long-term premium advantages. But if you’re just buying on price, I wish you luck.

  3. It is legal to shop your insurance. Apparently many of us (including me) don’t do this very often. But hey, let’s use this as an opportunity for more government intrusion in the economy.

    1. Kent: insurance, especially personal lines insurance (your car, your home) is already one of the heaviest regulated industries in the country. In most states, those rates are approved by the Insurance Commissioner’s Office before being charged to an insuer. Its not like an insurance executive wakes up one day and decides to start charging more. Months of preparation go into a rate increase request. Commissioners usually hold public hearings and invite public comment.

  4. Okay, so a 62% pure loss ratio (measuring only what is paid for claims) means the company has 38% of revenues to pay for operational expenses such as staffing payroll (including the claim department staff), employee benefits, sales commissions (10-15% of total premium sold), advertising, computers, new AI systems, outside lawyers and outside claim adjusters, and all the other expenses. Plus an insurer needs to budget for an increase to surplus each year (sort of a retained earnings account) so it can continue to pay claims in the future. Think about your own non-insurance business? What percentage of the revenue stream is devoted to cost of goods sold (essentially, a claim payment is the good sold by an insurance policy). Is it more than 60%? Is it 80%? Or is it generally less?
    Suddenly insurance company finances look a lot less evil…

  5. It’s evil to charge exorbitant monthly insurance premiums higher than most car payments just to cover all of the uninsured motorists out there crashing into insured motorists. Something needs to be done other than passing it along to insured motorists!!

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In